BSc Dissertation

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
1
Methods of Enquiry Dissertation: Modified photodynamic
therapy treatment for toenail onychomycosis in adults:
study protocol for a randomised controlled trial
Word Count
Pages 4-16 (up to “Trial Status”) 4,843 words
Less tables and headings 741 words
Revised word count 4,102 words
Within 10% allowance of the 4,000 word limit
Not including pages after “Trial Status” i.e. reference list, figures and appendices
Competing interests
The author declares that he has no competing interests.
Authors’ Contribution and Acknowledgements
This manuscript was prepared as a Methods of Experimental Design (MoED) dissertation
towards a BSc Podiatry Degree at the University of Salford. The author gratefully
acknowledges the University of Salford and his supervisor, Dr Andrew H. Findlow, for his
expert supervision, advice and support.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
2
Table of Contents
Table of Contents.......................................................................................................................2
Abbreviations.............................................................................................................................3
1. Introduction....................................................................................................................4
1.1 Aims and objectives ....................................................................................................4
1.2 Topic justification .......................................................................................................5
2. Literature review and background .................................................................................6
3. Methodology and data collection...................................................................................9
3.1 Mycological Examination – Microscopy & Microbiological Analysis ....................11
3.2 Initial nail curettage or drilling..................................................................................12
3.3 Photodynamic therapy (PDT) intervention ...............................................................12
3.4 Clearanail therapy intervention ................................................................................13
3.5 Combined Treatment – Clearanail and PACTMED
+ PACT Nail Fungus Gel ...........14
3.6 Calculation and sample size......................................................................................14
3.7 Outcome Measures....................................................................................................15
3.8 Hypothesis.................................................................................................................15
3.9 Organisation and statistical analysis of data .............................................................16
4. Discussion....................................................................................................................16
4.1 Trial Status ................................................................................................................16
5. References....................................................................................................................18
5.1 Websites ....................................................................................................................18
5.2 Papers ........................................................................................................................18
6. Attachments .................................................................................................................22

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
3
Abbreviations
PDT: Photodynamic Therapy
PS: Photosensitiser
PACT: Photodynamic Antimicrobial Therapy
PACTMED
: PACTMED
630nm laser system (Hahn Medical Systems)
MB: Methylene Blue
TB: Toluidine Blue
LED: Light Emitting Diode
SA: Surface Area
ROS: Reactive Oxygen Species

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
4
1. Introduction
Topical antifungals may be able to treat minor superficial fungal nail infections, but the
majority of presenting fungal nails involve a full thickness lesion against which topical
antifungals struggle to be effective. Recently, a new device, Clearanail, has been developed
which safely drills 0.4mm holes into the nail plate, allowing antifungal treatments direct
access the nail bed (Richards, 2015). A number of case studies have reported effective
treatment using the Clearanail device, with visible results claimed within two to eight weeks,
and resolution from 3 months. Prior to Clearanail arriving on the market in 2015, the other
device widely advertised for the safe treatment of fungal nails was the commercially
available PACTMED
(Photodynamic Antimicrobial Therapy) LED laser (figure 1). The
PACTMED
system claimed to combat fungal infections with a single treatment or repeated
treatments over a week, with effectiveness being apparent at approximately three months
once the affected nail has had chance to grow out (Hahn Medical Systems, n.d.). However,
there are no full scale clinical trials evaluating these two devices and their effectiveness in
treating toenail onychomycosis.
1.1 Aims and objectives
This study proposes to evaluate both PACTMED
and Clearanail, and a combined treatment to
see if enhanced efficacy and clinical cure rate can be achieved. Table 1 describes the thought
process from the initial hypothesis, to considering the problem and the population involved,
to the intervention groups proposed and the outcome measures.
Table 1 - Defining the research question
Initial Hypothesis:
Do nail plate perforations significantly improve the absorption of the photosensitising (PS) agent?
General nature of the problem:
In older people who may not be suitable for oral antifungal treatments, due its side effects or drug-drug
interactions, can we find a non-systemic treatment that can effectively treat fungal nails?
Population:
People with fungal nails, affecting up to 28% of adults over 60 years of age (Gupta, et al., 1997).
Intervention:
Group 1: PACTMED photodynamic therapy using PACT-Nail Fungus Gels (PS agent)

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
5
Group 2: Clearanail treatment followed by topical antifungal treatment – Lamisil spray
Group 3: Combined treatment of Clearanail perforations with PACTMED
PDT
Outcome:
Measure clinical outcome at 12 weeks (3 months) to 48 weeks (11 months), thus requiring at least 12 weeks for
the onychomycotic nail to begin to grow out, with eukaryotic nail developing – hopefully showing clearance
from fungus.
Outcome measures could involve looking at: nail regrowth (total, partial, or no clearance from fungus); fungal
cure rate (visual and mycological testing at 48 weeks); satisfaction (questionnaire); reduction in discomfort
(questionnaire); reduction in pain and improved mobility (questionnaire).
1.2 Topic justification
Generally, the NHS does not offer alternative non-systemic anti-fungal nail treatments for the
elderly or for those for whom oral or topical antifungals would either be ineffective or would
pose too much risk in terms of side effects (gastrointestinal disturbances, headache, change in
taste), and systemic antifungals have the potential to affect liver function (United States
National Library of Medicine, n.d.). Often with the elderly, fungal nails are simply managed
with appropriate cutting and filing, but a problem arises when they are not managed
appropriately and they become dystrophic and hyperkeratotic. This can cause pressure
leading to discomfort, possibly pain and reduced mobility, and may lead to ulcers and create
a wound as a site for infection. A recent study involving 150 subjects with fungal toenails
found that 54% had toenail discomfort, whilst 36% reported pain on walking which limited
mobility (Lubeck et al., 2014).
Fungal nails affect up to 28% of the population over the age of 60 (Gupta, et al., 1997), and
as a significant proportion of this population then goes on to suffer discomfort and pain from
their dystrophic hyperkeratotic nails, there is a clear need for an effective antifungal treatment
that will be suitable for patients who otherwise would not be candidates for oral anti-fungal
treatment, including the immunocompromised and the elderly with contraindications.
The PACTMED
system offers a simple and safe device that can be used with a photosensitiser
(PS) to target and treat onychomycotic toenails. As a specific wavelength of light is used (630
nm), there is no risk of heat generation, and the fungicidal effect is from the creation of ROS
within the tissue itself, rather than by heat destruction as with thermolytic lasers.
The Clearanail device safely perforates the nail plate allowing access to the nail bed, and
provides a useful port of entry to target fungal nail infections, vastly improving the surface

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
6
area available for treatment (see Appendices 1A and 1B). Case studies using Lamisil spray or
gel over a Clearanail perforated nail plate have reported successful clearing of toenail fungus
(Mason, 2015a; 2015b).
PDT in the PACTMED
system provides a useful antifungal tool to treat toenail onychomycosis.
The development of PDT continues today, and there are a number of different photodynamic
therapies available, ranging from treating cancerous cells (Brown, Brown, & Walker, 2004;
Shafirstein et al., 2015; Bahner & Bordeaux, 2013), to use in dental surgery to treat infected
root canals (‘Cumdente – Photoactivated therapy’, n.d.; Konopka & Goslinski, 2007; Gursoy,
et al., 2012). There are also further developments with PS dyes linked to antibodies or
antibody fragments for very specific targeted PDT (Drobizhev et al., 2006; Renno et al.,
2004).
2. Literature review and background
PDT in one of earliest forms of photo-medicine and can be traced back some 3,000 years to
ancient Egypt where an extract from the plant Ammi majus containing the furanocoumarin
compound psoralem was used on the skin to induce a beneficial photoreaction in sunlight to
help cure various skin aliments (Hamblin & Huang, 2013). From the 18th
Century onwards,
the benefits of light therapy or sunbathing were described for several conditions, including
rickets. The first reported PDT discovery was made in 1900 by Rabb, a medical student in
Munich, Germany, and von Tappeiner. They found that the combination of the dye acridine
red and light exposure, killed infusoria. By 1907, the term ‘photodynamic action’ was used to
describe the use of a PS dye being activated by light to cause a beneficial cytotoxic effect
(ibid).
PDT uses ROS produced by a non-toxic PS, activated by red/blue low intensity light to cause
a cytotoxic effect against microbial cells, cancer cells, and fungi, but leaving the majority of
healthy mammalian cells intact. Mammalian cells are more resistant to the ROS and singlet
oxygen molecules produced by PDT.
The photochemical process is concerned with matching light of the appropriate wavelength to
the absorption band of the PS dye. By matching these two elements, the applied light at that
specific wavelength is 100 times more intense without becoming hot. By comparison, white

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
7
light would generate heat if the intensity was increased 100 fold. In PDT this filtered
wavelength of light, specific to the dye or PS used, gives sufficient photon energy to the
absorbed PS molecule, exciting it into a triplet state which can then transfer energy to ground
state oxygen molecules present in tissue, and excite the oxygen into a singlet state or ROS
(Castano, Demidova, & Hamblin, 2004). Figure 2 (page 24) illustrates the photochemical
mechanism in PDT, and Figure 3 (page 25) illustrates the fungal cell wall structure that is
destroyed by ROS/singlet oxygen by oxidative cross-linking and fragmentation of the
proteins within the fungal cell wall (Kharkwal, et al., 2011).
The excited PS triplet state can cause two types of reaction within the normal physiological
oxygen molecules present within the tissue:
1. Type I reaction – superoxide or ROS – cytotoxic to microbial cells and host cells.
2. Type II reaction – singlet oxygen – cytotoxic to microbial cells and host cells.
A simplified mode of action is presented in Table 2:
Table 2 - Simplified mode of action
PS molecule absorbed into tissue e.g. toluidine blue – inactivate i.e. ‘Ground state PS molecule’
Photon energy is absorbed from the specific wavelength of the light source used
This photon energy causes the PS molecule to become excited into a state referred as – ‘first excited singlet state
PS molecule’
Then as the singlet PS molecule slightly loses a bit of energy by fluorescence or by intersystem crossing - where
there is a change in the spin of an electron, i.e. by slight loss of energy the excited PS molecule enters into a
third more stable excited state, the ‘PS triplet state’.
It is this PS triplet state that gives rise to ROS type I (superoxide O2
-
) and type II (singlet oxygen 1
O2) reactions.
Singlet oxygen as a result of the type II reaction - is widely believed to be the major damaging species in PACT
(Donnelly, McCarron, & Tunney, 2008; Konan, Gurny, & Allémann, 2002)
The fungal cell wall is made up is made of a plasm membrane coated by a thick layer of beta-
glucan and chitin which acts as a permeability barrier making it more difficult for the PS to
bind. It is common for a permeabilising agent such as EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic
acid) to be used with the PS, but other mechanisms can be used such as imparting a cationic
charge to the PS molecule to improve absorption (Valduga, et al., 1993). PS agents that have

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
8
been used in clinical studies, include: phenothiazinium dyes such as methylene blue (MB)
and toluidine blue (TB); porphyrins such as aminolevulinic acid (ALA) and
methylaminolevulinate (MAL); and heamatoporphyrin derivatives, such as neutral red,
indocyanine green, chlorophyll, and polyethyleneimine chlorin(e6) conjugate (PEI-ce6
conjugate). There are also endogenous porphyrins, for example those naturally produced by
the most common acne-causing bacterium Propionibacterium acne, which allow PDT
therapy to treat acne without the need to apply any additional PS agent (Elman, Slatkine, &
Harth, 2003). There is a wider range of PS agents which may have better properties but
would require FDA approval for human clinical trials, but further PS advances are being
made. For example, Osmium (II) is a biquinoline-based PS able to absorb light at
wavelengths throughout the green, red, and near infrared spectrum, allowing selective
activation to destroy cancerous targets at a wide range of tissue depths (Fleck, 2015). In
respect of the PACTMED
system which operates at 630nm, it has been reported that this
wavelength achieves a penetrative depth in the order of 1-3mm, and that increasing the
wavelength to 700-850nm can double the penetrative depth (Svaasand, 1984; Wilson, Jeeves,
& Lowe, 1985), but for oxidative action, the tissue needs to absorb the PS molecule to the
appropriate depth for activation.
Toenail fungus can affect up to 10% of the population with a 28% incidence in those over 60,
and it would not be uncommon for a podiatrist to see at least 2-3 patients every day who are
affected by onychomycotic toenails. Several studies have been conducted using PDT to treat
affected toenails with varying degrees of success. Souza et al. (2013) compared 40 patients
undergoing PDT with methylene blue (MB) as the PS and another 40 patients using an oral
fluconazole treatment. The inclusion criteria included having a positive mycological
examination confirmed by direct microscopic examination of the subungual material, or by
confirmation of positive cultures. The cohorts were further subdivided into those with
significant subungual hyperkeratosis (>2mm) requiring nail filing or curettage prior to PDT
(the ‘realised’ group), and those with nail thickness of ≤2mm who did not (the ‘unrealised’
group). Following PDT treatment lasting 24 weeks, and after a further 24 weeks, there was a
90% clinical cure rate in the MB-PDT patients with nail thickness ≤2mm (unrealised)
compared to a 78% clinical cure rate with patients with nail thickness originally >2mm and
having been subject to curettage (realised). When compared to the group taking fluconazole,
the author reported a 46% cure rate in patients with nail thickness ≤2mm. The 90% clinical

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
9
cure rate had actually been 100% at week 24, and is assumed that by week 48, 10% of those
patients had become re-infected. MB-PDT treatment had no systemic adverse events or
photo-toxicity reactions (ibid; Heyes, 2015).
In a separate study, Souza et al. (2014) looked at MB PDT therapy over a 6-month period
(treatment was given at 15 day intervals) of 22 patients, 11 of whom had severe toenail
onychomycosis. In all patients, Trichophyton rubrum was confirmed by mycology and none
had used any antifungal medication in the previous four months. The severe onychomycotic
cases had nail curettage and filing performed prior to treatment. In patients classed as having
mild to moderate onychomycosis, a 100% clinical cure rate was observed at 48 weeks and a
64% clinical cure rate was observed in the severe onychomycotic group. Again this
confirmed that MB PDT produces a favourable outcome, with 18 out of 22 patients having
achieved a clinical cure and with no adverse effects reported (ibid; Heyes, 2015).
A further study using a less intensive regime of PDT treatment was conducted by Tardivo et
al. (2015). They used a MB:TB-PDT therapy, repeated monthly. Results were based on visual
appearance at the end of the treatment session, being classed as complete clearance, partial
clearance, or no change. It was found that using this monthly PDT regime resulted in 28
patients (45%) showing complete clearance, 25 patients (40%) showing partial clearance, and
9 (15%) showing no change. The average number of sessions required for those patients to
achieve 100% clearance was 5. This compared favourably with other PDT regimens requiring
bi-weekly treatments over a 6-month period. The clinical cure rate was still good, and was
comparable to that achieved with oral antifungal medication. However, this study was based
purely on observational findings (Tardivo, Wainwright, & Baptista, 2015; Heyes, 2015).
3. Methodology and data collection
This study will comply with regulations governing research involving human subjects, and
approval will be sought from the Research Ethics Committee of the University of Salford.
The study will be registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, or an International Standard
Randomised Controlled Trial Number (ISRCTN) will be obtained in accordance with the
Research Governance Framework (England). Participants will be informed of the procedures
and will be asked to sign a statement of informed consent.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
10
Male and female patients enrolled at the University of Salford Podiatry Clinic will be
recruited for the study. Those aged between 40 and 80 years with visual distal and lateral
subungual toenail onychomycosis and having a positive mycological diagnosis for toenail
onychomycosis will be included. The inclusion and exclusion criteria (see Table 3) excludes:
patients with non-healed foot or plantar lesions; those with non-healed leg ulcers; those
undergoing cancer treatment; those having had antibiotic therapy in the last month; those who
are pregnant; and those with a known hypersensitivity to toluidine blue (PACT Fungal Nail
Gel) and 10% urea cream) or Lamisil antifungal spray. As this is a randomised clinical trial,
the recommendations of the Consolidating Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) will
be used to ensure greater transparency and quality (see Figure 4). For ethical considerations,
risk analysis, scope and limitations, see Appendices 2, 3 and 4. A further research question is
presented in Appendix 5, and the pros and cons of PDT are broadly considered in Appendix
6.
Table 3 - Inclusion / exclusion criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
Male and female adults aged 60 ± 20 years of age enrolled at the podiatry clinic of the University of Salford
Patients diagnosed positively for toenail onychomycosis:
1. POSITIVE Qualitative Examination i.e. presenting with clinical signs of onychomycosis –
discolouration / dystrophy of the nail plate / subungual debris / or onycholysis
2. POSITIVE Microscopic examination of the subungual material with 20% potassium hydroxide to
confirm the presence of fungal hyphae
3. POSITIVE Culture using Sabouraud agar gel with chloramphenicol and cycloheximide to identify the
presence of fungi
Exclusion Criteria:
Patients with nail changes because of skin disease or associated systemic disease
Patients who have undergone oral antifungal medication within the last 6 months
Patients undergoing any other current podiatry treatment e.g. corrective surgery or ongoing verrucae treatment
etc.
Patients with any osteomyelitis or gout trophi
Patients with any open or unhealed foot or lower leg lesions
Patients undergoing any cancer treatment (i.e. if receiving PDT therapy for cancerous lesions – the patient may
already have been injected with a photosensitiser)

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
11
Patients under any current antibiotic treatment or having taken antibiotics within the last month
Female patients currently pregnant
Patients with any known hypersensitivity or allergy to the photosensitiser
3.1 Mycological Examination – Microscopy & Microbiological Analysis
Clinical signs of toenail onychomycosis (nail dystrophy, discolouration, onycholysis,
subungual debris, hyperkeratosis, and ridges) will be confirmed by microscopic examination
of the subungual matter with 20% potassium hydroxide (with blue or black dye) to confirm
the presence of fungal hyphae. Culture will be performed using nail curettage on Sabouraud
agar with chloramphenicol and cycloheximide to isolate Trichophyton and Candida species.
Positive microbiological analyses should confirm that the majority of the fungal infections
are caused by Trichophyton rubrum, Trichophyton mentagrophytis or Candida albicans.
Table 4 confirms that treatment groups 1, 2 and 3 will be comprised of patients presenting
with onychomycosis as identified by both positive microscopy and positive culture results.
Previous studies have shown successful treatment of fungi both in vivo and in vitro, using
both methylene blue (MB) and toluidine blue (TB) as the photosensitising agent in PDT
treatment (Kharkwal, et al., 2011). Where possible, if the causative organism can be
successfully identified, this will also be noted for further analysis.
Table 4 – Summary of experimental conditions
Group Toenail Onychomycosis Qualitatively
Present
Treatment
1
POSITIVE MYCOLOGICAL
EXAMINATION:
POSITIVE microscopy i.e. identification
of fungal hyphae under the microscope
and
POSITIVE culture on Sabouraud agar
with chloramphenicol and cycloheximide
confirming the presence of a fungal sp.
PDT repeated on 3 successive days
+ sham daily urea cream and Lamisil spray as
prophylaxis for 3 months
2 Clearanail treatment
(repeated at week 6)
+ daily urea cream and Lamisil spray for 3
months
3 COMBINED TREATMENT:
Clearanail & PDT repeated on 3 successive
days
+ daily urea cream and Lamisil spray for 3
months

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
12
PDT = Photodynamic Therapy using the PACTMED
system and PACT Nail Fungus Gel (toluidine blue based
photosensitiser)
3.2 Initial nail curettage or drilling
Photographs will be taken of all onychomycotic toenails prior to treatment. Patients with
severe toenail onychomycosis (nail dystrophy and hyperkeratosis >2mm thickness) will
undergo nail drilling to reduce the nail down to approximately 2mm thickness. A suitable
tungsten carbide burr will be used to enable quick and effective reduction. Patients
undergoing curettage due to excessive thickness immediately prior to subsequent treatment
will be termed ‘realised’. Patients where severe onychomycosis causes the nail plate to
crumble and disintegrate on curettage will also be termed ‘realised’. Patients with toenail
onychomycosis where the nail plate has remained ≤ 2mm will undergo nail filing with a
diamond deb nail dresser (a new file will be used for each patient to ensure roughening up of
the nail surface), and these patients will be termed ‘unrealised’ within their appropriate
treatment groups.
3.3 Photodynamic therapy (PDT) intervention
The PACTMED
nail fungus therapy (Hahn Medical Systems) LED laser will be used. It
produces a red light (630 nm) and comes shielded, allowing the light source to be accurately
placed 25mm above the nail plate while shielding the user and patient from intense light
exposure. The PS developed by Hahn Medical systems (PACT Nail Fungus Gel) will be
used, which is a toluidine blue based dye (phenothiazinium derivative) with no known or
reported cytotoxicity at the concentrations present in the gel formula. It is assumed that the
gel formula may also contain an ingredient such as EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid)
to help with tissue absorption. Only the volunteer and patient will be present at the time of
PDT, and both will be given the appropriate protective eyewear. All fungal infected nails will
be treated, and sufficient time should be scheduled to enable complete treatment, which may
be speeded up by purchasing a second laser unit and treating the nails of the other foot
simultaneously. The PACT Nail Fungus Gel will be applied generously over the affected
nails, ensuring that the entire nail has been covered by gel, and it will be allowed to act for 10
minutes. Within this period, the gel will also be rubbed under the nail fold and nail wall using
an applicator stick to ensure that all exposed affected areas have been covered. Immediately
following this period, the affected nail will be treated with the PACTMED
laser for 9.5 minutes

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
13
(570 seconds) at an approximate distance of 25mm, the shield guard enabling correct
positioning. PDT therapy will be repeated three times on successive days. Following PDT
treatment on the first day, the patient will be also be given CCS 10% urea cream to apply at
night, followed by application of Lamisil spray (an antifungal) in the morning, after complete
drying if the patient has had a shower or bath. This treatment of CCS 10% urea cream and
Lamisil will continue for 12 weeks. The application of CCS 10% urea cream and Lamisil
may help to assist as a prophylaxis preventing re-infection, and will enable test conditions to
be compared against the other treatment groups (Group 2 – Clearanail, and Group 3
combined Clearanail + PDT treatments). The patient will also be offered the opportunity to
bring in all their shoes for decontamination using MesoSilver®
antifungal spray, and advised
on best practices to prevent re-infection, such as changing and washing bath mats and
bedding on a hot wash cycle.
3.4 Clearanail therapy intervention
The Clearanail device allows painless and safe drilling of the nail plate, creating 0.4mm
diameter holes (using disposable tips). This device is relatively new to the market, with the
device having been featured in Podiatry Now (Richards, 2015) and with case studies having
been published in March 2015 (Mason, 2015a) and further reports of successful use in the
treatment of onychomycotic nails (Mason, 2015b). To standardise the treatment, the device
will be used to drill holes over the entire surface of the affected nails at approximately 2mm
spacing (see Appendix 1A). A large toenail of width 18mm x length 18mm would require
some 64 holes using this spatial density, whilst a smaller toenail of say 8mm x 8mm would
require only 9. A perforated spatial density template will be created from a plastic nail cover
to ensure standardisation of this spacing. This arrangement will effectively create 1.6mm
bridges between adjacent perforations. A simple calculation of surface area before and after
drilling shows that the top surface area of the nail plate is only reduced by some 2%, and
therefore that the nail plate integrity will remain intact. However, this 2% of ‘opened’ surface
area vastly increases the surface area available within the drilled space itself, analogous to an
open-ended cylinder. PS absorption into the underlying tissue from the drilled pockets may
significantly improve efficacy, allowing the PS dye to penetrate deeper into the surrounding
tissues, the SA having been increased by up to 100%, as illustrated at Appendix 1B. This will
enable improved PS absorption into the nail bed for fungal treatment. Successful case studies

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
14
have been reported using Lamisil spray or gel in this manner on the perforated nail plate
(Mason, 2015a; 2015b), showing improved absorption of the active ingredient into the
underlying tissue. In this study, the device will be used to drill holes into onychomycotic
nails, which will then either be treated with Lamisil spray alone (as in Group 2), or they will
be subjected to PDT PACTMED
therapy as in (Group 3) with the PACT Nail Fungus Gel being
rubbed into the perforations and then subsequently being subjected to daily Lamisil
treatment.
3.5 Combined Treatment – Clearanail and PACTMED
+ PACT Nail Fungus Gel
The combined treatment will use both approaches, with predrilling using the Clearanail
device followed by PDT therapy accordingly. Daily Lamisil and urea cream treatment will be
continued for a total of 12 weeks. It is envisaged that this hybrid approach will vastly
improve the efficacy of the absorption of the PS dye and make the PDT treatment more
effective at treating the underlying fungus in the nail plate bed, enhancing outcome.
3.6 Calculation and sample size
The error was established as , in which and are the means of groups 1 and 2.
Assuming both samples are the same size (n1 = n2), the sample size is obtained from the
following equation:
in which and are the variances in groups 1 and 2, respectively. However, as more than
two groups will be studied, covariate-adjusted analyses were used, by adopting the error
found in the study performed by Figueiredo Souza, et al. (2013), who had initially evaluated
142 patients with clinical signs suggestive of onychomycosis. Of these, 95 satisfied the
inclusion criteria and 80 agreed to participate in and completed the study. This group was
randomly divided into two groups, each with 40 patients. In this proposed study, where the
endpoint is a comparative evaluation of the treatment groups (i.e. clinical cure rate – full,
partial or none), the required sample size has been matched at 40 patients per group, totalling
120 patients over the 3 groups. However, as we expect 5% of data to be randomly missing
from 3 covariates, the sample size has been corrected:

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
15
120 / 0.95
3 = 140 patients (i.e. 47 patients per group; groups A, B, C)
As each group is further sub-divided into two sets (realised and unrealised), the group size
was increased by 1 to 48 patients per group, making 24 patients per subset, or 144 in total.
Therefore, based on the study by Figueiredo Souza et al. (2013), it was determined that each
group should contain 48 participants. As they originally recruited 144 participants, which had
dropped to 80 by the end of the experiment, a similar extrapolation was made, in that to
achieve 144 ‘completed participants’, an initial recruitment of 259 would be required.
3.7 Outcome Measures
Only participants that have shown positive mycological examination (positive microscopy
and positive culture for fungal identification) will form part of the research, which limits the
treatment groups to those with confirmed onychomycotic fungal toenails. The treatment
groups will be randomly assigned to one of the three groups. The treatment regimen will
formally cease at 12 weeks when daily application of urea cream (night treatment) and
Lamisil spray (day treatment) will cease. Observational evaluations of the nail plate will be
made at the beginning of therapy, and again at weeks 4 and 8 during treatment, and then at
weeks 12, 16, 24 and 48 post treatment, to assess complete, partial or non-clearance of the
original fungal infection. Photographs will also be taken at each stage for subsequent
analysis. Clinical cure (complete clearance) will be defined as the complete replacement of
the mycotic nail bed and dystrophic nail plate with a normal eutrophic nail, allowing for the
mycotic nail to grow out i.e. it is the new nail growth that will be assessed. Microbiological
assessment would be assessed prior to treatment and again at 11 months (48 weeks)
posttreatment.
Patient questionnaires could be developed to assess satisfaction, reduction in discomfort,
reduction in pain, or improved mobility, as a result of treatment.
3.8 Hypothesis
The null hypothesis is that there will be no change in the fungal infection following the use of
either treatment alone, or when combined. The experimental hypothesis is that each method
will produce a reduction in the fungal infection by use of PDT, or Clearanail-Lamisil, or by a

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
16
dual-combined treatment. It is postulated that the best response will be observed from the
dual treatment regimen combining PDT with Clearanail-Lamisil.
3.9 Organisation and statistical analysis of data
The Fisher’s Exact Test will be used to evaluate the correlation between the treatment groups
and time periods. Paired t-tests will be used to compare the data before and after each
treatment to determine whether the various treatments reduce the degree of fungal infection
or provide a clinical cure. Depending on the quality of the digital data collected, more
sophisticated analyses could be performed, rather than a simple assessment of full, partial, or
no clearance. Quantitative analyses of the digital photography, subject to it presenting with a
normal distribution, may allow analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by a Tukey test to
evaluate differences between each test group and fungal reduction. A Wilcoxon test will also
be used to analyse the data before and after each experiment. A significance level of  = 0.05
will be applied.
4. Discussion
The main objective of this proposed study is to evaluate the effect of the PDT (PACTMED
)
system developed by Hahn Medical Systems with the combined used of the Clearanail
device, improving the surface area for absorption of the photosensitising dye (PACT Nail
Fungal Gel) for more effective treatment, enabling enhanced absorption of the PS dye into
the nail plate bed and surrounding tissue. This objective has two aspects: the qualitative and
quantitative evaluation of a clinical cure or reduction in fungal infection. Qualitatively, the
OSI score could be used (Carney et al., 2011), and quantitative analysis of fungal reduction
could be performed using digital software (3D, edge recognition, or other available
quantitative medical imaging technologies). The findings are expected to provide convincing
evidence that PDT is more effective when used in conjunction with the Clearanail device to
achieve a satisfactory clinical cure rate after three simple successive treatments.
4.1 Trial Status
The study would require funding to purchase a Clearanail device and two PACTMED
LED
(630nm) lasers for use within the Podiatry Clinic at the University of Salford, to enable

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
17
research trials to be conducted. Any proposed trials would require consideration and approval
from the Research Ethics Committee at the University of Salford.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
18
5. References
5.1 Websites
A Simple Solution to A Complex Problem – Clearanail®
http://www.Clearanail.com/.
Retrieved from http://www.Clearanail.com/
New product launched to treat fungal nail infections. Edited by Clare Richards
http://issuu.com/redactive/docs/april_15_pn (2015). Podiatry Now- April 2015. Retrieved
from http://issuu.com/redactive/docs/april_15_pn
Terbinafine – United States National Library of Medicine – Liver Tox – Drug Record
Retrieved from http://livertox.nih.gov/Terbinafine.htm
Clearanail proves a hit with podiatrists. Edited by Mason, L. (2015). Clearanail proves a hit
with podiatrists | exceed magazine, Pg 13 October 2015. Retrieved from http://exceed-
magazine.com/review/Clearanail-proves-a-hit-with-podiatrists/
PACT® nail fungus therapy – for effective treatment of nail fungus infections.
Retrieved from http://www.hahnmedicalsystems.com/?page_id=77&lang=en
Cumdente – Photoactivated therapy (Dental concepts - PACT therapy). Retrieved from
https://www.cumdente.com/en/products/pact/pact-therapy.html
Clearanail to help banish fungal nail infections, Edited by Mason, L. (2015). Clearanail to
help banish fungal nail infections | exceed magazine pg 7 March 2015. Retrieved from
http://exceed-magazine.com/review/Clearanail-to-help-banish-fungal-nail-infections/
5.2 Papers
Bahner, J., & Bordeaux, J. (2013). Non-melanoma skin cancers: Photodynamic therapy,
cryotherapy, 5-fluorouracil, imiquimod, diclofenac, or what? Facts and controversies. Clinics
in dermatology. 6(31). Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24160289
Brown, S., Brown, E., & Walker, I. (2004). The present and future role of photodynamic
therapy in cancer treatment. The Lancet. Oncology. 8(5). Retrieved from
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15288239

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
19
Carney, C., Tosti, A., Daniel, R., Scher, R., Rich, P., DeCoster, J., & Elewski, B. (2011). A
new classification system for grading the severity of onychomycosis: Onychomycosis
severity index. Archives of dermatology. 11(147). Retrieved from
Castano, A., Demidova, T., & Hamblin (2004). Mechanisms in photodynamic therapy: Part
one-photosensitizers, photochemistry and cellular localization. Photodiagnosis and
photodynamic therapy. 4(1). Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25048432
Donnelly, R. F., McCarron, P. A., & Tunney, M. M. (2008). Antifungal photodynamic
therapy. Microbiological Research, 163(1), 1–12. doi:10.1016/j.micres.2007.08.001
Drobizhev, M., Gong, A., Meng, F., Rebane, A., Starkey, J. R., & Spangler, C. W. (2006,
February 9). Synthesis, characterization and preclinical studies of two-photon-activated
targeted PDT therapeutic triads. Retrieved from
http://proceedings.spiedigitallibrary.org/proceeding.aspx?articleid=1276071
Elman, M., Slatkine, M., & Harth, Y. (2003). The effective treatment of acne vulgaris by a
high‐intensity, narrow band 405–420 nm light source. Journal of Cosmetic and Laser
Therapy, 5(2), 111–117. doi:10.1080/14764170310001276
Figueiredo Souza, L. W., Souza, S. V. T., & Botelho, A. C. C. (2013). Randomized
controlled trial comparing photodynamic therapy based on methylene blue dye and
fluconazole for toenail onychomycosis. Dermatologic Therapy, 27(1), 43–47.
doi:10.1111/dth.12042
Fleck, C. (2015). Theralase anti-cancer technology presented at international laser
conference. Retrieved from http://www.kereport.com/2015/11/10/theralase-anticancer-
technology-presented-international-laser-conference/
Gupta, A., Jain, H., Lynde, C., Watteel, G., & Summerbell, R. (1997). Prevalence and
epidemiology of unsuspected onychomycosis in patients visiting dermatologists’ offices in
Ontario, Canada--a multicenter survey of 2001 patients. International journal of
dermatology. 10(36). Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9372358

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
20
Gursoy, H., Ozcakir-Tomruk, C., Tanalp, J., & Yilmaz, S. (2012). Photodynamic therapy in
dentistry: A literature review. Clinical oral investigations. 4(17). Retrieved from
Hamblin, M. R., & Huang, Y.-Y. (2013). Introduction. Retrieved from
http://www.crcnetbase.com/doi/abs/10.1201/b15582-3
Heyes, R. (2015). Photodynamic therapy in the treatment of onychomycosis. Unpublished
manuscript, Salford University.
Kharkwal, G., Sharma, S., Huang, Y., Dai, T., & Hamblin (2011). Photodynamic therapy for
infections: Clinical applications. Lasers in surgery and medicine. 7(43). Retrieved from
Konan, Y., Gurny, R., & Allémann, E. (2002). State of the art in the delivery of
photosensitizers for photodynamic therapy. Journal of photochemistry and photobiology. B,
Biology. 2(66). Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11897509
Konopka, K., & Goslinski, T. (2007). Photodynamic therapy in dentistry. Journal of dental
research. 8(86). Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17652195
Lubeck, D., Bates, M., Fisk, R., Stier, Gause, D., & Schein, J. (2014, April 1).
Onychomycosis. Baseline results of an observational study. Retrieved from
http://www.japmaonline.org/doi/abs/10.7547/87507315-87-11-512
Renno, R. Z., Miller, J. W., Terada, Y., Haddadin, M. J., Michaud, N. A., & Gragoudas, E. S.
(2004, July 1). Selective Photodynamic therapy by targeted Verteporfin delivery to
Experimental Choroidal Neovascularization mediated by a homing peptide to Vascular
endothelial growth factor receptor-2. Retrieved from
http://archopht.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=416431
Shafirstein, G., Rigual, N. R., Arshad, H., Cooper, M. T., Bellnier, D. A., Wilding, G.,
Henderson, B. W. (2015). Photodynamic therapy with 3-(1′-hexyloxyethyl)
pyropheophorbide-a for early-stage cancer of the larynx: Phase Ib study. Head & Neck.
doi:10.1002/hed.24003

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
21
Souza, L., Souza, S., & Botelho, A. (2014). Endonyx toenail onychomycosis caused by
Trichophyton rubrum: Treatment with photodynamic therapy based on methylene blue dye.
Anais brasileiros de dermatologia., 6(88). Retrieved from
Svaasand, L. (1984). Optical dosimetry for direct and interstitial photoradiation therapy of
malignant tumors. Progress in clinical and biological research. Retrieved from
Tardivo, J., Wainwright, M., & Baptista, M. (2015). Small scale trial of photodynamic
treatment of onychomycosis in São Paulo. Journal of photochemistry and photobiology. B,
Biology. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25835504
Valduga, G., Bertoloni, G., Reddi, E., & Jori, G. (1993). Effect of extracellularly generated
singlet oxygen on gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. Journal of photochemistry and
photobiology. B, Biology. 1(21). Retrieved from
Wilson, B., Jeeves, W., & Lowe, D. (1985). In vivo and post mortem measurements of the
attenuation spectra of light in mammalian tissues. Photochemistry and photobiology., 2(42).
Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/4048297

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
22
6. Attachments
Figure 1: PACTMED
System for fungal toenail treatment
Figure 2: Photochemical mechanisms in PDT
Figure 3: Cell wall structure of fungal cells
Figure 4: Flowchart of study
Appendix 1A & 1B: Clearanail increases the surface area to promote absorption of
the active drug (e.g. Lamisil) or photosensitiser (PACT Nail
Fungus Gel) into the nail bed structure
Appendix 2: Ethical considerations
Appendix 3: Risk analysis
Appendix 4: Scope and limitations
Appendix 5: Further research question
Appendix 6: Table - Pros and cons of PDT therapy

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
23
Figure 1: PACTMED
System for fungal toenail treatment
Source:http://www.hahnmedicalsystems.com/?lang=en

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
24
Figure 2: Photochemical mechanisms in PDT
Source: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22057503 Kharkwal, et al. (2011)
Refer to table 2 for a simplified mode of action
Note: Intersystem crossing – causes a change in the spin of an electron i.e. loss of energy
The ground states PS molecule absorbs light which excites it to the singlet state 1
PS*
. This state
can fluoresce or undergo intersystem crossing to lose some energy which allows the PS molecule
to form into a more stable 3
PS*
state. It is this 3
PS*
state that then loses further energy by reacting
with oxygen molecules naturally present within the tissue (tissue oxygen) to create ROS such as
singlet oxygen (Type II reaction) or superoxide (Type I reaction) i.e. creating activated oxygen
species that are cytotoxic to microbial cells (bacteria, viruses and fungi). Host mammalian cells
can be affected but are more resistant to attack by activated oxygen. Unless the photosensitiser is
destroyed by photobleaching due to oxidation, this cycle can occur many times – causing the
‘oxidative burst’.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
25
Figure 3: Cell wall structure of fungal cells
‘Free Radical Damage’
A)
B)
Fungal cell wall breached ‘Oxidative Burst’
Adapted from source: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22057503 Kharkwal, et al. (2011)
Normal cell wall structure of a fungal cell wall
Fungal cell wall structure – undergoing oxidative attack
Activated oxygen – ROS and singlet oxygen species – result in free radical damage to the
fungal cell wall leading to oxidative crosslinking and fragmentation of proteins, resulting
in cell wall damage and destruction i.e. the oxidative burst.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
26
Figure 4: Flowchart of study
Adults aged 60 ± 20 years registered at University of Salford Podiatry Clinic
Recruitment n=259, allowing for total drop off of 115 patients
DIAGNOSIS: Visual - dystrophy, hyperkeratosis, discolouration,
subungual debris, onycholysis + Positive Fungal Microscopy
EXCLUDED:
Negative mycological examination
( -ve microscopy / -ve culture )
Those having had recent oral antifungal treatment within
the last 6 months / those with nail changes because of skin
diseases or associated systemic disease (see table 3)
INCLUDED:
Positive mycological examination
( +ve culture / +ve microscopy)
GROUP 1:
n = 48 (total size)
n* = 24 (realised)
n* = 24 (unrealised)
GROUP 2:
n = 48 (total size)
n* = 24 (realised)
GROUP 3:
n = 48 (total size)
n* = 24 (realised)
Treatment with PDT
PACT-MED & PACT-MED NAIL
FUNGUS GEL [PDT]
λ = 630 nm
T = 570 s @ 25 mm distance
Repeated on 3 successive days
Daily night treatment with CCS
10% urea cream and daily day
treatment with Lamisil spray used
“prophylactically” for 12 weeks
Treatment CLEARANAIL
Holes drilled over the entire
surface of the nail
Holes re-drilled at week 6 with
further holes added to any new
nail growth
for 12 weeks
COMBINED Treatment :
CLEARANAIL & PDT
Holes drilled over the entire
surface of the nail
λ = 630 nm, T = 570 s @ 25 mm
Repeated on 3 successive days
Holes re-drilled or cleared at week
6 with further holes added to any
new nail growth
for 12 weeks
Visual measure of outcome at 12 / 24 and 48 weeks (per group) and also split by realised
(nail curettage in nails > 2mm thickness i.e. severe OM) vs. non-realised (nail thickness
<2mm i.e. less severe OM):
Complete clearance i.e. clinical cure vs. Partial Clearance vs. No change
Analysis of results
Qualitative & QuantitativeT = time in seconds
*nb: the number of realised vs. unrealised patients
will depend on the randomisation process and may
vary, but total numbers per group should be a
minimum of n=48

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
27
Appendix 1A: Clearanail increases the surface area to promote absorption of the active drug
(e.g. Lamisil) or photosensitiser (PACT Nail Fungus Gel) into the nail bed structure

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
28
Appendix 1B: Clearanail increases the surface area to promote absorption of the active drug
(e.g. Lamisil) or photosensitiser (PACT Nail Fungus Gel) into the nail bed structure

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
29
Appendix 2: Ethical considerations
Informed consent will be obtained, as this is a service generally not offered on the NHS, no
payment for taking part will be arranged. However, travel expenses and the cost of the 10%
CCS Urea Cream and Lamisil spray for continued self-treatment at home will be covered.
Also, appropriate consents will be obtained to take various digital photographs and to be able
to use such photography anonymously in resultant publications.
Also good practice requires that in the opt-in process the patient has been actively involved in
making a conscious decision to take part.
Confidentiality and anonymity will be maintained, with any data or patient files held securely
in locked cabinets.
Potential harm – patients will be fully advised of the schedule of attendance beforehand so
that they do not perceive the number of visits as an inconvenience. The appropriate insurance
and indemnity arrangements will be in place, with the clinician having received prior training
or having had prior experience of use of the PACTMED
system and the Clearanail device.
Patients showing no clinical cure or improvement after 48 weeks, will be offered a further
course of PDT treatment.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
30
Appendix 3: Risk analysis
Both the PACTMED
PDT system and the Clearanail device are classed as non-invasive
therapies, and the toluidine blue dye as use in the PACT Fungal Nail Gel has no adverse
reports of toxicity at the concentrations that will be used. No adverse risk is expected from
such treatment either alone or combined as proposed in this study.
The participants’ night treatment of 10% CCS urea cream followed by daytime Lamisil spray
treatment for the first 12 weeks is also considered not to pose any significant risk being a
topical application. Should pain or burning or sensitivity occur, the patient will be directed to
stop treatment and attend the clinic for evaluation / or if a severe reaction takes place to seek
immediate emergency medical advice.
Patients will be fully informed and advised of all possible risks.
Safety will be assessed continually through adverse events and laboratory monitoring.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
31
Appendix 4: Scope and limitations
This study has formed part of a proposal and has a number of limitations namely:
Money – no funds have been sourced or allocated for such proposed study
Equipment – ‘PACTMED
’ and ‘Clearanail’ devices would need to be purchased along
with the necessary consumables.
Pre-trial study – no pre-trial studies has been conducted to assess whether the
‘PACTMED
’ or Clearanail systems are effective for the treatment of onychomycosis.
Non NHS Patients – i.e. university based – requires research ethics committee
approval and also patient numbers may be limited.
Time constraints – the ‘PACTMED
’ device has time issues – approximately 10
minutes per treatment time per nail (two units would speed up treatment times –
especially if treating both feet and all nails).
Measures of outcome – qualitative (OSI score index or other) & quantitative via
digital photographic analyses (edge detection in medical image processing / advanced
eye recognition software). Various medical image processing packages are available.
There should be a correlation between the qualitative and quantitative outcomes.
Toenail growth rates – depending on the health and age of the patient toenail growth
rates could be much slower than expected and there may be variability in toenails
growth rates anyway. Novel techniques could be developed to normalise the growth
rates to correctly quantify eukaryotic nail growth and the clearance of fungus. A
simple technique would involve digitally mapping a marker on the nail – which could
be a glued on marker or perhaps even a hole created by the Clearanail device i.e. as a
reference point.
Qualitative questionnaires – validated / non-validated.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
32
Appendix 5: Further research question
The PDT regimen could be further modified to ask the following research question:
As tissue oxygen is the source of the oxygen molecules which become ‘activated’ in
PDT, could the PDT treatment regimen be improved by trying to increase the actual
tissue oxygen present prior to PDT treatment. Some research has shown that peroxide
creams can actually increase tissue oxygen in the dermis. Therefore, could a simple
topical pre-PDT treatment using for example a Panoxyl gel (a standard peroxide gel
which comes in 2.5%, 5%, and 10% concentrations) – rubbed into the perforations
created by the CLEARANAIL device - improve subsequent tissue-oxygen levels within
the nail plate and nail bed structures – to further improve the efficacy of the PDT
treatment?
Other Considerations
In the field of podiatry, osteomyelitis and pin-point ulcers on lesser toes may prove
troublesome and difficult to heal. The podiatrist can only really dress the wound and
monitor healing or deterioration, referring on for microbial testing or surgery if
needed. PDT devices are now widely and effectively used in dentistry for the
treatment of infected root canals and periodontitis, etc. It may be that similar fibre
optic PDT systems can be used by podiatrists to treat toe osteomyelitis and leg ulcers
– with equally effective results. Furthermore, PDT therapy can be used in situations
where antibiotic resistance has occurred. Bacteria / fungi and viruses do not possess
the necessary mechanisms that will enable them to become PDT resistant per-se,
making PDT especially suitable in cases where antibiotic resistance has occurred.

00379468 MoED (2015-2016)
33
Appendix 6: Table - Pros and cons of PDT therapy
Pros of PDT:
There are no long-term side effects when used properly and in terms of PACTMED
for fungal toenails no side
effect has been reported
Less invasive than surgery (surface treatment can be classed as non-invasive)
The treatment time is usually only short and can often be done as an outpatient or in a normal clinical setting.
With non-invasive PDT therapy – not requiring a sterile or theatre environment under negative pressure
It can be targeted very precisely
PDT can be repeated many times at the same site if needed. PACTMED
for fungal toenails can be repeated
successively if needed
There is often little or no scarring after the site heals. PACTMED
for fungal toenails has no reports of scarring
being an issue
PDT therapy can cost less than other laser treatments (thermolytic lasers) and is often cheaper than other cancer
or antimicrobial treatments
Cons of PDT:
PDT can only treat areas where light can reach. Therefore, it is used to treat problems on or just under the skin,
or in the lining of organs that can be reached with a light source. As light has limited penetration through body
tissues, PDT cannot be used to treat large masses e.g. large tumorous cancers or cancers that have grown deeply
into the skin or other organs. Similarly, PDT therapy is generally not used to treat cancers that have spread to
many places
The drugs used i.e. the photosensitisers used for PDT leave some people very sensitive to light for some time, so
precautions must be taken after the drugs are put in or on the body. In terms of PACTMED
Fungal Nail Gel for
fungal toenails, the toluidine blue staining may leave a blue discolouration for several of days, but will return to
normal in due course and patients would be advised of potential photosensitivity in sunlight and advised to wear
socks covering any treating toenails for several days
PDT can’t be used in people who have certain blood diseases, such as any of the porphyrias (a rare group of
diseases that affect the skin or nervous system) or people who are allergic to porphyrins. This allergy is rare, but
it may happen in those who have had exposure to porphyrins in the past.
Source: http://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatmentsandside/treatmenttypes/photodynamic-therapy

BSc Dissertation

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (11)

Similar to BSc Dissertation

Similar to BSc Dissertation (20)

BSc Dissertation