SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Imagine that, in the after math of Hurricane Maria, local stores
in Puerto Rico suddenly find themselves flooded with panicked
citizens who need various goods to deal with their sudden new
problems (unfortunately this doesn't take much imagination).
But the stores have small inventories and cannot accommodate
everyone's desires. If Hayek were watching, how would he
expect the stores to decide how to allocate resources among the
citizens' competing desires?
Suppose that Donald Trump finds out about the hurricane
impact and wants to take action to help the citizens of Puerto
Rico. In addition to sending supplies and disaster relief
professionals to the scene, Trump considers using professional
economists to decide how goods should be allocated among the
local citizenry. If Trump asked Hayek for advice regarding this
proposal, what do you think Hayek would say? And why?
What do you think of Hayek's advice? Do you think local
stores or the Trump administration should -- in the sense of
morally should -- follow it? Why or why not?
As with previous VoiceThread assignments please try to keep
your responses under 4 minutes or so.

More Related Content

More from he45mcurnow

The film I chose is The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docx
The film I chose is  The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docxThe film I chose is  The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docx
The film I chose is The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docxhe45mcurnow
 
The fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docx
The fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docxThe fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docx
The fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docxhe45mcurnow
 
the event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docx
the event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docxthe event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docx
the event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docx
The Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docxThe Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docx
The Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docx
The Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docxThe Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docx
The Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docx
The essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docxThe essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docx
The essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docx
The essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docxThe essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docx
The essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docx
The entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docxThe entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docx
The entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docxhe45mcurnow
 
The end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docx
The end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docxThe end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docx
The end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docx
The Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docxThe Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docx
The Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docx
The emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docxThe emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docx
The emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docx
The Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docxThe Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docx
The Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docx
The Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docxThe Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docx
The Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docx
The Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docxThe Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docx
The Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docx
The federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docxThe federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docx
The federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docx
The Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docxThe Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docx
The Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docx
The diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docxThe diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docx
The diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docx
The Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docxThe Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docx
The Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docx
The documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docxThe documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docx
The documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docxhe45mcurnow
 
The Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docx
The Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docxThe Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docx
The Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docxhe45mcurnow
 

More from he45mcurnow (20)

The film I chose is The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docx
The film I chose is  The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docxThe film I chose is  The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docx
The film I chose is The Wizard of Oz.ReflectThere are many .docx
 
The fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docx
The fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docxThe fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docx
The fear that this population feels is not fear of the diagnosis bu.docx
 
the event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docx
the event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docxthe event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docx
the event is the Fort Hood Massacre 2009- themes to discuss are Terr.docx
 
The Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docx
The Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docxThe Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docx
The Extra Credit Assignment In Topic 6 you and your classmates consi.docx
 
The Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docx
The Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docxThe Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docx
The Estrangement of Labour, page 1 of 3We shall start out from a.docx
 
The essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docx
The essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docxThe essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docx
The essay that needs to be written requires-3-4 pages-3-5 sourc.docx
 
The essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docx
The essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docxThe essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docx
The essay due after 10h from now exactly at 12 p.m it cant be submi.docx
 
The entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docx
The entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docxThe entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docx
The entire memo is a total of one page long, single-spaced. This is .docx
 
The end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docx
The end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docxThe end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docx
The end of the Civil War left the United States in tatters. The sout.docx
 
The Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docx
The Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docxThe Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docx
The Effects of Addiction PaperMaterialsWeek 2 Electronic Reser.docx
 
The emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docx
The emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docxThe emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docx
The emergence of modern science began as a move from theological-bas.docx
 
The Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docx
The Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docxThe Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docx
The Economys Impact on Crime Please respond to the followingF.docx
 
The Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docx
The Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docxThe Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docx
The Dynamic Earth Research Paper Assignment This is to be a resear.docx
 
The Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docx
The Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docxThe Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docx
The Earth’s largest phylum is Arthropoda, including centipedes, mill.docx
 
The federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docx
The federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docxThe federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docx
The federal bureaucracy is sometimes referred to as the fourth bran.docx
 
The Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docx
The Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docxThe Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docx
The Distinction between Leadership and ManagementThink of the mana.docx
 
The diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docx
The diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docxThe diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docx
The diversity of the U.S. population has changed significantly over .docx
 
The Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docx
The Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docxThe Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docx
The Dual Nature of InformaticsInformatics can be used for impr.docx
 
The documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docx
The documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docxThe documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docx
The documents created at the inception of American democracy trace t.docx
 
The Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docx
The Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docxThe Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docx
The Double HelixDescribe the role of double helix in complimentary.docx
 

Imagine that, in the after math of Hurricane Maria, local stores i

  • 1. Imagine that, in the after math of Hurricane Maria, local stores in Puerto Rico suddenly find themselves flooded with panicked citizens who need various goods to deal with their sudden new problems (unfortunately this doesn't take much imagination). But the stores have small inventories and cannot accommodate everyone's desires. If Hayek were watching, how would he expect the stores to decide how to allocate resources among the citizens' competing desires? Suppose that Donald Trump finds out about the hurricane impact and wants to take action to help the citizens of Puerto Rico. In addition to sending supplies and disaster relief professionals to the scene, Trump considers using professional economists to decide how goods should be allocated among the local citizenry. If Trump asked Hayek for advice regarding this proposal, what do you think Hayek would say? And why? What do you think of Hayek's advice? Do you think local stores or the Trump administration should -- in the sense of morally should -- follow it? Why or why not? As with previous VoiceThread assignments please try to keep your responses under 4 minutes or so.