McCormick Group Principal Tim Ward presented to The University of Charleston (WV) School of Business and Leadership's Doctor of Executive Leadership class on May 23, 2016.
Working With an Executive Search Firm: How to Maximize the Benefits as an Employer and Candidate
1. How to Maximize the Benefits
as an Employer and Candidate
Tim Ward, Principal
The McCormick Group
2.
3. Overview of Search Firms
Engaged by companies to recruit,
screen, hire key employees
Manager, director, vice president, and C-
level positions
Fees paid by the hiring company –
never by the candidate hired
Candidate Representation
Act as agent for individual candidates with
specific skill-set in targeted industry
4. Types of Search Firms:
Contingency
Transaction-oriented, focused on mid- to
lower-level positions
Typical Fees: 20-30% of candidate’s first
year compensation
Fee paid only when candidate referred
by search firm is hired
5. Types of Search Firms:
Fully Retained
Engaged on an exclusive basis to fill a
specific executive role
Typical Fees: 30-35% of candidate’s first
year compensation
Three retainer installments
6. Types of Search Firms:
Container/Hybrid
More common with smaller, boutique
firms
Typical Fees: 25-30%
Engagement retainer to secure services
remaining portion of fee contingent on hiring
a candidate referred by search firm
7. Employer Expectations for the
Search Firm
Thoroughly source the
market
Vet candidates up front
Facilitate all
communications
Conduct candidate
reference and
background checks
Manage compensation
negotiations
Facilitate on-boarding
8. Candidate Expectations for the
Search Firm
Ask detailed questions about the
candidate
Facilitate all communications with
prospective employers
Negotiate compensation on behalf of
candidate
Check references and background
Assist with on-boarding and remain
available as a resource once hired
9. Advantages to Working with a
Search Firm: For Companies
Access to passive candidates
Targeted industry focus with
access to broader and deeper
network of qualified candidates
First right of refusal to top
talent (retained search only)
Comprehensive upfront vetting
Better quality candidates
promotes long-term fit
10. Advantages to Working with a
Search Firm: For Candidates
Access to confidential positions
Access to more in-depth (insider) company
info
Professional coaching
Sounding board to assist in making
decision whether to accept or decline
opportunity
Expert to assist with compensation
negotiations
Free service for candidates
11.
12. What’s Hot?
Cybersecurity
Cyber operations
Market is estimated to
grow to $170 billion by
2020 (from $75 billion
today)
Healthcare
Includes Veterans Affairs,
Military Health,
commercial industry
healthcare providers
Projected to grow by
19.5% between now and
2020
13. What’s Hot?
Big Data
How to manage and profit from
it
Storing, securing, making
sense of large quantities of
digital information
Slated to grow to $40 billion in
the next 3 years
Green Building
Projected 3 million jobs in 2016
Expected to generate $303.4
billion in GDP from 2015 to
2018
15. Resume
Feature-oriented vs.
Benefit-oriented
Feature: focuses only on
responsibility
Benefit: focuses on what
you actually accomplished
in measurable terms
Don’t overload with
details about specific
functions
Keep it clear and concise,
focused on
accomplishments
16. Resume
Show progression of increased
responsibility and advancement
Include section highlighting specific
skills/keywords
Active vs. Passive words
2 - 3 pages
17. Interviewing
Prepare, prepare,
prepare
Research company and
each person you will meet
Come armed with good, big
picture questions
When possible, maintain
control of the
conversation
Ask questions, revert back
to relevant skills and
experiences
18. Interviewing
Show high level of interest in company
and opportunity
People hire candidates who want to work for
them
Project yourself in the role/company
Close, close, close
Be proactive at conclusion of interview
19. Recruiters
Be responsive
Timely feedback following
interviews
Provide resume and other
documentation promptly when
requested
Be open and forthright about
compensation, personal
circumstances, etc.
Deal directly with recruiter
only during recruiting
process
Be coachable