Toby Turner's eye color is unclear from photographs alone, as they appear brown in some images but blue or grey in others with different lighting. His animated counterpart depicts his eyes as a solid green, providing evidence along with comparisons to other characters' eye colors that Toby's eyes are likely hazel.

1. WHAT COLOR ARE TOBY TURNER’S
EYES?
By Kandia Jackson

2. At first glance
they appear to
be some shade
of BROWN but
this conflicts
with what is
seen in other
photographs

3. However with
certain lighting
his eyes appear
to be a darker
shade of BLUE or
possibly even
Grey

4. HIS ANIMATED COUNTER PART OFFERS
SOME PERSPECTIVE
•Notice Toby’s eyes clearly
depicted as a solid green color
far lighter than Gabuscus

5. ANIMATED TOBY
Here as well where his eyes are clearly distinct from
Santa’s blue eyes as well as Gabe’s dark eyes provide
enough evidence to conclude that…

6. His eyes are in fact….
HAZEL