SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Brittany Meade
Professor Daniel Powell
ENC3241_CMB-13Spring
3 February 2013
Critical Analysis One: Achieving a Readable Style
Technical reports are an extremely difficult way to communicate to a reader. The author
must be able to demonstrate knowledge of the subjects, display technical information that some
may find hard to understand, and find a way to keep the attention of the audience. Both authors
had their own unique style of writing their reports. Though loaded with good information, I feel
as though one had a more effective way of connecting with the reader. Both demonstrated the
advancing technology in the virtual publishing world, and proved by technical reason the
supporting evidence needed for the reader to comprehend.
After reading both technical reports, I feel as though Jeffery Terrace has a more clear and
concise writing style. His way of displaying the knowledge of the virtual 3-D world, was riveting
and inviting. It is vital to support the technical information with passion and personal
connections. This makes for an easier read, and demonstrates a strong communicator. Daniel
Lynch was also a strong communicator. His way of using visual aids (pictures) was a strong way
to allow readers to "see what he sees."
Daniel Lynch certainly demonstrated a stronger design principle. As stated, visual aid
was used to clearly demonstrate and back up his report. As a reader this was helpful. Chapter 3.2
(pg. 14) is an example of how the picture was able to show the history of the machine used i the
early 1900's for printing. The use of diagrams and mathematical equations helps the reader
understand logic in a clear and concise manner. These aids along with the information on the
foundation and future of publishing, lead to a better designprinciple than Jeffery Terrance.
The better technical writer was in my opinion was Jeffery Terrace. I feel as though his report on
the 3D virtual world and it's future was a more technical topic in itself. There was more support for his
information in technical terms. Terrace explained in overviews of the platforms used to describe the met
averse. This is important in a technical report, as the reader is able to identify a clear plan of action for the
future. He also describes techniques and applications used for the met averse.
All in all, the strongest report was by Terrace. It was easier to understand and comprehend the
information. Lynch was strong with using more visual aid in the report, but ultimately the report is to
present the technical information needed for the reader to grasp concepts, ideas, and future analysis. It is
interesting to read a technical report to find the difficulties the writers may experience when conveying
their research. Communicating to the reader a set plan and understanding of the material is the ideal way
to convey the technicalities of the topic and information.

More Related Content

Similar to Critical Analysis

How Data Visualization Enhances the News
How Data Visualization Enhances the NewsHow Data Visualization Enhances the News
How Data Visualization Enhances the NewsInside Analysis
 
Dhir....technical communicatio
Dhir....technical communicatioDhir....technical communicatio
Dhir....technical communicatioHEMANT KUMAR
 
Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?
Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?
Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?Gail Leija
 
Novel Input Devices
Novel Input DevicesNovel Input Devices
Novel Input DevicesKaren Kiely
 
Technical Communications 101 (First draft)
Technical Communications 101 (First draft)Technical Communications 101 (First draft)
Technical Communications 101 (First draft)Dennis Torrecampo
 
Media A2 New Media Technology
Media A2 New Media TechnologyMedia A2 New Media Technology
Media A2 New Media TechnologyKate McCabe
 
Physical Terrain Modeling in a Digital Age
Physical Terrain Modeling in a Digital AgePhysical Terrain Modeling in a Digital Age
Physical Terrain Modeling in a Digital AgeWatson Mary
 
Infographic Guide of Guides
Infographic Guide of GuidesInfographic Guide of Guides
Infographic Guide of GuidesKBHN KT
 
Harvesting collective intelligence.
Harvesting collective intelligence. Harvesting collective intelligence.
Harvesting collective intelligence. Alberto Cottica
 
Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02
Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02
Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02J'ette Novakovich
 
Network Mapping & Data Storytelling for Beginners
Network Mapping & Data Storytelling for BeginnersNetwork Mapping & Data Storytelling for Beginners
Network Mapping & Data Storytelling for BeginnersRenaud Clément
 
Storytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data Journalist
Storytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data JournalistStorytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data Journalist
Storytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data JournalistHille van der Kaa MA MBA
 
My First Day In America Essay
My First Day In America EssayMy First Day In America Essay
My First Day In America EssayLiana Anderson
 
English Essay Internet
English Essay InternetEnglish Essay Internet
English Essay InternetShelly Lane
 
ESSIR 2013 - IR and Social Media
ESSIR 2013 - IR and Social MediaESSIR 2013 - IR and Social Media
ESSIR 2013 - IR and Social MediaArjen de Vries
 
Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2
Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2
Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2KBHN KT
 

Similar to Critical Analysis (20)

Critical analysis
Critical analysisCritical analysis
Critical analysis
 
How Data Visualization Enhances the News
How Data Visualization Enhances the NewsHow Data Visualization Enhances the News
How Data Visualization Enhances the News
 
Dhir....technical communicatio
Dhir....technical communicatioDhir....technical communicatio
Dhir....technical communicatio
 
Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?
Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?
Will the Real Information Architect Please Stand Up?
 
Novel Input Devices
Novel Input DevicesNovel Input Devices
Novel Input Devices
 
Technical Communications 101 (First draft)
Technical Communications 101 (First draft)Technical Communications 101 (First draft)
Technical Communications 101 (First draft)
 
Media A2 New Media Technology
Media A2 New Media TechnologyMedia A2 New Media Technology
Media A2 New Media Technology
 
HOW TO BECOME A TECHNICAL WRITER:A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
HOW TO BECOME A TECHNICAL WRITER:A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDEHOW TO BECOME A TECHNICAL WRITER:A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
HOW TO BECOME A TECHNICAL WRITER:A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
 
Physical Terrain Modeling in a Digital Age
Physical Terrain Modeling in a Digital AgePhysical Terrain Modeling in a Digital Age
Physical Terrain Modeling in a Digital Age
 
COM 450 Final
COM 450 FinalCOM 450 Final
COM 450 Final
 
Infographic Guide of Guides
Infographic Guide of GuidesInfographic Guide of Guides
Infographic Guide of Guides
 
Harvesting collective intelligence.
Harvesting collective intelligence. Harvesting collective intelligence.
Harvesting collective intelligence.
 
Making data more human
Making data more humanMaking data more human
Making data more human
 
Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02
Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02
Backgrounderandpositionpapers 101006123025-phpapp02
 
Network Mapping & Data Storytelling for Beginners
Network Mapping & Data Storytelling for BeginnersNetwork Mapping & Data Storytelling for Beginners
Network Mapping & Data Storytelling for Beginners
 
Storytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data Journalist
Storytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data JournalistStorytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data Journalist
Storytelling in a digital age - challenges of a Data Journalist
 
My First Day In America Essay
My First Day In America EssayMy First Day In America Essay
My First Day In America Essay
 
English Essay Internet
English Essay InternetEnglish Essay Internet
English Essay Internet
 
ESSIR 2013 - IR and Social Media
ESSIR 2013 - IR and Social MediaESSIR 2013 - IR and Social Media
ESSIR 2013 - IR and Social Media
 
Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2
Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2
Infographic Guide of Guides ACCESSIBLE2
 

Critical Analysis

  • 1. Brittany Meade Professor Daniel Powell ENC3241_CMB-13Spring 3 February 2013 Critical Analysis One: Achieving a Readable Style Technical reports are an extremely difficult way to communicate to a reader. The author must be able to demonstrate knowledge of the subjects, display technical information that some may find hard to understand, and find a way to keep the attention of the audience. Both authors had their own unique style of writing their reports. Though loaded with good information, I feel as though one had a more effective way of connecting with the reader. Both demonstrated the advancing technology in the virtual publishing world, and proved by technical reason the supporting evidence needed for the reader to comprehend. After reading both technical reports, I feel as though Jeffery Terrace has a more clear and concise writing style. His way of displaying the knowledge of the virtual 3-D world, was riveting and inviting. It is vital to support the technical information with passion and personal connections. This makes for an easier read, and demonstrates a strong communicator. Daniel Lynch was also a strong communicator. His way of using visual aids (pictures) was a strong way to allow readers to "see what he sees." Daniel Lynch certainly demonstrated a stronger design principle. As stated, visual aid was used to clearly demonstrate and back up his report. As a reader this was helpful. Chapter 3.2 (pg. 14) is an example of how the picture was able to show the history of the machine used i the
  • 2. early 1900's for printing. The use of diagrams and mathematical equations helps the reader understand logic in a clear and concise manner. These aids along with the information on the foundation and future of publishing, lead to a better designprinciple than Jeffery Terrance. The better technical writer was in my opinion was Jeffery Terrace. I feel as though his report on the 3D virtual world and it's future was a more technical topic in itself. There was more support for his information in technical terms. Terrace explained in overviews of the platforms used to describe the met averse. This is important in a technical report, as the reader is able to identify a clear plan of action for the future. He also describes techniques and applications used for the met averse. All in all, the strongest report was by Terrace. It was easier to understand and comprehend the information. Lynch was strong with using more visual aid in the report, but ultimately the report is to present the technical information needed for the reader to grasp concepts, ideas, and future analysis. It is interesting to read a technical report to find the difficulties the writers may experience when conveying their research. Communicating to the reader a set plan and understanding of the material is the ideal way to convey the technicalities of the topic and information.