SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 24
• I am not here to discuss my data of success i.e
how good surgeon am I or how many cases
our cancer centre has treated.
• This data gives me sense of hopelessness that
where I am standing and what I am doing
• This is data of pitiable conditions faced by our
women.
• This is data of poor education imparted to our
doctors and money stinking in us.
Cervical Cancer Management in
Rural India: Are we really living in
21st century or need to focus on
education of our Doctors
Dr Sujata Mittal
Dept of Gyne Oncology
Paras Hospital
Gurgaon
Cervical Cancer: Indian Scenario
Commonest Gynecological Cancer:
PREVENTABLE : yet not preventable in India
HBCR showed 69% -83% had regional disease at
the time of presentation
• OPPORTUNISTIC SCREENING
• OPPORTUNISTIC VACCINATION
• Dearth of trained cytologist, pathologist &
gyneccologist at district level.
OBJECTIVE
• study the cases of cervical cancer (Rural India)
MANAGED
UNMANAGED
• Analysis for poor outcome
• Shortcoming of our doctors as a community.
Methods
• Retrospective study from 2008 -2013
• 218 cases of cervical cancer
• Resultant outcome in terms of treatment
/absence of treatment
• Reasons for not taking treatment
• Analysis of 21 cases of simple hysterectomy
Results
• 44% refused to take treatment
• 29.8% took complete treatment
• 20.65% opted for other hospital
• 6.5% took partial treatment
• 9.7% had simple hysterectomy for invasive
disease
RESULTS
PLACE OF
SURGERY
OPERATING
SURGEON
DISCHARGE
SUMMARY
SLIDES /BLOCKS INDICATION OF
SURGERY
PRIVATE: 19
(RURAL)
Govt Hospital:2
SURGEON :18
Surgeon +
Gynecologist: 1
Surgeon : 2
NOT AVAILABLE
No details given
Discharge avail
Not
available
Excessive
bleeding : 15
PMB : 3
Ca Cervix :3
Analysis of simple hysterectomy
PREOP EVALUATION
(HPR/STAGING)
POST OP HPR
3 CASES—2 GOVT
1 PVT
(No HPR, Staging)
Only clinical diagnosis
ALL 21 CASES
Analysis
• ALL PATIENTS WERE REFERRED FOR RT ALONE.
• IF RT IS INSUFFICIENT : GIVE CHEMO.
• SIMPLE HYSTERCTOMY WILL BE TAKEN CARE
BY THESE TREATMENT
Discussion
• SURGEONS MORE DARING
In 1 case operated at Govt Hospital,
Ca cervix involved body uterus, rt ureter &
anterior wall of rectum.
Simple hysterectomy with rt ureteric stenting
with partial resection of anterior wall of
rectum was done.
• WHY & WHAT M.S/M.D GYNEC ARE DOING ?
1. Number of deliveries are decreasing.
(JANANI SURAKSHA YOJNA)
2. Has not seen much cases being operated in
Institutions
(LACK OF PROPER TRAINING IN P.G.)
(MORE EMPHASIS ON OBSTETRIC WORK)
Discussion
44% refused to take
treatment
WHY?
WHAT WE ARE DOING ABOUT IT
Reasons for not taking Rx
• Financial stress
• Lack of insurance
• Distance to be covered for treatment
• Loss of daily wages
• Non availability of blood donors
• Quacks/Alternative system of medicine
BUT
Districts in Rajasthan are poorly equipped in
terms of man power, technology and will.
Even PAP is not done in Govt Hospital due to
lack of availability of resources in terms of
equipment and man power.
Discussion
• Cervical Cancer Prevention should be part of
NRHM
Discussion
District Cancer Control Program
KERALA MODEL
Discussion
• Training in Medical Colleges
• Special Training for doctors at PHC,CHC,DH
(VIA, VILI)
• Special training for Aanganwadi, health
workers.(VIA, VILI)
• Incorporation of Cancer Prevention in
Reproductive & Child Health
• Vaccine should be part of National Vaccination
Program
• Strong Institutional message and teaching
• Stringent Govt Regulations
• Will of doctor community
• Strong RCC support
MOTTO
Every Physician office a cancer control clinic
Lets Talk Life
Thank you

More Related Content

What's hot

Nephrology leadership program 4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...
Nephrology leadership program  4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...Nephrology leadership program  4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...
Nephrology leadership program 4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...Ala Ali
 
ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7
ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7
ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7Maria Leah Comillas, MSN-HP
 
Theoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical care
Theoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical careTheoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical care
Theoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical careJoanna Ashby
 
2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...
2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...
2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...Donald Nease
 
Nephrology leadership program 3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...
Nephrology leadership program  3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...Nephrology leadership program  3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...
Nephrology leadership program 3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...Ala Ali
 
Patients' satisfaction towards doctors treatment
Patients' satisfaction towards doctors treatmentPatients' satisfaction towards doctors treatment
Patients' satisfaction towards doctors treatmentmustafa farooqi
 
Acute care practice settings
Acute care practice settingsAcute care practice settings
Acute care practice settingsbuttkek
 
Evidence based individual decision making
Evidence based individual decision makingEvidence based individual decision making
Evidence based individual decision makingMohammed Abdalla
 
L. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT Presentation
L. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT PresentationL. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT Presentation
L. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT PresentationLesley Johnson
 
Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...
Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...
Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...Cancer Institute NSW
 
Pta acute care
Pta acute carePta acute care
Pta acute caredeank16
 
Linda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong ward
Linda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong wardLinda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong ward
Linda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong wardThe King's Fund
 
New microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentationNew microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentationMahwish Afzal
 
Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...
Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...
Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...Irish Cancer Society
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015Marie Benz MD FAAD
 

What's hot (20)

Nephrology leadership program 4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...
Nephrology leadership program  4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...Nephrology leadership program  4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...
Nephrology leadership program 4 patient safety in dialysis and nephrology au...
 
ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7
ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7
ComillasM_CapstoneProjectPowerPointPresentation_NR660wk7
 
Theoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical care
Theoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical careTheoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical care
Theoneste Nkurunziza, Delays to surgical care
 
HRSN poster FINAL
HRSN poster FINALHRSN poster FINAL
HRSN poster FINAL
 
2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...
2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...
2014 engaging communities in education and research - SNOCAP introduction - w...
 
Nephrology leadership program 3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...
Nephrology leadership program  3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...Nephrology leadership program  3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...
Nephrology leadership program 3 Infection control and prevention in dialysis...
 
Obstetric enhanced recovery
Obstetric enhanced recoveryObstetric enhanced recovery
Obstetric enhanced recovery
 
Patients' satisfaction towards doctors treatment
Patients' satisfaction towards doctors treatmentPatients' satisfaction towards doctors treatment
Patients' satisfaction towards doctors treatment
 
Acute care practice settings
Acute care practice settingsAcute care practice settings
Acute care practice settings
 
Evidence based individual decision making
Evidence based individual decision makingEvidence based individual decision making
Evidence based individual decision making
 
Week 12 assignment
Week 12 assignmentWeek 12 assignment
Week 12 assignment
 
L. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT Presentation
L. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT PresentationL. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT Presentation
L. Johnson_NR660_Standardization PPT Presentation
 
Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...
Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...
Enhancing the patient experience in a new purpose-build MDT meeting room with...
 
Pta acute care
Pta acute carePta acute care
Pta acute care
 
Linda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong ward
Linda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong wardLinda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong ward
Linda Patterson: wrong bed, wrong ward
 
New microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentationNew microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentation
 
Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...
Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...
Cancer Survivorship: longer term issues and the role of primary care - Prof E...
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews March 24 2015
 
Using Technology to Transform Care for Patients with Parkinson Disease
Using Technology to Transform Care for Patients with Parkinson DiseaseUsing Technology to Transform Care for Patients with Parkinson Disease
Using Technology to Transform Care for Patients with Parkinson Disease
 
South Nassau's Transitional Care Unit Wins 5-Star Rating
South Nassau's Transitional Care Unit Wins 5-Star RatingSouth Nassau's Transitional Care Unit Wins 5-Star Rating
South Nassau's Transitional Care Unit Wins 5-Star Rating
 

Similar to Cervical cancer management in Developing Countries

Approach to breast disease (accad)
Approach to breast disease (accad)Approach to breast disease (accad)
Approach to breast disease (accad)Elvira Cesarena
 
Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011
Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011
Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011ian.mckinnell
 
Implementation science tailored to precision prevention
Implementation science tailored to precision preventionImplementation science tailored to precision prevention
Implementation science tailored to precision preventionGraham Colditz
 
How evidence affects clinical practice in egypt
How evidence affects clinical practice in egyptHow evidence affects clinical practice in egypt
How evidence affects clinical practice in egyptWafaa Benjamin
 
PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)
PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)
PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)Lifecare Centre
 
Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience
Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience
Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience Criterion Conferences
 
Duke Industry Statistics Symposium - Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...
Duke Industry Statistics Symposium -  Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...Duke Industry Statistics Symposium -  Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...
Duke Industry Statistics Symposium - Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...Warren Kibbe
 
Colorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinar
Colorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinarColorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinar
Colorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinarFight Colorectal Cancer
 
Brian Sick, M.D.
Brian Sick, M.D.Brian Sick, M.D.
Brian Sick, M.D.smsherman
 
Health Career of Interest.pptx
Health Career of Interest.pptxHealth Career of Interest.pptx
Health Career of Interest.pptxanushkp
 
surgery of the primary in MBC
surgery of the primary in MBCsurgery of the primary in MBC
surgery of the primary in MBCPriyanka Malekar
 
RETROPERITONEAL TERATOMA
RETROPERITONEAL TERATOMARETROPERITONEAL TERATOMA
RETROPERITONEAL TERATOMAcaptullash
 
YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...
YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...
YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...Jay Naik
 
Adjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancer
Adjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancerAdjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancer
Adjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancerGita Bhat
 
Gi care measures model
Gi care measures modelGi care measures model
Gi care measures modelRajat Chander
 

Similar to Cervical cancer management in Developing Countries (20)

Approach to breast disease (accad)
Approach to breast disease (accad)Approach to breast disease (accad)
Approach to breast disease (accad)
 
Newly Diagnosed, Stephanie Wethington, MD
Newly Diagnosed, Stephanie Wethington, MDNewly Diagnosed, Stephanie Wethington, MD
Newly Diagnosed, Stephanie Wethington, MD
 
Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011
Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011
Right care shared-decision-making-core-clinical-presentation-23-march2011
 
Implementation science tailored to precision prevention
Implementation science tailored to precision preventionImplementation science tailored to precision prevention
Implementation science tailored to precision prevention
 
How evidence affects clinical practice in egypt
How evidence affects clinical practice in egyptHow evidence affects clinical practice in egypt
How evidence affects clinical practice in egypt
 
PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)
PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)
PANEL DISCUSSION ON ENDOMETRIOSIS RELATED INFERTILITY (EVIDENCE BASED)
 
Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience
Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience
Implementing Physician Assistants in the ED to improve patient experience
 
Duke Industry Statistics Symposium - Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...
Duke Industry Statistics Symposium -  Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...Duke Industry Statistics Symposium -  Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...
Duke Industry Statistics Symposium - Real world evidence , EHRs and Cancer S...
 
Management of Nonunion
Management of NonunionManagement of Nonunion
Management of Nonunion
 
Colorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinar
Colorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinarColorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinar
Colorectal Cancer Risk & Risk Reduction: Jan 2017 #CRCWebinar
 
Transitional urology 1
Transitional urology 1 Transitional urology 1
Transitional urology 1
 
Brian Sick, M.D.
Brian Sick, M.D.Brian Sick, M.D.
Brian Sick, M.D.
 
DEPRESSURIZATION OF URBAN MEGA PUBLIC HOSPITAL.pptx Mid term ppt
DEPRESSURIZATION OF URBAN MEGA PUBLIC HOSPITAL.pptx Mid term pptDEPRESSURIZATION OF URBAN MEGA PUBLIC HOSPITAL.pptx Mid term ppt
DEPRESSURIZATION OF URBAN MEGA PUBLIC HOSPITAL.pptx Mid term ppt
 
Health Career of Interest.pptx
Health Career of Interest.pptxHealth Career of Interest.pptx
Health Career of Interest.pptx
 
surgery of the primary in MBC
surgery of the primary in MBCsurgery of the primary in MBC
surgery of the primary in MBC
 
RETROPERITONEAL TERATOMA
RETROPERITONEAL TERATOMARETROPERITONEAL TERATOMA
RETROPERITONEAL TERATOMA
 
Integrative Oncology
Integrative OncologyIntegrative Oncology
Integrative Oncology
 
YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...
YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...
YCN Breast Educational Meeting 2015-NICE Breast Cancer Quality Standards- E A...
 
Adjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancer
Adjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancerAdjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancer
Adjuvant chemotherapy of breast cancer
 
Gi care measures model
Gi care measures modelGi care measures model
Gi care measures model
 

Cervical cancer management in Developing Countries

  • 1. • I am not here to discuss my data of success i.e how good surgeon am I or how many cases our cancer centre has treated. • This data gives me sense of hopelessness that where I am standing and what I am doing • This is data of pitiable conditions faced by our women. • This is data of poor education imparted to our doctors and money stinking in us.
  • 2. Cervical Cancer Management in Rural India: Are we really living in 21st century or need to focus on education of our Doctors Dr Sujata Mittal Dept of Gyne Oncology Paras Hospital Gurgaon
  • 3. Cervical Cancer: Indian Scenario Commonest Gynecological Cancer: PREVENTABLE : yet not preventable in India HBCR showed 69% -83% had regional disease at the time of presentation
  • 4. • OPPORTUNISTIC SCREENING • OPPORTUNISTIC VACCINATION • Dearth of trained cytologist, pathologist & gyneccologist at district level.
  • 5. OBJECTIVE • study the cases of cervical cancer (Rural India) MANAGED UNMANAGED • Analysis for poor outcome • Shortcoming of our doctors as a community.
  • 6. Methods • Retrospective study from 2008 -2013 • 218 cases of cervical cancer • Resultant outcome in terms of treatment /absence of treatment • Reasons for not taking treatment • Analysis of 21 cases of simple hysterectomy
  • 7. Results • 44% refused to take treatment • 29.8% took complete treatment • 20.65% opted for other hospital • 6.5% took partial treatment • 9.7% had simple hysterectomy for invasive disease
  • 8. RESULTS PLACE OF SURGERY OPERATING SURGEON DISCHARGE SUMMARY SLIDES /BLOCKS INDICATION OF SURGERY PRIVATE: 19 (RURAL) Govt Hospital:2 SURGEON :18 Surgeon + Gynecologist: 1 Surgeon : 2 NOT AVAILABLE No details given Discharge avail Not available Excessive bleeding : 15 PMB : 3 Ca Cervix :3
  • 9. Analysis of simple hysterectomy PREOP EVALUATION (HPR/STAGING) POST OP HPR 3 CASES—2 GOVT 1 PVT (No HPR, Staging) Only clinical diagnosis ALL 21 CASES
  • 10. Analysis • ALL PATIENTS WERE REFERRED FOR RT ALONE. • IF RT IS INSUFFICIENT : GIVE CHEMO. • SIMPLE HYSTERCTOMY WILL BE TAKEN CARE BY THESE TREATMENT
  • 11. Discussion • SURGEONS MORE DARING In 1 case operated at Govt Hospital, Ca cervix involved body uterus, rt ureter & anterior wall of rectum. Simple hysterectomy with rt ureteric stenting with partial resection of anterior wall of rectum was done.
  • 12. • WHY & WHAT M.S/M.D GYNEC ARE DOING ? 1. Number of deliveries are decreasing. (JANANI SURAKSHA YOJNA) 2. Has not seen much cases being operated in Institutions (LACK OF PROPER TRAINING IN P.G.) (MORE EMPHASIS ON OBSTETRIC WORK)
  • 13. Discussion 44% refused to take treatment WHY? WHAT WE ARE DOING ABOUT IT
  • 14. Reasons for not taking Rx • Financial stress • Lack of insurance • Distance to be covered for treatment • Loss of daily wages • Non availability of blood donors • Quacks/Alternative system of medicine
  • 15.
  • 16. BUT Districts in Rajasthan are poorly equipped in terms of man power, technology and will. Even PAP is not done in Govt Hospital due to lack of availability of resources in terms of equipment and man power.
  • 17. Discussion • Cervical Cancer Prevention should be part of NRHM
  • 18. Discussion District Cancer Control Program KERALA MODEL
  • 19. Discussion • Training in Medical Colleges • Special Training for doctors at PHC,CHC,DH (VIA, VILI) • Special training for Aanganwadi, health workers.(VIA, VILI) • Incorporation of Cancer Prevention in Reproductive & Child Health • Vaccine should be part of National Vaccination Program
  • 20.
  • 21. • Strong Institutional message and teaching • Stringent Govt Regulations • Will of doctor community • Strong RCC support
  • 22. MOTTO Every Physician office a cancer control clinic

Editor's Notes

  1. All the 44% patients those have not taken treatment had stage III disease. 80% were illiterate . 21 cases of SH 197 cases: Stage 1: 7 cases (3.5%),stage II:51 cases(25%), stage III:130 cases(65%),stage IV:9cases(4.5%)
  2. Post Op HPR said about the disease only. No comments on LVS, margins etc.
  3. No separate dept for oncology. Dearth of trained gynec/surgical oncologist. No collaboration in most of the medical colleges with RCC where residents are sent for gyne training. In fact, gynecologist should have compulsory 6 months training in surgical units.
  4. All thee were stage III disease 90% were postmenopausal 10% were perimenopausal. All had atleast visited one M.B.B.S doctor (CHC/private doctor) Also, visited by ANM/Aanganwadi workers
  5. Community: Muslims are more prejudice. We are crying and raising voice for female fetecide but female infanticide, sexual harassment and deaths due to cancer specially due to cervical cancer is eating large part of our live female population.
  6. Even in kerala, reluctance on part of doctors at CHC, PHC to go the screening centers.
  7. Emphasis should be on good quality work and not on doctors having long OT lists. It takes 5 years to learn the art of the surgery but it takes 25 years to learn to say no.