2. Leadership
Shoko Asahara was born Chizuo Matsumoto in Yatsushiro, Japan in 1955. He suffered from congenital
glaucoma and was partially blind. In 1977, he failed to secure a place at the prestigious Tokyo
University, and rather than applying elsewhere, opened a Chinese medicine shop. Asahara was
arrested for selling fake medicines in 1982. This resulted in bankruptcy and loss of his business. “He
was reportedly crushed by the event.” (START2, p1) This set the stage for increasing resentment and
distrust in authority and government. He became increasingly interested in mysticism and went on a
pilgrimage to the Himalayas in 1987. Upon his return, he changed his name and the name of the group
to Aum Shinrikyo. He announced that he had achieved ultimate enlightenment and claimed that he
could teach levitation and telepathy. (BBC) Asahara became increasingly paranoid with delusions of
grandeur. (Jackson)
Fumihiro Joyu, was an artificial intelligence engineer who headed operations in Russia. He currently
leads a branch of Aum (Aleph).
Tatsuko Muraoka, leads a new faction, called Hikarinowa, that formally split from Aleph in 2006-2007.
(START2, MOJ)
Hayakawa Kiyohide, Minister of Construction (Nuclear Weapons) unsuccessfully led Aum efforts to
recruit Russian nuclear scientists and to purchase a nuclear weapon for $15M. (Church)
Seiichi Endo was Minister of Health and Welfare and led biological weapons development. (Koschade)
Tomomitsu Niimi was Minister of Home Affairs. (Koschade)
Hideo Muari was Minister of Science and Technology. (Koschade)
Tomomasa Nakagawa was the Household Agency Director. (Koschade)
Yoshihiro Inoue headed Aum's Intelligence Agency. (Koschade)
Masami Tsuchiya was chief of the Chemical Arms Unit. (Cameron)
Structure
Aum Shinrikyo was organized into a vertical structure. Shoko Asahara was the supreme leader, considered
a deity by his disciples, and had absolute power. Once a member was in the group, absolute obedience
was enforced. (Crenshaw) The group was divided into two major classes, lay practitioners and sanga
(monks and nuns). Ascending the rank levels in each class was dependent upon theological study,
meditation, and the endurance of “austere treatments,” essentially episodes of deprivation and torture,
with the intended effect of spiritual cleansing and an increase in enlightenment. (JREF) Samana
(novices) were expected to renounce their families and former lives, move into an Aum compound, and
sign over their wealth to the group. Lay members were able to continue in their chosen life style. This
“complex, stratified hierarchical structure” mimicked the elitist structure of Japanese society. (Eate,
p159) The group was further organized into departments that mimicked the Japanese government in
order to be prepared to take over society after the apocalypse. (Church) An extreme competitiveness
combined with constant pressure to perform...tend[ed] to foster a culture of extreme elitism[,]”
isolation from society, and a distorted perception of reality. (Eate, p. 175) The intense devotion of the
sanga to Asahara resulted in their willingness to do anything asked of them, regardless of the moral or
3. ethical implications. (Jackson)
Strategies
In 1990, 20 Aum candidates ran for public office--the Japanese Diet. Shoko Asahara had predicted that
they would all win. Instead, they were uniformly defeated. He was enraged and accused the
government of rigging the election. (Olson) “It was around this time that [Asahara] started justifying
murder on spiritual grounds[,]...a…doctrine called 'poa'.” (START1, p1) Between 1990 and 1995, Aum
committed seventeen acts of terror involving WMDs, seven using biological weapons, ten using
chemicals. (Church) The group initially focused on biological weapons. (Olson) Research and
development of weapons based on botulinum, anthrax, cholera, and Q fever was performed. In 1993,
they unsuccessfully attempted to obtain Ebola virus in Zaire. (Olson) The group attempted to relase
botulinum toxin around government buildings in Tokyo 1990, at the wedding of the Crown Prince in
1993 and anthrax from the roof of its building in 1993, and in 1995, in the subway as a diversion from
the sarin attack. (Olson) Aum developed a biocapability comparable to a major pharmaceutical firm at
its headquarters in Kamakuishki, a rural area near Mt. Fuji, and at several other locations. (Cameron)
These biological attacks were all unsuccessful. The anthrax used was a nonlethal strain developed for
vaccine production. The botulinum strain did not make toxin.
The group was developing conventional, chemical and radiological capabilities in parallel to its
biological program. Members trained with Russian Spetznaz forces and purchase blueprints for AK-74
rifles. Chemicals used for explosives production were also found at Aum properties. The group
purchased military helicopters from Russia and members obtained flight training in Florida. (Jackson)
In 1994, there was an unsuccessful attempt to obtain nuclear materials and weapons experts from
Russia. They were able to purchase a precision interferometer and other equipment for measurement
and development of nuclear weapons from the Zygo Corporation in Connecticut. The group attempted
to hack into a computer at Brookhaven National Laboratory to obtain weapons data. They were also
able to steal additional technology from Mitsubishi Heavy Industries. (Cameron) Despite these efforts,
nuclear weapons research did not result in any success.
Aum subsequently increased their focus on chemical weapons and were successful in obtaining a
Russian formula for industrial production of sarin (GB). Small quantities of VX were also produced
and used to assassinate dissident members. The first public use of sarin was an attempt to assassinate
three judges' ruling on a land case that involved the Aum. A shift in the wind steered the plume away
from the judges' homes and, though exposed and lightly injured, the judges survived. The attack killed
seven people, caused 500 casualties, with 200 people admitted to the hospital. (Olson) In 1995, the
Tokyo subway attack represented the most successful strike by the group. It was staged in order to
preempt police raids on March 17 on Satyan 7 (a chemical weapons production facility disguised as a
shrine to the Hindu god Shiva) and kill as many police and government workers as possible. (Olson,
514) In coordinated, simultaneous attacks on 5 separate, converging trains, sarin was released from
bags punctured by sharpened umbrellas. 3800 casualties, 1000 hospital admissions, and 12 dead
resulted. (Olson)
Aum Shinrikyo financed and logistically supported its terror operations through multiple legitimate
businesses, focusing on computer hardware and software, chemicals, and mining (START1, Jackson).
Offices were established in the US, Taiwan, and Germany. (START1) At its peak, its net worth was as
much as US$1 billion. It had accumulated at least sixteen properties in Japan, a chain of restaurants, a
fitness club, a tea plantation in Sri Lanka, and an import/export company in Taiwan. (Cameron) Aum
also conducted manufacture of illegal drugs which were marketed by the Yakuza and was able to extort
money from individuals and towns. (Olson) They established Moscow-Japan University and made
4. payoffs to high level Russia officials. The group was also able to develop ties to Boris Yeltsin through
Oleg Lobov, chair of the Russian National Security Council. (Olson, Jackson)
Aum conducted intelligence operations but the impact is not clear. There are allegations that they had
penetrated police organizations but open source material regarding pending police raids was available.
Their counter intelligence operations appeared to be mostly based in the paranoia that spies were
present in the organization and their focus was on elimination of these individuals and members
planning to leave the group. (Jackson)
Impact of Ideology
Charismatic leadership tends to be more characteristic in closed groups. (Crenshaw) The result was
evident in Asahara's success in recruiting of people frustrated with the pressures of a materialistic
society, ultimately growing to ~40000 members. (Eate) The Aum also demonstrated success in
recruiting biological scientists and other well educated members. (Olson) Asymmetric attacks were a
logical conclusion when the group failed to obtain political power through conventional means. The
escalating violence against society was also a result of a personal vengeance in response to frustration
and possible feelings of humiliation caused by Shoko Asahara's failures. (Cameron) The group showed
a perseverance despite setbacks, and a careful, methodical planning approach to research and
development, as well as operations. Aum Shinrikyo showed a willingness to raise the bar for
complexity and impact. (Church)
Jackson divides the group's evolution into five periods. Pre-1988--birth and spirituality. 1988-1990
when a death of one member and the murder of another, who wished to leave the group, raised
legitimacy issues. At this same time, an Aum Shinrikyo Victim's Society was formed and unfavorable
media coverage began. Shoko Asahara became increasingly paranoid that there was a conspiracy
against him that would prevent his goals from being obtained. In response, Tsutsumi Sakamoto, the
attorney for the Society, and his family, were killed by Aum members. The third phase began after the
failure to win election. Asahara's world view became more pessimistic and paranoid. He accused the
US military of attacking Aum with chemical weapons and justified killing of society in order to save it.
There was also a competitive struggle against competing religious groups. Assassinations of members
of rival groups were ordered. Shoko Asahara developed a “sense of inferiority and victimhood.”
(Jackson, p16) The organization learned that it was only successful when it confronted challenges
aggressively. Violence paid off. (Jackson) The fourth phase ran from 1992 to the chemical attacks in
1995. This coincided with the development and deployment of chemical and biological weapons.
Asahara used the 1995 Kobe earthquake to prove to his followers that the end was near and blamed the
United States for the event. (Cameron) The fifth phase begins at the trial and continues to the present.
(Jackson)
Koschade analyzed the social network of a 21 member Aum cell that traveled to Australia in 1993 to
purchase a remote ranch for development of a WMD weapons laboratory. He concluded that the cell's
members operated in a “vastly different [manner than] traditional terrorist cells.”(Koschade, p16)
There was a “total lack of structural covertness” with individual members interacting with all other
members of the group with all channels of communication open. He concludes that the best way to
destabilize such a network is to target leaders to reduce the cell's decision making capacity.
Alternatively, the structure allows the identification of any single member to disclose the entire cell,
permitting apprehension or surveillance of all members. (Koschade, p16) This openness was a direct
result of the fact that the Japanese government did not outlaw the group. Instead, it was granted legal
status as a religion. The government and citizenship were sensitive to the WWII suppression of
religions in order to support the official Shinto state religion. Aum was able to openly function without
5. interference or surveillance. There were, therefor, strong pressures to leave the group unmolested,
despite obvious data suggesting illegal activities. (START1)
Wilkinson states:
“The violence of Aum Shinrikyo has had four observable consequences for new religious
movements in Japan: a change in posture by the Japanese government toward new religious
movements, stricter laws and regulations regarding new religious movements and tighter
enforcement of those laws, a growing skepticism by the media and scholars towards new
religious movements, and increasing skepticism about new
religious movements among community groups and the public at large. This... show[s]that the
crimes of Aum Shinrikyo have created a shift in Japan’s society resulting in a contraction of
operational space available to Japan’s new religious movements.” (Wilkinson, p1)
Aum Shinrikyo has led to heightened anxiety about the attractiveness and feasibility of future mass
casualty terrorist use of CBW (Report to Congress) but there were many gaps in their abilities. Their
capabilities did not match their plans. Despite impressive development of biological and chemical
weapons, Aum's ability to deploy them was crude and largely ineffective. This suggests an ignorance
and naivete of the use of CBW. An alternate explanation is that there was interference with operations
by intelligence agencies, allowing acquisition of low pathogenicity organisms and misinformation
regarding agent dispersal. The Japanese government now looks on emerging religions with a different
view and is actively looking for the “next Aum.” (Wilkinson, p177)
Future of the Group
The trial concluded in 2004 with Shoko Asahara and eleven followers sentenced to death. The cult is
still active but its legal status was revoked. (Olson). The group continues to hold seminars and collect
contributions. (START1) The current head of the group is Fumihiro Joyu, a senior leader under
Shoko Asahara. (JREF) Aleph has apologized to the sarin victims, claims to have changed its doctrine,
and has established a victim's compensation fund. (JREF) A surveillance law was passed in 2000 that
requires monitoring of the group. It was extended in 2006 and is still in effect. (START1) Factions
have developed with some of Shoko Asahara's biological children supporting Tatsuko Muraoka while
others support the revised belief system under Joyu. The offspring of SA and other senior leaders have
had difficult time securing university admissions due to their ties to the group. (Wilkinson)
In light of the recent earthquake, tsunami, and nuclear accident in Japan, combined with the world
economic crisis, it is not a stretch to consider this tragedy to be a new sign to Aleph of an impending
Apocalypse and a trigger for renewed terrorist activities. It is incumbent upon governments to monitor
such groups for signs of impending terrorist activities and to take appropriate preemptive action.
Bibliography
BBC News, Profile: Shoko Asahara, 2004/02/27, http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/asia-
pacific/3504237.stm, accessed November 6, 2011.
Cameron, G, Multi-track Microproliferation: Lessons from Aum Shinrikyo and Al Qaida, Studies in
Conflict and Terrorism, 22:277-309, 1999,
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/105761099265658?journalCode=uter20#preview,
accessed November 6, 2011.
Church, DM, The Ominous Precedent of Aum Shinrikyo, Global Review, Vol. 1, pp. 14-21, Summer
2011, http://sirgo.org/sites/default/files/GlobalReview_VolumeOne.pdf#page=20, accessed November
6. 6, 2011.
Crenshaw, M, The psychology of Terrorism: An Agenda for the 21st
Century, Political Psychology, Vol.
21, No. 2, June 2000, pp 405-420, http://cocomaan.net/psychology%20of%20terrorism.pdf, accessed
November 6, 2011..
Cronin, AK, Terrorist Motivations for Chemical and Biological Weapons Use: Placing the Threat in
Context, Report for Congress, RL31831,March 28, 2003, http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?
AD=ADA445051&Location=U2&doc=GetTRDoc.pdf, accessed November 6, 2011.
Eate, PN, The Replication and Excess of Disciplinary Power in Sekigun and Aum Shinrikyo-- A
Foucaultian Approach, University of Adelaide, p.153-178,
http://www.jpf.org.au/newvoices/2/vol2.pdf#page=161, accessed November 6, 2011.
Jackson, BA, et al, Chapter 2, Aum Shinrikyo in Aptitude for Destruction, Volume 2, Case Studies of
Organizational Learning in Five Terrorist Groups, RAND Corporation, http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-
bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA435246&Location=U2&doc=GetTRDoc.pdf#page=100, 2005, accessed
November 6, 2011.
JREF, Aum Shinrikyo, Japan Reference, http://www.jref.com/glossary/aum_shinrikyo.shtml, accessed
November 6, 2011, accessed November 6, 2011.
Koschade, S, A Social Network Analysis of Aum Shinrikyo: Understanding Terrorism in Australia,
Center for Social Change Research, Queensland University of Technology, 2005,
http://eprints.qut.edu.au/3496/1/3496.pdf, accessed November 6, 2011.
Lifton, RJ, Destroying the World to Save It: Aum Shinrikyo, Apocalyptic Violence, and the New
Global Terrorism, Metropolitan Books, 1st edition,1999, http://books.google.com/books?
hl=en&lr=&id=s6ZszhuzrrkC&oi=fnd&pg=PA3&dq=Lifton,+RJ,+Destroying+the+World+to+Save+It:
+Aum+Shinrikyo,+Apocalyptic+Violence,
+and+the+New+Global+Terrorism&ots=FGp_Cl9Pnu&sig=dXLDDAeZI2zjoGyejHbX3kKrhHs#v=on
epage&q&f=false, accessed November , 2011.
MOJ, Japan Ministry of Justice, Public Security Intelligence Agency,
http://www.moj.go.jp/ENGLISH/PSIA/psia03-03.html, accessed November 6, 2011.
Olson, KB, Aum Shinrikyo: Once and Future Threat?, Emerging Infectious Disease,Vol. 5, No. 4, pp.
513-516, July-August, 1999,
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2627754/pdf/10458955.pdf, accessed November 6,
2011..
START1, Terrorist Organization Profile: Aum Shinrikyo, National Consortium for the Study of
Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism, US Department of Homeland Security and University of
Maryland, http://www.start.umd.edu/start/data_collections/tops/terrorist_organization, accessed
November 6, 2011.
START2, Shoko Asahara, Terrorist Organization Profile: Aum Shinrikyo, National Consortium for the
Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism, US Department of Homeland Security and University
of Maryland, http://www.start.umd.edu/start/data_collections/tops/terrorist_organization, accessed
7. November 6, 2011.
Wilkinson, GE, The next Aum: religious violence and new religious movements in twenty-first
century Japan, University of Iowa Iowa Research Online, 2009, http://ir.uiowa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?
article=1457&context=etd&sei-redir=1&referer=http%3A%2F%2Fscholar.google.com%2Fscholar
%3Fhl%3Den%26q%3DWilkinson%252C%2BGE%252C%2B%2B%2BThe%2Bnext%2BAum
%253A%2Breligious%2Bviolence%26btnG%3DSearch%26as_sdt%3D0%252C7%26as_ylo%3D
%26as_vis%3D0#search=%22Wilkinson%2C%20GE%2C%20next%20Aum%3A%20religious
%20violence%22, accessed November 6, 2011.