SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 3
Download to read offline
Editorial: Obamacare stands
Don't let the angry press releases fool you. Republicans have plenty to celebrate now that the U.S.
Supreme Court upheld a challenge to the Affordable Care Act. Not only will candidates be able to
continue using the law as a political whipping-boy for the 2016 election, but the party also won't
have to come up with any viable alternative. Perhaps they'll even start calling it SCOTUScare. At
least that's what Justice Antonin Scalia recommended in his dissent.
The issue raised by the case, King v. Burwell, wasn't a question of whether the law itself is
constitutional - the court settled that question three years ago when it held that the individual
mandate to buy insurance was enforceable as a tax.
In this case the court was asked to address whether the law prohibited policyholders who purchased
their insurance through federal exchanges from receiving the subsidies that make insurance
affordable. In Texas, more than 832,000 people receive these subsidies to help purchase health
insurance through the federal exchange.
The problem rests with four words out of a 900-page document, which states that those subsidies
are for people who purchased their plans through exchanges "established by the state."
On their own, those words seem like a death knell - to use the words of Gov. Greg Abbott - for
Obamacare insurance plans in the 34 states that refused to establish their own exchanges, such as
Texas. But those four words don't exist in a vacuum, and it isn't the job of the Supreme Court to
presume that Congress would write a law that fails to accomplish what it was created to do. Looking
at those words in context, as Chief Justice John Roberts did in his majority opinion, it is implausible
to think that Congress would write a law that effectively self-destructs. This is the smart decision of
a justice who refuses to play politics.
Yet while the court has settled these legal questions, the Obamacare fight continues. Texas
Republicans wasted no time in releasing the usual harangues against the healthcare law. Lt. Gov.
Dan Patrick called the Affordable Care Act "broken and a burden." U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz called it a
"disaster."
There's no denying problems with the rollout of Obamacare, but as time passes the law's actual
impact is growing clearer. Health care costs are rising slower, the uninsured rate has hit a record
low at 12.9 percent and the law itself saves taxpayers $353 billion over 10 years. Hospitals are also
in a better financial position because of these new ranks of insured patients, according to Ted Shaw,
president of the Texas Hospital Association. Overall, the law helps people take responsibility for
their own health insurance.
If there is a disaster, we don't see it. But that hasn't stopped Abbott from calling for a "President
who will repeal Obamacare and enact real healthcare reforms."
What exactly "real healthcare reform" means is a mystery. It isn't as if Obamacare sprung
spontaneously from the president's forehead in 2009. As the Supreme Court documents in the King
decision, the United States has a long history of failed health insurance reform, and the Affordable
Care Act serves as a national adaptation of the one successful state plan - Massachusetts' 2006
health care reform, which was proposed, signed and implemented by then-Gov. Mitt Romney, the
Republican candidate for president in 2012.
At this point, fights over Obamacare smack more of politics than policy, and the poorest Texans are
getting caught in the crossfire. Texas' political leaders have refused to accept $100 billion in federal
funds that would expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act. Those dollars would cover 90
percent of the program's cost and provide health insurance for the 1.4 million Texans who are too
poor to receive subsidies on the federal health care exchange. Without insurance, those Texans rely
either on charity or county taxpayers to cover their bills.
For the time being, Texans will have to pay twice for public health care, with federal and local taxes,
while the people who need help the most get left behind. Expanding Medicaid would help everyone,
but we're not optimistic. After all, it is hard to send out an angry press release when people are
happy.
http://www.chron.com/opinion/editorials/article/Obamacare-stands-6350038.php

More Related Content

What's hot

Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...
Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...
Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...jthorn4
 
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to SucceedUpdates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to SucceedCora Butler, JD, RN, CHC
 
Health Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to Pass
Health Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to PassHealth Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to Pass
Health Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to Passjthorn4
 
Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01
Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01
Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01Peggy Gonder
 
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?benefitexpress
 
House Health Care Bill Over
House Health Care Bill OverHouse Health Care Bill Over
House Health Care Bill OverNATURE 4EVER
 
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...Behn Wyetzner, Chartered
 
Current legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcareCurrent legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcarewstarc5
 
Is US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MD
Is US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MDIs US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MD
Is US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MDRichard W Bank MD
 
Connor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay Word
Connor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay WordConnor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay Word
Connor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay WordConnor Maser
 
Obamacare - What a Mess!
Obamacare - What a Mess!Obamacare - What a Mess!
Obamacare - What a Mess!Richard Kelley
 
Health Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking News
Health Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking NewsHealth Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking News
Health Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking Newsresonantspray561
 
FOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 Update
FOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 UpdateFOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 Update
FOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 UpdateS. Troy Bagwell, CAWC
 
The Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance Market
The Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance MarketThe Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance Market
The Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance MarketRuss Kuhn
 
New woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent out
New woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent outNew woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent out
New woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent outgrotesquemosaic06
 
11 healthcare debate
11 healthcare debate11 healthcare debate
11 healthcare debatemrmarr
 
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press ReleaseThe Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press ReleaseBehn Wyetzner, Chartered
 
TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)
TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)
TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)Steve Levine
 

What's hot (20)

Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...
Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...
Dallas health insurance agent say premium increases are because the cost of c...
 
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to SucceedUpdates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
 
Health Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to Pass
Health Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to PassHealth Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to Pass
Health Insurance in Fort Worth May Be Expendable As Senate Bill Fails to Pass
 
Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01
Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01
Healthcareorhealthscarechc2 22-11final-110223150054-phpapp01
 
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
 
House Health Care Bill Over
House Health Care Bill OverHouse Health Care Bill Over
House Health Care Bill Over
 
Test
TestTest
Test
 
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
 
Current legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcareCurrent legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcare
 
Is US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MD
Is US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MDIs US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MD
Is US Biotechnology in Jeopardy? By Richard W. Bank, MD
 
Connor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay Word
Connor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay WordConnor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay Word
Connor Maser Annual RBM Seminar Essay Word
 
Obamacare - What a Mess!
Obamacare - What a Mess!Obamacare - What a Mess!
Obamacare - What a Mess!
 
Health Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking News
Health Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking NewsHealth Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking News
Health Insurance: Pictures, Videos, Breaking News
 
FOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 Update
FOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 UpdateFOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 Update
FOYperspective Healthcare Upheava l- 2017 Q1 Update
 
The Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance Market
The Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance MarketThe Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance Market
The Cost & Impact of Massive Complexity in the US Health Insurance Market
 
New woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent out
New woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent outNew woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent out
New woes for HealthCare.gov: Wrong tax info sent out
 
11 healthcare debate
11 healthcare debate11 healthcare debate
11 healthcare debate
 
Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011
Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011
Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011
 
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press ReleaseThe Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
 
TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)
TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)
TEXT: Protecting Texas' Liability Reforms (PIAA 2014)
 

Viewers also liked

pedido de Reynaldo Ruiz
pedido de Reynaldo Ruizpedido de Reynaldo Ruiz
pedido de Reynaldo Ruizreynaldorl
 
Taller cross docking[1]-1(2) original
Taller cross docking[1]-1(2) originalTaller cross docking[1]-1(2) original
Taller cross docking[1]-1(2) originaldiego12alejandro
 
Matrimono diapositivas
Matrimono diapositivasMatrimono diapositivas
Matrimono diapositivasabeltranc
 
Power point ok
Power point okPower point ok
Power point okjcardila
 
Шляхецкія сядзібы Гомельшчыны
Шляхецкія сядзібы ГомельшчыныШляхецкія сядзібы Гомельшчыны
Шляхецкія сядзібы ГомельшчыныMaryia Bulavinskaya
 
27 توصية من أجل معمل افضل
27 توصية من أجل معمل  افضل27 توصية من أجل معمل  افضل
27 توصية من أجل معمل افضلmanaljoraif
 
Venta de apartamentos en barrio villadela
Venta de apartamentos en barrio villadelaVenta de apartamentos en barrio villadela
Venta de apartamentos en barrio villadelajoserhn
 
High efficiency coalescer separator
High efficiency coalescer separatorHigh efficiency coalescer separator
High efficiency coalescer separatorDiggricp
 
abc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachments
abc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachmentsabc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachments
abc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachmentsYoshea Nyelle Hazzette
 
Examen2a alejandro roman
Examen2a alejandro romanExamen2a alejandro roman
Examen2a alejandro romanhumanidades1
 
Have fun with your iPad
Have fun with your iPad Have fun with your iPad
Have fun with your iPad Website Wings
 
Spill response oil dehydration
Spill response oil dehydrationSpill response oil dehydration
Spill response oil dehydrationDiggricp
 

Viewers also liked (18)

pedido de Reynaldo Ruiz
pedido de Reynaldo Ruizpedido de Reynaldo Ruiz
pedido de Reynaldo Ruiz
 
Taller cross docking[1]-1(2) original
Taller cross docking[1]-1(2) originalTaller cross docking[1]-1(2) original
Taller cross docking[1]-1(2) original
 
Matrimono diapositivas
Matrimono diapositivasMatrimono diapositivas
Matrimono diapositivas
 
Power point ok
Power point okPower point ok
Power point ok
 
Pac3 Apartat1
Pac3 Apartat1Pac3 Apartat1
Pac3 Apartat1
 
Artikel OV4U
Artikel OV4UArtikel OV4U
Artikel OV4U
 
1a
1a1a
1a
 
Las Tic
Las TicLas Tic
Las Tic
 
Шляхецкія сядзібы Гомельшчыны
Шляхецкія сядзібы ГомельшчыныШляхецкія сядзібы Гомельшчыны
Шляхецкія сядзібы Гомельшчыны
 
Sexualidad
SexualidadSexualidad
Sexualidad
 
27 توصية من أجل معمل افضل
27 توصية من أجل معمل  افضل27 توصية من أجل معمل  افضل
27 توصية من أجل معمل افضل
 
Venta de apartamentos en barrio villadela
Venta de apartamentos en barrio villadelaVenta de apartamentos en barrio villadela
Venta de apartamentos en barrio villadela
 
High efficiency coalescer separator
High efficiency coalescer separatorHigh efficiency coalescer separator
High efficiency coalescer separator
 
Kollel R Kops
Kollel R KopsKollel R Kops
Kollel R Kops
 
abc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachments
abc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachmentsabc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachments
abc27 WHTM first e-mail Mr. Anthony Maydwell - 19 attachments
 
Examen2a alejandro roman
Examen2a alejandro romanExamen2a alejandro roman
Examen2a alejandro roman
 
Have fun with your iPad
Have fun with your iPad Have fun with your iPad
Have fun with your iPad
 
Spill response oil dehydration
Spill response oil dehydrationSpill response oil dehydration
Spill response oil dehydration
 

Similar to SCOTUS Upholds Obamacare Subsidies in King v Burwell

New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...Mrsunny4
 
MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2
MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2
MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2Sarah Boehm
 
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?Galen Institute
 
Having health care LegalApproach
Having health care LegalApproachHaving health care LegalApproach
Having health care LegalApproachwenhsing yang
 
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docxRunning Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docxtodd521
 
·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docx
·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docx·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docx
·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docxphilipnelson29183
 

Similar to SCOTUS Upholds Obamacare Subsidies in King v Burwell (9)

New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
 
Political ppt
Political pptPolitical ppt
Political ppt
 
MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2
MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2
MedicaidObamacare Presentation Final 2
 
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
 
Having health care LegalApproach
Having health care LegalApproachHaving health care LegalApproach
Having health care LegalApproach
 
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docxRunning Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
 
Gruper cap 1 y 2
Gruper cap 1 y 2Gruper cap 1 y 2
Gruper cap 1 y 2
 
·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docx
·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docx·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docx
·NEWSStates Take Aim at Social Welfare Programs  By Ti.docx
 
TCCRI Rally for Freedom Presentation
TCCRI Rally for Freedom PresentationTCCRI Rally for Freedom Presentation
TCCRI Rally for Freedom Presentation
 

SCOTUS Upholds Obamacare Subsidies in King v Burwell

  • 1. Editorial: Obamacare stands Don't let the angry press releases fool you. Republicans have plenty to celebrate now that the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a challenge to the Affordable Care Act. Not only will candidates be able to continue using the law as a political whipping-boy for the 2016 election, but the party also won't have to come up with any viable alternative. Perhaps they'll even start calling it SCOTUScare. At least that's what Justice Antonin Scalia recommended in his dissent. The issue raised by the case, King v. Burwell, wasn't a question of whether the law itself is constitutional - the court settled that question three years ago when it held that the individual mandate to buy insurance was enforceable as a tax. In this case the court was asked to address whether the law prohibited policyholders who purchased their insurance through federal exchanges from receiving the subsidies that make insurance affordable. In Texas, more than 832,000 people receive these subsidies to help purchase health insurance through the federal exchange. The problem rests with four words out of a 900-page document, which states that those subsidies are for people who purchased their plans through exchanges "established by the state." On their own, those words seem like a death knell - to use the words of Gov. Greg Abbott - for Obamacare insurance plans in the 34 states that refused to establish their own exchanges, such as Texas. But those four words don't exist in a vacuum, and it isn't the job of the Supreme Court to presume that Congress would write a law that fails to accomplish what it was created to do. Looking at those words in context, as Chief Justice John Roberts did in his majority opinion, it is implausible to think that Congress would write a law that effectively self-destructs. This is the smart decision of a justice who refuses to play politics. Yet while the court has settled these legal questions, the Obamacare fight continues. Texas Republicans wasted no time in releasing the usual harangues against the healthcare law. Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick called the Affordable Care Act "broken and a burden." U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz called it a "disaster."
  • 2. There's no denying problems with the rollout of Obamacare, but as time passes the law's actual impact is growing clearer. Health care costs are rising slower, the uninsured rate has hit a record low at 12.9 percent and the law itself saves taxpayers $353 billion over 10 years. Hospitals are also in a better financial position because of these new ranks of insured patients, according to Ted Shaw, president of the Texas Hospital Association. Overall, the law helps people take responsibility for their own health insurance. If there is a disaster, we don't see it. But that hasn't stopped Abbott from calling for a "President who will repeal Obamacare and enact real healthcare reforms."
  • 3. What exactly "real healthcare reform" means is a mystery. It isn't as if Obamacare sprung spontaneously from the president's forehead in 2009. As the Supreme Court documents in the King decision, the United States has a long history of failed health insurance reform, and the Affordable Care Act serves as a national adaptation of the one successful state plan - Massachusetts' 2006 health care reform, which was proposed, signed and implemented by then-Gov. Mitt Romney, the Republican candidate for president in 2012. At this point, fights over Obamacare smack more of politics than policy, and the poorest Texans are getting caught in the crossfire. Texas' political leaders have refused to accept $100 billion in federal funds that would expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act. Those dollars would cover 90 percent of the program's cost and provide health insurance for the 1.4 million Texans who are too poor to receive subsidies on the federal health care exchange. Without insurance, those Texans rely either on charity or county taxpayers to cover their bills. For the time being, Texans will have to pay twice for public health care, with federal and local taxes, while the people who need help the most get left behind. Expanding Medicaid would help everyone, but we're not optimistic. After all, it is hard to send out an angry press release when people are happy. http://www.chron.com/opinion/editorials/article/Obamacare-stands-6350038.php