Maria gave her boyfriend Mark a blank check to withdraw $500 to repay a $2,000 loan. However, Mark withdrew $800 instead without Maria's permission. Maria is upset and threatens to sue Mark for the $300 difference. There are a few options for Maria: 1) She can sue Mark for $300, claiming they had a verbal agreement for $500. 2) She can negotiate with Mark to only repay the remaining $1200 balance of the original $2,000 loan. However, Maria will likely not be successful suing Mark as oral agreements are difficult to prove in court without evidence. Additionally, her prior relationship with Mark influences the case ethically, as he violated her trust by withdrawing more than agreed upon
2. Business Ethical Issues Assignment
Help on the following assignment
Select ONE of the scenarios below and explain the best solution. Include
comments related to ethical issues that may arise.
Scenario 1
Maria gave her boyfriend, Mark, a check, but she left the amount incomplete.
The check was given as partial payment for a $2,000 loan that Mark made to
Maria three months ago. The amount was left blank because Maria was in a
hurry. Maria signed a blank check and told Mark to fill out the check for $500.
Mark needed to make an $800 car payment, so he wrote the check for $800 and
cashed it at Maria’s bank. Maria was upset when she found out about it. She
broke up with Mark and demanded that he immediately pay her the $300
difference. Mark refused claiming Maria owed her more than that. Maria
threatens to sue Mark for the $300.
What are Maria’s options?
If Maria files a complaint in the appropriate course, will she be successful?
Discuss why or why not.
Does Maria and Mark’s prior relationship influence the case in any way?
Discuss why or why not
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
3. Business Ethical Issues
Assignment Help
Options for Maria
In this scenario, an oral agreement took place between
Maria and her boyfriend, Maria told his boyfriend to
take out the amount of only $500. But he took out $800
and refused to give the extra amount in this case.
Maria trusted over Mark and gave him blank check.
His boyfriend broke the trust of Maria and it raised
ethical issue.
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
4. Business Ethical Issues
Assignment Help
On the basis of oral agreement, she can sue Mark for
$300. Both Maria and Mark agreed to take amount of
$500 from banks that created a verbal agreement on
the basis of that, she can sue Mark. At the same time,
the other option is to negotiate for the remaining
amount as Maria also borrowed the amount of $2,000
from Mark that she has to pay
She can negotiate with Mark to make payment for only
$1200 (1500-500-300) after this time.
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
5. Consequences of Filing a Complaint
No, she will not be successful due to legal reasons. An
oral agreement can be validate when one party putting
the words into immediate actions. This way may not
help Maria to attain success in this case. In this case,
the opposite party, Mark immediately cashed the
amount after she told him to withdraw but he did it in
a wrongful manner. Oral agreement that took place
between both Maria and Mark can be validated if she
has some evidences to prove it in the court
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
6. Business Ethical Issues
Assignment Help
At the same time, in order to support this oral
agreement, Maria will have to present some
supporting materials also for strengthening the claim.
She does not have any material to support or prove her
claim in court that will become a reason of her failure.
Ethically, Mark dishonored the essentials of oral
agreement by breaking the trust of Maria.
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
7. Business Ethical Issues
Assignment Help
But at the same time, she does not have any evidence
to prove this ethical violation. In this case, Maria
cannot be satisfied the two conditions that are
essential to make a verbal agreement valid or legal in
the court. Due to this, she will not be successful in
getting the claim.
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
8. Business Ethical Issues Assignment
Help
Relationship’s Influence over the Case
Yes, the prior relationship of Maria and Mark does
influence the case in ethical manner. In some culture,
oral agreement requires a written consent, whereas in
some other, it ignores the written consent. In such
culture, the establishment of relationship symbolizes
on the basis of giving and receiving of gifts between
two people.
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
9. Business Ethical Issues Assignment
Help
This relation also acts as prove of an oral consent in
this verbal agreement. In this case, the total amount of
$2,000 was borrowed by Maria to Mark three months
ago. Maria made partial payment of this money by
giving check to Mark.
This give and take of money between both persons
proves that Maria asked his boyfriend to withdraw
money from her bank account through the check.
Maria trusted her boyfriend and gave him a blank
check, but he broke the trust
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
10. Business Ethical Issues Assignment
Help
This act of Mark creates ethical issues as he breached
the trust of her girlfriend. In this way, prior
relationship of both members does influence this case
in ethical manner.
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
11. Contact US for Assignment Help
Get Business Ethics Assignment help Ethical
Issues Assignment Help from experienced
experts
100% original business ethics assignment help
info@assignmenthelpexperts.com
www.assignmenthelpexperts.com
