Cervical cancer management in Developing Countries
1. • I am not here to discuss my data of success i.e
how good surgeon am I or how many cases
our cancer centre has treated.
• This data gives me sense of hopelessness that
where I am standing and what I am doing
• This is data of pitiable conditions faced by our
women.
• This is data of poor education imparted to our
doctors and money stinking in us.
2. Cervical Cancer Management in
Rural India: Are we really living in
21st century or need to focus on
education of our Doctors
Dr Sujata Mittal
Dept of Gyne Oncology
Paras Hospital
Gurgaon
3. Cervical Cancer: Indian Scenario
Commonest Gynecological Cancer:
PREVENTABLE : yet not preventable in India
HBCR showed 69% -83% had regional disease at
the time of presentation
4. • OPPORTUNISTIC SCREENING
• OPPORTUNISTIC VACCINATION
• Dearth of trained cytologist, pathologist &
gyneccologist at district level.
5. OBJECTIVE
• study the cases of cervical cancer (Rural India)
MANAGED
UNMANAGED
• Analysis for poor outcome
• Shortcoming of our doctors as a community.
6. Methods
• Retrospective study from 2008 -2013
• 218 cases of cervical cancer
• Resultant outcome in terms of treatment
/absence of treatment
• Reasons for not taking treatment
• Analysis of 21 cases of simple hysterectomy
7. Results
• 44% refused to take treatment
• 29.8% took complete treatment
• 20.65% opted for other hospital
• 6.5% took partial treatment
• 9.7% had simple hysterectomy for invasive
disease
9. Analysis of simple hysterectomy
PREOP EVALUATION
(HPR/STAGING)
POST OP HPR
3 CASES—2 GOVT
1 PVT
(No HPR, Staging)
Only clinical diagnosis
ALL 21 CASES
10. Analysis
• ALL PATIENTS WERE REFERRED FOR RT ALONE.
• IF RT IS INSUFFICIENT : GIVE CHEMO.
• SIMPLE HYSTERCTOMY WILL BE TAKEN CARE
BY THESE TREATMENT
11. Discussion
• SURGEONS MORE DARING
In 1 case operated at Govt Hospital,
Ca cervix involved body uterus, rt ureter &
anterior wall of rectum.
Simple hysterectomy with rt ureteric stenting
with partial resection of anterior wall of
rectum was done.
12. • WHY & WHAT M.S/M.D GYNEC ARE DOING ?
1. Number of deliveries are decreasing.
(JANANI SURAKSHA YOJNA)
2. Has not seen much cases being operated in
Institutions
(LACK OF PROPER TRAINING IN P.G.)
(MORE EMPHASIS ON OBSTETRIC WORK)
14. Reasons for not taking Rx
• Financial stress
• Lack of insurance
• Distance to be covered for treatment
• Loss of daily wages
• Non availability of blood donors
• Quacks/Alternative system of medicine
15.
16. BUT
Districts in Rajasthan are poorly equipped in
terms of man power, technology and will.
Even PAP is not done in Govt Hospital due to
lack of availability of resources in terms of
equipment and man power.
19. Discussion
• Training in Medical Colleges
• Special Training for doctors at PHC,CHC,DH
(VIA, VILI)
• Special training for Aanganwadi, health
workers.(VIA, VILI)
• Incorporation of Cancer Prevention in
Reproductive & Child Health
• Vaccine should be part of National Vaccination
Program
20.
21. • Strong Institutional message and teaching
• Stringent Govt Regulations
• Will of doctor community
• Strong RCC support
All the 44% patients those have not taken treatment had stage III disease. 80% were illiterate .
21 cases of SH
197 cases: Stage 1: 7 cases (3.5%),stage II:51 cases(25%), stage III:130 cases(65%),stage IV:9cases(4.5%)
Post Op HPR said about the disease only. No comments on LVS, margins etc.
No separate dept for oncology. Dearth of trained gynec/surgical oncologist. No collaboration in most of the medical colleges with RCC where residents are sent for gyne training. In fact, gynecologist should have compulsory 6 months training in surgical units.
All thee were stage III disease
90% were postmenopausal
10% were perimenopausal.
All had atleast visited one M.B.B.S doctor (CHC/private doctor)
Also, visited by ANM/Aanganwadi workers
Community: Muslims are more prejudice. We are crying and raising voice for female fetecide but female infanticide, sexual harassment and deaths due to cancer specially due to cervical cancer is eating large part of our live female population.
Even in kerala, reluctance on part of doctors at CHC, PHC to go the screening centers.
Emphasis should be on good quality work and not on doctors having long OT lists. It takes 5 years to learn the art of the surgery but it takes 25 years to learn to say no.