This document provides instructions for a five paragraph essay assignment on Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston. The introduction must contain topic sentences outlining each body paragraph. Each body paragraph argues whether one of Janie's three husbands was a good match and discusses what she learned from that marriage, citing evidence from the text. The closing paragraph summarizes the arguments and can earn extra credit by discussing a theme in the novel. Students will lose points for missing topic sentences.