Anti-ProphetMohammadMediaACriticalDiscourseAnalysis (1).pdf

!

##
$%%'( ) *

+$%%,' - +$%#$,
. +$%#$,
) / ) ) 0 *
) ' ) ) 12
312 3

) ( 2
- 2

'
4
( 5
' +#667#668$%#,. *
-95 .
-9
: 2
' ; ;)

!
#
$ !% ! $
' ' ($
' # % %) %* %
' $ '
+ %
' !# $,
( $
- .

!
- (
%
. %
% % % $
$ $ -
-
- -
// $$$
0
11#23.

4 )*5/ +)
678%99::: % ) -
2 ; !
*

- = -% %7:?
/- @7:94 )*5/ +)
3 7:9

$ $%
$#%#(##$# %$$#
'# #
!%(

$
%

$

%#

#

'$

'$## (# $$#
%'

$#
+! GMB +KHIAM!BEF
+( GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=@G=:
+( GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=HGMKHOKLR
+(( GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=(=B:
KBMB:EBLHNKLG:ERLBL
LM KBMB:EBLHNKLG:ERLM
' KBMB:E'BG@NBLMBL
, BKM,NHM:MBHG
O:EN:MBHGH?JNHM=F:MKB:E
!KJ !KJNGR
+ HOKGFGM:E+HEBMBB:G
+( HOKGFGML+KBF(BGBLMK
( HOKGFGML(BGBLMK
$ $G=BKM,NHM:MBHG
$*+ $LE:FHIAH;B:
%* %HNKG:EBLM
(+L (BKHIKHIHLBMBHGL
(. (:KHLMKNMNK
) )PLBLHNKL
)+ )PL+N;EBLABG@@GR
*- *K@:GBS:MBHG
+:K@ +:K:@K:IA
+* +HEBMBB:G
+ +KHI:@:G=:
+( +KHI:@:G=:(H=E
- -?KGMHIHIE =HNFGML LM:MFGM
/ -?KGMHMKFBGHEH@R IAK:LL:LLHB:M=PBMAI:KMBNE:KIHIEHK
=HNFGML
- -EB@BHNLNMAHKBMR
-( -EB@BHNL(:G
.(.L .F:GMB(:KHLMKNMNKL
. .GMG
/A:GBLA:KMHHGHGMKHOKLR
! /A!KGA:KB:MNKL
0$( /A0.?BEF$GGHGH?(NLEBFL
0 0L:@H?E:G@N:@MRIB:EH?KM:BG=BLHNKLMRIL HFFNGB:MBO
LBMN:MBHGL

$#%#
/:;E -L:KA,NLMBHGL #RIHMALL :G=IIEB=IIKH:A
/:;E /AHKINLH?MA.MN=R
/:;E /A.BMN:MBHGH?/AHKBLIIEB=BGMAG:ERLBL
/:;E /A$GBMB:E(BKHIKHIHLBMBHGLH?
/:;E KBO:MBHGH?/HIBL?HK
/:;E /A$GBMB:E(BKHIKHIHLBMBHGLH?(
/:;E KBO:MBHGH?/HIBL?HK(
/:;E /A$GBMB:E(BKHIKHIHLBMBHGLH?)4/
/:;E KBO:MBHGH?/HIBL?HK)4/
/:;E /A$GBMB:E(BKHIKHIHLBMBHGLH?0/
/:;E KBO:MBHGH?/HIBL?HK0/

/:;E 7HUPV8VHGWR5HIHUWRµSURSKHW¶DQGµ0XKDPPDG¶
/:;E /KFLNL=MHK?KMHMA:GBLA:G=!KGAHGMKHOKLBL
/:;E 7HUPVROORFDWHGZLWKWKH8VHRIµSURSKHW¶DQG 0XKDPPDG¶
/:;E /KFL0L=MHLKB;MAFKB:G?BEF
/:;E /A0LH?MAH7HUPVµDQWL ,VODP¶µDQWL 0XVOLP¶DQGµDQWL SURSKHW¶
/:;E (NLEBFL:G=AKBLMB:GLBGMAHKINL
/:;E /KFL0L=MHA:K:MKBS1BHEG
/:;E /KFLNL=MHA:K:MKBS(=B:!K=HF
/:;E $GMKMQMN:E-?KGBGMAHKINL
/:;E $FIHKM:GM.HB:E1HBLBGMAHKINL
/:;E +KHI:@:G=:BOBLBHGLBGMAHKINL
/:;E HFI:KBLHGH?MA.EM=)PLI:IKL
/:;E /A0L=-AMHKB:E=OBLBGMAHKINL

!B@NK GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=+KHI:@:G=:
!B@NK 9DQ'LMN¶V6FKHPDRI1HZV'LVFRXUVH
!B@NK $6XJJHVWHG5HSUHVHQWDWLRQRI9DQ'LMN¶V,GHRORJLFDO6TXDUHV
!B@NK /A.EM=(H=E:G=BML.MILH?G:ERLBL
!B@NK BLHNKL/HIBLH?MA.EM=HKINL

$$#

=B:MBHG
;;KOB:MBHGL
/:;EL:G=!B@NKL
HGMGML
$GMKH=NMBHG

+KHIAM(NA:FF:=L.;)J;H

)PLBLHNKL $=HEH@RG=KBMB:EBLHNKLG:ERLBL

(MAH=HEH@R

G:ERLBLG=BLNLLBHG

HGENLBHGL

B;EBH@K:IAR

$%$

NKBG@ MA E:LM GMNKR HG?EBML :;HNM MA ?K=HF H? QIKLLBHG HG KEB@BHG MAHN@AM :G=
HGLBGA:OPBMGLL=:=K:F:MBBGK:LBG(NLEBF:G=GHG (NLEBFPHKE=L /H=:RF:GR
(NLEBFHFFNGBMBLBGMA2LM:KK:EERLN??KBG@?KHFAHLMBEK:MBHGLMHP:K=LMAF:G=
MABLBLA:K:MKBS=;RB@GHK:G LNLIBBHG =I KHHM=IKCN=B :G= BGLHF:LL IARLB:E
:G=OK;:EA:K:LLFGM /ABLBLDGHPG:L$LE:FHIAH;B: PABA:G;KI:M=ER=?BG=:LMA
?:K H? HK IKCN=B= OBPIHBGML MHP:K=L (NLEBFL $LE:F :G= F:MMKL KE:M= MH MAF
$LE:FHIAH;B: BL GHM : GP IAGHFGHG PAMAK BM BL H? =:BER ?HKFL H? K:BLF :G=
=BLKBFBG:MBHG HK BM M:DL FHK OBHEGM :G= KBFBG:E ?HKFL :@:BGLM ANF:G KB@AML :G= LHB:E
HALBHGLBG BM BL GHMKE:M=MH(NLEBFL:EHG 2BMABGMA E:LM=:=H?MABLGMNKR :G=
I:KMBNE:KER:?MKMAOGMLH?.IMF;KMA
GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=HGMKHOKLRBLMAFHLM
NLN:E?HKFH?$LE:FHIAH;B: .NA?HKFLA:OGHMHGER=IBM=MA;BH@K:IARH?MA+KHIAM ;NM
A:O:ELHKBMBBL=ABLKEB@BHG:G=;EB?L
/A IKLGM ;HHD BL : KBMB:E =BLHNKL :G:ERLBL H? MA KIKH=NMBHG H? MA :GBLA
:KMHHGHGMKHOKLR MA!KGA:KB:MNKL:G=MA0.?BEF#DDE9;D9;E'KIB?CI:LGMB
+KHIAM(NA:FF:=F=B:BGLEM=KBMBLA:G=FKB:GGPLI:IKL MHKO:EAHPMAR
A:O;GKIKH=N=B HOK=:G=IHKMK:R= BGMAF=B:EBG@NBLMB:EER:G=B=HEH@B:EER
/ALF=B:A:O=BKMKEO:GMHMAOGMLBGMAPHKE= :G=BGMNKGA:O:@K:MBFI:MHG
MABGLM:GMER A:G@BG@IKHLLH?LM:;EBLABG@GPK@BFLLIB:EERBGMAK:;2HKE= /AL
:K:ELH:LLHB:M=PBMAHGMKHOKLB:EIHEBMB:E=BLINML:FHG@MAIN;EB:G=IHEBMBB:GL
:MMA
EH:E :G= @EH;:E EOEL /AK?HK :KMBEL :K LEM= ?KHF MA P;LBML H? MPH KBMBLA
GPLI:IKL G:FER.;!K7H:?7D:G=7?BO'7?B :G=MAHMAKMPHFKB:GLG:FER /-
.E:7O:G=.;(;M3EHA.?C;I /AEBG@NBLMB:G=B=HEH@B:E:G:ERLLH?MAKIKH=NMBHGH?
MABLF=B:AEIBGNG=KLM:G=BG@MAKEO:GM:G=KNB:EBLLNL:HFI:GB=;RMABLI:KMBNE:K
=BLHNKL !KHF:GB=HEH@B:EIHBGMH?OBP BMBLGLL:KRMHGKBAHK=BG:KRIHIEMAKHN@A
KBMB:E :G:ERLBL H? MA =BLHNKL H? GMB +KHIAM (NA:FF:= F=B: PABA PBEE K?EM MA
=B??KGMB=HEH@BL:=HIM=
/ABL;HHD:BFL:MQ:FBGBG@MAKIKH=NMBHGH?GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=@G=::G=
F=B:BGMPHKBMBLAGPLI:IKL G:FER.;!K7H:?7D:G=7?BO'7?B :G=MPHHMAKFKB:G
G:FER /-.E:7O:G=.;(;M3EHA.?C;IBGOLMB@:MBG@MAKIKLGM:MBHGH?B=HEH@R
BG
MALEM=GPLI:IKLB=GMB?RBG@MAKIKLGM:MBHGH?:=EB;K:MIKHI:@:G=:BGMALEM=
HGMKHOKLBL:G=HGLHEB=:MBG@MAO:EB=BMRH?K@:K=BG@GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=(=B::L:
NGBOKL:EHGMKHOKLR !HKMAL:BFL MABL;HHDPBEEEHHD?HKMALLBFBE:KBMBL:G==B??KGL
MG=MHHFHNMBGMAKIKH=NMBHGH?MABLF=B:BGMAE:G@N:@H?MALEM=KBMBLA:G=
FKB:GGPLI:IKL:G=?HKMAKIKLGM:MBHGH?B=HEH@RBGMALEM=:KMBEL LB=L BM
PBEE LAHP PAMAK MA LEM= HGMKHOKLBL G:FER :GBLA :KMHHG HGMKHOKLR !KGA
:KB:MNKL:G=#DDE9;D9;E'KIB?CI MG=MHKO:ELBFBE:KHK=B??KGM:@G=::G=IKHI:@:G=:
/AL PBEE E:= MA PKBMK MH LM:M MA:M GMB +KHIAM (NA:FF:= HGMKHOKLR BL HNMLM:G=BG@
GHN@AMH;:O:EB=LN;LMBMNMMHHMAKHGMKHOKLBLEBDGMB HFFNGBLF:G=GMB .FBMBLF
/A;HHDBL=BOB==BGMH?HNKI:KML /A?BKLMI:KMBL==B:M=MHQ:FBGGMB +KHIAM
(NA:FF:= (=B: :G= MA K:EBS:MBHG H? MA IKHIAM :L MA )J;H PBMA K?KG MH F=B:
:@G=: LMMBG@ IKHI:@:G=::G:ERLBL :G=BLE:FHIAH;B=BLHNKL +:KMMPH=:ELPBMAMAMHIBL
H?GPL=BLHNKL B=HEH@R:G=KBMB:E=BLHNKL:G:ERLBL /AFMAH=HEH@RBLIKLGM=BGMA
MABK=I:KMPAKMAKL:KAJNLMBHGL MAFH=EH?:G:ERLBL:G==:M:HEEMBHGL:KLM:M= /A
?HNKMAI:KMBLMAKBMB:E=BLHNKL:G:ERLBLH?MALEM=:KMBEL?KHFMAKBMBLA:G=FKB:G
GPLI:IKL LB=L :IKHI:@:G=::G:ERLBL:G=BGMKMQMN:E:G:ERLBL:K=HG?HKH;CMBOBMRHG

MAHGA:G= :G=?HKMA:BFLH?MALMN=RHGMAHMAK HGENBHGLKE:M=MHMAO:EB=BMRHK
K?NM:MBHGH?MALMN=R:BFL:G=ARIHMALL:K:ELHBGEN==
!BG:EER $ PHNE= EBD MH QIKLL FR @K:MBMN= :G= :DGHPE=@FGM MH OKRHG
I:KMBBI:M=BGF:DBG@MABLPHKDO:EN:;E

$%#

/ABLI:KMIKHOB=L:G:HNGMH?MAKIKLGM:MBHGH?+KHIAM(NA:FF:=:LMA)J;H
$LLNL
EBD $LE:FHIAH;B: AG?HKMA $*+ MA KIKLGM:MBHG H? $LE:F :G= (NLEBFL :L MA )J;H
GMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=(=B:AG?HKMA +((
:G=MAK:LLH?MABLF=B:PBEE;
HOK=
/AL BG:==BMBHGMHF:GRHMAKBLLNL PBEEHGLMBMNMMAGMB +KHIAM(NA:FF:=
@G=:AG?HKMA+(

HMA 1:G BCD :G= 2H=:D : LM:M MA:M DGHPE=@ :;HNM HGMQM
KIKLGM= ;R NEMNK ;EB?L :G= IHEBMBL H? MA MHIB H? BGOLMB@:MBHG A:L :G BFIHKM:GM
BG?ENG :L BM ?:BEBM:ML MQM BGMKIKM:MBHG BG MA:M BM F:BGM:BGL MA :G:ERLBL H;CMBO :G=
HAKGMHGMAHGA:G= :G=E:=LMA=BLHNKL:G:ERLMLMHF:DF:GBG@?NEHGENLBHGLBGMA
IKHLLH?BGMKIKM:MBHG HGMAHMAKL:ELH!:BKEHN@A
L ?HK MA IKLGM LMN=R MA PKBMK BL DG MH LMN=R MA GMB +KHIAM (NA:FF:=
HGMKHOKLRAG?HKMA+( :G=BMLBGK:LBG@ER LN;LJNGMKIKH=NMBHG:G=OGML?KHF
:G G@EBLA E:G@N:@ IKLIMBO OB: MA ?HNK LEM= GPLI:IKL ;R AHHLBG@ LHF GPL
LMHKBL HK :KMBEL ?KHF MABK P;LBML MH ; MA M:K@M MQML ?HK BGOLMB@:MBHG 'BG@NBLMB :G=
B=HEH@B:E :G:ERLBL H? DR OGML :EHG@ MABL HGMKHOKLR PBEE ; =HG PAG HG=NMBG@
JN:GMBM:MBO:G=JN:EBM:MBO:G:ERLL /ABLBLKM:BGERMHKIKH=NAHPMALGPLI:IKL:G=
MAGPLI:KMBBI:GMLK:MMHP:K=LMABLKBMB:E+(

,+0)
NKBG@ MA E:LM GMNKR MA =;:M HG MA =?BGBMBHG BFIHKM:G :G= ??ML H? F=B: E= MH
B=GMB?R F:LL HFFNGB:MBHG EBD MEOBLBHG K:=BH GPLI:IKL :G= BGMKGM :L HG H? MA
BFIHKM:GMP:IHGLBGIHEBMB:E NEMNK:E:G=KEB@BHNLHG?EBML :G=$LE:F±2LMBLHGH?MAF
/ALHG?EBMLA:OBGMNKG:MBO:M=MAREH?B=HEH@R A@FHGR :@G=: LMMBG@EBMK:MNK
MHFGMBHG;NM:?P /ABLLMBHG=:ELPBMAF=B::G=LHFKE:M=BLLNL EBDBMLKE:MBHGMH
E:G@N:@:G=IHEBMBL
(=B:
:K:G BG?ENGMB:E:G= BGM@K:EI:KMH?MH=:RL=:BER EB? :EEHOKMAPHKE= LMA
µ)RXUWK(VWDWH¶
MARHGMBGNHNLERA:O:GMK:ELM:G LQVKDSLQJSHRSOH¶VLQGLYLGXDOVRFLDO
:G=NEMNK:EP:RLH?EBOBG@ (HKHOK F=B:AEINLG@HMB:M MAF:GBG@L H?PA:MBL:K
@HBG@HGBGMAPHKE==NMHC;:?77H;?CFEHJ7DJ7=;DJIEIE9?7B?P7J?EDL2BEEB:FL
I 2BEEB:FLL:B=MA:MMABLLHB:EBS:MBHG:GAEIIHIEMHB;7HD78EKJJ;L7BK;I 8;B?;I7D:
DEHCIEEKHIE9?;J?;I:;L;BEFEKHEMDI;DI;E?:;DJ?JO7D:C;:?7J;EKH?DJ;H79J?EDM?JEJ;H
VRFLDOLQVWLWXWLRQVDQGZLWKHDFKRWKHU´I (=B::GIK?HKFMABLBG:GNF;KH?P:RL
:MBG@LHFMBFL:L³DVRXUFHRIFRQIOLFWDQGDWRWKHUVDVDVRXUFHRIFRQVHQVXV´1:GBCD
I ELH MAF=B:LBG?ENGHGLHB:EEB?BLKBMB:E:G= PBMAHNM:DGHPE=@BG@
MABL BMBLBFIHLLB;EMHQ:FBGLHB:EKE:MBHGL L:KLNEM MAKE:MBHGLABI;MPGF=B::G=
LHBMRA:L;GK@:K==:GBFIHKM:GMHFIHGGMH?F=B:LMN=BL
(=B: :L=HILQHGE2¶.HHIIH S BL³DEURDGWHUPZKLFKFDQUHIHUWRDWRWDOLWRI
EMH;7B?JO?IH;FH;I;DJ;:?D8HE7:97IJ7D:FH?DJ;:C;:?7IURPWHOHYLVLRQWRQHZVSDSHU´ /ANL
BMK?KLMHIHEBMB:E BGMKOBPL A:MLAHPL K:=BHIAHG BGL :G=LHHG PAKMPHIHIEHK
FHK:KBGMK:MBG@:G=:G:N=BGBLEBLMGBG@ /AK?HK ³PHGLDGLVFRXUVHZLOOQRWEHYLHZHG
M?J?D7H;FH;I;DJ7J?ED7BRUFULWLFDOIUDPHZRUNEXWUDWKHUZLWKLQDQLQWHUDFWLRQDORQH´HEEBG
I :?:MK:EBS=;RF:CHKBMRH?MAHLPHKDBG@BGMABL?BE= /ANL BG:LH?=K:PBG@:
:KB:MNK LSHFLDOLVWV OLNH 2¶.HHIIH S ;EBO MA:M : DBG= H? BGMK:MBHG HK

BGMK:MBOHFFNGB:MBHGBLIKLGM;MPGMAMPHHKFHKI:KMBBI:GML /AHLI:KMBBI:GML
LAHNE=:@KHG:GNG=KLM:G=BG@H?:K:G@H?LA:K=LI: ::AH?LA:K=DGHPE=@ :G=:
LGLH?HFFHGB=GMBMR G=MAL?:MNKL:KF:KD=MAKHN@AE:G@N:@NL
#HPOK F=B:BL:GMK:E BG?ENGMB:E :G=NEMNK:EMQMIN;EBLA=:L:K=B;ELHNKH?
NQRZOHGJHRIFXUUHQWHYHQWVHWLWFUHDWHVWKHUHDOLWLHVWKDW LWµGHVFULEHV¶RUDV:LOVRQ
I LM:ML³PHDQLQJVDUHRXUV´ EEGK I :K@NLMA:MMAIKH=NMLH?F=B:NEMNK
IKHOB=MA
C7J;H?7BIEKJEM?9M;EH=;EKH?:;DJ?J?;IEKHI;DI;EI;BEE:EKH
DEJ?EDEM7J?JC;7DIJE8;C7B;EH;C7B;EKHI;DI;E9B7II ;JD?9?JO
7D:H79; ED7J?ED7B?JO EI;NK7B?JO7D:EKIR7D:J;C ';:?7?C7=;I
;BFI7F;EKHL?;MEJ;MEHB:7D:EKH:;;F;IJL7BK;IM7JM;9EDI?:;H
=EE:EH87: FEI?J?L;EHD;=7J?L; CEH7BEH;L?B

HGLJNGMER F=B:BL:IKH?HNG=LHNKH?NEMNK:EI=:@H@RPABABGLMKNMLIHIEBGP:RL
H? ;BG@ PAMAK MABL BL BG MA IK?HKF:G H? @G=K :@ E:LL K: G:MBHG:EBMR BG
FRQVXPSWLRQDQGOHLVXUHRU³?D9EDEHC?JOJE7:EC?D7DJIOIJ;CEDEHCI L7BK;I FH79J?9;I7D:
LQVWLWXWLRQV´I
2BMABG MA L:F K:G@ ':N@AR I =?BGL F=B: :L J;9DEBE=?;I J7J
9ECCKD?97J;C;II7=;IJE7K:?;D9;I?D:?;H;DJF7HJIE7H;=?ED 9EKDJHOEH;L;DJ;MEHB:
7KHVHPHGLDZKLFKDUHPRUHDFFXUDWHOGHVFULEHGDVµPDVVPHGLDDUHWKHPRVW H;OBHNL:G=
?:FBEB:KMHIKLGM±=:REB? /AMKFµPDVV¶LQWKLVVHQVHUHIHUVWR³WKHPDVVLYHUHFHSWLRQRI
PHGLD VXFKDVWHOHYLVLRQILOPDQGVRRQ´ BEL I HK=BG@MHBF:@@BH
I F:LLF=B:BL=?BG=:LBGEN=BG@J;;DJ?H;IF;9JHKCC7?DIJH;7CC;:?7 ?D9BK:?D=DEJ
@KIJD;JMEHAD;MIIJ7J?EDIB?A;- ( 7D: 7BBEM?9 7L;8;;D:;I9H?8;:7IJ;
FH;;HH;:D;MIC;:?KCEJ;C;H?97DC7II;I +KBGMF=B: I:KMBNE:KEREBMF=B:HNMEML
EBD /- .E:7O .; (;M 3EHA .?C;I 17I?D=JED *EIJ :G= EI D=;B;I .?C;I :K :ELH
BGEN== IKBF:KBER;:NLJ;OI;JJ;JED;7D:7=;D:7EHH;FEHJ?D=9EC?D=EKJEBE97BBO
87I;:D;MIF7F;HII :LPEE:L?HKG:MBHG:E:G=EH:EIKBFMBFMEOBLBHGGPLIKH@K:FL
:G=:;E:G=K:=BHGPL
/AEBMK:MNKH?MA=OEHIFGMH?F=B:MAHKRBLLHKBA:G=HEHNK=;R?HNK?HKFL
H?BG?ENG :G=MAL:KMAF:GLH?HFFNGB:MBHG MA=OEHIFGMBGF:KDM;NLBGLL

WKH GHYHORSPHQW LQ WKH VRFLDO WKHRU DQG WKH GHYHORSPHQW LQ WKH SROLWLFDO WKHRU /DXJKH¶V
%;O.;C;I?D';:?7.;EHOIKLGML:=M:BE=MK:MFGMH?MABLEBMK:MNKLM:KMBG@PBMA
/DVVZHOO¶V PRGHORIFKDLQRIFRPPXQLFDWLRQ S WLOO%RXUGLHX¶V WKHKDELWXVDQGILHOGWKHRU
I ? HGKGBG@MA?BKLMBG?ENG ':N@ARLM:MLMA:MF=B:I:LL=?KHFIKBGM=?HKFMH
FNEMBF=B:HGL :G=MABGK:LBG@=IG=GHGMABGMKGM:G=LHB:EHFFNGB:MBHGF=B:
A:L OB=GMER LG KGM =OEHIFGML BG MA (B==E :LM :L :G Q:FIE !HK MA LHG=
BG?ENG ':N@AR I ? FGMBHGL MAK BFIHKM:GM LM:@L :G= MAL :K A:OBHNKBLF
.MKNMNK:EBLF :G=$GMK:MBHG
!HKMK:BG@MABG?ENGH?;NLBGLLF:KDM ':N@ARLM:MLMA:M
MA EBMK:MNK A:L PBMGLL= =K:F:MB A:G@L =N MH MAHKBL H? HGLNFIMBHG :G= FH=EL H?
5LW]HU¶V0F'RQDOGL]DWLRQ)LVNH¶VRQVXPHU5HVLVWDQFH'HHUWHDX¶V(YHUGD7DFWLFVDUHXS
MH =:MQ:FIELLEQ:G=K M:E !HKMAE:LMBG?ENG G:FERMA=OEHIFGMH?
MA IHEBMB:E MAHKR ':N@AR MK:L MA BG?ENG H? +KHI:@:G=: AG?HKMA + MAGBJN
:@G=: LMMBG@ FH=KGBMR IHLMFH=KGBLF HEHGB:EBLF IHLM HEHGB:EBLF ?FBGBLF @G=K
MAHKR :G=IHEBMB:EHGHFR !HKMAINKIHLH?MAIKLGMLMN=R MALHG=BG?ENGBLFHK
KEO:GM:G=KEB:;EMA:GMAHMAKMAK LIB:EERLBG+(BLF:BGERH?IHEBMB:EG:MNK

#'*+('/'!('.!+0-.#
!MSK':NK;:A; I A:O=LKB;=MAKE:MBHGL;MPGMAF=B::G=IHEBMBL:L
DQ ³H[LVWHQWLDO H[FKDQJH VVWHP´ RU D ³KDSS VPELRVLV´ LQ ZKLFK
?DEHC7J?EDEDJ;F7HJEJ;FEB?J?9?7DI ?I;N97D=;:EHFK8B?9?JOEDJ;
F7HJEJ;C;:?7 ±78ED:J7JA;;FI=HEM?D=J?=J;H7IJ;C;:?78;9EC;
CEH;7D:CEH;IK8@;9JJEJ;9ECC;H9?7B?CF;H7J?L;

6XFKDµKDSSVPELRVLV¶;MPGMAF=B::G=IHEBMBLBLMAHIIHLBMMHMAPHGLD¶VUROHDV
³DQHXWUDOPHGLDWRUDQGFULWLFDOPRQLWRURISROLWLFV´I :G=BMBLGHM=FHK:MB:EER:IM=
HK E@BMBF:M= /AK?HK BM BL NGEBDER HK BFIHLLB;E MH IKLGM BMLE? HG MA LNK?: H?
µLRF;HEBSROLWLFV¶ -:MAK BMF:GB?LMLBMLE?BGIAGHFG:EBDMALM:@=:GM:@HGBLF PABA
BLLGBGOBLN:EIHEBMB:EM:EDL:G=BGMKOBPL
HGKGBG@MAIKLGM =:RLM:MNLH?MAKE:MBHGL;MPGMA F=B: IHEBMBL :G=MA
IN;EB ³WKH UHOHYDQW GLVFRXUVHV LQ FRPPXQLFDWLRQ VWXGLHV SROLW?97B 9ECCKD?97J?ED 7D:
:?I9EKHI; 7D7BOI?I 7H; L;HO IA;FJ?97B I ´ /AK BL KBMBBLF :L LM:M= ;R 'PBL
I ? MA:M
?J7BBIIEHJEJ;:;CE9H7J?9?:;7B799EH:?D=JEM?9H;; E8@;9J?L;7D:
I9HKFKBEKIC;:?7?DEHCJ;FK8B?9EDFEB?J?97B:;9?I?EDI7D:?IIK;I 7JJ;
I7C;J?C;9EDJHEBB?D=J;79JEHI?DJ;FEB?J?97BIF;H;8O?DI?IJ?D=EDJ;
JH7DIF7H;D9OEJ;FEB?J?97BFHE9;II7D:EDJ;@KIJ??97J?EDE?JI:;9?I?EDI
JEJ;FK8B?9

ELH ;:NL H? MA HFFKB:E IKLLNK :G= ;G?BML KIKLGM= ;R :N=BG K:MBG@L HK
GNF;KLH?HIBLLHE=LEQ:G=K M :E MAF=B::KL:B=MH;@BOBG@BGMH 7
J;D:;D9O JE C7A; FEB?J?97B :?I9EKHI; CEH; ;DJ;HJ7?D?D= 8O JH?L?7B?P?D= F;HIED7B?P?D=
:H7C7J?P?D= 9EDL;HI7J?ED7B?P?D= 7 IE9?7B :EC7?D M?9 :;F;D:I ED 7D ?DEHC;: FK8B?9
H;IF;9J?L;BO ;B;9JEH7J; EH :;CE9H79O JE MEHA´ )HW]HU /DXHUEDFK E S? :G=
NG?HKMNG:MER MABLBLMAP:RMA$K:J2:K:G=:GBLA:KMHHGLA:O;GMK:M= !HK
MABKI:KM MAIHEBMBB:GL:KHG=FG=?HKNLBG@MALHB:EF=B:EBD!:;HHD /PBMMK:G=
4HN /N; MH BG?ENG IN;EB HIBGBHG BGLM:= H? @BOBG@ K:E BG?HKF:MBHG :G= MABL A:L ;G
:ABO=;R³HPSORLQJSURIHVVLRQDOSXEOLFUHODWLRQVVWUDWHJLHVDQGµVSLQQLQJ¶ZKDWLQIRUPDWLRQ
WKHGRSURYLGH´%HLIA I
/PHFH=EL:K:O:BE:;E?HKMAKE:MBHGL;MPGIHEBMBL:G=F=B: HGMAHGA:G=
:G=PBMAIN;EB HGMAHMAK /A?BKLMLV%OXPOHU *XUHYLWFK¶V S?? FH=E BM=BG
!MSK ':NK;:A ; I ? H? : LRLMF H? IHEBMB:E HFFNGB:MBHG PAK ?HNK
BGMKKE:M=LN;LRLMFL:KIKLGM
x MALRLMFH?MAF=B:PBMAKLIMMHMABKIHEBMB:E:LIML
x WKH VVWHP RI WKH SXEOLF¶V H[SHFWDWLRQV DQG RULHQWDWLRQV UHJDUGLQJ SROLWLFDO
HFFNGB:MBHG
x MALRLMFH?IHEBMB:EBGLMBMNMBHGLPBMAKLIMMHMABKHFFNGB:MBHG:LIML
:G=
x HFFNGB:MBHG KEO:GM:LIMLH?IHEBMB:ENEMNK

:L=HGMAIKLIMBOLH?BGJNBKR :L:??BKF=;RENFEKNKOBMA HG:G
HGGMK:MHGHGH?MAL?HNKLRLMFL:M:MBF AHE=BG@LBFNEM:GHNLERBMLKE:MBHGLMHMA
RWKHUV7KLVFRQFHSWRIUHSUHVHQWDWLRQLVXVHGLQWKHSUHVHQWVWXGDVµUHSURGXFWLRQ¶ZKLFKPHDQV
ZKDWDQGKRZWKHDXGLHQFH¶VUHDFWLRQV:KMHMA:MLMAIKH=NKIKLGM=MAKHN@AF=B:
/H
IROORZ)HW]HU /DXHUEDFK¶VDUJXPHQW E SROLWLFDOGLVFRXUVHLQWKHPHGLDUHIHUVWR

x ³WKH GLVFRXUVH E SROLWLFDO DJHQWV LQ WKH PHGLD´ S :L LIHDLIKLHGL BG MA
I:KEB:FGM:KR=;:MLHKIKLLHG?KGL
x ³WKH GLVFRXUVH RI MRXUQDOLVWV M?J FEBLWLFLDQV LQ WKH PHGLD´ S EBD BGMKOBPL BG
LIHDG:G=PKBMMGF=B:
x ³WKHGLVFRXUVHRIMRXUQDOLVWV78EKJSROLWLFVDQGSROLWLFDODJHQWVLQWKHPHGLD´ S :LBG
MA:LLH?:G:ERLBL KIHKM HFFGM:KR M ;RMALI:DKLH?GPLIKH@K:FFL ;R
LMN=BHQIKML:G=HKKLIHG=GMLHGEH:MBHG

(=B: =BLHNKL EBD K:=BH :G= MEOBLBHG GPL LM:@= IE:RL BGMKOBPL LKFHGL
OHFWXUHVDQGWDONVKRZVLV³7F7HJ?9KB7H97BB;D=;EHFEB?J?97B:?I9EKHI;7D7BOIJI ?DJ7JJ;
;J;HE=;D;EKI7K:?;D9;I?DC7II C;:?7:?I9EKHI;C7O9ECFH?I;DEJEDBO:?;H;DJD7J?ED7B7D:
?DJ;HD7J?ED7B J7H=;JI 8KJ 7BIE :?;H;DJ ?:HRORJLFDOO GHILQHG JURXSV´I
/ABL G=L
KL:KAHG;HMAIKH=NMBHG:G=KIMBHGLB=LH?MAHFFNGB:MBOIKHLL 2A:MIHIE:G
EHHDIRURQWKHSURGXFWLRQVLGHLVWKHGLVFXUVLYHWUDFHVRIMRXUQDOLVWV¶DQGSROLWLFLDQV¶FRQFHUQWR
FNEMBIE:==KLLLPBMA=B??KGM:??BEB:MBHGL:G=BGMKLMLHGMAHGA:G= :G=PBMA=B??KGM
NEMNK:E :G= LN; NEMNK:E ;:D@KHNG=L HG MA HMAK *G MA KIMBHG LB= MABL F:GL
:?I9EKHI;7D7BOJ?97K:?;D9;H;9;FJ?EDH;I;7H9 M?9?IIJ?BB?D?JI?D7D9O.MKXMA2H=:D
I
/A=BLHNKLH?IHEBMBL CNLM:LHMAK=BLHNKLLH?LHBMR :G= BML=B??KGMP:RLH?
BGM@K:MBG@PBMAMAF:LLF=B:=BLHNKL BLLN;CMMHHGLM:GMA:G@ .NAA:G@L :LLM:M=
;R!:BKEHN@A I ?? FBKKHKMAFLEOLMAKHN@A³WKHKEULGL]DWLRQRILWVFRPPXQLFDWLYH
=;DH;I±8O?D9EHFEH7J?D=;7JKH;IEED;=;DH;?DJE7DEJ;H 7D: EH8O78B;D:?D=E=;D;H?9
IJOB;I EH8O:H7M?D=EDEJ;HEHCEH;:?I9EKHI;IJ7D8;EH; .BFBE:KER !MSK':NK;:A
; I =LKB;IKLGM =:RIHEBMB:E=BLHNKLBGMAF=B::L?HEEHPL

6BM77I8;9EC;O8H?:?DJ7J?J7HJ?9KB7J;IJE=;J;HJ;EH:;HIE:?I9EKHI;
E J; FEB?J?97B IOIJ;C 9EDL;DJ?ED7B E?9?7B FEB?J?9I E J; C;:?7 E
I9?;D9; 7D: J;9DEBE=O E =H7IIHEEJI IE9?EFEB?J?97B CEL;C;DJI E
EH:?D7HO FH?L7J; B?; 7D: IE EHJ ± 8KJ ?D 7D KDIJ78B; 7D: I?J?D=
9ED?=KH7J?ED

/ABLOBPA:L;G=LKB;=;R.MKXMA2H=:D I ?
:L:MNKG:P:RH?LAHPBG@MA:M
MA:G:ERLBLH?MAFBKH EOEH?F=B:BGMK:MBHGHOKPB@ALMA:G:ERLBLH?MAF:KH EOEH?
LHB:EBGLMBMNMBHGL !NKMAKFHK MAKE:MBHGL;MPGMAF=B: IHEBMBL:G=MAIN;EBLIAK
A:OMK:=BMBHG:EER;GHGBO=H?:LC79HE IJHK9JKH7BF;DEC;D77D:CK9J;EH?P?D=ED
J;F7HJEIE9?EBE=O C;:?7IJK:?;I7D:FEB?J?97B9ECCKD?97J?ED7L;=ED;?DJE;BK9?:7J?D=J;
UHODWLRQVEHWZHHQWKHP´I

#2.#'
)PLF=B::KHGH?MA?P?HKFLH?HFFNGB:MBHGBGMANKKGMPHKE=MA:MEMLIHIEL
IE:LMARA:OGOK;GMH :G=K:=:;HNMIHIEMARA:OGOKFM $MLNL:GMEEMAF
MH:E:K@QMGMAHPE:G@N:@KIKLGMLMALHB:EF:GBG@L:G=LMKHMRIL2BELHG
I NMHMABLKNB:ELB@GB?B:G MAF=B:A:OPBMGLL=FNAIKH@KLL:G==OEHIFGM
BGMAE:LMMAK=:=L:G=HGLJNGMER@:BG=HGLB=K:;E :MMGMBHGBG:P:RMA:MA:LGHM
A:IIG=;?HK $MA:L;G:DGHPE=@=;RF:GR=BLHNKLIK:MBMBHGKL EBD!:BKEHN@A
I ? MA:MMAF=B::KMAF:BG:MHKBG:KOBG@:G=HKBGMBG@IN;EBHIBGBHGMHP:K=L
LB@GB?B:GMBLLNLI:KMBNE:KERBGMANKKGMPHKE= :PHKE=MA:MBL;BG@=LKB;=:L:PHKE=H?
F:LLHFFNGB:MBHG

/AKBL:;H=RH?EBMK:MNKMA:MLNIIHKMLMAARIHMALBLMA:MGPLF=B:BG?ENGL
IN;EB:MMBMN=L:G=KIKLGMLBLLNL?KHFMALB=HKMAIKLIMBOLBM?:OHNKL /ABL;H=RH?
EBMK:MNKFIA:LBSLMA:MMABG?ENGH?MAF=B:HFL?KHFMAGMK:EBMRH?B=HEH@RBG
OKRMABG@MARKIHKMHKIKH=NL5BSD :G=(:=HG:E= NMHMAGMK:EBMR
:G= BG?ENG H? B=HEH@R BG F=B: =BLHNKL MA F=B: A:O ;HF MA ?HNL H? F:GR
IK:MBMBHGKLBGMA?BE=H?E:G@N:@:G=KIKLGM:MBHGHKPA:MBLDGHPG:LF=B:LMN=BLEE
:KKMM
/AHN@A E:G@N:@ BL GHMMAHGER F:GLMAKHN@APABA ANF:G ;BG@L BGMK:MBGMA
PHKE=H?F=B: BMBLMAF:BG?HNLH?F=B::G==BLHNKLLMN=BL /ABLHNE=;=NMHMPH
F:BGK:LHGL1:GBCD A /A?BKLMK:LHGBL=NMHMA?NGMBHGH?MAF=B:PABABL
F:BGER B=HEH@B:E NM IK:MBMBHGKL BG MA ?BE= FIA:LBS MA:M :GR :MMFIM MH KH@GBS
B=HEH@R PBEE ; :;HKM= B? E:G@N:@ BL G@EM= HK=BG@ MH !:BKEHN@A I
E:G@N:@BLMAAHFH?:EEB=HEH@R :G=AGA@BOLBM:KNB:E:G:ERMB:EKHEBGB=GMB?RBG@
:G=:G:ERSBG@B=HEH@BL
/ALHG=K:LHGBLMA:MF=B::G=E:G@N:@:K;HMALRLMFLH?KIKLGM:MBHGPABA
BG HK=BG:KR IK:MB :G= NL =H GHM IKLGM K:E EB? ;NMMAR K KIKLGM BM 1:G BCD
I $GMABLIKLIMBO E:G@N:@BLGHMLG:L:;LMK:M@K:FF:MB:E:M@HKBL:LBMBLOBP=
PBMABG MK:=BMBHG:E EBG@NBLMBL $GLM:= BM BL OBP= :L : F=BNF MA:M BL BFIK@G:M= PBMA
B=HEH@R .BFBE:KER EE:KKMM :G=F:GRHMAKEBG@NBLMLEBD!:BKEHN@A L
E:G@N:@ :L : IHEBMB:E MHHE PBMA : IHMGMB:E MHHGOR FLL:@L =IBM BF:@L :G= F=B:M
HGIMLMHK?EM:G=MAGBG?ENGMAQIKLLBHG:G=?HKF:MBHGH?LHB:EEB? NEMNK :G=
IHEBMBL
/H1:GBCD I ? MALHB:EKIKH=NMBHGIKHLLH?MAF=B:?NGMBHGL;HMA
B=HEH@B:EER:G=IHEBMB:EER !KHF:GB=HEH@B:EIHBGMH?OBP MAF=B:HGMBGN:EERF:G:@
=:M:IKH=N=BGLHB:EEB?BGHK=KMH;BGM@K:M=BGMH:HGLBLMGMB=HEH@B:ELRLMF /A:MBL
MA F=B: AEI MH BG?ENG :G= LA:I MA B=HEH@B:E LMKNMNK H? MA LHBMR +HEBMB:EER
LI:DBG@ MAF=B:F:BGM:BGLGLH?MAPHKE=?HKMAF=B: IKH=NMHGLNFKL #DIE7H7I
?:;EBE=?;I7H;J?;:?DJE7D:7H?I;EKJEIE9?7B7D:C7J;H?7BFH79J?9;I7D:=?L;;NFH;II?ED7D:
7HJ?9KB7J?ED JE J;C J; C;:?7 ?D;L?J78BO 7L; 7 FEB?J?97B ;;9J ED IE9?7B H;FHE:K9J?ED
#:K=F:G I HFBG:GM F=B: =BLHNKLL MAG :K LN;CM MH MA LMKN@@E HOK
KIKLGM:MBHG :G= MA HNKL H? MABL LMKN@@E (HK LIB?B:EER J; C;:?7 7;9J 7D: 7H;
7;9J;:8OFEM;HH;B7J?EDIM?J?DJ;IE9?7BIOIJ;C M?9C;7DIJ7JC;:?7:?I9EKHI;IFHEL?:;
;HJ?B;=HEKD:IEH7D?:;EBE=?97BBOEH?;DJ;::?I9EKHI;7D7BOI?II

380 645/,89/)22)+.,3+)
NKBG@ MA E:LM MAK =:=L I:KMBNE:KER :?MK MA K:; $LK:EB HG?EBM MA F=B: A:O
PBMGLL= : =K:F:MB:EER LQFUHDVLQJ XVH DQG UHSHWLWLRQ RI WHUPV OLNH µ0XVOLPV¶ ¶,VO:P¶
¶,VODPLVWV¶ µPLJUDQWV¶ µMLKDGLVWV¶ µ0XKDPPDG¶ DQG µSROLWLFDO ,VODP¶ WR PHQWLRQ EXW D IHZ
.MN=BL HG $LE:F ±2LM KE:MBHGLHG?EBML =;:ML P:KL HK HMAKL K:A= MH MAHNL:G=L
$PRQJWKHVHDUHWKHRQHVZLWKWLWOHVRIµ2ULHQWDOLVP¶)URPMBEE MAK;HHDL:II:K=
WRLQIODPHWKHVHFRQIOLFWVDQGWKHVHDUH6DLG¶V )H?;DJ7B?IC 5XVKGLH¶V-7J7D?90;HI;I
DQG+XQWLQJWRQ¶V.;E:LAE?L?B?P7J?EDI .BFBE:KER BGMABLIKBH= MA
(B==E :LMA:=PBMGLL=MPH+:ELMBGB:G$GMB?:=:L NE?2:K$$K:J $K:G :G=NE?2:K$$
NP:BM BGO:LBHG 2BMABG MAK R:KL MPH OKR =K:F:MB OGML HNKK= E:=BG@ MH PA:M BL
DGHPG:L.;(;M1EHB:)H:;H :G=MAL:K.IMF;KMA DQG6DGGDP¶VUHPRYDOLQ
$K:J2:K /ALOGML:KMAF:BG MHFGMBHG;NM:?P E:OBG@MAPHKE=BGMHGP
A:G@L BG :EE =HF:BGL /AL A:G@L BG MNKG A:O K=KLL= MA PHKE= BG @GK:E :G= MA
(B==E :LM BGI:KMBNE:K /AL=KLLL:K:EP:RLK= /AREEHPHGL:K:@:BGLM$LE:F:G=

BML+KHIAM /ABLLMBHGQ:FBGLMAMGM:MBO:@G=::@:BGLM+KHIAM(NA:FF:=MABLBL=HG
;RHNMEBGBG@MAIK==;IJ;:;ENIKBGM B?IKLGMBG@BMBGMABLP:R :ME:LMMHMA;LMDGHPE=@H?
MAPKBMK MABLA:LGHM;GA:G=E=;?HK
-GMER MAK A:L ;G DQ LQFUHDVLQJ PHQWLRQLQJRIWHUPV OLNHµDJHQGD¶DQGµDJHQGD
VHWWLQJ¶ LQ PHGLD WR WKH H[WHQW WKDW DJHQGD LMMBG@ BL : GLL:KR IKKJNBLBM HG=BMBHG ?HK
IHEBMB:E:MHKL:G=MABK=BLBHG F:DBG@IKHLL +KBGG I LBFIER=LKB;LMABLBG
MA?HEEHPBG@P:R

.EI;MEM7DJJE97D=;7D;N?IJ?D=FEB?9O?HIJ7L;JE=;JJ7J?IIK;ED
J;7=;D:7 J7J?I 7JJH79JJ;7JJ;DJ?EDE:;9?I?ED C7A;HIJE?J EDL;HI;BO
JEI; ME7H;7FFO M?JJ; IJ7JKIGKE M?BB JHOJE A;;FJ;?IIK;EJ;
7=;D:7J7J?I FH;L;DJ:;9?I?ED C7A;HIHECJ7BA?D=78EKJ?J 8;97KI;DE
7=;D:77JJ;DJ?EDEH7D?IIK;?IJ;8;IJ=K7H7DJ;;J7JJ;IJ7JKIGKEM?BB8;
C7?DJ7?D;:

/ANL MA IHEBMB:E :@G=:L ?HKF :G= HGMGM :K AB@AER KHFFG== ?HK NG=KLM:G=BG@
IHEBRF:DBG@ $GMA0. MAABLMHKRH?:@G=: LMMBG@LMN=BL:G;MK:=;:DMHMA:KER
L PABEMA NKHI:GHGL:KFHKKGM ;NMJNBDERA:O;HF:GHNMLM:G=BG@I:KMH?
MAPAHEEBMK:MNK
/A 7=;D:7 I;JJ?D= FHE9;II BL :G HG@HBG@ HFIMBMBHG MH @:BG MA :MMGMBHG H? F=B:
QIKML:G=IKH?LLBHG:EL IHEBR :G=EBMLH?MAIN;EB @G=: LMMBG@H??KL7D;NFB7D7J?ED
EMO?DEHC7J?ED 78EKJ 9;HJ7?D?IIK;I 7D:DEJEJ;H?IIK;I ?I7L7?B78B;JE J;FK8B?9?D 7
:;CE9H79OEMFK8B?9EF?D?ED?II7F;:7D:MO9;HJ7?D?IIK;I7H;7::H;II;:JHEK=FEB?9O
79J?EDI M?B; EJ;H ?IIK;I 7H; DEJ:KBG@ -H@KL I /ANL :@G=: LMMBG@ BL MA
LMN=RH?MK:BG@LHB:EA:G@:G=HKLM:;BEBMR
/A :@G=: LMMBG@ :IIKH:A LDL MH KD9EL;H BED= J;HC ± DEJ IEHJ J;HC ± C;:?7
;;9JI ':N@AR I HK=BG@ MH :KBG@ -H@KL I ?? :@G=: LMMBG@
MAHKR A:L OHEO= ?KHF : EHG@K MAHKMB:E MK:=BMBHG HGKG= PBMA AHP IN;EB HIBGBHG BL
LA:I=;RF=B:KIKLGM:MBHGLH?MAPHKE=HNMLB= %HNKG:EBLMLBGI:KMBNE:KBG?ENGIN;EB
HIBGBHG :HK=BG@ MH MA L:EBG MAR @BO MH KM:BG GPL BMFL L :KKHEE ; I
)PLI:IK LMHKBL :L :G Q:FIE BM= ;R :KBG@ -H@KL :K LEM= :G= MAG
HK=K=BGMKFLH?KM:BG GPL O:ENL !HKBGLM:G MAFHLMGPLPHKMARLMHKBL:K@BOG
E:K@A:=EBGL:G=?KHGM I:@HOK:@ELLGPLPHKMARLMHKBL:KIE:=?NKMAK;:DBGMA
GPLI:IK:G=@BOGELLIKBGMLI: G:@G=: LMMBG@MAHKR7II;HJIJ7J7K:?;D9;I79GK?H;
J;I; I7B?;D9;I HEC J; D;MI C;:?7 ?D9EHFEH7J?D= I?C?B7H I;JI E M;?=JI ?DJE J;?H EMD
7=;D:7I I (HF;L :??BKFL MA:M MAK :K ?HNK KAMHKB:E NL :??MBG@ MA
:@G=: LMMBG@ IKHLL ;R =K:PBG@ :N=BG :MMGMBHG MH MA L:EBG H? I:KMBNE:K GPL
BMFLI

)UHTXHQFRIUHSHWLWLRQWKHµUROOLQJ¶QHZVVWRULVGHHPHGWREHVDOLHQW
/AIKHFBGGPBMAPABABMFL:K=BLIE:R=A:=EBGGPL ;R=?BGBMBHG BL:LLNF=
MHA:O@K:MKLB@GB?B:GMA:GLF:EEKGPLLMHKBL
/A=@KH?HG?EBMIKLGMBGMAGPLBMFIHEBMB:EL:G=:EL:KFHKGPLPHKMAR
MA:GIHEBMB:EHGLGLNL ?HKQ:FIE
/A ?K:FBG@ H? : GPL BMF ± BG PA:M HGMQM:G= PAG BM :II:KL LNFFK AHEB=:R
PDG=L:KH?MG:NMHM:ED:;HNMQLLBOMG:@OB=H@:FLHGLNFIMBHG ?HK
BGLM:G

/A;:LBHGENLBHG=K:PG;R(HF;L:G=HMAK:@G=: LMMBG@ MAHKBLMLBLMA:M:GR@BOG
F=B::@G=:PBEE@BOKBLMH:IN;EB:@G=:HOKMAHNKLH?MBF $GMABLKLIM ':N@AR
I ? LM:ML MA:M MA ?BG=BG@L H? FIBKB:E KL:KA ?HK :LLLLBG@ :G :@G=: LMMBG@
:IIKH:AEKD:J7JEKHCEDJIM7IJ;EFJ?CKCIF7DEJ?C;8;JM;;DFH;I;DJ7J?EDE7C;:?7
7=;D:77D:7I7L?D=?BJ;H;:79HEIIJEJ;FK8B?9H;7BC GHMAK?BG=BG@?KHFMA:@G=:
LMMBG@:IIKH:AP:LJ;I7B?;D9;EC;:?7?C7=;IEL;H?IIK;IEHH;7:;HI ?DH;IFEDI;JEJ;
;:?JEH?7B:;9?I?EDIED;MIF7F;H@EKHD7B?IJIJEEH;=HEKD:FEJE=H7FO(HF;L I
@G=: LMMBG@LMN=BLH??K:LHEB=LM:QFHWRVWXGWKHµVHFRQGIDFHRISRZHU¶ZKLOHJ;
?HIJ79;EFEM;H?IJ;FEM;HJE?DBK;D9;:;9?I?ED C7A?D=ED7=?L;D?IIK; I MABLBL
MA?HKFH?IHPKMA:MBL?HNL=HGBGMAKL:KAH?=BLBHG F:DBG@ /ALHG=?:BLMA
IHPKMHF:BGM:BGBLLNLH??MA:@G=: $GGHKF:ELBMN:MBHGL MABLPBEE;G@EM=BGLMN=BLH?
MAIKHLLLH?=BLBHG F:DBG@ ;NMBM:G;LMN=B=;R:G:ERLBG@MA:@G=: LMMBG@IKHLLL
NG=KERBG@ MA IHEBMB:E :@QGD DV D ZKROH DVWHOOV¶ S HGMFIHK:KR =?BGBMBHG H?
µSRZHU¶LVYHUXVHIXOIRUWKHFXUUHQWGLVFXVVLRQ

*EM;H ?I J; H;B7J?ED7B 97F79?JO J7J ;D78B;I 7 IE9?7B 79JEH JE ?DBK;D9;
7IOCC;JH?97BBOJ;:;9?I?EDIEEJ;HIE9?7B79JEHI ?DM7OIJ7J7LEHJ;
HPSRZHUHGDFWRU¶VZLOO?DJ;H;IJI 7D:L7BK;I *EM;H?I;N;H9?I;:8OC;7DI
E9E;H9?EDEHJ;FEII?8?B?JOE?J 7D: EH8OJ;9EDIJHK9J?EDEC;7D?D=
ED J; 87I?I E J; :?I9EKHI;I JHEK= M?9 IE9?7B 79JEHI =K?:; J;?H
79J?ED *EM;HH;B7J?EDI?FI7H;H7C;:8O:EC?D7J?ED M?9?IJ;FEM;H
J7J?I;C8;::;:?DJ;?DIJ?JKJ?EDIEIE9?;JO

G=MABL@BOLBGMNKGMACNLMB?B:MBHG?HKMHI =HPG:@G=:BGLM:EE:MBHG LBGBMBL:F:MMKH?
GHJUHHQRWµRQ¶RUµRII¶DJHQGD7KHUHIRUHCK9EJ;FEB?J?97BIJHK==B;7HEKD:7=;D:7 I;JJ?D=
?I9ED9;HD;:M?JCEL?D=?IIK;I?=;HKFJ;7=;D:7EHFKI?D=J;C:EMD/:EE;K@ I

G :@G=: :L =?BG= ;R :BG@ -H@KL I BL 7 I;J E ?IIK;I J7J 7H;
9ECCKD?97J;:?D7?;H7H9OE?CFEHJ7D9;7J7FE?DJ?DJ?C; /AR?NKMAKHG?BKFMA:MMA
:@G=: BL =?BG= :HK=BG@ MH MA BLLN Q:FBG= !HK Q:FIE BG IHEBMB:E MKFL :@G=:
=?BG=:L7=;D;H7BI;JEFEB?J?97B9EDJHEL;HI?;IJ7JM?BB8;L?;M;:7J7DOFE?DJ?DJ?C;7I
7BB?D= M?J?D J; H7D=; E B;=?J?C7J; 9ED9;HDI C;H?J?D= J; 7JJ;DJ?ED E J; FEB?JO B;B=
$QRWKHUSRLQWUDLVHGLQWKHLUILUVWGHILQLWLRQLVµDWDSRLQWLQWLPH¶7KHA:O:IM=MAGHMBHG
H?LMMBG@:G:@G=::M:I:KMBNE:KMBF ;NMA:OKMNKG=MHLM:ME:KERMA:M7=;D:7I7H;J;
H;IKBJE7:OD7C?9?DJ;HFB7O I:?;H;DJ?IIK;IH?I;7D:7BB?D?CFEHJ7D9;EL;HJ?C; 7=;D:7I
FHEL?:;ID7FIEJIEJ?IBK?:?JOI
.BFBE:KER :G:@G=:BL=?BG=:LJ;I;JE?IIK;IJ7JH;9;?L;I;H?EKI9EDI?:;H7J?ED?D
7FEB?J?97BIOIJ;C+KBGG I #K µVHULRXVFRQVLGHUDWLRQ¶LVXVHGWRPHDQDWWHQWLRQ
:G= HGLJNGMER :@G=:L :K MA :MMGMBHG @BOG MH I:KMBNE:K BLLNL I?D9; F;EFB; 97DDEJ
7JJ;D:JE7D?D?D?J;DKC8;HEJ?D=I:K;JEJ?C;IF7D7D:;EHJIEH;D;H=O7D:;NF;HJ?I;B?C?JI
B;B= BG@=HG I ?? LNIIHKML LNA :K@NFGM :??BKFBG@ MA:M MA L:F BL MKN ?HK
I:KEB:FGML HK @HOKGFGM ;NK:NK:BL :G= HMAK BGLMBMNMBHGL OG B? LNA BGLMBMNMBHGL :G
F:G:@ HK IKHLL E:K@ER FHK BLLNL MA:G :GR LBG@E BG=BOB=N:E HNE= MAR LMBEE GHNGMK
EBFBML BG MBF :G= F:GIHPK LB=L J; CEIJ ?CFEHJ7DJ ?IIK;I ?D 7DO FEB?J?97B ?DIJ?JKJ?ED
JOF?97BBO7L;JE=EJHEK=7B?C?J;:DKC8;HEF;HIEDIJ;H;EH; F7HB?7C;DJ7HO9ECC?JJ;;I
7H;7L7?B78B;I
/AL:;HO FGMBHG==?BGBMBHGLA:O:GMK:EHGIMBGHFFHGQDPHOµDQLVVXH¶
RUµLVVXHV¶REE (OGHU FLWHGLQ'H:KBG@-H@KL I =?BGµ:GBLLN¶:L7

9EDB?9J8;JM;;DJMEEHCEH;?:;DJ??78B;=HEKFIEL;HFHE9;:KH7BEHIK8IJ7DJ?L;C7JJ;HIH;B7J?D=
JE J; :?IJH?8KJ?ED E FEI?J?EDI EH H;IEKH9;I I /A:M BL :G BLLN BL PA:MOK BL BG
HGMGMBHG /ABLMPH LB==G:MNKH?:GBLLNBLLLGMB:EBGK:EBSBG@AHP:G=PAR:GBLLNAHE=L
NI :G :@G=: /A IHMGMB:EER HG?EBMBG@ G:MNK H? :G BLLN F:DL BM GPLPHKMAR :L
FHEFED;DJI 7D: EFFED;DJI E J; ?IIK; 87JJB; ?J EKJ ?D J; I7H;: FK8B?9 7H;D7 M?9 ?D
CE:;HDIE9?;JO ?IJ;C7IIC;:?7:KBG@-H@KL I

/AKMRILH?:@G=::K:EP:RL?HNG=BGMAEBMK:MNK G:FERµSROLWLFDO¶RUµIRUPDO¶
DJHQGDµSXEOLF¶RUµVVWHPDWLF¶DJHQGDDQGµPHGLD¶DJHQGD +KBGG I 7KHµSROLWLFDO¶
:@G=:BLMA:MLMH?BLLNLMA:M:KKBMB:EERHGLB=K=;RIHEBMB:E=BLBHG F:DKL /ANL MA
µSXEOLF¶ DJHQGD LV WKDW VHW RI LVVXHV WKDW DUH FULWLFDOO FRQVLGHUHG E µWKH SXEOLF¶ DV LQ WKH
UHVHDUFK RQ SXEOLF RSLQLRQ SROOV 7KH WKLUG WSH WKH µPHGLD DJHQGD¶ UHIHUV WR WKRVH LVVXHV
HOK=BGMAF=B: :AH?MALMRILH?:@G=:LA:L;GMAHGKGH?QMGLBOLMN=BL
ELH ;:NLMARG=GHMHFIEMERHOKE:I :GBFIHKM:GMMAHKMB:EHGKGBLAHP:G=
PAK MAL MRIL H? :@G=: BG?ENG :A HMAK GHMAK =BLMBGMBHG :G ; F:= ;MPG
DJHQGDVWKDWDUHµFORVHU¶WRRUPRUHµUHPRWH¶IURPDFWXDO=BLBHG F:DBG@ BG@=HG I
A:LB=GMB?B=DEURDGHUµJRYHUQPHQWDODJHQGD¶RILVVXHVWKDWDUHGLVFXVVHGESROLFPDNHUV
LQ DJLYHQSHULRG RI WLPHIURPDQDUURZHUµGHFLVLRQ DJHQGD¶RI LVVXHVWKDWDUHXSIRUDFWLYH
:;9?I?ED C7A?D= /ABL=BLMBGMBHGBLKEO:GM ;:NLMAIKH=NKLMA:ME:=BLLNLHKKBLL
HGMHMA@HOKGFGM:E:@G=::K=B??KGM?KHFMAHLMA:ME:=MAFHGMHMA=BLBHG:@G=:

)RUUHDOL]LQJWKHVHWSHVRIDJHQGDVWKHSULQFLSDOVWHSKHUHLVWRLGHQWLIµLVVXHV¶ZLWK
µFRQIOLFW¶ LVVXHV DUH LGHQWLILHG RIWHQ LQ WHUPV RIWRSLFV OLNH UDFLVP µFULPH¶ GLVFULPLQDWLRQ
µXQHPSORPHQW¶DQGUHFHQWOµWHUURULVP¶)ROORZLQJREE (OGHU¶V LGHQWLILFDWLRQRIDQ
BLLN AHPOK ?KHF:IHEBMB:EIHBGMH?OBP MALMHIBLHGER;HFHG?EBMLPAGIHEBMB:E
:MHKL :KH? =B??KGMHKBGM:MBHGL HK B=:L :;HNM PA:M LAHNE= ; =HG :;HNM MAL HG?EBML
/AK?HK MAB=GMB?B:MBHGH?:GBLLNBGOHEOLMA=?BGBMBHGH?=BFGLBHGLPAKHG?EBML
;MPGIHEBMB:E:MHKLBL:KQBLMGM /ANL7=;D:7 I;JJ?D=C7O9ED9;HD8EJJ;?:;DJ??97J?ED
E9EDB?9JIEL;HD;MJEF?9I 7D:J;9H;7J?EDED;M9EDB?9JIEL;HEB:JEF?9I+KBGG
I BOGMAGMK:EBMRH?BLLNLBGMA?HKF:MBHGH?:@G=:L :GBFIHKM:GMJNLMBHGBL?KHF
PAKMALBLLNLHF =HIMBG@MAIKHIHL:EF:=;R(:GL;:A1:LJNS I ??
BM=BG+KBGGI MABGMKG:MBHG:EGOBKHGFGM:G=MALHB:E :MHKLMAFLEOL:G;
=BLKG=:LMAMPHLHNKLH?BLLNLHGBGMKG:MBHG:E:@G=:L /ABGMKG:MBHG:EGOBKHGFGM
HKMA QMKG:E LHNK 9H;7J;I 7=;D:7 ?IIK;I M;D ?DJ;HD7J?ED7B 79JEHI 7H; 9EDHEDJ;: M?J
JH;7JIHKKBLL E997I?ED;:8O79JEHIDEJ:?H;9JBO7IIE9?7J;: M?JJ;8;7L?EKHE79JEHI
B;B=
LBGMKG:ELHNKLH?:@G=:BLLNL :MHKL NLN:EERDGHPG:LEBM F:RBGBMB:M:G=E:=
MAFINKIHL?NEER;R9H;7J?D=7D;MIJ7A; H;L?L?D=7DEB:ED; EH7BJ;H?D=J;L7BK;I7I9H?8;:
JE7D;N?IJ?D=IJ7A;(:GL;:A1:LJNS I
HK=BG@MH+=KH: I MA
MKFEBMBLNG=KLMHH=MHK?KAKMH
«C;C8;HIEJ;KFF;HIE9?7B9B7II;I ME;D@EO7FH?L?B;=;:IJ7JKI?D
FEM;H H;B7J?EDI #D F7HJ?9KB7H ?J H;;HI JE JEI; ME EB: ?D7D9?7B
;9EDEC?9FEM;H FEB?J?97B IJ7J;FEM;H 7D:C?B?J7HOFEM;H 7BJEK=?J?I
DEJ B?C?J;: ;N9BKI?L;BO JE J;I; JH;; I;9JEHI .?I C?DEH?JO 9EDJHEBI J;
C;7DI E FHE:K9J?ED 7D: J; ?D7D9?7B I;9JEH EB:I 7 :?IFHEFEHJ?ED7J;
I7H;EJ;7L7?B78B;97F?J7BF7HJ?9?F7J;I?DFEB?J?97B7D:;9EDEC?9FB7DI
=K?:;IJ;79J?EDIEJ;IJ7J;F7HJ?9?F7J;I?DFEM;HKB?DIJ?JKJ?EDIIK97I
J;C;:?7 KD?L;HI?J?;I 7D:9KBJKH7B?DIJ?JKJ?EDI;J9 #DIEHJ J;O7H;J;

?D:?L?:K7BIMEE99KFOFH?L?B;=;:IJH7J;=?9FEI?J?EDIJ7J7EH:J;CJ;
B7H=;IJFHEFEHJ?EDE:;9?I?ED C7A?D=FEM;H

/ABL EHG@ TXRWDWLRQ LQGLFDWHVHYLGHQWOWKDW3HGUR¶VGHILQLWLRQ LV EDVHG RQ 0DU[LDQWKHRURI
IHPK !:K@:BGL I =LKB;LMABL(:KQB:GMAHKR:??BKFBG@MA:MJ;9B7IIM?97I
J;C;7DIEC7J;H?7BFHE:K9J?ED7J?JI:?IFEI7B 7I9EDJHEB7JJ;I7C;J?C;EL;HJ;C;7DIE
C;DJ7BFHE:K9J?ED IEJ7JJ;H;8O =;D;H7BBOIF;7A?D= J;?:;7IEJEI;MEB79AJ;C;7DIE
C;DJ7BFHE:K9J?ED7H;IK8@;9JJE?J +HUHWKHWHUPµWKHFODVV¶LVXVHGWRPHDQµWKHHOLWH¶ZKLFK
:HK=BG@MH(:KQ A:LMAIHPKH?FGM:EHGMKHE :IKBOBE@GHMFGMBHG=EBMK:KR;R+=KH
/A:@G=:MH;LN@@LM=;EHP BL ;EBO= ;RMA PKBMKMHHGM:BGMAMAKMRILH?
:@G=: FGMBHG= :;HO G:FER MA IHEBMB:E IN;EB :G= F=B: :@G=:L NM MA P:R H?
IKLGMBG@ MABL :@G=: PBEE ; =B??KGM ?KHF MAHL :O:BE:;E BG MA EBMK:MNK OG MAK BL
LHFAHP:FBLE:=BG@HGIMBHGMA:MBLLNLEBD/AKNL:=:G=/A$K:J2:K:G;
K:EBS=;R+ :G=GHM;R:@G=: *GMAHGMK:KR Q:FBGBG@LNABLLNLF:RKO:EMA:MMAK
:K?NKMAK?:MHKLPABAG=MH;LM:M= B?:;MMKNG=KLM:G=BG@BLKJNBK= /AK?HK MA
LN@@LM=:@G=:BGEN=L?:MHKLEBDIKH=NKL B=HEH@R MHHEL I:K:=B@F M HGLJNGMER
µ3$)UDPHV¶EHORZLVXVHGWRPHDQµ$JHQGD¶LQWKHOLWK:MNKQ:FBG=:;HO EMMBG@MAMKF
µ$JHQGD¶XVHGWRLQFOXGHµ3$)UDPHV¶DQGH[WUDILYHIDFWRUV7KXVWKHVXJJHVWHGHOHPHQWVRI
+(:KMA?HEEHPBG@LIIG=BQ?HKMAHKINLH?MALN@@LM=MKFEBDGMB +KHIAM
@G=:
+!K:FL
.MMBG@
/HHEL
+:KMBBI:GML
.HB:E$=HEH@R
/:K@ML

645).)3+)
2A:MBLBFIHKM:GMBGMABLLMBHGBLMHNG=KLM:G=MA:M:GRB=HEH@RMH;?NE?BEE=G=L+ GR
+ WREHIXOILOOHGQHHGVWRWKHUHVHDUFKHU¶VXQGHUVWDQGLQJDVHWRISDUWLFXODUIDFWRUVYDULD;EL
HK:GRMKFMA:MF:R;AHLG /HIKLGM:L:MBL?:MHKR+ MKFLEBDµ,VODP¶µ0XVOLPV¶
µMA4XUDQ¶DQGµ3URSKHW0XKDPPDG¶DUHUHJDUGHGZLWKLQRQHFRQFHUQ7KDWLVWRVDWKDWWKH
?HEEHPBG@=BLNLLBHGPBEEHGLB=KMAL?HNK=HF:BGLPBMABGHGNF;KEE: G:FERGMB +KHIAM
+
(:GR =?BGBMBHGL H? + :K :O:BE:;E BG MA EBMK:MNK H? F=B: LMN=BL :G= MAL
=?BGBMBHGL:KIHKMK:R=PBMAMAHEHNKLH?MA=BLBIEBGLMAR :KKE:M=MH FHG@MAL
=BLBIEBGL:KIABEHLHIAR LHBHEH@R ILRAHEH@R IHEBMBL BGMKG:MBHG:EKE:MBHGL :G=F=B: MH
PHQWLRQEXWDIHZ7KLVµPXOWLSOLFLWRILQWHUHVW¶DV:LOOFR[ S :EELBM A:LE=MHMA
IHLLB;BEBMR H? IKLGMBG@ : @GK:E =?BGBMBHG H? + H? HNKL H? NGBOKL:E NL:@ /ANL :L
2BEHQ :??BKFL MAK :K +L K:G@BG@ ?KHF ;BG@ BG=BOB=N:E MH : =FHK:MB HK MHM:EBM:KB:G
K@BFLHF:KIHLBMBO:G=HMAKL:KG@:MBO:G=LHF:KF:LNK:;E:G=HMAKL:KGHM
7KHDFWXDOXVHRIWKHWHUPµ3URSDJDQGD¶VWDUWVZLWKWKHWZHQWLHWKFGMNKRPAK:KF=
HG?EBML:G=HEHGBS:MBHGLMK:M@R:II:K=.NM:K I /AK?HK MANLH?MABLMKF
P:L:LLHB:M=PBMA2HKE=2:KL$:G=$$ EB;K:MBHGFHOFGML HBEBG=NLMKBL HGHFBF:KDM
:G=BGMEEMN:EHKBGM:MBHGL
:L=HGK:R(:KMBG .NM:K I LM:MLMA:M+BL:M@HKBS=BGMAK
HEHNKLBGMA0.ILRAHEH@B:EF:GN:EL ;E:D PABM:G=@KR+
x $G;E:D+ MALHNKH?MABG?HKF:MBHGBLGHMDGHPGHKKO:E=

x $GPABM+ MALHNKH?BG?HKF:MBHGBL DGHPG :G=MABG?HKF:MBHGIKHOB==
F:R;;HGLB=K=EHLMHMAK:ELBMN:MBHG
x KR+BL::M@HKRNG=KPABABG?HKF:MBHGBL?:ELER:MMKB;NM=HKMAK:K
=HN;ML:;HNMMALHNK *G:=:RMH=:R;:LBL BMBL@KR+PABAIHIEE:K@ER
=:EPBMA LHFBG?HKF:MBHGIKHOB==BLHKKM PAK:LLHFBLGHM

EEMAL:K:HFI:GB=;RMABGK:LBG@KHEH?F=B: :G=/AHE=2:K:G=*KBGM:EBLF
:K QEEGM Q:FIEL /A E:LM MAK =:=L LIB:EER MA OGML BG MA (B==E :LM E=
LAHE:KLBGIHEBMBL:G=F=B:MHPHKDA:K=?HK:LNBM:;E=?BGBMBHGH?+
EENE I =?BGL+:L7I;JEC;JE:I;CFBEO;:8O7DEH=7D?P;:=HEKFJ7J
M7DJIJE 8H?D= 78EKJ J;79J?L;EHF7II?L;F7HJ?9?F7J?ED ?D ?JI79J?EDIEC7IIE?D:?L?:K7BI
FIO9EBE=?97BBO KD??;: JHEK= FIO9EBE=?97B C7D?FKB7J?EDI 7D: ?D9EHFEH7J;: ?D 7D
EH=7D?P7J?ED /ABL =?BGBMBHG BGEN=L MA ;:LB :G= GLL:KR HFIHGGML H? :GR +
KIKLGM=;R
x LMH?FMAH=L:LIKH=NKHKI:K:=B@F
x GHK@:GBS=@KHNI:LI:KMBBI:GML
x MBO HK I:LLBO I:KMBBI:MBHG MH K?K MH MA MPH LB=L¶ K?EMBHGL 2BEEHQ
VWDWHGWKDWµDFWLYH¶DQGµSDVVLYH¶DUHXVHGWRUHIOHFWWKHSXEOLFRSLQLRQV
PAMAKLNIIHKMKLHKGHM
x /AOHENMBHGH?;HMAMAHN@AM:G=ABLMHKR :LGLL:KRHGLMBMNGML?HK:;MMK
NG=KLM:G=BG@H?:+LBMN:MBHGB;B=
(:DGSB I IKLGMLMA?HEEHPBG@=?BGBMBHG
*HEF7=7D:797D8;:;?D;:7IJ;JH7DIC?II?ED E?:;7I7D:L7BK;IHEC
ED;F;HIED EH=HEKFEF;HIEDI JE7DEJ;H M?JJ;IF;9??9?DJ;DJ?EDE
LQIOXHQFLQJWKHUHFLSLHQWV¶DWWLWXGHVLQ VXFKDZDWKDWWKHLQWHUHVWVRILWV
7KJEHIM?BB8;;D7D9;: BJEK=?JC7O8;L;?B;: I;;A?D=JE?DBK;D9;
JEK=JI 8;B?;I 7D: 79J?EDI 8O IK==;IJ?EDI ?J CKIJ 8; 9EDI9?EKI 7D:
:;B?8;H7J;
/ABL=?BGBMBHG BLLHFAHPLBFBE:KMHMAHG FGMBHG= :;HO ;NMF:GR=B??KGL:G ;
LM:M=
x +HGMGMB=:LHKO:ENL BGHGMK:LMMH:LMH?FMAH=L
x /A IKHI:@:G=BLM BL :G BG=BOB=N:E IKLHG HK : @KHNI H? IKLHGL BG HGMK:LM MH :G
HK@:GBS=@KHNI
x +HNE=;OBE=
x +LRAHEH@B:EHKBGM:MBHGHKBG?ENGBLQBLMGMBG;HMA=?BGBMBHGL :G=
x +BLHGLBHNL:G==EB;K:M
#KF:G AHFLDR I =?BG + :L C7DK79JKH?D= 9EDI;DJ OG BM F:R ; MA
LF:EELM =?BGBMBHG HG F:R QIM ;NM BM :KKBL : EHM H? =M:BEL LIB:EER MA HGGHM:MBHGL
EHKLQGWKHFRPELQHGWZRZRUGVDUHPDQ7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWRQH LV+HUPDQ KRPVN¶V
+KHI:@:G=:(H=EAG?HKMA+( :FH=E ?HKMAKHEH? F=B: BGIHEBMB:E :G=HGHFB
;NLBGLL $MPBEE;Q:PLQHGEHORZ6LPLODUWR0DFNHQ]LH¶VGHILQLWLRQWKHIRXUWKGHILQLWLRGBL
-RZHWW 2¶'RQQHOO¶V S * ?I J; :;B?8;H7J; 7D: IOIJ;C7J?9 7JJ;CFJ JE I7F;
F;H9;FJ?EDI C7D?FKB7J;9E=D?J?EDI 7D::?H;9J8;7L?EKHJE79?;L;7H;IFEDI;J7JKHJ;HIJ;
:;I?H;: ?DJ;DJ E J; FHEF7=7D:?IJ /A ?B?MA :G= E:LM =?BGBMBHG MH ; FGMBHG= AK BL
:LOOFR[¶V S *HEF7=7D:7 ?I J; 9EDI9?EKI EH KD9EDI9?EKI 7JJ;CFJ 8O J;
FHEF7=7D:?IJJE7:L7D9;J;?H97KI;JHEK=J;C7D?FKB7J?EDEJ;EF?D?ED F;H9;FJ?ED7D:
8;7L?EKHE7J7H=;J;:=HEKF $GKE:MBHGMHMABL MA?HEEHPBG@IHBGML:G;K@BLMK=

x +BLE:LLB?B=BGMHHGLBHNL:G=NGHGLBHNL
x /A IKHI:@:G=BLM :=O:GL MA IKIMBHG :G= ;A:OBHNK H? : M:K@M= @KHNI MAKHN@A
IKLN:LBHG
x 'BD#UPDQ KRPVN¶V:LOOFR[¶VDQG-RZHWW 2 'RQQHOO VGHILQLWLRQVDUHRIEURDG
HKBGM:MBHG B MARHNE=;:IIEB=MH:K:LHMAKMA:GF=B:
x 7KH ZRUGVµ DGYDQFH ¶µ FDXVH¶ µ;A:OBHNK¶ DQG µWDUJHWHG¶ LQGLFDWH WKDW :LOOFR[¶V 3$
HGLBHNL G:MNK HOKPB@KV WKH RWKHU 7KLV LV IXUWKHU FRQVROLGDWHG E :LOOFR[¶V
FRQILUPDWLRQRQXVLQJµEHKDYLRXU¶GHOLEHUDWHOIRUVLJQLILQJDUDQJHRIDFWLRQV5J6;
J7H=;J;: =HEKF C7O ?D:;;: J7A; 7 FEI?J?L; 79J?ED EH GK?;JBO 79GK?;I9; 7D: E;H DE
H;I?IJ7D9;JEJ;?DEHC7J?EDM?JM?9J;O7H;9EDHEDJ;:

/H LNF NI MAK :K F:GR IHBGML MA:M LAHNE= ; QBLMGM B? HG G=L MH =LKB; I:KMBNE:K
OGML:L+ :G=MAL:K
¾ +BLHGLBHNL
¾ /AIKHI:@:G=BLMA:L:=LBK= =EB;K:M LRLMF:MBBGMGMBHG
¾ /ABLBGMGMBHG:G;IKLGM=:LB=:L MAHN@AML HIBGBHGL O:ENL FMAH=L M
¾ +:G;OBE=
¾ /A M:K@M= IKLHG HK IKLHGL HK @KHNI :G ; BG?ENG= G@:MBOER /A G@:MBO
BG?ENG:G;=K:F:MBMHMAQMGMMA:MMA@KHNIM:DLGHK:MBHG
¾ /AHMAKI:KMBBI:GMLH?+:G;H?=B??KGMKHEL H?HNKL MABLBLKE:M=MHMABK
BGMKLML:G=PBEEL
¾ /AF:GL;RPABA:+:G;BFIEFGM=:G;F=B: HKHMAKL
¾ /ABLIKHLLH?+:G;=HGMAKHN@AF:GBINE:MBG@:I:KMBNE:KFH=E

$GMALHG=A:IMKH?MABK;HHD #KF:GAHFLDRA:LGHMHGERIKLGM=:NGBJN
+(=DBGL I ;NMA:O:ELH:IIEB=BMMH:LLHNMLB=0.F=B:EBD/ABK=2HKE=
EMBHGL 1BMG:F ':HL :F;H=B: MA NE@:KB:GIEHMMHDBEEMA+HI M /ABKFH=E
A:L;KHN@AM:=K:F:MBA:G@BGMAMAHKRH?+:G=F=B:E:AG I ?? LIB:EER
IE9?7B ?D;GK7B?J?;I M?J?D J; 8HE7:;H IE9?;JO 7D: IE9?7B MEHB: 7H; ?=B?=J;: (NEEG
E:AG /ABL;HHDP:LKBO=;HMAG@:MBOER:G=IHLBMBOER )@:MBOK:MBHGLA:=;G
HGGMK:M= HG BML :IIEB:;BEBMR MH KM:BG :LL
#KF:G AHFLDR IN;EBLA= MA LHG=
=BMBHG H? MABK ;HHD MH BGEN= ?NKMAK MK:MFGML :G= Q:FIEL ?KHF MA HNGMKBL
FGMBHG=:;HOHGMAHGA:G= :G=MHBGEN==:M:?KHF$K:J /NKDR HLHOH @EH;:EBS:MBHG
:G= BGMKGM /A IHLBMBO K:MBHGL :K KIKLGM= ;R :IIERBG@ MABL FH=E ;R HMAKL NG=K
FH=B?B:MBHGL(NEEG
DQGFRQVHTXHQWOWKHODVWWZRGHFDGHVDUHGHVFULEHGDVµDJHRI
3$¶ 3UDWNDQLV $UHGLHG I
+HUPDQ KRPVN¶V 30LVEDVHGRQWZRUROHVIRUPHGLD
.;C7IIC;:?7I;HL;7I7IOIJ;CEH9ECCKD?97J?D=C;II7=;I7D:IOC8EBI
JEJ;=;D;H7BFEFKB79;« DQG #J?IJ;?HKD9J?EDJE7CKI; ;DJ;HJ7?D 7D:
?DEHC 7D:JE?D9KB97J;?D:?L?:K7BI M?JJ;L7BK;I 8;B?;I 7D:9E:;IE
8;7L?EHJ7JM?BB?DJ;=H7J;J;C?DJEJ;?DIJ?JKJ?EDIJHK9JKH;IEJ;B7H=;
IE9?;JOI

/AK?HK #KF:GAHFLDRIKLGMMABK+(BGMABK'7DK79JKH?D=EDI;DJ.;*EB?J?97B
9EDECOEJ;'7II';:?7 PABABL9ED9;HD;:JE;NFBEH;J;?DJ;HFB7O8;JM;;D
FEM;H IE9?7BIJHK9JKH;7D:?:;EBE=O(NEEGE:AG I
HGLJNGMER ?NE?BEEBG@MABLKHEBG:@EH;H?HG?EBMH?BGMKLM:G=HGGMK:M=P:EMA
KJNBKL + !NKMAKFHK MABL FH=E DUJXHV WKDW EHFDXVH µWKRXJKW FRQWURO¶ ?I L?HJK7BBO

JH7DIF7H;DJ?D:;CE9H7J?9IE9?;J?;I J;*IOIJ;C?I79JK7BBOCEH;;;9J?L;7D:;?9?;DJJ7D?J
?I ?D JEJ7B?J7H?7D IJ7J;I E:AG I /A #KF:G AHFLDRL +( BL H? MAK
ARIHMALL I BO QQB
B /A?BKLMARIHMALBLBLMA:M M;H;J;H;?I;B?J;9EDI;DIKIJ;C;:?7 M?BBI;HL;;B?J;
?DJ;H;IJIKD9ECFHEC?I?D=BOI OB
BB /ALHG= ARIHMALBL BLMA:M M;H;J;C7II C;:?7 ?IKD:;H 9EHFEH7J;H7J;HJ7D
IJ7J;9EDJHEB C;:?79EL;H7=;M?BB8;I7F;:8OM7J?I ?D;;9J 7=K?:;:C7HA;JIOIJ;C
KD:;HF?DD;:8O?L;?BJ;HI J;EF;H7J?L;FH?D9?FB;IEJ;*'I OBB
BBB /A MABK= ARIHMALBL BL MA:M J; *' 7D: IJK:?;I E IK9 C;:?7 F;HEHC7D9; M?BB 8;
?=DEH;:7D:C7H=?D7B?P;:I Q
/HE:;HK:MMA?BKLMARIHMALBL #KF:GAHFLDRK?KMHMAKE:MBHGLABI;MPGLHBMR
IHEBMBL :G=F=B: LIB:EERB?MABGMEEMN:E:MFHLIAKBLM:DGBGMHHGLB=K:MBHG )HHG
:G=GRMAQBLMGH?FHKMA:GHGLHBHEH@B:E:G=IHEBMB:EHKBGM:MBHG?HNG=BGMAE:LM
GMNKR 2LMKGLHBMBLFHO=LN;LJNGMER?KHFGEB@AMGFGMMH(:KQBLFPABABLBGMNKG
VWLOOSUHVHQWLQWKHµIUHHPDUNHW¶SROLWLFV%HVLGHVOLEHUDOLVPQDWLRQDOLVPPXOWLFXOWXUDOLVPDQG
MAGBOBBGM@K:MBHGA:O:II:K=E:MK
(NEEG E:AG I ? LM:M MA:M PBMABG HGMFIHK:KR :IBM:EBLM EB;K:E
=FHK:MB LHBMBL MAKBMB:E(:KQBLF:G=MAEB;K:EIENK:EBLMOBP:KMAMPHHIIHL=
IKLIMBOLHGMAKHEH?MAF=B::G=MA=BLMKB;NMBHGH?IHPK /AEB;K:EIENK:EBLMOBP
LN@@LMLMA:MMAKQBLML:A:EMARF:KDMIE:H?B=:L HIBGBHGL IHEBRIKHIHL:EL PHKE=OBPL
M PABA:KKG=K= BGMNKG BGMHMA@GK:E IN;EBLAHBL /A FHLMHFFHGH?MAL
B=:LPBEE;LGBGMAIHEBBL:G=E:PL?HEEHP=;RIHEBMB:ELRLMFLF=B:AKHGLMBMNM:
µIRXUWKHVWDWH¶RUDVµZDWFKGRJ¶RQWKHSUDFWLFHRISRZHU7KHFULWLFDO0DU[LVPYLHZPLUURUVWKH
E:LL ;:L=G:MNKH?MAHLLHBMBL :G=MAG:M=E:PL:G=IHEBBL:KJEI;J7JI;HL;JE
8H?D= 78EKJ 7D: JE C7?DJ7?D HKB?D= 9B7II :EC?D7J?ED 7D: ;NFBE?J7J?ED I #KF:G
AHFLDR I ? ;EBOMA:MMAKBMB:E (:KQBLFHOKPB@ALMAEB;K:EIENK:EBLM :G=
HGLJNGMER BMBLIHLLB;EMHBG?KMA:MBMBGMNKG=HFBG:MLMAF=B: =DBGL I
LNIIHKMLMABLBG?KG LM:MBG@MA:MMA(:KQB:GMAHKRH?IHPK=HFBG:GBLLMBEEPHKDBG@ :G=
WKHUXOLQJPDWHULDOIRUFHRIVRFLHW«EHFRPHVWKHGRPLQDQWSROLWLFDODQGLGHRORJLFDOIRUFHLQ
IE9?;JOI $QGPHGLDZRUNDVµODSGRJ¶ILOOLQJXSWKHGHWHUPLQDQW3$
!HKMALHG=ARIHMALBL ?BO?BEMKL:KLM:M=#KF:GAHFLDR A
B /A ?BKLM?BEMKLMFL ?KHFMA ?:MMA:MMA F=B:LHPGKLABI BL EBFBM=MHMAHLPBMA
GHN@A:IBM:EMHBGOHEOBGMAF=B:BG=NLMKBL
BB /ALHG= ?BEMK BL:=OKMBLBG@ PAKGPLI:IKL:MMK:M :G= F:BGM:BG AB@ALA:KLH?
:=OKMBLBG@?HKHOKBG@MAHLMLH?IKH=NMBHG
BBB /AMABK=?BEMKBLKE:M=MHMALHNKBG@FA:GBLFH?F:LLF=B:GPL PABAAHE=L
:G=HGLHEB=:MLF=B:LKE:MBHGLABIPBMABG?ENGMB:ELHNKLH?BG?HKF:MBHG !HK;BG@
:;EMH:??HK=HLM HGHKKLIHG=GM:GPHKDBGMAKHK?HNKGPLI:IKL
BO 7KHIRXUWKILOWHULVµIODN¶M?9?I:;I9H?8;:7ID;=7J?L;H;IFEDI;IJE7C;:?7IJ7J;C;DJ
EH.0 H7:?EFHE=H7CI #KF:GAHFLDRLM:MMA:M?E:DF:RJ7A;J;EHCE
B;JJ;HI J;B;=H7CI FED;97BBI F;J?J?EDI B7M IK?JI IF;;9;I 7D:?BBI8;EH;ED=H;II
JH;7JI ;J9
O /A?B?MA:G=?BG:E?BEMKP:L:GMB HFFNGBLFBG=BMBHG=NMHMAHE=2:K :G=
QI:G==BG=BMBHGMHBGEN=MA2:KHG/KKHK #K BMBLIHLLB;EMHLM:MMA:MBL
MALM:G=:K=2LMKGGFR B BMBLLN;CMMH FH=B?B:MBHG :G=MH=:RMA2:KHG
/KKHKBLFHKBGENLBOMA:GMABK:KEBKGFR G:FER:GMB HFFNGBLF

L FGMBHG= ;R +=KH I MAL ?BEMKL 9EHH;IFED: JE J; ?DIJ?JKJ?ED7B 7D:
EH=7D?P7J?ED7B9EDIJH7?DJIKD:;HM?9J;C;:?7EF;H7J;?DB?8;H7B9EKDJH?;IEJ;9;DJ;H EH
J;IE 97BB;::;L;BEF;:9EKDJH?;I #KF:G:G= AHFLDR I QQB IHBGMHNMMA:MMA0.
F=B::G=MAHLH?HMAKHNGMKBL:K=B??KGM M?9=;D;H7BBOH;IKBJ?D7D7HHEM;HH7D=;E
:?I9EKHI;?D J;/D?J;:-J7J;I )OKMAELL :M : GHKF:EHK@:GBS:MBHG:E :G=LMKNMNK:E EOE
J; FH?L7J; 9EHFEH7J; C;:?7 ?D EJ;H ;9EDEC?97BBO :;L;BEF;: 9EKDJH?;I EF;H7J; KD:;H J;
H;IJH?9J?EDI?CFEI;:8OJ;;B;C;DJIJ7J9ECFH?I;J;*' *GMAHMAKA:G= ;BG@MAGMK
H? MA PHKE= LRLMF A@FHGR PBMA FHK =OEHI= ?:L H? :IBM:EBLF :G= MA IHPK
FA:GBLFL MABG?ENGH?MAL?BEMKLBGMA0.BLFHKOB=GM B?GHM@K:MKMHHOKPB@A
MA:MBGEJ;H9EKDJH?;IM?JI?C?B7H97H79J;H?IJ?9I
/A=OEHIFGM:G=LMKG@MAH?MAL?BEMKLBG NKHI:GGPLHGMGMHOKPB@ALMAHL
BGK@BHG L.I:KDL A:LIHBGM=HNM MAK:K?BOLIB?B?:MHKLE:=BG@HGLJNGMER
MH : PB=K LI: H? GPL HGMGM :G= MAL :K B HIG FBG== NEMNK:E :G= B=HEH@B:E
HGMQML BB HIG FBG== CHNKG:EBLMB NEMNK BBB LHE= :G= ??MBO KBMB:E NKKGML BO
HGMBGNHNLHFIMBMBHGBGMAF:KDMBG@H?GPLI:IKL :G=O MAHGMKHEH?E?MBLMIHEBMB:E
I:KMBLPBMA:MBO:G=AB@A@HOKGFGMKIKLGM:MBHG /AK?HK :ELL=BOKLBMRBGMA0.BL
?HNG=MA:GMA:MBGHNGMKBLPBMA:ABLMHKR:G=KHNMBGHRIVRFLDOGHPRFUDFEXWEHFDXVHWKHµIUHH
PDUNHW¶DQGPHGLDFRQJORPHUDWLRQDQGFRQFHQWUDWLRQLVIDYRXUHGEWKHZRUOGZLGHLGHRORJLFDO
H??GLBO :GBFIHKM:GMEB;K:E;B:L?HKMA NKHI:GLGLH?MAMKFL?KF:KDM EB;K:EBLF
GH EB;K:EBLF :G=MAEBD A:LKHHMLBGMAF=B:LAHFLDR#KF:G A
!HKMABKMABK=ARIHMALBL #KF:GAHFLDR I ? LN@@LMMPHIK=BMBHGL
?BKLM HK=KIK=BMBHGPAKMA+(:G=F=B:IK?HKF:GPBEE;B@GHK= :G=LHG= HK=K
IK=BMBHG PAK MAR PBEE ; F:K@BG:EBS= (:GR KBMBL H? MA +( :K =BLL:MBL?B= ;R MABL
KSRWKHVLVEHOLHYLQJWKDWWKHDXWKRUVDUHEHKLQGSURYLQJWKDWPHGLDKDVDµFRQVSLUDWLRQDOYLHZ¶
(NEEG I (NEEGBGABLBGMKOBPPBMA#KF:G:G=AHFLDRJNLMBHG=MAF:;HNM
MABLHIBGBHG /ARKIEB=:L?HEEHPL
1;7H;L;HO9B;7HJ7JJ;*':E;IDEJH;IJED7DO9EDIF?H79O7IIKCFJ?ED
8KJ?IHEEJ;:C7?DBO?DC7HA;J EH?;DJ;:FHE9;II;I KJC7DO9H?J?9I7L;DEJ
8;;D78B;JEI;;EMI?C?B7HH;IKBJI9EKB:7H?I;M?JEKJ9EDIF?H79O ;D9;
J;H;CKIJ8;7DKD:;HBO?D=9EDIF?H79O7IIKCFJ?ED

/ABL HGLIBK:R :LLNFIMBHG G=L FHK OB=G =KBO= ?KHF MA BFIEFGM:MBHG H? :
I:KMBNE:K:@G=: :G=MABLBLMAE:RHNMH?MABLA:IMK
2BEEHQ
I IKHIHLL?BOMAFLH?+H?HG?EBM :G= H?HNKL+(
BLHGH?MAHLHG?EBML :ME:LM?HK(NLEBFL /AL?BO+MAFLJH7DI9;D:J;L7H?78B;I
8;JM;;DJ;9EDB?9JI M?JJ;:EC?D7D9;E;79;B;C;DJI?J?D=?DH;B7J?EDJEJ;IF;9??9*
H;GK?H;C;DJIEJ;9H?I?II /AL?BOMAFL:K
/AIHKMK:R:EH?MAE:=K?B@NK7KH3$WDNHVWZRIRUPVIRUWKHUROHRIWKHRSSRQHQW¶V
E:=K?B@NK !BKLM J;9H?I?I?IIF;9??97BBOF;HIED7B?P;:M?JJ;;D;COB;7:;HIEJ7J
J;?DJHE:K9J?EDE?ID7C;8;9EC;IIODEDOCEKIM?JJ;9EDB?9JI .HG= J;
?D:?L?:K7B ED9;:?H;9JBO7IIE9?7J;:M?JJ;9EDB?9J ?I:;CED?P;: FHEL?:?D=D;=7J?L;
9EDDEJ7J?EDIJHEK=J;?DLEA?D=E?ID7C;
/AIHKMK:R:EH?MAGFR ?MKMAIHKMK:R:E H?MAGFR E:=K ?B@NK BL ?K:F=
E:K@K @KHNIL :K :ELH =?BG= :L MA GFR BG MA LGL MA:M MA 9EDI;GK;DJ
:;CED?P7J?ED 97D ;NJ;D: JE 7D 7HCO H79; EH 7D ;DJ?H; 9EKDJHOI 2BEEHQ :ELH
:??BKFLMA:MMAK:LHG;ABG=LNALN;LJNGM=FHGBSBG@BLMH?K:F:OBLB;EGFRMH
P:@:HGLBLMGMIHEBRP:K:@:BGLMPAHFBLCNLMB?B:;E

(BEBM:KRMAK:M/AKIKLGM:MBHGFBEBM:KR:I:;BEBMRH?MA GFRA:L;:LBINKIHLL
:G=G=LBGIKLGMBG@MAKBLBLMHMA=HFLMB:N=BG /PHLMK:M@BL:G;NL=
QDPHOµGRZQSODHG¶DQGµHQKDQFHG¶7KHIRUPHULVWR@:MAKIN;BLNIIHKM :G=PBMAHNM
BMK:MBG@G@:MBOBHGLPBEE;EBFBM=:G==BFBGBLABG@ /AE:MMK HGMAHMAKA:G= BL
JEFH;F7H;J;=;D;H7BFK8B?9EH7FHEBED=:?FBEC7J?97D:C?B?J7HO97CF7?=DI ?
/AK:MMHBGMKG:MBHG:ELM:;BEBMR/ABLBL:ABO=;R?=B?=J?D=J;:;IJ78?B?P7J?ED7
9H?I?I 97D 97KI; 7D: 8O J; FEJ;DJ?7B J;HHEH?IJ 97CF7?=DI J7J C7O :;L;BEF HEC ?J
I
/AGHEH@B:EP:K?:K/AG@:MBOIHKMK:R:EH?MAMAGHEH@RH?P:IHGLBGMAIKLL
BLHGH?MAF:CHKHFIHGGMLH?MAKBLBLG:KK:MBO

/AMABK=FH=EBL%HPMM*HGGEEL EHG@FHKMA:G:JN:KMKH?:GMNKR:G=
;:L=HGFH=ELKE:MBOERLBFBE:KMHMAMPHFGMBHG=AK MARA:=;GPHKDBG@A:K=HG
=OEHIBG@:FH=EH?+:G:ERLBLMA:MHNE=;LN??BBGMMHO:EN:MKBLBLMBFL EBD2:KHG
/KKHK:G=+( /ARB=GMB?RMG=BOBLBHGLH?MABK:G:ERLBLI :G=MAL:K
.;?:;EBE=O7D:FKHFEI;EJ;FHEF7=7D:797CF7?=D
.;9EDJ;NJ?DM?9J;FHEF7=7D:7E99KHI
#:;DJ??97J?EDEJ;FHEF7=7D:?IJ
.;IJHK9JKH;EJ;FHEF7=7D:7EH=7D?P7J?ED
.;J7H=;J7K:?;D9;
';:?7KJ?B?P7J?EDJ;9D?GK;I
-F;9?7BJ;9D?GK;IJEC7N?C?P;;;9J
K:?;D9;H;79J?EDJEL7H?EKIJ;9D?GK;I
EKDJ;HFHEF7=7D:7 ?FH;I;DJ
;9JI7D:;L7BK7J?ED

!HKMALOGMA=BOBLBHG MABK+(BGEN=LB@AMMAGBJNL
H;7J?D=,;IED7D9; (LL:@LPBEE;FHKBG?ENGMB:EPAGMAR:KBG:HK=:GPBMA
QBLMBG@;EB?L HIBGBHGL :G=HKBGM:MBHGLI
-EKH9; H;:?8?B?JO +HIE :K PBMA : MG=GR MH ?HEEHP NI :NMAHKBMR ?B@NKL ?HK
=BKMBHGL:G=DGHPE=@I
)F?D?ED;7:;HI /AIKHI:@:G=BLMFNLM:II:EMHMAHIBGBHGE:=KLMHB=GMB?RMABK
BG?ENG:G=LM:MNLI
79;±JE 79;EDJ79J /AIKHI:@:G=BLMFNLM?HEEHPMAOGMLHGM:MLI
!HEKF (EHCI /AR :K ;EB?L :G= O:ENL =KBO= ?KHF MA FF;KL H? MA @KHNIL
I
,;M7H:7D:*KD?IC;DJ /ABLBLMHF:DIHIE 799;FJ7D?:;7FK8B?97BBOJHEK=7
IOIJ;CEH;M7H:I7D:FKD?IC;DJII
'EDEFEBO E J; ECCKD?97J?ED -EKH9; 2AG MA LHNK H? HFFNGB:MBHG BL :
FHGHIHER EBD : LBG@E GPLI:IK : /1 A:GGE HK M;D F;EFB; 7H; DEJ B?A;BO JE
97BB;D=;7D?:;7I
0?IK7B-OC8EBIE*EM;H /AIKHI:@:G=BLMLAHNE=:GLPKMAJNLMBHGEJ;L?IK7B
H;FH;I;DJ7J?EDI7L;7D?9EDE=H7F?9:;DEJ7J?EDEFEM;H7D:K8?GK?JOI
BG@FHK:IIEB:;ELIB:EERBGKGMF=B: %HPMM*HGGEELFH=EPBEE;NL=MH
NG=KLM:G=MAKIKH=NMBHGH?+(( -?KGMHMAHMAKMPHFH=ELPBEE;=HG F:=
GLL:KR

?@A:GBLM:G2:K MAOBHEGBGGHKMAKG G@E:G=;MPGG:MBOKBMBLA:G=
LB:G(NLEBFRHNMA KBL:G==:MAH?+BF!HKMNRG
BGMA)MAKE:G=L
$K:J2:K FNK=KH?/AH1:GH@A
(:=KB= ;HF;BG@L 'HG=HG
;HF;BG@L +:KBLNMNFG;:GEBNKBHML :KMHHGKBLBLBGGF:KD KBMBLA
DELQHW 0LQLVWHU -DFN 6WUDZ¶V VSHHFK DERXW KLV ZLVK WR VHH ZRPHQ QRW HOKBG@ MABK ?:
/DUV9LONV¶GUDZLQJV
IN;EBLA=BGMA.P=BLA=:BER (;H?A;IBB;7D:7 MA
.P=BLA?BEF ?JD7 .PBLLFBG:KM=;:M
GNE:K=;:MPBMA$K:G /ABEH
6DUUD]LQ¶V SROHPLFDO ERRN
.MHDAHEF ERPELQJV DQ ,PDP¶V EHDWLQJ XS WKH
LMN=GML BG E:LL BG BKFBG@A:F BG MA 0 MA ;NKGBG@ H? ,NK:G ;R MA FKB:G
I:LMHKL /KKR%HGL:G= 2:RG.:II BG:BGLOBEE !EHKB=: H??BB:E ;:GH? 8KHG7 BG
!K:G MA!KGA:KB:MNKL MAFKB:G?BEF#DDE9;D9;E'KIB?CI

:G=A:KEB#;=HKBLBL
/ALOGML:MN:EERE=MHJNLMBHGMABFIHKM:GH?HEEMBOIKLGH?(NLEBFLBG
MA 0. :G= NKHI :G= MA K:=B:EBS:MBHG H? $LE:FB B=GMBMR BG NKHI ?MK MA OGML H?
.IMF;K MA
MA L:E:MBHG H? $LE:FHIAH;B =BLHNKLL H? LHF IHEBMB:E :G= IN;EB
BGMEEMN:ELA:LF:=MAPHKE=BGMPHIHLBMBHGL 'KIB?CI:G=J;H;IJ HK=BG@MHE:SS:GR
I $LE:FA:L9;HJ7?DBO8;9EC;FEB?J?9?P;:8OL7H?EKI=HEKFIM?J'KIB?C879A=HEKD:
7IM;BB7I8OIEC;DED 'KIB?CI /A?HKFK@KHNILA:O;GL:KABG@?HK7D?:;EBE=OJE
FHEJ;9JJ;CI;BL;I7=7?DIJJ;:;JH?C;DJ7BEH9;IE=BE87B?P7J?EDIK97I?D@KIJ?9; ?D;GK7B?JO
FEL;HJO KD;CFBEOC;DJ ;N9BKI?ED H79?IC 7D: :?I9H?C?D7J?ED I L :ELH :L:M ::L
*NGBLLB I ?? )HG (NLEBFL KIKLGM= ;R LHF 2LMKG E:=KL :G= BGMEEMN:EL
7L; 7BIE FEB?J?9?P;: #IB7C JE CE8?B?P; J; C7@EH?J?;I EH J;?H EMD ?DJ;H;IJI 7BED= M?J J;
9EDIJUXFWHGIHDURIDQµHQHPZLWKLQ¶RUDQµRXWVLGHHQHP¶L:ELH(:A:F:
$GHGP:RHK:GHMAK MALOGML:G=LBFBE:KHGLA:OLA:I=AHPMA2LMKGIN;EB
A:L IKBO= (NLEBFL :G= AHP (NLEBFL A:O IKBO= MA 2LM /ABL BL PAR (NLEBFL
HFFNGBMBLA:OH?MG;G:NL=@NBEMRBGMBFLH?MNKFHBE :G=E:SS:GRA:LFGMBHG=MA
KGMF:LLFNK=KBG)HKP:RHG%NER :L:O:EB=Q:FIE EB':F:G?
HGLB=K LNA Q:FIEL :L MA P:RL BG PAK $*+ A:L ;G NL= :L : ?HKF H?
=EL;HDC;DJ7B?JO

/A KIHKM LN;FBMM= ;R L:KB M :E I BM= BG EEG ? MH MA
NKHI:G HFFBLLBHG LM:ML MA:M MA G@:MBO IKIMBHGL H? $LE:F BG MA PHKE= :G=
I:KMBNE:KERBG NKHI :G;MK:=;:DMHMAKNL:=LBGF:GRP:RL :G=$*+BLK:MAK7
CE:;HD7D:I;9KB7H7DJ? #IB7C?9:?I9EKHI;7D:FH79J?9;7FF;7H?D=?DJ;FK8B?9IF;H;M?JJ;
?DJ;=H7J?EDE'KIB?C?CC?=H7DJ9ECCKD?J?;I7D:?DJ;DI?O?D=7J;H HK=BG@MHEEG
I ? $*+BL7CK9KI;:8KJB?JJB;KD:;HIJEE:J;HC :G=:MN:EERBMBL;EBO=MH;
PRUHSRSXODUDIWHUWKHLVVXLQJRI5XQQPHGH7UXVW¶VRPPLVVLRQUHSRUWRQ%ULWLVK0XVOLPV
:G=$*+($ GMBME=#IB7CEFE8?77BB;D=;EH/IBB-NGGRF= $GMABL
KIHKM BMBL :LLNK=MA:MMAMKFL ?BKLMNL:@ BGGPLI:IKL P:L ;R:G FKB:G GPLI:IK
KIHKMK BG /ABL ($ =?BG= $*+ :L 7D KDEKD:;: EIJ?B?JO JEM7H:I #IB7C 7D:
J;H;EH;;7HEH:?IB?A;E7BBEHCEIJ'KIB?CII :G=J?IEIJ?B?JOM7IKHJ;H;B78EH7J;:
8OJ;FHEFEI7BE;?=JFEII?8B;#IB7CEFE8?9C?D:I;JI /ALB@AMLM:MFGML
:K

³#IB7C?II;;D7I7CEDEB?J?98BE9 IJ7J?97D:KDH;IFEDI?L;JE97D=;´
³,VODPLVVHHQDVVHSDUDWHDQGµRWKHU¶,WGRHVQRWKDYHYDOXHVLQFRPPRQZLWKRWKHU
9KBJKH;I ?IDEJ7;9J;:8OJ;C7D::E;IDEJ?DBK;D9;J;C ´
³#IB7C?II;;D7I?D;H?EHJEJ;1;IJ #J?II;;D7I87H87H?9 ?HH7J?ED7B FH?C?J?L;7D:
I;N?IJ ´

³#IB7C?II;;D7IL?EB;DJ 7==H;II?L; JH;7J;D?D= 7D:IKFFEHJ?L;EJ;HHEH?IC 7D:
;D=7=HGLQDµFODVKRIFLYLOLVDWLRQV¶´
³#IB7C?II;;D7I7FEB?J?97B?:;EBE=O7D:?IKI;:EHFEB?J?97BEHC?B?J7HO7:L7DJ7=;
³H?J?9?ICIC7:;EJ;1;IJ8O#IB7C7H;H;@;9J;:EKJE7D: ´
³EIJ?B?JOJEM7H:I#IB7C?IKI;:JE@KIJ?O:?I9H?C?D7JEHOFH79J?9;IJEM7H:I'KIB?CI
7D:;N9BKI?EDE'KIB?CIHECC7?DIJH;7CIE9?;JO ´
³DJ? 'KIB?CEIJ?B?JO?II;;D7ID7JKH7BEHDEHC7B ´

HK=BG@MH.NM:K I ?? MAKBLGHE@:EER :@K==?BGBMBHGH?$*+ :G=A
@HL?NKMAKMHFGMBHGMA:MGHHFFHG=?BGBMBHG :MBHG:G=IHEBRA:O;G=OEHI=;R
LHB:E LBGL MH E:KB?R BM BMAK #HPOK MH K?K MH 1:G BCD $*+ A:L ;G
=BLNLL=NG=KMAHL;KH:=KHGIMLH?=BLKBFBG:MBHG:G=K:BLF :G=MAL:KNGBOKL:EER
:IM=;RF:GRBGMKG:MBHG:EHK@:GBS:MBHGL:G=@HOKGFGML $GMABLKLIM MA*K@:GBS:MBHG
H?.NKBMR:G=HHIK:MBHGBG NKHI :G=MA NKHI:G0GBHG :G=MA0)AE=:G=BLLN=
HG?KGL =HNFGML :G= KIHKML L 0( MH B=GMB?R MA IAGHFGHG :G= BML
F:GB?LM:MBHGL HG BGMKG:MBHG:E LM:G=:K=L H? K:B:E =BLKBFBG:MBHG !HK Q:FIE BG MA
RXQFLORI(XURSH¶VSXEOLVKHGµ,VODPRSKRELD¶DQGLWVRQVHTXHQFHVRQRXQJ3HRSOHMHK?KMH
$*+:L³WKHIHDURIRUSUHMXGLFHGYLHZSRLQWJEM7H:I#IB7C 'KIB?CI7D:C7JJ;HIF;HJ7?D?D=JE
J;C-:F;K@ I :G=#)*?I7L?EB7J?EDEKC7DH?=JI7D:7JH;7J JE IE9?7B
9E;I?ED´ .BFBE:KER BG MA +K?: H? ABL #IB7CEFE8?7 EEG =LKB;L LNA HK@:GBS:MBHG:E
??HKML:LO:EN:;E;NMGHM?NEERHGOBGBG@ :G=ALM:M=MA:M

;IF?J;DKC;HEKIIEKH9;IIK==;IJ?D=J7J#IB7CEFE8?7?I8;9EC?D=8EJ
?D9H;7I?D=BOFH;L7B;DJ7D:IE9?7BBO799;FJ78B;?DJ;9EDJ;CFEH7HOMEHB:
J;H;H;C7?DI7B79AEJ;NJK7BIEKH9;IJ7J9EDI?:;H;?J;HJ;F;DEC;DED
?JI;B EH?JIC7D?;IJ7J?EDI7D:9EDI;GK;D9;I .;H;?IDE7KJEH?J7J?L;J;NJ
J7J7JJ;CFJIJEKD:;HIJ7D:EH9EDJ;NJK7B?P;M7JC?=J8;I;;DJE8;ED;E
J;CEIJ:7D=;HEKIFH;@K:?9;I?DJ;9EDJ;CFEH7HO9B?C7J; I BB

LBFBE:KIKLIMBOP:L:KEBKIKLGM=;R.:B= PAHIHKMK:R=$*+HK2LMKG?:K
H?$LE:FBGMA?HEEHPBG@P:R
«LVDFXOWXUDO ?:;EBE=?97BEKJBEEAJ7JI;;AIJE;NFB7?D?BBIEJ;=BE87B
IE9?7B EH:;H 8O 7JJH?8KJ?D= J;C JE #IB7C #J ?I 7 M7O E J?DA?D= J7J
9EDB7J;I?IJEH?;I FEB?J?9I IE9?;J?;I7D:9KBJKH;IEJ;'?::B;7IJ?DJE7
I?D=B;KD??;:7D:D;=7J?L;9ED9;FJ?EDRI,VODP«,WLVDQLGHRORJLQZKLFK
WKH µEDFNZDUGQHVV¶ RI WKH RWKHU LV HVWDEOLVKHG JHEK= 7D ;II;DJ?7B?P;:
#IB7CI

(HKHOK !:=BE I ? A:L H;LKO= $*+ :L ED; E J; 8?= GK;IJ?EDI E EKH :7O
FH;I;DJ?D=7FHE8B;CJ7J?ICEIJEJ;D7DIM;H;:M?J?=DEH7D9;EHM?J9ECCEDOIJ;H?7 7D:
7BCEIJD;L;HM?JH;IJ?DA?D= O:GL I BLMAFHLMILLBFBLMBHGBGLM:MBG@MA:M
$*+;KBG@L=:F:@HGMA NKHI:GIN;EBBLPDNLQJDPRQVWHUZKHUHLWVKRXOGQ¶WH[LVWD
CEDIJ;HC7:;HECJ;C7D?7EEKHEMD;7HLBFBE:KOBPBLLGBGL:KBM:E
PAH:K@NMA:M$*+:MN:EER 9ED9;7BI:?;H;DJEHCIE:?I9H?C?D7J?ED=NMH:GMB $LE:FB
=BLHNKL:G=BMLHGLJNGMLMKNMNK:EBGJN:EBMBL

.?IF;DEC;DED97DDEJI?CFBO8;IK8IKC;:?DJEJ;J;HC#IB7CEFE8?7
#D:;;: J;J;HC97D8;C?IB;7:?D= 7I?JFH;IKFFEI;IJ;FH; ;C?D;D9;E

H;B?=?EKI:?I9H?C?D7J?EDM;DEJ;HEHCIE:?I9H?C?D7J?EDIK97IH79?7B
EH 9B7II C7O 8; CEH; H;B;L7DJ 1; J;H;EH; ?DJ;D: JE KI; J; J;HC
#IB7CEFE8?77I7IJ7HJ?D=FE?DJEH7D7BOP?D=J;:?;H;DJ:?C;DI?EDIJ7J
:;?D;J;FEB?J?97BI?JK7J?EDE'KIB?CC?DEH?J?;I?DKHEF; 1;M?BBDEJ
J7A;J;J;HCEH=H7DJ;:8O7II?=D?D=?JEDBOED;C;7D?D= IK97I7DJ?
#IB7C?9:?I9EKHI;I

/ABLBL:MN:EER :LFGMBHG=;RE:SS:GR I ? MAIKH=NKMAGH EB;K:ELM:ML
HIK:MLJHEK=I;9KH?J?P?D=7D:IJ?=C7J?P?D=JEI;ME7H;;JDE 9KBJKH7BBO7D:H;B?=?EKIBO
:?;H;DJHECJ;C7@EH?JOIE9?;J?;I :IHBGMK?EM=PEEBGQ:FBGBG@*KBGM:EBLF
MA$K:J
2:K
:G=+(
EEG :EHG@ ABL #IB7CEFE8?7 D #DJHE:K9J?ED M7I LDBG@ :G :NMAHKBM:MBO
=?BGBMBHGH?$*+ PABADQEHXVHGDVDVXLWDEOHGHILQLWLRQWRWHUPVOLNHµ$QWL ,VODPUDFLVP¶
RUµ$QWL 3URSKHW0XKDPPDGUDFLVP¶DQGKLVILQDOGHILQLWLRQLVWKHIROORZLQJ
#IB7CEFE8?7 ?I 7D ?:;EBE=O I?C?B7H ?D J;EHO KD9J?ED 7D: FKHFEI; JE
H79?IC 7D: EJ;H I?C?B7H F;DEC;D7 J7J IKIJ7?D 7D: F;HF;JK7J;I
D;=7J?L;BO;L7BK7J;:C;7D?D=78EKJ'KIB?CI7D:#IB7C?DJ;9EDJ;CFEH7HO
VHWWLQJLQVLPLODUZDVWRWKDWZKLFKLWKDVKLVWRULFDOO«LQIOXHQFLQJDQG
?CF79J?D=KFEDIE9?7B79J?ED ?DJ;H79J?ED H;IFEDI;7D:IEED I7F?D=7D:
:;J;HC?D?D= KD:;HIJ7D:?D= F;H9;FJ?EDI 7D: 7JJ?JK:;I ?D J; IE9?7B
FRQVHQVXV«WKDWLQIRUPDQGFRQVWUXFWWKLQNLQJDERXW0XVOLPVDQG,VODPDV
)J;HI

/HMA;LMDGHPE=@H?MAPKBMK MABLBLMA?BKLMMBF$*+BLIKLGM=:L:GB=HEH@R;R
GHG (NLEBF
PABA:G:LBER;NG=KLMHH=:L=EB;K:M:G=PBMA:@G=: :LPBEE;LGBG
MA?HEEHPBG@LMBHGL /ABL:@G=: BGHK=KMH;BG?ENGMB:E =RG:FB :G=LNLL?NE KJNBKL
F:GR=OEHIBG@HFIHGGML EBD+ MHHEL M:K@ML :G=F:GRHMAKMABG@L /HMAPKBMK MA
FHLMKGM?HKFH?MABL$LE:FHIAH;B:@G=: LIB:EERBGMABL=:= BL+((
/AKHN@A MA HNKL H? MA E:LM MAK =:=L MA BHGL H? (NLEBFL :G= $LE:F BG MA
2LMKGF=B:A:L;HFMAHGKGH?F:GRKL:KAKL:EEHOUWKHZRUOG7RXVH$OOHQ¶V
PHK=L 6$M7?I9KHH;DJBO7IK8@;9JECK9:;87J;7CED=IJ797:;C?9I C;:?7?DIJ?JKJ?EDI
'KIB?CEH=7D?P7J?EDI7D:J;=;D;H7BFK8B?9I (:GRF=B:LMN=BL:LLKMMA:MJ;9KHH;DJ
9EL;H7=; E #IB7C ?D J; 1;IJ;HD C;:?7 7I C7:; #IB7C 7 I7B?;DJ ?IIK; 7D: 7I B;: JE ?JI
FK8B?9?JO?DJ;9KHH;DJ;H7KHPLHG I :R:M I ? :G=E:SS:GR
I LAHPMA:MGHMHIBA:LKGMER;G=BLNLL=:G=LKNMBGBS=BGMAF=B:FHKMA:G$LE:F
:G=(NLEBFL !NKMAKFHK E:SS:GRLM:ML?NKMAKMA:M=NMHMABLAN@HOK:@ MAPHKE=:M
E:K@A:L;HFLN;CM=MH:P:EMAH?:G:ERLBLH?$LE:FBG:P:RMA:M?NELNKBHLBMRH?MA
IHIE:;HNMMAKEB@BHG:G= BML:=AKGML MHMAQMGMMA:M;HHD LEEKL BG NKHI:G=MA
(B==E :LMA:OKIHKM=:GNILNK@BGMAINKA:LH?MA,NK:G PABALNIIHKMLPA:MHG
KBMBLA GPLI:IK A:L:??BKF=MA:M$LE:F A:L GOK ;GH?@K:MK BGMKLMMHMAIHIEH?
KBM:BGMA:GBMBLMH=:R
/AL:FOBPBLF;K:=;RE LAB;:GB PAHLM:MLMA:M?HEEHPBG@MA
OGML $LE:F :G= (NLEBFL A:O ;HF :FHG@ MA F:BG MHIBL H? MA 2LMKG F=B: :G=
IHIE:KHNG=MAPHKE=A:O;HFLMN=GMLGPER LAHHE=BG$LE:FLLMK:M@B@H@K:IAR
NEMNK :G=IHIE :L:M ::L*NGBLLB :G=/:A: IHBGMHNMMA:MMAF=B:A:L
;HFMAF:BG B?GHMMAHGER :O:BE:;ELHNKMHH;M:BGMABLBG?HKF:MBHG .BFBE:KER -:F;K@
:G=':F;KMBMAGL (:SK LM:MMA:M MAKHN@AMAF=B:HOK:@H?$LE:F MA

Anti-ProphetMohammadMediaACriticalDiscourseAnalysis (1).pdf

Anti-ProphetMohammadMediaACriticalDiscourseAnalysis (1).pdf

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Similar to Anti-ProphetMohammadMediaACriticalDiscourseAnalysis (1).pdf

Similar to Anti-ProphetMohammadMediaACriticalDiscourseAnalysis (1).pdf (20)

More from Ahmed Qadoury Abed

More from Ahmed Qadoury Abed (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Anti-ProphetMohammadMediaACriticalDiscourseAnalysis (1).pdf