LAWYER IN VIETNAM DR. OLIVER MASSMANN – PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS VIETNAM ON THE RELEVANT REGULATIONS ON PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – HERE ARE OUR ANSWERS:

1. LAWYER IN VIETNAM DR. OLIVER
MASSMANN – PUBLIC PROCUREMENT –
THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE
MORRIS VIETNAM ON THE RELEVANT
REGULATIONS ON PUBLIC
PROCUREMENT – HERE ARE OUR
ANSWERS:
1. What are the three central/federal government entities that have conducted the
largest procurements by volume in Vietnam in the last three years? Please, list
the three procuring entities in the order of importance.
This information is not published by the government.
2. Please provide a list of laws, regulations, and other binding materials
(including guidelines and manuals) that regulate public procurement in Vietnam.
• Law No. 43/2013/QH13 on Bidding (Law on Bidding)
• Law No. 49/2014/QH13 on Public Investment
• Law No. 64/2020/QH14 on Investment in the form of Public – Private Partnership
• Law No. 03/2022/QH15 amending and supplementing some of articles of Law on
Public Investment, Law on Investment in the form of public-private partnership, Law on
Investment, Law on Housing, Law on Bidding, Law on Electricity, Law on Enterprises,
Law on Consumption Tax Special and the Law on Execution of Civil Judgments.
• Decree No. 95/2020/ND-CP guiding the procurement under the Comprehensive
and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership
• Decree No. 09/2022 ND-CP amending and supplementing some articles of
Decree No. 95/2020/ND-CP guiding the implementation of procurement under the
CPTPP, the EVFTA and the UKVFTA

2. • Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP detailing the implementation of several provisions of
the Bidding Law on the selection of contractor
• Decree No. 25/2020/ND-CP detailing the implementation of several provisions of
the Bidding Law on the selection of investors
• Decree No. 21/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents
for non-consulting services for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP, the
EVFTA and the UKVFTA
• Decree No. 20/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents
for consulting services for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP, the EVFTA
and the UKVFTA
• Circular 09/2022/TT-BYT detailing the sample invitation to bid for procurement of
herbal ingredients and traditional medicines at public health facilities
• Circular 12/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents for
the procurement of goods for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP, the
EVFTA and the UKVFTA
• Circular No. 15/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents
for construction and installation for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP,
the EVFTA and the UKVFTA
• Circular 08/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the provision and posting of information on
bidding and contractor selection on the National Procurement Network System
• Circular No. 09/2022/TT-BGTVT guiding some contents on methods and criteria
for evaluating bids for investor selection under the public-private partnership method
and the form of a build-operate-transfer contract in the transport sector
• Circular No. 23/2021/TT-BGTVT guiding the formulation, approval and
publication of the list of projects; methods and criteria for evaluating bids and bidding for
selection of investors in specialized aviation service works at airports and aerodromes
• Circular 22/2021/TT-BGTVT detailing methods and criteria for evaluating bids to
select investors to implement projects on dredging seaport waters and inland waterways
in combination with product recovery
• Circular No. 06/2020/TT-BKHDT guiding the implementation of Decree No.
25/2020/ND-CP detailing the implementation of a number of articles of the Law on
Bidding on investor selection

3. • Circular 15/2020/TT-BYT promulgating the List of drugs for bidding, the List of
drugs for concentrated bidding, and the List of drugs eligible for price negotiation.
• Circular No. 14/2020/TT-BYT promulgating some contents in bidding for medical
equipment at public medical facilities
• Circular 15/2019/TT-BYT regulating on drug bidding at public health facilities
• Circular No. 10/2015/TT-BKHDT detailing the contractor selection plan
• Circular No. 19/2015/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of appraisal report
during the contractor selection period
• Circular No. 23/2015/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of evaluation report of
bid dossier
• Circular No. 16/2016/TT-BKHDT guiding the preparation of pre-qualification
dossier, bidding dossier for the investor carrying land use projects
3. Specific instruments applicable to a sector (goods, services or works):
• Decree No. 21/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents
for non-consulting services for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP, the
EVFTA and the UKVFTA
• Decree No. 20/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents
for consulting services for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP, the EVFTA
and the UKVFTA
• Circular 09/2022/TT-BYT detailing the sample invitation to bid for procurement of
herbal ingredients and traditional medicines at public health facilities
• Circular 12/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents for
the procurement of goods for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP, the
EVFTA and the UKVFTA
• Circular No. 15/2022/TT-BKHDT detailing the preparation of bidding documents
for construction and installation for bidding packages within the scope of the CPTPP,
the EVFTA and the UKVFTA
• Circular No. 23/2021/TT-BGTVT guiding the formulation, approval and
publication of the list of projects; methods and criteria for evaluating bids and bidding for
selection of investors in specialized aviation service works at airports and aerodromes

4. • Circular 22/2021/TT-BGTVT regulating on methods and criteria for evaluating
bids to select investors to implement projects on dredging seaport waters and inland
waterways in combination with product recovery
• Circular 15/2020/TT-BYT promulgating the List of drugs for bidding, the List of
drugs for concentrated bidding, and the List of drugs eligible for price negotiation.
• Circular No. 14/2020/TT-BYT promulgating a Circular stipulating a number of
contents in bidding for medical equipment at public medical facilities
• Circular 15/2019/TT-BYT regulating on drug bidding at public health facilities
4. Does the regulatory framework establish value thresholds for determining
procedural or regulatory aspects of the procurement process?
Yes (Articles 2.2 and 3.2, Law on Bidding)
5. Is there an operational central electronic public procurement (e-procurement)
portal in Vietnam?
Yes (https://muasamcong.mpi.gov.vn)
6. Is the central e-procurement portal used by all the procuring entities?
Yes
7. Please complete the table below based on the features available in the central
electronic public procurement portal
Yes, fully digitized Yes, but hard copy
documents must be
submitted
No
Registering as a ve
ndor
X
Accessing notices
on procurement op
portunities
x
Accessing bidding
documents
x
Asking a procuring
entity for clarificatio
ns
x
Submitting tenders x
Submitting bid secu
rity with electronic v
alidation
x
Bid opening x

5. Virtual workspace t
o manage tender pr
ocedures (including
operative tools for
members of the eva
luation committee)
x
Notification of decis
ions (clarifications,
awards, contract si
gning, etc.)
x
Accessing award d
ecisions (including t
heir rationale)
x
Submitting perform
ance guarantee wit
h electronic validati
on
x
Contract signing x
Accessing contract
s
x
Accessing contract
amendments
x
Submitting invoices
to the procuring ent
ity
x
Module for framewo
rk agreement mana
gement
x
E-catalogue of appr
oved suppliers
x
Green catalogue x
E-reverse auction
module
x
E-contract manage
ment and implemen
tation module
x
Receiving payment
s from the procurin
g entity
x
Applying for vendor
eco-certifications/ec
o-labels
x
Access to specificat
ions, standards, or
criteria for eco-label
s and environmenta
x

6. lly preferable goods
and services
8. Are the features supported by the central e-procurement portal available for
procurements of goods, works, and services?
Yes
9. For the following types of data, please select if there is a data portal that
provides open access to such information in machine readable format:
Yes No
Data on tenders (including
description, dates, categor
y of spending, estimated v
alue, contracting authority,
and identification of bidder
s)
x
Data on tenders (including
description, dates, categor
y of spending, estimated v
alue, contracting authority,
and identification of bidder
s)
x
Data on suppliers x
10. Link to the webpage with data
https://muasamcong.mpi.gov.vn/web/guest/contractor-selection?render=index
11. Are there any main procuring entities for which data on contracts and tenders
is not published on the open access data portal?
No.
12. Are gender-disaggregated data on firms that have participated in tenders
collected by the central e-procurement portal?
No.
13. Does the regulatory framework require procuring entities to use standard
bidding/tender documents when preparing a tender?
Yes, but with some exception.
14. Circumstances the use of model bidding/tender documents is not required.
Based on sector of procurement (Article 4, Circular No. 08/2022/TT-BKHDT)

7. 15. Do these standard bidding documents contain sustainability clauses?
Yes, in all model documents
16. Does the regulatory framework define minimum content requirements for
procurement plans?
Yes. (Article 35, Law on Bidding)
17. Do the minimum content requirements for procurement plans include a
gender dimension?
No.
18. According to the regulatory framework, which of the following tools must be
used when a procuring entity prepares to estimate the contract value of the new
procurement opportunity?
Regulations are silent on this matter
19. Is there a legal mandate for the development and implementation of special
programs to engage innovative and emerging suppliers?
No.
20. Does the regulatory framework establish open procurement as a default
method for tendering a contract?
Yes, but with some exception.
21. Circumstances exceptions to the general rule of using open procurement are
provided in the regulatory framework.
Based on the value of procurement and based on the entity conducting the procurement
(Articles 21, 22, 23, 24, 26, 26, Law on Bidding)
22. Does the regulatory framework designate specific tendering procedures for
innovation procurement?
No
23. Does the regulatory framework provide incentives for preparing bids with
environmentally-friendly components?
No.
24. Does the regulatory framework impose any participation or award restrictions
on foreign firms?
Yes, in some public tenders

8. 25. If the restrictions apply only in some public tenders, please identify the
parameter in which these restrictions are applicable:
Sector (Article 15, Law on Bidding).
26. Does the regulatory framework require foreign firms to have partnerships with
domestic firms to be eligible to participate in a tender?
Yes, in some public tenders (Article 5.1(h), Law on Bidding)
27. Does the regulatory framework require foreign firms to own (fully or partially)
subsidiaries in the domestic economy to be eligible to participate in a tender?
No. (Article 5.1, Law on Bidding)
28. Does the regulatory framework prohibit splitting contracts for the purpose of
circumventing thresholds for open tendering?
Yes (Article 89.6(k), Law on Bidding)
29. According to the regulatory framework, which of the following documents
need to be made publicly available?
Yes, for all contract
s
Yes, except for low
value contracts
No
Procurement plans x
Tender notices x
Tender documents (
project specific)
x
Award decisions Ye
s
x
Contracts x
Contract amendme
nts
x
Subcontractors x
30. Please provide the legal basis for all the key materials listed in the table
above:
Article 8, Law on Bidding; Article 9, Law on Investment in the form of Public – Private
Partnership
31. Does the regulatory framework set a minimum timeframe between
advertisement of a tender notice and a submission deadline?
Yes, for all procurement procedures (Article 12.1(b), Law on Bidding)

9. 32. According to the regulatory framework, how should clarification requests
from potential bidders be communicated?
Required to communicate answers to all bidders (Article 77.1, Law on Bidding; Article
51.4, Decree No. 35/2021/ND-CP; Article 14.2(c), Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP)
33. In practice, how many days would usually pass between bid opening, and
contract signing (i.e., the time in which all tenderers, participants and relevant
parties are notified of the award decision and the awardee can start implementing
the contract) for the following scenarios:
Days to complete a procurement of a works contract in an open procedure valued
above the threshold for international procurement: 210
Days to complete the procurement of a services contract in a restricted procedure with
limited competition, valued below the threshold for international procurement: 210
Days to complete the prequalification of supplier: 0
Days to complete an electronic auction: 45
Days to complete a Framework agreement with a competitive second stage: 0
34. Does the regulatory framework establish criteria for identifying abnormally
low bids?
Yes, but only in some procurement procedures (Articles 117.6 and 117.9, Decree No.
63/2014/ND-CP)
35. According to the regulatory framework, which award criteria must be used in
bid evaluations for high-value procurement?
Lowest price, Project life cycle cost, Total cost of ownership, Value for money, Most
economically advantageous tender, Sustainability (Articles 39 – 41, Law on Bidding)
36. Please indicate whether Lowest price must be used for some or all
procurement sectors.
No, applicable to some.
37. Please indicate whether Project life cycle cost must be used for some or all
procurement sectors.
No, applicable to some.
38. Please indicate whether Total cost of ownership must be used for some or all
procurement sectors.
No, applicable to some.

10. 39. Does the regulatory framework explicitly recommend the preference to use
Most Economically Advantageous tender criteria over lowest price criteria?
Yes, but only in some procurement procedures.
40. According to the regulatory framework, should the procuring entity provide a
reference price in tender documents?
Yes, but only in some procurement procedures.
41. Does the regulatory framework include gender-specific provisions that
promote gender equality in public procurement?
Yes (Article 14.3, Law on Bidding)
42. Does the regulatory framework outline a designated procedure for awarding
contracts based on a framework agreement where contracts are awarded
following a competitive two-stage process?
No, only one stage is competitive (Article 65, Law on Bidding)
43. Which of the small and medium-sized enterprise preferential treatment
approaches are included in the regulatory framework?
None (Article 6 Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP, Article 14.2.c Bidding Law)
44. Does the regulatory framework mandate communication of an award
decision?
Yes, to all bidders (•Articles 42.3, 43.2, 11.8(d), 11.8(dd), Law on Bidding)
45. Is there a mandatory standstill period between the public notice of award and
contract signing to allow unsuccessful bidders challenge the decision?
No.
46. Does the regulatory framework establish a timeframe within which a procuring
entity must process a payment once an invoice is received?
Yes, for all contracts (Articles 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP)
47. Does the regulatory framework allow firms to claim interest on late payments
(or any similar contractual penalty) if the government does not pay within the
legally established timeframe?
Yes (Article 94.1, Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP)
48. How often does the government pay late payment interest (or any similar
contractual penalty) in the event that it fails to meet the payment deadline?
Government often pays late payment interest.

11. 49. Does the regulatory framework designate a specialized and independent
authority to receive procurement challenges filed by firms on decisions issued by
the procuring entities?
Yes, specialized (Article 92, Law on Bidding)
50. Does an aggrieved bidder have the right to appeal decisions on challenges
made by the authority that receives procurement challenges?
Yes (Articles 92.1(c), 92.2(c), 92.3(c), 92.4(c), Law on Bidding)
51. Are there any legally binding time limits to resolve a procurement challenge?
Yes, for all types of challenges (Article 92, Law on Bidding)
52. Is there a legal recourse for an aggrieved bidder experiencing delays in either
challenge or review processes?
Yes, for all types of challenges (Articles 91.1(b) and 91.2, Law on Bidding)
Please do not hesitate to contact Dr. Oliver Massmann under
omassmann@duanemorris.com if you have any questions or want to know more details
on the above. Dr. Oliver Massmann is the General Director of Duane Morris Vietnam
LLC.