4. Agenda
Cost is no expense
Unit prices
Media cost efficiency
Television
Radio
Magazines
Newspapers
Internet
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
5. Cost is No Expense
Price
What sellers ask for their inventory
Verbal or on rate card
Cost
What buyers pay sellers for time or space
Typically negotiated with seller
May be less than seller’s initial price
Expense
Dollars spent to achieve an objective
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
6. What is a media unit worth?
Unit Prices
All media have unit prices-- a :30 in NCIS or a four color page
in Tennis Magazine
However, without more information, we don’t know if a
$10,000 per unit asking price is high or low
What’s the size of audience? The right audience?
Cost Efficiency – a better measure of price
Two measures of media cost efficiency
CPM - What is the cost per 1000 impressions in a media vehicle?
CPP - What is the cost per rating point? How does it compare to
other programs or stations?
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
7. Cost per Thousand (CPM)
Cost per thousand (CPM) is a rudimentary measure of media
value received per dollar-- based on audience and cost.
Media people believe that the cost of audience is an important
purchasing criterion.
CPM = Cost/Audience x 1000
Example: If the price of an ad is $10,000 and it reaches 25,000
persons, the CPM is $66.67:
$10,000/25,000 x 1000 = $66.67
Now compare this CPM to the other media options!
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
8. Cost per Point (CPP)
Cost per point (CPP) is a second measure of media
efficiency, i.e., “what does it cost to reach 1% of a target market in a
geographic area?”
Spot buyers use CPP to cost out plans and to compare the efficiency
of alternative programs and buys
CPP = Cost/TRPS
Example: If the price of an ad is $10,000 and it reaches 10% of
the target audience, the CPP is $1000
$10,000/10 = $1000
Now compare this CPP to your other options in the same geographic
area!
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
9. TRPS vs. CPM
Will a bag of
CPMs work?
Captain,
marketing
need s an
infusion of
TRPS
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
10. Are CPM and CPP Interchangeable?
Yes and No
Yes, if the audience base is in exactly the same area.
e.g., metro area, DMA
No, if using total survey audience for CPM vs. DMA
audience for CPP
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
11. Comparison of Media Efficiencies
Media
Vehicle
Price of
Ad Unit
Audience
(Adults)
CPM
CPM
Rank
A
$187,000
10,841,000
$17.25
5
B
267,000
44,707,000
5.97
2
C
94,000
8,436,000
11.14
4
D
165,000
16,429,000
10.04
3
E
90,000
22,206,000
4.06
1
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
12. Television Pricing/Costs
Television prices are affected by many variables
Geographic coverage area
Commercial length (e.g.,:60 vs. :30 vs. :15)
Day part/Time of Day
Audience size
Individual programs
Supply & demand conditions
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
13. Example of Television Costs
2011 Network Upfront
Cost/:30
Program Network
(000)
A25-54
Rating
CPP
60 Minutes
CBS
$92.2
9.0
$10,244
Glee
FOX
272.7
5.1
53,470
College Ftbl
ABC
92.2
3.5
26,340
NCIS
CBS
150.7
5.5
27,400
Idol
FOX
400.0
12.0
33,333
Lie to Me
FOX
100.8
2.0
50,400
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
14. Radio Pricing/Costs
Radio costs are affected by similar factors
Geographic coverage area
Commercial length
Daypart
Station
Size of audience
Supply & Demand Conditions
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
15. Example of Radio Costs
MSAs
% US HH
CPP
A25-54
Top 10
26
$4600
4400
5500
Top 20
35
6600
5450
6200
Top 40
47
8600
8850
10,100
Top 60
54
11100
10600
11900
Top 80
59
12300
11400
13000
Top 100
62
13000
12200
14000
Top 200
72
16200
15200
17700
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
CPP
M25-54
CPP
W25-54
16. Magazine Pricing
Magazine ad pricing
Creative unit – single page vs. spread
Size of ad – Full page, spread, fractional page
Bleed – Color to edge of page
Geographic or demographic edition
Circulation rate base
Size of audience
What the market will bear (publishers)
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
17. Examples of Magazine Prices
Magazine
Circulation
Cost P4C
CPM Circ.
CPM
Adults
Entrepreneur
618,000
$84,000
$136.00
$37.53
Forbes
937,000
115,000
123.00
20.91
Fortune
877,000
119,000
136.00
29.62
Inc.
721,000
74,000
103.00
50.51
Black
Enterprise
507,000
42,000
83.00
10.80
U.S. News
1,486,000
90,000
61.00
8.04
Time
3,445,000
288,000
84.00
14.26
Newsweek
2,523,000
165,000
65.00
10.06
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
18. Newspaper Pricing
Newspaper rate cards - extremely complex
National vs. local rate differential (often 100%+)
Product category discounts, e.g., auto dealers
Rate differentials by sections
Classifieds and classified display
Supplements, e.g., a TV Guide or a Home Living section –
different rates
Prices extremely high for national advertiser
Daily Newspapers (PB/W)
Magazines (P4C)
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
CPM Circulation
$150-1000
65 - 135
19. Examples of Newspaper Pricing
National Rates
Full Page
B/W
Circulation
CPM
Wall Street Journal
223,000
1,722,000
130.00
USA Today
120,000
1,900,000
63.00
New York Times (M-F)
142,000
928,000
153.00
LA Times
155,000
658000
236.00
Chicago Tribune
121,000
466.000
260.00
St. Louis Post Dispatch
204,000
214,000
953.00
Charlotte Observor
54,000
168,000
321.00
Hartford Courant
62,000
144,000
360.00
Newspaper
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
20. Internet Pricing Models
Three Pricing Models
CPM Impressions
Example: 100,000 impressions x $5.00 CPM = $500.00
Suggestion: estimate cost per click based on CTR history
CPC/PPC – Cost per click/pay per click
Cost per click a function of bid and budget
Example: 10,000 clicks x $.75 CPC = $7500
CPA – Cost per Action (Purchase, inquiry, etc.)
Some sellers offer CPA as alternative to CPC
Example: 1000 conversions x $10 CPA = 10,000
Media Planning & Buying in the 21st Century
Editor's Notes
The audiences reached are key. The cost of reaching those audiences is also key, given waste surpassed only by the federal government
The second leg of the media selection triangle is cost. Audience must be in line with cost per ad unit.
Agenda--
Important distinctions--
Media price their inventory in terms a price per unit, whether by commercial length in a program or ad pages in magazine.
Cost per unit doesn’t measure value, so cost efficiency measures developed to at least estimate value on basis of cost vs. vehicle audience
CPP another measure of cost efficiency
Who to believe: Kirk or Spock?
However, CPM and CPP are not interchangeable, depending on the geographic area chosen for media coverage
Example of CPM
Sellers establish television prices based on many variables
Example of TV costs paid in 2010 upfront market
Radio costs are affected by similar factors
Example of radio costs by how deep coverage is for spot buys, If you bougbht 1000 TRPS in top 40 markets with a target of Adults 25-54, the cost would be $8.6 million(1000 TRPS x $8600)
Magazine ad pricing affected by
Examples. Note differences in CPM circulation vs. CPM adults. What does this tell you?
Newspaper rates are complex and high
Examples, note variations by newspaper
Internet is a different ball game. Three pricing models