SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
PATENT INFRINGEMENT DEFENSE
&
INTER PARTES REVIEW
Presented by
Alex Fjelstad
Twin City Group
Minneapolis MN
Nothing in this presentation should be considered legal advice. Consult your legal advisor
All rights reserved
PATENT INFRINGEMENT PATHWAY
Patent Holder Demand by letter or lawsuit Accused Infringer
Settle Full Litigation PTAB
•Inter Partes Review
•Post Grant Review
PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
• Known as PTAB
• New Process Created by the American Invents
Act
• Post Grant Review (within 9 months of patent issue)
• Business Method Patents Review (within 9 months)
• Inter Partes Review
INTER PARTES REVIEW SUMMARY
Limited to Prior Art
• Previously issued patents
• Previously published material
Petition for IPR Sent To PTAB
• “More likely than not” standard
• Hearings & decision within 12 months
PTAB Decisions Available
• Extinguish entire patent
• Extinguish specific patent claims
• Validate patent and/or specific patent claims
LITIGATION COSTS-PER SIDE
• Full Litigation $2,000,000
• Inter Partes Review $300,000 to $500,000
• Post Grant Review Minimal
INSURANCE COSTS
• Full Litigation $40,000 +
$2,000,000 limit
• Inter Partes Review $7,000 to $10,000
$300,000 to $500,000 limit
IPR INSURANCE HIGHLIGHTS
• Limits up to $5 million available
• 2% of limit self insured retention applies
• 10% of limit co-payment applies
• Limit not used on IPR expenses can be used for
related litigation expense
• Litigation expense only-no damages coverage
• Reimbursement of eligible expenses
ABOUT ALEX
• Former CEO of a publicly-held insurance
company
• Former CEO of a technology company
• Technology patent holder
• Speaker at IP law firms, LES meetings and legal
continuing education forums
• Senior Vice President at Twin City Group a
Minneapolis based insurance brokerage firm
• Currently works with clients throughout the US
and Europe

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)
Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)
Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)Nor Shamsiah
 
Sample copyright case study
Sample copyright case studySample copyright case study
Sample copyright case studyMark Lushenko
 
Driving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdf
Driving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdfDriving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdf
Driving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdfSunil Maulik
 
Avi spl huddle spaces corporate guide
Avi spl huddle spaces corporate guideAvi spl huddle spaces corporate guide
Avi spl huddle spaces corporate guideMichael Pesaturo
 
Enterprise digital transformation
Enterprise digital transformationEnterprise digital transformation
Enterprise digital transformationSunil Maulik
 
Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014
Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014
Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014freedeb
 
PatSeer Introduction
PatSeer IntroductionPatSeer Introduction
PatSeer IntroductionGridlogics
 
Industrial design [compatibility mode]
Industrial design [compatibility mode]Industrial design [compatibility mode]
Industrial design [compatibility mode]Delwin Arikatt
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)
Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)
Kerja kursus ting.4 (ict)
 
Sample copyright case study
Sample copyright case studySample copyright case study
Sample copyright case study
 
Driving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdf
Driving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdfDriving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdf
Driving healthy habits through behavioral product design (short) pdf
 
Avi spl huddle spaces corporate guide
Avi spl huddle spaces corporate guideAvi spl huddle spaces corporate guide
Avi spl huddle spaces corporate guide
 
Enterprise digital transformation
Enterprise digital transformationEnterprise digital transformation
Enterprise digital transformation
 
Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014
Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014
Trolls Aren't the Only Threat Under the Bridge OSCON 2014
 
PatSeer Introduction
PatSeer IntroductionPatSeer Introduction
PatSeer Introduction
 
Industrial design [compatibility mode]
Industrial design [compatibility mode]Industrial design [compatibility mode]
Industrial design [compatibility mode]
 

Similar to Insurance strategies

Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)
Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)
Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)Society of Women Engineers
 
America Invents Act: Recent Changes to US Patent Law and Practice
America Invents Act:  Recent Changes to US Patent Law and PracticeAmerica Invents Act:  Recent Changes to US Patent Law and Practice
America Invents Act: Recent Changes to US Patent Law and PracticeGary M. Myles, Ph.D.
 
Inter Partes Review of Patents
Inter Partes Review of PatentsInter Partes Review of Patents
Inter Partes Review of PatentsRichard Beem
 
Leahy Smith America Invents Act
Leahy Smith America Invents ActLeahy Smith America Invents Act
Leahy Smith America Invents ActMarc Hubbard
 
New Strategies for Third Parties The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...
New Strategies for Third Parties  The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...New Strategies for Third Parties  The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...
New Strategies for Third Parties The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...Marc Hubbard
 
The Pitch on Patent Reform
The Pitch on Patent ReformThe Pitch on Patent Reform
The Pitch on Patent ReformMichael Annis
 
Patent Litigation Issues and the America Invents Act
Patent Litigation Issues and the America Invents ActPatent Litigation Issues and the America Invents Act
Patent Litigation Issues and the America Invents ActHovey Williams LLP
 
Introduction to Patent Law
Introduction to Patent LawIntroduction to Patent Law
Introduction to Patent LawMichael E. Dukes
 
The New Patent Act & Major Changes in the Law
The New Patent Act & Major Changes in the LawThe New Patent Act & Major Changes in the Law
The New Patent Act & Major Changes in the LawMichael Annis
 
IP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You File
IP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You FileIP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You File
IP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You FileFinancial Poise
 
Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)
Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)
Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)rimonlaw
 
AIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes Review
AIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes ReviewAIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes Review
AIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes ReviewCraig Buschmann
 
Getting The Patent
Getting The PatentGetting The Patent
Getting The PatentAlex Sousa
 
REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007
REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007
REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007David A. Jones
 
Patents, Licenses, NDA's
Patents, Licenses, NDA'sPatents, Licenses, NDA's
Patents, Licenses, NDA'sMary Johnson
 
Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...
Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...
Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...Professor Jon Cavicchi, UNH School of Law
 
Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...
Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...
Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...VijayKamble86
 

Similar to Insurance strategies (20)

IPR Presentation
IPR PresentationIPR Presentation
IPR Presentation
 
Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)
Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)
Big Changes in Patent Law: The America Invents Act (“AIA”)
 
America Invents Act: Recent Changes to US Patent Law and Practice
America Invents Act:  Recent Changes to US Patent Law and PracticeAmerica Invents Act:  Recent Changes to US Patent Law and Practice
America Invents Act: Recent Changes to US Patent Law and Practice
 
Inter Partes Review of Patents
Inter Partes Review of PatentsInter Partes Review of Patents
Inter Partes Review of Patents
 
Leahy Smith America Invents Act
Leahy Smith America Invents ActLeahy Smith America Invents Act
Leahy Smith America Invents Act
 
New Strategies for Third Parties The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...
New Strategies for Third Parties  The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...New Strategies for Third Parties  The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...
New Strategies for Third Parties The Role of New Third Party Preissuance Sub...
 
The Pitch on Patent Reform
The Pitch on Patent ReformThe Pitch on Patent Reform
The Pitch on Patent Reform
 
Patent Litigation Issues and the America Invents Act
Patent Litigation Issues and the America Invents ActPatent Litigation Issues and the America Invents Act
Patent Litigation Issues and the America Invents Act
 
Introduction to Patent Law
Introduction to Patent LawIntroduction to Patent Law
Introduction to Patent Law
 
The New Patent Act & Major Changes in the Law
The New Patent Act & Major Changes in the LawThe New Patent Act & Major Changes in the Law
The New Patent Act & Major Changes in the Law
 
IP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You File
IP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You FileIP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You File
IP-301 POST-GRANT REVIEW TRIALS 2022 - Things to Consider Before You File
 
Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)
Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)
Inter-Partes Review of Patents: The Case So Far (CLE)
 
AIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes Review
AIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes ReviewAIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes Review
AIA - What are you doing now - Post Grant and Inter Partes Review
 
Getting The Patent
Getting The PatentGetting The Patent
Getting The Patent
 
REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007
REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007
REEXAMINATION - Dave Jones - 4-28-2007
 
Introduction to patents
Introduction to patentsIntroduction to patents
Introduction to patents
 
Patents, Licenses, NDA's
Patents, Licenses, NDA'sPatents, Licenses, NDA's
Patents, Licenses, NDA's
 
Speeding Up Invalidity Using Procedures at the USPTO
Speeding Up Invalidity Using Procedures at the USPTOSpeeding Up Invalidity Using Procedures at the USPTO
Speeding Up Invalidity Using Procedures at the USPTO
 
Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...
Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...
Potential liability of lawyers performing/handling patent and trademark searc...
 
Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...
Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...
Dr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Kamble IPRDr V A Ka...
 

Insurance strategies

  • 1. PATENT INFRINGEMENT DEFENSE & INTER PARTES REVIEW Presented by Alex Fjelstad Twin City Group Minneapolis MN Nothing in this presentation should be considered legal advice. Consult your legal advisor All rights reserved
  • 2. PATENT INFRINGEMENT PATHWAY Patent Holder Demand by letter or lawsuit Accused Infringer Settle Full Litigation PTAB •Inter Partes Review •Post Grant Review
  • 3. PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD • Known as PTAB • New Process Created by the American Invents Act • Post Grant Review (within 9 months of patent issue) • Business Method Patents Review (within 9 months) • Inter Partes Review
  • 4. INTER PARTES REVIEW SUMMARY Limited to Prior Art • Previously issued patents • Previously published material Petition for IPR Sent To PTAB • “More likely than not” standard • Hearings & decision within 12 months PTAB Decisions Available • Extinguish entire patent • Extinguish specific patent claims • Validate patent and/or specific patent claims
  • 5. LITIGATION COSTS-PER SIDE • Full Litigation $2,000,000 • Inter Partes Review $300,000 to $500,000 • Post Grant Review Minimal INSURANCE COSTS • Full Litigation $40,000 + $2,000,000 limit • Inter Partes Review $7,000 to $10,000 $300,000 to $500,000 limit
  • 6. IPR INSURANCE HIGHLIGHTS • Limits up to $5 million available • 2% of limit self insured retention applies • 10% of limit co-payment applies • Limit not used on IPR expenses can be used for related litigation expense • Litigation expense only-no damages coverage • Reimbursement of eligible expenses
  • 7. ABOUT ALEX • Former CEO of a publicly-held insurance company • Former CEO of a technology company • Technology patent holder • Speaker at IP law firms, LES meetings and legal continuing education forums • Senior Vice President at Twin City Group a Minneapolis based insurance brokerage firm • Currently works with clients throughout the US and Europe