Alternative Management Methods and
Impacts with the System of Rice
Intensification (SRI) in Responding to
Climate Change E...
Rice producers face diverse and adverse
consequences from climate change:
• Droughts, storm damage, cold snaps,
hot spells...
System of Rice Intensification (SRI)
represents a management strategy –
developed in Madagascar 25 years ago
• It modifies...
CUBA: Farmer showing two
rice plants of same age (52 d)
and same variety (VN 2084),
i.e. both are same genotype,
get diffe...
IRAN:
SRI roots
and normal
(flooded)
roots: note
differences
in color as
well as size
Comparison
picture sent
by Haraz
Tec...
Total bacteria Total diazotrophs
TNAU research on microbial populations in rhizosphere soil for rice crop under
different ...
Dehydrogenase activity (μg TPF) Urease activity (μg NH4-N))
TNAU research on microbial activities in rhizosphere soil in r...
Treatments Total
microbes
(x105
)
Azotobacter
(x103
)
Azospirillum
(x103
)
PSM
(x104
)
Conventional (T0) 2.3a 1.9a 0.9a 3....
SRI Involves Only Changes in Practices
1. Transplant young seedlings to preserve their growth
potential - but DIRECT SEEDI...
Results from SRI Changes in Practices
1. Reduced crop requirements for water – can help
farmers to get ‘more crop per drop...
Despite reduction in rice cultivation area, State produces over 60 lakh tonnes
“Rice intensification project a boon to far...
SRI phenotypes give higher water-use efficiency
as indicated in the ratio of
photosynthesis to transpiration:
For each 1 m...
Parameters
Cultivation method
SRI RMP SRI % LSD.05
Total chlorophyll
(mg g-1
FW)
3.37
(0.17)
2.58
(0.21)
+30 0.11
Ratio of...
Effects of the system of rice intensification and fertilizer
N rate on irrigation water use efficiency (IWUE) and
total wa...
Other Benefits from Changes in Practices
1. Water saving – major concern in many places, also
now have ‘rainfed’ version w...
Journal of Sichuan Agricultural Science and Technology
(2009), Vol. 2, No. 23
“Introduction of Land-Cover Integrated Techn...
Storm resistance
in VIETNAM:
paddy fields in
Dông Trù village,
Hanoi province,
after typhoon
SRI field and
rice plant on l...
CHINA: Nie Fu-qiu, Bu Tou village, Zhejiang
In 2004, his SRI field gave
top yield in province: 12 t/ha
In 2005, although h...
Irrigation
method
Seedling
age
Spacing
(cm2
)
Plant lodging percentage
Partial Complete Total
Inter-
mittent
irrigation
(A...
PeriodPeriod Mean max.Mean max.
temp.temp.00
CC
Mean min.Mean min.
temp.temp.00
CC
No. ofNo. of
sunshine hrssunshine hrs
1...
Disease and pest incidence in VIETNAM:
National IPM Program evaluation: average of data
from on-farm trials in 8 provinces...
Crop duration in NEPAL (from seed to seed) of different
rice varieties with SRI vs. conventional methods (6.3 t/ha
vs. 3.1...
Methane and Nitrous Oxide Emissions from
Paddy Rice Fields in Indonesia
Comparison of SRI and surrounding conventional fie...
CH4 Flux
Water status at the time of sampling had a greater
influence on CH4 flux than did the difference between SRI
and ...
Highlights of S.R.I. Research in
Indonesia
Iswandi Anas, D. K. Kalsim, Budi I. Setiawan, Yanuar, and
Sam Herodian, Bogor A...
METHANE
EMISSIONS
Initial results reported by IPB
Soil Biotechnology Laboratory
from GHG studies with SRI
management in In...
N2O
EMISSIONS
Yan, X., H. Akiyama, K. Yagi and H. Akomoto. ‘Global
estimations of the inventory and mitigation potential
of methane emis...
Thank you
Website:
http://sri.ciifad.cornell.edu
Email:
ntu1@cornell.edu
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

1055 Alternative Management Methods and Impacts with the System of Rice Intensification (SRI) in Responding to Climate Change Effects

1,513

Published on

Presented by: Norman Uphoff, CIIFAD, Cornell University, USA

Presented at: Panel on Climate Change and Rice Agriculture 3rd International Rice Congress, Hanoi, Vietnam

Presented on: 9 November 2010

Published in: Technology
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,513
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
36
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • Picture provided by Dr. Rena Perez. These two rice plants are ‘twins’ in that they were planted on the same day in the same nursery from the same seed bag. The one on the right was taken out at 9 days and transplanted into an SRI environment. The one on the left was kept in the flooded nursery until its 52nd day, when it was taken out for transplanting (in Cuba, transplanting of commonly done between 50 and 55 DAP). The difference in root growth and tillering (5 vs. 42) is spectacular. We think this difference is at least in part attributable to the contributions of soil microorganisms producing phytohormones in the rhizosphere that benefit plant growth and performance.
  • This is the most simple description of what SRI entails. Transplanting is not necessary since direct seeding, with the other SRI practices, also produces similarly good results. The principle of SRI is that if transplanting is done, very young seedling should be used, and there should be little or no trauma to the young plant roots. These are often ‘abused’ in transplanting process, being allowed to dry out (desiccate), or are knocked to remove soil, etc.
  • This is the most simple description of what SRI entails. Transplanting is not necessary since direct seeding, with the other SRI practices, also produces similarly good results. The principle of SRI is that if transplanting is done, very young seedling should be used, and there should be little or no trauma to the young plant roots. These are often ‘abused’ in transplanting process, being allowed to dry out (desiccate), or are knocked to remove soil, etc.
  • This is the most simple description of what SRI entails. Transplanting is not necessary since direct seeding, with the other SRI practices, also produces similarly good results. The principle of SRI is that if transplanting is done, very young seedling should be used, and there should be little or no trauma to the young plant roots. These are often ‘abused’ in transplanting process, being allowed to dry out (desiccate), or are knocked to remove soil, etc.
  • 1055 Alternative Management Methods and Impacts with the System of Rice Intensification (SRI) in Responding to Climate Change Effects

    1. 1. Alternative Management Methods and Impacts with the System of Rice Intensification (SRI) in Responding to Climate Change Effects Panel on Climate Change and Rice Agriculture 3rd International Rice Congress, Hanoi, November 9, 2010 Norman Uphoff CIIFAD, Cornell University
    2. 2. Rice producers face diverse and adverse consequences from climate change: • Droughts, storm damage, cold snaps, hot spells, etc. are likely to become more frequent and more severe in future • Pest and disease problems also are likely to increase with climate change Alternative/complementary strategies: • Breeding strategies (G): breed in resistance • Management strategies (E): alter phenotype
    3. 3. System of Rice Intensification (SRI) represents a management strategy – developed in Madagascar 25 years ago • It modifies the way that rice plants, soil, water and nutrients are managed • Results in rice phenotypes that are more resistant to abiotic and biotic stresses through biological processes that promote: • Larger, deeper, less-senescent root systems • More abundant, diverse & active soil biota
    4. 4. CUBA: Farmer showing two rice plants of same age (52 d) and same variety (VN 2084), i.e. both are same genotype, get different phenotype
    5. 5. IRAN: SRI roots and normal (flooded) roots: note differences in color as well as size Comparison picture sent by Haraz Technology Research Center, Amol, Mazandaran
    6. 6. Total bacteria Total diazotrophs TNAU research on microbial populations in rhizosphere soil for rice crop under different management at active tillering, panicle initiation and flowering stages [units are √ transformed values of population g-1 of dry soil] SRI = yellow; conventional = red Phosphobacteria Azotobacter
    7. 7. Dehydrogenase activity (μg TPF) Urease activity (μg NH4-N)) TNAU research on microbial activities in rhizosphere soil in rice crop under different management at active tillering, panicle initiation and flowering stages [units = √ transformed values of units g-1 of dry soil in 24 h] SRI = yellow; conventional = red Acid phosphate activity (μg p- Nitrogenase activity (nano mol C2H4)
    8. 8. Treatments Total microbes (x105 ) Azotobacter (x103 ) Azospirillum (x103 ) PSM (x104 ) Conventional (T0) 2.3a 1.9a 0.9a 3.3a Inorganic SRI (T1) 2.7a 2.2a 1.7ab 4.0a Organic SRI (T2) 3.8b 3.7b 2.8bc 5.9b Inorg. SRI + BF (T3) 4.8c 4..4b 3.3c 6.4b CFU = colony forming units PSM = Phosphate-solubilizing microbes BF = Bio-organic fertilizer Values with the different letters in a column are significantly different by LSD at the 0.05 level. Treatments: T0 = 20x20 cm spacing, 30 day seedlings, 6 seedlings/hill, 5 cm flooding depth of water, fertilized with inorganic NPK (250 kg urea, 200 kg SP-18, 100 kg KCl ha-1 ); T1, T2, T3 = All 30x30 cm spacing, 6-10 day seedlings, 1 seedling/hill, moist soil or intermittent irrigation, with different fertilization: T1 = same inorganic NPK as T0; T2 = 5 t ha-1 of organic fertilizer (compost); T3 = Inorganic NPK as in T0 + 300 kg ha-1 bioorganic fertilizer. IPB research on total microbes and numbers of beneficial soil microbes (CFU g-1 ) under conventional and SRI rice cultivation methods, Tanjung Sari, Bogor district, Indonesia, Feb-Aug 2009 (Iswandi et al., 2009)
    9. 9. SRI Involves Only Changes in Practices 1. Transplant young seedlings to preserve their growth potential - but DIRECT SEEDING is now an option 2. Avoid trauma to the roots - transplant quickly and shallow, not inverting root tips which halts growth 3. Give plants wider spacing - one plant per hill and in square pattern for more exposure to air and sunlight 4. Keep paddy soil moist but unflooded - soil is kept mostly aerobic, never continuously saturated – but SRI methods are being extended to rainfed cropping 5. Actively aerate the soil as much as possible 6. Enhance soil organic matter as much as possible – while fertilizer can be used with other SRI methods, best results have come from compost applications These methods work with practically all rice varieties – also give buffering against drought, storm damage, etc.
    10. 10. Results from SRI Changes in Practices 1. Reduced crop requirements for water – can help farmers to get ‘more crop per drop’ 2. Greater water use efficiency – increased fixation of CO2 per unit of water transpired by rice plants 3. Drought resistance – even better yields reported in drought year from Sichuan province, China 4. Resistance to storm damage and cold temperatures – less lodging; good production despite cold snap 5. Pest and disease resistance – SRI management reduces plants’ attractiveness and vulnerability 6. Shorter crop duration with higher yield – reducing exposure to end-of-season biotic/abiotic stresses 7. Reduced greenhouse gas emissions – reduced CH4 when fields are not kept flooded; apparent reduction or no increase in N2O when nol chem. fertilizer used
    11. 11. Despite reduction in rice cultivation area, State produces over 60 lakh tonnes “Rice intensification project a boon to farmers” Special Correspondent http://www.hindu.com/2009/12/01/stories/2009120155040500.htm — Photo: E. Lakshmi Narayanan SALEM: Agriculture Minister Veerapandi S. Arumugam has pointed out that despite reduction in rice cultivation area due to poor monsoons, the State could produce 64.61 lakh tonnes, thanks to the rice intensification project. The Minister, inaugurating a seminar organised by the Agriculture Technology Management Agency (ATMA) of Department of Agriculture here on Monday, said that erratic monsoon had reduced the area of paddy cultivation in the State. “Because of the rice intensification scheme, however, the production touched 64.61 lakh tonnes. While in normal cultivation, 3,450 kg of rice could be produced per hectare, under the intensification scheme, it is somewhere between 6,000 and 9,000 kg…”
    12. 12. SRI phenotypes give higher water-use efficiency as indicated in the ratio of photosynthesis to transpiration: For each 1 millimol of water lost by transpiration, SRI plants fixed 3.6 millimols of CO2, RMP plants fixed 1.6 millimols of CO2 Climate change will make such gains in water efficiency increasingly important -- C4 transformation is not the only way to achieve more water-efficient phenotypes -- agroecological means now available, not hypothetical AK Thakur, N Uphoff, E Antony (2010). An assessment of physiological effects of the System of Rice Intensification (SRI) compared with recommended rice cultivation practices in India. Experimental Agriculture, 46: 77-98
    13. 13. Parameters Cultivation method SRI RMP SRI % LSD.05 Total chlorophyll (mg g-1 FW) 3.37 (0.17) 2.58 (0.21) +30 0.11 Ratio of chlorophyll a/b 2.32 (0.28) 1.90 (0.37) +22 0.29 Transpiration (m mol m-2 s-1 ) 6.41 (0.43) 7.59 (0.33) -16 0.27 Net photosynthetic rate (μ mol m-2 s-1 ) 23.15 (3.17) 12.23 (2.02) +89 1.64 Stomatal conductance (m mol m-2 s-1 ) 422.73 (34.35) 493.93 (35.93) -15 30.12 Internal CO2 concentration (ppm) 292.6 (16.64) 347.0 (19.74) -16 11.1 Comparison of chlorophyll content, transpiration rate, net photosynthetic rate, stomatal conductance, and internal CO2 concentration in SRI and RMP Standard deviations are given in parentheses [N = 15]
    14. 14. Effects of the system of rice intensification and fertilizer N rate on irrigation water use efficiency (IWUE) and total water use efficiency (WUE) (irrigation + rain) Cultivation IWUE (kg m−3 ) WUE (kg m−3 ) systems N rate 2005 2006 2005 2006 TF N0 0.298 f 0.232 e 0.210 f 0.182 f N1 0.371 e 0.278 e 0.262 e 0.218 e N2 0.433 d 0.344 d 0.305 d 0.270 d N3 0.448 d 0.326 d 0.316 d 0.256 d SRI N0 0.675 c 0.602 c 0.399 e 0.396 c N1 0.837 a 0.738 a 0.494 a 0.485 a N2 0.825 a 0.724 a 0.483 ab 0.475 a N3 0.769 b 0.655 b 0.465 b 0.431 b Values with the same letters in a column are not significantly different by LSD at the 0.05 level across cultivation systems TF: traditional flooding; SRI: System of Rice Intensification practices N0: no N fertilizer ; N1: 80 kg ha−1 ; N2: 160 kg ha−1 ; N3: 240 kg ha−1 Influence of the System of Rice Intensification on rice yield and nitrogen and water use efficiency with different N application rates. LM Zhao, LH Wu, YS Li, XH L, DF Zhu, N Uphoff, Exper Agric 45: 275-286 (2009).
    15. 15. Other Benefits from Changes in Practices 1. Water saving – major concern in many places, also now have ‘rainfed’ version with similar results 2. Greater resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses – less damage from pests and diseases, drought, typhoons, flooding, cold spells [discuss tomorrow] 3. Shorter crop cycle – same varieties are harvested by 1-3 weeks sooner, save water, less crop risk 4. High milling output – by about 15%, due to fewer unfilled grains (less chaff) and fewer broken grains 5. Reductions in labor requirements – widely reported incentive for changing practices in India and China; also, mechanization is being introduced many places 6. Reductions in costs of production – greater farmer income and profitability, also health benefits Drought-resistance in SRI LANKA: Rice fields 3 weeks after irrigation water was suspended; conventionally-grown field on left, and SRI field on right
    16. 16. Journal of Sichuan Agricultural Science and Technology (2009), Vol. 2, No. 23 “Introduction of Land-Cover Integrated Technologies with Water Saving and High Yield” -- Lv Shihua et al. • Yield in normal year is 150-200 kg/mu (2.25-3.0 t/ha); yield in drought year is 200 kg/mu (3.0 t/ha) or even more • Net income in normal year is increased by new methods from profit of 100 ¥/mu to 600-800 ¥/mu (i.e., from profit of $220/ha to >$1,500/ha) • Net income in drought year with new methods goes from loss of 200-300 ¥/mu to 300-500 ¥/mu profit (from a loss of $550/ha to a profit of $880/ha)
    17. 17. Storm resistance in VIETNAM: paddy fields in Dông Trù village, Hanoi province, after typhoon SRI field and rice plant on left; conventional field and plant on right
    18. 18. CHINA: Nie Fu-qiu, Bu Tou village, Zhejiang In 2004, his SRI field gave top yield in province: 12 t/ha In 2005, although his SRI fields were hit by 3 typhoons -- he was able to harvest 11.15 tons/ha while other farmers’ fields were badly affected by storm damage (CNRRI report) In 2008, Nie used chemical fertilizer to try for highest yield - and his crop lodged
    19. 19. Irrigation method Seedling age Spacing (cm2 ) Plant lodging percentage Partial Complete Total Inter- mittent irrigation (AWDI) 14 30x30 6.67 0 6.67 30x18 40.00 6.67 46.67 21 30x30 26.67 20 46.67 30x18 13.33 13.33 26.67 Ordinary irrigation (continuous flooding) 14 30x30 16.67 33.33 50.00 30x18 26.67 53.33 80.00 21 30x30 20 76.67 96.67 30x18 13.33 80 93.33 Rice plant lodging as affected by intermittent vs. ordinary irrigation practices when combined with different ages of seedlings and spacing in Chiba, Japan, 2008 (Chapagain and Yamaji, Paddy & Water Envir., 2009)
    20. 20. PeriodPeriod Mean max.Mean max. temp.temp.00 CC Mean min.Mean min. temp.temp.00 CC No. ofNo. of sunshine hrssunshine hrs 1 – 151 – 15 NovNov 27.727.7 19.219.2 4.94.9 16–3016–30 NovNov 29.629.6 17.917.9 7.57.5 1 – 15 Dec1 – 15 Dec 29.129.1 14.614.6 8.68.6 16–31 Dec16–31 Dec 28.128.1 12.212.2** 8.68.6 Cold resistance in INDIA: Data from an IPM evaluation, ANGRAU, Andhra Pradesh, 2005-06 SeasonSeason Normal (t/ha)Normal (t/ha) SRI (t/ha)SRI (t/ha) Rabi 2005-06Rabi 2005-06 2.252.25 3.473.47 Kharif 2006Kharif 2006 0.21*0.21* 4.164.16 * Low yield was due to cold injury for plants (see above) *Sudden drop in min. temp. during 16–21 Dec. (9.2-9.8o C for 5 days)
    21. 21. Disease and pest incidence in VIETNAM: National IPM Program evaluation: average of data from on-farm trials in 8 provinces, 2005-06: Spring season Summer season SRI Plots Farmer Plots Differ- ence SRI Plots Farmer Plots Differ- ence Sheath blight 6.7% 18.1% 63.0% 5.2% 19.8% 73.7% Leaf blight -- -- -- 8.6% 36.3% 76.5% Small leaf folder * 63.4 107.7 41.1% 61.8 122.3 49.5% Brown plant hopper * 542 1,440 62.4% 545 3,214 83.0% AVERAGE 55.5% 70.7% * Insects/m2
    22. 22. Crop duration in NEPAL (from seed to seed) of different rice varieties with SRI vs. conventional methods (6.3 t/ha vs. 3.1 t/ha) 125 days vs. 141 days=16-day reduction Varieties (N = 412) Conventional duration SRI duration Difference Bansdhan/Kanchhi 145 127 (117-144) 18 (28-11) Mansuli 155 136 (126-146) 19 (29- 9) Swarna 155 139 (126-150) 16 (29- 5) Sugandha 120 106 (98-112) 14 (22- 8) Radha 12 155 138 (125-144) 17 (30-11) Barse 3017 135 118 17 Hardinath 1 120 107 (98-112) 13 (22- 8) Barse 2014 135 127 (116-125) 8 (19-10)
    23. 23. Methane and Nitrous Oxide Emissions from Paddy Rice Fields in Indonesia Comparison of SRI and surrounding conventional fields - SRI Experiment Plots + Farmers Fields Tabo-Tabo Jampue Langunga Penarungan Sungsang Dr. KIMURA Sonoko Dorothea Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology
    24. 24. CH4 Flux Water status at the time of sampling had a greater influence on CH4 flux than did the difference between SRI and conventional methods. However, since SRI fields tend to be drained, CH4 flux tended to be higher in conventional fields. Highest CH4 emission was found during early growing stages with conventional methods. N2O Flux High variability. Unexpected negative flux in some fields. SRI fields tended to emit more N2O than conventional fields -- but the values are in the range found for conventional paddy fields (F.M. Honmachi, 2007 -- total emission 0-0.2 kg N ha-1 ). Conclusion
    25. 25. Highlights of S.R.I. Research in Indonesia Iswandi Anas, D. K. Kalsim, Budi I. Setiawan, Yanuar, and Sam Herodian, Bogor Agricultural University (IPB) Presented at workshop on S.R.I at Ministry of Agriculture, Jakarta, June 13, 2008
    26. 26. METHANE EMISSIONS Initial results reported by IPB Soil Biotechnology Laboratory from GHG studies with SRI management in Indonesia
    27. 27. N2O EMISSIONS
    28. 28. Yan, X., H. Akiyama, K. Yagi and H. Akomoto. ‘Global estimations of the inventory and mitigation potential of methane emissions from rice cultivation conducted using the 2006 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Guidelines.’ Global Biochemical Cycles, (2009) “We estimated that if all of the continuously flooded rice fields were drained at least once during the growing season, the CH4 emissions would be reduced by 4.1 Tg a-1 . Furthermore, we estimated that applying rice straw off-season wherever and whenever possible would result in a further reduction in emissions of 4.1 Tg a-1 globally. … if both of these mitigation options were adopted, the global CH4 emission from rice paddies could be reduced by 7.6 Tg a-1. Although draining continuously flooded rice fields may lead to an increase in nitrous oxide (N2O) emission, the global warming potential resulting from this increase is negligible when compared to the reduction in global warming potential that would result from the CH4 reduction associated with draining the fields.”
    29. 29. Thank you Website: http://sri.ciifad.cornell.edu Email: ntu1@cornell.edu
    1. A particular slide catching your eye?

      Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

    ×