SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
ACCEPTANCE
BY – Pooja
Bhattacharjee
and
Mahak Rani
Of
Submitting to :-
Sonia Suman
Ma’am
MEANING
According to the Indian
Contract Act, 1872, Section
2(b), acceptance is expressed
as “When the person to whom
the proposal has been made
signifies his assent thereto,
the offer is said to be
accepted. Thus, the proposal
when accepted becomes a
promise.”
DEFINITIONS :-
EXAMPLE :-
“Can I buy your
car for $1,500?”
“Yes, I accept your
offer to buy my
car for $1,500.”
Essential
s /
Elements
of
Acceptan
ce
1. Acceptance by whom the offer is made or by
authorized agent .
2. Communication of acceptance must be made ,
mere mental resolution to accept is no
acceptance .
3. Communication must be made by reasonable
manner or manner prescribed .
4. Absolute / unqualified must be in terms of
proposal in TOTALITY .
Communicati
on :- When it
reaches ?
Communication of acceptance
in contract is only complete
when the party to whome the
offer is made accepts the same .
OR
An acceptance can only be
communicated by the person to
FELTHOU
SE
V.
BINDLY
[ 1863 ]
Facts:
Paul Felthouse was a builder who lived in London. He wanted to buy a horse from his
nephew
called John Felthouse. Uncle offered to buy a horse from nephew by stating in his written
statement that “if I hear no more about him, I consider the horse mine at £30 15s.” The
nephew,
John did not reply to him and was busy at his farm in Tamworth however he asked his
auctioneer, William Bindley to reserve the horse i.e. not to sell the horse. But by mistake,
the
horse was sold by auctioneer and fetched more money than the uncle offered. Auctioneer
soon
realized his mistake and hence wrote to the uncle apologizing for the error committed. He
also
stated in his writing that “Instructions were given me to reserve the horse ...”. Later
nephew
also wrote to his uncle stating that he was annoyed by the negligence shown by the
auctioneer
as he already told him that the horse was sold. He further also stated that he will try to
recover
the horse from the buyer. Auctioneer was sued for the tort of conversion i.e. to use
someone
else’s property inconsistently with their rights. But to show that the horse belonged to Mr.
Paul
Felthouse he had to prove that it was a valid contract. Whereas Bindley argued that the
nephew
never communicated his acceptance to the offer of buying the horse made by the uncle.
Issue:
This case calls into question whether or not
a valid contract existed between Plaintiff,
Paul
Felthouse and defendant William Bindley.
Additionally this case raises the question of
whether
silence or a failure to reject an offer
amount to acceptance.
Judgement:
It was held that there was no contract for the
horse between the complainant and his nephew.
There had not been an acceptance of the offer;
silence did not amount to acceptance and an
obligation cannot be imposed by another. Any
acceptance of an offer must be communicated
clearly. Although the nephew had intended to
sell the horse to the complainant and showed
this interest, there was no contract of sale.
FELTHOUSE
V.
BINDLY
[ 1863 ]
LALMAN
SUKHLA
V.
GAURI
DUTT
[ 1930 ]
Facts of the case:
In this case the defendant Gauri Dutta Vs. Nephew was absconded
from his house. The trace of the boy was not found. After the
incident Gauri Dutt the defendant send all his servants in search for
her missing nephew and out of the servants was the plaintiff Lalman
Shukla who had also gone to find the boy and bring him back.
After Lalman shukla had left the house and was sent to Haridwar
from Kanpur . He was provided with money and other expenses for
his railway fare. As soon as Lalman Shukla left the house Gauri Dutt
made an announcement that any person who will trace and find his
missing Nephew will be rewarded with money of Rs 501. Lalman
Shukla had no idea and was not aware of the fact . He had no
knowledge about it before he went to trace the missing boy.
Then Lalman shukla traced the boy and brought the boy back to
Kanpur. After knowing about the reward Lalman Shukla claimed the
money from his master Gauri Dutt. But Gauri Dutt denied paying the
reward of Rs 501 to him. As a result the plaintiff Lalman Shukla filed
a case against Gauri Dutt his master for not giving him the reward
as he is not entitled to recover for the performance of his act.
Issues raised in this case:
The main issues which was
raised in this case were as
follows
Whether there exists a
contract or whether the
situation amounts to contract
between the two
Whether Lalman Shukla was
entitled to get the reward from
Gauri Dutt for tracing the
missing boy
Whether there was a valid
acceptance of the offer made
by the plaintiff
Judgement of the case:
In the case of Lalman Shukla verses Gauri
Dutt case the petitioners appeal against the
respondent Gauri Dutt was dismissed by the
court. After analyzing all the facts of the case
It was held by the honorable court that for
creating or entering into a valid contract
there has to be knowledge and assent to the
offer being made by the proposer. There has
to be proper acceptance or the offeree must
give his approval before accepting which was
absent in the present case.
The plaintiff had no knowledge about the
reward before performing his act. He came
to know afterwards in which there is no
possibility of accepting the offer. Hence
there exist no contract so as a result the
court came to the decision that the appellant
Lalman Shukla was not entitled to get the
reward . without having any prior knowledge
and information about the facts which
restricts him to claim the reward.
CONCLUSION
The acceptance of the offer is the
agreement to a request or
proposal. The acceptance can be
oral or written, but it must be
unequivocal and unconditional to
have legal effect. An offer, once
accepted, becomes a binding
contract. For a contract to be
legally binding, both parties must
agree to the terms.
An offer, once accepted, becomes a
THANK
YOU

More Related Content

Similar to What is acceptance? According to the Ind

CHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.ppt
CHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.pptCHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.ppt
CHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.pptMuhammadHasnain415787
 
Offer And Acceptance
Offer And AcceptanceOffer And Acceptance
Offer And Acceptanceshweta verma
 
Offer and-acceptance-aamir
Offer and-acceptance-aamirOffer and-acceptance-aamir
Offer and-acceptance-aamirAhsan Farooq
 
business law case studies with solution
business law case studies with solution business law case studies with solution
business law case studies with solution Yats Bats
 
Introduction to Civil Obligations: Agreements
Introduction to Civil Obligations: AgreementsIntroduction to Civil Obligations: Agreements
Introduction to Civil Obligations: Agreementspaulwhite1983
 
The indian contract act 1872
The indian contract act 1872The indian contract act 1872
The indian contract act 1872rahulmathur
 
BUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid consideration
BUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid considerationBUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid consideration
BUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid considerationjebaselvianitha
 
AIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract Law
AIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract LawAIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract Law
AIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract LawPreeti Sikder
 
21415474 the-indian-contract-act
21415474 the-indian-contract-act21415474 the-indian-contract-act
21415474 the-indian-contract-actDilpreet Chawla
 
the-indian-contract-act-18722.ppt
the-indian-contract-act-18722.pptthe-indian-contract-act-18722.ppt
the-indian-contract-act-18722.pptCHSubhaniGujjar
 
Offer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptx
Offer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptxOffer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptx
Offer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptxRamanSharma846913
 
Presentation on consent
Presentation on consentPresentation on consent
Presentation on consentTanvir Bhatti
 
Legal rules for a valid offer
Legal rules for a valid offerLegal rules for a valid offer
Legal rules for a valid offerabhianvbansal
 
ContractsA contract is based on promises .docx
ContractsA contract is based on promises .docxContractsA contract is based on promises .docx
ContractsA contract is based on promises .docxmaxinesmith73660
 
Indian contract act Notes
Indian contract act NotesIndian contract act Notes
Indian contract act NotesGovt RC College
 
Acceptance in Contract and its Communication
Acceptance in Contract and its CommunicationAcceptance in Contract and its Communication
Acceptance in Contract and its CommunicationPreeti Sikder
 

Similar to What is acceptance? According to the Ind (20)

CHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.ppt
CHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.pptCHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.ppt
CHP#2 Offer and Acceptance Business Law.ppt
 
What is contract
What is contractWhat is contract
What is contract
 
Offer And Acceptance
Offer And AcceptanceOffer And Acceptance
Offer And Acceptance
 
Offer and-acceptance-aamir
Offer and-acceptance-aamirOffer and-acceptance-aamir
Offer and-acceptance-aamir
 
business law case studies with solution
business law case studies with solution business law case studies with solution
business law case studies with solution
 
Introduction to Civil Obligations: Agreements
Introduction to Civil Obligations: AgreementsIntroduction to Civil Obligations: Agreements
Introduction to Civil Obligations: Agreements
 
The indian contract act 1872
The indian contract act 1872The indian contract act 1872
The indian contract act 1872
 
BUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid consideration
BUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid considerationBUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid consideration
BUSINESS LAW (COM/CME 2655)Essential and legal rules for valid consideration
 
AIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract Law
AIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract LawAIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract Law
AIS 2102 Acceptance in Contract Law
 
21415474 the-indian-contract-act
21415474 the-indian-contract-act21415474 the-indian-contract-act
21415474 the-indian-contract-act
 
the-indian-contract-act-18722.ppt
the-indian-contract-act-18722.pptthe-indian-contract-act-18722.ppt
the-indian-contract-act-18722.ppt
 
Indian contract act 1872
Indian contract act 1872Indian contract act 1872
Indian contract act 1872
 
Offer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptx
Offer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptxOffer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptx
Offer and Acceptance and Consideration.pptx
 
Presentation on consent
Presentation on consentPresentation on consent
Presentation on consent
 
Legal rules for a valid offer
Legal rules for a valid offerLegal rules for a valid offer
Legal rules for a valid offer
 
1.Offer
1.Offer1.Offer
1.Offer
 
ContractsA contract is based on promises .docx
ContractsA contract is based on promises .docxContractsA contract is based on promises .docx
ContractsA contract is based on promises .docx
 
Indian contract act Notes
Indian contract act NotesIndian contract act Notes
Indian contract act Notes
 
GROUP_6.pptx
GROUP_6.pptxGROUP_6.pptx
GROUP_6.pptx
 
Acceptance in Contract and its Communication
Acceptance in Contract and its CommunicationAcceptance in Contract and its Communication
Acceptance in Contract and its Communication
 

Recently uploaded

CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptxCASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptxMUKUL TYAGI
 
Streamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal Services
Streamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal ServicesStreamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal Services
Streamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal ServicesEternity Paralegal Services
 
Law of succession-Notes for students studying law
Law of succession-Notes for students studying lawLaw of succession-Notes for students studying law
Law of succession-Notes for students studying lawMANGAUNGUSDGQUARTERL
 
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;bhavenpr
 
(Hamad khadam ) ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docx
(Hamad khadam )   ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docx(Hamad khadam )   ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docx
(Hamad khadam ) ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docxlibiwo274
 
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...Sehrish Saba
 
HOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASES
HOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASESHOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASES
HOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASESMesnik Law Group,Inc.
 
Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[
Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[
Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[bhavenpr
 
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...Nilendra Kumar
 
一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制
一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制
一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制afukemk
 
Embed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekp
Embed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekpEmbed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekp
Embed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekpbhavenpr
 
Embed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoi
Embed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoiEmbed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoi
Embed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoibhavenpr
 
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptxTermination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptxBrV
 
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of DisclaimersBad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of DisclaimersMike Keyes
 
Petitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docx
Petitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docxPetitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docx
Petitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docxRumantSharma
 
posts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdf
posts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdfposts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdf
posts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdfbhavenpr
 
Embed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopo
Embed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopoEmbed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopo
Embed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopobhavenpr
 
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[kAsif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[kbhavenpr
 
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx PresentationTTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx PresentationRRR Chambers
 

Recently uploaded (20)

CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptxCASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
 
Streamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal Services
Streamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal ServicesStreamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal Services
Streamline Legal Operations: A Guide to Paralegal Services
 
Law of succession-Notes for students studying law
Law of succession-Notes for students studying lawLaw of succession-Notes for students studying law
Law of succession-Notes for students studying law
 
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
 
(Hamad khadam ) ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docx
(Hamad khadam )   ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docx(Hamad khadam )   ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docx
(Hamad khadam ) ENGLISH LEGAL 2.0.docx
 
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
 
HOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASES
HOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASESHOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASES
HOW LAW FIRMS CAN SUPPORT MILITARY DIVORCE CASES
 
Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[
Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[
Embed-2-2.pdf[[app[r[prf[-rk;lme;[ed[prp[
 
Trending Topics in ITC Litigation with Knobbe Martens
Trending Topics in ITC Litigation with Knobbe MartensTrending Topics in ITC Litigation with Knobbe Martens
Trending Topics in ITC Litigation with Knobbe Martens
 
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
 
一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制
一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制
一比一原版美国加州大学戴维斯分校毕业证(ucd毕业证书)学位证书仿制
 
Embed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekp
Embed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekpEmbed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekp
Embed-4-2.pdf vk[di-[sd[0edKP[p-[kedkpodekp
 
Embed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoi
Embed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoiEmbed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoi
Embed-1-1.pdfohediooieoiehohoiefoloeohefoi
 
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptxTermination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
 
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of DisclaimersBad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
 
Petitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docx
Petitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docxPetitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docx
Petitioner Moot Memorial including Charges and Argument Advanced.docx
 
posts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdf
posts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdfposts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdf
posts-harmful-to-secular-structure-of-the-country-539103-1.pdf
 
Embed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopo
Embed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopoEmbed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopo
Embed-6 (1).pdfc p;p;kdk[odk[drskpokpopo
 
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[kAsif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
 
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx PresentationTTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
 

What is acceptance? According to the Ind

  • 1.
  • 2. ACCEPTANCE BY – Pooja Bhattacharjee and Mahak Rani Of Submitting to :- Sonia Suman Ma’am
  • 3. MEANING According to the Indian Contract Act, 1872, Section 2(b), acceptance is expressed as “When the person to whom the proposal has been made signifies his assent thereto, the offer is said to be accepted. Thus, the proposal when accepted becomes a promise.”
  • 5. EXAMPLE :- “Can I buy your car for $1,500?” “Yes, I accept your offer to buy my car for $1,500.”
  • 6. Essential s / Elements of Acceptan ce 1. Acceptance by whom the offer is made or by authorized agent . 2. Communication of acceptance must be made , mere mental resolution to accept is no acceptance . 3. Communication must be made by reasonable manner or manner prescribed . 4. Absolute / unqualified must be in terms of proposal in TOTALITY .
  • 7. Communicati on :- When it reaches ? Communication of acceptance in contract is only complete when the party to whome the offer is made accepts the same . OR An acceptance can only be communicated by the person to
  • 8. FELTHOU SE V. BINDLY [ 1863 ] Facts: Paul Felthouse was a builder who lived in London. He wanted to buy a horse from his nephew called John Felthouse. Uncle offered to buy a horse from nephew by stating in his written statement that “if I hear no more about him, I consider the horse mine at £30 15s.” The nephew, John did not reply to him and was busy at his farm in Tamworth however he asked his auctioneer, William Bindley to reserve the horse i.e. not to sell the horse. But by mistake, the horse was sold by auctioneer and fetched more money than the uncle offered. Auctioneer soon realized his mistake and hence wrote to the uncle apologizing for the error committed. He also stated in his writing that “Instructions were given me to reserve the horse ...”. Later nephew also wrote to his uncle stating that he was annoyed by the negligence shown by the auctioneer as he already told him that the horse was sold. He further also stated that he will try to recover the horse from the buyer. Auctioneer was sued for the tort of conversion i.e. to use someone else’s property inconsistently with their rights. But to show that the horse belonged to Mr. Paul Felthouse he had to prove that it was a valid contract. Whereas Bindley argued that the nephew never communicated his acceptance to the offer of buying the horse made by the uncle.
  • 9. Issue: This case calls into question whether or not a valid contract existed between Plaintiff, Paul Felthouse and defendant William Bindley. Additionally this case raises the question of whether silence or a failure to reject an offer amount to acceptance. Judgement: It was held that there was no contract for the horse between the complainant and his nephew. There had not been an acceptance of the offer; silence did not amount to acceptance and an obligation cannot be imposed by another. Any acceptance of an offer must be communicated clearly. Although the nephew had intended to sell the horse to the complainant and showed this interest, there was no contract of sale. FELTHOUSE V. BINDLY [ 1863 ]
  • 10. LALMAN SUKHLA V. GAURI DUTT [ 1930 ] Facts of the case: In this case the defendant Gauri Dutta Vs. Nephew was absconded from his house. The trace of the boy was not found. After the incident Gauri Dutt the defendant send all his servants in search for her missing nephew and out of the servants was the plaintiff Lalman Shukla who had also gone to find the boy and bring him back. After Lalman shukla had left the house and was sent to Haridwar from Kanpur . He was provided with money and other expenses for his railway fare. As soon as Lalman Shukla left the house Gauri Dutt made an announcement that any person who will trace and find his missing Nephew will be rewarded with money of Rs 501. Lalman Shukla had no idea and was not aware of the fact . He had no knowledge about it before he went to trace the missing boy. Then Lalman shukla traced the boy and brought the boy back to Kanpur. After knowing about the reward Lalman Shukla claimed the money from his master Gauri Dutt. But Gauri Dutt denied paying the reward of Rs 501 to him. As a result the plaintiff Lalman Shukla filed a case against Gauri Dutt his master for not giving him the reward as he is not entitled to recover for the performance of his act.
  • 11. Issues raised in this case: The main issues which was raised in this case were as follows Whether there exists a contract or whether the situation amounts to contract between the two Whether Lalman Shukla was entitled to get the reward from Gauri Dutt for tracing the missing boy Whether there was a valid acceptance of the offer made by the plaintiff
  • 12. Judgement of the case: In the case of Lalman Shukla verses Gauri Dutt case the petitioners appeal against the respondent Gauri Dutt was dismissed by the court. After analyzing all the facts of the case It was held by the honorable court that for creating or entering into a valid contract there has to be knowledge and assent to the offer being made by the proposer. There has to be proper acceptance or the offeree must give his approval before accepting which was absent in the present case. The plaintiff had no knowledge about the reward before performing his act. He came to know afterwards in which there is no possibility of accepting the offer. Hence there exist no contract so as a result the court came to the decision that the appellant Lalman Shukla was not entitled to get the reward . without having any prior knowledge and information about the facts which restricts him to claim the reward.
  • 13. CONCLUSION The acceptance of the offer is the agreement to a request or proposal. The acceptance can be oral or written, but it must be unequivocal and unconditional to have legal effect. An offer, once accepted, becomes a binding contract. For a contract to be legally binding, both parties must agree to the terms. An offer, once accepted, becomes a