2. LEARNING
OBJECTIV
ES
To define Counseling and its
uses
Enumerate the functions of
primary care counseling
Discuss the Rogerian Model of
Counseling
Discuss the different active
listening skills
3. There is a continuum ranging from a narrow
disease orientation to a social orientation. In the
disease orientation, the physician is concerned
almost exclusively with a patient's liver. The
more humanistically oriented physician asks
the nurse and the patient not only about the
diseased liver but about whether the patient
has expressed fears of dying or any second
thoughts about alcohol use. The meaning of
illness in the patient's culture is considered.
Doherty and Baird
5. COUNSELIN
G
MAGLONZO, COUNSELING
SKILLS FOR CARING
PHYSICIANS, 2005.
It is defined as a set
of techniques, skills
and attitudes to help
people manage their
own problems using
their own resources.
Skills alone is not
enough.
It seeks to provide
self insight,
behavior change
and symptom relief.
6. PEOPLE NEED COUNSELING
WHEN…
A noticeable change
in behavior (self-
defeating behavior or
unaware of the
consequences of their
behavior
Unusually troubled,
tensed or anxious
Thinking is clouded
Not solving problems
which they have the
resources to solve
Not mobilizing their
energies
Not responding to
usual motivators
7. FUNCTIONS OF PRIMARY CARE
COUNSELING
1.Suppor
t
1.Challen
ge
1.Educati
on
1.Prevention
9. ROGERIAN MODEL
Carl Rogers
"Client-centered" or "patient-
centered"
The problem begins when there is
discrepancy or incongruence
between what is actual and what is
perceived
10. ROGERIAN MODEL
Many of the chief complaints and
symptoms of the patient during
consultation have no biomedical
basis or the biomedical component
can be aggravated by a
psychosocial factor
12. GENUINENESS
Genuineness demands transparency
Key ingredients:
Self-awareness – knowledge of one’s biases
and prejudices, perceptions, values and
belief systems
Self-acceptance - one’s ownership of the
full range of feelings and thoughts one has
and not being ashamed of any part of it
Self-expression – the innermost thoughts
and feelings must be expressed judiciously
13. UNCONDITIONAL POSITIVE
REGARD
Setting aside the conditions, such as
biases and prejudices inherited from
upbringing, for the period that we
are dealing with our patient.
This creates a “healing environment”
Insight Constructive Action
14. EMPATHY
It is the ability to put oneself in the
situation of another.
16. ATTENDING SKILLS
Attending skills refer to the way in which
we use our bodies to communicate the
message nonverbally that we are listening
to our patients.
Lean forward
Open stance
Voice of compassion
Eye contact
Relaxed
Sit at an angle
17. BRACKETING
Setting aside your own thoughts,
feelings and judgements that detract
from emphatizing with the patient.
“Mental skill”
We need to see the world from the
patient's point of view
18. LEADING
Indirect Lead
Open invitations made by
the counselor for the patient
to talk about anythings that he
wishes.
"What would you like to talk
about?" Or "What can I do for
you?"
It may also be in a form of
words of phrases: "yes", "go
on", "and then?"
Direct Lead
The doctor-counselor
make a judgement call as
to where the patient
should go and asks him
to go in that direction.
Guidelines for the
doctors to make
judgments:
1. Feeling is greatest or most
intense
2. Most important issues saved
for last
20. REFLECTING CONTENT
The doctor-counselor takes the
verbal content of what the patient
says, repackages and rephrases it so
that it becomes clearer, then gives it
back to the patient.
Two ways of doing this:
1. Paraphrasing - "To summarize in ten
words what it took the patient hundred
words to say"
2. Perception-checking - same as
paraphrasing but it is phrased in the
21. REFLECTING
CONTENT
Paraphrasing
Doctor-Counselor: “So
you’ve been having on
and off headache for 3
months already. You have
tried different
medications but still not
relieved and now it’s
giving you dizziness too
and you don’t know why”
Case: 33/F, single, a call center agent,
came into the clinic because of frontal
headache. "Doctor, I've had this on and
off headache for 3 months already. I had
a consult with our company physician
and she gave me Paracetamol." (Looks at
the floor). ”I’ve been religiously taking
the mediation, it recurred again and now
it it is making me dizzy, too." (patient
shifts in her seat and looks at the floor)
"I went back to our company doctor and
she gave me Mefenamic Acid. I have
been taking it for 1 week now but the
headache still recurs. I just can't
22. REFLECTING
CONTENT
Perception-Checking
Doctor-Counselor: “You
have been having on and
off headache for 3
months already. You tried
2 different medications
already but your headache
still recurs and you don’t
understand why. Is that
it?”
Case: 33/F, single, a call center agent,
came into the clinic because of frontal
headache. "Doctor, I've had this on and
off headache for 3 months already. I had
a consult with our company physician
and she gave me Paracetamol." (Looks at
the floor). ”I’ve been religiously taking
the mediation, it recurred again and now
it it is making me dizzy, too." (patient
shifts in her seat and looks at the floor)
"I went back to our company doctor and
she gave me Mefenamic Acid. I have
been taking it for 1 week now but the
headache still recurs. I just can't
23. REFLECTING FEELING
The doctor-counselor will articulate the
feelings for the patient
Reflecting feelings have therapeutic
purposes
1. Articulating the feelings makes the patient
aware of the emotion
2. Unarticulated feelings have somehow a way
of taking control of the behavior
3. Patient feels understood if feelings are
accurately reflected
It is important for the doctor-counselor
to realize the the feelings are neither
right nor wrong.
24. REFLECTING
FEELING
Case: 33/F, single, a call center agent,
came into the clinic because of frontal
headache. "Doctor, I've had this on and
off headache for 3 months already. I had
a consult with our company physician
and she gave me Paracetamol." (Looks at
the floor). ”I’ve been religiously taking
the mediation, it recurred again and now
it it is making me dizzy, too." (patient
shifts in her seat and looks at the floor)
"I went back to our company doctor and
she gave me Mefenamic Acid. I have
been taking it for 1 week now but the
headache still recurs. I just can't
Doctor-Counselor:
“You seem to be
anxious about your
on and off
headache.”
25. REFLECTING EXPERIENCE
Reflecting of non-verbals that are
often done unconsciously and that
the patients are not aware of doing
them.
Patient becomes aware of his/her
behavior by pointing out the non-
verbals
The patient may be able to gain
insight if he/she becomes aware of
the feeling or perception behind the
26. REFLECTING
EXPERIENCE
Case: 33/F, single, a call center agent,
came into the clinic because of frontal
headache. "Doctor, I've had this on and
off headache for 3 months already. I had
a consult with our company physician
and she gave me Paracetamol." (Looks at
the floor). ”I’ve been religiously taking
the mediation, it recurred again and now
it it is making me dizzy, too." (patient
shifts in her seat and looks at the floor)
"I went back to our company doctor and
she gave me Mefenamic Acid. I have
been taking it for 1 week now but the
headache still recurs. I just can't
Doctor-Counselor: “I
noticed that your
voice became softer
and you became
teary eyed when you
you said that the
headache still
recurred even with
the new medication.
Can you tell me what
was behind that
27. FOCUSING
When a patient is anxious or emotionally in
pain, they have the tendency to bring up a lot of
things in their mind or they present with a
jumble of emotions
What to do?
1. Enumerate the emotions.
2. Ask the patient to choose which one is the most
troublesome for him/her.
3. Talk about the issue or emotion that is giving
him/her most pain.
28. PROBING
Asking questions in order to elicit more
information
It must be open-ended
Probing for feelings > Probing for content
“How does that make you feel?”
“Can you tell me more about that feeling?”
Probe…
1. Where the emotional content is greatest
2. What the patient decides to mention last
3. When the patient repeats several times
29. SUMMARY
1. Counseling is a set of techniques, skills
and attitudes that can help address the
psychosocial issues associated with the
biomedical problem of the patient
2. The key attitudes of a doctor-
counselor are Genuineness,
Unconditional Positive Regard and
Empathy
3. The active listening skills are essential
to fully understand what a patient
would like to say. Verbal and non-
verbal cues are equally important.
Active listening skills include:
Attending, Bracketing, Leading,
30. Are you ready for the
workshop/interactive session?
Thank you for listening!
Editor's Notes
Good day! I'm Dr. Ofina and today we will discuss Counseling and Active Listening Skills
This will be the learning objectives of today's lecture:
READ the objectives :)
This is a good message from Doherty and Baird....
READ the Message :)
This means that the the psychosocial issues of the disease is also important when treating a patient. We should keep in my that we should also take note of the pschosocial impart of the disease to the life of a patient. Therefore, we should always used the Biopsychosocial model when dealing with a patient's illness.
This is a diagram that summarizes the biopsychosocial approach to health. This approach helps doctors to understand the interactions among the biological, psychological and social components of illness. By using this model, it helps us to think that a simple illness may be complex at it seems and so we need to use a multidisciplinary approach to its management. We should not focus only on the disease process but also its impact to our patient. We need to ask our patient what he thinks and feels about his illness.
The psychosocial component of the Biopsychosocial model to health is addressed by Counseling. Counseling is defined as a set of techniques, skills and attitudes to help people manage their own problems using their own resources.
It is important to note that SKILLS alone is not enough. We should also possess the key attitudes of a good counselor which will be discussed later on. There are 3 main goals of primary care counseling: One is to provide self insight which could help in the decision-making processes in the future, second is to help the patient to change towards a positive behavior. Lastly, counseling helps in the relief of the symptom associated with the psychosocial component of the disease. An example of which is psychosocial issues affecting the expression of pain of the patient.
When do we start counseling to our patient. The following are the consderations when to start counseling:
READ the slides!
Counseling has 4 distinct functions or purposes:
The first function which is to give support is done by helping the patients thorugh a difficult time. The aim is to make the patient feel that you are concerned and available to listen and help them with their problems.
While the supportive function of primary care counseling is to comfort the disturbed, Counseling is also used to disturb the comfortable. Hence another function of primary care counseling is to challenge the illusive sense of good health of the patient.
The third function of primary care counseling is to educate. Education about the disease is not enough. It should be connected with the misperceptions of the patient and his families to make education more effective.
Lastly, preventive purpose of counseling is provide anticipatory guidance regarding diseases in the future.
Before we discuss the active listening skills, Let us first review the Rogerian model which is very much related to active listening skills. Active listening is first developed by Rogers and Farson as a therapeutic technique designed to promote positive change in the client.
Doctors who applied the client-centered approach of Carl Rogers to counseling, call this model the “patient-centered” approach. And it fits very well to Family Medicine practice.
The Rogerian Model of Therapy is very useful to doctor-patient setting. The problem starts when there discrepancy or incongruence between what is actual and what is perceive. For example, a patient who complains of headache will come to your clinic will insist of having a Cranial CT Scan because he had a friend who died 2 weeks after the onset of headache. Although the headache of the patient is not the same as that of his friend, we should take note that the death of his friend may cause fear and anxiety to him.
This model of therapy is very helpful in dealing with the biomedical condition and its emotional impact to the patient.
There are times that we encounter patients who presents with symptoms that have no biomedical basis or the biomedical aspect id aggravated by a psychosocial factor. An example of which is a young patient who is stressed because her boss gives her a lot of pressure at work comes in to the clinic with a chief complaint of chest pain. The first thing that will come in to your mind is “is this a cardiac pathology”. And then later on after doing a comprehensive history taking and examination, you find out that the chest pain due stress leading to increased acid reflux.
As I’ve said earlier, Skills alone is not enough to make a counseling effective. The doctor-counselor must possess the 3 key attitudes as prescribed by Carl Rogers. These are the following: READ!!!
Genuineness demands transparency. It has 3 key ingredients:
Self-awareness is the knowledge of one’s biases and prejudices, perceptions, values and belief systems. It is best that the doctor-counselor is more aware of himself to be able to do effective counseling.
Self-acceptance, on the other hand, refer to one’s ownership of the full range of feelings and thoughts one has and not being ashamed of any part of it, whether it is positive or negative.
Although self-acceptance is important, we should be cautious in expressing these innermost thoughts and feelings.
Unconditional positive regard in Rogerian Method means that we set aside the conditions, such as biases and prejudices inherited from upbringing, for the period that we are dealing with our patient. This means that we should accept and respect our patients for what he or she is. This enables a patient to look at himself– even at the things about himself that he does not like and he judges as unacceptable – and later on gives him the insight leading to constructive action.
The last key attitude a good doctor-counselor must have is Empathy. This refers to the ability to put oneself in the situation of another. This enables us to understand our patient’s feelings as if we were having them ourselves.
After reviewing Counseling and its functions as well as the attitudes that a of a good doctor-counselor must have, we now go to the skills that we must have for effective counseling. Active listening is an essential skill a doctor-counselor must have to fully understand what a patient is saying. It basically involves all the senses in giving full attention to our patients. We do not just listen to what our patients say verbally but we are also attentive of the body language, the tone of the voice, etc.
The following are the different active listening skills that we apply In primary care counseling.
READ the definition!
A good acronym to summarize the attending skills a doctor-counselor must have is LOVERS
(Read!!!))
Bracketing is setting aside your own thoughts, feelings and judgements that detract from emphatizing with the patient. This skill is not a verbal or a non-verbal skill but more of a mental skill. Most of the time we think of questions we want to ask to our patient while he is still talking. The questions are influenced by how we look at the problem which can be affected by our own biases, prejudices and experiences.
We need to set aside these thoughts, feelings and judgements so we can see the world from the patient’s point of view.
Leading Skills are of 2 different kinds
Indirect leads are open invitations made by the doctot-counselor to allow the patient to talk more. The Doctor-counselor must not use questions that are answerable by yes or no. We may ask questions like “What would you like to talk about?” or “What can I do for you” or use phrases like “yes”, “go on”, “and then?”
Direct lead on the other hand is when a doctor-counselor make a judgement call as to where the patient should go and asks him to go in that particular direction. This judgement is usually signaled by some circumstances like where the feeling is greatest or most intense or sometimes what the patient saves for last which is the most important issues for him.
Reflecting skills have 3 different types –
READ!
As we differentiate the 3, I have prepared a case so we can also practice how to do the different reflecting skills
Reflecting Content is when the doctor-counselor takes the verbal content of what the patient says, repackages and rephrases it so that it becomes clearer and we give it back to the patient. This can be done by either paraphrasing or by perception checking. So what is the difference between the 2?
Paraphrasing is summarizing in ten words what it took the patient hundred words to say. Perception Cheking, on the other hand, is like paraphrasing but phrased in the interrogative way.
Let us go through the case! (READ)
So this is our case!
Case: 33/F, single, a call center agent, came into the clinic because of frontal headache. "Doctor, I've had this on and off headache for 3 months already. I had a consult with our company physician and she gave me Paracetamol." (Looks at the floor). ”I’ve been religiously taking the mediation, it recurred again and now it it is making me dizzy, too." (patient shifts in her seat and looks at the floor) "I went back to our company doctor and she gave me Mefenamic Acid. I have been taking it for 1 week now but the headache still recurs. I just can't understand what is happening to me". (Voice becomes softer and patient became teary eyed)
So this is one way of parapharising it. READ!
Reflecting Content is when the doctor-counselor takes the verbal content of what the patient says, repackages and rephrases it so that it becomes clearer and we give it back to the patient. This can be done by either paraphrasing or by perception checking. So what is the difference between the 2?
Paraphrasing is summarizing in ten words what it took the patient hundred words to say. Perception Cheking, on the other hand, is like paraphrasing but phrased in the interrogative way.
Let us go through the case! (READ)
In reflecting feeling, we articulate the feelings of our patients. There are therapeutic purposes when articulating patients’ feelings.
First We make our patients aware of their emotion by giving a name to their feelings.
Second, When we help the patients articulate their feelings, we allow them to take responsibility and control of their behavior
Third, When we articulate their feelings correctly, we make them feel that they are understood and this encourages them to open up even more.
When articulating the feelings of our patient, we should realize that these feelings are neither right or wrong. The actions that come as a result of these feelings should be assessed as neither right or wrong and not the feelings themselves.
Going back to our case, how are we going to reflect the feeling?
The third type of reflecting skills is reflecting experience. This skill is focused on reflecting the non-verbals of the patients that are often done unconsciously and that the patients are not aware of doing. The doctor-counselor allows the patient to become aware of his behavior by pointing out his non-verbals. In some cases, this could even make the patient to gain insight if he becomes aware of the feeling brought about by his non-verbal.
Going back to our case, an example of reflecting experience is: READ!!!!
Focusing is the skills used by doctor-counselor to help him choose which direction to proceed if the patient has so many issues to deal with. When a patient is anxious or emotionally in pain, they have the tendency to bring up a lot of things in their mind or they present with a jumble of emotions.
The doctor-counselor will ask the patient to enumerate all the emotions.
He will then as the patient to choose which is most disturbing or most important to him.
Whichever the patient chooses, that is where the the doctor-counselor should go on.
The last active listening skill that we will discuss is probing. Probing is done by asking questions in order to elicit more information. Questions must be open-ended.
An example of these questions are “how does that make you feel?’ OR “Could you tell me more about…”
IN probing, it is more worthwhile to probe for the feeling than the content.
Just like the guideline of Direct Leading Skills, we probe:
Where the emotional content is greatest
What the patient decides to mention last
When the patient repeats several times