SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 5
Download to read offline
THEMATIC ISSUE



  Is There Evidence for Mandating Electrocardiogram as Part
             of the Pre-Participation Examination?
                               Mats Borjesson, MD, PhD and Mikael Dellborg, MD, PhD


                                                                          Key Words: ECG screening, cardiac screening, pre-participation
Abstract: The risk of sudden cardiac death may be increased up to         examination, sudden cardiac death
2.8 times in competitive athletes compared with nonathletes. The
majority of sudden cardiac death cases are caused by an underlying        (Clin J Sport Med 2011;21:13ā€“17)
abnormality that potentially may be identiļ¬ed on cardiovascular
screening, depending on the speciļ¬c abnormality and the content of
the cardiovascular screening applied. Indeed, today, cardiac screening
is universally recommended by the cardiac societies [European                                   BACKGROUND
Society of Cardiology (ESC) and American Heart Association (AHA)]
                                                                                 Regular physical activity (PA) is important for primary
and required by the sporting bodies [Federation Internationale de
                                           Ā“ Ā“                            and secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease.1,2 Sports
Football Association (FIFA) and Union of European Football As-
                                                                          activities may have speciļ¬c effects, as more intensive PA has
sociations (UEFA)]. Pre-participation examination is by consensus
                                                                          added value, and physical ļ¬tness is a predictor of mortality.3
understood to include personal history and physical examination;
                                                                          However, the risk to beneļ¬t ratio of very intensive PA may
controversy exists regarding the usefulness and appropriateness of
                                                                          even be negative in the case of an underlying cardiovascular
screening using resting 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG), with an
                                                                          abnormality.4
apparent transatlantic difference. The ESC recommends screening
                                                                                 Sudden cardiac death (SCD) increases transiently with
consisting of personal history, physical examination, and 12-lead
                                                                          the intensity of PA,4 most often caused by coronary artery
resting ECG, whereas recommendations from the AHA includes only
                                                                          disease in individuals older than 35 years. In younger athletes,
personal history and physical examination. There is ļ¬rm scientiļ¬c
                                                                          underlying cardiac abnormalities, such as hypertrophic
ground to state that the sensitivity of screening with ECG is vastly
                                                                          cardiomyopathy (HCM), coronary artery anomaly, arrhythmo-
superior to, and the cost-effectiveness signiļ¬cantly better than,
                                                                          genic right ventricular cardiomyopathy, different ion channe-
screening without ECG. Cardiac screening of elite athletes with
                                                                          lopathies (long QT-syndrome and Brugada syndrome),
personal history, physical examination, and ECG is cost-effective also
                                                                          congenital valve disease, and complications related to Marfan
in comparison with other well-accepted procedures of modern health
                                                                          syndrome, remain the leading causes of death.5
care, such as dialysis and implantable cardiac deļ¬brillators. Newly
                                                                                 The incidence of SCD is low in this population, and
published recommendations for the interpretation of the ECG in
                                                                          a recent review estimated it to be around 1 to 3 in 100 000 per
athletes (ESC) and future studies on ECGs in athletes of different
                                                                          year6; but the risk for SCD may be signiļ¬cantly increased in
ethnicity, gender, and age may further increase the speciļ¬city of ECG
                                                                          competitive athletes compared with nonathletes.7 The noted 2.8
in cardiac screening, reļ¬ning the screening procedure and lowering
                                                                          greater incidence was only apparent in athletes with underlying
the costs for additional follow-up testing. Cardiac screening without
                                                                          cardiovascular disease,7 forming a rationale for regular cardiac
ECG is not cost-effective and may be only marginally better than no
                                                                          screening of competitive athletes, to try to identify individuals
screening at all and at a considerable higher cost. The difļ¬culties in
                                                                          with such an underlying predisposition for SCD.
feasibility and liability issues for recommending ECGs in some
                                                                                 The majority of SCD cases are indeed caused by an
countries need to be acknowledged but must be dealt with within
                                                                          underlying abnormality that potentially could have been
those countries/systems. On ethical grounds, the reasons (logistical,
                                                                          identiļ¬ed on cardiovascular screening, depending on the
legal, economic) for not screening individual athletes should be
                                                                          speciļ¬c abnormality and the content of the cardiovascular
clearly stated. Alas, the current evidence, as presented here, suggests
                                                                          screening applied. As a consequence, cardiac screening is
that the ECG should be mandatory in pre-participation screening
                                                                          universally recommended by the cardiac societies [European
of athletes.
                                                                          Society of Cardiology (ESC) and American Heart Association
                                                                          (AHA)]8,9 and required by the major sporting bodies
                                                                          [Federation Internationale de Football Association (FIFA)
                                                                             Ā“ Ā“
Submitted for publication March 4, 2010; accepted November 1, 2010.       and Union of European Football Associations (UEFA)] today.
From the Department of Acute and Emergency Medicine, Sahlgrenska          Pre-participation examination is by consensus understood to
   University Hospital, Ostra, Sahgrenska Academy, Goteborg, Sweden.      include personal history and physical examination; contro-
The authors report no conļ¬‚icts of interest to disclose.                   versy exists regarding the usefulness and appropriateness of
Corresponding Author: Mats Borjesson, MD, PhD, Department of Acute and
   Emergency Medicine, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Ostra, 416 85
                                                                          screening using resting 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG), also
   Goteborg, Sweden (e-mail: mats.borjesson@vgregion.se).                 with an apparent transatlantic difference. The ESC recom-
Copyright Ɠ 2011 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins                         mends screening consisting of personal history, physical

Clin J Sport Med  Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011                                                         www.cjsportmed.com |      13
Borjesson and Dellborg                                                      Clin J Sport Med  Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011


examination and 12-lead resting ECG,8 whereas the US                              SENSITIVITY OF SCREENING
recommendations from the AHA includes only personal                               WITH ELECTROCARDIOGRAM
history and physical examination.9                                            Several studies have looked at the sensitivity of a resting
       Screening to identify individuals with increased risk for      ECG to identify the most common cause of SCD (HCM).15 In
sudden death in relation to PA has many implications for              1 study, more than 95% of cases of SCD caused by HCM,
society, for the individual, and for professional bodies and          where previous ECGs were available, showed abnormal
individual clubs. A potentially preventable case of sudden            resting ECGs.16 In other studies, 70% to 80% of SCD caused
death in a young professional athlete may have tremendous             by arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy, where
impact on personal, professional, economic, and legal levels.         resting ECGs were available, showed abnormal ļ¬ndings.17,18
Barring a high-risk professional athlete from personal and                    In fact, the ECG may be almost as good as, or equal to,
economic success, whose risk nevertheless is less than, say,          echocardiography regarding sensitivity for detecting underly-
smoking 20 cigarettes per day or riding a motorcycle without          ing HCM, as shown by comparing the Italian data, using the
a helmet, also has obvious profound implications for that             ECG,19 with similar ļ¬gures of discovery in the United States,
individual and for his family, club, and society. Any screening       using echocardiography.20 Furthermore, Pelliccia et al21
must, in addition to fulļ¬lling the World Health Organizationā€™s        showed that a normal ECG has a very high negative predictive
classic screening criteria,10 also yield a reasonable balance         value (99.98%) for excluding HCM, in an 8-year follow-up.
between sensitivity and speciļ¬city because this will ultimately               In addition, resting ECG will identify the majority of
determine the utility of the screening.                               cases with pre-excitation, long/short QT-interval, and Brugada
       The aim of this article is to discuss the existing evidence    syndrome, if certainly not all.22 A large variety of arrhythmias
for mandating resting ECG as a part of the recommended                could also be identiļ¬ed, possibly as a marker of an underlying
cardiac screening of athletes. Most of the ECG changes seen           structural disease.
in athletes will be due to the cardiac physical adaptation to                 A Swedish study by Wisten et al23 indicated that of
training (ie, athleteā€™s heart), but abnormalities on the ECG may      66 cases of SCD in young individuals (,35 years, athletes
also be an expression of an underlying cardiovascular disease,        or nonathletes), 18% had a positive family history, 76% had
with an increased risk for SCD during sports. We will discuss         previous symptoms, and 82% showed earlier ECG abnormal-
the sensitivity, speciļ¬city, cost-effectiveness, and feasibility of   ities. In the study of Baggish et al,14 .500 collegiate athletes
the 12-lead ECG as a part of the pre-participation examination        underwent pre-participation screening with personal history
of athletes.                                                          and physical examination, identifying 5 of 11 cases of
                                                                      structural disease. The addition of an ECG made it possible to
                                                                      identify an additional 5 cases for a total of 10 of the overall
           SENSITIVITY OF SCREENING                                   total of 11 (sensitivity 91%).
         WITHOUT ELECTROCARDIOGRAM                                            All in all, adding the 12-lead resting ECG to the personal
      For any screening to be meaningful, the chosen method of        history and physical examination will substantially increase
screening must be able to detect what we want to ļ¬nd.10 Thus,         the sensitivity for detecting the underlying cardiac abnormal-
cardiac screening should be able to identify relevant underlying      ities, with a very high negative predictive value.
cardiovascular abnormalities, that is, having a high sensitivity.
      The current US screening recommendations include
personal history and physical examination only (see AHA).
The limited data available indicate that the sensitivity of                       SPECIFICITY OF SCREENING
personal history and physical examination without an ECG                          WITH ELECTROCARDIOGRAM
for identiļ¬cation of cases of SCD is very low. In a study of                 The physiologic adaptation to regular intensive PA
115 cases of SCD by Maron et al,11 only 1 case was identiļ¬ed          includes structural and electrical remodeling, also resulting
using the US screening method without mandatory ECG.                  in electrocardiographic changes, which is all a part of the
Similar low ļ¬gures for sensitivity of screening without the           ā€˜ā€˜athleteā€™s heart.ā€™ā€™ Most ECG abnormalities found in athletes
ECG has been found in Italian studies12 and in a recent British       will therefore not be due to an underlying cardiac abnormality.
study.13                                                              The presence of undeļ¬ned ECG abnormalities may have a low
      Recently, the study by Baggish et al14 of 510 collegiate        speciļ¬city for cardiac disease in the athletic population. For
athletes showed that a screening strategy including personal          example, coronary artery disease and coronary artery anomaly
history and physical examination would identify 5 of 11               may be difļ¬cult to identify by ECG alone, although they may
individuals with underlying cardiovascular abnormality, as            well be suspected by the combination of symptoms and family
determined by echocardiography, yielding a sensitivity of             history.
46%.14 However, it should be kept in mind that echocardi-                    Up to 40% of athletes, depending on type of sport,
ography will not identify all possible causes of SCD in               duration of regular activity, ethnicity, age, and gender, may
athletes, such as nonstructural diseases like arrhythmias.            show some kind of abnormalities on standard 12-lead ECG.24
      The sensitivity of cardiac screening with personal              Clearly, the cutoff values chosen to deļ¬ne abnormalities on the
history and physical examination but without the ECG is               athlete ECG will greatly inļ¬‚uence the speciļ¬city achieved.
low or very low, and the lack of sensitivity remains a major          Previously given cutoff values for ECG interpretation25
concern for recommending a screening strategy without                 yielded a high number of ā€˜ā€˜false-positivesā€™ā€™ in cardiac
including the ECG.                                                    screening. Larger studies examining different athletes of

14   | www.cjsportmed.com                                                                         q 2011 Lippincott Williams  Wilkins
Clin J Sport Med  Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011                                             ECG in Pre-Participation Examination


different age and gender and in a variety of sports showed that              Several costā€“effect analyses of screening with ECG have
60% of the ECGs deļ¬ned as abnormal were in fact showing              been performed; in Japan,30 in Italy (unpublished data), and in
isolated QRS amplitude signs of left ventricular hypertrophy         the United States.31,32 The Fuller32 study estimated that adding
and/or repolarization abnormalities only.24,26                       the ECG to personal history and physical examination was
       Newer studies have shown that some ECG changes seen           more cost-effective (USD 44 000 per life-year saved as
in athletes, such as repolarization changes, are not associated      compared with USD 84 000 per life-year saved without the
with an increased risk in the long term but instead may be the       ECG screening). The Japanese study by Tanaka et al30
expression of autonomic adaptations secondary to long-term           concluded that ECG screening was cost-effective. Still, a more
training.26,27                                                       strict and formal costā€“effect analysis fully accounting for costs
       Electrocardiographic changes are dependent also on            and beneļ¬ts of screening has been needed.33 Recently, such an
ethnicity.28,29 For example, echocardiographic studies showed        analysis was published from Stanford University.34 The
that 20% of black athletes compared with 4% of white athletes        authors used a decision model to project the costs and
will have an increased left ventricular wall thickness .12 mm,       survival rates for 14-year-old to 22-year-old US athletes
which is also associated with a higher degree of ECG                 undergoing a cardiac screening session, either by personal
changes.28                                                           history and physical examination alone or with an added 12-
       The ESC section of Sports Cardiology recently pro-            lead resting ECG. The data were compared with no screening
posed26 to classify ECG changes in athletes into 2 groups:           at all, using Italian data of survival and adjusting the ļ¬gures to
1. Common and training-related ECG changes, such as sinus            US standards. The analysis estimated that adding the ECG to
   bradycardia, ļ¬rst-degree atrioventricular block, incomplete       history and physical examination saves 2.06 life-years per
   right bundle branch block (RBBB), early repolarization, and       1000 athletes screened, costing USD 42 000 per life-year
   isolated QRS voltage criteria for left ventricular hypertrophy.   saved, compared with screening without ECG.34 The addition
2. Uncommon and training-unrelated ECG changes, such as              of the ECG was considered cost-effective. In fact, screening
   widespread T-wave inversion, complete RBBB/left bundle            with added ECG is cost-effective also compared with other
   branch block, and Brugada-like early repolarization.26            well-known and widely accepted procedures in health care,
       Indeed, the common and training-related ECG changes           such as giving dialysis to patients with chronic kidney disease
are much more common, constituting more than 80% of                  (USD 20-80 000 per quality-adjusted life-year saved) or
ECG changes found in athletes. The training-unrelated ECG            application of an implanted cardioverter deļ¬brillator for the
changes typically constitute only 5% to 10% of ECG changes           prevention of sudden death (USD 34-70 000 per quality-
seen in athletes.26,27 However, this ļ¬gure can be expected to        adjusted life-year saved). In a ļ¬nal comment, the authors
vary in respect of ethnicity and gender, and more studies are        concluded that cardiovascular screening with history and
therefore needed in different ethnic groups and genders.             physical examination without the ECG was substantially more
       When Corrado et al26 applied this new classiļ¬cation to        costly and marginally more effective than no screening at all.34
the previously reported data from Pelliccia et al24 on 1005                  The continuous development of new even stricter ECG
highly trained athletes without structural or other heart disease,   criteria for abnormality has the potential to further decrease the
292 of the 402 athletes previously described as having               number of athletes falsely classiļ¬ed as abnormal, potentially
ECG abnormalities showed either an isolated increase of              improving the cost-effectiveness even more.
QRS voltage (n = 233) or early repolarization patterns
(n = 59). Only 11% (n = 110) were classiļ¬ed as ā€˜ā€˜uncommon
and training-unrelatedā€™ā€™ according to the new criteria,26                          FEASIBILITY AND LIABILITY
thus showing the potential efļ¬cacy of the new classiļ¬cation                 What is the rationale for leaving out the ECG? Given the
to increase the speciļ¬city of the ECG as a part of cardiac           superior sensitivity of cardiac screening with ECG, the limited but
screening.                                                           steadily improving speciļ¬city, and that the cost-effectiveness of
       In summary, although the speciļ¬city of any abnormal           including the ECG also seems superior to screening without
ECG is limited, new criteria suggest that, if appropriate            ECG, why is the ECG not universally recommended to be a part
consideration is given to gender, level of training, and             of the regular pre-participation screening of athletes?
ethnicity, the speciļ¬city of screening with the ECG are greatly             As the scientiļ¬c reasons for including the ECG in pre-
improved.                                                            participation screening look clear and undisputable, we
                                                                     probably have to look elsewhere for the reasons for excluding
                                                                     the ECG.9 Different health care systems in general and
                 COSTā€“EFFECTIVENESS                                  different legal systems regarding liability in particular may
      Up to now, one of the most common reasons for not              play a major role in the different approaches of different
advocating ECG as part of the routine pre-participation cardiac      countries. In Italy, cardiac screening including ECG has been
screening of athletes has been the purportedly high cost of          mandated by law since 1971,35 and it has also been mandatory
follow-up examinations due to the low speciļ¬city of the ECG          in other countries, such as Hungary. In the United States,
in screening. The actual cost of the ECG itself has not been         however, the complex legal system with high liability charges
considered to be the main problem,9 nor the cost of physical         against a physician allegedly missing a diagnosis (eg, in the
examination and personal history taking by a physician,              case of SCD in an athlete) could be disastrous for the
because this has been advocated by the AHA/American                  individual physician. The presence of any kind of pathology
College of Sports Medicine for competitive athletes.9                on the pre-participation ECGs will have tremendous impact

q 2011 Lippincott Williams  Wilkins                                                                     www.cjsportmed.com |       15
Borjesson and Dellborg                                                                  Clin J Sport Med  Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011


in any liability case. In Europe, such liability is rarely an                        coronary events in men ,65 and .65 years. Am J Cardiol. 2002;89:
important issue in relation to cardiovascular screening.                             1187ā€“1192.
                                                                                4.   Albert CM, Mittleman MA, Chae CU, et al. Triggering of sudden death
       The opposite angle is perhaps equally important: the                          from cardiac causes by vigorous exertion. N Engl J Med. 2000;343:
consequences for the athleteā€™s career if a benign ECG                                1355ā€“1361.
abnormality is wrongly interpreted as indicating a serious                      5.   Courson R. Preventing sudden death on the athletic ļ¬eld: the emergency
underlying disease may also be vast. To the club and its                             action plan. Curr Sports Med Rep. 2007;6:93ā€“100.
members, or owners, the disqualiļ¬cation of a highly compe-                      6.   Borjesson M, Pelliccia A. Incidence and aetiology of sudden cardiac death
                                                                                     in young athletes: an international perspective. Br J Sports Med. 2009;43:
tent, and very costly(!), athlete may have profound economic
                                                                                     644ā€“648.
impact in a judicial system focused on liability.                               7.   Corrado D, Basso C, Rizzoli G, et al. Does sports activity enhance the risk
       However, from a societal perspective, it is important to                      of sudden death in adolescents and young adults? J Am Coll Cardiol.
adequately identify individuals at increased risk for sudden                         2003;42:1959ā€“1963.
death, not only to prevent unnecessary deaths in young                          8.   Corrado D, Pelliccia A, Bjornstad HH, et al. Cardiovascular pre-
individuals but also to prevent the public impression that PA                        participation screening of young competitive athletes for prevention of
                                                                                     sudden death: proposal for a common European protocol. Consensus
is dangerous and should best be avoided. This being said, an                         statement of the Study Group of Sports Cardiology of the Working Group
intensive and vigorous screening procedure with a large number                       of Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology and the Working
of false-positive cases may also confer the notion that PA is, in                    Group of Myocardial and Pericardial Diseases of the European Society of
general, dangerous. The impact on public health of decreased                         Cardiology. Eur Heart J. 2005;26:516ā€“524.
PA among the population is difļ¬cult to calculate but potentially                9.   Maron BJ, Thompson PD, Ackerman MJ, et al. Recommendations and
                                                                                     considerations related to preparticipation screening for cardiovascular
highly negative and very costly.                                                     abnormalities in competitive athletes: 2007 update. A scientiļ¬c statement
       These differences in health care/legal systems have to be                     from the American Heart Association Council on Nutrition, Physical
acknowledged and respected. They may also partly explain                             Activity, and Metabolism: endorsed by the American College of
the somewhat differing approaches to screening in different                          Cardiology Foundation. Circulation. 2007;115:1643ā€“1655.
countries and by different sporting bodies (FIFA and UEFA                      10.   Wilson JMG, Jungner G. Principles and Practice of Screening for
mandate cardiac screening by ECG, whereas the International                          Diseases. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organisation; 1968.
                                                                               11.   Maron BJ, Shirani J, Poliac LC, et al. Sudden death in young competitive
Olympic Committee is somewhat more cautious in their latest                          athletes. Clinical, demographic and pathological proļ¬les. JAMA. 1996;
recommendations36).                                                                  276:199ā€“204.
                                                                               12.   Pelliccia A, Maron BJ. Preparticipation cardiovascular evaluation of the
                                                                                     competitive athlete: perspectives from the 30-year Italian experience.
                             SUMMARY                                                 Am J Cardiol. 1995;75:827ā€“829.
      Cardiac pre-participation screening of elite athletes is                 13.   Wilson MG, Basavarajaiah S, Whyte GP, et al. Efļ¬cacy of personal
universally recommended for several reasons, including                               symptom and family history questionnaires when screening for inherited
                                                                                     cardiac pathologies: the role of electrocardiography. Br J Sports Med.
ethical (AHA/American College of Sports Medicine) and                                2008;42:207ā€“211.
employer/employee relations, ultimately to prevent SCD                         14.   Baggish AL, Hutter AM, Wang F, et al. Cardiovascular screening in
during sports.                                                                       college athletes with and without electrocardiography. Ann Intern Med.
      The sensitivity of screening with ECG, in addition to                          2010;152:269ā€“275.
personal history and physical examination, is superior, and the                15.   Maron BJ. Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy: a systematic review. JAMA.
                                                                                     2002;287:1308ā€“1320.
cost-effectiveness is clearly better than screening without                    16.   Maron BJ, Roberts WC, Epstein SE. Sudden death in hypertrophic
ECG.34 Screening including the ECG is cost-effective also in                         cardiomyopathy: a proļ¬le of 78 patients. Circulation. 1982;65:1388ā€“
comparison with other well-accepted procedures of modern                             1394.
health care.                                                                   17.   Steriotis AK, Bauce B, Daliento L, et al. Electrocardiographic pattern in
      Thus, cardiac pre-participation screening without ECG                          arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy. Am J Cardiol. 2009;
cannot be recommended given our current knowledge. The                               103:1302ā€“1308.
                                                                               18.   Bauce B, Frigo G, Marcus FI, et al. Comparison of clinical features of
difļ¬culties in feasibility and liability issues for recommending                     arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy in men versus women.
ECGs in some countries need to be acknowledged but must be                           Am J Cardiol. 2008;102:1252ā€“1257.
dealt with within those countries/systems. On ethical grounds,                 19.   Corrado D, Basso C, Schiavon M, et al. Screening for hypertrophic
the reasons (logistical, legal, economic) for not screening                          cardiomyopathy in young athletes. N Engl J Med. 1998;339:
individual athletes should be clearly stated.                                        364ā€“369.
                                                                               20.   Maron BJ, Gardin JM, Flack JM, et al. Prevalence of hypertrophic
      Alas, the current evidence, as presented here, suggests                        cardiomyopathy in a general population of young adults. Echocardio-
that the ECG should be mandatory in pre-participation                                graphic analysis of 4111 subjects in the CARDIA Study. Circulation.
screening of athletes.                                                               1995;92:785ā€“789.
                                                                               21.   Pelliccia A, DiPaolo FM, Corrado D, et al. Evidence for efļ¬cacy of the
                            REFERENCES                                               Italian national pre-participation screening programme for identiļ¬cation
 1. DeBacker G, Ambrosini E, Borch-Johnsen K, et al. Third Joint Task Force          of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy in competitive athletes. Eur Heart J.
    of European and other societies on cardiovascular disease prevention in          2006;27:2196ā€“2200.
    clinical practice: European Guidelines on cardiovascular disease pre-      22.   Marcus FI. Electrocardiographic features of inherited diseases that
    vention in clinical practice. Eur Heart J. 2003;24:1601ā€“1610.                    predispose to the development of cardiac arrhythmias, long QT syndrome,
 2. Talbot LA, Morrell CH, Fleg JL, et al. Changes in leisure-time physical          arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy/dysplasia and Brugada
    activity and risk of all-cause mortality in men and women: the Baltimore         syndrome. J Electrocardiol. 2000;33(suppl):1ā€“10.
    longitudinal study of aging. Prev Med. 2007;45:169ā€“176.                    23.   Wisten A, Andersson S, Forsberg H, et al. Sudden cardiac death in the
 3. Talbot LA, Morrell C, Metter EJ, et al. Comparison of cardiorespi-               young in Sweden: electrocardiogram in relation to forensic diagnosis.
    ratory ļ¬tness versus leisure-time physical activity as predictors of             J Intern Med. 2004;255:213ā€“220.

16   | www.cjsportmed.com                                                                                         q 2011 Lippincott Williams  Wilkins
Clin J Sport Med  Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011                                                              ECG in Pre-Participation Examination


24. Pelliccia A, Maron BJ, Culasso F, et al. Clinical signiļ¬cance of abnormal    29. Magalski A, Maron BJ, Main ML, et al. Relation of race to
    electrocardiographic patterns in trained athletes. Circulation. 2000;102:        electrocardiographic patterns in elite American football players. J Am
    278ā€“284.                                                                         Coll Cardiol. 2008;51:2250ā€“2255.
25. Pelliccia A, Fagard R, Bjornstad H, et al. Recommendations for               30. Tanaka Y, Yoshinaga M, Anan R, et al. Usefulness and cost effectiveness
    competitive sports participation in athletes with cardiovascular disease:        of cardiovascular screening of young adolescents. Med Sci Sports Exerc.
    a consensus document from the Study Group of Sports Cardiology of the            2006;38:2ā€“6.
    Working Group of Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology and          31. Risser WL, Hoffman HM, Bellah Jr GG, et al. A cost-beneļ¬t analysis of
    the Working Group of Myocardial and Pericardial Diseases of the                  preparticipation sports examinations of adolescent athletes. J Sch Health.
    European Society of Cardiology. Eur Heart J. 2005;26:1422ā€“1445.                  1985;55:270ā€“273.
26. Corrado D, Pelliccia A, Heidbuchel H, et al. Recommendations for             32. Fuller CM. Cost effectiveness analysis of screening of high school athletes
    interpretation of 12-lead electrocardiogram in the athlete. Section of           for risk of sudden cardiac death. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;32:887ā€“890.
    Sports Cardiology, European Association of Cardiovascular Prevention         33. MacAuley D. Olympic dreams. Br Med J. 2008;337:a739.
    and Rehabilitation. Eur Heart J. 2010;31:243ā€“1259.                           34. Wheeler MT, Heidenreich PA, Froelicher VF, et al. Cost-effectiveness of
27. Corrado D, Bifļ¬ A, Basso C, et al. 12-Lead ECG in the athlete:                   preparticipation screening for prevention of sudden cardiac death in young
    physiological versus pathological abnormalities. Br J Sports Med. 2009;          athletes. Ann Intern Med. 2010;152:276ā€“286.
    43:669ā€“676.                                                                  35. Italian Ministry of Health. Rules concerning the medical protection of
28. Basavarajaiah S, Boraita A, Whyte G, et al. Ethnic differences in left           athletic activity. Gazzetta Ufļ¬ciale. 1982;5:63.
    ventricular remodeling in highly-trained athletes relevance to differenti-   36. Ljungqvist A, Jenoure P, Engebretsen L, et al. The International Olympic
    ating physiologic left ventricular hypertrophy from hypertrophic                 Committee (IOC) consensus statement on periodic health evaluation of
    cardiomyopathy. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2008;51:2256ā€“2262.                            elite athletes March 2009. Br J Sports Med. 2009;43:631ā€“643.




q 2011 Lippincott Williams  Wilkins                                                                                        www.cjsportmed.com |            17

More Related Content

What's hot

Ppci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbai
Ppci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbaiPpci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbai
Ppci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbaicardiositeindia
Ā 
ć›ć‚“å¦„ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ 
ć›ć‚“å¦„ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ ć›ć‚“妄ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ 
ć›ć‚“å¦„ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ Masaaki Sakuraya
Ā 
Broken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain Injury
Broken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain InjuryBroken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain Injury
Broken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain InjuryAmit Agrawal
Ā 
Cardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copy
Cardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copyCardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copy
Cardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copyhospital
Ā 
Remote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert Kloner
Remote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert KlonerRemote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert Kloner
Remote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert KlonerEndothelix
Ā 
Orthogeriatrics
OrthogeriatricsOrthogeriatrics
OrthogeriatricsRohit Vikas
Ā 
Why should we measure endothelial function
Why should we measure endothelial functionWhy should we measure endothelial function
Why should we measure endothelial functionEndothelix
Ā 
Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...
Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...
Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...drucsamal
Ā 
Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology a new ...
Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology   a new ...Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology   a new ...
Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology a new ...M. Luisetto Pharm.D.Spec. Pharmacology
Ā 
Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...
Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...
Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...Endothelix
Ā 
Primary Percutaneus coronary intervention
Primary Percutaneus coronary interventionPrimary Percutaneus coronary intervention
Primary Percutaneus coronary interventionRamachandra Barik
Ā 
Clinical Implications of Ischemic Pre and Postconditioning
Clinical Implications  of Ischemic Pre and PostconditioningClinical Implications  of Ischemic Pre and Postconditioning
Clinical Implications of Ischemic Pre and PostconditioningMohamed Hamoda
Ā 
Cardiovascular ischemia - reperfusion injury
Cardiovascular   ischemia - reperfusion injuryCardiovascular   ischemia - reperfusion injury
Cardiovascular ischemia - reperfusion injuryGuillaume Michigan
Ā 
Myocardial protection 2004
Myocardial protection 2004Myocardial protection 2004
Myocardial protection 2004Sandeep Jose K
Ā 
ICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathy
ICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathyICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathy
ICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathyPRAVEEN GUPTA
Ā 
CABG in ischemic cardiomyopathy
CABG in ischemic cardiomyopathyCABG in ischemic cardiomyopathy
CABG in ischemic cardiomyopathydaych
Ā 

What's hot (18)

Ppci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbai
Ppci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbaiPpci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbai
Ppci culprit vs mv acad card 2013 mumbai
Ā 
Percutaneous coronary intervention by hossein
Percutaneous coronary intervention  by hosseinPercutaneous coronary intervention  by hossein
Percutaneous coronary intervention by hossein
Ā 
ć›ć‚“å¦„ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ 
ć›ć‚“å¦„ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ ć›ć‚“妄ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ 
ć›ć‚“å¦„ćØICU-AWćØē”ēœ 
Ā 
Broken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain Injury
Broken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain InjuryBroken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain Injury
Broken Heart Syndrome: Cardiovascular Manifestations of Traumatic Brain Injury
Ā 
Cardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copy
Cardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copyCardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copy
Cardio respiratory nuclear imaging ihab - copy
Ā 
Remote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert Kloner
Remote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert KlonerRemote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert Kloner
Remote Ischemic Conditioning - Dr. Robert Kloner
Ā 
Orthogeriatrics
OrthogeriatricsOrthogeriatrics
Orthogeriatrics
Ā 
Why should we measure endothelial function
Why should we measure endothelial functionWhy should we measure endothelial function
Why should we measure endothelial function
Ā 
Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...
Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...
Prognosis and treatment of cardiogenic shock complicating acute myocardial in...
Ā 
Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology a new ...
Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology   a new ...Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology   a new ...
Luisetto m, luca c, farhan a, ghulam r. sudden death heart pathology a new ...
Ā 
Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...
Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...
Ischemic Conditioning Therapy - A New Path for Treatment of Endothelial Dysfu...
Ā 
Primary Percutaneus coronary intervention
Primary Percutaneus coronary interventionPrimary Percutaneus coronary intervention
Primary Percutaneus coronary intervention
Ā 
Aki cticu final
Aki cticu finalAki cticu final
Aki cticu final
Ā 
Clinical Implications of Ischemic Pre and Postconditioning
Clinical Implications  of Ischemic Pre and PostconditioningClinical Implications  of Ischemic Pre and Postconditioning
Clinical Implications of Ischemic Pre and Postconditioning
Ā 
Cardiovascular ischemia - reperfusion injury
Cardiovascular   ischemia - reperfusion injuryCardiovascular   ischemia - reperfusion injury
Cardiovascular ischemia - reperfusion injury
Ā 
Myocardial protection 2004
Myocardial protection 2004Myocardial protection 2004
Myocardial protection 2004
Ā 
ICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathy
ICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathyICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathy
ICD in Non-ischemic cardiomyopathy
Ā 
CABG in ischemic cardiomyopathy
CABG in ischemic cardiomyopathyCABG in ischemic cardiomyopathy
CABG in ischemic cardiomyopathy
Ā 

Similar to Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4

Risk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletes
Risk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletesRisk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletes
Risk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletesDr.Mahmoud Abbas
Ā 
Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy Adolfo Aliaga Quezada
Ā 
The role of Echocardiography In coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...
The role of Echocardiography In  coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...The role of Echocardiography In  coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...
The role of Echocardiography In coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...Nizam Uddin
Ā 
ARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdf
ARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdfARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdf
ARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdfJim Dowling
Ā 
Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...
Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...
Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...MIMS Hospital
Ā 
Blunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injuryBlunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injuryXenia Klein
Ā 
Blunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injuryBlunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injuryXenia Klein
Ā 
Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology a new researc...
Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology   a new researc...Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology   a new researc...
Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology a new researc...M. Luisetto Pharm.D.Spec. Pharmacology
Ā 
Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...
Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...
Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...lifextechnologies
Ā 
STE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptx
STE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptxSTE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptx
STE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptxSetiawanWinarso2
Ā 
Update of heart failure guidelines
Update of heart failure guidelinesUpdate of heart failure guidelines
Update of heart failure guidelinesMohamed Ashraf
Ā 
1. 2 8 21 cardiology
1. 2 8 21 cardiology 1. 2 8 21 cardiology
1. 2 8 21 cardiology .krishu80
Ā 
Preoperative Electrocardiograms Patient Factors[1].7
Preoperative Electrocardiograms  Patient Factors[1].7Preoperative Electrocardiograms  Patient Factors[1].7
Preoperative Electrocardiograms Patient Factors[1].7Luis Sanchez Torre
Ā 
Sports cardiology talk slideshare export
Sports cardiology talk slideshare exportSports cardiology talk slideshare export
Sports cardiology talk slideshare exportJohn Vyselaar
Ā 
Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...
Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...
Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...M. Luisetto Pharm.D.Spec. Pharmacology
Ā 
00000542 200710000-00007
00000542 200710000-0000700000542 200710000-00007
00000542 200710000-00007Juan Siri
Ā 

Similar to Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4 (20)

Risk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletes
Risk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletesRisk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletes
Risk stratification to prevent SCD in young athletes
Ā 
Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Cardiac MRI in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Ā 
The role of Echocardiography In coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...
The role of Echocardiography In  coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...The role of Echocardiography In  coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...
The role of Echocardiography In coronary artery disease and Acute Myocardial...
Ā 
Nuclear imaging bck
Nuclear imaging bckNuclear imaging bck
Nuclear imaging bck
Ā 
ARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdf
ARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdfARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdf
ARVC and flecainide case report[EI] Jim.docx.pdf
Ā 
Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...
Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...
Comparison of clinical, radiological and outcome characteristics of ischemic ...
Ā 
Blunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injuryBlunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injury
Ā 
Blunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injuryBlunt cardiac injury
Blunt cardiac injury
Ā 
Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology a new researc...
Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology   a new researc...Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology   a new researc...
Luisetto m, khan fa, mashori gr (2017) sudden heart pathology a new researc...
Ā 
Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...
Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...
Intramyocardial Angiogenic Cell Precursors in Non-Ischemic Dilated Cardiomyop...
Ā 
STE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptx
STE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptxSTE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptx
STE-ACS IN VERY YOUNG MALE.pptx
Ā 
Update of heart failure guidelines
Update of heart failure guidelinesUpdate of heart failure guidelines
Update of heart failure guidelines
Ā 
1. 2 8 21 cardiology
1. 2 8 21 cardiology 1. 2 8 21 cardiology
1. 2 8 21 cardiology
Ā 
23
2323
23
Ā 
Preoperative Electrocardiograms Patient Factors[1].7
Preoperative Electrocardiograms  Patient Factors[1].7Preoperative Electrocardiograms  Patient Factors[1].7
Preoperative Electrocardiograms Patient Factors[1].7
Ā 
EIS poster
EIS posterEIS poster
EIS poster
Ā 
Pathogroup2
Pathogroup2Pathogroup2
Pathogroup2
Ā 
Sports cardiology talk slideshare export
Sports cardiology talk slideshare exportSports cardiology talk slideshare export
Sports cardiology talk slideshare export
Ā 
Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...
Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...
Luisetto m, luca c, f. a. khan, g. r. mashori. sudden heart pathology a new r...
Ā 
00000542 200710000-00007
00000542 200710000-0000700000542 200710000-00007
00000542 200710000-00007
Ā 

More from Andrew Cannon

Pep program 04122011-1
Pep program 04122011-1Pep program 04122011-1
Pep program 04122011-1Andrew Cannon
Ā 
S O R E N E S S R U L E S
S O R E N E S S  R U L E SS O R E N E S S  R U L E S
S O R E N E S S R U L E SAndrew Cannon
Ā 
NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1
NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1
NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1Andrew Cannon
Ā 
Data based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball players
Data based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball playersData based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball players
Data based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball playersAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Role Instability In Resistance Training
Role Instability In Resistance TrainingRole Instability In Resistance Training
Role Instability In Resistance TrainingAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4
Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4
Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4Andrew Cannon
Ā 
Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?
Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?
Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?Andrew Cannon
Ā 
Cannon Return To Run Progression
Cannon  Return To  Run  ProgressionCannon  Return To  Run  Progression
Cannon Return To Run ProgressionAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Hip impingement
Hip impingementHip impingement
Hip impingementAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Dance regional interdependence
Dance regional interdependenceDance regional interdependence
Dance regional interdependenceAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Dance regional interrelationships
Dance regional interrelationshipsDance regional interrelationships
Dance regional interrelationshipsAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Turf presentation
Turf presentationTurf presentation
Turf presentationAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Turf presentation
Turf presentationTurf presentation
Turf presentationAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Dance nutrition
Dance nutritionDance nutrition
Dance nutritionAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Turf Presentation
Turf PresentationTurf Presentation
Turf PresentationAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Dance nutrition
Dance nutritionDance nutrition
Dance nutritionAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Athlete hip score
Athlete hip scoreAthlete hip score
Athlete hip scoreAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Convention versus Evidence
Convention versus EvidenceConvention versus Evidence
Convention versus EvidenceAndrew Cannon
Ā 
Convention versus Evidence
Convention versus EvidenceConvention versus Evidence
Convention versus EvidenceAndrew Cannon
Ā 

More from Andrew Cannon (20)

Pep program 04122011-1
Pep program 04122011-1Pep program 04122011-1
Pep program 04122011-1
Ā 
S O R E N E S S R U L E S
S O R E N E S S  R U L E SS O R E N E S S  R U L E S
S O R E N E S S R U L E S
Ā 
NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1
NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1
NH Sport Concussion Advisory Council Consensus statement version 2.1
Ā 
Data based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball players
Data based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball playersData based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball players
Data based interval throwing programs for collegiate softball players
Ā 
Role Instability In Resistance Training
Role Instability In Resistance TrainingRole Instability In Resistance Training
Role Instability In Resistance Training
Ā 
Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4
Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4
Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4
Ā 
Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?
Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?
Is Pilates Good for Rehabilitation?
Ā 
Cannon Return To Run Progression
Cannon  Return To  Run  ProgressionCannon  Return To  Run  Progression
Cannon Return To Run Progression
Ā 
Hip impingement
Hip impingementHip impingement
Hip impingement
Ā 
Dance pfp
Dance pfpDance pfp
Dance pfp
Ā 
Dance regional interdependence
Dance regional interdependenceDance regional interdependence
Dance regional interdependence
Ā 
Dance regional interrelationships
Dance regional interrelationshipsDance regional interrelationships
Dance regional interrelationships
Ā 
Turf presentation
Turf presentationTurf presentation
Turf presentation
Ā 
Turf presentation
Turf presentationTurf presentation
Turf presentation
Ā 
Dance nutrition
Dance nutritionDance nutrition
Dance nutrition
Ā 
Turf Presentation
Turf PresentationTurf Presentation
Turf Presentation
Ā 
Dance nutrition
Dance nutritionDance nutrition
Dance nutrition
Ā 
Athlete hip score
Athlete hip scoreAthlete hip score
Athlete hip score
Ā 
Convention versus Evidence
Convention versus EvidenceConvention versus Evidence
Convention versus Evidence
Ā 
Convention versus Evidence
Convention versus EvidenceConvention versus Evidence
Convention versus Evidence
Ā 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...CALL GIRLS
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...narwatsonia7
Ā 
Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...
Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...
Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...Miss joya
Ā 
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore EscortsCall Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escortsvidya singh
Ā 
Call Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoybabeytanya
Ā 
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...Miss joya
Ā 
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas AliAspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas AliRewAs ALI
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safenarwatsonia7
Ā 
Call Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoynarwatsonia7
Ā 
VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...
VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...
VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...Miss joya
Ā 
ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...astropune
Ā 
Call Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on Delivery
Call Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on DeliveryCall Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on Delivery
Call Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on Deliverynehamumbai
Ā 
Call Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Coimbatore
Call Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Service CoimbatoreCall Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Service Coimbatore
Call Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Coimbatorenarwatsonia7
Ā 
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls JaipurCall Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipurparulsinha
Ā 
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...Taniya Sharma
Ā 
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort ServicePremium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Servicevidya singh
Ā 
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...narwatsonia7
Ā 
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoybabeytanya
Ā 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ā¤ļøšŸ‘ 8250192130 šŸ‘„ Independent Escort Service ...
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...
Ā 
Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...
Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...
Call Girls Service Pune Vaishnavi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call ...
Ā 
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore EscortsCall Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Ā 
Call Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Vashi MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Ā 
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Low Rate Call Girls Pune Esha 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girl...
Ā 
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas AliAspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Ā 
Escort Service Call Girls In Sarita Vihar,, 99530Ā°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Sarita Vihar,, 99530Ā°56974 Delhi NCREscort Service Call Girls In Sarita Vihar,, 99530Ā°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Sarita Vihar,, 99530Ā°56974 Delhi NCR
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Ā 
Call Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girls Yelahanka Bangalore šŸ“² 9907093804 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Ā 
VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...
VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...
VIP Call Girls Pune Vrinda 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call girls S...
Ā 
ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
ā™›VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls ChintalkuntašŸ–•7001035870šŸ–•Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
Ā 
sauth delhi call girls in Bhajanpura šŸ” 9953056974 šŸ” escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Bhajanpura šŸ” 9953056974 šŸ” escort Servicesauth delhi call girls in Bhajanpura šŸ” 9953056974 šŸ” escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Bhajanpura šŸ” 9953056974 šŸ” escort Service
Ā 
Call Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on Delivery
Call Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on DeliveryCall Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on Delivery
Call Girls Colaba Mumbai ā¤ļø 9920874524 šŸ‘ˆ Cash on Delivery
Ā 
Call Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Coimbatore
Call Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Service CoimbatoreCall Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Service Coimbatore
Call Girl Coimbatore Prishaā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Coimbatore
Ā 
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls JaipurCall Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ā¤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Ā 
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
Ā 
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort ServicePremium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Ā 
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
VIP Call Girls Tirunelveli Aaradhya 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Tir...
Ā 
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Ā 

Is there evidence_for_mandating_electrocardiogram.4

  • 1. THEMATIC ISSUE Is There Evidence for Mandating Electrocardiogram as Part of the Pre-Participation Examination? Mats Borjesson, MD, PhD and Mikael Dellborg, MD, PhD Key Words: ECG screening, cardiac screening, pre-participation Abstract: The risk of sudden cardiac death may be increased up to examination, sudden cardiac death 2.8 times in competitive athletes compared with nonathletes. The majority of sudden cardiac death cases are caused by an underlying (Clin J Sport Med 2011;21:13ā€“17) abnormality that potentially may be identiļ¬ed on cardiovascular screening, depending on the speciļ¬c abnormality and the content of the cardiovascular screening applied. Indeed, today, cardiac screening is universally recommended by the cardiac societies [European BACKGROUND Society of Cardiology (ESC) and American Heart Association (AHA)] Regular physical activity (PA) is important for primary and required by the sporting bodies [Federation Internationale de Ā“ Ā“ and secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease.1,2 Sports Football Association (FIFA) and Union of European Football As- activities may have speciļ¬c effects, as more intensive PA has sociations (UEFA)]. Pre-participation examination is by consensus added value, and physical ļ¬tness is a predictor of mortality.3 understood to include personal history and physical examination; However, the risk to beneļ¬t ratio of very intensive PA may controversy exists regarding the usefulness and appropriateness of even be negative in the case of an underlying cardiovascular screening using resting 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG), with an abnormality.4 apparent transatlantic difference. The ESC recommends screening Sudden cardiac death (SCD) increases transiently with consisting of personal history, physical examination, and 12-lead the intensity of PA,4 most often caused by coronary artery resting ECG, whereas recommendations from the AHA includes only disease in individuals older than 35 years. In younger athletes, personal history and physical examination. There is ļ¬rm scientiļ¬c underlying cardiac abnormalities, such as hypertrophic ground to state that the sensitivity of screening with ECG is vastly cardiomyopathy (HCM), coronary artery anomaly, arrhythmo- superior to, and the cost-effectiveness signiļ¬cantly better than, genic right ventricular cardiomyopathy, different ion channe- screening without ECG. Cardiac screening of elite athletes with lopathies (long QT-syndrome and Brugada syndrome), personal history, physical examination, and ECG is cost-effective also congenital valve disease, and complications related to Marfan in comparison with other well-accepted procedures of modern health syndrome, remain the leading causes of death.5 care, such as dialysis and implantable cardiac deļ¬brillators. Newly The incidence of SCD is low in this population, and published recommendations for the interpretation of the ECG in a recent review estimated it to be around 1 to 3 in 100 000 per athletes (ESC) and future studies on ECGs in athletes of different year6; but the risk for SCD may be signiļ¬cantly increased in ethnicity, gender, and age may further increase the speciļ¬city of ECG competitive athletes compared with nonathletes.7 The noted 2.8 in cardiac screening, reļ¬ning the screening procedure and lowering greater incidence was only apparent in athletes with underlying the costs for additional follow-up testing. Cardiac screening without cardiovascular disease,7 forming a rationale for regular cardiac ECG is not cost-effective and may be only marginally better than no screening of competitive athletes, to try to identify individuals screening at all and at a considerable higher cost. The difļ¬culties in with such an underlying predisposition for SCD. feasibility and liability issues for recommending ECGs in some The majority of SCD cases are indeed caused by an countries need to be acknowledged but must be dealt with within underlying abnormality that potentially could have been those countries/systems. On ethical grounds, the reasons (logistical, identiļ¬ed on cardiovascular screening, depending on the legal, economic) for not screening individual athletes should be speciļ¬c abnormality and the content of the cardiovascular clearly stated. Alas, the current evidence, as presented here, suggests screening applied. As a consequence, cardiac screening is that the ECG should be mandatory in pre-participation screening universally recommended by the cardiac societies [European of athletes. Society of Cardiology (ESC) and American Heart Association (AHA)]8,9 and required by the major sporting bodies [Federation Internationale de Football Association (FIFA) Ā“ Ā“ Submitted for publication March 4, 2010; accepted November 1, 2010. and Union of European Football Associations (UEFA)] today. From the Department of Acute and Emergency Medicine, Sahlgrenska Pre-participation examination is by consensus understood to University Hospital, Ostra, Sahgrenska Academy, Goteborg, Sweden. include personal history and physical examination; contro- The authors report no conļ¬‚icts of interest to disclose. versy exists regarding the usefulness and appropriateness of Corresponding Author: Mats Borjesson, MD, PhD, Department of Acute and Emergency Medicine, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Ostra, 416 85 screening using resting 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG), also Goteborg, Sweden (e-mail: mats.borjesson@vgregion.se). with an apparent transatlantic difference. The ESC recom- Copyright Ɠ 2011 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins mends screening consisting of personal history, physical Clin J Sport Med Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011 www.cjsportmed.com | 13
  • 2. Borjesson and Dellborg Clin J Sport Med Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011 examination and 12-lead resting ECG,8 whereas the US SENSITIVITY OF SCREENING recommendations from the AHA includes only personal WITH ELECTROCARDIOGRAM history and physical examination.9 Several studies have looked at the sensitivity of a resting Screening to identify individuals with increased risk for ECG to identify the most common cause of SCD (HCM).15 In sudden death in relation to PA has many implications for 1 study, more than 95% of cases of SCD caused by HCM, society, for the individual, and for professional bodies and where previous ECGs were available, showed abnormal individual clubs. A potentially preventable case of sudden resting ECGs.16 In other studies, 70% to 80% of SCD caused death in a young professional athlete may have tremendous by arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy, where impact on personal, professional, economic, and legal levels. resting ECGs were available, showed abnormal ļ¬ndings.17,18 Barring a high-risk professional athlete from personal and In fact, the ECG may be almost as good as, or equal to, economic success, whose risk nevertheless is less than, say, echocardiography regarding sensitivity for detecting underly- smoking 20 cigarettes per day or riding a motorcycle without ing HCM, as shown by comparing the Italian data, using the a helmet, also has obvious profound implications for that ECG,19 with similar ļ¬gures of discovery in the United States, individual and for his family, club, and society. Any screening using echocardiography.20 Furthermore, Pelliccia et al21 must, in addition to fulļ¬lling the World Health Organizationā€™s showed that a normal ECG has a very high negative predictive classic screening criteria,10 also yield a reasonable balance value (99.98%) for excluding HCM, in an 8-year follow-up. between sensitivity and speciļ¬city because this will ultimately In addition, resting ECG will identify the majority of determine the utility of the screening. cases with pre-excitation, long/short QT-interval, and Brugada The aim of this article is to discuss the existing evidence syndrome, if certainly not all.22 A large variety of arrhythmias for mandating resting ECG as a part of the recommended could also be identiļ¬ed, possibly as a marker of an underlying cardiac screening of athletes. Most of the ECG changes seen structural disease. in athletes will be due to the cardiac physical adaptation to A Swedish study by Wisten et al23 indicated that of training (ie, athleteā€™s heart), but abnormalities on the ECG may 66 cases of SCD in young individuals (,35 years, athletes also be an expression of an underlying cardiovascular disease, or nonathletes), 18% had a positive family history, 76% had with an increased risk for SCD during sports. We will discuss previous symptoms, and 82% showed earlier ECG abnormal- the sensitivity, speciļ¬city, cost-effectiveness, and feasibility of ities. In the study of Baggish et al,14 .500 collegiate athletes the 12-lead ECG as a part of the pre-participation examination underwent pre-participation screening with personal history of athletes. and physical examination, identifying 5 of 11 cases of structural disease. The addition of an ECG made it possible to identify an additional 5 cases for a total of 10 of the overall SENSITIVITY OF SCREENING total of 11 (sensitivity 91%). WITHOUT ELECTROCARDIOGRAM All in all, adding the 12-lead resting ECG to the personal For any screening to be meaningful, the chosen method of history and physical examination will substantially increase screening must be able to detect what we want to ļ¬nd.10 Thus, the sensitivity for detecting the underlying cardiac abnormal- cardiac screening should be able to identify relevant underlying ities, with a very high negative predictive value. cardiovascular abnormalities, that is, having a high sensitivity. The current US screening recommendations include personal history and physical examination only (see AHA). The limited data available indicate that the sensitivity of SPECIFICITY OF SCREENING personal history and physical examination without an ECG WITH ELECTROCARDIOGRAM for identiļ¬cation of cases of SCD is very low. In a study of The physiologic adaptation to regular intensive PA 115 cases of SCD by Maron et al,11 only 1 case was identiļ¬ed includes structural and electrical remodeling, also resulting using the US screening method without mandatory ECG. in electrocardiographic changes, which is all a part of the Similar low ļ¬gures for sensitivity of screening without the ā€˜ā€˜athleteā€™s heart.ā€™ā€™ Most ECG abnormalities found in athletes ECG has been found in Italian studies12 and in a recent British will therefore not be due to an underlying cardiac abnormality. study.13 The presence of undeļ¬ned ECG abnormalities may have a low Recently, the study by Baggish et al14 of 510 collegiate speciļ¬city for cardiac disease in the athletic population. For athletes showed that a screening strategy including personal example, coronary artery disease and coronary artery anomaly history and physical examination would identify 5 of 11 may be difļ¬cult to identify by ECG alone, although they may individuals with underlying cardiovascular abnormality, as well be suspected by the combination of symptoms and family determined by echocardiography, yielding a sensitivity of history. 46%.14 However, it should be kept in mind that echocardi- Up to 40% of athletes, depending on type of sport, ography will not identify all possible causes of SCD in duration of regular activity, ethnicity, age, and gender, may athletes, such as nonstructural diseases like arrhythmias. show some kind of abnormalities on standard 12-lead ECG.24 The sensitivity of cardiac screening with personal Clearly, the cutoff values chosen to deļ¬ne abnormalities on the history and physical examination but without the ECG is athlete ECG will greatly inļ¬‚uence the speciļ¬city achieved. low or very low, and the lack of sensitivity remains a major Previously given cutoff values for ECG interpretation25 concern for recommending a screening strategy without yielded a high number of ā€˜ā€˜false-positivesā€™ā€™ in cardiac including the ECG. screening. Larger studies examining different athletes of 14 | www.cjsportmed.com q 2011 Lippincott Williams Wilkins
  • 3. Clin J Sport Med Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011 ECG in Pre-Participation Examination different age and gender and in a variety of sports showed that Several costā€“effect analyses of screening with ECG have 60% of the ECGs deļ¬ned as abnormal were in fact showing been performed; in Japan,30 in Italy (unpublished data), and in isolated QRS amplitude signs of left ventricular hypertrophy the United States.31,32 The Fuller32 study estimated that adding and/or repolarization abnormalities only.24,26 the ECG to personal history and physical examination was Newer studies have shown that some ECG changes seen more cost-effective (USD 44 000 per life-year saved as in athletes, such as repolarization changes, are not associated compared with USD 84 000 per life-year saved without the with an increased risk in the long term but instead may be the ECG screening). The Japanese study by Tanaka et al30 expression of autonomic adaptations secondary to long-term concluded that ECG screening was cost-effective. Still, a more training.26,27 strict and formal costā€“effect analysis fully accounting for costs Electrocardiographic changes are dependent also on and beneļ¬ts of screening has been needed.33 Recently, such an ethnicity.28,29 For example, echocardiographic studies showed analysis was published from Stanford University.34 The that 20% of black athletes compared with 4% of white athletes authors used a decision model to project the costs and will have an increased left ventricular wall thickness .12 mm, survival rates for 14-year-old to 22-year-old US athletes which is also associated with a higher degree of ECG undergoing a cardiac screening session, either by personal changes.28 history and physical examination alone or with an added 12- The ESC section of Sports Cardiology recently pro- lead resting ECG. The data were compared with no screening posed26 to classify ECG changes in athletes into 2 groups: at all, using Italian data of survival and adjusting the ļ¬gures to 1. Common and training-related ECG changes, such as sinus US standards. The analysis estimated that adding the ECG to bradycardia, ļ¬rst-degree atrioventricular block, incomplete history and physical examination saves 2.06 life-years per right bundle branch block (RBBB), early repolarization, and 1000 athletes screened, costing USD 42 000 per life-year isolated QRS voltage criteria for left ventricular hypertrophy. saved, compared with screening without ECG.34 The addition 2. Uncommon and training-unrelated ECG changes, such as of the ECG was considered cost-effective. In fact, screening widespread T-wave inversion, complete RBBB/left bundle with added ECG is cost-effective also compared with other branch block, and Brugada-like early repolarization.26 well-known and widely accepted procedures in health care, Indeed, the common and training-related ECG changes such as giving dialysis to patients with chronic kidney disease are much more common, constituting more than 80% of (USD 20-80 000 per quality-adjusted life-year saved) or ECG changes found in athletes. The training-unrelated ECG application of an implanted cardioverter deļ¬brillator for the changes typically constitute only 5% to 10% of ECG changes prevention of sudden death (USD 34-70 000 per quality- seen in athletes.26,27 However, this ļ¬gure can be expected to adjusted life-year saved). In a ļ¬nal comment, the authors vary in respect of ethnicity and gender, and more studies are concluded that cardiovascular screening with history and therefore needed in different ethnic groups and genders. physical examination without the ECG was substantially more When Corrado et al26 applied this new classiļ¬cation to costly and marginally more effective than no screening at all.34 the previously reported data from Pelliccia et al24 on 1005 The continuous development of new even stricter ECG highly trained athletes without structural or other heart disease, criteria for abnormality has the potential to further decrease the 292 of the 402 athletes previously described as having number of athletes falsely classiļ¬ed as abnormal, potentially ECG abnormalities showed either an isolated increase of improving the cost-effectiveness even more. QRS voltage (n = 233) or early repolarization patterns (n = 59). Only 11% (n = 110) were classiļ¬ed as ā€˜ā€˜uncommon and training-unrelatedā€™ā€™ according to the new criteria,26 FEASIBILITY AND LIABILITY thus showing the potential efļ¬cacy of the new classiļ¬cation What is the rationale for leaving out the ECG? Given the to increase the speciļ¬city of the ECG as a part of cardiac superior sensitivity of cardiac screening with ECG, the limited but screening. steadily improving speciļ¬city, and that the cost-effectiveness of In summary, although the speciļ¬city of any abnormal including the ECG also seems superior to screening without ECG is limited, new criteria suggest that, if appropriate ECG, why is the ECG not universally recommended to be a part consideration is given to gender, level of training, and of the regular pre-participation screening of athletes? ethnicity, the speciļ¬city of screening with the ECG are greatly As the scientiļ¬c reasons for including the ECG in pre- improved. participation screening look clear and undisputable, we probably have to look elsewhere for the reasons for excluding the ECG.9 Different health care systems in general and COSTā€“EFFECTIVENESS different legal systems regarding liability in particular may Up to now, one of the most common reasons for not play a major role in the different approaches of different advocating ECG as part of the routine pre-participation cardiac countries. In Italy, cardiac screening including ECG has been screening of athletes has been the purportedly high cost of mandated by law since 1971,35 and it has also been mandatory follow-up examinations due to the low speciļ¬city of the ECG in other countries, such as Hungary. In the United States, in screening. The actual cost of the ECG itself has not been however, the complex legal system with high liability charges considered to be the main problem,9 nor the cost of physical against a physician allegedly missing a diagnosis (eg, in the examination and personal history taking by a physician, case of SCD in an athlete) could be disastrous for the because this has been advocated by the AHA/American individual physician. The presence of any kind of pathology College of Sports Medicine for competitive athletes.9 on the pre-participation ECGs will have tremendous impact q 2011 Lippincott Williams Wilkins www.cjsportmed.com | 15
  • 4. Borjesson and Dellborg Clin J Sport Med Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011 in any liability case. In Europe, such liability is rarely an coronary events in men ,65 and .65 years. Am J Cardiol. 2002;89: important issue in relation to cardiovascular screening. 1187ā€“1192. 4. Albert CM, Mittleman MA, Chae CU, et al. Triggering of sudden death The opposite angle is perhaps equally important: the from cardiac causes by vigorous exertion. N Engl J Med. 2000;343: consequences for the athleteā€™s career if a benign ECG 1355ā€“1361. abnormality is wrongly interpreted as indicating a serious 5. Courson R. Preventing sudden death on the athletic ļ¬eld: the emergency underlying disease may also be vast. To the club and its action plan. Curr Sports Med Rep. 2007;6:93ā€“100. members, or owners, the disqualiļ¬cation of a highly compe- 6. Borjesson M, Pelliccia A. Incidence and aetiology of sudden cardiac death in young athletes: an international perspective. Br J Sports Med. 2009;43: tent, and very costly(!), athlete may have profound economic 644ā€“648. impact in a judicial system focused on liability. 7. Corrado D, Basso C, Rizzoli G, et al. Does sports activity enhance the risk However, from a societal perspective, it is important to of sudden death in adolescents and young adults? J Am Coll Cardiol. adequately identify individuals at increased risk for sudden 2003;42:1959ā€“1963. death, not only to prevent unnecessary deaths in young 8. Corrado D, Pelliccia A, Bjornstad HH, et al. Cardiovascular pre- individuals but also to prevent the public impression that PA participation screening of young competitive athletes for prevention of sudden death: proposal for a common European protocol. Consensus is dangerous and should best be avoided. This being said, an statement of the Study Group of Sports Cardiology of the Working Group intensive and vigorous screening procedure with a large number of Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology and the Working of false-positive cases may also confer the notion that PA is, in Group of Myocardial and Pericardial Diseases of the European Society of general, dangerous. The impact on public health of decreased Cardiology. Eur Heart J. 2005;26:516ā€“524. PA among the population is difļ¬cult to calculate but potentially 9. Maron BJ, Thompson PD, Ackerman MJ, et al. Recommendations and considerations related to preparticipation screening for cardiovascular highly negative and very costly. abnormalities in competitive athletes: 2007 update. A scientiļ¬c statement These differences in health care/legal systems have to be from the American Heart Association Council on Nutrition, Physical acknowledged and respected. They may also partly explain Activity, and Metabolism: endorsed by the American College of the somewhat differing approaches to screening in different Cardiology Foundation. Circulation. 2007;115:1643ā€“1655. countries and by different sporting bodies (FIFA and UEFA 10. Wilson JMG, Jungner G. Principles and Practice of Screening for mandate cardiac screening by ECG, whereas the International Diseases. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organisation; 1968. 11. Maron BJ, Shirani J, Poliac LC, et al. Sudden death in young competitive Olympic Committee is somewhat more cautious in their latest athletes. Clinical, demographic and pathological proļ¬les. JAMA. 1996; recommendations36). 276:199ā€“204. 12. Pelliccia A, Maron BJ. Preparticipation cardiovascular evaluation of the competitive athlete: perspectives from the 30-year Italian experience. SUMMARY Am J Cardiol. 1995;75:827ā€“829. Cardiac pre-participation screening of elite athletes is 13. Wilson MG, Basavarajaiah S, Whyte GP, et al. Efļ¬cacy of personal universally recommended for several reasons, including symptom and family history questionnaires when screening for inherited cardiac pathologies: the role of electrocardiography. Br J Sports Med. ethical (AHA/American College of Sports Medicine) and 2008;42:207ā€“211. employer/employee relations, ultimately to prevent SCD 14. Baggish AL, Hutter AM, Wang F, et al. Cardiovascular screening in during sports. college athletes with and without electrocardiography. Ann Intern Med. The sensitivity of screening with ECG, in addition to 2010;152:269ā€“275. personal history and physical examination, is superior, and the 15. Maron BJ. Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy: a systematic review. JAMA. 2002;287:1308ā€“1320. cost-effectiveness is clearly better than screening without 16. Maron BJ, Roberts WC, Epstein SE. Sudden death in hypertrophic ECG.34 Screening including the ECG is cost-effective also in cardiomyopathy: a proļ¬le of 78 patients. Circulation. 1982;65:1388ā€“ comparison with other well-accepted procedures of modern 1394. health care. 17. Steriotis AK, Bauce B, Daliento L, et al. Electrocardiographic pattern in Thus, cardiac pre-participation screening without ECG arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy. Am J Cardiol. 2009; cannot be recommended given our current knowledge. The 103:1302ā€“1308. 18. Bauce B, Frigo G, Marcus FI, et al. Comparison of clinical features of difļ¬culties in feasibility and liability issues for recommending arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy in men versus women. ECGs in some countries need to be acknowledged but must be Am J Cardiol. 2008;102:1252ā€“1257. dealt with within those countries/systems. On ethical grounds, 19. Corrado D, Basso C, Schiavon M, et al. Screening for hypertrophic the reasons (logistical, legal, economic) for not screening cardiomyopathy in young athletes. N Engl J Med. 1998;339: individual athletes should be clearly stated. 364ā€“369. 20. Maron BJ, Gardin JM, Flack JM, et al. Prevalence of hypertrophic Alas, the current evidence, as presented here, suggests cardiomyopathy in a general population of young adults. Echocardio- that the ECG should be mandatory in pre-participation graphic analysis of 4111 subjects in the CARDIA Study. Circulation. screening of athletes. 1995;92:785ā€“789. 21. Pelliccia A, DiPaolo FM, Corrado D, et al. Evidence for efļ¬cacy of the REFERENCES Italian national pre-participation screening programme for identiļ¬cation 1. DeBacker G, Ambrosini E, Borch-Johnsen K, et al. Third Joint Task Force of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy in competitive athletes. Eur Heart J. of European and other societies on cardiovascular disease prevention in 2006;27:2196ā€“2200. clinical practice: European Guidelines on cardiovascular disease pre- 22. Marcus FI. Electrocardiographic features of inherited diseases that vention in clinical practice. Eur Heart J. 2003;24:1601ā€“1610. predispose to the development of cardiac arrhythmias, long QT syndrome, 2. Talbot LA, Morrell CH, Fleg JL, et al. Changes in leisure-time physical arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy/dysplasia and Brugada activity and risk of all-cause mortality in men and women: the Baltimore syndrome. J Electrocardiol. 2000;33(suppl):1ā€“10. longitudinal study of aging. Prev Med. 2007;45:169ā€“176. 23. Wisten A, Andersson S, Forsberg H, et al. Sudden cardiac death in the 3. Talbot LA, Morrell C, Metter EJ, et al. Comparison of cardiorespi- young in Sweden: electrocardiogram in relation to forensic diagnosis. ratory ļ¬tness versus leisure-time physical activity as predictors of J Intern Med. 2004;255:213ā€“220. 16 | www.cjsportmed.com q 2011 Lippincott Williams Wilkins
  • 5. Clin J Sport Med Volume 21, Number 1, January 2011 ECG in Pre-Participation Examination 24. Pelliccia A, Maron BJ, Culasso F, et al. Clinical signiļ¬cance of abnormal 29. Magalski A, Maron BJ, Main ML, et al. Relation of race to electrocardiographic patterns in trained athletes. Circulation. 2000;102: electrocardiographic patterns in elite American football players. J Am 278ā€“284. Coll Cardiol. 2008;51:2250ā€“2255. 25. Pelliccia A, Fagard R, Bjornstad H, et al. Recommendations for 30. Tanaka Y, Yoshinaga M, Anan R, et al. Usefulness and cost effectiveness competitive sports participation in athletes with cardiovascular disease: of cardiovascular screening of young adolescents. Med Sci Sports Exerc. a consensus document from the Study Group of Sports Cardiology of the 2006;38:2ā€“6. Working Group of Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology and 31. Risser WL, Hoffman HM, Bellah Jr GG, et al. A cost-beneļ¬t analysis of the Working Group of Myocardial and Pericardial Diseases of the preparticipation sports examinations of adolescent athletes. J Sch Health. European Society of Cardiology. Eur Heart J. 2005;26:1422ā€“1445. 1985;55:270ā€“273. 26. Corrado D, Pelliccia A, Heidbuchel H, et al. Recommendations for 32. Fuller CM. Cost effectiveness analysis of screening of high school athletes interpretation of 12-lead electrocardiogram in the athlete. Section of for risk of sudden cardiac death. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;32:887ā€“890. Sports Cardiology, European Association of Cardiovascular Prevention 33. MacAuley D. Olympic dreams. Br Med J. 2008;337:a739. and Rehabilitation. Eur Heart J. 2010;31:243ā€“1259. 34. Wheeler MT, Heidenreich PA, Froelicher VF, et al. Cost-effectiveness of 27. Corrado D, Bifļ¬ A, Basso C, et al. 12-Lead ECG in the athlete: preparticipation screening for prevention of sudden cardiac death in young physiological versus pathological abnormalities. Br J Sports Med. 2009; athletes. Ann Intern Med. 2010;152:276ā€“286. 43:669ā€“676. 35. Italian Ministry of Health. Rules concerning the medical protection of 28. Basavarajaiah S, Boraita A, Whyte G, et al. Ethnic differences in left athletic activity. Gazzetta Ufļ¬ciale. 1982;5:63. ventricular remodeling in highly-trained athletes relevance to differenti- 36. Ljungqvist A, Jenoure P, Engebretsen L, et al. The International Olympic ating physiologic left ventricular hypertrophy from hypertrophic Committee (IOC) consensus statement on periodic health evaluation of cardiomyopathy. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2008;51:2256ā€“2262. elite athletes March 2009. Br J Sports Med. 2009;43:631ā€“643. q 2011 Lippincott Williams Wilkins www.cjsportmed.com | 17