SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 20
Running head: REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 1
Reducing the Preventable Use of Emergency Services
Could Generate Substantial Healthcare Savings
Irina Bubnova
HCA 450A: Critical Issues in Health Care
Professor Ronning
Warner Pacific College
June 26, 2016
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 2
Reducing the Preventable Use of Emergency Services
Could Generate Substantial Healthcare Savings
Since the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in 2010, America entered into an era
of healthcare reform in a desperate attempt to curb ever rising healthcare costs. The Centers for
Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) were given unprecedented power to develop and
implement various cost saving pilot programs in the hopes of finding something that works.
Many hospitals as well as numerous private, state, and federal organizations have also been
implementing their own experimental programs, all with the intention of stopping growing
healthcare costs. However, the issues are numerous and no one solution can fix the entire
healthcare system. One aspect that has not been well addressed by the CMS and can be vastly
improved upon is the problem of unnecessary and/or avoidable ambulance transports and
emergency department visits by Medicare and more specifically Medicaid patients.
Background
Prior to examining the issue of the overuse of emergency departments (EDs) and
emergency medical services (EMS), it is important to put these costs on the system in the right
perspective. According to The Pew Charitable Trusts organization, in 2012 the American
government spent $1.3 trillion on healthcare, of which 4 percent went to ED costs (Ollove,
2015). Four percent does not seem like a lot compared to the $1.3 trillion total, however this
percentage is debatable and critics point out that there are multiple formulas that can be used to
calculate this number (The Fiscal Times, 2013). By adjusting for discrepancies and adding more
databases, a secondary source estimated ED costs to be between 4.9 and 5.8 percent of total
health care expenditures (The Fiscal Times, 2013). By using still another database, this same
source found ED costs to be between 6.2 and 10 percent (The Fiscal Times, 2013). It is difficult
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 3
to ascertain the exact percentage of spending that goes toward ED costs, but one thing is
undisputable, and that is the fact that emergency services are exponentially more costly than
office-based care and can be successfully reduced with the right approach.
According to CMS (2014), Medicaid recipients utilize the ED at twice the rate of those
with private insurance. For example, in Oregon 50 percent of all ED expenses are accrued as a
result of just 3 percent of the Medicaid population or 16,000 individuals (CMS, 2014). Many
assume that there is rampant abuse of the system amongst Medicaid beneficiaries, but data shows
that in reality only 10 percent of all ED visits by these patients are non-urgent and all other visits
are indeed appropriate and necessary (CMS, 2014).
There are a number of reasons as to why specifically Medicaid patients have a
disproportionate need for ED services and most of them can be traced back to a poorer health
status and poor access to care. Due to socio-economic disadvantages, Medicaid patients are
generally less healthy than the overall population (Ollove, 2015). They tend to have poor
nutrition and to be prone to numerous chronic disorders that are extremely costly to the
healthcare system. Medicaid recipients also come up against countless barriers when it comes to
getting primary care. Many providers do not accept Medicaid patients due to low reimbursement
rates, or at the very least they severely limit their numbers. In Illinois, more than 35 percent of
physicians will not accept any new Medicaid patients and appointments with specialists are
denied two-thirds of the time (Ingram, 2013). Furthermore, Medicaid patients also often lack
transportation and have jobs that make it difficult for them to get to a doctor’s appointment
during regular working hours (Ollove, 2015). ED’s on the other hand are open 24 hours a day,
and cannot by law turn anybody away from receiving care, making it the perfect place for
Medicaid patient to turn to during a medical crisis. Overall, poor health coupled with a lack of
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 4
good access to care creates a disastrous cycle that easily compounds medical conditions and in
the end, healthcare costs.
As was mentioned earlier, depending on how data is interpreted, ED costs account for
approximately 4-10 percent of annual healthcare expenditures. While this number is not awe
inspiring, it is beneficial in this instance to take a step back and look at the whole picture.
According to Kaiser Health News, 1 percent of patients account for 21 percent of all healthcare
costs, while 5 percent account for 50 percent of all costs (Boodman, 2013). Now this data is
shocking. Image that a meager 5 percent of patients accounts for half of all healthcare
expenditures. The patients in this 5 percent are commonly called super-utilizers and “nearly all
wind up in emergency rooms because they have enormous difficulty navigating the increasingly
fragmented, complicated and inflexible health-care system” (Boodman, 2013, para. 4).
Furthermore, “because of lack of alternatives or force of habit, they use hospitals, often several
in the same city, for care that could be provided far more cheaply and effectively in outpatient
settings” (Boodman, 2013, para. 4). For example, a certain patient loses his method of
transportation and misses 2 weeks worth of dialysis treatments. He then ends up being
transported by ambulance to an ED, where he incurs a $30,000 hospitalization bill on top of
substantial EMS and ED charges. The takeaway here is that the costliest patients nearly all begin
their journey in the ED, which is why it is important to find a new and innovative approach
towards super-utilizers.
Copayments
Seeing as a good portion of Medicaid spending comes from state budgets, many states
have shown great interest in cutting down unnecessary ED visits. One of the earliest strategies to
do so was to impose copayments and cost-sharing tactics on Medicaid beneficiaries in hopes that
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 5
the token payments would decrease the use of medical services for non-urgent problems
(Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). During the 2007-2009 Great Recession the Medicaid
program greatly expanded and many states began struggling to contain costs. In response to this
crisis, authority was given through the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 for states to administer and
enforce copayments and premiums for up to 5 percent of the beneficiaries’ annual income
(Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). This included copayments for ED visits if they proved to
be non-urgent in nature. Some states went ahead and implemented copayments for non-urgent
ED visits while other states did not.
However, in a recent study done by Siddiqui, Roberts, and Pollack (2015), it was found
that there was no significant change in ED visits in states that implemented copayments, nor was
there any significant change in ED visits when compared to states that did not have a copayment
(Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). The reason for this may be because ED’s have to provide
care regardless of a patients ability to pay and collecting the copayment after the fact is much
more difficult (Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). It is also often hard to immediately
distinguish between emergent and non-emergent symptoms, which also creates a lag in payment.
Nevertheless, there are states that maintain that higher copayments are needed in order to reduce
unnecessary ED visits. Utah Governor Gary Herbert is proposing to lower premiums for
Medicaid beneficiaries and increasing the ED copayment to $50 for non-emergent conditions
(Ollove, 2015). California and Arizona are also seeking to raise copayments for non-emergent
ED visits (Ollove, 2015).
Alaska
The state of Alaska took a different approach and launched a 2-year pilot program called
the Alaska Medicaid Coordinated Care Initiative, which focuses on providing one-on-one care to
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 6
willing Medicaid patients. Alaska also suffers from Medicaid patients disproportionately
utilizing emergency services, where “3 percent of Medicaid clients are responsible for 22 percent
of all Medicaid emergency room visits” (Andrews, 2014, para. 1). Under the new initiative, case
managers will be assigned to willing clients and will help them with provider selection,
pharmacy selection, appointment scheduling, and any other problems that may arise during the
course of their care (Andrews, 2014). Seeing as Alaska presents some unique geographic
obstacles, the initiative will also work on removing social barriers such as a lack of
transportation and good housing (Andrews, 2014). The outcomes of this pilot program are not
yet available, but considerable savings are expected.
Oregon
The state of Oregon has a few different experiments under way, one of which is a pilot
program called the Alternative Destination and Transportation study, which was implemented in
Multnomah County by the Portland Fire Bureau and American Medical Response (AMR). The
premise of this study is that individuals who use the ED inappropriately, also often get there by
calling 911 and utilizing an ambulance. An ambulance transport costs in the vicinity of $1000,
while an ED visit can be thousands more. In these situations, often times what is more
appropriate is an alternative source of transportation and an alternative destination such as an
urgent care clinic or a doctor’s office (Law, 2014).
The way the program works, is when an eligible individual calls 911, specially trained
paramedics work with that person to either get them to their primary care physician or to an
urgent care clinic via taxi or private vehicle. Unfortunately, because the rules of eligibility were
so strict and only Medicaid and Medicare patients were qualified to participate, only about 100
people were ever candidates for this program (Law, 2014). Of the 100 candidates, many would
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 7
not give written consent to go to an alternative destination, and still others were unable to get an
appointment soon enough. In the end, only 16 people were actually transported to an alternative
destination and not to an emergency room (Law, 2014). While the idea was good, there were too
many limitations and not enough incentive for patients to decline an ambulance that was already
there in lieu of getting care at a later time.
The latest efforts from the state of Oregon to control unnecessary ED costs comes in a
much more comprehensive form. In 2012, Oregon received a federal grant of $1.9 billion to
reorganize its Medicaid delivery system into Coordinated Care Organizations (CCOs), which
would bring an estimated $3 billion worth of savings over the course of 5 years (Broffman,
2014). This type of organization would form “regional public-private partnerships that accept a
single global budget and are accountable for the physical, mental, and dental health care of their
Medicaid population” (Broffman, 2014, para. 2). While this structure was not strictly made to
cut Medicaid related ED costs, that was one of its goals and there has already been some success.
Going from year 2013 to 2014, the rate of avoidable ED visits decreased from 8.6 percent to 7.4
percent even with the large inflow of new Medicaid members (Oregon.gov, 2016).
Under the CCOs, super-utilizers are identified by the organization and assigned to a
community health worker who then helps the patient and providers to coordinate all needed care.
One such individual, 45-year old Jeremie Seals lived in his car and had multiple ongoing chronic
medical conditions. In 2011 he visited the hospital ED 15 times and was hospitalized 11 times
(Foden-Vencil, 2013). This got the attention of the CCOs and he was asked if he would
participate in their program. He accepted and his coordinator went on to help him purchase
shoes, a sleeping bag, a pillow, helped him schedule medical appointments, made sure he
understood doctor’s instructions, and got him passes to a community center so he could shower.
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 8
As a result, in 2012 he had only 4 visits to the ED and 4 hospitalizations (Foden-Vencil, 2013).
According to CareOregon, one of the health plans for Medicaid and Medicare patients, it takes
less than one hospital admission to more than pay for all the services that the community health
workers provide to the patient (Foden-Vencil, 2013).
Washington
The state of Washington has been perhaps the most aggressive in their search for ways to
cut down on unnecessary ED expenditures. In 2011, the Washington State Health Care
Authority released a mandate that in a one-year period it would pay for no more than 3 non-
emergent ED visits per Medicaid beneficiary. The expected savings from this mandate were
going to be approximately $35 million a year (Ollove, 2015). This plan, however did not sit well
with the state’s doctors and they filed a lawsuit to block it. What was problematic to the doctors
was that the state classified 700 diagnoses as non-emergent, including chest pain, abdominal
pain, and shortness of breath (Ollove, 2015). It would be inappropriate to tell a 60-year-old man
with chest pain not to go to the ED even though the last 3 visits of a similar nature came up
negative for a cardiac event. The fourth visit could easily prove to be a true emergency. The
doctors won in court, which resulted in negotiations between the state and hospitals to work out a
system that would work. “Those sessions ultimately led to Washington State launching the most
comprehensive effort to reduce unnecessary emergency room visits among Medicaid
beneficiaries” (Ollove, 2015, para. 25).
In the end, what Washington created was a network between all the hospitals, so that
information could be shared in order to identify frequent ED users amongst Medicaid recipients
(Ollove, 2015). Once such an individual is identified, hospital personnel work with that person
to get him/her an appointment to see a primary care physician within 96 hours of the ED visit.
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 9
Education is also a big part of the plan and is offered to patients in order to guide them to a better
understanding of what does and does not constitute a real emergency. A 24-hour hotline staffed
with qualified nurses is available to Medicaid beneficiaries for cases where they are not sure if
their complaints and symptoms warrant a trip to the ED. “In the first year of the program,
emergency department visits by Medicaid enrollees declined by 9.9 percent and the rate of visits
by frequent users… fell by 10.7 percent. The savings for 2013 totaled $33.6 million” (Ollove,
2015, para. 29). It appears that Washington’s assertive approach has thus far paid off and has
resulted in millions dollars worth of savings.
Maryland
In many areas around the country where the state itself is not as interested in actively
pursuing limiting preventable ED use, hospitals are picking up the slack. In Maryland where
healthcare reform is in full swing and value-based reimbursement is well under way, hospitals
find it imperative to cut all unnecessary spending. The ED happens to be the best place to start
because of how much more expensive the care is versus other outpatient care settings. Anne
Arundel Medical Center located in Maryland decided to focus on the top 500 patients seen most
often in the ED and in the organization by giving willing participants free in-home support
(Letourneau, 2015). As part of the in-home support plan, care managers visit patients at their
home and assess their social needs and ability to access necessary care. They also provide
education on medication administration and on how to create a better lifestyle. There is no data
yet on how successful this program has been but it shows much promise in keeping patients from
needing to access more intensive and costly medical services (Letourneau, 2015).
Anne Arundel Medical Center did not stop at just free in-home support services for its
patients. The hospital also identified that an inordinate number of 911 ambulances were bringing
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 10
in patients to the ED from a nearby low-income senior housing facility for the treatment of
chronic medical conditions that could easily be treated by a primary care provider (Letourneau,
2015). In response, Anne Arundel applied for and received a grant to build a one-doctor primary
care clinic on the first floor of this senior facility, which gave the residents easy access to a
doctor who also had the ability to make house calls. Since the clinic has been up and running,
there has been a 50 percent reduction in the number of 911 calls from the residents and therefore
a 50 percent reduction in the number of ED visits (Letourneau, 2015). It stands to reason that
with time, and the continuous presence of an on-site doctor, the health of the residents will
increase, and the number of ED visits will decrease even more.
Texas
The Area Metropolitan Ambulance Authority, better known as MedStar, provides
emergent and non-emergent ambulance services to the Forth Worth area in the state of Texas. In
2009, MedStar observed that in a 12-month period, 21 of their patients were transported to local
ED’s a total of 800 times (EMS1.com, 2012). These 21 patients generated $950,000 worth of
ambulance charges that were unpaid or scarcely reimbursed due to the fact that they were either
Medicaid beneficiaries or completely uninsured (EMS1.com, 2012). MedStar’s medical director
decided that it was time for an intervention and launched a pilot Community Health Program
(CHP) that aimed at decreasing unnecessary ambulance transports and ED visits.
In this program, super-utilizers are identified through ED and caseworker referrals, as
well as through the company database. Specially trained paramedics then make contact with the
patients and offer them their services. If a patient agrees, the paramedics conduct an in-depth
home visit where they make a full medical assessment and help the patient build “an
individualized care plan that outlines their needs and responsibilities related to managing health
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 11
and health care on an ongoing basis” (EMS1.com, 2012, para. 15). After the initial home visit,
paramedics continue to conduct 2-3 shorter visits per week, which later taper off as the patient
begins making progress. Patients are also able to telephone the CHP paramedics any time an
urgent need arises. When the paramedics deem a patient is able to sufficiently manage their own
health, that patient then graduates from the program. Graduates continue to have access to a 24-
hour hotline that will activate the CHP paramedics for a visit within an hour if they should call.
To date, the CHP has been widely successful and MedStar has even launched several
more similar programs directed at patients who would otherwise utilize an ambulance transport
and the ED (Jacob, 2014). Between the programs launch in 2009 and 2011, “the volume of 911
calls from the program’s 186 enrollees fell by 58 percent” (EMS1.com, 2012, para. 27). With
the decline in calls and transports, MedStar saved $2.8 million on ambulance charges and local
hospitals saved an estimated $9 million in ED charges (EMS1.com, 2012). As of 2014, CHP has
had 264 graduates with an 85 percent reduction in ED use in the year following graduation
(Jacob, 2014).
The barrier to this type of program for many EMS systems is that traditionally,
responders only get paid when they transport to an ED. With the lack of reimbursement, there is
often little incentive for ambulance companies to provide this type of service to the community.
Fortunately, with the shift toward value-based and coordinated care, there is now room for EMS
systems to be part of the team. For example, MedStar now has several agreements with local
accountable care organizations (ACOs) to fund an Observation Admission Avoidance program, a
Hospice Revocation Avoidance program, and a 911 Nurse Triage program (Jacob, 2014). The
Observation Admission Avoidance program allows patients to be observed by paramedics
overnight at their homes instead of the hospital, while the Hospice Revocation Avoidance
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 12
program works to prevent high-risk patients from calling 911, as that would revoke their hospice
status. Lastly, the 911 Nurse Triage program redirects non-emergent 911 calls to MedStar’s call
center, where a trained nurse helps the callers find appropriate medical resources. In a seven-
month stretch, more than 500 patients were diverted from using the ED via the 911 Nurse Triage
program (Jacob, 2014). Since the start of these programs, “MedStar estimates its mobile
healthcare programs have saved more than $3.3 million in healthcare expenditure” (Jacob, 2014,
para. 16).
Conclusion
Healthcare expenditures in the United States are steadily rising and many private, state,
and federal organizations are working hard to reverse this trend while still retaining a high
quality of care. One area of the healthcare system that can be substantially improved is the
overutilization of EMS and ED services. The top 5 percent of patients in the United States are
responsible for 50 percent of all healthcare expenditures and the majority of these patients are in
and out of the ED on a regular basis (Boodman, 2013). If a system were in place that could catch
these individuals early on to provide them with self-management skills, perhaps many of the
consequential hospitalizations and health complications could be avoided, thus effectively
decreasing healthcare spending.
Statistics say that Medicaid patients utilize the ED at twice the rate of those with private
insurance, with only 10 percent of those visits being non-emergent (CMS, 2014). This is
indicative of a much bigger problem, which is the egregious lack of access to primary care. Due
to low reimbursement rates, Medicaid beneficiaries often have a hard time finding providers that
will treat them in the primary care setting. Medicaid patients are also generally less healthy,
frequently lack transportation, and often work hourly jobs making it difficult to make doctor’s
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 13
appointments during business hours (Ollove, 2015). Making access to primary care more
available to this population would go a long way in cutting down on preventable ambulance
transports and ED visits.
While the federal government has not been as involved in undertaking this challenge,
many States and private organizations have been hard at work. Several states have been
especially interested in cutting avoidable ED visits by Medicaid recipients, as that would mean
huge savings for their budgets. Alaska, Oregon, and Washington have each invested in various
forms of patient-centered systems that focus on providing one-on-one care to problem
populations. Those systems have generally showed improvement in how often the ED was used
and in the health of the patients themselves. It appears that teaching and educating patients on
how to care for themselves is better then any punitive approaches that have been taken in the
past, such as increasing copays.
The last innovative idea that was explored is the Community Health Program
implemented by MedStar in Texas. This program allows specially trained paramedics to identify
individuals who frequently call 911 for transport to the ED and to work with them to get their
medical needs under control. As of 2014, MedStar has seen an 85% reduction in ED use from
the individuals they have worked with in the year following their graduation from the program
(Jacob, 2014). If this type of program were widely implemented it could become the first line of
defense for people battling chronic conditions and not knowing how to self-manage their health.
Paramedics make great candidates for this job as they already work out in the field and have
experience in administering care in the patient’s personal environment.
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 14
Recommendations
Reducing avoidable EMS and ED utilization is feasible and can be achieved by doing the
following: expanding access to care for disadvantaged populations, creating a communications
network between hospitals, switching to an integrated and value-based system of patient care,
and by incorporating ambulance based community programs for super-utilizers. Expanding
access to primary care would be the first step in the process. If patients are to be diverted from
using the more expensive services in the ED, then they have to have a place to go to instead. The
first method by which access to care can be improved by is extending primary care hours to
cover evenings and weekends. According to CMS (2014), two-thirds of all visits to the
emergency room occur after business hours. It is estimated that an annual net savings of $4.4
billion can be realized if this type of access was increased (CMS, 2014). In a rural area of
Georgia, four clinics were opened with extended hours and as a result over a 3-year period,
33,000 patients were served with savings of approximately $7.3 million (CMS, 2014).
Another problem that is often encountered with access to care is the lack of same day
appointments. Patients who are experiencing a medical event of some kind and are ready to go to
the ED are not likely to wait for weeks or even days to get an appointment with their doctor. To
solve this problem, a system called open-access can be implemented. Open-access is a
scheduling model that a number of medical practices use to consistently offer their patients same
day appointments. This system works by allowing the majority of time slots to be available for
same or next day appointments. The other portion of the time slots, which is smaller, remains
reserved for patients who want to schedule further in advance. In addition, in the open-access
model, all appointment types are the same and interchangeable which allows for maximum
flexibility (Carlson, 2002). This is in stark contrast to conventional scheduling practices, where
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 15
provider’s book appointments by type and assorted exclusion and inclusion criteria make the
system uncompromising and appointments difficult to move around (Carlson, 2002). Data
clearly shows that open-access scheduling is profitable and generally drops the number of no-
shows from approximately 20 percent to nearly zero (Jones, 2014). Going to this type of system
would significantly benefit patients as well as providers.
The second step in reducing avoidable costs associated with the use of EMS and the ED
is to build a communications network between all the hospitals. Due to the scope of this
endeavor, the state may have the best advantage and the necessary authority to accomplish
developing such a network. A network that includes all area hospitals would be instrumental in
identifying super-utilizers and individuals who frequent many different hospitals on a regular
basis. After these individuals were identified, they could then be referred to a caseworker or a
community paramedic program where they would receive one-on-one education and instruction
on how to manage their health. The state of Washington has this kind of network in place and
they use hospital personnel to help direct patients to a primary care clinic as well as to provide
education (Ollove, 2015), which is also a viable option.
The third step is to establish Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) and/or any other
type of value-based care system that would encourage the formation of programs that could
individually work with patients to address their medical needs and their inability to effectively
manage their health. This could take on many different forms as each population greatly varies
by location and culture. In Oregon, CCO’s developed at the state level have been the driving
force behind the one-on-one care being done by community health workers while in Maryland,
the federally implemented value-based reimbursement system is what is triggering hospitals to
pursue free in-home health and individualized care through caseworkers. Having some type of
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 16
value-based system in place is important because it is what provides incentive for physicians to
coordinate care and to work with patients to stop unnecessary over-utilization. In a value-based
system, coordinating care is key, which is why all kinds of relationships are being created with
both public and private health organizations opening doors for new and innovative ways to
provide better care and to decrease spending.
The last step in decreasing unnecessary ED costs and EMS transports is to incorporate
more ambulance based community paramedic programs, such as the one MedStar began in
Texas. Many super-utilizers of the ED are also super-utilizers of 911 ambulances, especially
when it comes to disadvantaged populations who may lack their own transportation (Ollove,
2015). Moreover, patients who are prone to using the ED for their primary care needs often go
to multiple different hospitals, which puts the ambulance companies in the best position to more
quickly identify who these individual are. Once identified, these individuals can be enrolled in a
community paramedic program, which will provide them with education and the necessary
management skills to successfully manage their health, all from the comfort of their own home.
Paramedics are uniquely suited for this type of program because they are mobile, have medical
training, and are experienced in providing care outside the medical setting.
Expanding access to primary care, creating a communications network, providing
healthcare on a value-based system, and integrating community paramedic programs are four
elements that are all important and necessary in decreasing avoidable ED visits and EMS
transports. While some of these elements are being applied individually, they would be most
effective when used as a collective. It is important to take note that certain elements are not
likely to exist without the other. For example, EMS companies have no incentive to create
community paramedic programs because they would not be reimbursed for those services.
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 17
However with the development of ACO’s reimbursement becomes possible, thus making the two
rely on each other. The same can be applied to the communications network. What is the point
of communicating if there is nowhere the patient can be directed? The network depends on the
existence of primary care access, caseworkers, and community paramedic programs.
If implemented, these four elements could make a huge impact on the quality of
healthcare in the United States and the amount of money spent on it. Not only is there the
potential to cut costs by stopping unnecessary and preventable ED visits, but there is also the
potential to stop future costs that individuals with poorly managed chronic conditions will incur
in their lifetime. Catching these problem areas as early as possible and offering individuals a
chance to take their life back through personalized education and assistance will no doubt results
in a higher level of care for the patient and significant savings for the county.
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 18
References
Andrews, L. (2014, July 3). State aims to curb overuse of emergency rooms by some Medicaid
patients. Alaska Dispatch News. Retrieved from http://www.adn.com/alaska-
news/article/state-aims-curb-overuse-emergency-rooms-some-medicaid-patients-
0/2014/07/03/
Boodman, S. G. (2013, October 7). Costliest 1 percent of patients account for 21 percent of U.S.
health spending. Kaiser Health News. Retrieved from http://khn.org/news/one-percent-of-
costliest-patients/
Broffman, L. (2014, September 11). Year zero: Leaders at Oregon’s CCOs share lessons from
the early days. Health Affairs Blog. Retrieved from
http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2014/09/11/year-zero-leaders-at-oregons-ccos-share-lessons-
from-the-early-days/
Carlson, B. (2002). Same-day appointments promise increased productivity. Managed Care
Magazine. Retrieved from http://www.managedcaremag.com/archives/2002/12/same-
day-appointments-promise-increased-productivity
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services [CMS]. (2014). Reducing nonurgent use of
emergency departments and improving appropriate care in appropriate settings.
Retrieved from https://www.medicaid.gov/Federal-Policy-Guidance/Downloads/CIB-01-
16-14.pdf
EMS1.com. (2012). Case study: How an EMS agency tackled ‘frequent fliers’. Retrieved from
http://www.ems1.com/research-reviews/articles/1233831-Case-study-How-an-EMS-
agency-tackled-frequent-fliers/
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 19
Foden-Vencil, K. (2013, July 10). How Oregon is getting ‘frequent flyers’ out of hospital ERs.
Kaiser Health News. Retrieved from http://khn.org/news/emergency-room-frequent-
flyers/
Ingram, J. (2013, May 21). Medicaid expansion won’t reduce unnecessary ER visits. Illinois
Policy. Retrieved from https://www.illinoispolicy.org/medicaid-expansion-wont-reduce-
unnecessary-er-visits/
Jacob, S. (2014, February 12). “EMS loyalty program” slashes emergency room trips, saves
millions. D Healthcare Daily. Retrieved from
http://healthcare.dmagazine.com/2014/02/12/ems-loyalty-program-slashes-emergency-
room-trips-saves-millions/
Jones, M. (2014, February 11). Open-access scheduling: 5 surprising misconceptions. The
Profitable Practice. Retrieved from http://profitable-
practice.softwareadvice.com/misconceptions-about-open-access-scheduling-0214/
Law, S. (2014, October 30). ER trips test new ride. Portland Tribune. Retrieved from
http://portlandtribune.com/pt/9-news/238842-104102-er-trips-test-new-ride
Letourneau, R. (2015, June 29). Population health strategies to keep frequent flyers out of the
hospital. Health Leaders Media. Retrieved from
http://www.healthleadersmedia.com/finance/population-health-strategies-keep-frequent-
flyers-out-hospital
Ollove, M. (2015). States strive to keep Medicaid patients out of the emergency department. The
Pew Charitable Trusts. Retrieved from http://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-
analysis/blogs/stateline/2015/2/24/states-strive-to-keep-medicaid-patients-out-of-the-
emergency-department
REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 20
Oregon.gov. (2016). Post ACA population – avoidable emergency department utilization.
Retrieved from http://www.oregon.gov/oha/Metrics/Pages/aca-avoid-ed-utilization.aspx
Siddiqui, M., Roberts, E. T., & Pollack, C. E. (2015). The effect of emergency department
copayments for Medicaid beneficiaries following the deficit reduction act of 2005. JAMA
Internal Medicine, 175(3), 393-398. doi: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2014.7582
The Fiscal Times. (2013). Emergency room costs have skyrocketed to as much as $151 billion.
Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/er-costs-skyrocketed-to-151-billion-
2013-4

More Related Content

What's hot

Money Your Practice May Be Throwing Away
Money Your Practice May Be Throwing AwayMoney Your Practice May Be Throwing Away
Money Your Practice May Be Throwing Awaye-MedTools
 
Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025
Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025
Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025needppthelp
 
Defensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcare
Defensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcareDefensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcare
Defensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcareAlexander Decker
 
Population health management real time state-of-health analysis
Population health management real time state-of-health analysisPopulation health management real time state-of-health analysis
Population health management real time state-of-health analysispscisolutions
 
DataBrief No. 21: Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional Impairment
DataBrief No. 21:  Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional ImpairmentDataBrief No. 21:  Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional Impairment
DataBrief No. 21: Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional ImpairmentThe Scan Foundation
 
Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...
Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...
Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...Gerrit Lensink
 
DataBrief No. 23: Medicare Spending by Quintile
DataBrief No. 23:  Medicare Spending by QuintileDataBrief No. 23:  Medicare Spending by Quintile
DataBrief No. 23: Medicare Spending by QuintileThe Scan Foundation
 
Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...
Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...
Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...Global Medical Cures™
 
National Juxtapositions in Healthcare Delivery and Quality
National Juxtapositionsin Healthcare Delivery and QualityNational Juxtapositionsin Healthcare Delivery and Quality
National Juxtapositions in Healthcare Delivery and QualityEric Luellen
 
DataBrief No. 25: Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...
DataBrief No. 25:  Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...DataBrief No. 25:  Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...
DataBrief No. 25: Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...The Scan Foundation
 
IHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's next
IHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's nextIHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's next
IHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's nextGalen Institute
 
Hit Potential Peg Schible
Hit Potential   Peg SchibleHit Potential   Peg Schible
Hit Potential Peg Schiblepegscheible
 
Health policy primer
Health policy primerHealth policy primer
Health policy primerjeff214
 
Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2
Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2
Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2soder145
 
Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...
Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...
Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...Ardavan Shahroodi
 
MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...
MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...
MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...Frank Fortin
 
DataBrief No. 22: Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...
DataBrief No. 22:  Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...DataBrief No. 22:  Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...
DataBrief No. 22: Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...The Scan Foundation
 
WorldVistA 061607
WorldVistA 061607WorldVistA 061607
WorldVistA 061607ckuyehar
 
Evolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPP
Evolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPPEvolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPP
Evolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPPDebbie Fernando
 

What's hot (20)

Money Your Practice May Be Throwing Away
Money Your Practice May Be Throwing AwayMoney Your Practice May Be Throwing Away
Money Your Practice May Be Throwing Away
 
Middleton.Cgu2005v6
Middleton.Cgu2005v6Middleton.Cgu2005v6
Middleton.Cgu2005v6
 
Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025
Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025
Current healthcare trends and jobs outlook for 2025
 
Defensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcare
Defensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcareDefensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcare
Defensive medicine effect on costs, quality, and access to healthcare
 
Population health management real time state-of-health analysis
Population health management real time state-of-health analysisPopulation health management real time state-of-health analysis
Population health management real time state-of-health analysis
 
DataBrief No. 21: Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional Impairment
DataBrief No. 21:  Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional ImpairmentDataBrief No. 21:  Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional Impairment
DataBrief No. 21: Dual Eligibles, Chronic Conditions and Functional Impairment
 
Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...
Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...
Physician Expectations and Primary Care Shortages: Evidence from the Affordab...
 
DataBrief No. 23: Medicare Spending by Quintile
DataBrief No. 23:  Medicare Spending by QuintileDataBrief No. 23:  Medicare Spending by Quintile
DataBrief No. 23: Medicare Spending by Quintile
 
Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...
Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...
Global Medical Cures™ | Medicare Payments- How Much Do Chronic Conditions Mat...
 
National Juxtapositions in Healthcare Delivery and Quality
National Juxtapositionsin Healthcare Delivery and QualityNational Juxtapositionsin Healthcare Delivery and Quality
National Juxtapositions in Healthcare Delivery and Quality
 
DataBrief No. 25: Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...
DataBrief No. 25:  Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...DataBrief No. 25:  Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...
DataBrief No. 25: Service Utilization Functional Impairment and Chronic Cond...
 
IHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's next
IHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's nextIHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's next
IHC -- Health reform: What it means and what's next
 
Hit Potential Peg Schible
Hit Potential   Peg SchibleHit Potential   Peg Schible
Hit Potential Peg Schible
 
Health policy primer
Health policy primerHealth policy primer
Health policy primer
 
Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2
Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2
Pres arm2010 june27_kenney2
 
Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...
Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...
Elements of the Health Care Eco-Sytem that Pose as Barriers to Care Week 5 Wr...
 
MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...
MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...
MMS State of the State: JudyAnn Bigby- Overview of the State of the State's H...
 
DataBrief No. 22: Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...
DataBrief No. 22:  Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...DataBrief No. 22:  Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...
DataBrief No. 22: Medicare Spending by Functional Impairment and Chronic Con...
 
WorldVistA 061607
WorldVistA 061607WorldVistA 061607
WorldVistA 061607
 
Evolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPP
Evolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPPEvolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPP
Evolution in Health Care Delivery- Urgent Care Centers PPP
 

Viewers also liked

Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?
Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?
Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?WebExpo
 
인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임
인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임
인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임복 성규
 
User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...
User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...
User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...Maria Chaykina
 
Matemáticas i Bachilleres
Matemáticas i BachilleresMatemáticas i Bachilleres
Matemáticas i BachilleresFane Hered
 
Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...
Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...
Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...Tommy Darker
 
Web.com Small Business Mobile Survey
Web.com Small Business Mobile SurveyWeb.com Small Business Mobile Survey
Web.com Small Business Mobile SurveyWeb.com
 
20140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture10
20140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture1020140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture10
20140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture10Computer Science Club
 
El Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato Lenguas
El Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato LenguasEl Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato Lenguas
El Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato LenguasAna Basterra
 
Garcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primero
Garcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primeroGarcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primero
Garcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primeroLuis Lopez Ac
 
Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...
Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...
Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...Tommy Darker
 

Viewers also liked (18)

CENTR+
CENTR+CENTR+
CENTR+
 
Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?
Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?
Marli Mesibov - What's in a Story?
 
인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임
인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임
인터넷경마…SDS119"COM…바둑이게임
 
User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...
User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...
User Experience 2011: Принципы композиции и модульные сетки при проектировани...
 
Matemáticas i Bachilleres
Matemáticas i BachilleresMatemáticas i Bachilleres
Matemáticas i Bachilleres
 
Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...
Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...
Felix Canetty-Clarke - What The Heck Does Your Audience Want? [Darker Music T...
 
Boletin prensa04 12-2012
Boletin prensa04 12-2012Boletin prensa04 12-2012
Boletin prensa04 12-2012
 
Bài 8
Bài 8Bài 8
Bài 8
 
Web.com Small Business Mobile Survey
Web.com Small Business Mobile SurveyWeb.com Small Business Mobile Survey
Web.com Small Business Mobile Survey
 
1. cover ppl
1. cover ppl1. cover ppl
1. cover ppl
 
Fuentes aqtx-1.1
Fuentes aqtx-1.1Fuentes aqtx-1.1
Fuentes aqtx-1.1
 
20140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture10
20140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture1020140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture10
20140420 parallel programming_kalishenko_lecture10
 
Cero papel
Cero papelCero papel
Cero papel
 
El Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato Lenguas
El Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato LenguasEl Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato Lenguas
El Nuevo Curriculum Bachillerato Lenguas
 
busqueme
busqueme busqueme
busqueme
 
Garcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primero
Garcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primeroGarcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primero
Garcia j et al 2000 aprenda java como si estuviera en primero
 
Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...
Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...
Tyrone Isaac-Stuart - How Musicpreneurs Deal With Their Struggles [Darker Mus...
 
Pates
PatesPates
Pates
 

Similar to Dissertation

DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docxDQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docxelinoraudley582231
 
11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docx
11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docx11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docx
11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docxdrennanmicah
 
Suraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_Care
Suraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_CareSuraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_Care
Suraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_CareSuraj Jaladanki
 
How to Use HIT for CCM
How to Use HIT for CCMHow to Use HIT for CCM
How to Use HIT for CCMPhytel
 
Realizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docx
Realizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docxRealizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docx
Realizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docxsodhi3
 
Running head PUBLIC HEALTH 1PUBLIC H.docx
Running head PUBLIC HEALTH          1PUBLIC H.docxRunning head PUBLIC HEALTH          1PUBLIC H.docx
Running head PUBLIC HEALTH 1PUBLIC H.docxtodd581
 
Unit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docx
Unit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docxUnit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docx
Unit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docxwillcoxjanay
 
MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION,
MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION, MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION,
MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION, DioneWang844
 
Primary Care Physician (PCP)
Primary Care Physician (PCP)Primary Care Physician (PCP)
Primary Care Physician (PCP)Kristen Stacey
 
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docxRunning head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docxtoddr4
 
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docxRunning head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docxhealdkathaleen
 
Non-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain Applications
Non-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain ApplicationsNon-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain Applications
Non-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain ApplicationsMaria Yaremenko
 
Running head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docx
Running head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docxRunning head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docx
Running head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docxjenkinsmandie
 
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docxApril 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docxjewisonantone
 
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docxApril 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docxjustine1simpson78276
 
Assessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at Summa
Assessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at SummaAssessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at Summa
Assessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at SummaAhmed Furkan Ozgur
 
Running head HEALTH CARE .docx
Running head HEALTH CARE                                        .docxRunning head HEALTH CARE                                        .docx
Running head HEALTH CARE .docxcowinhelen
 

Similar to Dissertation (20)

DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docxDQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
 
11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docx
11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docx11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docx
11 minutes agoJessica Dunne RE Discussion - Week 3COLLAPS.docx
 
Suraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_Care
Suraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_CareSuraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_Care
Suraj_Jaladanki_Research_Paper_Cost_Effective_Health_Care
 
How to Use HIT for CCM
How to Use HIT for CCMHow to Use HIT for CCM
How to Use HIT for CCM
 
READMISSION
READMISSIONREADMISSION
READMISSION
 
Realizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docx
Realizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docxRealizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docx
Realizing Health Reform’s Potential How the Affordable Care .docx
 
Running head PUBLIC HEALTH 1PUBLIC H.docx
Running head PUBLIC HEALTH          1PUBLIC H.docxRunning head PUBLIC HEALTH          1PUBLIC H.docx
Running head PUBLIC HEALTH 1PUBLIC H.docx
 
Mechanisms used by managed care
Mechanisms used by managed careMechanisms used by managed care
Mechanisms used by managed care
 
Unit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docx
Unit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docxUnit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docx
Unit 1Emergency Department Overcrowding Due to L.docx
 
MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION,
MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION, MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION,
MHA6999 SEMINAR IN HEALTHCARE CASES-- WEEK 2 LECTURE, DISCUSSION,
 
Primary Care Physician (PCP)
Primary Care Physician (PCP)Primary Care Physician (PCP)
Primary Care Physician (PCP)
 
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docxRunning head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
 
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docxRunning head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
Running head A REVIEW OF KEY CURRENT HEALTHCARE ISSUES QUALITY A.docx
 
Non-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain Applications
Non-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain ApplicationsNon-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain Applications
Non-Emergency Medical Transportation and the Promise of Blockchain Applications
 
Project Two HCS 410
Project Two HCS 410Project Two HCS 410
Project Two HCS 410
 
Running head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docx
Running head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docxRunning head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docx
Running head U.S. HEALTHCARE EXECUTIVES 1U.S. HEALTHCARE EX.docx
 
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docxApril 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
 
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docxApril 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
April 2011In the fall of 2010, the Alliance for Health R.docx
 
Assessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at Summa
Assessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at SummaAssessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at Summa
Assessing the Effectiveness of the New Senior ED Program at Summa
 
Running head HEALTH CARE .docx
Running head HEALTH CARE                                        .docxRunning head HEALTH CARE                                        .docx
Running head HEALTH CARE .docx
 

More from Irina Bubnova

More from Irina Bubnova (9)

Pre-incident plan
Pre-incident planPre-incident plan
Pre-incident plan
 
Acupuncture Presentation
Acupuncture PresentationAcupuncture Presentation
Acupuncture Presentation
 
Obesity Final Paper
Obesity Final PaperObesity Final Paper
Obesity Final Paper
 
Pharma Final Presentation
Pharma Final PresentationPharma Final Presentation
Pharma Final Presentation
 
Diabetes PP
Diabetes PPDiabetes PP
Diabetes PP
 
Rhabdomyolysis
RhabdomyolysisRhabdomyolysis
Rhabdomyolysis
 
Irina&Jeff
Irina&JeffIrina&Jeff
Irina&Jeff
 
SKPM Volunteer Application Form-2016
SKPM Volunteer Application Form-2016SKPM Volunteer Application Form-2016
SKPM Volunteer Application Form-2016
 
Russian for Beginners
Russian for BeginnersRussian for Beginners
Russian for Beginners
 

Dissertation

  • 1. Running head: REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 1 Reducing the Preventable Use of Emergency Services Could Generate Substantial Healthcare Savings Irina Bubnova HCA 450A: Critical Issues in Health Care Professor Ronning Warner Pacific College June 26, 2016
  • 2. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 2 Reducing the Preventable Use of Emergency Services Could Generate Substantial Healthcare Savings Since the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in 2010, America entered into an era of healthcare reform in a desperate attempt to curb ever rising healthcare costs. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) were given unprecedented power to develop and implement various cost saving pilot programs in the hopes of finding something that works. Many hospitals as well as numerous private, state, and federal organizations have also been implementing their own experimental programs, all with the intention of stopping growing healthcare costs. However, the issues are numerous and no one solution can fix the entire healthcare system. One aspect that has not been well addressed by the CMS and can be vastly improved upon is the problem of unnecessary and/or avoidable ambulance transports and emergency department visits by Medicare and more specifically Medicaid patients. Background Prior to examining the issue of the overuse of emergency departments (EDs) and emergency medical services (EMS), it is important to put these costs on the system in the right perspective. According to The Pew Charitable Trusts organization, in 2012 the American government spent $1.3 trillion on healthcare, of which 4 percent went to ED costs (Ollove, 2015). Four percent does not seem like a lot compared to the $1.3 trillion total, however this percentage is debatable and critics point out that there are multiple formulas that can be used to calculate this number (The Fiscal Times, 2013). By adjusting for discrepancies and adding more databases, a secondary source estimated ED costs to be between 4.9 and 5.8 percent of total health care expenditures (The Fiscal Times, 2013). By using still another database, this same source found ED costs to be between 6.2 and 10 percent (The Fiscal Times, 2013). It is difficult
  • 3. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 3 to ascertain the exact percentage of spending that goes toward ED costs, but one thing is undisputable, and that is the fact that emergency services are exponentially more costly than office-based care and can be successfully reduced with the right approach. According to CMS (2014), Medicaid recipients utilize the ED at twice the rate of those with private insurance. For example, in Oregon 50 percent of all ED expenses are accrued as a result of just 3 percent of the Medicaid population or 16,000 individuals (CMS, 2014). Many assume that there is rampant abuse of the system amongst Medicaid beneficiaries, but data shows that in reality only 10 percent of all ED visits by these patients are non-urgent and all other visits are indeed appropriate and necessary (CMS, 2014). There are a number of reasons as to why specifically Medicaid patients have a disproportionate need for ED services and most of them can be traced back to a poorer health status and poor access to care. Due to socio-economic disadvantages, Medicaid patients are generally less healthy than the overall population (Ollove, 2015). They tend to have poor nutrition and to be prone to numerous chronic disorders that are extremely costly to the healthcare system. Medicaid recipients also come up against countless barriers when it comes to getting primary care. Many providers do not accept Medicaid patients due to low reimbursement rates, or at the very least they severely limit their numbers. In Illinois, more than 35 percent of physicians will not accept any new Medicaid patients and appointments with specialists are denied two-thirds of the time (Ingram, 2013). Furthermore, Medicaid patients also often lack transportation and have jobs that make it difficult for them to get to a doctor’s appointment during regular working hours (Ollove, 2015). ED’s on the other hand are open 24 hours a day, and cannot by law turn anybody away from receiving care, making it the perfect place for Medicaid patient to turn to during a medical crisis. Overall, poor health coupled with a lack of
  • 4. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 4 good access to care creates a disastrous cycle that easily compounds medical conditions and in the end, healthcare costs. As was mentioned earlier, depending on how data is interpreted, ED costs account for approximately 4-10 percent of annual healthcare expenditures. While this number is not awe inspiring, it is beneficial in this instance to take a step back and look at the whole picture. According to Kaiser Health News, 1 percent of patients account for 21 percent of all healthcare costs, while 5 percent account for 50 percent of all costs (Boodman, 2013). Now this data is shocking. Image that a meager 5 percent of patients accounts for half of all healthcare expenditures. The patients in this 5 percent are commonly called super-utilizers and “nearly all wind up in emergency rooms because they have enormous difficulty navigating the increasingly fragmented, complicated and inflexible health-care system” (Boodman, 2013, para. 4). Furthermore, “because of lack of alternatives or force of habit, they use hospitals, often several in the same city, for care that could be provided far more cheaply and effectively in outpatient settings” (Boodman, 2013, para. 4). For example, a certain patient loses his method of transportation and misses 2 weeks worth of dialysis treatments. He then ends up being transported by ambulance to an ED, where he incurs a $30,000 hospitalization bill on top of substantial EMS and ED charges. The takeaway here is that the costliest patients nearly all begin their journey in the ED, which is why it is important to find a new and innovative approach towards super-utilizers. Copayments Seeing as a good portion of Medicaid spending comes from state budgets, many states have shown great interest in cutting down unnecessary ED visits. One of the earliest strategies to do so was to impose copayments and cost-sharing tactics on Medicaid beneficiaries in hopes that
  • 5. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 5 the token payments would decrease the use of medical services for non-urgent problems (Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). During the 2007-2009 Great Recession the Medicaid program greatly expanded and many states began struggling to contain costs. In response to this crisis, authority was given through the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 for states to administer and enforce copayments and premiums for up to 5 percent of the beneficiaries’ annual income (Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). This included copayments for ED visits if they proved to be non-urgent in nature. Some states went ahead and implemented copayments for non-urgent ED visits while other states did not. However, in a recent study done by Siddiqui, Roberts, and Pollack (2015), it was found that there was no significant change in ED visits in states that implemented copayments, nor was there any significant change in ED visits when compared to states that did not have a copayment (Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). The reason for this may be because ED’s have to provide care regardless of a patients ability to pay and collecting the copayment after the fact is much more difficult (Siddiqui, Roberts, & Pollack, 2015). It is also often hard to immediately distinguish between emergent and non-emergent symptoms, which also creates a lag in payment. Nevertheless, there are states that maintain that higher copayments are needed in order to reduce unnecessary ED visits. Utah Governor Gary Herbert is proposing to lower premiums for Medicaid beneficiaries and increasing the ED copayment to $50 for non-emergent conditions (Ollove, 2015). California and Arizona are also seeking to raise copayments for non-emergent ED visits (Ollove, 2015). Alaska The state of Alaska took a different approach and launched a 2-year pilot program called the Alaska Medicaid Coordinated Care Initiative, which focuses on providing one-on-one care to
  • 6. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 6 willing Medicaid patients. Alaska also suffers from Medicaid patients disproportionately utilizing emergency services, where “3 percent of Medicaid clients are responsible for 22 percent of all Medicaid emergency room visits” (Andrews, 2014, para. 1). Under the new initiative, case managers will be assigned to willing clients and will help them with provider selection, pharmacy selection, appointment scheduling, and any other problems that may arise during the course of their care (Andrews, 2014). Seeing as Alaska presents some unique geographic obstacles, the initiative will also work on removing social barriers such as a lack of transportation and good housing (Andrews, 2014). The outcomes of this pilot program are not yet available, but considerable savings are expected. Oregon The state of Oregon has a few different experiments under way, one of which is a pilot program called the Alternative Destination and Transportation study, which was implemented in Multnomah County by the Portland Fire Bureau and American Medical Response (AMR). The premise of this study is that individuals who use the ED inappropriately, also often get there by calling 911 and utilizing an ambulance. An ambulance transport costs in the vicinity of $1000, while an ED visit can be thousands more. In these situations, often times what is more appropriate is an alternative source of transportation and an alternative destination such as an urgent care clinic or a doctor’s office (Law, 2014). The way the program works, is when an eligible individual calls 911, specially trained paramedics work with that person to either get them to their primary care physician or to an urgent care clinic via taxi or private vehicle. Unfortunately, because the rules of eligibility were so strict and only Medicaid and Medicare patients were qualified to participate, only about 100 people were ever candidates for this program (Law, 2014). Of the 100 candidates, many would
  • 7. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 7 not give written consent to go to an alternative destination, and still others were unable to get an appointment soon enough. In the end, only 16 people were actually transported to an alternative destination and not to an emergency room (Law, 2014). While the idea was good, there were too many limitations and not enough incentive for patients to decline an ambulance that was already there in lieu of getting care at a later time. The latest efforts from the state of Oregon to control unnecessary ED costs comes in a much more comprehensive form. In 2012, Oregon received a federal grant of $1.9 billion to reorganize its Medicaid delivery system into Coordinated Care Organizations (CCOs), which would bring an estimated $3 billion worth of savings over the course of 5 years (Broffman, 2014). This type of organization would form “regional public-private partnerships that accept a single global budget and are accountable for the physical, mental, and dental health care of their Medicaid population” (Broffman, 2014, para. 2). While this structure was not strictly made to cut Medicaid related ED costs, that was one of its goals and there has already been some success. Going from year 2013 to 2014, the rate of avoidable ED visits decreased from 8.6 percent to 7.4 percent even with the large inflow of new Medicaid members (Oregon.gov, 2016). Under the CCOs, super-utilizers are identified by the organization and assigned to a community health worker who then helps the patient and providers to coordinate all needed care. One such individual, 45-year old Jeremie Seals lived in his car and had multiple ongoing chronic medical conditions. In 2011 he visited the hospital ED 15 times and was hospitalized 11 times (Foden-Vencil, 2013). This got the attention of the CCOs and he was asked if he would participate in their program. He accepted and his coordinator went on to help him purchase shoes, a sleeping bag, a pillow, helped him schedule medical appointments, made sure he understood doctor’s instructions, and got him passes to a community center so he could shower.
  • 8. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 8 As a result, in 2012 he had only 4 visits to the ED and 4 hospitalizations (Foden-Vencil, 2013). According to CareOregon, one of the health plans for Medicaid and Medicare patients, it takes less than one hospital admission to more than pay for all the services that the community health workers provide to the patient (Foden-Vencil, 2013). Washington The state of Washington has been perhaps the most aggressive in their search for ways to cut down on unnecessary ED expenditures. In 2011, the Washington State Health Care Authority released a mandate that in a one-year period it would pay for no more than 3 non- emergent ED visits per Medicaid beneficiary. The expected savings from this mandate were going to be approximately $35 million a year (Ollove, 2015). This plan, however did not sit well with the state’s doctors and they filed a lawsuit to block it. What was problematic to the doctors was that the state classified 700 diagnoses as non-emergent, including chest pain, abdominal pain, and shortness of breath (Ollove, 2015). It would be inappropriate to tell a 60-year-old man with chest pain not to go to the ED even though the last 3 visits of a similar nature came up negative for a cardiac event. The fourth visit could easily prove to be a true emergency. The doctors won in court, which resulted in negotiations between the state and hospitals to work out a system that would work. “Those sessions ultimately led to Washington State launching the most comprehensive effort to reduce unnecessary emergency room visits among Medicaid beneficiaries” (Ollove, 2015, para. 25). In the end, what Washington created was a network between all the hospitals, so that information could be shared in order to identify frequent ED users amongst Medicaid recipients (Ollove, 2015). Once such an individual is identified, hospital personnel work with that person to get him/her an appointment to see a primary care physician within 96 hours of the ED visit.
  • 9. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 9 Education is also a big part of the plan and is offered to patients in order to guide them to a better understanding of what does and does not constitute a real emergency. A 24-hour hotline staffed with qualified nurses is available to Medicaid beneficiaries for cases where they are not sure if their complaints and symptoms warrant a trip to the ED. “In the first year of the program, emergency department visits by Medicaid enrollees declined by 9.9 percent and the rate of visits by frequent users… fell by 10.7 percent. The savings for 2013 totaled $33.6 million” (Ollove, 2015, para. 29). It appears that Washington’s assertive approach has thus far paid off and has resulted in millions dollars worth of savings. Maryland In many areas around the country where the state itself is not as interested in actively pursuing limiting preventable ED use, hospitals are picking up the slack. In Maryland where healthcare reform is in full swing and value-based reimbursement is well under way, hospitals find it imperative to cut all unnecessary spending. The ED happens to be the best place to start because of how much more expensive the care is versus other outpatient care settings. Anne Arundel Medical Center located in Maryland decided to focus on the top 500 patients seen most often in the ED and in the organization by giving willing participants free in-home support (Letourneau, 2015). As part of the in-home support plan, care managers visit patients at their home and assess their social needs and ability to access necessary care. They also provide education on medication administration and on how to create a better lifestyle. There is no data yet on how successful this program has been but it shows much promise in keeping patients from needing to access more intensive and costly medical services (Letourneau, 2015). Anne Arundel Medical Center did not stop at just free in-home support services for its patients. The hospital also identified that an inordinate number of 911 ambulances were bringing
  • 10. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 10 in patients to the ED from a nearby low-income senior housing facility for the treatment of chronic medical conditions that could easily be treated by a primary care provider (Letourneau, 2015). In response, Anne Arundel applied for and received a grant to build a one-doctor primary care clinic on the first floor of this senior facility, which gave the residents easy access to a doctor who also had the ability to make house calls. Since the clinic has been up and running, there has been a 50 percent reduction in the number of 911 calls from the residents and therefore a 50 percent reduction in the number of ED visits (Letourneau, 2015). It stands to reason that with time, and the continuous presence of an on-site doctor, the health of the residents will increase, and the number of ED visits will decrease even more. Texas The Area Metropolitan Ambulance Authority, better known as MedStar, provides emergent and non-emergent ambulance services to the Forth Worth area in the state of Texas. In 2009, MedStar observed that in a 12-month period, 21 of their patients were transported to local ED’s a total of 800 times (EMS1.com, 2012). These 21 patients generated $950,000 worth of ambulance charges that were unpaid or scarcely reimbursed due to the fact that they were either Medicaid beneficiaries or completely uninsured (EMS1.com, 2012). MedStar’s medical director decided that it was time for an intervention and launched a pilot Community Health Program (CHP) that aimed at decreasing unnecessary ambulance transports and ED visits. In this program, super-utilizers are identified through ED and caseworker referrals, as well as through the company database. Specially trained paramedics then make contact with the patients and offer them their services. If a patient agrees, the paramedics conduct an in-depth home visit where they make a full medical assessment and help the patient build “an individualized care plan that outlines their needs and responsibilities related to managing health
  • 11. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 11 and health care on an ongoing basis” (EMS1.com, 2012, para. 15). After the initial home visit, paramedics continue to conduct 2-3 shorter visits per week, which later taper off as the patient begins making progress. Patients are also able to telephone the CHP paramedics any time an urgent need arises. When the paramedics deem a patient is able to sufficiently manage their own health, that patient then graduates from the program. Graduates continue to have access to a 24- hour hotline that will activate the CHP paramedics for a visit within an hour if they should call. To date, the CHP has been widely successful and MedStar has even launched several more similar programs directed at patients who would otherwise utilize an ambulance transport and the ED (Jacob, 2014). Between the programs launch in 2009 and 2011, “the volume of 911 calls from the program’s 186 enrollees fell by 58 percent” (EMS1.com, 2012, para. 27). With the decline in calls and transports, MedStar saved $2.8 million on ambulance charges and local hospitals saved an estimated $9 million in ED charges (EMS1.com, 2012). As of 2014, CHP has had 264 graduates with an 85 percent reduction in ED use in the year following graduation (Jacob, 2014). The barrier to this type of program for many EMS systems is that traditionally, responders only get paid when they transport to an ED. With the lack of reimbursement, there is often little incentive for ambulance companies to provide this type of service to the community. Fortunately, with the shift toward value-based and coordinated care, there is now room for EMS systems to be part of the team. For example, MedStar now has several agreements with local accountable care organizations (ACOs) to fund an Observation Admission Avoidance program, a Hospice Revocation Avoidance program, and a 911 Nurse Triage program (Jacob, 2014). The Observation Admission Avoidance program allows patients to be observed by paramedics overnight at their homes instead of the hospital, while the Hospice Revocation Avoidance
  • 12. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 12 program works to prevent high-risk patients from calling 911, as that would revoke their hospice status. Lastly, the 911 Nurse Triage program redirects non-emergent 911 calls to MedStar’s call center, where a trained nurse helps the callers find appropriate medical resources. In a seven- month stretch, more than 500 patients were diverted from using the ED via the 911 Nurse Triage program (Jacob, 2014). Since the start of these programs, “MedStar estimates its mobile healthcare programs have saved more than $3.3 million in healthcare expenditure” (Jacob, 2014, para. 16). Conclusion Healthcare expenditures in the United States are steadily rising and many private, state, and federal organizations are working hard to reverse this trend while still retaining a high quality of care. One area of the healthcare system that can be substantially improved is the overutilization of EMS and ED services. The top 5 percent of patients in the United States are responsible for 50 percent of all healthcare expenditures and the majority of these patients are in and out of the ED on a regular basis (Boodman, 2013). If a system were in place that could catch these individuals early on to provide them with self-management skills, perhaps many of the consequential hospitalizations and health complications could be avoided, thus effectively decreasing healthcare spending. Statistics say that Medicaid patients utilize the ED at twice the rate of those with private insurance, with only 10 percent of those visits being non-emergent (CMS, 2014). This is indicative of a much bigger problem, which is the egregious lack of access to primary care. Due to low reimbursement rates, Medicaid beneficiaries often have a hard time finding providers that will treat them in the primary care setting. Medicaid patients are also generally less healthy, frequently lack transportation, and often work hourly jobs making it difficult to make doctor’s
  • 13. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 13 appointments during business hours (Ollove, 2015). Making access to primary care more available to this population would go a long way in cutting down on preventable ambulance transports and ED visits. While the federal government has not been as involved in undertaking this challenge, many States and private organizations have been hard at work. Several states have been especially interested in cutting avoidable ED visits by Medicaid recipients, as that would mean huge savings for their budgets. Alaska, Oregon, and Washington have each invested in various forms of patient-centered systems that focus on providing one-on-one care to problem populations. Those systems have generally showed improvement in how often the ED was used and in the health of the patients themselves. It appears that teaching and educating patients on how to care for themselves is better then any punitive approaches that have been taken in the past, such as increasing copays. The last innovative idea that was explored is the Community Health Program implemented by MedStar in Texas. This program allows specially trained paramedics to identify individuals who frequently call 911 for transport to the ED and to work with them to get their medical needs under control. As of 2014, MedStar has seen an 85% reduction in ED use from the individuals they have worked with in the year following their graduation from the program (Jacob, 2014). If this type of program were widely implemented it could become the first line of defense for people battling chronic conditions and not knowing how to self-manage their health. Paramedics make great candidates for this job as they already work out in the field and have experience in administering care in the patient’s personal environment.
  • 14. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 14 Recommendations Reducing avoidable EMS and ED utilization is feasible and can be achieved by doing the following: expanding access to care for disadvantaged populations, creating a communications network between hospitals, switching to an integrated and value-based system of patient care, and by incorporating ambulance based community programs for super-utilizers. Expanding access to primary care would be the first step in the process. If patients are to be diverted from using the more expensive services in the ED, then they have to have a place to go to instead. The first method by which access to care can be improved by is extending primary care hours to cover evenings and weekends. According to CMS (2014), two-thirds of all visits to the emergency room occur after business hours. It is estimated that an annual net savings of $4.4 billion can be realized if this type of access was increased (CMS, 2014). In a rural area of Georgia, four clinics were opened with extended hours and as a result over a 3-year period, 33,000 patients were served with savings of approximately $7.3 million (CMS, 2014). Another problem that is often encountered with access to care is the lack of same day appointments. Patients who are experiencing a medical event of some kind and are ready to go to the ED are not likely to wait for weeks or even days to get an appointment with their doctor. To solve this problem, a system called open-access can be implemented. Open-access is a scheduling model that a number of medical practices use to consistently offer their patients same day appointments. This system works by allowing the majority of time slots to be available for same or next day appointments. The other portion of the time slots, which is smaller, remains reserved for patients who want to schedule further in advance. In addition, in the open-access model, all appointment types are the same and interchangeable which allows for maximum flexibility (Carlson, 2002). This is in stark contrast to conventional scheduling practices, where
  • 15. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 15 provider’s book appointments by type and assorted exclusion and inclusion criteria make the system uncompromising and appointments difficult to move around (Carlson, 2002). Data clearly shows that open-access scheduling is profitable and generally drops the number of no- shows from approximately 20 percent to nearly zero (Jones, 2014). Going to this type of system would significantly benefit patients as well as providers. The second step in reducing avoidable costs associated with the use of EMS and the ED is to build a communications network between all the hospitals. Due to the scope of this endeavor, the state may have the best advantage and the necessary authority to accomplish developing such a network. A network that includes all area hospitals would be instrumental in identifying super-utilizers and individuals who frequent many different hospitals on a regular basis. After these individuals were identified, they could then be referred to a caseworker or a community paramedic program where they would receive one-on-one education and instruction on how to manage their health. The state of Washington has this kind of network in place and they use hospital personnel to help direct patients to a primary care clinic as well as to provide education (Ollove, 2015), which is also a viable option. The third step is to establish Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) and/or any other type of value-based care system that would encourage the formation of programs that could individually work with patients to address their medical needs and their inability to effectively manage their health. This could take on many different forms as each population greatly varies by location and culture. In Oregon, CCO’s developed at the state level have been the driving force behind the one-on-one care being done by community health workers while in Maryland, the federally implemented value-based reimbursement system is what is triggering hospitals to pursue free in-home health and individualized care through caseworkers. Having some type of
  • 16. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 16 value-based system in place is important because it is what provides incentive for physicians to coordinate care and to work with patients to stop unnecessary over-utilization. In a value-based system, coordinating care is key, which is why all kinds of relationships are being created with both public and private health organizations opening doors for new and innovative ways to provide better care and to decrease spending. The last step in decreasing unnecessary ED costs and EMS transports is to incorporate more ambulance based community paramedic programs, such as the one MedStar began in Texas. Many super-utilizers of the ED are also super-utilizers of 911 ambulances, especially when it comes to disadvantaged populations who may lack their own transportation (Ollove, 2015). Moreover, patients who are prone to using the ED for their primary care needs often go to multiple different hospitals, which puts the ambulance companies in the best position to more quickly identify who these individual are. Once identified, these individuals can be enrolled in a community paramedic program, which will provide them with education and the necessary management skills to successfully manage their health, all from the comfort of their own home. Paramedics are uniquely suited for this type of program because they are mobile, have medical training, and are experienced in providing care outside the medical setting. Expanding access to primary care, creating a communications network, providing healthcare on a value-based system, and integrating community paramedic programs are four elements that are all important and necessary in decreasing avoidable ED visits and EMS transports. While some of these elements are being applied individually, they would be most effective when used as a collective. It is important to take note that certain elements are not likely to exist without the other. For example, EMS companies have no incentive to create community paramedic programs because they would not be reimbursed for those services.
  • 17. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 17 However with the development of ACO’s reimbursement becomes possible, thus making the two rely on each other. The same can be applied to the communications network. What is the point of communicating if there is nowhere the patient can be directed? The network depends on the existence of primary care access, caseworkers, and community paramedic programs. If implemented, these four elements could make a huge impact on the quality of healthcare in the United States and the amount of money spent on it. Not only is there the potential to cut costs by stopping unnecessary and preventable ED visits, but there is also the potential to stop future costs that individuals with poorly managed chronic conditions will incur in their lifetime. Catching these problem areas as early as possible and offering individuals a chance to take their life back through personalized education and assistance will no doubt results in a higher level of care for the patient and significant savings for the county.
  • 18. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 18 References Andrews, L. (2014, July 3). State aims to curb overuse of emergency rooms by some Medicaid patients. Alaska Dispatch News. Retrieved from http://www.adn.com/alaska- news/article/state-aims-curb-overuse-emergency-rooms-some-medicaid-patients- 0/2014/07/03/ Boodman, S. G. (2013, October 7). Costliest 1 percent of patients account for 21 percent of U.S. health spending. Kaiser Health News. Retrieved from http://khn.org/news/one-percent-of- costliest-patients/ Broffman, L. (2014, September 11). Year zero: Leaders at Oregon’s CCOs share lessons from the early days. Health Affairs Blog. Retrieved from http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2014/09/11/year-zero-leaders-at-oregons-ccos-share-lessons- from-the-early-days/ Carlson, B. (2002). Same-day appointments promise increased productivity. Managed Care Magazine. Retrieved from http://www.managedcaremag.com/archives/2002/12/same- day-appointments-promise-increased-productivity Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services [CMS]. (2014). Reducing nonurgent use of emergency departments and improving appropriate care in appropriate settings. Retrieved from https://www.medicaid.gov/Federal-Policy-Guidance/Downloads/CIB-01- 16-14.pdf EMS1.com. (2012). Case study: How an EMS agency tackled ‘frequent fliers’. Retrieved from http://www.ems1.com/research-reviews/articles/1233831-Case-study-How-an-EMS- agency-tackled-frequent-fliers/
  • 19. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 19 Foden-Vencil, K. (2013, July 10). How Oregon is getting ‘frequent flyers’ out of hospital ERs. Kaiser Health News. Retrieved from http://khn.org/news/emergency-room-frequent- flyers/ Ingram, J. (2013, May 21). Medicaid expansion won’t reduce unnecessary ER visits. Illinois Policy. Retrieved from https://www.illinoispolicy.org/medicaid-expansion-wont-reduce- unnecessary-er-visits/ Jacob, S. (2014, February 12). “EMS loyalty program” slashes emergency room trips, saves millions. D Healthcare Daily. Retrieved from http://healthcare.dmagazine.com/2014/02/12/ems-loyalty-program-slashes-emergency- room-trips-saves-millions/ Jones, M. (2014, February 11). Open-access scheduling: 5 surprising misconceptions. The Profitable Practice. Retrieved from http://profitable- practice.softwareadvice.com/misconceptions-about-open-access-scheduling-0214/ Law, S. (2014, October 30). ER trips test new ride. Portland Tribune. Retrieved from http://portlandtribune.com/pt/9-news/238842-104102-er-trips-test-new-ride Letourneau, R. (2015, June 29). Population health strategies to keep frequent flyers out of the hospital. Health Leaders Media. Retrieved from http://www.healthleadersmedia.com/finance/population-health-strategies-keep-frequent- flyers-out-hospital Ollove, M. (2015). States strive to keep Medicaid patients out of the emergency department. The Pew Charitable Trusts. Retrieved from http://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and- analysis/blogs/stateline/2015/2/24/states-strive-to-keep-medicaid-patients-out-of-the- emergency-department
  • 20. REDUCING THE PREVENTABLE USE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES 20 Oregon.gov. (2016). Post ACA population – avoidable emergency department utilization. Retrieved from http://www.oregon.gov/oha/Metrics/Pages/aca-avoid-ed-utilization.aspx Siddiqui, M., Roberts, E. T., & Pollack, C. E. (2015). The effect of emergency department copayments for Medicaid beneficiaries following the deficit reduction act of 2005. JAMA Internal Medicine, 175(3), 393-398. doi: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2014.7582 The Fiscal Times. (2013). Emergency room costs have skyrocketed to as much as $151 billion. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/er-costs-skyrocketed-to-151-billion- 2013-4