Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Validation of the Proposed
                       Improvement-trend
                            Technique

               ...
Improvement-trend criterion
                                feedback




                                                 ...
Validation of our technique
                                       feedback




                                       fee...
feedback




        Renaissance Hollywood Hotel
        Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza
        Vagabond Inn
        Elan Ho...
1
                              Proposed technique
                                       1.2
                            ...
Rankings based on proposed
                               technique

 Renaissance Hollywood Hotel                         ...
Calculation of ‘actual’
                                improvement

  Renaissance Hollywood Hotel
  Hyatt Regency, Centur...
Large amount
                                                                 of feedback




         Renaissance Hollywo...
Rankings based on proposed
                               feedback
                                       Feedback average...
For each hotel:

                October 2009    Rank
                                       Average rank
              Se...
‘Rank improvement’
       For each hotel:

         July - October 2009
                Ranking            R4


          ...
Rankings based on ‘Rank
                                 improvement’

 Renaissance Hollywood Hotel                       ...
Ranking comparison
    Based on ‘rank improvement’                 Proposed technique
    (large feedback number)         ...
Thank you!



                                14
Friday, December 11, 2009
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Validation Improvement Trend

243 views

Published on

Published in: Travel
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Validation Improvement Trend

  1. 1. Validation of the Proposed Improvement-trend Technique Presented by: Abhishek Srivastava Department of Computing Science University of Alberta 1 Friday, December 11, 2009
  2. 2. Improvement-trend criterion feedback line fitted using the Ordinary Least Squares technique feedback × × × × × time 2 Friday, December 11, 2009
  3. 3. Validation of our technique feedback feedback × × Hotels in × Los Angeles × × time 3 Friday, December 11, 2009
  4. 4. feedback Renaissance Hollywood Hotel Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza Vagabond Inn Elan Hotel Hollywood City Inn Hollywood Orchid Suites Sofitel Los Angeles Sheraton Universal Hotel Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... Angeleno Hotel 4 Friday, December 11, 2009
  5. 5. 1 Proposed technique 1.2 = 0.833 2 = 1.33 Randomly collected Renaissance Hollywood Hotel 1.5 small number of Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza 2 feedback Vagabond Inn = 2.5 0.8 Elan Hotel Hollywood City Inn {Reliability}α Hollywood Orchid Suites = Available · {W aiting-time}β Af f inity Sofitel Los Angeles Sheraton Universal Hotel HolidayAf fExpress...Hollywood... ·Availablej · Inn inityij = Couplingij {Reliabilityj }α · {Improvement-trendj }γ Angeleno Hotel {W aiting-timej }β feedback × × T ransition-rate = Completion-ratei ∗ Couplingij × × × Length of queue W aiting-time = Completion-rate time 5 Improvement-trend = {Slope of f itted line}∗{M ean f eedback value} Friday, December 11, 2009
  6. 6. Rankings based on proposed technique Renaissance Hollywood Hotel 1. Sofitel Los Angeles 1.5423 Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza 2. Elan Hotel 1.4119 Vagabond Inn Ranked based on 3. Angeleno Hotel 1.3097 calculated Elan Hotel Improvement-trend 4. Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... 1.2503 Hollywood City Inn 5. Hollywood City Inn 1.1707 Hollywood Orchid Suites 6. Vagabond Inn 1.1053 Sofitel Los Angeles 7. Sheraton Universal Hotel 1.0931 Sheraton Universal Hotel 8. Renaissance Hollywood Hotel 1.0871 Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... 9. Hollywood Orchid Suites 0.9739 Angeleno Hotel 10. Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza 0.8815 6 Friday, December 11, 2009
  7. 7. Calculation of ‘actual’ improvement Renaissance Hollywood Hotel Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza Vagabond Inn Elan Hotel Hollywood City Inn Hollywood Orchid Suites Sofitel Los Angeles Sheraton Universal Hotel Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... Angeleno Hotel Large amount of feedback 7 Friday, December 11, 2009
  8. 8. Large amount of feedback Renaissance Hollywood Hotel Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza Vagabond Inn Elan Hotel For each hotel Hollywood City Inn Monthly feedback Hollywood Orchid Suites average Sofitel Los Angeles Sheraton Universal Hotel Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... Angeleno Hotel 8 Friday, December 11, 2009
  9. 9. Rankings based on proposed feedback Feedback average Hotels ranked October 2009 based on feedback September 2009 Hotels ranked Renaissance Hollywood Hotel based on feedback . . Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza . . Vagabond Inn . . Elan Hotel Hollywood City Inn Hotels ranked December 2008 Hollywood Orchid Suites based on feedback Sofitel Los Angeles Sheraton Universal Hotel . . Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... . . Angeleno Hotel . . Hotels ranked July 2008 based on feedback 9 Friday, December 11, 2009
  10. 10. For each hotel: October 2009 Rank Average rank September 2009 Rank July - October 2009 Ranking August 2009 Rank July 2009 Rank . . . March - June 2009 Ranking December 2008 . Oct. `08 - June `09 . Ranking . July 2008 July - October 2008 Ranking 10 Friday, December 11, 2009
  11. 11. ‘Rank improvement’ For each hotel: July - October 2009 Ranking R4 March - June 2009 Ranking R3 Rank improvement = (R1-R2)+ (R2-R3)+ (R3-R4) Oct. `08 - June `09 Ranking R2 July - October 2008 Ranking R1 11 Friday, December 11, 2009
  12. 12. Rankings based on ‘Rank improvement’ Renaissance Hollywood Hotel Vagabond Inn +3 Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza Elan Hotel +2.5 Vagabond Inn Ranked based on Sofitel Los Angeles +1.75 Elan Hotel Rank improvement Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... +1.25 Hollywood City Inn Angeleno Hotel - 0.5 Hollywood Orchid Suites Hollywood Orchid Suites - 0.75 Sofitel Los Angeles Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza - 0.75 Sheraton Universal Hotel Hollywood City Inn - 1.25 Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... Sheraton Universal Hotel -2 Angeleno Hotel Renaissance Hollywood Hotel - 3.25 12 Friday, December 11, 2009
  13. 13. Ranking comparison Based on ‘rank improvement’ Proposed technique (large feedback number) (small feedback number) 1.Vagabond Inn 1. Sofitel Los Angeles 2. Elan Hotel 2. Elan Hotel 3. Sofitel Los Angeles 3. Angeleno Hotel 4. Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... 4. Holiday Inn Express...Hollywood... 5. Angeleno Hotel 5. Hollywood City Inn 6. Hollywood Orchid Suites 6.Vagabond Inn 6. Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza 7. Sheraton Universal Hotel 8. Hollywood City Inn 8. Renaissance Hollywood Hotel 9. Sheraton Universal Hotel 9. Hollywood Orchid Suites 10. Renaissance Hollywood Hotel 10. Hyatt Regency, Century Plaza Average ‘Manhattan’ distance = 2.3 13 Friday, December 11, 2009
  14. 14. Thank you! 14 Friday, December 11, 2009

×