2. Approaches to the Engagement
• Each firm has its own approach or framework
• Many similarities between them
• How to
• Describe the problem
• Analyze data
• Evaluate options and choose one
• Implement
Based on the work of Elliott N. Weiss
4. Booz Allen Hamilton’s Hypothesis Approach
• Combine your expertise
and what you learn from
the client to develop
testable hypotheses
• Collect and analyze data
to test hypotheses
• Try to prove the
hypotheses wrong,
not right
• Look for context and
boundary conditions
• Draw conclusions
5. A similar line of attack
Identify the problem (or
opportunity)
Identify possible solutions
Evaluate possible solutions (with
data)
Implement the best solution
Repeat if necessary
6. SCR Approach
Situation
Context
What is already
accepted as fact
• Maybe the problem
or opportunity,
maybe not
Complication
What are the root
causes?
What will be the
impact if not
addressed?
Data as evidence
This is where
persuasion comes in
Resolution
What action is
required to solve
problem or leverage
opportunity?
7. Key questions, regardless of approach
• Has the client’s customer been considered?
• What is necessary to secure top management
team support?
• How does the client currently solve
problems?
• Are any of your recommendations based on
opinions or untested hypotheses? Use data!
• How sustainable are the gains?
8. What you need to gain commitment on
• The problem (Or opportunity)
• The root causes
• What will happen if we don’t take action
• What success should look like
• What we should do
9. Five Decision Making Styles
• Charismatic (25%)
• Thinker (11%)
• Skeptic (19%)
• Follower (36%)
• Controller (9%)
Based on the work of Williams & Miller
11. How to persuade Charismatics
• Focus on results
• Make
straightforward
arguments
• Stress benefits-–
use visuals
• Key words:
Proven, Actions,
Easy, Clear
17. How to persuade Followers
• Use testimonials to
prove low risk
• Present innovative,
though proven,
solutions
• Key words:
Expertise, Similar
to, Innovate,
Previous
19. How to persuade controllers
• Present highly
structured arguments
• Make listener “own” the
idea: Make multiple
options
• Avoid aggressive
advocacy
• Key words: Facts,
Reason, Power, Just
do it
20. Takeaways
• From the beginning of the engagement, be
thinking about who you need commitment
from and how you will get them on your side
• Successful implementation is 70% content,
30% selling
• As you learn more about your client and the
organization, pay attention to how they have
made decisions in the past