SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
House easily votes to repeal ObamaCare tax on medical
equipment
The House shrugged off a White House veto threat and voted Thursday to repeal a tax that President
Obama's health care law imposed on medical equipment makers.
The Republican-led chamber has voted more than 50 times since 2011 to void all or part of Obama's
overhaul, usually along party lines. In this case, Republicans were joined by roughly four dozen
Democrats from states where medical devices are made to erase the 2.3 percent tax.
The measure's fate is uncertain in the Senate. Foes of the tax would probably have a difficult time
mustering the two-thirds majorities Congress needs to override a veto.
Thursday's 280-140 House vote came as lawmakers brace for a Supreme Court decision as soon as
next week that could erase a more vital piece of the 2010 law -- federal subsidies millions of
Americans use to help buy coverage.
The medical device tax, which took effect two years ago, was designed to help pay for the health
care overhaul, which has expanded coverage for millions of people. It is imposed on equipment like
artificial hearts and X-ray machines, but not items used by individuals, like eye glasses.
Opponents of the repeal effort say taxes the law imposed on many branches of the health care
industry were outweighed by added customers the law has created. They also object that opponents
would pay the $24 billion, 10-year cost of repeal with bigger federal deficits.
In a letter issuing its veto threat, the White House said repealing the tax "would take away a funding
source for financial assistance that is working to improve coverage and affordability" of health care.
Supporters of repeal -- including Democrats from states where the devices are made -- say the tax
drives up companies' expenses and stifles innovation. Rep. Larry Bucshon, R-Ind., called it a "job-
killing tax."
The House is expected to take another shot at the health care law next week and vote to eliminate
the Independent Payment Advisory Board that the law established to find ways to reduce Medicare
spending.
Republicans say that board's proposals would lead to health care rationing. Democrats say the
repeal effort is simply another GOP effort to weaken the overhaul law.
Thursday's vote came with Congress more focused on the imminent Supreme Court decision on
whether federal health care subsidies have been distributed legally.
A ruling voiding the subsidies would be a major blow to millions of people and to Obama's prized
health care overhaul, which relies on the assistance to help make insurance affordable.
House and Senate Republicans briefed rank-and-file GOP lawmakers on Wednesday about their
plans should the court annul many of those subsidies. With Republicans running Congress, most
want to find a way to avoid being blamed for causing such problems and antagonizing voters.
Conservatives bringing the case say the law's language limits subsidies to people in states that run
their own insurance marketplaces -- and not to residents of roughly three-dozen states relying on the
federal HealthCare.gov website.
The Health and Human Services Department says canceling those subsidies would deprive 6.4
million people of assistance. Many experts say most would drop coverage, which would become
unaffordable.
Under the tentative House GOP proposal, the subsidies would continue for a year. Then, states could
design their own plans for funneling federal health dollars to residents and drop the health law's
consumer protections, such as guaranteeing that family policies cover children until age 26.
In 2017 -- when Republicans hope to control the White House -- the entire health law would be
eliminated.
The Senate GOP plan, which could change, would continue federal aid for people who lost subsidies
until after the 2016 elections, said a chief author, Sen. John Barrasso, R-Wyo.
Like the House plan, it would erase the mandates for individual and employer-provided coverage.
Democrats say without those requirements, the health law would not function properly because too
many people would be uncovered.
It remains unclear whether Republicans would have enough votes to push such plans through
Congress. Solid Democratic opposition and a virtually certain Obama veto would await them.

More Related Content

What's hot

Communicating changes in health care
Communicating changes in health careCommunicating changes in health care
Communicating changes in health careAmy Fletcher
 
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?benefitexpress
 
Obamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive news
Obamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive newsObamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive news
Obamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive newsAlisha North
 
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to SucceedUpdates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to SucceedCora Butler, JD, RN, CHC
 
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...Behn Wyetzner, Chartered
 
Current legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcareCurrent legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcarewstarc5
 
Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017
Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017
Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017ConnectYourCare
 
Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)
Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)
Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)Floyd Arthur
 
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press ReleaseThe Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press ReleaseBehn Wyetzner, Chartered
 
Controlling the cost of medicaid
Controlling the cost of medicaidControlling the cost of medicaid
Controlling the cost of medicaidPaul Coelho, MD
 
Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06
Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06
Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06TerryEngleman
 
Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010
Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010
Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010BenefitMall
 
Apr12 editorialing
Apr12 editorialingApr12 editorialing
Apr12 editorialingSam Mayorga
 
case analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care actcase analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care actBobbi Jo Glowacki
 
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActAnalysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActKaryssa Costagliola
 
Healthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple Aim
Healthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple AimHealthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple Aim
Healthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple AimBESLER
 
North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12
North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12
North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12MattMcCord
 
HCS 410 project assignment
HCS 410 project assignmentHCS 410 project assignment
HCS 410 project assignmentMegan Serafin
 

What's hot (20)

Communicating changes in health care
Communicating changes in health careCommunicating changes in health care
Communicating changes in health care
 
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
What Happens if Obamacare is Struck Down?
 
Obamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive news
Obamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive newsObamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive news
Obamacare markets debut as early hurdles may slow signups hCentive news
 
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to SucceedUpdates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
Updates from Washington & Key Strategies to Succeed
 
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
Press Release from the U.S. Dept. of Justice on Whistleblower Case Settlement...
 
AHS - ObamaCare 3
AHS - ObamaCare 3AHS - ObamaCare 3
AHS - ObamaCare 3
 
h-15-014
h-15-014h-15-014
h-15-014
 
Current legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcareCurrent legal challenges facing healthcare
Current legal challenges facing healthcare
 
Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017
Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017
Health Care Legislative Roundup: February 2017
 
Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)
Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)
Medical Malpractice Reform Resurrected in Congress By Floyd Arthur (PPT)
 
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press ReleaseThe Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
The Qui Tam Lawsuit Against Walgreens - the Federal Press Release
 
Controlling the cost of medicaid
Controlling the cost of medicaidControlling the cost of medicaid
Controlling the cost of medicaid
 
Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06
Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06
Press Release For Enrollment Numbers 6.14.06
 
Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010
Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010
Legislative Webinar - December 3, 2010
 
Apr12 editorialing
Apr12 editorialingApr12 editorialing
Apr12 editorialing
 
case analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care actcase analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care act
 
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActAnalysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
 
Healthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple Aim
Healthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple AimHealthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple Aim
Healthcare Retrospect Part 3: Achieving The Triple Aim
 
North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12
North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12
North Oakland Tea Party Presentation 8.23.12
 
HCS 410 project assignment
HCS 410 project assignmentHCS 410 project assignment
HCS 410 project assignment
 

Similar to House easily votes to repeal ObamaCare tax on medical equipment

Health reform: What it means. What's next?
Health reform: What it means. What's next?Health reform: What it means. What's next?
Health reform: What it means. What's next?Galen Institute
 
V DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdf
V DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdfV DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdf
V DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdfadityavision1
 
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?Galen Institute
 
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docxRunning Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docxtodd521
 
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01Jon Nadler
 
Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...
Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...
Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...Paige Catizone
 
Case Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power point
Case Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power pointCase Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power point
Case Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power pointKaryssa Costagliola
 
Problem 17.4 Consider the following financial statements for Be.docx
Problem 17.4  Consider the following financial statements for Be.docxProblem 17.4  Consider the following financial statements for Be.docx
Problem 17.4 Consider the following financial statements for Be.docxsleeperharwell
 
Foyperspective: No Deal on Repeal
Foyperspective: No Deal on RepealFoyperspective: No Deal on Repeal
Foyperspective: No Deal on RepealJared Foy
 
Overview of Federal Health Care Reform
Overview of Federal Health Care ReformOverview of Federal Health Care Reform
Overview of Federal Health Care Reformsoder145
 
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...Paige Catizone
 
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...Paige Catizone
 
week3 discuss 6050.docx
week3 discuss 6050.docxweek3 discuss 6050.docx
week3 discuss 6050.docxwrite5
 
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...Mrsunny4
 

Similar to House easily votes to repeal ObamaCare tax on medical equipment (15)

Health reform: What it means. What's next?
Health reform: What it means. What's next?Health reform: What it means. What's next?
Health reform: What it means. What's next?
 
Political ppt
Political pptPolitical ppt
Political ppt
 
V DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdf
V DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdfV DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdf
V DetailsThe purpose of this assignment is to develop relevant neg.pdf
 
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
GWAHU: Health Reform -- Where Are We Now?
 
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docxRunning Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
Running Head ROLE OF EXECUTIVE ORDER IN ACARole of Executiv.docx
 
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
 
Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...
Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...
Case analysis of the affordable care act power point, hcs410, hcs organizatio...
 
Case Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power point
Case Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power pointCase Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power point
Case Analysis of the Affordable Care Act power point
 
Problem 17.4 Consider the following financial statements for Be.docx
Problem 17.4  Consider the following financial statements for Be.docxProblem 17.4  Consider the following financial statements for Be.docx
Problem 17.4 Consider the following financial statements for Be.docx
 
Foyperspective: No Deal on Repeal
Foyperspective: No Deal on RepealFoyperspective: No Deal on Repeal
Foyperspective: No Deal on Repeal
 
Overview of Federal Health Care Reform
Overview of Federal Health Care ReformOverview of Federal Health Care Reform
Overview of Federal Health Care Reform
 
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
 
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Paper, HCS410, hea...
 
week3 discuss 6050.docx
week3 discuss 6050.docxweek3 discuss 6050.docx
week3 discuss 6050.docx
 
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
New health care bills devastating impact on the mentally ill addicts and trea...
 

House easily votes to repeal ObamaCare tax on medical equipment

  • 1. House easily votes to repeal ObamaCare tax on medical equipment The House shrugged off a White House veto threat and voted Thursday to repeal a tax that President Obama's health care law imposed on medical equipment makers. The Republican-led chamber has voted more than 50 times since 2011 to void all or part of Obama's overhaul, usually along party lines. In this case, Republicans were joined by roughly four dozen Democrats from states where medical devices are made to erase the 2.3 percent tax. The measure's fate is uncertain in the Senate. Foes of the tax would probably have a difficult time mustering the two-thirds majorities Congress needs to override a veto. Thursday's 280-140 House vote came as lawmakers brace for a Supreme Court decision as soon as next week that could erase a more vital piece of the 2010 law -- federal subsidies millions of Americans use to help buy coverage. The medical device tax, which took effect two years ago, was designed to help pay for the health care overhaul, which has expanded coverage for millions of people. It is imposed on equipment like artificial hearts and X-ray machines, but not items used by individuals, like eye glasses. Opponents of the repeal effort say taxes the law imposed on many branches of the health care industry were outweighed by added customers the law has created. They also object that opponents would pay the $24 billion, 10-year cost of repeal with bigger federal deficits. In a letter issuing its veto threat, the White House said repealing the tax "would take away a funding source for financial assistance that is working to improve coverage and affordability" of health care. Supporters of repeal -- including Democrats from states where the devices are made -- say the tax drives up companies' expenses and stifles innovation. Rep. Larry Bucshon, R-Ind., called it a "job- killing tax." The House is expected to take another shot at the health care law next week and vote to eliminate the Independent Payment Advisory Board that the law established to find ways to reduce Medicare spending. Republicans say that board's proposals would lead to health care rationing. Democrats say the repeal effort is simply another GOP effort to weaken the overhaul law. Thursday's vote came with Congress more focused on the imminent Supreme Court decision on whether federal health care subsidies have been distributed legally. A ruling voiding the subsidies would be a major blow to millions of people and to Obama's prized health care overhaul, which relies on the assistance to help make insurance affordable. House and Senate Republicans briefed rank-and-file GOP lawmakers on Wednesday about their plans should the court annul many of those subsidies. With Republicans running Congress, most want to find a way to avoid being blamed for causing such problems and antagonizing voters.
  • 2. Conservatives bringing the case say the law's language limits subsidies to people in states that run their own insurance marketplaces -- and not to residents of roughly three-dozen states relying on the federal HealthCare.gov website. The Health and Human Services Department says canceling those subsidies would deprive 6.4 million people of assistance. Many experts say most would drop coverage, which would become unaffordable. Under the tentative House GOP proposal, the subsidies would continue for a year. Then, states could design their own plans for funneling federal health dollars to residents and drop the health law's consumer protections, such as guaranteeing that family policies cover children until age 26. In 2017 -- when Republicans hope to control the White House -- the entire health law would be eliminated. The Senate GOP plan, which could change, would continue federal aid for people who lost subsidies until after the 2016 elections, said a chief author, Sen. John Barrasso, R-Wyo. Like the House plan, it would erase the mandates for individual and employer-provided coverage. Democrats say without those requirements, the health law would not function properly because too many people would be uncovered. It remains unclear whether Republicans would have enough votes to push such plans through Congress. Solid Democratic opposition and a virtually certain Obama veto would await them.