SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
A QUALITATIVE STUDY OF DIFFERENTIATED TEACHER SUPERVISIONS IMPACT ON
CLASSROOM INSTRUCTION AND PEDAGOGY
PIRAINO, JR., GENNARO R. (2006)
Doctoral Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh. EdD
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this qualitative study was to investigate the influence that a differentiated
teacher supervision system has on improving classroom instruction. Qualitative research
methodology was used to collect data through personal interviews and document analysis. The
sample population consisted of high school administrators working in three southwestern
Pennsylvania school districts. The research questions investigated high school principal
perceptions on differentiated supervisions ability to improve classroom instruction based upon
Charlotte Danielsons Four Domains of Instruction. Principal perceptions regarding
differentiated supervisions influence on school culture and the most effective differentiated
supervision options were also explored. The analysis of the data was done through descriptive
narrative and the use of charts to depict common answers and themes. Key findings include a
strong principal preference for differentiated teacher supervision. Also, principals indicate that
differentiated supervision was effective in fostering a school culture characteristic of teacher
collaboration, professional inquiry, and a commitment to continuous improvement. Also,
principals felt that differentiated teacher supervision was very effective in improving the
planning and preparation, classroom instruction, and professionalism of teachers through
collegiality and professional inquiry. Principals perceived that cooperative professional
development was the most effective model for improving classroom instruction.
Official URL: http://etd.library.pitt.edu/ETD/available/etd-0407...
TOWARDS A FRAMEWORK FOR LEADERSHIP COACHING
(EJ880818)
Author(s) WISE, DONALD; JACOBO, AMBER
Source:School Leadership & Management, v30 n2 p159-169 Apr 2010
Pub Date: 2010-04-00
Pub Type(s): Journal Articles; Reports - Descriptive
Peer-Reviewed: Yes
Descriptors:
Learning Theories; Educational Change; Educational Policy; Leadership; Principals;
Coaching (Performance); Change Agents; Organizational Change; Educational
Practices; Stakeholders; Transformational Leadership; Leadership Styles;
Supervisory Methods
ABSTRACT
Today's school principals face unprecedented challenges. This article proposes a
school-based outline framework in which the principal is the primary agent of
change aided by an external coach. In this framework, the principal receives
coaching and guides the change process at the school through a variety of
coaching practices involving the stakeholders in the school, including teachers,
staff and students. Sociocultural and organisational learning theory provides the
theoretical basis for this framework. The model includes the development of a
shared vision of student learning, and the evolution from a management-based
organisation to one of leadership, and ultimately, to a sustained
schootransformation.http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search
PRESSURING TEACHERS TO LEAVE: HONEST TALK ABOUT HOW PRINCIPALS USE
HARASSING SUPERVISION (EJ908995)
Author(s):Stoelinga, Sara Ray
Source:Phi Delta Kappan, v92 n4 p57-61 Dec 2010-Jan 2011
Pub Date: 2011-01-00
Pub Type(s): Journal Articles; Reports - Descriptive
Descriptors:
Teacher Evaluation; Principals; Teacher Supervision; Supervisory Methods; Labor
Turnover; Administrative Change; Administrative Principles; Teacher
Administrator Relationship; Personnel Management; Quality of Working Life
ABSTRACT
Many principals use harassing supervision to encourage low-performing teachers
to leave. Principals are driven to this tactic because teacher evaluation systems
don't systematically identify low-performing teachers, principals don't understand
the teacher removal process, principal training programs don't build principal
expertise in hiring and teacher professional development, and high turnover rates
mean that principals often are new at their job.
http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search
A qualitative study of differentiated teacher supervisions impact on classroom instruction and pedagogy

More Related Content

What's hot

Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014
Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014
Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014William Kritsonis
 
Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...
Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...
Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...Nagima Sarsenbayeva
 
Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...
Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...
Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...Alexander Decker
 
Gurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action research
Gurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action researchGurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action research
Gurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action researchJOHNLOULUCENARIO1
 
How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...
How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...
How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...Cesar Orsini
 
Machovcova et al. Persuaded to Lead
Machovcova et al. Persuaded to LeadMachovcova et al. Persuaded to Lead
Machovcova et al. Persuaded to LeadKaterina Machovcova
 
Teacher attitude towards inclusive education copy
Teacher attitude towards inclusive education   copyTeacher attitude towards inclusive education   copy
Teacher attitude towards inclusive education copyDr Francis R. Ackah-Jnr
 
Effective Instructional Strategies
Effective  Instructional StrategiesEffective  Instructional Strategies
Effective Instructional StrategiesDK Padua
 
My research proposal
My research proposalMy research proposal
My research proposalom collins
 
Gender issues in management education
Gender issues in management educationGender issues in management education
Gender issues in management educationVishnu Viswambharan
 
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...sallywywan
 
Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...
Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...
Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...William Kritsonis
 
Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02
Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02
Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02Ching Nemis
 

What's hot (18)

Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014
Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014
Borgemenke, arthur j examining recurring critical events schooling v5 n1 2014
 
Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...
Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...
Teachers’ Organizational Commitment in Nazarbayev Intellectual School in Tara...
 
Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...
Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...
Dominant management styles of the classrooms by the faculty members in alia u...
 
Gurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action research
Gurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action researchGurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action research
Gurot bayanihan as contextualized lesson study action research
 
How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...
How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...
How Do Clinical Tutors Encourage Intrinsic Motivation In Undergraduate Studen...
 
Machovcova et al. Persuaded to Lead
Machovcova et al. Persuaded to LeadMachovcova et al. Persuaded to Lead
Machovcova et al. Persuaded to Lead
 
Introspection
IntrospectionIntrospection
Introspection
 
Teacher attitude towards inclusive education copy
Teacher attitude towards inclusive education   copyTeacher attitude towards inclusive education   copy
Teacher attitude towards inclusive education copy
 
Self regulation
Self regulationSelf regulation
Self regulation
 
Effective Instructional Strategies
Effective  Instructional StrategiesEffective  Instructional Strategies
Effective Instructional Strategies
 
Relationship between Principals? Instructional Supervision Practices and Teac...
Relationship between Principals? Instructional Supervision Practices and Teac...Relationship between Principals? Instructional Supervision Practices and Teac...
Relationship between Principals? Instructional Supervision Practices and Teac...
 
My research proposal
My research proposalMy research proposal
My research proposal
 
Gender issues in management education
Gender issues in management educationGender issues in management education
Gender issues in management education
 
A Study of Teachers’ Self
A Study of Teachers’ SelfA Study of Teachers’ Self
A Study of Teachers’ Self
 
Nature of Mathematics.pptx
Nature of Mathematics.pptxNature of Mathematics.pptx
Nature of Mathematics.pptx
 
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
 
Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...
Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...
Inclusive Practices in Large Urban Inner-City Schools: School Principal Invol...
 
Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02
Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02
Curriculumdevelopmentreport 130107005619-phpapp02
 

Similar to A qualitative study of differentiated teacher supervisions impact on classroom instruction and pedagogy

SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdfSUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdfssuser9c1e1d
 
Assessment For Learning Effects And Impact
Assessment For Learning  Effects And ImpactAssessment For Learning  Effects And Impact
Assessment For Learning Effects And ImpactAndrea Porter
 
The Search For An Educational Holy Grail
The Search For An Educational Holy GrailThe Search For An Educational Holy Grail
The Search For An Educational Holy Grailnoblex1
 
English presentation g3 rombel 1
English presentation g3 rombel 1English presentation g3 rombel 1
English presentation g3 rombel 1200409190711
 
Effective instructional leadership
Effective instructional leadershipEffective instructional leadership
Effective instructional leadershipAzreen5520
 
How leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learningHow leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learningElniziana
 
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learning
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learningEDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learning
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learningEduexcellence
 
The Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School Organization
The Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School OrganizationThe Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School Organization
The Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School Organizationnoblex1
 
Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...
Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...
Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...MENGZHANG156709
 
Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...
Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...
Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...Pakistan
 
Pp effective leader]
Pp effective leader]Pp effective leader]
Pp effective leader]maxcatchevy
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...om collins
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE om collins
 
Leadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School Success
Leadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School SuccessLeadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School Success
Leadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School Successnorshimhashim
 
RELNEI educator_autonomy sources
RELNEI educator_autonomy sourcesRELNEI educator_autonomy sources
RELNEI educator_autonomy sourcesppageegd
 

Similar to A qualitative study of differentiated teacher supervisions impact on classroom instruction and pedagogy (20)

SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdfSUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
 
Assessment For Learning Effects And Impact
Assessment For Learning  Effects And ImpactAssessment For Learning  Effects And Impact
Assessment For Learning Effects And Impact
 
The Search For An Educational Holy Grail
The Search For An Educational Holy GrailThe Search For An Educational Holy Grail
The Search For An Educational Holy Grail
 
English presentation g3 rombel 1
English presentation g3 rombel 1English presentation g3 rombel 1
English presentation g3 rombel 1
 
Effective instructional leadership
Effective instructional leadershipEffective instructional leadership
Effective instructional leadership
 
Effective-teaching-2013
 Effective-teaching-2013 Effective-teaching-2013
Effective-teaching-2013
 
Ed546794
Ed546794Ed546794
Ed546794
 
Nursheha copyright
Nursheha copyrightNursheha copyright
Nursheha copyright
 
How leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learningHow leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learning
 
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learning
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learningEDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learning
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- How leadership-influences-student-learning
 
The Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School Organization
The Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School OrganizationThe Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School Organization
The Importance Of Collective Leadership Aimed At Developing School Organization
 
Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...
Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...
Zhang meng ecer2021-teacher-led teacher learning in cross-school professional...
 
Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...
Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...
Impact Of Classroom Management Strategies On Students' Performance And Motiva...
 
Pp effective leader]
Pp effective leader]Pp effective leader]
Pp effective leader]
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
 
720 pm
720 pm720 pm
720 pm
 
720 pm
720 pm720 pm
720 pm
 
Leadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School Success
Leadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School SuccessLeadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School Success
Leadership Effects On Student Achievement And Sustained School Success
 
RELNEI educator_autonomy sources
RELNEI educator_autonomy sourcesRELNEI educator_autonomy sources
RELNEI educator_autonomy sources
 

A qualitative study of differentiated teacher supervisions impact on classroom instruction and pedagogy

  • 1. A QUALITATIVE STUDY OF DIFFERENTIATED TEACHER SUPERVISIONS IMPACT ON CLASSROOM INSTRUCTION AND PEDAGOGY PIRAINO, JR., GENNARO R. (2006) Doctoral Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh. EdD ABSTRACT The purpose of this qualitative study was to investigate the influence that a differentiated teacher supervision system has on improving classroom instruction. Qualitative research methodology was used to collect data through personal interviews and document analysis. The sample population consisted of high school administrators working in three southwestern Pennsylvania school districts. The research questions investigated high school principal perceptions on differentiated supervisions ability to improve classroom instruction based upon Charlotte Danielsons Four Domains of Instruction. Principal perceptions regarding differentiated supervisions influence on school culture and the most effective differentiated supervision options were also explored. The analysis of the data was done through descriptive narrative and the use of charts to depict common answers and themes. Key findings include a strong principal preference for differentiated teacher supervision. Also, principals indicate that differentiated supervision was effective in fostering a school culture characteristic of teacher collaboration, professional inquiry, and a commitment to continuous improvement. Also, principals felt that differentiated teacher supervision was very effective in improving the planning and preparation, classroom instruction, and professionalism of teachers through collegiality and professional inquiry. Principals perceived that cooperative professional development was the most effective model for improving classroom instruction. Official URL: http://etd.library.pitt.edu/ETD/available/etd-0407...
  • 2. TOWARDS A FRAMEWORK FOR LEADERSHIP COACHING (EJ880818) Author(s) WISE, DONALD; JACOBO, AMBER Source:School Leadership & Management, v30 n2 p159-169 Apr 2010 Pub Date: 2010-04-00 Pub Type(s): Journal Articles; Reports - Descriptive Peer-Reviewed: Yes Descriptors: Learning Theories; Educational Change; Educational Policy; Leadership; Principals; Coaching (Performance); Change Agents; Organizational Change; Educational Practices; Stakeholders; Transformational Leadership; Leadership Styles; Supervisory Methods ABSTRACT Today's school principals face unprecedented challenges. This article proposes a school-based outline framework in which the principal is the primary agent of change aided by an external coach. In this framework, the principal receives coaching and guides the change process at the school through a variety of coaching practices involving the stakeholders in the school, including teachers, staff and students. Sociocultural and organisational learning theory provides the theoretical basis for this framework. The model includes the development of a shared vision of student learning, and the evolution from a management-based organisation to one of leadership, and ultimately, to a sustained schootransformation.http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search
  • 3. PRESSURING TEACHERS TO LEAVE: HONEST TALK ABOUT HOW PRINCIPALS USE HARASSING SUPERVISION (EJ908995) Author(s):Stoelinga, Sara Ray Source:Phi Delta Kappan, v92 n4 p57-61 Dec 2010-Jan 2011 Pub Date: 2011-01-00 Pub Type(s): Journal Articles; Reports - Descriptive Descriptors: Teacher Evaluation; Principals; Teacher Supervision; Supervisory Methods; Labor Turnover; Administrative Change; Administrative Principles; Teacher Administrator Relationship; Personnel Management; Quality of Working Life ABSTRACT Many principals use harassing supervision to encourage low-performing teachers to leave. Principals are driven to this tactic because teacher evaluation systems don't systematically identify low-performing teachers, principals don't understand the teacher removal process, principal training programs don't build principal expertise in hiring and teacher professional development, and high turnover rates mean that principals often are new at their job. http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search