SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
4 0 www.uslaw.org U S L A W
Purchasing a business in Canada often means
becoming an employer of Canadian employees.
Given the real potential of becoming liable for sev-
erance payments after acquiring a business in Canada,
potential buyers would be prudent to consider the ways
by which they can mitigate their exposure to such costs.
CONTINUOUS EMPLOYMENT
The first thing potential buyers need to be aware
of is the deemed continuous employment provisions
contained in provincial employment standards leg-
islation (or federal legislation for certain industries
such as inter-provincial transportation and telecom-
munications). Pursuant to that legislation, if an em-
ployer sells the whole or a part of a business and
the buyer employs an employee of the seller, then
the legislation imposes two important conse-
quences. First, the employee’s employ-
ment is deemed not to have been
terminated. Second, the law deems
the employee’s employment history
and obligations with the seller to be
transferred with the purchase which
will impact any subsequent calculation
of the employee’s length or period of
employment. These legal conse-
quences are important because it can
significantly increase the amount of
severance pay to which an employee
can become entitled to upon dismissal, as dis-
cussed below.
INHERITING SEVERANCE OBLIGATIONS
Unlike the United States, Canada does not have
‘at will’ employment. Because the concept of at will employment is
foreign to Canadian employment law, businesses with Canadian em-
ployees must not include at will employment concepts into
Canadian employment agreements. In Canada, all employment con-
ditions must comply with at least the minimum
requirements provided in employment stan-
dard legislation. Some contracts will provide for
severance entitlements which exceed the mini-
mum obligations, to provide something closer to
common law notice (discussed below). As a successor
employer, the buyer should ensure that individual em-
ployment contracts are carefully reviewed well prior to
closing in order to be aware of the obligations that it
will assume, particularly the obligations related to
any future terminations of employment.
REASONABLE NOTICE
Where, however, the seller’s employees have no
written contracts containing severance provisions
(or written contracts which are void or unenforce-
able for any of a number of reasons), employees in
Canada (other than in the province of Quebec, as
discussed below) are considered to have ‘common
law’ entitlements. Canadian common law presumes
that employment can only be terminated with ‘just
cause’ (which is a high standard to meet, but a topic
for another day) or upon the provision of ‘reasonable
notice’ (or pay in lieu of reasonable notice).
Reasonable notice is invariably greater than applicable
provincial statutory minimums. What is reasonable is in
the eyes of the judge, based on: the specific employee’s
age; length of service; nature of employment (i.e.
skill level, managerial responsibilities, if any, and
compensation); availability of alternative employ-
ment given existing market conditions; and any
other factor the Court considers relevant (such as
restrictive covenants which may hinder the employee’s ability
to readily secure comparable employment). Unfortunately there
is no formula for determining reasonable notice; as the judiciary
puts it, determining reasonable notice “is an art, not a science.” But
more often than not, the Courts consider notice in terms of months,
rather than weeks as used in minimum standards legislation. It has
PURCHASING A BUSINESS IN CANADA?
UNDERSTAND THE KEY ASSETS:
YOUR NEW EMPLOYEES
Andrea Raso Clark Wilson LLP • Sean Bawden Kelly Santini LLP
Veronique Poirier Therrien Couture lawyers LLP
U S L A W www.uslaw.org 4 1
not been unheard of for employees to be
awarded 24 or more months of reasonable
notice or pay in lieu thereof.
In the province of Quebec, the law is
based on civil law principles (similar to the
State of Louisiana) rather than the common
law. Pursuant to the Civil Code of Quebec,
with or without written contracts, the reason-
able notice obligation applies. Even if a pe-
riod of notice is provided in a contract, a
civil court could decide otherwise if it con-
siders the notice to be “unreasonable” or in-
sufficient in the circumstances.
In the rest of Canada, for buyers look-
ing to limit this potential significant expo-
sure, the positive news is that the
presumption of reasonable notice can be re-
butted if the transferred employees sign
contracts which may address the issue of no-
tice. That said, a buyer must be careful
when taking on the seller’s employees to
not alter their existing terms and conditions
of employment; otherwise, the buyer risks
constructive dismissal claims.
CHANGING EMPLOYEES’ TERMS OF
EMPLOYMENT
A buyer must exercise care when plan-
ning to change any of the employment con-
ditions that employees enjoyed at the time
of purchase, including common law entitle-
ments such as reasonable notice. The no-
tion of constructive dismissal prevents
employers from imposing unilateral funda-
mental changes to terms of employment in
such matters as salary, benefits, working
hours or relocation, without sufficient no-
tice. For example, a reduction of 10% to
20% of the annual compensation an em-
ployee is entitled to will usually be consid-
ered as a fundamental change compliant in
constructive dismissal.
The buyer needs to provide adequate
notice for imposing a fundamental change
to the terms of employment of those em-
ployees it takes over, or provide adequate
consideration (such as a signing bonus) be-
fore instituting a change to a fundamental
term or condition of employment.
OTHER OBLIGATIONS
So far we have largely focused on the
purchaser’s obligations as they relate to no-
tice or severance. Some other key obliga-
tions that purchasers should consider are:
1. Workers’ Compensation: Almost all
Canadian employers are obligated to pay
into provincial government workers’ com-
pensation schemes, regardless of whether
they offer a similar private benefit;
2. Overtime pay: All employees are statuto-
rily entitled to overtime pay, regardless
of whether they are paid hourly or by
salary (except in the province of Quebec
where salaried employees are exempt),
unless they fall into a specifically legis-
lated exemption (such as the managerial
exclusion);
3. Privacy rights: British Columbia, Alberta
and Quebec have private-sector privacy
legislation which protects the collection,
use and disclosure of employees’ personal
information, and which allow employees
to access any employer document which
contains their personal information;
4. Leaves of Absence: Canadian mothers are
entitled to job-protected pregnancy leave
for up to 17 weeks and both mothers and
fathers are entitled to up to 37 weeks of
job-protected parental leave. Provincial
legislation also mandates other leaves,
such as compassionate care leave, emer-
gency leave and family responsibility
leave, to name a few.
5. Drug and Alcohol Testing: Employees are
generally free from pre-employment test-
ing and random testing, even in safety-
sensitive work environments, unless the
employee or the workplace has a known
drug or alcohol problem.
AVOIDING THE BAGGAGE
For purchasers wary about the prospect
of becoming an employer in Canada and
being bound by the terms and conditions of
employment enjoyed by employees with the
seller, the buyer may try to insist that the
seller either terminate the employment of
its existing staff pre-closing or agree to as-
sume those costs associated with future ter-
mination. This is easier said than done:
most sellers will be reluctant to incur the
costs of terminating employees pre-closing
only to have the buyer immediately re-hire
them upon closing, particularly when those
costs are contingent on terminations that
may or may not happen at some time in the
future.
BUYING A UNIONIZED WORK FORCE
The rules are somewhat similar when
the seller’s employees are unionized. A
prospective buyer must realize that in addi-
tion to purchasing the assets or equity of the
company, they will also inherit any union al-
ready in place, as well as the existing certifi-
cate giving recognition to the representative
rights of the union, any proceedings being
undertaken by a union to become certified,
any unfair labour practice complaints in
progress, and collective bargaining agree-
ments in force between the parties. In
Canada, this principle is known as the ‘suc-
cessor rights provisions’ of the labour codes
of every Canadian province. The purpose of
these legislative rights is to prevent a buyer
from refusing to recognize a union already
in place or a union in the process of apply-
ing to become recognized.
Often, working conditions stipulated in
a collective bargaining agreement are over-
looked during the negotiation process lead-
ing up to the purchase of the business. Time
and again, a buyer only pays attention to in-
herited working conditions of the collective
agreement when it comes to starting to run
the acquired business. The buyer may then
be in a for a number of surprises regarding
the costs attached to wage rates and upcom-
ing adjustments, benefit costs, or outstand-
ing grievances that will have an impact on
labour costs and the running of the business.
These unwelcome surprises can be avoided
by the prospective buyer taking steps during
the due diligence process to become fully
aware of the current situation. The time to
do so is before closure of the sale.
Sean Bawden is a labour
and employment lawyer
practicing with Kelly
Santini LLP in Ottawa,
Ontario, Canada. He pro-
vides advice to both employ-
ers and employees on a
broad range of employment
law issues. He is also the editor of the firm’s em-
ployment law blog “Labour Pains.”
Veronique Poirier is a law
graduate from McGill
University. She is part of the
Labor and Employment
Law team at Therrien
Couture lawyers LLP. She
provides advice and services
to employers from different
sectors with respect to labor standards, health
and safety issues, employment contracts, inter-
nal policies and employee manuals and inter-
pretation of laws, regulations and collective
bargaining agreements.She represents employers
before civil and administrative tribunals in
Quebec.
Andrea Raso is Chair of the
Labour & Employment
Group of Clark Wilson LLP
in Vancouver, B.C.,
Canada. Andrea acts for
employers in defence of civil
claims and tribunal pro-
ceedings, and has appeared
at every level of Court including the Supreme
Court of Canada. Andrea routinely assists cor-
porate counsel in managing employee issues in
business transactions.

More Related Content

What's hot

Joint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Joint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation SlidesJoint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Joint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation SlidesSlideTeam
 
Ertl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspective
Ertl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspectiveErtl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspective
Ertl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspectivevintagevinogirl
 
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary WorkersWhite Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workersss
 
Navigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-Mehra
Navigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-MehraNavigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-Mehra
Navigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-MehraKegler Brown Hill + Ritter
 
CCS ARC - A question of ethical selling
CCS ARC - A question of ethical sellingCCS ARC - A question of ethical selling
CCS ARC - A question of ethical sellingGary Luther
 
Liability of Directors for a Company's Breach of Contract
Liability of Directors for a Company's Breach of ContractLiability of Directors for a Company's Breach of Contract
Liability of Directors for a Company's Breach of ContractAbraham Vergis
 
MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010
MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010
MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010jyates
 
Short Sales
Short SalesShort Sales
Short Salesnsaunders
 
Directors Fiduciary Duties
Directors Fiduciary DutiesDirectors Fiduciary Duties
Directors Fiduciary Dutiessurrenderyourthrone
 
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers
Bankruptcy For Business LawyersBankruptcy For Business Lawyers
Bankruptcy For Business LawyersSteven Silton
 
Champion Hr NDA
Champion Hr NDAChampion Hr NDA
Champion Hr NDARonnie O'Dell
 
Quick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property From Cousins Business Law
Quick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property  From Cousins Business LawQuick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property  From Cousins Business Law
Quick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property From Cousins Business LawHARRISONP012
 
What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?
What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?
What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?Patton Boggs LLP
 
The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013
The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013
The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013Alan McIntosh
 
Busn 420 final exam
Busn 420 final examBusn 420 final exam
Busn 420 final examarnitaetsitty
 
Chapter 18: Written Form
Chapter 18: Written Form Chapter 18: Written Form
Chapter 18: Written Form Tara Kissel, M.Ed
 
Seven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn Steger
Seven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn StegerSeven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn Steger
Seven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn StegerKegler Brown Hill + Ritter
 

What's hot (19)

Joint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Joint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation SlidesJoint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Joint Venture Proposal Powerpoint Presentation Slides
 
Ertl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspective
Ertl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspectiveErtl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspective
Ertl and kistemaker preventable losses from a business perspective
 
H-1B AMENDMENTS POST-SIMEIO SOLUTIONS: WHY CIS SHOULD CONSIDER TAKING OFF THE...
H-1B AMENDMENTS POST-SIMEIO SOLUTIONS: WHY CIS SHOULD CONSIDER TAKING OFF THE...H-1B AMENDMENTS POST-SIMEIO SOLUTIONS: WHY CIS SHOULD CONSIDER TAKING OFF THE...
H-1B AMENDMENTS POST-SIMEIO SOLUTIONS: WHY CIS SHOULD CONSIDER TAKING OFF THE...
 
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary WorkersWhite Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
 
Navigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-Mehra
Navigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-MehraNavigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-Mehra
Navigating the Indian Legal Landscape | Vinita Bahri-Mehra
 
CCS ARC - A question of ethical selling
CCS ARC - A question of ethical sellingCCS ARC - A question of ethical selling
CCS ARC - A question of ethical selling
 
Liability of Directors for a Company's Breach of Contract
Liability of Directors for a Company's Breach of ContractLiability of Directors for a Company's Breach of Contract
Liability of Directors for a Company's Breach of Contract
 
MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010
MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010
MMM/GA Restrictive Covenants Act Webinar 11-2010
 
Short Sales
Short SalesShort Sales
Short Sales
 
Directors Fiduciary Duties
Directors Fiduciary DutiesDirectors Fiduciary Duties
Directors Fiduciary Duties
 
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers
Bankruptcy For Business LawyersBankruptcy For Business Lawyers
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers
 
Champion Hr NDA
Champion Hr NDAChampion Hr NDA
Champion Hr NDA
 
Quick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property From Cousins Business Law
Quick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property  From Cousins Business LawQuick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property  From Cousins Business Law
Quick Guide To Buying A Commercial Property From Cousins Business Law
 
What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?
What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?
What is a “Small Business” Under the Army’s $7 Billion Renewable Energy RFP?
 
Non compete
Non competeNon compete
Non compete
 
The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013
The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013
The Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill 2013
 
Busn 420 final exam
Busn 420 final examBusn 420 final exam
Busn 420 final exam
 
Chapter 18: Written Form
Chapter 18: Written Form Chapter 18: Written Form
Chapter 18: Written Form
 
Seven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn Steger
Seven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn StegerSeven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn Steger
Seven Habits of Highly Ineffective Global Contract Negotiators | Martijn Steger
 

Viewers also liked

How to force your subscribers to take action!
How to force your subscribers to take action!How to force your subscribers to take action!
How to force your subscribers to take action!Ray Edwards
 
Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)
Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)
Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)Pinpointe On-Demand
 
Get response increase-your-emails-impact
Get response increase-your-emails-impactGet response increase-your-emails-impact
Get response increase-your-emails-impactbakor Balla
 
Short and Sweet Emails that get responses
Short and Sweet Emails that get responsesShort and Sweet Emails that get responses
Short and Sweet Emails that get responsesThe Russell Realty Group
 
When Prevention Sells Better Than Cures
When Prevention Sells Better Than CuresWhen Prevention Sells Better Than Cures
When Prevention Sells Better Than CuresRay Edwards
 
Free response email
Free response   emailFree response   email
Free response emailhhs
 
Selling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right Questions
Selling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right QuestionsSelling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right Questions
Selling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right QuestionsAnnArborSPARK
 
Sales Questioning Strategies
Sales Questioning StrategiesSales Questioning Strategies
Sales Questioning Strategiessimonlushin
 
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brandsChallenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brandsVasily Dubeykovskiy
 
Conversation expressions
Conversation expressionsConversation expressions
Conversation expressionsSandra Àlvarez
 
H R Professionals Business Coaching Guide
H R  Professionals  Business  Coaching  GuideH R  Professionals  Business  Coaching  Guide
H R Professionals Business Coaching GuideVanHalen
 
10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)
10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)
10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)Jane Hart
 

Viewers also liked (12)

How to force your subscribers to take action!
How to force your subscribers to take action!How to force your subscribers to take action!
How to force your subscribers to take action!
 
Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)
Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)
Email Marketing: 21 Tips to Improve Email Responses (Webinar Slides)
 
Get response increase-your-emails-impact
Get response increase-your-emails-impactGet response increase-your-emails-impact
Get response increase-your-emails-impact
 
Short and Sweet Emails that get responses
Short and Sweet Emails that get responsesShort and Sweet Emails that get responses
Short and Sweet Emails that get responses
 
When Prevention Sells Better Than Cures
When Prevention Sells Better Than CuresWhen Prevention Sells Better Than Cures
When Prevention Sells Better Than Cures
 
Free response email
Free response   emailFree response   email
Free response email
 
Selling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right Questions
Selling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right QuestionsSelling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right Questions
Selling Smart Workshop - Questioning Technique - Asking the Right Questions
 
Sales Questioning Strategies
Sales Questioning StrategiesSales Questioning Strategies
Sales Questioning Strategies
 
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brandsChallenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brands
 
Conversation expressions
Conversation expressionsConversation expressions
Conversation expressions
 
H R Professionals Business Coaching Guide
H R  Professionals  Business  Coaching  GuideH R  Professionals  Business  Coaching  Guide
H R Professionals Business Coaching Guide
 
10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)
10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)
10 Trends for Workplace Learning (from the Top 100 Tools for Learning 2015)
 

Similar to USLaw FW 2014

Overview New 2012 Laws Marketing
Overview New 2012 Laws MarketingOverview New 2012 Laws Marketing
Overview New 2012 Laws MarketingDBlas1975
 
The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...
The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...
The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...Christine Hui Jun Zhong
 
Enforceability of Termination Provisions
Enforceability of Termination ProvisionsEnforceability of Termination Provisions
Enforceability of Termination ProvisionsThis account is closed
 
Alternatives To Lay Offs
Alternatives To Lay OffsAlternatives To Lay Offs
Alternatives To Lay Offslnarvid
 
Advertising & The Dirty Dozen
Advertising & The Dirty DozenAdvertising & The Dirty Dozen
Advertising & The Dirty DozenJim Radogna
 
Renewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.ca
Renewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.caRenewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.ca
Renewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.cacapitalhl
 
Terminating Employees in California
Terminating Employees in CaliforniaTerminating Employees in California
Terminating Employees in CaliforniaDiana Maier
 
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers IiBankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Iiguestd2a8f81
 
Strategic Use of Contracts
Strategic Use of ContractsStrategic Use of Contracts
Strategic Use of ContractsRudner Law
 
Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...
Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...
Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...Malcolm MacKillop
 
Employment Law Newsletter
Employment Law NewsletterEmployment Law Newsletter
Employment Law NewsletterdmurrayTH
 
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By BusinessesTop 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By BusinessesFrank C. Cardenas
 
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine Rosenberg
 
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment AgreementsElaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment AgreementsElaine Rosenberg
 
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine Rosenberg
 
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine Rosenberg
 
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment AgreementsElaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment AgreementsElaine Rosenberg
 
Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective
Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective
Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective Outsauce
 

Similar to USLaw FW 2014 (20)

Overview New 2012 Laws Marketing
Overview New 2012 Laws MarketingOverview New 2012 Laws Marketing
Overview New 2012 Laws Marketing
 
The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...
The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...
The OHL Wire ISSUE 17: Off the Plan Purchase - NSW changes in response to sun...
 
RCM
RCMRCM
RCM
 
Enforceability of Termination Provisions
Enforceability of Termination ProvisionsEnforceability of Termination Provisions
Enforceability of Termination Provisions
 
Alternatives To Lay Offs
Alternatives To Lay OffsAlternatives To Lay Offs
Alternatives To Lay Offs
 
Advertising & The Dirty Dozen
Advertising & The Dirty DozenAdvertising & The Dirty Dozen
Advertising & The Dirty Dozen
 
Renewing and Renegotiating Your Mortgage!
Renewing and Renegotiating Your Mortgage!Renewing and Renegotiating Your Mortgage!
Renewing and Renegotiating Your Mortgage!
 
Renewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.ca
Renewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.caRenewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.ca
Renewing and renegotiating your mortgage - Capitalhomelending.ca
 
Terminating Employees in California
Terminating Employees in CaliforniaTerminating Employees in California
Terminating Employees in California
 
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers IiBankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
 
Strategic Use of Contracts
Strategic Use of ContractsStrategic Use of Contracts
Strategic Use of Contracts
 
Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...
Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...
Malcolm MacKillop on Dawe v The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, P...
 
Employment Law Newsletter
Employment Law NewsletterEmployment Law Newsletter
Employment Law Newsletter
 
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By BusinessesTop 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
 
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
 
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment AgreementsElaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
 
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
 
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
Elaine rosenberg october 21 2015
 
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment AgreementsElaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
Elaine Rosenberg - Employment Agreements
 
Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective
Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective
Pensions auto-enrolment -The Outsauce perspective
 

USLaw FW 2014

  • 1. 4 0 www.uslaw.org U S L A W Purchasing a business in Canada often means becoming an employer of Canadian employees. Given the real potential of becoming liable for sev- erance payments after acquiring a business in Canada, potential buyers would be prudent to consider the ways by which they can mitigate their exposure to such costs. CONTINUOUS EMPLOYMENT The first thing potential buyers need to be aware of is the deemed continuous employment provisions contained in provincial employment standards leg- islation (or federal legislation for certain industries such as inter-provincial transportation and telecom- munications). Pursuant to that legislation, if an em- ployer sells the whole or a part of a business and the buyer employs an employee of the seller, then the legislation imposes two important conse- quences. First, the employee’s employ- ment is deemed not to have been terminated. Second, the law deems the employee’s employment history and obligations with the seller to be transferred with the purchase which will impact any subsequent calculation of the employee’s length or period of employment. These legal conse- quences are important because it can significantly increase the amount of severance pay to which an employee can become entitled to upon dismissal, as dis- cussed below. INHERITING SEVERANCE OBLIGATIONS Unlike the United States, Canada does not have ‘at will’ employment. Because the concept of at will employment is foreign to Canadian employment law, businesses with Canadian em- ployees must not include at will employment concepts into Canadian employment agreements. In Canada, all employment con- ditions must comply with at least the minimum requirements provided in employment stan- dard legislation. Some contracts will provide for severance entitlements which exceed the mini- mum obligations, to provide something closer to common law notice (discussed below). As a successor employer, the buyer should ensure that individual em- ployment contracts are carefully reviewed well prior to closing in order to be aware of the obligations that it will assume, particularly the obligations related to any future terminations of employment. REASONABLE NOTICE Where, however, the seller’s employees have no written contracts containing severance provisions (or written contracts which are void or unenforce- able for any of a number of reasons), employees in Canada (other than in the province of Quebec, as discussed below) are considered to have ‘common law’ entitlements. Canadian common law presumes that employment can only be terminated with ‘just cause’ (which is a high standard to meet, but a topic for another day) or upon the provision of ‘reasonable notice’ (or pay in lieu of reasonable notice). Reasonable notice is invariably greater than applicable provincial statutory minimums. What is reasonable is in the eyes of the judge, based on: the specific employee’s age; length of service; nature of employment (i.e. skill level, managerial responsibilities, if any, and compensation); availability of alternative employ- ment given existing market conditions; and any other factor the Court considers relevant (such as restrictive covenants which may hinder the employee’s ability to readily secure comparable employment). Unfortunately there is no formula for determining reasonable notice; as the judiciary puts it, determining reasonable notice “is an art, not a science.” But more often than not, the Courts consider notice in terms of months, rather than weeks as used in minimum standards legislation. It has PURCHASING A BUSINESS IN CANADA? UNDERSTAND THE KEY ASSETS: YOUR NEW EMPLOYEES Andrea Raso Clark Wilson LLP • Sean Bawden Kelly Santini LLP Veronique Poirier Therrien Couture lawyers LLP
  • 2. U S L A W www.uslaw.org 4 1 not been unheard of for employees to be awarded 24 or more months of reasonable notice or pay in lieu thereof. In the province of Quebec, the law is based on civil law principles (similar to the State of Louisiana) rather than the common law. Pursuant to the Civil Code of Quebec, with or without written contracts, the reason- able notice obligation applies. Even if a pe- riod of notice is provided in a contract, a civil court could decide otherwise if it con- siders the notice to be “unreasonable” or in- sufficient in the circumstances. In the rest of Canada, for buyers look- ing to limit this potential significant expo- sure, the positive news is that the presumption of reasonable notice can be re- butted if the transferred employees sign contracts which may address the issue of no- tice. That said, a buyer must be careful when taking on the seller’s employees to not alter their existing terms and conditions of employment; otherwise, the buyer risks constructive dismissal claims. CHANGING EMPLOYEES’ TERMS OF EMPLOYMENT A buyer must exercise care when plan- ning to change any of the employment con- ditions that employees enjoyed at the time of purchase, including common law entitle- ments such as reasonable notice. The no- tion of constructive dismissal prevents employers from imposing unilateral funda- mental changes to terms of employment in such matters as salary, benefits, working hours or relocation, without sufficient no- tice. For example, a reduction of 10% to 20% of the annual compensation an em- ployee is entitled to will usually be consid- ered as a fundamental change compliant in constructive dismissal. The buyer needs to provide adequate notice for imposing a fundamental change to the terms of employment of those em- ployees it takes over, or provide adequate consideration (such as a signing bonus) be- fore instituting a change to a fundamental term or condition of employment. OTHER OBLIGATIONS So far we have largely focused on the purchaser’s obligations as they relate to no- tice or severance. Some other key obliga- tions that purchasers should consider are: 1. Workers’ Compensation: Almost all Canadian employers are obligated to pay into provincial government workers’ com- pensation schemes, regardless of whether they offer a similar private benefit; 2. Overtime pay: All employees are statuto- rily entitled to overtime pay, regardless of whether they are paid hourly or by salary (except in the province of Quebec where salaried employees are exempt), unless they fall into a specifically legis- lated exemption (such as the managerial exclusion); 3. Privacy rights: British Columbia, Alberta and Quebec have private-sector privacy legislation which protects the collection, use and disclosure of employees’ personal information, and which allow employees to access any employer document which contains their personal information; 4. Leaves of Absence: Canadian mothers are entitled to job-protected pregnancy leave for up to 17 weeks and both mothers and fathers are entitled to up to 37 weeks of job-protected parental leave. Provincial legislation also mandates other leaves, such as compassionate care leave, emer- gency leave and family responsibility leave, to name a few. 5. Drug and Alcohol Testing: Employees are generally free from pre-employment test- ing and random testing, even in safety- sensitive work environments, unless the employee or the workplace has a known drug or alcohol problem. AVOIDING THE BAGGAGE For purchasers wary about the prospect of becoming an employer in Canada and being bound by the terms and conditions of employment enjoyed by employees with the seller, the buyer may try to insist that the seller either terminate the employment of its existing staff pre-closing or agree to as- sume those costs associated with future ter- mination. This is easier said than done: most sellers will be reluctant to incur the costs of terminating employees pre-closing only to have the buyer immediately re-hire them upon closing, particularly when those costs are contingent on terminations that may or may not happen at some time in the future. BUYING A UNIONIZED WORK FORCE The rules are somewhat similar when the seller’s employees are unionized. A prospective buyer must realize that in addi- tion to purchasing the assets or equity of the company, they will also inherit any union al- ready in place, as well as the existing certifi- cate giving recognition to the representative rights of the union, any proceedings being undertaken by a union to become certified, any unfair labour practice complaints in progress, and collective bargaining agree- ments in force between the parties. In Canada, this principle is known as the ‘suc- cessor rights provisions’ of the labour codes of every Canadian province. The purpose of these legislative rights is to prevent a buyer from refusing to recognize a union already in place or a union in the process of apply- ing to become recognized. Often, working conditions stipulated in a collective bargaining agreement are over- looked during the negotiation process lead- ing up to the purchase of the business. Time and again, a buyer only pays attention to in- herited working conditions of the collective agreement when it comes to starting to run the acquired business. The buyer may then be in a for a number of surprises regarding the costs attached to wage rates and upcom- ing adjustments, benefit costs, or outstand- ing grievances that will have an impact on labour costs and the running of the business. These unwelcome surprises can be avoided by the prospective buyer taking steps during the due diligence process to become fully aware of the current situation. The time to do so is before closure of the sale. Sean Bawden is a labour and employment lawyer practicing with Kelly Santini LLP in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. He pro- vides advice to both employ- ers and employees on a broad range of employment law issues. He is also the editor of the firm’s em- ployment law blog “Labour Pains.” Veronique Poirier is a law graduate from McGill University. She is part of the Labor and Employment Law team at Therrien Couture lawyers LLP. She provides advice and services to employers from different sectors with respect to labor standards, health and safety issues, employment contracts, inter- nal policies and employee manuals and inter- pretation of laws, regulations and collective bargaining agreements.She represents employers before civil and administrative tribunals in Quebec. Andrea Raso is Chair of the Labour & Employment Group of Clark Wilson LLP in Vancouver, B.C., Canada. Andrea acts for employers in defence of civil claims and tribunal pro- ceedings, and has appeared at every level of Court including the Supreme Court of Canada. Andrea routinely assists cor- porate counsel in managing employee issues in business transactions.