The vast majority of Americans are frustrated with the constant partisan gridlock in Congress. Fewer and fewer laws are being passed and the threat of a government shutdown is always present. What needs to be reformed on Capitol Hill so our legislators can start legislating again? This panel will propose cultural and procedural ideas from four former Hill staffers from both sides of the aisle for how we can help Congress get back to work for the American people.
This proposal is for SXSW PanelPicker 2019
2. Americans Are Frustrated With Congress
25
34
49
36
19
14
17
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
2015
% Approve
1990
2000
2005
1995
2010
2018
Source: Gallup Poll, Public Policy Polling
Do you approve or disapprove of the way Congress is handling its job?
For comparison,
Nickelback polls at
39% approval.
3. 772
729
804
736
529
677 687
761
665
610
473
337
404
604
383
504 483
460
385
284 296
329
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
105th100th93rd 95th 110th 114th
Congress Is Taking Less And Less Action
Number of enacted laws per each two-year session of Congress
Source: Govtrack.us
The fewest laws enacted
in recent history!
4. The Threat Of A Government Shutdown Is
Constantly Looming
"Congress Again Misses Deadline
To Avert Government Shutdown"
- The Hill (2/9/18)
"Congress Acting
Downright
Childish About
Government
Shutdown"
- Washington Times (1/23/18)
"Why Republicans Just
Might Be Okay With
Another Government
Shutdown"
- Washington Post (9/22/15)
"Another
Government
Shutdown?"
- Washington Post (6/24/14)
"Government Heads
Towards Shutdown As
Senate Recesses Without
Passing Budget Bill"
- Los Angeles Times (2/8/18)"Now It's Democrats
Who Are Hinting At A
Government Shutdown"
- New York Times (3/27/17)
5. Passing Must-Pass Spending Bills Is Harder Than Ever
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
1977 1980 19951985 1990 2000 2005 2010 2017
Percentage of standalone appropriations bills signed into law on or before October 1 of each fiscal year
Washington, we have a
problem.
Source: Pew Research Center
6. Members Are Fleeing
Congress, Not Fixing It
Source: The Atlantic
55 incumbent representatives
are not running for re-election
8. "Earmarks were an
effective tool for creating
buy-in for members on
issues that they
otherwise may not be
inclined to support."
Millenials Have Ideas About
How To Reform Congress
"In conjunction with extending the budget to two years,
this joint committee should be repurposed and given the
task of reforming the budget process. Discussions,
debates, and hearings on fixing the budget process will
help create buy-in from members, and a policy developed
by the rank and file of the joint committee will help reach a
bipartisan solution. "
"Since earmarks have been
banned we have seen the
government shutdown
more than once over an
uncompromising budget
feud. Earmarks could help
avoid these costly, and
inefficient debates."
"If earmarks were allowed, with full
transparency and reasonable limits,
members would have a justification for
compromising on ideology that would
likely pacify their constituents as long as
the earmark served a legitimate need of
the state/district."
"Uncertainty is incredibly
damaging both to the
ability of Congress to
govern and the rest of the
federal government to
effectively plan and carry
out its duties. A small
change that could lessen
this partisan gridlock
would be to adopt a
biennial budget cycle."
9. We Need To Reform The Budget Process
A bipartisan, bicameral
Joint Committee on
Congressional reform
Biennial budgeting
=+
Congress Isn't Passing Budgets On Time;
Fewer government
shutdown threats and a
smoother budget process
10. Congress Needs To Reclaim Its Legislative Power
The legislative branch needs to enact
reform so that it can its job
Over the past three decades, too much power
has been given to the executive branch
11. Members Of Congress Need More Opportunities To
Socialize Off The Hill
Better personal relationships lead to better professional relationships
Extracurricular bipartisan team
building activities
Bipartisan member dinners
with no press or staff
Trips that encourage members to
present a united American
perspective