My new book The Techno-Human Shell-A Jump in the Evolutionary Gap was just released. It deals with the consequences of a future where minds and bodies are enhanced due to the inevitable incorporation of computers and other technologies. I ask at what point, and in what ways, our future cyborg-selves might begin to regard our own humanity differently? I am a member of the Yale Community Bioethics Forum of the Program on Biomedical Ethics at Yale School of Medicine, as well as a member of the Yale Technology and Ethics working group. I am also an adjunct Professor of Law, Science and Technology at Quinnipiac University School of Law as well as a patent attorney and engineer. You can read a few chapters at:
http://www.amazon.com/The-Techno-Human-Shell-Evolutionary-ebook/dp/B00AW53NCK
4. CONTENTS
PREFACE...........................................................................2
INTRODUCTION..............................................................6
SNAPSHOT OF THE FUTURE.....................................18
Manufacturing New Life.....................................................32
Where We Are Headed.......................................................37
EMBEDDED TECHNOLOGIES....................................41
Body meet Computer—Computer meet Body.....................45
Reengineering Perception...................................................49
The Drug—Electronic Trade-off ..........................................51
Electronic Art of Seeing ......................................................55
Cochlear Implant System....................................................60
Accessing the Deep—Sensors and Controllers ....................61
Artificial Brains...................................................................65
Implantable Pumps.............................................................68
Real-time Imaging of the Anatomy .....................................71
Bit of Biology......................................................................73
Nanotechnology.................................................................76
Language at the Bottom......................................................84
5. A Gizmo is a Gizmo by any Name........................................87
Merging Structure and Process ...........................................95
TECTONIC FUTURE ..................................................110
The Anatomy Socialized and Commercialized....................115
Concentrations of Power ..................................................117
Admission Fees.................................................................121
Inventions Alter Society Unpredictably .............................124
Who Will Own In-The-Body Technology?...........................128
Rationing Therapeutics ....................................................131
Processes and Artifacts.....................................................138
Through the Lens of A Cyborg...........................................143
Quantum Society..............................................................147
Functions and Assigned Purpose.......................................151
FORM IN CYBORGIZATION.....................................157
CONCLUSION...............................................................169
ENDNOTES...................................................174
6.
7. Sunlight1
by Jim Harrison
After days of darkness I didn't understand
a second of yellow sunlight
here and gone through a hole in clouds
as quickly as a flashbulb, an immense
memory of a moment of grace withdrawn.
It is said that we are here but seconds in cosmic
time, twelve and a half billion years,
but who is saying this and why?
In the Salt Lake City airport eight out of ten
were fiddling relentlessly with cell phones.
The world is too grand to reshape with babble.
Outside the hot sun beat down on clumsy metal
birds and an actual ten-million-year-old
crow flew by squawking in bemusement.
We're doubtless as old as our mothers, thousands
of generations waiting for the sunlight.
1
8. Joseph Carvalko
Now I've argued this is not genesis; this is building on three and a
half billion years of evolution. And I've argued that we're about to
perhaps create a new version of the Cambrian explosion, where
there's massive new speciation based on this digital design.—Craig
Venter 2
PREFACE
If we study the great works of art, sculpture, and
literature, we learn that our ancestors looked like us
physically, thought like us, and perhaps felt much as we
do. After all, we largely inherited their design: two arms,
two legs, a body, and a head filled with matter adept at
abstract thinking and feeling: a design which allows
adaptation to the environment and survival into the next
generation. However, as the human body tumbles
headlong into the future, the fact that it and its ancestors
may look familiar may be as far as resemblance goes. On
the horizon of those now being born, their maturation,
their death, and their children’s natural cycles of birth, will
be driven as much by technology as driven by the genes
cast in the DNA backbone over 3.5 billion years ago. 3
Respected futurists have concluded that we have gone
beyond our ability to retard this technological fate as we
inescapably move toward a singularity—that event after
which nothing looks like what came before. But is it really
too late to change course? Must we resign ourselves to a
future that will include successors that may look like us,
but at their core will not represent the current model, nor
represent what has heretofore passed as human? And if
so, what steps should we take to push against devolving
into a civilization of post-post-moderns that will look back
upon their ancestors as Neanderthal cousins?
When the planet formed 4.6 billion years ago, oceans,
mountains, and flat lands were created. Approximately 2.5
million years ago—relatively recently on the cosmic scale—
Homo genus appeared, followed 2.3 million years later,
Homo sapiens—those upright creatures we see in the
mirror every day.4 We have come to know ourselves not
through mirrored reflections, but through conscious
observation, thoughts, emotions, and self-awareness
2
9. The Techno-Human Shell
manifesting in a developed persona that exhibits a
combination of openness, extraversion, neuroticism,
agreeableness, and conscientiousness.5 Combined, this
persona learned to adapt to ever-changing circumstances
to appreciate cause and effect, to invent tools, weapons,
and skills and, over time, language that passed on the non-
genetic essentials needed for its persistence in a sometimes
hostile world. In the span of six to ten thousand years,
language paved the way for philosophy, physics, chemistry,
biology, medicine, computation, and the proliferation of
know-how called technology. Over the course of the last
five hundred years accumulated knowledge changed not
only our understanding of the world outside ourselves, but
changed our understanding of the world inside ourselves. 6
The curves of scientific knowledge and technological
progress bend increasingly skyward, every year more
steeply as we reach for the stars from which we originated.
Is our current track yet another indication of non-genetic
essentials serving as tools, and language once did—this
time transcending existential biological limitations, finally
eschewing the Homo sapiens within the borders of our
epidermis, to be reborn as altered creatures—as post
biological Homo sapiens?
A central thesis of this book is: As computers with ever
increasing computational power of the famous Watson IBM
computer spiral downward in size, the wholesale
incorporation of these devices into the anatomy will become
as common as a pill ingested, a vaccine injected or a body
pierced. 7 In the first phase, these will be installed first for
medicinal therapy, then for diagnostics, followed by
physical and mental enhancements. In the second phase
they will be installed to more efficiently interface with a
digital evolution.
It is in this second phase when Darwinian evolutionary
rivers will merge with the rivers of intelligent designers,
represented by scientists, programmers and engineers who
will fuse organic natural biology, synthetic biology, and
digital technology into a unified whole that future
generations will deem their anatomy. The merger will serve
to afford greater intelligence and, longer, healthier lives. In
exchange, we will relinquish actual autonomy for apparent
3
10. Joseph Carvalko
autonomy, where what was once considered “free will” will
be supplanted by the deterministic logic of machinery
somewhere in the mainstream of our unconscious.
Although in-the-body technology will have an explosive
effect on commerce, entertainment, and employment, in
the near term the concentration will be on medical devices,
such as the innocuous pacemaker (essentially a working
silicon-based computer, with sensors, memories, and a
stimulation device with telecommunications to the outer
world). In a second epoch, these devices will be gradually
down-sized by advances in synthetic DNA, molecular- and
nano-sized processors, each deployed alongside and within
cells and organs as permanent non-organic, internal
adjuncts to our anatomy for use as: nano-prosthetics,
nano-stimulators/suppressors, artificial organ processors,
metabolic and cognitive enhancers, and permanent
diagnostic tools to ensure our physical and psychological
well-being as we head toward a practically interminable
lifetime. 8
Will a wide-spread practice of installing technology into
the body fundamentally change human essence? Our
sense of self-sufficiency, authenticity, or individual
identity? Will it change that numerical identity, the one “I”
as some static aspect of ourselves (as self-consciousness as
idealized by Locke)? Or will it change our narrative identity,
our unseen internal human form, to eventually redefine
what it means to be human?9
The digital revolution altered our social reality (just
compare the habits of someone born a generation ago to
someone born four generations ago). But today, most
computers are at our fingertips. Darwin insisted “natura
non facit saltum”—nature does not make leaps—but what
happens when computers are moved inside our core,
internalized, and become ubiquitous subterranean
assistants function within our anatomical structure? 10 Will
a new exterior reality emerge? Or will it go unnoticed, like
the daily 80 milligram aspirin, acting undetected on our
physiology? Social philosopher Francis Fukuyama
suggests what Darwin might have concluded had he been
alive today:
4
11. The Techno-Human Shell
... while Aristotle believed in the eternity of the
species (i.e., that what we have been labeling
‘species-typical behavior’ is somewhat unchanging),
Darwin’s theory maintains that this behavior
changes in response to the organism’s interaction
with its environment. What is typical for a species at
one particular moment of evolutionary time; what
came before and what comes after will be different. 11
This book will explore the question: Will the course of
accelerating technological advance cause a subtle
revolution in the human form—one that shifts the
foundations of Homo sapiens, forming post-Homo sapiens
who will have failed to record the journey, and thus
making it impossible to return to a time, when humans
roamed the Earth?
5
12. Joseph Carvalko
Cy·borg (sbôrg) n. A human who has certain physiological processes
aided or controlled by mechanical or electronic devices. 12
INTRODUCTION
According to Greek Mythology, the gods ordered
Prometheus and his brother Epimetheus to create
humankind. Epimetheus, being the more impetuous, took
the lead, but rather than creating the species directly,
formed animals first, to which he gave fur, feathers, wings,
and shells, leaving his second creation, humans, naked.
Prometheus came to the rescue, first helping this new
creature stand erect among all beasts, and then he
traveled to the sun, where he ignited a torch and
bequeathed fire to Earth’s new subjects so that camp fires
would light the nights and enemies would be brought out
of the darkness.
Fire changed humanity. It cast upon it light and shaped
a being whose quintessence could not be separated from
this new force—this new technology, which inevitably led
the way out of inferiority—to stand tall against the forces of
nature and other creatures. But it wasn’t until the
Industrial Revolution that the tools of technology began to
inundate this new life. Some would say this was for the
greater good, but it carried in its undercurrents
unintended consequences. If modern technology were
suddenly wrested from us, it is certain our days would be
numbered and we would not survive more than a few days,
weeks at most. Technology constantly shapes us as
intellectual, moral, and social agents, yet when we first
held fire in our hands, not even Prometheus could have
predicted the extent to which we have evolved in this the
Twenty-first Century.
The transition from human to posthuman will occur in
two stages: the first memetic, where the current
technological culture fades into a society, loosely in
control, but largely accepting and dependent on in-the-
body technology for its health, enhanced abilities, security,
social mobility, and economic condition. The second stage
6