Theorist                Idea                               Example
Firth 1988              To give the audience the           Bow wow ft Ciara – Like you
                        experience of an in concert
                        performance. The Males are         Cassie – Official Girl
                        often presented to be the
                        dominant one and the females
                        follow on from what the males
                        do. Love story is most popular
                        within this theory. Conceptual –
                        metaphors to create a mood.
Steve Archer (2004)     Music videos will cut between a    Cassie – Long way to go
                        narrative and a performance of
                        the song by the artist. A
                        choreographed dance might be       Cherish – Do it do it
                        present in the video. The artist
                        will be a part of the story,
                        acting as a narrator and
                        participant at the same time.
                        Lip synching close up and
                        miming of playing instruments
                        that remains at the heart of
                        music videos.

Andrew Goodwin (1992)   Images provide a literal           Rihanna – Rehab
                        representation. The theory also
                        includes of repetition of key      M.I.A – Bad girls
                        meanings and effects to
                        manipulate the audience. The
                        images contrast with the music
                        and the meaning of the song is
                        completely ignored. The music
                        video tends to frame the star.
Vladimir Propp          A set of stock characters that     Ray J – One wish
                        reappear in each music video.
                        The rules include of:

                                Hero: person on the
                                quest
                                Princess- Prize for the
                                Hero
                                Helper – helps the hero
                                on the quest.
                                False hero – Somebody
                                who believes they are
                                the hero.
                                Dispatcher – Sends the
                                hero on their quest
                                Father- Rewards the
                                hero
                                Villian- Attempts to
                                stop the hero on his
quest
                                       Donor- Provides objects
                                       to help the hero on his
                                       quest.

Levi-Strauss                 In every media text there are       AvrilLavigne – Girlfriend
                             binary oppositions, or a conflict
                             between two opposites. The          Beyonce – If I were a boy
                             audience know who they would
                             side with. Examples:
                                     Good and bad
                                     Rich and poor
                                     Eastern and Western
                                     World
                                     Love and Hate
Roland Barthes                       The enigma code:            Chris Brown – She aint you
                                     Audience interested by
                                     the need to solve a         Rihanna – Love the way you lie
                                     problem.
                                     Action Code: Audience
                                     gain excitement with
                                     resolving a problem.
                                     Semantic code –
                                     Audience make
                                     assumptions that a
                                     person dressed in black
                                     is evil.
                                     Cultural code – The
                                     audience derives the
                                     meaning in a text from
                                     shared cultural
                                     knowledge about the
                                     way the world works.
Todorov                      There are 5 stages in this          Basshunter - Now you gone
                             theory.
                                     Original Equilibrium        Basshunter – All I ever wanted
                                     Disruption
                                     Recognition
                                     Attempt to restore
                                     original equilibrium
                                     New equilibrium.
John Berger ‘Ways of Seeing’ Dance tracks may just have          Rihanna – Rude Boy
                             pulsating abstract visuals which
                             follow the beat with no visual      T Pain Ft Chris Brown - Freeze
                             reference to human agency.

Theorist 1

  • 1.
    Theorist Idea Example Firth 1988 To give the audience the Bow wow ft Ciara – Like you experience of an in concert performance. The Males are Cassie – Official Girl often presented to be the dominant one and the females follow on from what the males do. Love story is most popular within this theory. Conceptual – metaphors to create a mood. Steve Archer (2004) Music videos will cut between a Cassie – Long way to go narrative and a performance of the song by the artist. A choreographed dance might be Cherish – Do it do it present in the video. The artist will be a part of the story, acting as a narrator and participant at the same time. Lip synching close up and miming of playing instruments that remains at the heart of music videos. Andrew Goodwin (1992) Images provide a literal Rihanna – Rehab representation. The theory also includes of repetition of key M.I.A – Bad girls meanings and effects to manipulate the audience. The images contrast with the music and the meaning of the song is completely ignored. The music video tends to frame the star. Vladimir Propp A set of stock characters that Ray J – One wish reappear in each music video. The rules include of: Hero: person on the quest Princess- Prize for the Hero Helper – helps the hero on the quest. False hero – Somebody who believes they are the hero. Dispatcher – Sends the hero on their quest Father- Rewards the hero Villian- Attempts to stop the hero on his
  • 2.
    quest Donor- Provides objects to help the hero on his quest. Levi-Strauss In every media text there are AvrilLavigne – Girlfriend binary oppositions, or a conflict between two opposites. The Beyonce – If I were a boy audience know who they would side with. Examples: Good and bad Rich and poor Eastern and Western World Love and Hate Roland Barthes The enigma code: Chris Brown – She aint you Audience interested by the need to solve a Rihanna – Love the way you lie problem. Action Code: Audience gain excitement with resolving a problem. Semantic code – Audience make assumptions that a person dressed in black is evil. Cultural code – The audience derives the meaning in a text from shared cultural knowledge about the way the world works. Todorov There are 5 stages in this Basshunter - Now you gone theory. Original Equilibrium Basshunter – All I ever wanted Disruption Recognition Attempt to restore original equilibrium New equilibrium. John Berger ‘Ways of Seeing’ Dance tracks may just have Rihanna – Rude Boy pulsating abstract visuals which follow the beat with no visual T Pain Ft Chris Brown - Freeze reference to human agency.