SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
*My thesis was written in greek, and it consists of roughly 50 pages of quantitative research
findings. The following is the abstract and the first parts of the introduction, namely 'System
Justification Theory' and ''Right-Wing Authoritarianism', translated in english by me.
Justice Beliefs And System Justification
Abstract
The present research has gathered responses from 217 individuals concerning the following six
variables of psychological and sociological interest: personal and general belief in a just world,
justice centrality, justice sensitivity-beneficiary perspective, social dominance orientation and
right-wing authoritariansism. The sample consisted of Greek university students and
employees. The results indicated a positive relevance between general belief in a just world and
right-wing authoritarianism. Furthermore, in male participants, general belief in a just world
appeared to correlate positively also with social dominance orientation. A negative relevance
was found between justice sensitivity-beneficiary perspective with the variants of right-wing
authoritarianism and social dominance orientation. Personal belief in a just world and justice
centrality didn't appear in the present paper to have a statistically important correlation with
either right-wing authoritarianism or social dominance orientation. The findings would suggest
that people who deem the world to be a just place in general will tend to be more authoritarian
and prejudiced in their beliefs. Moreover, that people who do not wish to be subject to any
special treatment at other peoples' expense will tend to be less authoritarian and prejudiced.
Key-words: Right-wing authoritarianism, Social dominance orientation, Belief in a just world,
justice beliefs, system justification theory
System Justification Theory
System Justification Theory was developed in order to explain how and why people tend
to accept and perpetuate the existing status quo (Jost, Banaji, & Nosek, 2004. Jost & Hunyady,
2002), even when they don't belong themselves in the privileged class, therefore making it more
reasonable that they would wish an overthrow of the existing situation. This theory has been
used to explain social phenomena such as working class conservatism, increased commitment
to the established authorities and meritocracy beliefs among the poorer classes and the
unconscious or conscious preferance exhibited by members of minority groups for people
belonging to the majority. According to System Justification Theory, people tend to justify and
rationalize the status quo, and as a result the existing political and economical conditions are
perceived as just and legitimate. This tendency seems to apply to members of both privileged
and less privileged social classes.
System Justification Theory as a psychological phenomenon has a reassuring effect on
the individual, seeing that it reduces stress, guilt, discomfort and uncertainty for privileged as
well as less privileged people. As Vaclav Havel puts it (1991), “The primary excusatory
function of ideology, is to provide people, both as victims and pillars of the post-totalitarian
system, with the illusion that the system is in harmony with the human order and the order of
the universe .”
This particular psychological phenomenon appears to have at least two negative
consequences. Firstly, it legitimizes descrimination and places the blame on the individual
rather than the system. Consequently, the poor are deemed responsible for their poverty, mental
patients for their disease and people who belong to majority groups are viewed as the norm that
everybody should try to comply to. The second negative aspect of this tendency is that the
acceptance of the existing system as just and legitimate intercepts any attempt to change.
Jost and Hunyady (2002, 2005) suggested the existence of a psychological motive that
supports system justification and serves to maintain or enhance the legitimacy and stability of
the existing status quo. However, system justification is not the only theory that serves to
explain and rationalize the perpetuation of the established social and political situation. It could
even be argued that this theory is merely a sub-category of theories proposed to explain why
people tend to perpetuate the status quo. Such theories are right-wing authoritarianism, social
dominance orientation, belief in just world (which have been studied in this research), but also
others such as the Protestant Work Ethic, Meritocracy and Individualism.
Right-Wing Authoritarianism
The theory of right-wing authoritarianism has its roots in the theory of the authoritarian
personality, which was presented by Adorno et al. in 1950 to explain the rise of fascism in
Europe during the previous decades. According to Adorno, the emergence of the authoritarian
personality is attributed to psychoanalytic causes. More specifically, it is considered to be the
result of a strong Superego controling a weak Ego that is powerless to command the powerful
impulses dictated by Id. As a result of this conflict, the individual tends to rigidly adopt rules set
by authoritative figures and comply absolutely to them (authoritarian submission). Furthermore,
the impulses originated from Id and not accepted by the strict Superego, are projected to lower
social classes who do not belong to the inner group of the individual, through the respective
defense mechanism and subsequently lead to hostility towards these groups (authoritarian
aggression) .
According to Adorno et al., a domineering, manipulative and hierarchy-oriented parental
behavior can play a crucial role in shaping the authoritarian personality. A child who is not
allowed to express hostility against its parents, will displace aggressive feelings towards easier
goals later in life, such as towards various minority groups.
From the first moments after Adorno et al. published their theory and corresponding
scale measuring the susceptibility of people to fascism in personality level (the F-scale, deriving
its name from the word fascism), it received severe criticism from the scientific community.
Eventually, Adorno's authoritarian personality theory lost its credibility due to methodological
errors in the F-scale, the failure of psychoanalytic interpretation to explain the extensive social
phenomena of prejudice and racism, as well as the inability of the theory to provide explanation
for the authoritarianism expressed in cases of extreme left regimes.
Right wing authoritarianism as was studied in the present research, was introduced to the
scientific community via the work of Bob Altemeyer (1981). The canadian psychologist starting
from the observation that not all the items of the F-scale had the same correlations with each
other, concluded that right-wing authoritarianism was consisting of three attitudes; authoritarian
submission, authoritarian aggression and conventionalism. The first attitude, refers to a high
degree of submissiveness to the authorities who are perceived to be established and legitimate
in the society in which one lives. The second, to a general aggressiveness directed against
deviants, outgroups, and other people that are perceived to be targets according to established
authorities. Finally, conventionalism is described as a high degree of adherence to the traditions
and social norms that are perceived to be endorsed by society and its established authorities,
and a belief that others in one's society should also be required to adhere to these norms
(Altemeyer, 2006).
Altemeyer instead of following the psychodynamic approach of Adorno et al.,
incorporated in his theory elements of social learning theory. According to him, right-wing
authoritarianism was not a personality trait, developed in the early psychosexual stages of life,
but rather a behavior, result of social learning that people develop later in life. While Adorno et
al. were more concerned about providing a theory that explained the prejudice expressed
against national minorities, Altemeyer was more interested in the relevance between his theory
and political attitudes and beliefs. Finally, the scale that he created was free of the
methodological errors of the F-scale; it consists of a well-balanced scale with an equal number
of pro and anti authoritarian statements, internal consistency and formulation aiming to reduce
social desirability bias.

More Related Content

What's hot

Political Compass
Political CompassPolitical Compass
Political Compasszmiers
 
Political psychology tol
Political psychology tolPolitical psychology tol
Political psychology tolTol Long
 
Chapter 8 feminist ethics
Chapter 8 feminist ethicsChapter 8 feminist ethics
Chapter 8 feminist ethicsstanbridge
 
Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL
Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL
Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL Danny Athenour
 
Equally Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & Humanities
Equally Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & HumanitiesEqually Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & Humanities
Equally Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & Humanitiestheproffessorofthehumanities
 
Objectivity & Values in Sociology
Objectivity & Values in SociologyObjectivity & Values in Sociology
Objectivity & Values in SociologyBeth Lee
 
Polsc22 1 introduction to political philosophy
Polsc22   1 introduction to political philosophyPolsc22   1 introduction to political philosophy
Polsc22 1 introduction to political philosophyYvan Gumbao
 
Equallyokedtarianism - Advanced Concepts - Charter School Project
Equallyokedtarianism -  Advanced Concepts - Charter School ProjectEquallyokedtarianism -  Advanced Concepts - Charter School Project
Equallyokedtarianism - Advanced Concepts - Charter School Projecttheprofessorofthehumanities3
 
9 chapter 5 political_philosophy
9 chapter 5 political_philosophy9 chapter 5 political_philosophy
9 chapter 5 political_philosophyChormvirak Moulsem
 
Introduction to sociology 1
Introduction to sociology 1Introduction to sociology 1
Introduction to sociology 1angelickhan2
 
"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - Perspectives
"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - Perspectives"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - Perspectives
"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - PerspectivesHumanitiesPr0fess0r
 
“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watson
“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watson“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watson
“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watsonFarah Diana
 
Critical culture and theory
Critical culture and theoryCritical culture and theory
Critical culture and theorysakinaay
 
Introduction to sociology
Introduction to sociologyIntroduction to sociology
Introduction to sociologyShyamasree Saha
 

What's hot (20)

Self identity
Self identitySelf identity
Self identity
 
Political Compass
Political CompassPolitical Compass
Political Compass
 
Political psychology tol
Political psychology tolPolitical psychology tol
Political psychology tol
 
Chapter 8 feminist ethics
Chapter 8 feminist ethicsChapter 8 feminist ethics
Chapter 8 feminist ethics
 
Institutionalism
InstitutionalismInstitutionalism
Institutionalism
 
SOCIOLOGY IN NURSING
SOCIOLOGY IN NURSINGSOCIOLOGY IN NURSING
SOCIOLOGY IN NURSING
 
Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL
Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL
Disgust and Syrian Refugees FINAL
 
Equally Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & Humanities
Equally Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & HumanitiesEqually Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & Humanities
Equally Yoked Dyads - SocPsy444 - Advanced Concepts - Liberal Arts & Humanities
 
Objectivity & Values in Sociology
Objectivity & Values in SociologyObjectivity & Values in Sociology
Objectivity & Values in Sociology
 
Polsc22 1 introduction to political philosophy
Polsc22   1 introduction to political philosophyPolsc22   1 introduction to political philosophy
Polsc22 1 introduction to political philosophy
 
Political Science and Concept of Power
Political Science and Concept of PowerPolitical Science and Concept of Power
Political Science and Concept of Power
 
Autismo 1
Autismo 1Autismo 1
Autismo 1
 
Equallyokedtarianism - Advanced Concepts - Charter School Project
Equallyokedtarianism -  Advanced Concepts - Charter School ProjectEquallyokedtarianism -  Advanced Concepts - Charter School Project
Equallyokedtarianism - Advanced Concepts - Charter School Project
 
9 chapter 5 political_philosophy
9 chapter 5 political_philosophy9 chapter 5 political_philosophy
9 chapter 5 political_philosophy
 
Introduction to sociology 1
Introduction to sociology 1Introduction to sociology 1
Introduction to sociology 1
 
"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - Perspectives
"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - Perspectives"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - Perspectives
"Equallyokedtarian" - it's Definition - Social Studies - Concepts - Perspectives
 
“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watson
“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watson“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watson
“Behaviorism as a behaviorist views it” original writing by j.b watson
 
Critical culture and theory
Critical culture and theoryCritical culture and theory
Critical culture and theory
 
Behaviouralism
BehaviouralismBehaviouralism
Behaviouralism
 
Introduction to sociology
Introduction to sociologyIntroduction to sociology
Introduction to sociology
 

Viewers also liked

Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion
Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion
Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion Carlos Garcia
 
Post-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics Simulation
Post-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics SimulationPost-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics Simulation
Post-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics SimulationUral-PDC
 
AMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englisch
AMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englischAMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englisch
AMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englischlambros pappas
 
Soiree commune Poster
Soiree commune PosterSoiree commune Poster
Soiree commune PosterDavid Minetti
 
Shellback - Kyle Starkey
Shellback - Kyle StarkeyShellback - Kyle Starkey
Shellback - Kyle StarkeyKyle Starkey
 
Función Lineal
Función LinealFunción Lineal
Función LinealITCN
 
Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...
Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...
Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...ManageEngine, Zoho Corporation
 
[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)
[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)
[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)Orange
 
Sucesion o progresion geometrica
Sucesion o progresion geometricaSucesion o progresion geometrica
Sucesion o progresion geometricaITCN
 
Factors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenal
Factors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenalFactors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenal
Factors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenalThe Economist Media Businesses
 
MangoRain Company Profile and Case Study
MangoRain Company Profile and Case StudyMangoRain Company Profile and Case Study
MangoRain Company Profile and Case StudyUdom Sar
 
La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)
La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)
La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)artesonado
 
Customer Service Training by McGraw-Hill Companies
Customer Service Training by McGraw-Hill CompaniesCustomer Service Training by McGraw-Hill Companies
Customer Service Training by McGraw-Hill CompaniesAtlantic Training, LLC.
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Concept of ems
Concept of emsConcept of ems
Concept of ems
 
Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion
Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion
Ciclo de vida de los Sistemas de informacion
 
Post-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics Simulation
Post-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics SimulationPost-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics Simulation
Post-Processing the Results of Metastable States Molecular Dynamics Simulation
 
AMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englisch
AMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englischAMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englisch
AMC Reference Lambros Pappas 2015 englisch
 
Soiree commune Poster
Soiree commune PosterSoiree commune Poster
Soiree commune Poster
 
Shellback - Kyle Starkey
Shellback - Kyle StarkeyShellback - Kyle Starkey
Shellback - Kyle Starkey
 
Función Lineal
Función LinealFunción Lineal
Función Lineal
 
Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...
Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...
Case study: Leading bank uses NetFlow Analyzer to solve mysteries on their ne...
 
[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)
[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)
[Fr] étude CRM Orange Business Services et AFRC (2010-2011)
 
Sucesion o progresion geometrica
Sucesion o progresion geometricaSucesion o progresion geometrica
Sucesion o progresion geometrica
 
Factors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenal
Factors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenalFactors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenal
Factors: Finding a place in institutional investors' arsenal
 
MangoRain Company Profile and Case Study
MangoRain Company Profile and Case StudyMangoRain Company Profile and Case Study
MangoRain Company Profile and Case Study
 
La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)
La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)
La Segunda República Española (1931-1936)
 
Customer Service Training by McGraw-Hill Companies
Customer Service Training by McGraw-Hill CompaniesCustomer Service Training by McGraw-Hill Companies
Customer Service Training by McGraw-Hill Companies
 

Similar to thesis abstract

Interpretevism vs positivism
Interpretevism vs positivismInterpretevism vs positivism
Interpretevism vs positivismProfessorkhurram
 
Crim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGS
Crim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGSCrim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGS
Crim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGSRoshaineEsganaTarona
 
Communication research
Communication researchCommunication research
Communication researchShuayb Dawood
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docxjeremylockett77
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docxcroftsshanon
 
DISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptx
DISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptxDISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptx
DISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptxLeonaFaelnar
 
Intersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&PrivilegeIntersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&PrivilegeNykolai Blichar
 
Theories of gender inequality
Theories of gender inequalityTheories of gender inequality
Theories of gender inequalityjahid51
 
Political Theory and Ideology
Political Theory and IdeologyPolitical Theory and Ideology
Political Theory and IdeologyChristopher Rice
 
Critical sw study notes
Critical sw study notesCritical sw study notes
Critical sw study noteshunterkirsty
 
Theories Of International Relations
Theories Of International RelationsTheories Of International Relations
Theories Of International RelationsJenny Smith
 
Political Theory And Ideology
Political Theory And IdeologyPolitical Theory And Ideology
Political Theory And IdeologyChristopher Rice
 
Chapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspective
Chapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspectiveChapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspective
Chapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspectiveAsadAli775
 
The Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of Disability
The Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of DisabilityThe Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of Disability
The Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of DisabilityScott Rains
 
Critical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docx
Critical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docxCritical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docx
Critical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docxmydrynan
 

Similar to thesis abstract (20)

Interpretevism vs positivism
Interpretevism vs positivismInterpretevism vs positivism
Interpretevism vs positivism
 
Prejudice.
Prejudice.Prejudice.
Prejudice.
 
Feminism And The Feminist Theory Essay
Feminism And The Feminist Theory EssayFeminism And The Feminist Theory Essay
Feminism And The Feminist Theory Essay
 
Crim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGS
Crim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGSCrim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGS
Crim-Luga.pdfINTRODUCTINTOCRIMINOLOGYLUGS
 
Communication research
Communication researchCommunication research
Communication research
 
Social Psychology And Social Influence
Social Psychology And Social InfluenceSocial Psychology And Social Influence
Social Psychology And Social Influence
 
TOCC-2.pptx
TOCC-2.pptxTOCC-2.pptx
TOCC-2.pptx
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
 
DISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptx
DISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptxDISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptx
DISS REPORT GROUP 6.pptx
 
Intersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&PrivilegeIntersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&Privilege
 
The Elements Of Social Psychology Essay
The Elements Of Social Psychology EssayThe Elements Of Social Psychology Essay
The Elements Of Social Psychology Essay
 
Theories of gender inequality
Theories of gender inequalityTheories of gender inequality
Theories of gender inequality
 
Political Theory and Ideology
Political Theory and IdeologyPolitical Theory and Ideology
Political Theory and Ideology
 
Critical sw study notes
Critical sw study notesCritical sw study notes
Critical sw study notes
 
Theories Of International Relations
Theories Of International RelationsTheories Of International Relations
Theories Of International Relations
 
Political Theory And Ideology
Political Theory And IdeologyPolitical Theory And Ideology
Political Theory And Ideology
 
Chapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspective
Chapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspectiveChapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspective
Chapter 11 theoretical Criminology perspective
 
The Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of Disability
The Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of DisabilityThe Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of Disability
The Developmment and Critique of the Social Model of Disability
 
Critical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docx
Critical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docxCritical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docx
Critical Social Pol icy Demetrius 5. atridis 1lf .docx
 

thesis abstract

  • 1. *My thesis was written in greek, and it consists of roughly 50 pages of quantitative research findings. The following is the abstract and the first parts of the introduction, namely 'System Justification Theory' and ''Right-Wing Authoritarianism', translated in english by me. Justice Beliefs And System Justification Abstract The present research has gathered responses from 217 individuals concerning the following six variables of psychological and sociological interest: personal and general belief in a just world, justice centrality, justice sensitivity-beneficiary perspective, social dominance orientation and right-wing authoritariansism. The sample consisted of Greek university students and employees. The results indicated a positive relevance between general belief in a just world and right-wing authoritarianism. Furthermore, in male participants, general belief in a just world appeared to correlate positively also with social dominance orientation. A negative relevance was found between justice sensitivity-beneficiary perspective with the variants of right-wing authoritarianism and social dominance orientation. Personal belief in a just world and justice centrality didn't appear in the present paper to have a statistically important correlation with either right-wing authoritarianism or social dominance orientation. The findings would suggest that people who deem the world to be a just place in general will tend to be more authoritarian and prejudiced in their beliefs. Moreover, that people who do not wish to be subject to any special treatment at other peoples' expense will tend to be less authoritarian and prejudiced. Key-words: Right-wing authoritarianism, Social dominance orientation, Belief in a just world, justice beliefs, system justification theory System Justification Theory System Justification Theory was developed in order to explain how and why people tend to accept and perpetuate the existing status quo (Jost, Banaji, & Nosek, 2004. Jost & Hunyady, 2002), even when they don't belong themselves in the privileged class, therefore making it more
  • 2. reasonable that they would wish an overthrow of the existing situation. This theory has been used to explain social phenomena such as working class conservatism, increased commitment to the established authorities and meritocracy beliefs among the poorer classes and the unconscious or conscious preferance exhibited by members of minority groups for people belonging to the majority. According to System Justification Theory, people tend to justify and rationalize the status quo, and as a result the existing political and economical conditions are perceived as just and legitimate. This tendency seems to apply to members of both privileged and less privileged social classes. System Justification Theory as a psychological phenomenon has a reassuring effect on the individual, seeing that it reduces stress, guilt, discomfort and uncertainty for privileged as well as less privileged people. As Vaclav Havel puts it (1991), “The primary excusatory function of ideology, is to provide people, both as victims and pillars of the post-totalitarian system, with the illusion that the system is in harmony with the human order and the order of the universe .” This particular psychological phenomenon appears to have at least two negative consequences. Firstly, it legitimizes descrimination and places the blame on the individual rather than the system. Consequently, the poor are deemed responsible for their poverty, mental patients for their disease and people who belong to majority groups are viewed as the norm that everybody should try to comply to. The second negative aspect of this tendency is that the acceptance of the existing system as just and legitimate intercepts any attempt to change. Jost and Hunyady (2002, 2005) suggested the existence of a psychological motive that supports system justification and serves to maintain or enhance the legitimacy and stability of the existing status quo. However, system justification is not the only theory that serves to explain and rationalize the perpetuation of the established social and political situation. It could even be argued that this theory is merely a sub-category of theories proposed to explain why people tend to perpetuate the status quo. Such theories are right-wing authoritarianism, social dominance orientation, belief in just world (which have been studied in this research), but also others such as the Protestant Work Ethic, Meritocracy and Individualism. Right-Wing Authoritarianism The theory of right-wing authoritarianism has its roots in the theory of the authoritarian personality, which was presented by Adorno et al. in 1950 to explain the rise of fascism in Europe during the previous decades. According to Adorno, the emergence of the authoritarian personality is attributed to psychoanalytic causes. More specifically, it is considered to be the
  • 3. result of a strong Superego controling a weak Ego that is powerless to command the powerful impulses dictated by Id. As a result of this conflict, the individual tends to rigidly adopt rules set by authoritative figures and comply absolutely to them (authoritarian submission). Furthermore, the impulses originated from Id and not accepted by the strict Superego, are projected to lower social classes who do not belong to the inner group of the individual, through the respective defense mechanism and subsequently lead to hostility towards these groups (authoritarian aggression) . According to Adorno et al., a domineering, manipulative and hierarchy-oriented parental behavior can play a crucial role in shaping the authoritarian personality. A child who is not allowed to express hostility against its parents, will displace aggressive feelings towards easier goals later in life, such as towards various minority groups. From the first moments after Adorno et al. published their theory and corresponding scale measuring the susceptibility of people to fascism in personality level (the F-scale, deriving its name from the word fascism), it received severe criticism from the scientific community. Eventually, Adorno's authoritarian personality theory lost its credibility due to methodological errors in the F-scale, the failure of psychoanalytic interpretation to explain the extensive social phenomena of prejudice and racism, as well as the inability of the theory to provide explanation for the authoritarianism expressed in cases of extreme left regimes. Right wing authoritarianism as was studied in the present research, was introduced to the scientific community via the work of Bob Altemeyer (1981). The canadian psychologist starting from the observation that not all the items of the F-scale had the same correlations with each other, concluded that right-wing authoritarianism was consisting of three attitudes; authoritarian submission, authoritarian aggression and conventionalism. The first attitude, refers to a high degree of submissiveness to the authorities who are perceived to be established and legitimate in the society in which one lives. The second, to a general aggressiveness directed against deviants, outgroups, and other people that are perceived to be targets according to established authorities. Finally, conventionalism is described as a high degree of adherence to the traditions and social norms that are perceived to be endorsed by society and its established authorities, and a belief that others in one's society should also be required to adhere to these norms (Altemeyer, 2006). Altemeyer instead of following the psychodynamic approach of Adorno et al., incorporated in his theory elements of social learning theory. According to him, right-wing authoritarianism was not a personality trait, developed in the early psychosexual stages of life, but rather a behavior, result of social learning that people develop later in life. While Adorno et
  • 4. al. were more concerned about providing a theory that explained the prejudice expressed against national minorities, Altemeyer was more interested in the relevance between his theory and political attitudes and beliefs. Finally, the scale that he created was free of the methodological errors of the F-scale; it consists of a well-balanced scale with an equal number of pro and anti authoritarian statements, internal consistency and formulation aiming to reduce social desirability bias.