The document discusses factors impacting farmland markets according to an expert panel. Farmland represents 83% of farm assets in the US and has low debt levels. Key factors affecting farmland values are crop income, capitalization rates, demand for food, and availability of farmland financing. The largest risks are sudden policy changes, changes to crop insurance, slowing global income growth, and water issues. New technologies are increasing agricultural production and supply chain efficiency while making more data available. This will increase transparency in farmland markets and disrupt existing industries over time.
2. Factors impacting farmland markets
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets 2
LeeAnn Moss, AcreValue
โ Director of Industry Marketing
โ Joined Granular in 2017
โ Former farm real estate broker,
auctioneer and appraiser
Featured Guest:
Dr. Bruce Sherrick
โ Fruin Professor of Land
Economics, University of Illinois
โ Director, TIAA Center for
Farmland Research
โ Board Member, Farmer Mac
โ Partner, Integrated Financial Analytics & Research
Our Speakers Today
3. 01 / Making Sense of Farmland Markets โ Past and Present
02 / Thoughts on the Future
03 / Impact of Data and Technology
04 / Q & A
3Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
4. 4
Historic Balance Sheet of Ag Sector: What Matters?
Selected balance sheet characteristics of US Agricultural Sector.
$3 trillion in assets 2017
โช Concentrated in real
estate
โช Very low relative debt
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
5. The Ag Sector Balance Sheet is Unique
5
โช Farmland = 83% of farm assets
โช Farm real estate debt = 62% of total
farm debt
โช Low aggregate leverage
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
6. Some Major Factors Affecting Values
6
Income
โช Short term income changes not translated fully to values
โช Crop insurance and risk management
โช Long-term expectations vs. current experience
Cap rate - cost of capital to control farmland investment
โช Opportunity costs
โช Returns/multiple expansion
โช Limited tradability of assets
Long-term food demand prospects
โช Positive macro outlook
โช Positive world outlook
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
10. 10
No, We Are Not In The 1980s...
Farm mortgage interest rates and funding relationships
1980s farm mortgages:
โช 80% LTV
โช 40-year amortization
Present mortgage environment:
โช Lower interest rates
โช Lower leverage
โช Crop insurance / risk management
โช Different lending environment
โช Beginning-stage financialization
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
11. 01 / Making Sense of Farmland Markets โ Past and Present
02 / Thoughts on the Future
03 / Impact of Data and Technology
04 / Q & A
11Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
12. Largest Risks to Farmland Markets?
12
โช Sudden change in policy or macro environment
โช Change in crop insurance
โช Global slowdown in income growth (e.g. China)
โช Water usage/availability
โช Major changes in trade
โช Consumer relationship with food
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
13. Near Term Farmland Market Issues
13
โช Range of sales prices steady and rents steady
to lower
โช Low land turnover
โช Continued movement toward cash and flex
cash rents
โช Debt levels could become more efficient
โช Influence of big data and ag-technology
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
14. 01 / Making Sense of Farmland Markets โ Past and Present
02 / Thoughts on the Future
03 / Impact of Data and Technology
04 / Q & A
14Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
15. 15
Technology and Consumer Impacts Increasing
Production
Technologies
Information
Technologies
Management
Technologies
Supply Chain
Technologies
Precision Ag-tech:
โช Genetics, remote sensing, conservation,
location-specific inputs, verified production
practices, controlled environments
Evolving Supply Chain:
โช Consumer demands
increasingly impacting
production
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
17. 17
โช Consolidation continuing
โช Efficient financing - separability of ownership and
operation
โช Technology adoption
โช Mooreโs law and Big Data in Ag - still early stage
โช Local context still critical
โช When technology allows more data and
information at low cost, decision making is
increasingly valuable
Futurecasting โ Farmland Market Impacts
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
23. The Horizon Effect
23
โช Greater Efficiencies: Technology, Information, Research, Production Practices
โช Farmland Markets: More Transparency
โช Disruption: Appraisal, Lending, Investing, Brokerage, Management
Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
24. 01 / Making Sense of Farmland Markets โ Past and Present
02 / Thoughts on the Future
03 / Impact of Data and Technology
04 / Q & A
24Factors Impacting Farmland Markets
Making sense of farmland markets
Understanding the farmland market
How to make sense of farmland markets
Factors Affecting Values
Making Sense of the Farmland Market
Farmland Trends & Returns 1970 โ 2017
Illinois Farmland Analysis: Values, Comps, Soil, Crop Histories
The Impact of Technology
Large and growing sector topped $3 trillion in 2017, concentrated in real estate and very low relative debt - much lower than in 1980s - BJS
โขFarmland represents about 83% of farm assets
โขFarm real estate debt only 62% of total farm debt
โขLow aggregate leverage (approx. 13% D/A)
โขGrowth rates 1970-2017, continuous compounding, excluding income:
โขAssets --5%
โขReal Estate -- 5.3%
โขDebt โ 5%
โขEquity โ 5%
โขAbsence of active equity market with โhedgeableโ indices โ key in future.
โขAg Balance sheet compared to corporate sector vastly different, especially in financial structure (far less debt, non-uniform distribution)
โขEarly stage โfinancializationโ critical to improving efficiency of farmland market.
Income and expectations for future income and its growth
Recent episodes influence expectations of future income in dampened fashion
โReal Optionโ issues (once out of game, cannot re-enter)
Stickiness of rental markets, ability to smooth through time
Crop insurance, risk management options create floors to some degree
Cost of capital, opportunity costs, willingness to pay/accept
Economy-wide compression of returns/multiple expansion
Relative advantage of long duration, inflation sensitive assets to institutions
Limited tradeability of assets in agricultural sector
Long-term world thesis around food production remains fairly strong.
Factors Affecting Values
Making Sense of the Farmland Market
Farmland Trends & Returns 1970 โ 2017
Illinois Farmland Analysis: Values, Comps, Soil, Crop Histories
The Impact of Technology
Influence of big data and technology - information and decision systems that rely on high resolution or high frequency information will increasingly matter as an โinputโ
Factors Affecting Values
Making Sense of the Farmland Market
Farmland Trends & Returns 1970 โ 2017
Illinois Farmland Analysis: Values, Comps, Soil, Crop Histories
The Impact of Technology
Consolidation is beginning in Ag-Tech space. Lots of Dry Powder on the sidelines, but lots of redundant IP in system.
Connection of efficient financing sources is key
Routinization of technology allows other services to be added
Mooreโs law and Big Data in Ag โ not only in processing capacity but also in applications, especially land mgt.
Local context โ when technology allows more data assembly at low cost, decisions making is increasingly valuable. Separates winners and Losers
(and a comment about Values, thermometers, and RMSEs)
(and a comment about PI and taxes..)
(and a comment about crop insurance, and in-year rapid eval.)
โFinancializationโ likely to continue for the sector. Equity & indexing vehicles very positive developments despite local concerns. GAIC.
Financial regulation will not retreat significantly in Ag โ lenders key
Relationship of consumers to food and food channel will cost more.
Better use of data has always been the key to successful management. Technology is exploding and layering transactions with meta data
Separation of accounting for ownership and operation is healthy
Farmland markets are still in infancy compared to other real asset markets
Improved efficiency will always capture economic rents
Factors Affecting Values
Making Sense of the Farmland Market
Farmland Trends & Returns 1970 โ 2017
Illinois Farmland Analysis: Values, Comps, Soil, Crop Histories
The Impact of Technology