SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
The Issue of Sustainability John E. Harper March 19, 2011
Fiscal conservatism Constitutionally limited government Personal responsibility American Exceptionalism Uncompromising Integrity
Greater duty to be prudent when spending Other People’s Money Limit recurring spending to only what is taken in.  Reduce spending where appropriate. Use savings for one-time critical needs or for investments with assured returns in the future Seek the People’s permission Fiscal Conservatism
High city property tax rate Increased already too high utility fees Spent savings on employee retirement plan Spent savings on office furniture, carpeting, out-of-town retreats, high-end personal computers, more… Reduced city investment in neighborhood streets, roads, alleys, sidewalks, screening walls Lowered level of municipal services, claims more is needed Failed to reduce spending to sustainable levels Recently, another heavy-handed allegiance to rules, regulations Now…where else do you want to cut…or, how much of a tax increase do you support! All of this was approved by the City Council.  Voting record since May 2010:  6 in favor, Mayor against State of the City - Backsliding
The traditional definition of sustainability calls for policies and strategies that meet present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Spending decisions and the time-path of expenditures need to be affordable from a multi-year perspective.  Projected recurring expenditures must not exceed projected recurring revenues Sustainability
6
7
The Rowlett City Employee Retirement Plan is a “Cadillac” plan – Lewis Ward, Consultant hired by the City to defend the status quo, November 30, 2010 “Mayor, you are correct. A new employee earning $35,000 annually could retire with an annual income of $115,400 after 30 years of service at age 57 based on the actuarial method used by TMRS.” – Brian Funderburk, Rowlett CFO, February 26, 2011 City Employee Retirement Plan
Employee pays 7% of salary into TMRS City matches employee 2:1 (14%) Employee can retire at any age after 20 years Automatic cost of living increases presumed Unfunded liability - $51,000 per member TMRS assumes unlikely return on investments TMRS combining reserves; reducing catch-up payments TMRS will not allow two-tier plan to be adopted Legislators considering charges for administration New accounting rules coming to cause greater transparency and accountability to TMRS Texas Municipal Retirement System (TMRS)
Reduction in force (RIF)			$288,000 Cut recurring spending			$379,680 Reduce employee retirement:		 Reduce COLA by 20%			$ 92,945 Eliminate death benefits			$ 36,791  Reduce municipal services			$   XX Increase city property tax			$   XX Total needed:				$2,050,000 Unsustained amount:			$1,540,296 City Manager Response to Call for Reductions in Recurring Spending
The City must reduce expenses to sustainable levels now and into the future Changes made now will be less expensive and less impacting than those made under stress The Special Meeting called to discuss such needs in detail was cancelled without notice There was no public discussion of the spending cuts proposed by the City Manager There are alternatives to laying off employees How can there be no debate? “Mayor Harper unhappy with reductions” – Lakeshore Times
12
Addison,  Mesquite,  Irving,  Garland,  Richardson,  Highland Park, University Park, Flower Mound, Duncanville, Colony, Carrollton, Greenville, and Hurst Likely others in 2010-2011, but City Council blocked me from gaining that information 13 Nearby Cities which have adjusted their Employee Retirement Plan
Grow the commercial tax base  No increase in taxes or fees for operations Maintain current levels of municipal services Reduce recurring expenses to sustainable levels Adopt selected “ad hoc” changes to retirement Spend for operations only what is taken in Continue investments in neighborhood parks, streets, alleys, and sidewalks Adopt long range financial planning (7-10 years) 14 Strategic Financial Management
Councilmembers who have “uncompromising integrity” Core values provide courage to make hard decisions Campaign promises that are kept Open debate – end the manipulation of data Stand with the taxpayer  Voters – oversee elected officials promises What is needed?
Place 1 – Randy Mays, Cindy Rushing, Doug Phillips Place 3 – Patrick Jackson, Ron Miller, Carl Pankratz Place 5 – Chad McEntee, Chris Kilgore With new members there is a better chance for full and open debate, resulting in the economic development Rowlett needs to grow wisely May Election
Do you agree that commercial growth is the key to Rowlett’s economic prosperity? Will you commit to spending no more on daily operations than what is received each year? Will you commit to using reserves only for emergencies and then investments to stimulate the commercial growth in Rowlett? Will you commit to full, open, and honest debate about the difficult decisions necessary to secure the future of Rowlett? Will you commit to not increase taxes or fees for daily operations for the next three years? Questions for Candidates
DrJEHSr@tx.rr.com (214) 284-6972

More Related Content

What's hot (11)

Subnational Financing in Support of the SDGs
Subnational Financing in Support of the SDGsSubnational Financing in Support of the SDGs
Subnational Financing in Support of the SDGs
 
Week 10, budget approval and budget communication
Week 10, budget approval and budget communicationWeek 10, budget approval and budget communication
Week 10, budget approval and budget communication
 
Working Characterising Central Local Government Relationships Since 97
Working Characterising Central Local Government Relationships Since 97Working Characterising Central Local Government Relationships Since 97
Working Characterising Central Local Government Relationships Since 97
 
Income tax basics
Income tax basicsIncome tax basics
Income tax basics
 
Revenue structure decision making
Revenue structure decision makingRevenue structure decision making
Revenue structure decision making
 
Plan for the Gradual Elimination of Property Tax
Plan for the Gradual Elimination of Property TaxPlan for the Gradual Elimination of Property Tax
Plan for the Gradual Elimination of Property Tax
 
How do elections affect the economy
How do elections affect the economyHow do elections affect the economy
How do elections affect the economy
 
ELECTION AFFECT TO ECONOMY
ELECTION AFFECT TO ECONOMYELECTION AFFECT TO ECONOMY
ELECTION AFFECT TO ECONOMY
 
2013-10-31 The New York Non-Profit Revitalization Act
2013-10-31 The New York Non-Profit Revitalization Act2013-10-31 The New York Non-Profit Revitalization Act
2013-10-31 The New York Non-Profit Revitalization Act
 
Is There Life After Sovereign Debt?
Is There Life After Sovereign Debt?Is There Life After Sovereign Debt?
Is There Life After Sovereign Debt?
 
Professional Bio
Professional BioProfessional Bio
Professional Bio
 

Viewers also liked

Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014
Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014
Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014
Tatu Marttila
 
Startupsauna slidedeck
Startupsauna slidedeckStartupsauna slidedeck
Startupsauna slidedeck
tseppala
 
Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...
Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...
Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...
Aalto Media Factory
 
Contemporary sustainability issues in urban areas
Contemporary sustainability issues in urban areasContemporary sustainability issues in urban areas
Contemporary sustainability issues in urban areas
anicholls1234
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014
Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014
Sustainability, design & academia - talk at CS Breakfast 28.3.2014
 
Startupsauna slidedeck
Startupsauna slidedeckStartupsauna slidedeck
Startupsauna slidedeck
 
Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...
Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...
Media Factory: ENMDA - EU Based Quality Management System for the Digital Art...
 
Tallinn uni 110408
Tallinn uni 110408Tallinn uni 110408
Tallinn uni 110408
 
Contemporary sustainability issues in urban areas
Contemporary sustainability issues in urban areasContemporary sustainability issues in urban areas
Contemporary sustainability issues in urban areas
 
FAO at RIO+20 and beyond
FAO at RIO+20 and beyondFAO at RIO+20 and beyond
FAO at RIO+20 and beyond
 

Similar to The issue of sustainability 2011

Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docxDeanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
edwardmarivel
 
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4
Kevin Wren
 
Reform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needsReform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needs
30088
 
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
EmpowerLA
 
Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium
Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium
Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium
Heather L. Carpenter
 
GROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docx
GROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docxGROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docx
GROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docx
shericehewat
 
Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13
Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13 Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13
Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13
Anthony Tanner, CFA
 

Similar to The issue of sustainability 2011 (20)

Generating Municipal Revenue in the New Economy
Generating Municipal Revenue in the New EconomyGenerating Municipal Revenue in the New Economy
Generating Municipal Revenue in the New Economy
 
WKAR Candidate Survey: Jackson Mayor
WKAR Candidate Survey: Jackson MayorWKAR Candidate Survey: Jackson Mayor
WKAR Candidate Survey: Jackson Mayor
 
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docxDeanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
 
NJ Redevelopment Forum 2020 - Fahl
NJ Redevelopment Forum 2020 - FahlNJ Redevelopment Forum 2020 - Fahl
NJ Redevelopment Forum 2020 - Fahl
 
A Buyer's Guide to Economic Impact Analysis
A Buyer's Guide to Economic Impact AnalysisA Buyer's Guide to Economic Impact Analysis
A Buyer's Guide to Economic Impact Analysis
 
DMarshall_Public
DMarshall_PublicDMarshall_Public
DMarshall_Public
 
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt ResponseDawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
Dawn Zimmer Tax Revolt Response
 
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4
Kevin Wren Journal Entry 4
 
Reform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needsReform of the local state and new learning needs
Reform of the local state and new learning needs
 
Engaging Communities For Economic Linked In
Engaging Communities For Economic Linked InEngaging Communities For Economic Linked In
Engaging Communities For Economic Linked In
 
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
 
Improving FDI Fiscal Policies for Equitable Distribution of GVC Gains
Improving FDI Fiscal Policies for Equitable Distribution of GVC GainsImproving FDI Fiscal Policies for Equitable Distribution of GVC Gains
Improving FDI Fiscal Policies for Equitable Distribution of GVC Gains
 
A Blueprint for Smart Cities
A Blueprint for Smart CitiesA Blueprint for Smart Cities
A Blueprint for Smart Cities
 
F5 Linking Economic Development and Social Equity
F5   Linking Economic Development and Social EquityF5   Linking Economic Development and Social Equity
F5 Linking Economic Development and Social Equity
 
Oki Fiam In Apa 10 22 09
Oki Fiam In Apa 10 22 09Oki Fiam In Apa 10 22 09
Oki Fiam In Apa 10 22 09
 
Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium
Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium
Nonprofit Financial Management Practices: A 50 Year Compendium
 
GROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docx
GROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docxGROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docx
GROUP 5Police OutsourcingContracting Police Services.docx
 
Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13
Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13 Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13
Rethinking Muni Interest Deduction 5.17.13
 
Julie luton texas house district 70
Julie luton texas house district 70Julie luton texas house district 70
Julie luton texas house district 70
 
Urban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
Urban Public Finance / Local Public FinanceUrban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
Urban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
 

The issue of sustainability 2011

  • 1. The Issue of Sustainability John E. Harper March 19, 2011
  • 2. Fiscal conservatism Constitutionally limited government Personal responsibility American Exceptionalism Uncompromising Integrity
  • 3. Greater duty to be prudent when spending Other People’s Money Limit recurring spending to only what is taken in. Reduce spending where appropriate. Use savings for one-time critical needs or for investments with assured returns in the future Seek the People’s permission Fiscal Conservatism
  • 4. High city property tax rate Increased already too high utility fees Spent savings on employee retirement plan Spent savings on office furniture, carpeting, out-of-town retreats, high-end personal computers, more… Reduced city investment in neighborhood streets, roads, alleys, sidewalks, screening walls Lowered level of municipal services, claims more is needed Failed to reduce spending to sustainable levels Recently, another heavy-handed allegiance to rules, regulations Now…where else do you want to cut…or, how much of a tax increase do you support! All of this was approved by the City Council. Voting record since May 2010: 6 in favor, Mayor against State of the City - Backsliding
  • 5. The traditional definition of sustainability calls for policies and strategies that meet present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Spending decisions and the time-path of expenditures need to be affordable from a multi-year perspective. Projected recurring expenditures must not exceed projected recurring revenues Sustainability
  • 6. 6
  • 7. 7
  • 8. The Rowlett City Employee Retirement Plan is a “Cadillac” plan – Lewis Ward, Consultant hired by the City to defend the status quo, November 30, 2010 “Mayor, you are correct. A new employee earning $35,000 annually could retire with an annual income of $115,400 after 30 years of service at age 57 based on the actuarial method used by TMRS.” – Brian Funderburk, Rowlett CFO, February 26, 2011 City Employee Retirement Plan
  • 9. Employee pays 7% of salary into TMRS City matches employee 2:1 (14%) Employee can retire at any age after 20 years Automatic cost of living increases presumed Unfunded liability - $51,000 per member TMRS assumes unlikely return on investments TMRS combining reserves; reducing catch-up payments TMRS will not allow two-tier plan to be adopted Legislators considering charges for administration New accounting rules coming to cause greater transparency and accountability to TMRS Texas Municipal Retirement System (TMRS)
  • 10. Reduction in force (RIF) $288,000 Cut recurring spending $379,680 Reduce employee retirement: Reduce COLA by 20% $ 92,945 Eliminate death benefits $ 36,791 Reduce municipal services $ XX Increase city property tax $ XX Total needed: $2,050,000 Unsustained amount: $1,540,296 City Manager Response to Call for Reductions in Recurring Spending
  • 11. The City must reduce expenses to sustainable levels now and into the future Changes made now will be less expensive and less impacting than those made under stress The Special Meeting called to discuss such needs in detail was cancelled without notice There was no public discussion of the spending cuts proposed by the City Manager There are alternatives to laying off employees How can there be no debate? “Mayor Harper unhappy with reductions” – Lakeshore Times
  • 12. 12
  • 13. Addison, Mesquite, Irving, Garland, Richardson, Highland Park, University Park, Flower Mound, Duncanville, Colony, Carrollton, Greenville, and Hurst Likely others in 2010-2011, but City Council blocked me from gaining that information 13 Nearby Cities which have adjusted their Employee Retirement Plan
  • 14. Grow the commercial tax base No increase in taxes or fees for operations Maintain current levels of municipal services Reduce recurring expenses to sustainable levels Adopt selected “ad hoc” changes to retirement Spend for operations only what is taken in Continue investments in neighborhood parks, streets, alleys, and sidewalks Adopt long range financial planning (7-10 years) 14 Strategic Financial Management
  • 15. Councilmembers who have “uncompromising integrity” Core values provide courage to make hard decisions Campaign promises that are kept Open debate – end the manipulation of data Stand with the taxpayer Voters – oversee elected officials promises What is needed?
  • 16. Place 1 – Randy Mays, Cindy Rushing, Doug Phillips Place 3 – Patrick Jackson, Ron Miller, Carl Pankratz Place 5 – Chad McEntee, Chris Kilgore With new members there is a better chance for full and open debate, resulting in the economic development Rowlett needs to grow wisely May Election
  • 17. Do you agree that commercial growth is the key to Rowlett’s economic prosperity? Will you commit to spending no more on daily operations than what is received each year? Will you commit to using reserves only for emergencies and then investments to stimulate the commercial growth in Rowlett? Will you commit to full, open, and honest debate about the difficult decisions necessary to secure the future of Rowlett? Will you commit to not increase taxes or fees for daily operations for the next three years? Questions for Candidates