SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 3
Managing the Dissertation Committee

           RajshreeAgarwal, Professor and Dean’s Chair in
     Entrepreneurship and Strategy, University of Maryland
Choosing your committee members
   Know what you want from your committee members
       Expert knowledge in theory, data or methods
       Overall “wisdom” in positioning
       “External” committee member
           Some schools require member outside of department
           Some schools regulate the number of outside school members
            you can have
       Co-chairs?
   Consult with your dissertation advisor
       Collaborative decision
       You’ll need your advisor to help out in case conflicts arise
           be aware of ex ante conflict situations
How to reduce nasty surprises at the end?
   Make sure that you connect with your committee
    members often
   The more engaged they are in your dissertation…
       The more you benefit from their insights and expertise
       The more they know of what you are doing before your defense
       The less likely they will be to introduce thorny issues at a very
        late stage
   Help them help you…
       Be cognizant of their time pressures
       Prepare ahead for meetings
           Provide them with materials ahead of time, but don’t always count
            on them reading these.
           Have summary slides, and directed questions, so their response
            burden is not high
       DO NOT provide them with documents incomplete information,
        un-edited text, incorrect grammar, etc.
           Small issues that lead to major impression management problems

More Related Content

Similar to Managing your dissertation committee 2011

Similar to Managing your dissertation committee 2011 (20)

STRENGTHSFINDER 2.0-MRINAL KRANT
STRENGTHSFINDER 2.0-MRINAL KRANTSTRENGTHSFINDER 2.0-MRINAL KRANT
STRENGTHSFINDER 2.0-MRINAL KRANT
 
strengths raven
strengths ravenstrengths raven
strengths raven
 
GallupReport
GallupReportGallupReport
GallupReport
 
How to prepare for oral defense
How to prepare for oral defenseHow to prepare for oral defense
How to prepare for oral defense
 
Top questions asked during ph
Top questions asked during phTop questions asked during ph
Top questions asked during ph
 
Gallup Strengths Finder Report Summary
Gallup Strengths Finder Report SummaryGallup Strengths Finder Report Summary
Gallup Strengths Finder Report Summary
 
strengthsfinder report.PDF
strengthsfinder report.PDFstrengthsfinder report.PDF
strengthsfinder report.PDF
 
GallupReport (1)
GallupReport (1)GallupReport (1)
GallupReport (1)
 
Greg Dow StrengthsFinder2.0
Greg Dow StrengthsFinder2.0Greg Dow StrengthsFinder2.0
Greg Dow StrengthsFinder2.0
 
Strengths Guide - Chris Carpenter
Strengths Guide - Chris CarpenterStrengths Guide - Chris Carpenter
Strengths Guide - Chris Carpenter
 
GallupReport
GallupReportGallupReport
GallupReport
 
Andrew Willmert Strengths Finder
Andrew Willmert Strengths FinderAndrew Willmert Strengths Finder
Andrew Willmert Strengths Finder
 
Strengths-Based Leadership Insight Report
Strengths-Based Leadership Insight ReportStrengths-Based Leadership Insight Report
Strengths-Based Leadership Insight Report
 
Strengthsfinder2.0
Strengthsfinder2.0Strengthsfinder2.0
Strengthsfinder2.0
 
Effective Advising
Effective AdvisingEffective Advising
Effective Advising
 
KFManning Strengths Finder Results
KFManning Strengths Finder ResultsKFManning Strengths Finder Results
KFManning Strengths Finder Results
 
Saat StrengthsFinder 2.0 Report
Saat StrengthsFinder 2.0 ReportSaat StrengthsFinder 2.0 Report
Saat StrengthsFinder 2.0 Report
 
Attitude, Committee Selection, and Topic Development
Attitude, Committee Selection, and Topic DevelopmentAttitude, Committee Selection, and Topic Development
Attitude, Committee Selection, and Topic Development
 
GallupReport
GallupReportGallupReport
GallupReport
 
Design Thinking for Inclusive Collaboration
Design Thinking for Inclusive CollaborationDesign Thinking for Inclusive Collaboration
Design Thinking for Inclusive Collaboration
 

More from Chuck Eesley

Eesley research overview MS&E
Eesley research overview MS&EEesley research overview MS&E
Eesley research overview MS&EChuck Eesley
 
Business idea sources
Business idea sourcesBusiness idea sources
Business idea sourcesChuck Eesley
 
Stanford eesley miller_impact_report
Stanford eesley miller_impact_reportStanford eesley miller_impact_report
Stanford eesley miller_impact_reportChuck Eesley
 
Competition lecture
Competition lectureCompetition lecture
Competition lectureChuck Eesley
 
985 paper presentation -banff 2015
985 paper presentation -banff 2015985 paper presentation -banff 2015
985 paper presentation -banff 2015Chuck Eesley
 
Aom early venture_evolution_eesley
Aom early venture_evolution_eesleyAom early venture_evolution_eesley
Aom early venture_evolution_eesleyChuck Eesley
 
Bps managing dissertation
Bps managing dissertationBps managing dissertation
Bps managing dissertationChuck Eesley
 
Oettl bps-managing dissertation
Oettl bps-managing dissertationOettl bps-managing dissertation
Oettl bps-managing dissertationChuck Eesley
 
Writing the dissertation
Writing the dissertationWriting the dissertation
Writing the dissertationChuck Eesley
 
Armanios august aom
Armanios august aomArmanios august aom
Armanios august aomChuck Eesley
 
Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012
Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012
Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012Chuck Eesley
 
Financial fraud in china2
Financial fraud in china2Financial fraud in china2
Financial fraud in china2Chuck Eesley
 
Aom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in china
Aom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in chinaAom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in china
Aom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in chinaChuck Eesley
 
Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012
Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012
Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012Chuck Eesley
 
Eesley China Performance
Eesley China PerformanceEesley China Performance
Eesley China PerformanceChuck Eesley
 

More from Chuck Eesley (20)

Eesley research overview MS&E
Eesley research overview MS&EEesley research overview MS&E
Eesley research overview MS&E
 
Business idea sources
Business idea sourcesBusiness idea sources
Business idea sources
 
Stanford eesley miller_impact_report
Stanford eesley miller_impact_reportStanford eesley miller_impact_report
Stanford eesley miller_impact_report
 
Competition lecture
Competition lectureCompetition lecture
Competition lecture
 
985 paper presentation -banff 2015
985 paper presentation -banff 2015985 paper presentation -banff 2015
985 paper presentation -banff 2015
 
Aom early venture_evolution_eesley
Aom early venture_evolution_eesleyAom early venture_evolution_eesley
Aom early venture_evolution_eesley
 
UDD chile talk
UDD chile talkUDD chile talk
UDD chile talk
 
Bps managing dissertation
Bps managing dissertationBps managing dissertation
Bps managing dissertation
 
Oettl bps-managing dissertation
Oettl bps-managing dissertationOettl bps-managing dissertation
Oettl bps-managing dissertation
 
Getting a job
Getting a jobGetting a job
Getting a job
 
03 aom bps
03 aom bps03 aom bps
03 aom bps
 
Aom pdw
Aom pdwAom pdw
Aom pdw
 
Writing the dissertation
Writing the dissertationWriting the dissertation
Writing the dissertation
 
Armanios august aom
Armanios august aomArmanios august aom
Armanios august aom
 
Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012
Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012
Nascent entrepreneurship & china 2012
 
Financial fraud in china2
Financial fraud in china2Financial fraud in china2
Financial fraud in china2
 
Aom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in china
Aom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in chinaAom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in china
Aom pdw 2012 nascent entrepreneurship in china
 
Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012
Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012
Nascent entreprenurialship in china and beyond aom pdw 2012
 
Mit eship show
Mit eship showMit eship show
Mit eship show
 
Eesley China Performance
Eesley China PerformanceEesley China Performance
Eesley China Performance
 

Managing your dissertation committee 2011

  • 1. Managing the Dissertation Committee RajshreeAgarwal, Professor and Dean’s Chair in Entrepreneurship and Strategy, University of Maryland
  • 2. Choosing your committee members  Know what you want from your committee members  Expert knowledge in theory, data or methods  Overall “wisdom” in positioning  “External” committee member  Some schools require member outside of department  Some schools regulate the number of outside school members you can have  Co-chairs?  Consult with your dissertation advisor  Collaborative decision  You’ll need your advisor to help out in case conflicts arise  be aware of ex ante conflict situations
  • 3. How to reduce nasty surprises at the end?  Make sure that you connect with your committee members often  The more engaged they are in your dissertation…  The more you benefit from their insights and expertise  The more they know of what you are doing before your defense  The less likely they will be to introduce thorny issues at a very late stage  Help them help you…  Be cognizant of their time pressures  Prepare ahead for meetings  Provide them with materials ahead of time, but don’t always count on them reading these.  Have summary slides, and directed questions, so their response burden is not high  DO NOT provide them with documents incomplete information, un-edited text, incorrect grammar, etc.  Small issues that lead to major impression management problems