The document provides background information on Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), a social enterprise founded in 2010 in South Africa. DHW provides training to deaf individuals to develop job skills in industries like construction, textiles, and furniture making. It aims to empower the deaf community and reduce unemployment among deaf South Africans. The consulting team was engaged to explore ways for DHW to expand its operations and impact. The team visited a DHW construction site and met with DHW's founder. This report makes recommendations in four areas - organizational structure, financing plant/equipment, online presence, and timelines for growth. It suggests options for DHW to increase its social mission on a larger scale.
2.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 1
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION
a. The Consulting Team………………………………………………….2
b. DHW Background……………………………………………………...2
c. The Scope of Work…………………………………………………….4
2. ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
a. Current Structure………………………………………………………6
b. Social Franchising……………………………………………………..9
c. Subsidiary……………………………………………………………....9
d. Recommendation……………………………………………………..10
3. PLANT AND EQUIPMENT FINANCE
a. Justification…………………………………………………………….11
b. Plant and Equipment Specification………………………………….12
c. Financing Options and Resources……………………...…………..13
d. Recommendation and Timeline……………………………………..14
4. ONLINE PRESENCE
a. Customer Identification……………………………………….. …….15
b. Current Online Experience…………………………………………..16
c. Growth Potential……………………………………………………...17
d. Considering Amazon.com…………………………………………...19
e. Recommendation and Timeline…………………………………….19
5. SUMMARY……………………………………………………………………25
6. APPENDICES………………………………………………………………..26
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
3.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 2
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
1. INTRODUCTION
a. The Consulting Team and Context of this Consultation
The Sonoma State University Cohort 7 consulting team, hereinafter referred to as “the
team” is a group of graduate business students enrolled in an executive Master of
Business Administration course at Sonoma State University. The team consists of five
business professionals from diverse backgrounds including but not limited to
quasigovernment agencies, the construction industry, the medical field, and the
manufacturing industry. The client for this consultation was Deaf Hands at Work,
hereinafter referred to as “the client” and/or “DHW.” The team approached the client
and offered its consulting services as part of its ongoing course and is very appreciative
of the time, effort, and information Mr. Nyakurwa has shared with the team in order to
assemble this document. The team has had numerous conference calls with the client
over the course of three months and visited one of the client’s construction division’s
projects in Caledonia, South Africa on September 21, 2016. This consultation has been
assembled based on information gathered during those conference calls, the site visit,
and the team’s own research. No financial documents, documents in general, trade
secrets, unique corporate practices, and/or letters of incorporation have been shared
between the client and the team, therefore all of the opinions expressed in this
document are based on verbal communications and emails between the team and the
client.
b. DHW Background
DHW, the client was founded as a “Hybrid Enterprise” in 2010 by Charles Nyakurwa.
Mr. Nyakurwa found the inspiration to start this enterprise in his own deaf brother. He
saw the need to provide job and skills training to other deaf individuals like his brother in
the Cape Town area of South Africa. The purpose was to provide lifelong skills to foster
independent living within the deaf population. After some struggles in 2012, DHW was
officially created as a NonProfitOrganization (NPO) and Private Company (Pty Ltd) in
South Africa. According to the current DHW website, the primary mission of DHW is to
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
4.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 3
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
“selfempower the hearing and deaf people of South Africa by providing training and
creating employment for deaf people irrespective of work experience, education, race,
denomination or nationality.” Per the client’s Facebook page the mission is as follows:
“ It is our mission to ensure DHW can provide every hearing impaired individual with the
skills necessary to launch their career regardless of the challenges faced by physical
limitations not ability.” It is also of note that the client is not focused strictly on profits,
but more on social impact and sustainability within the three pillars of “People, Place &
Planet” as being equal stakeholders. Increased knowledge of the social good created by
DHW is necessary as well as brand awareness, support of the deaf and disabled
community, and the demand for houses.
DHW provides a threeweek training and threeweek apprenticeship for deaf individuals
in order to enable each person to become selfsufficient and empowered, and over time,
to reduce the unemployment and illiteracy rates amongst the deaf and hard of hearing
population. DHW employs and trains deaf and disabled individuals to be competent in
the following industries: textiles, construction, maid services, furniture manufacturing,
and light fixture manufacturing. Awareness of deaf individuals' disabilities is promoted
through the teaching of South African Sign Language (SASL) to locals and businesses
who have regular interaction with the deaf community. Financial support for these
endeavours is provided by marketing DHW’s construction, Deafstyle branded tshirts,
deaf housemaids, furniture, light fixtures, products and services under the DHW brand.
To provide the historical context within which DHW exists it is necessary to
acknowledge that the hard of hearing and deaf communities of South Africa have a high
rate of unemployment. According to 2011 data provided by the South African Hearing
Institute, in South Africa about 7.5% of school children suffer from varying degrees of
hearing loss and 20% of the disabled population suffer from hearing loss due to
illnesses. As a result, this population suffers high rates of illiteracy and unemployment.
According to DHW, in the Cape Town region, 99% of the deaf community are
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
5.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 4
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
unemployed and 25% of this population is illiterate. Comparatively, South Africa
experienced an overall unemployment rate of 26.6%, as of July of 2016 and an 1
illiteracy rate of 7% as of 2010
.
2
c. The Scope of Work
The client has requested that the team explore ways in which DHW can grow its
enterprise. In discussion with the client, the team has expanded upon the notion of
growth as constituting an increase in sales of DHW products and services, an increase
in DHW’s overall presence within the community, and an increase in the number of deaf
individuals and businesses participating in DHW’s training programs beyond the Cape
Town area and throughout South Africa. Please see the scope of work below:
The Scope of Work
1. Consultants review of material, information and documents related to project.
2. Consultants site visit.
a. Meet with Charles Nyakurwa.
b. Site visit to DHW construction site in Caledonia South Africa.
c. Meeting with John Stayton, SSU EMBA Program Director, regarding site
visit and project.
3. Create a proposal including a recommendation on the following:
a. Development of social franchise or subsidiary model that empowers
additional deaf and disabled people to invest in DHW and enter into a
career with the organization. These entrepreneurs would then employ
others who are living with or affected by disabilities. This franchise model
would begin at a provincial level and then expand to a national level. The
purpose of the proposed model would be to recommend an organisational
structure that best suits the client’s mission.
b. Specific recommendations to improve website in order to market the Deaf
1
South Africa, Statistics South Africa. (n.d.). Quarterly Labour Force Survey: Quarter 2, 2016 .
2
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SE.ADT.LITR.ZS accessed October 31, 2016.
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
6.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 5
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
Hands at Work brand and provide a financially viable retail outlet for the
products manufactured by DHW while requiring minimal ongoing
maintenance by DHW personnel. The ultimate objective is to increase
DHW’s sales of its products and services and to promote DHW’s presence
within the community.
c. Provide viable options for acquiring a plant and equipment such as a
truckmounted construction crane with the purpose of increasing positive
cash flow for the client that can be used to further growth of the enterprise.
On September 21, 2016 the teamNathan Bately, Shauna Finley, Brett Lear, Michael
Janezic and Xochitl Pradocompleted a site visit to Deaf Hands at Work’s timber home
construction site in Caledonia, South Africa. Based on this site visit and subsequent
conversations, this report includes recommendations in the following key areas:
● Strategic growth
● Financing and funding of crane and truck
● Branding, marketing, and online presence of DHW
The report also includes a recommendation for proceeding with the project over the
longer term and includes key Issues in areas that must be addressed to move the
project forward successfully. The SSU team considers some of the following ideas,
particularly those related to funding and website development, relatively easy to
accomplish with low costs. These ideas should be acceptable due to the fact that they
are scalable in order to allow for immediate implementation and progress.
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
7.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 6
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
2. ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
a. Current Organizational Structure
A review of the corporate structure of DHW has been completed and the team will
review in this section the current DHW structure, business model for DHW, and two
organisational structures that Mr. Nyakurwa has expressed some interest in: social
franchising and a subsidiary business model.
Per information compiled and provided throughout the consultation, DHW has the Pty
Ltd & NPO structures in place with Charles Nyakurwa as the founder. The client has
four business divisions that generate significant revenues: textiles, light fixtures,
furniture, and construction. We see each product line as complementary to the other.
The construction division is currently the main revenue stream for DHW and generation
of revenue within this division is important to continue bolstering the other divisions and
further the client's mission and growth goals.
The team sees Mr Nyakurwa as important to the current and future success of DHW,
due to his business knowledge, experience, and vision. He completed his graduate
studies, while working, in South Africa and currently holds an MBA with experience in
project management and accounting. He has firsthand experience in the difficulties the
deaf and disabled face because he grew up in a village in Zimbabwe with his deaf and
mute younger brother. As a result, Mr. Nyakurwa has become very passionate and
driven by the vision and growth of DHW, which drives his passion for longterm success.
The team believes that Mr. Nyakurwa and DHW’s social entrepreneurship is important
for South Africa and all those who benefit through training, longterm employments, and
the products and services created by DHW. Therefore, the team believes Mr. Nyakurwa
should continue in his principal management role at DHW.
Under the leadership of Mr. Nyakurwa, DHW is providing both products and services,
with himself acting as operations director of the construction business and overall
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
8.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 7
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
executive director of the DHW organization. The three additional product lines of DHW
(chandeliers, carpentry & sewing) have operations directors who oversee the daytoday
work of the employees of DHW. Please see the existing organisational structure figure
2.1 in the appendices. As a result, his ability to focus on growing the social impact of
DHW from a small area in Cape Town to all of South Africa is currently limited.
Per the requested outcomes expressed by the client, he is currently interested in
scalingup DHW’s business model, which goes hand in hand with the organization’s
online strategy. DHW wishes to build its expansion strategy with at least 40% of the
funding from online revenues from DHW branded products. Areas of focus for products
offered are housecleaning, sewing, construction, and chandelier production.
Currently DHW receives more than 60% of its revenue from DHW construction, 20%
from reclaimed furniture products, 10% from chandeliers, and about 10% from sewing
and clothing. Revenues from these business streams fund the employment of up to
sixteen employees and over sixty graduates of the DHW training and internship
program. DHW also teaches the South African Sign Language (SASL) to the deaf and
disabled population in targeted areas of South Africa. DHW also has a shop where
refurbished products are sold to raise money.
"Social Franchise" or “Subsidiary” Business Model Options
DHW is interested in establishing a longterm business goal and has shown interest in
both a social franchise business model and a subsidiary business model. The team
believes that both business models are approaches that would enable people within the
deaf and disabled community to work with/for members of the Cape Town community to
gain job skills and obtain employment. The model that is ultimately selected should align
with the values and vision of DHW’s founder, Charles Nyakurwa. Mr. Nyakurwa believes
that community action is the way to solve the major social issues of
unemployment/underemployment faced by deaf and disabled persons in South Africa.
His business model was developed to provide skills and training to members of the
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
9.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 8
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
hearing and deaf communities and place people in a position to secure longterm,
quality employment .
The revised DHW business model: 4 things to consider
1. Identify a product in the local township of Cape Town that is in demand, can be
readily outsourced (that is, performed by a third party), and would benefit from
the special abilities of DHW individualsfocus, attention to detail, persistence,
and honesty. Some examples are construction, carpentry, and sewing.
2. Ensure that practical, handson training is available and is appropriate for DHW
deaf and disabled individuals. In many cases, as for DHW, such training
programs will need to be created by an experienced individual in the field of
business. Mr. Nyakurwa has such expertise.
3. After individuals are trained, they will still lack experience on their resume and
confidence in their own abilities to do the job. An internship program should be
continued by DHW that allows the newly trained workforce to gain realworld
experience by working in a more supportive and understanding environment.
This may either take the form of employer contracts in which DHW establishes
MOUs with local businesses that agree to employee DHW individuals, or
partnerships with local businesses that involve the businesses supplying mentors
to the DHW trainees. These mentors would help the DHW trainees navigate their
way into the workforce. Such internships should last a minimum of three months
so that participants can gain the proper skills and selfsufficiency for future
employment.
4. Transition DHW individuals to open market positions in the chosen field of
carpentry, sewing, construction, or chandelier work. This needs to include
support for employers as well as program graduates, at least on a temporary
basis.
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
10.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 9
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
b. Social Franchising
In order for DHW to meet the requirement to be a social franchise both DHW franchisor
and franchisee must be a social enterprise with social purpose and should include:
● Organization with social franchise business model or social franchisor.
● A minimum of one social franchisee trained by social franchisor.
● Social franchise should operate under one common brand.
● Knowledge between members that follows business model.
Benefits of social franchising:
● Responsive to local needs due to local ownership, and economies of scale are
created for a more effective development of enterprises.
● Increased knowledge and experience between franchised organizations.
● Awareness of brand.
● Support between franchisor and franchisee organizations.
● Shared services and training provided by franchise.
● Ability to innovate due to sharing of ideas between franchised organizations.
● Growth of awareness of social impacts to better serve the local communities.
c. Subsidiary
In order for DHW to meet the requirement to be a subsidiary, DHW must be the parent
company and should have operating companies operating as subsidiaries. The amount
of control DHW would have as parent (Note: parent in terms of corporate entity in
charge of subsidiaries) company will depend on the established management style of
the executives and shared ownership structure. In order for DHW to meet the
requirement to be a subsidiary, both DHW parent company and subsidiaries must
ensure alignment with the overarching social purpose and should include:
● Organization with “Parent” subsidiary business model.
● Establishment of role “Sole Corporate Member” in place of “Director of DHW.”
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
11.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 10
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
● A minimum of one subsidiary trained by “Parent” subsidiary.
● Subsidiaries should operate under one common brand.
● Knowledge between members that follows business model.
Benefits of subsidiary:
● Parentsubsidiary structure are separate legal entities and isolates risk.
● Parent company may exercise control over subsidiary through the ownership of
stock.
● Structure of operation does not require involvement of management from parent
company and as a result may increase efficiencies and diversification within
subsidiary.
● Adopt structure for accountability and protection of “parent” company.
● Creation of corporate boundaries for “parent” company against a lawsuit faced by
subsidiary.
c. Recommendation and Timeline
Going forward the client will need to evaluate the current business structure that DHW
has in place and review whether DHW meets the requirements to structure in South
Africa as a “social franchise” or “subsidiary.” In order for the client to scale up and
increase the social impact of DHW within South Africa, it is crucial that directors of each
business section and management staff be trained using the current business model in
place and restructure the organization for longterm impact. The skills, knowledge and
vision that the client brings to DHW are strengths of the organization and has positioned
DHW in the development of a new strategy to increase awareness and social impact of
the benefits of DHW to the South African economy.
As a shortterm goal throughout the restructuring process, the team recommends that
Mr. Nyakurwa take on more of a leadership and management role over the entire
organization and train directors and managers to then train other staff according to the
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
12.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 11
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
vision and mission of DHW. This shortterm goal should then dovetail into the longterm
goal of restructuring DHW into a “subsidiary” in South Africa using the business model
developed through the process. It is the opinion of the team that DHW restructure its
organisation with Mr. Nyakurwa being replaced as director of the construction division
and transitioning to a Chief Executive Officer position per the following chart in figure
2.2 . With this structure the team believes that Mr. Nyakurwa can focus his skills on the
continued growth of the organisation as a whole and achievement of the client's mission
by being freed from the constraints of also managing the construction division. This will
also allow for the creation of a new position within the organisation, the Director of
Construction. The individual placed within the new role will then be able to focus on the
expansion of the construction division without the hinderance of managing DHW as a
whole. The teams sees this recommendation as critical.
It is also recommended that the client explore partnerships with organizations with
similar missions and vision. These partnerships could provide insight to growth strategy
and/or the possibility of joint ventures. Please see figure 4.2 in the appendices and visit
http://www.goodwill.org/global/ to investigate becoming a Goodwill Global Partner.
Timeline: 1st Quarter 2017
3. PLANT AND EQUIPMENT FINANCE
a. Justification
During the site visit by the team, Mr. Nyakurwa indicated that he wanted to begin
constructing prefabricated homes. These homes would be manufactured at a central
site and then transported via a flatbed truck to the intended site of use. A crane would
then lift the modular pieces into place. Currently, DHW receives 60% of its revenue from
the construction portion of its business portfolio. With the appropriate equipmenta
flatbed truck and craneDHW will be able to build more homes and generate more
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
13.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 12
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
revenue than it is currently able to do with its builtfromthegroundup approach to
home construction.
b. Plant and Equipment Specification
Mr. Nyakurwa has indicated that he is looking for a 12 meter, rigid, flatbed truck with a
jib or knuckle crane. The client prefers the Mercedes brand. Isuzu, UD Trucks, and
Sinotruk also manufacture trucks suitable for mounting a flatbed and crane. The crane
can be purchased from companies such as Hiab. The costs of a truck and crane vary
greatly depending on whether the equipment is new or used.
✓ A new truck with crane are available in South Africa for approximately 1.5 Million
ZAR. (The Mercedes dealer in Cape Town is MercedesBenz Commercial Vehicles, Cnr
Freedom Way and Montague Drive, Montague Gardens, 7441. The phone number is
+27 21 550 9600 and the web address is http://www.mercedesbenz.co.za/content/
south_africa/mpc/mpc_south_africa_website/en/home_mpc/passengercars.html. )
✓ Used trucks with cranes range anywhere from 130,000 ZAR to 800,000 ZAR
depending on the make, age, and condition of the truck and crane. (OLX
( https://www.olx.co.za ) is a good website to explore the variety and prices of used trucks
with cranes. AutoTrader is a useful site as well ( http://commercial.autotrader.co.za /).)
✓ Prices for Hiab used cranes begin around 220,000 ZAR and around 500,000 ZAR for
new cranes. (Hiab South Africa is located at Cnr Forsdick and Aberdein Roads,
Roodekop, Germiston, Gauteng, 1422, South Africa. The phone number is +27 11 865
1425 and the web address is http://www.hiab.com/en/global/ .)
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
14.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 13
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
c. Financing Options and Resources
The client has a variety of financial options to consider.
✓ Financing: This may occur through the dealership. For example, Mercedes Benz
offers a variety of financing plans, including leasing and installment plans ( http://
www.sandown.mercedesbenz.co.za/content/southafrica/retailsandown/sandown/
en/desktop/trucks/financialservices/financialsolutions.html ).
The client may also wish to explore similar financing options—leasing, rentals,
installment—through a commercial bank such as FNB ( https://www.fnb.co.za/
businessbanking/finance/vehiclefinance/index.html ).
✓ PeertoPeer Lending: The client may wish to consider various peertopeer lending
options.
Peertopeer lending clubs such as RainFin ( https://rainfin.com/About/Corporate ) allow
investors to compete in lending money to firms. Loans are usually come with interest
rates lower than those of commercial banks.
Stokvels operate as invitationonly savings clubs in which members contribute a fixed
amount of money on a set schedule. Members then receive a lump sum on a rotating
basis and they are free to use the money for any purpose. Stokvels are beneficial in that
they pool money and therefore generate larger investment returns, and they encourage
members to save so that they meet their member contribution requirements. Further
information about Stokvels is available at the National Stokvel Association of South
Africa website ( http://nasasa.co.za/site/ ).
✓ Crowdfunding: Crowdfunding platforms such as Jumpstarter ( http://
jumpstarter.co.za/ ) offer nonprofits an opportunity to mount a 60day online fundraising
campaign for their projects. This may be a viable option to consider for funding the truck
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
15.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 14
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
and crane. Such a campaign could be promoted through the DHW website. (The team
offers detailed recommendations on DHW’s online presence in the following section.)
✓ Foundations: Numerous foundations offer support for NPOs and NGOs in South
Africa. Web portals such as AdvanceAfrica.com
( http://www.advanceafrica.com/Grantsfor NGOsandOrganisations.html ) list these
opportunities. A subscriptionbased resource called Inyathelo ( http://inyathelo.org ) is
also an excellent resource.
✓ Additional options: The client may wish to make direct contact with the owners of
local commercial vehicle dealerships, share his remarkable story of the history of Deaf
Hands at Work, and ask the owner to make an equipment donation to DHW. One of the
consultants, Brett Lear, similarly approached an automobile dealership in the United
States and was rewarded with a minivan to use as a library bookmobile for children.
The client could also approach heavy equipment rental firms and likewise ask for
equipment donations to DHW.
Additionally, the client should investigate regional auctions of commercial equipment for
good deals on trucks and cranes. The S.A. Institute of Auctioneers lists upcoming
auctions on its website ( http://www.auctioneering.co.za/ ) as does the website The
Auctioneer ( http://www.theauctioneer.co.za/auctions ). Online auctions are also offered
by such groups as SA Auction Group ( http://www.saauctiongroup.co.za/ ).
d. Recommendation and Timeline
Going forward the client will want to evaluate his liquid capital and longterm assets to
help determine which financial option is most suitable for DHW with respect to
equipment acquisitions (the team has not done this and did not have access to DHW’s
financial statements as it prepared this report.) Time is also a significant factor: Is this
equipment urgently needed now, or does the client have a longer runway to work with?
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
16.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 15
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
If the latter, then the client may wish to further explore grants and foundations and
crowd funding. If adequate cash is available and time is limited, the client would further
explore leases, cash purchases of new or used equipment, and purchases via auction.
If cash is limited but the need is urgent, the client should consider leases and
peertopeer funding options. The team sees the acquisition of plant and equipment that
can add to the revenue stream of any of DHW’s divisions as critical in obtaining the
mission and goals of the organization but stresses that a cost benefit analysis and
return on investment analysis be completed thoroughly for any plant and equipment that
the client's considers acquiring. A chart of possible traditional financing options
available in South Africa has been included in the appendices figure 3.1 .
Timeline: 1st Quarter 2017
4. ONLINE PRESENCE
a. Customer Identification
Identifying customers of DHW products and services offers insight into a strategy for
online expansion. The client expects to grow sales geographically, first expanding to the
rest of South Africa and then internationally. The largest commercial markets in South
Africa are the regions of Western Cape, where DHW already has a physical presence,
and Gauteng. Additionally, both of these areas have the most robust Internet
infrastructure in South Africa, providing DHW with an opportunity expand its online
marketing and sales efforts.
Consumers who physically buy products from DHW may not be the same people who
will make online purchases. Considering the limitations of DHW’s current online
presence, Mr. Nyakurwa has identified an improved online presence as a way to expand
sales by utilizing eCommerce.
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
17.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 16
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
Awareness of South Africa’s infrastructure will allow DHW to concentrate its
eCommerce related resources toward consumers that have access to specific services.
Three important services are access to the Internet, ability to pay with credit cards, and
convenience of receiving deliveries.
In South Africa, the majority of online access occurs on mobile devices,
which website
3
design should consider. Two design considerations include bandwidth and screen size.
Detailed graphics, that accompany photographs and videos, require larger amounts of
bandwidth and may limit accessibility on wireless devices. Meanwhile, screen sizes on
cellular telephones are smaller than laptop computers, affecting how a website will
appear on different devices.
The majority of eCommerce depends on the use of credit cards and South Africa is “the
most developed credit card market in Africa.”
In order to access these customers,
4
DHW must have the financial means to accept online payments. Currently, the DHW
website does not provide an option to use credit cards, limiting its ability to reach these
consumers.
Finally, consumers who buy products online have delivery expectations. They anticipate
timely delivery and responsive customer service. Considering DHW does not currently
have an active online shop, procedures related to fulfilling orders, responding to
customer concerns, and mailing products are underdeveloped.
b. The Current Online DHW Experience
The client has already identified the Internet as a platform to assist its expansion,
especially through increased sales and improved marketing. Existing websites that
DHW controls include the organization’s own website, Facebook, and Twitter pages.
3
Mzekandaba, S. (2016, June 3). SA's Internet user numbers surge. ITweb .
4
Kiruga, M. (2016, May 10). Credit cards in Africa: Continent lagging behind...but that's
great potential right there. Mail & Guardian Africa .
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
18.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 17
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
Other formats that currently exist, but do not allow direct control, include search engines
and media outlets. The latter two formats are important because it is possible to
influence search engine optimization (SOE) and utilize the media in marketing efforts.
The current DHW website provides a framework, encapsulating many of the
organization’s priorities. The website acts as a source of contact with both customers
and stakeholders. In its current form, it attempts to grab the attention of multiple parties
and solve numerous problems, limiting its effectiveness in all these aspects. Mr.
Nyakurwa asserts he would like the website to be a “world class presentation,” but he
believes it is currently lacking. Mr. Nyakurwa identified several limitations, which
include: (1) it has not been updated since 2012, when he and a friend first created it
“from scratch”; (2) there have been minimal changes since its creation, highlighting the
website’s inflexibility, (3) it is not aesthetically appealing, and (4) it includes an inefficient
online shop.
In contrast, the Facebook and Twitter pages are actively updated and modified. It is
apparent that these pages provide connectivity to stakeholders and brand awareness.
An important consideration is determining why these pages are actively utilized:
possibly because it is easy to use, because there is a perceived reward from customer
feedback, or other reasons? Furthermore, based on the way it is utilized, it is apparent
that the Facebook page allows DHW to provide brand recognition. While allowing
contact with stakeholders, the Facebook and Twitter pages also have limitations. They
do not provide businesses with simple solutions to directly sell products to consumers.
Considering eCommerce is an important part of online strategy development, the DHW
Facebook and Twitter pages do not fulfill this identified need.
c. Growth Potential
Current online sales are limited and DHW hopes to increase revenue from online sales
to 40% of total revenue. Options considered by the organization include selling products
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
19.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 18
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
from DHW websites or utilizing a third party online retailer, such as Amazon. Mr.
Nyakurwa expressed interest in developing multiple websites including a corporate
website and websites dedicated to specific products. While these options have their
merits, DHW’s limited resources should be considered prior to implementation.
There exist two identified limitations related to staff, those who would be needed to
update DHW’s online presence and others who would be needed to fulfill online
purchases. It can be expected that changes to the current online presence will create
more work. In fact, successful implementation of an eCommerce strategy will inevitably
require changes to organizational infrastructure to improve business processes.
Technical knowledge of the Internet limits how DHW can proceed. Considering how
cumbersome it is to update the current DHW website, it is important to minimize
unnecessary complexity. As an example, the current website attempts to fulfill multiple
needs; however, either developing one website focused solely on interacting with
customers or multiple websites devoted to individual types of products will allow focused
and controlled growth.
Finally, it is important to acknowledge that the current effectiveness of DHW’s online
presence at increasing revenue is unknown. While having the goal of reaching 40%
revenue is important, measuring outcomes of online marketing and sales efforts will
determine whether that revenue is profitable. Unless efforts are measured, the amount
of time and energy spent on improving online interaction and the value of these
changes will remain unknown. The measurement of these efforts is not solely limited to
the new websites, but also social media outreach. Time spent updating Facebook and
Twitter could potentially be more beneficial if spent in other efforts.
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
20.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 19
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
d. Considering Amazon.com
It is not recommended that DHW immediately pursue its online efforts by using Amazon.
The process of maintaining a presence on Amazon may be more administratively
involved than DHW anticipates. In the United States, there exist entire businesses that
specialize in selling various products on Amazon. Other companies that sell items on
the platform employ specialists who focus their efforts on managing how products are
advertised. These efforts are compounded by the international nature of Amazon.
The outcomes of these businesses efforts directly affect how products appear when
consumers perform searches for products. For example, simply using a keyword search
in Amazon for a “chandelier,” results in 591,760 available products. Other businesses
selling chandeliers actively promote products by utilizing Amazon’s “Sponsor” program,
managing customer service to become a “best seller,” offering free shipping, and
specially pricing their products. DHW’s chandeliers would be forced to compete with all
these other businesses in respect to paid advertising, price, quality, delivery service,
historical customer feedback, and other attributes.
Should the client continue its pursuit of selling products on Amazon, it is recommended
the company first develop its organizational structure to facilitate needed
responsiveness. By first developing an online strategy, improving its own website(s),
and analyzing the effectiveness of its social media efforts, the company will develop the
necessary skills to effective market products on online platforms, analyze customer
data, manage customer service, and fulfill orders. By taking incremental steps in its
online and eCommerce efforts, DHW will be better prepared for the increased
requirements to sustain an Amazon account.
e. Recommendation and Timeline
It is recommended that DHW pursue its online presence in an incremental manner,
measuring and analyzing the results as it expands. Four stages are described as they
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
21.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 20
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
pertain to the DHW online presence: strategy development, implementation, analysis of
results, and longterm operational management. Recommendations include specific
examples of services that DHW may wish to pursue to create its website(s); however,
other options were also explored and can be seen in figure 4.1 below.
Strategy Development : Instead of relying on its current website, the team
recommends DHW create a new website or websites, focusing on selling products. The
creation of a separate corporate website with focused attention on stakeholders is
highly encouraged. Such a website may be especially helpful when reaching out to
technologically savvy stakeholders, such as people involved in crowdfunding. Much of
this development will be revisited in later timeframes.
Determine the current available finances that can be dedicated to website
development and also ongoing available finances to manage website(s).
Determine content on the current website that should be retained for future use:
Much of this content represents DHW’s values and how stakeholders currently
associate the DHW brand. Because DHW uses the Facebook and Twitter to
interact with the community and maintain its brand recognition, some of this
information will likely have a positive impact at these locations. Furthermore,
some current content may be appropriate for a corporate website.
Develop processes to prepare products to be sold online: All products sold online
must be first prepared for marketing and order fulfillment. When these processes
are implemented, it should be expected that changes to processes will occur;
therefore, they may need to be developed broadly with flexibility in mind. It may
be beneficial to develop these processes for one product category at a time to
reduce initial complexity and maximize outcomes. It is recommended that this
effort be first implemented using low volume products, such as furniture. This will
minimize the need to immediately develop a complex fulfillment system. The
current website contains one picture of a chandelier and a shirt that is used by
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
22.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 21
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
market salespeople. In contrast, the new website(s) will require products to be
organized, photographed, described, stored, and ultimately delivered.
Consider how the organizational structure influences longterm operational
management of online marketing and sales: As items are sold and new ones
marketed, these items must also go through a similar process to be prepared for
online sale. Remember these processes may have to be repeated on a daily
basis depending on customer activity, DHW production volume, and levels of
sales.
Determine the use and content of the DHW website(s): Knowing how the
websites will be used by DHW, its stakeholders, and its customers will help the
organization decide which website development service is best suited to fulfill its
needs. It will be important to determine the number of websites being developed
(whether one or multiple), the quantity of products expected to be listed and sold,
and the level of customer service desired.
Develop ways to measure marketing efforts: It will be important to determine
what types of data about marketing and sales efforts to track, maintain record this
information, and later analyze data.
Prepare for increased staffing needs: While it may not be immediately apparent
how changes to DHW’s online presence will affect staffing, it is important to have
awareness throughout the process in order to make effective changes as
necessary. Expect to regularly update the website(s), list new products, take
photographs of products, track marketing efforts, organize product storage,
provide customer service, and fulfill orders. These activities and others will
require time. As previously mentioned in the organisational structure section
above, Mr. Nyakurwa’s time may be more effectively utilized in an increasingly
managerial capacity.
Timeline: 1st Quarter 2017
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
23.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 22
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
Implementation : Updating the DHW online presence is a multifaceted endeavor that
will require removing the current website, creating the new website(s), and developing
organizational infrastructure to support changes.
Remove content from current website: Depending on available finances and
costs associated with the current website, it may be beneficial to keep the current
website in a very minimalist and skeletal form that explains changes are being
made to the website with links to new websites as the are implemented.
Implement processes to prepare products for sale online: Remember, these
processes will inevitably change and evolve with experience.
Choose a website development service: A potential service for developing a
website focused on eCommerce is webs.co.za. The reason this website is 5
recommended is because it provides a simple pricing structure and a simple
format. Pricing is a flat monthly fee in a tiered manner, depending on the number
of products being sold, simplifying expenses. Services provided include hosting
and domain names. It provides a “complete turnkey online store,” minimizing the
need for ongoing technical expertise. It also provides receivables services,
mobile device responsivity, and training. For additional examples see Figure 4.1
below.
5
Website: https://webs.co.za/
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
24.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 23
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
figure 4.1
Improve consistency among online formats: This would make it potentially easier
for customers to locate DHW related website(s). For example, there are
differences among the website URL, Facebook page URL, and DHW logo that
may be potentially confusing to new customers. The website’s URL
(www.dhwsa.co.za) is different than the Facebook page URL
(www.facebook.com/deafhandsatwork). Meanwhile, the DHW logo appears as
“Deaf Hands @ Work.” If there are multiple websites based on different product
lines, a possible solution is to keep URLs consistent (i.e. dhw. co.za ,
dhwlighting. co.za , dhwconstruction. co.za , and dhwfashion. co.za ). Such a
differentiation between products would provide search engine optimization
(SEO). Of note, the mission statements on the current website and Facebook
page are also different. It is considered important to express consistency in the
mission and goals of DHW as stated in different online formats.
Timeline: 2nd Quarter 2017
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
25.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 24
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
Analysis of Results : Changing the company’s online footprint will inevitably change
many aspects of DHW’s infrastructure. An evaluation of progress by utilizing information
gathered throughout development and implementation processes will inevitably help
with ongoing longterm operational management and strategic decisionmaking.
Measuring whether these changes are helping or inhibiting goal accomplishment at
regular and consistent intervals will assist in making changes using available data,
instead of decisionmaking based on intuition alone.
Create ways to measure results: The efficiency of processes, from marketing
products to actual fulfillment, should be measured to determine areas that can
increase eCommerce effectiveness.
Determine effectiveness of social media efforts: Maintaining a social media
presence is time consuming and should lead to specific outcomes to facilitate the
accomplishment of organizational goals. An example of measuring social media
effectiveness is to offer a promotion separately on Facebook or Twitter.
Determining how many people view (it would be even better to determine how
many people purchase) advertised product(s) on different platforms. This may
help DHW determine the value of Facebook and Twitter in relation to its
eCommerce efforts.
Timeline: 3rd and 4th Quarter 2017
How DHW utilizes the Internet may change in the future as the business evolves and as
the interaction between the organization and consumers changes. It has been
recommended that DHW take incremental steps as it develops an online presence.
Advancing into the future, an incremental approach will likely still be appropriate.
Staffing considerations will likely become increasingly important as more products are
sold online. It is recommended that DHW utilize parttime employees and potentially
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear
26.
Deaf Hand @ Work (DHW), Planning for Growth Page 25
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group October 2016
__________________________________________________________________________
hire fulltime employees for labor. People who show proficiency with computers and
marketing may be utilized to maintain the different online platforms and provide
customer service, freeing Mr. Nyakurwa to focus on online strategy.
Timeline: Ongoing
It is also recommended that the client pursue its own empirical research into what other
enterprises of similar mission do to exploit growth opportunities online. A couple of
possible peer enterprises have been noted in figure 4.2 in the appendices.
5. SUMMARY
This report reviews the current challenges of Deaf Hands at Work as they relate to
growth and expansion. It provides an overview of the current DHW organizational
structure, needed equipment, and online presence. These three areas were identified
as essential to the continued growth and expansion of DHW and its social impact
model.The team feels all are equally important and has indicated a timeline for
implementation for each recommended action. This is summarized in figure 5.1 in the
appendices. The first, and most critical recommendation is for the client to transition
from a frontline management role with daily direct involvement in the operations to one
with a larger scope of focus on strategy and business development the position of Chief
Executive Officer. Next, equipment needs as identified by the client area addressed
with resources and options to fund and source the identified equipment. Lastly,
resources and options of increasing online presence are discussed. The team feels
these three areas if addressed as recommended, will perpetuate the continued
synergistic expansion that to date Deaf Hands at Work has experienced, allowing this
social enterprise to continue its missiondriven service for the deaf and hardofhearing
community in and around Cape Town.
Sonoma State University Cohort 7 Consulting Group
__________________________________________________________________________
Xochitl Prado · Shauna Finley · Nathan Bately · Michael Janezic · Brett Lear