Dynasty -Indias Nehru , Daughter and Grand Son Critically Analysed
January 2020
DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.29563.67369
Project: BOOK REVIEWS
Agha H AminAgha H Amin
The document discusses the roles of Punjab and Baluch regiments in the 1971 war. It was published on September 2023 with a DOI number and was written by Agha H Amin.
Major Agha H. Amin was commissioned in the old PAVO Cavalry in 1983. He served in various command, staff, research, logistics and instructional positions over his military career. In his civilian career, he performed projects in infrastructure and transmission lines in Uzbekistan, Afghanistan, and Turkmenistan. He has authored over 120 books and journals on military topics. The document goes on to describe a battle of Pandu fought by the 4/10 Baluch battalion against India in the 1947-48 Kashmir war, and criticizes the omission of accurate accounts of the battle from official Pakistani military histories.
Battles of Najafgarh , Gangiri and Delhi RidgeAgha A
- The 6th Dragoon Guards regiment arrived in Bengal, India from England in November 1856 and was stationed in Meerut at the time of the 1857 rebellion.
- During the rebellion, the regiment saw action at Ghaziabad, Badli Ki Serai, Delhi, and helped destroy a rebel battery at Eidgah with no reported casualties.
- It lost a few men at the battles of Ghaziabad, Badli Ki Serai, and in minor actions in July 1857 but overall emerged from the rebellion relatively lightly compared to other British units.
- However, the limited historical sources available in Pakistan make it difficult for researchers there to find all details on the regiment's role and casualties during
The battalion was part of an infantry brigade deployed at Sulaimanke Headworks during the 1965 war with India. It saw little serious action as it primarily engaged Indian border police posts that were no match for regular Pakistani army battalions. The battalion suffered only 3 fatal casualties for the entire war, showing it faced little militarily credible opposition. While the battalion performed well, it must be remembered that it faced inferior Indian border police rather than other army units.
This document summarizes the performance of the 9 Punjab battalion during the 1965 war with India. The battalion was part of the 12th Division of the Pakistan Army and was tasked with capturing the town of Chhamb. Despite having significant superiority in tanks and artillery, the 12th Division failed to cross the Tawi River on the first day. The 9th Punjab battalion suffered 15 killed and 31 wounded but managed to form a bridgehead across the Tawi. After the war, the battalion was praised for its performance and received several awards, though its strategic impact was limited due to the overall failure of Operation Grand Slam.
The battalion was deployed as a guard battalion but parts saw action in 1965 war including C Company commanded by Major Anis. C Company withdrew from its position exposing the rear of 16 Punjab to Indian attack, effectively sealing 16 Punjab's fate. C Company's withdrawal doomed 16 Punjab and was described as cowardly and the cause of 16 Punjab's debacle. While most of 8 Punjab saw no action, C Company under Major Anis performed poorly and was to blame for 16 Punjab's defeat.
1) The battalion was deployed as part of 11 Division along the Ravi-Sutlej Corridor according to maps.
2) The battalion faced a brigade-level attack from the Indian army using three infantry battalions and a tank squadron.
3) A captain from the Pakistani artillery played a crucial role by engaging the attacking forces with 60 medium shells, repulsing the Indian attack.
The document discusses the roles of Punjab and Baluch regiments in the 1971 war. It was published on September 2023 with a DOI number and was written by Agha H Amin.
Major Agha H. Amin was commissioned in the old PAVO Cavalry in 1983. He served in various command, staff, research, logistics and instructional positions over his military career. In his civilian career, he performed projects in infrastructure and transmission lines in Uzbekistan, Afghanistan, and Turkmenistan. He has authored over 120 books and journals on military topics. The document goes on to describe a battle of Pandu fought by the 4/10 Baluch battalion against India in the 1947-48 Kashmir war, and criticizes the omission of accurate accounts of the battle from official Pakistani military histories.
Battles of Najafgarh , Gangiri and Delhi RidgeAgha A
- The 6th Dragoon Guards regiment arrived in Bengal, India from England in November 1856 and was stationed in Meerut at the time of the 1857 rebellion.
- During the rebellion, the regiment saw action at Ghaziabad, Badli Ki Serai, Delhi, and helped destroy a rebel battery at Eidgah with no reported casualties.
- It lost a few men at the battles of Ghaziabad, Badli Ki Serai, and in minor actions in July 1857 but overall emerged from the rebellion relatively lightly compared to other British units.
- However, the limited historical sources available in Pakistan make it difficult for researchers there to find all details on the regiment's role and casualties during
The battalion was part of an infantry brigade deployed at Sulaimanke Headworks during the 1965 war with India. It saw little serious action as it primarily engaged Indian border police posts that were no match for regular Pakistani army battalions. The battalion suffered only 3 fatal casualties for the entire war, showing it faced little militarily credible opposition. While the battalion performed well, it must be remembered that it faced inferior Indian border police rather than other army units.
This document summarizes the performance of the 9 Punjab battalion during the 1965 war with India. The battalion was part of the 12th Division of the Pakistan Army and was tasked with capturing the town of Chhamb. Despite having significant superiority in tanks and artillery, the 12th Division failed to cross the Tawi River on the first day. The 9th Punjab battalion suffered 15 killed and 31 wounded but managed to form a bridgehead across the Tawi. After the war, the battalion was praised for its performance and received several awards, though its strategic impact was limited due to the overall failure of Operation Grand Slam.
The battalion was deployed as a guard battalion but parts saw action in 1965 war including C Company commanded by Major Anis. C Company withdrew from its position exposing the rear of 16 Punjab to Indian attack, effectively sealing 16 Punjab's fate. C Company's withdrawal doomed 16 Punjab and was described as cowardly and the cause of 16 Punjab's debacle. While most of 8 Punjab saw no action, C Company under Major Anis performed poorly and was to blame for 16 Punjab's defeat.
1) The battalion was deployed as part of 11 Division along the Ravi-Sutlej Corridor according to maps.
2) The battalion faced a brigade-level attack from the Indian army using three infantry battalions and a tank squadron.
3) A captain from the Pakistani artillery played a crucial role by engaging the attacking forces with 60 medium shells, repulsing the Indian attack.
The battalion was deployed in September 1965 as part of Operation Grand Slam, relieving the 13th Punjab battalion near Dalpat-Chak Kirpal. According to Brigadier Rizvi, the battalion attacked towards Fatwal along with 13 Lancers, advancing up to 6 miles near Kasur and suffering 9 killed and 21 wounded. However, records list the battalion as losing either 9, 11, or 10 killed. The battalion had little impact as it joined the war late when the focus had shifted, and did not receive any awards despite actions in the Rann of Kutch prior to the war.
NORTH LINCOLNSHIRE REGIMENT OF FOOT IN 1857-59 BATTLESAgha A
This document provides biographical and career details of Major Agha.H.Amin, who was commissioned in the old PAVO Cavalry in March 1983. It discusses his education, various military and civilian positions held over his career, publications authored, and contact information. The document also briefly describes a study aid about British infantry battalions that participated in the battles of 1857-59 in India, including their roles, operations, casualties, and contributions to the outcome of the war.
The 2nd Battalion of the Punjab Regiment fought in the 1965 war against India. While it received several gallantry awards, the document argues that its role was exaggerated and it did not actually face most of the major Indian attacks. Only one company saw direct fighting on the first day, and it dispersed against heavy odds. The battalion was deployed away from the main sites of battle and did not face significant enemy forces apart from this initial engagement. Its impact on the decisive Battle of Chawinda was marginal.
This document provides information about Major Agha.H.Amin, including his military and civilian career experiences. It notes that he was commissioned in the old PAVO Cavalry in March 1983, attended Saint Marys Academy Lalazar and Forman Christian College Lahore, and served in various command, staff, research, logistics and instructional positions in the military. It also lists some of his civilian career projects and publications. The document provides his contact email addresses.
1ST BATTALION WARWICKSHIRE REGIMENT IN 1857-59 BATTLES.pdfAgha A
- 1st Battalion HM 8th Foot was stationed in India when the 1857 rebellion broke out. It was involved in securing areas around Delhi.
- At the siege of Delhi in September 1857, it suffered 46 of its total 57 fatal casualties and played a marginal role in the assault.
- Overall it saw minor action in other battles, with limited casualties. The majority of its casualties occurred at the decisive battle of Delhi.
Northumberland Fusiliers in 1857-59 Battles.pdfAgha A
The 1st Battalion of the 5th Regiment of Foot (Northumberland Fusiliers) was stationed in Mauritius when it was called to reinforce British forces in India during the 1857 uprising. The battalion arrived in Calcutta in July and August 1857. It participated in key battles including relieving Arrah where it suffered two casualties, the first relief of Lucknow where it suffered heavy losses and helped ensure the relief's success, the defense of the Lucknow garrison, and operations through 1858. The battalion performed outstandingly and suffered high casualties of 62 men, including five officers killed in action, primarily during the relief of Lucknow. Its role was pivotal in some of the major battles, but relatively minor in others
43 BALUCH IN 1971 AND INDIAN OFFICER WHO SAW THEMAgha A
1) The document analyzes the performance of the 43rd Baluch battalion in the 1971 war, which suffered heavy casualties after being poorly employed by incompetent commanders in the 88th Brigade.
2) When the 5th East Bengal battalion defected to the Indian side, the 43rd Baluch battalion was brought in to replace it, even though they were inexperienced and unprepared for the situation.
3) In an attack by Indian forces guided by defectors, the 43rd Baluch battalion suffered the highest fatalities of any battalion on the western front due to being put into a vulnerable position by the failed leadership of the 88th Brigade commander and 10th Division commander.
Battle of Gangiri-Heavy Price paid by HM 6 Dragoon Guards for Gallantry Agha A
Battle of Gangiri-Heavy Price paid by HM 6 Dragoon Guards for Gallantry https://www.academia.edu/52632772/Battle_of_Gangiri_Heavy_Price_paid_by_HM_6_Dragoon_Guards_for_Gallantry via @academia
4th Punjab Infantry now 9 FF Pakistan Army and 42 Highlanders led the Final ...Agha A
The 4th Punjab Infantry battalion arrived in Calcutta in November 1857, meaning it missed the decisive battles of the war, including the siege of Delhi and the relief and evacuation of Lucknow. The battalion's participation in the battle of Cawnpore was minimal and it suffered no casualties. The battalion played a significant role in the final assault on Lucknow in March 1858, leading the assault on Martiniere with the 4th Punjab Infantry while the 42nd Highlanders and 90th Foot attacked frontally. The British enjoyed overwhelming artillery superiority, evidenced by the 42nd Highlanders suffering only 10 fatal casualties over 10 days of operations culminating in the final capture of Lucknow.
WHY PAKISTAN ARMY OR INDIAN ARMY CAN NEVER PRODUCE A MUSTAFA KAMAL- SOMETHING...Agha A
WHY PAKISTAN ARMY OR INDIAN ARMY CAN NEVER PRODUCE A MUSTAFA KAMAL- SOMETHING SERIOUSLY WRONG IN THE GENES
April 2020
DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.20723.27689
Project: MILITARY HISTORY
Agha H Amin
The Western Theatre in 1971 A Strategic and Operational AnalysisAgha A
This document provides a strategic and operational analysis of the Western Theatre of the 1971 Indo-Pakistan war. It summarizes the Pakistani and Indian forces and plans in the Western sector. For Pakistan, the plan involved preliminary operations along the border to fix Indian forces, followed by a main counter-offensive using 1st Armoured Division and two infantry divisions against Ganganagar, India. Indian strategy was to defend in the West while launching an offensive in East Pakistan to create Bangladesh. The Indian Western Command defended along the border while maintaining reserves to counter any Pakistani attack.
Tarak Barkawis soldiers of empire reviewed-Part twoAgha A
This document criticizes Tarak Barkawi's book for inaccurately portraying the class composition of the British Indian Army during World War I. It provides evidence that there were 30 infantry battalions organized along single ethnic or religious lines during WWI, contrary to Barkawi's claims. It also notes several important aspects of British Indian military history that Barkawi failed to address, such as the influence of the 1857 mutiny on reorganization, acts of defiance by Indian officers, and the impact of casualties and mutinies on changes to the army's composition. The critic concludes that while the book provides anecdotes, it cannot be considered a serious military history work due to factual inaccuracies and omissions.
OTTOMANS MISERABLY FAIL TO REOCCUPY AZOV FOR THREE MONTHSAgha A
The Ottomans unsuccessfully tried to reoccupy the city of Azov for three months. In July 2021, Agha H Amin published a report on their failed military campaign as part of a project on military history. The report documented the Ottomans' miserable failure to retake the city.
the man who raised 5th Punjab Infantry- now 10 FFAgha A
Lieutenant-General James Eardley Gastrell had a distinguished career serving in the Bengal Native Infantry and Revenue Survey Department in British India. He raised the 5th Punjab Infantry in 1849 and saw active service in several campaigns. Gastrell made his name as an eminent revenue survey officer and wrote an important report on the 1864 Calcutta cyclone. After serving in the military and seeing combat against rebels and in the Sikh Wars, he had a long and notable career as a civilian administrator in the Revenue Survey Department before retiring with the rank of Lieutenant General in 1894.
NAIB RISALDAR AKBAR COMMANDING LEFT TANK TROOP OF B SQUADRON 25 CAVALRY LOST HIS WAY IN THE EXCITEMENT OF BATTLE AND WENT TO GENERAL AREA MAHARAJKE ---CHASING WIND MILLS (WILD GOOSE CHASE) WHILE MAJOR AHMAD CONFRONTED AND CHECKED 16 CAVALRY WITH JUST TWO TANK TROOPS
Lord Clive not the first one to capture Bengal by TreacheryAgha A
Agha H. Amin is a retired Pakistani military officer who has written extensively on military and intelligence topics. He headed the Centre for Study of Intelligence Operations and edited several journals. Amin served in the Pakistani army for many years, holding command positions and writing tactical papers that influenced Pakistani military doctrine. He has authored several books on military history and conflicts in Afghanistan and Pakistan.
The largest number of Victoria Crosses in British history were awarded between 1857-1859, exceeding both the Crimean War and Boer War. Specifically, 16 VCs were awarded during the Second Afghan War while 23 were awarded alone in the Battle of Rorke's Drift during the Anglo-Zulu War, demonstrating that these conflicts produced more individual acts of bravery recognized by the VC than other major wars until World War I.
The battalion was deployed in September 1965 as part of Operation Grand Slam, relieving the 13th Punjab battalion near Dalpat-Chak Kirpal. According to Brigadier Rizvi, the battalion attacked towards Fatwal along with 13 Lancers, advancing up to 6 miles near Kasur and suffering 9 killed and 21 wounded. However, records list the battalion as losing either 9, 11, or 10 killed. The battalion had little impact as it joined the war late when the focus had shifted, and did not receive any awards despite actions in the Rann of Kutch prior to the war.
NORTH LINCOLNSHIRE REGIMENT OF FOOT IN 1857-59 BATTLESAgha A
This document provides biographical and career details of Major Agha.H.Amin, who was commissioned in the old PAVO Cavalry in March 1983. It discusses his education, various military and civilian positions held over his career, publications authored, and contact information. The document also briefly describes a study aid about British infantry battalions that participated in the battles of 1857-59 in India, including their roles, operations, casualties, and contributions to the outcome of the war.
The 2nd Battalion of the Punjab Regiment fought in the 1965 war against India. While it received several gallantry awards, the document argues that its role was exaggerated and it did not actually face most of the major Indian attacks. Only one company saw direct fighting on the first day, and it dispersed against heavy odds. The battalion was deployed away from the main sites of battle and did not face significant enemy forces apart from this initial engagement. Its impact on the decisive Battle of Chawinda was marginal.
This document provides information about Major Agha.H.Amin, including his military and civilian career experiences. It notes that he was commissioned in the old PAVO Cavalry in March 1983, attended Saint Marys Academy Lalazar and Forman Christian College Lahore, and served in various command, staff, research, logistics and instructional positions in the military. It also lists some of his civilian career projects and publications. The document provides his contact email addresses.
1ST BATTALION WARWICKSHIRE REGIMENT IN 1857-59 BATTLES.pdfAgha A
- 1st Battalion HM 8th Foot was stationed in India when the 1857 rebellion broke out. It was involved in securing areas around Delhi.
- At the siege of Delhi in September 1857, it suffered 46 of its total 57 fatal casualties and played a marginal role in the assault.
- Overall it saw minor action in other battles, with limited casualties. The majority of its casualties occurred at the decisive battle of Delhi.
Northumberland Fusiliers in 1857-59 Battles.pdfAgha A
The 1st Battalion of the 5th Regiment of Foot (Northumberland Fusiliers) was stationed in Mauritius when it was called to reinforce British forces in India during the 1857 uprising. The battalion arrived in Calcutta in July and August 1857. It participated in key battles including relieving Arrah where it suffered two casualties, the first relief of Lucknow where it suffered heavy losses and helped ensure the relief's success, the defense of the Lucknow garrison, and operations through 1858. The battalion performed outstandingly and suffered high casualties of 62 men, including five officers killed in action, primarily during the relief of Lucknow. Its role was pivotal in some of the major battles, but relatively minor in others
43 BALUCH IN 1971 AND INDIAN OFFICER WHO SAW THEMAgha A
1) The document analyzes the performance of the 43rd Baluch battalion in the 1971 war, which suffered heavy casualties after being poorly employed by incompetent commanders in the 88th Brigade.
2) When the 5th East Bengal battalion defected to the Indian side, the 43rd Baluch battalion was brought in to replace it, even though they were inexperienced and unprepared for the situation.
3) In an attack by Indian forces guided by defectors, the 43rd Baluch battalion suffered the highest fatalities of any battalion on the western front due to being put into a vulnerable position by the failed leadership of the 88th Brigade commander and 10th Division commander.
Battle of Gangiri-Heavy Price paid by HM 6 Dragoon Guards for Gallantry Agha A
Battle of Gangiri-Heavy Price paid by HM 6 Dragoon Guards for Gallantry https://www.academia.edu/52632772/Battle_of_Gangiri_Heavy_Price_paid_by_HM_6_Dragoon_Guards_for_Gallantry via @academia
4th Punjab Infantry now 9 FF Pakistan Army and 42 Highlanders led the Final ...Agha A
The 4th Punjab Infantry battalion arrived in Calcutta in November 1857, meaning it missed the decisive battles of the war, including the siege of Delhi and the relief and evacuation of Lucknow. The battalion's participation in the battle of Cawnpore was minimal and it suffered no casualties. The battalion played a significant role in the final assault on Lucknow in March 1858, leading the assault on Martiniere with the 4th Punjab Infantry while the 42nd Highlanders and 90th Foot attacked frontally. The British enjoyed overwhelming artillery superiority, evidenced by the 42nd Highlanders suffering only 10 fatal casualties over 10 days of operations culminating in the final capture of Lucknow.
WHY PAKISTAN ARMY OR INDIAN ARMY CAN NEVER PRODUCE A MUSTAFA KAMAL- SOMETHING...Agha A
WHY PAKISTAN ARMY OR INDIAN ARMY CAN NEVER PRODUCE A MUSTAFA KAMAL- SOMETHING SERIOUSLY WRONG IN THE GENES
April 2020
DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.20723.27689
Project: MILITARY HISTORY
Agha H Amin
The Western Theatre in 1971 A Strategic and Operational AnalysisAgha A
This document provides a strategic and operational analysis of the Western Theatre of the 1971 Indo-Pakistan war. It summarizes the Pakistani and Indian forces and plans in the Western sector. For Pakistan, the plan involved preliminary operations along the border to fix Indian forces, followed by a main counter-offensive using 1st Armoured Division and two infantry divisions against Ganganagar, India. Indian strategy was to defend in the West while launching an offensive in East Pakistan to create Bangladesh. The Indian Western Command defended along the border while maintaining reserves to counter any Pakistani attack.
Tarak Barkawis soldiers of empire reviewed-Part twoAgha A
This document criticizes Tarak Barkawi's book for inaccurately portraying the class composition of the British Indian Army during World War I. It provides evidence that there were 30 infantry battalions organized along single ethnic or religious lines during WWI, contrary to Barkawi's claims. It also notes several important aspects of British Indian military history that Barkawi failed to address, such as the influence of the 1857 mutiny on reorganization, acts of defiance by Indian officers, and the impact of casualties and mutinies on changes to the army's composition. The critic concludes that while the book provides anecdotes, it cannot be considered a serious military history work due to factual inaccuracies and omissions.
OTTOMANS MISERABLY FAIL TO REOCCUPY AZOV FOR THREE MONTHSAgha A
The Ottomans unsuccessfully tried to reoccupy the city of Azov for three months. In July 2021, Agha H Amin published a report on their failed military campaign as part of a project on military history. The report documented the Ottomans' miserable failure to retake the city.
the man who raised 5th Punjab Infantry- now 10 FFAgha A
Lieutenant-General James Eardley Gastrell had a distinguished career serving in the Bengal Native Infantry and Revenue Survey Department in British India. He raised the 5th Punjab Infantry in 1849 and saw active service in several campaigns. Gastrell made his name as an eminent revenue survey officer and wrote an important report on the 1864 Calcutta cyclone. After serving in the military and seeing combat against rebels and in the Sikh Wars, he had a long and notable career as a civilian administrator in the Revenue Survey Department before retiring with the rank of Lieutenant General in 1894.
NAIB RISALDAR AKBAR COMMANDING LEFT TANK TROOP OF B SQUADRON 25 CAVALRY LOST HIS WAY IN THE EXCITEMENT OF BATTLE AND WENT TO GENERAL AREA MAHARAJKE ---CHASING WIND MILLS (WILD GOOSE CHASE) WHILE MAJOR AHMAD CONFRONTED AND CHECKED 16 CAVALRY WITH JUST TWO TANK TROOPS
Lord Clive not the first one to capture Bengal by TreacheryAgha A
Agha H. Amin is a retired Pakistani military officer who has written extensively on military and intelligence topics. He headed the Centre for Study of Intelligence Operations and edited several journals. Amin served in the Pakistani army for many years, holding command positions and writing tactical papers that influenced Pakistani military doctrine. He has authored several books on military history and conflicts in Afghanistan and Pakistan.
The largest number of Victoria Crosses in British history were awarded between 1857-1859, exceeding both the Crimean War and Boer War. Specifically, 16 VCs were awarded during the Second Afghan War while 23 were awarded alone in the Battle of Rorke's Drift during the Anglo-Zulu War, demonstrating that these conflicts produced more individual acts of bravery recognized by the VC than other major wars until World War I.
Dynasty -Indias Nehru , Daughter and Grand Son Critically Analysed
1.
2. Dynasty -Indias Nehru , Daughter and Grand Son Critically Analysed
• January 2020
• DOI:
• 10.13140/RG.2.2.29563.67369
• Project:
• BOOK REVIEWS
• Agha H Amin