SlideShare a Scribd company logo
HaroldSowards
CJ 322, Tu/Th 9:30
9/17/15
State v. Loge
608 N.W. 2d 152 (Minn. 2000)
1. Facts
 StevenMark Loge borrowshisdad’spickupon Sept.2,1997
 Is stoppedby2 AlbertLeaCityPO @ 8:15 PMfor speeding
 Duringthe stop,one of the POs seesabeer bottle stickingoutof a brownpaperbag
underthe passengerseat,itwasretrieved,whichresultsinafull searchof the truck.
Thisresultsinthe findingof 1 full unopenedcanand1 emptycan
 Loge passesall standardfieldsobrietytestsstill givena citationforviolatingMinn.Stat.
169.122, Subd.3 (1998)
 Trial court says that undersubd.3, he had “absolute liability”andissentencedto5 days
injail,executionstayed,placedonprobationfor1 yr, fined$150 and$32.50
 Stevenappeals
 The Court of Appealsaffirmsthe trial courtsstatingthatknowledge of the bottle inthe
truck isn’trequiredtosustainaconviction
 Grantedpetitionforfurtherreview,the AttorneyGeneral isgivenresponsibilityandhe
arguesthat there isno knowledgerequirementundersubd.3
 Decisionisaffirmed
2. Issue
Is the meaningof Statute 169.122 clearand free fromall ambiguity?
Is knowledgeanecessaryelementof the opencontaineroffense?
3. Holdings
No
No
4. Reasoning
Theystate that Minn. Stat.169.122 subd.3 establishesliabilityforthe driverwhenthatdriver
“keepsorallowstobe kept”anyopenbottle containingintoxicatingliquorwithinthe area
normallyoccupiedbythe driverandpassengers.Sincethese twoconceptsare separatedbythe
disjunctive“or”,theyusedtheirpreviousholdingsthatsince there isanabsence of some
ambiguitysurroundingthe legislature’suse of the word“or”, theyread that the disjunctive
requiredonlyone of the possiblefactual situationsbe presentinorderforthat statute tobe
satisfied.Theylimitedtheiropinionstothe word“to keep”.If knowledge wasrequiredthan
there wouldbe difficultyindeterminingproof,sotheythoughtthe legislature decidedthata
proof of knowledgeundersubd.3wasn’tnecessaryinordertoprotectsociety. Since Steven
tookcontrol of the truck, theydecidedthathe tookcontrol overall the contentsof the truck
whichincludedthe openbottles.

More Related Content

What's hot

State v. snowden
State v. snowdenState v. snowden
State v. snowden
Harold Sowards
 
Duest v. state
Duest v. stateDuest v. state
Duest v. state
Harold Sowards
 
State v. stark
State v. starkState v. stark
State v. stark
Harold Sowards
 
Sonnier v. state
Sonnier v. stateSonnier v. state
Sonnier v. state
Harold Sowards
 
Us v. maze
Us v. mazeUs v. maze
Us v. maze
Harold Sowards
 
George lee mims, sr. v. us
George lee mims, sr. v. usGeorge lee mims, sr. v. us
George lee mims, sr. v. us
Harold Sowards
 
King v. cogden
King v. cogdenKing v. cogden
King v. cogden
Harold Sowards
 
State v. hoying
State v. hoyingState v. hoying
State v. hoying
Harold Sowards
 
Commonwealth v. mitchell
Commonwealth v. mitchellCommonwealth v. mitchell
Commonwealth v. mitchell
Harold Sowards
 
Commonwealth v. schnopps
Commonwealth v. schnoppsCommonwealth v. schnopps
Commonwealth v. schnopps
Harold Sowards
 
People v. allen
People v. allenPeople v. allen
People v. allen
Harold Sowards
 
State v. jantzi
State v. jantziState v. jantzi
State v. jantzi
Harold Sowards
 
State v. ninham
State v. ninhamState v. ninham
State v. ninham
Harold Sowards
 
Jewell v. state
Jewell v. stateJewell v. state
Jewell v. state
Harold Sowards
 
State v. zeta chi fraternity
State v. zeta chi fraternityState v. zeta chi fraternity
State v. zeta chi fraternity
Harold Sowards
 
C ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby siders
C ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby sidersC ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby siders
C ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby siders
Harold Sowards
 
Ted bundy
Ted bundyTed bundy
Ted bundy
BashayerTariq
 
Torts cases and_material
Torts cases and_materialTorts cases and_material
Torts cases and_material
FAROUQ
 
Legal Memorandum
Legal MemorandumLegal Memorandum
Legal MemorandumDean Goff
 

What's hot (20)

State v. snowden
State v. snowdenState v. snowden
State v. snowden
 
Duest v. state
Duest v. stateDuest v. state
Duest v. state
 
State v. stark
State v. starkState v. stark
State v. stark
 
Sonnier v. state
Sonnier v. stateSonnier v. state
Sonnier v. state
 
Us v. maze
Us v. mazeUs v. maze
Us v. maze
 
George lee mims, sr. v. us
George lee mims, sr. v. usGeorge lee mims, sr. v. us
George lee mims, sr. v. us
 
King v. cogden
King v. cogdenKing v. cogden
King v. cogden
 
State v. hoying
State v. hoyingState v. hoying
State v. hoying
 
Commonwealth v. mitchell
Commonwealth v. mitchellCommonwealth v. mitchell
Commonwealth v. mitchell
 
Commonwealth v. schnopps
Commonwealth v. schnoppsCommonwealth v. schnopps
Commonwealth v. schnopps
 
People v. allen
People v. allenPeople v. allen
People v. allen
 
State v. jantzi
State v. jantziState v. jantzi
State v. jantzi
 
State v. ninham
State v. ninhamState v. ninham
State v. ninham
 
Jewell v. state
Jewell v. stateJewell v. state
Jewell v. state
 
State v. zeta chi fraternity
State v. zeta chi fraternityState v. zeta chi fraternity
State v. zeta chi fraternity
 
C ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby siders
C ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby sidersC ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby siders
C ity of saint paul v. east side boys and selby siders
 
Ted bundy
Ted bundyTed bundy
Ted bundy
 
Adv. Legal R & W- memo
Adv. Legal R & W- memoAdv. Legal R & W- memo
Adv. Legal R & W- memo
 
Torts cases and_material
Torts cases and_materialTorts cases and_material
Torts cases and_material
 
Legal Memorandum
Legal MemorandumLegal Memorandum
Legal Memorandum
 

More from Harold Sowards

Dive heart project
Dive heart projectDive heart project
Dive heart project
Harold Sowards
 
Pseudo family violence
Pseudo family violencePseudo family violence
Pseudo family violence
Harold Sowards
 
Pseudofamilyviolence sowards
Pseudofamilyviolence sowardsPseudofamilyviolence sowards
Pseudofamilyviolence sowards
Harold Sowards
 
Sowards 440exam
Sowards 440examSowards 440exam
Sowards 440exam
Harold Sowards
 
Rape review
Rape reviewRape review
Rape review
Harold Sowards
 
Movie review
Movie reviewMovie review
Movie review
Harold Sowards
 
Line of duty review
Line of duty reviewLine of duty review
Line of duty review
Harold Sowards
 
Us v. garcia
Us v. garciaUs v. garcia
Us v. garcia
Harold Sowards
 
Us v. ancheta
Us v. anchetaUs v. ancheta
Us v. ancheta
Harold Sowards
 
State v. tomaino
State v. tomainoState v. tomaino
State v. tomaino
Harold Sowards
 
State v. sexton
State v. sextonState v. sexton
State v. sexton
Harold Sowards
 
State v. schleifer
State v. schleiferState v. schleifer
State v. schleifer
Harold Sowards
 
State v. metzger
State v. metzgerState v. metzger
State v. metzger
Harold Sowards
 
State v. mays
State v. maysState v. mays
State v. mays
Harold Sowards
 
State v. kimball
State v. kimballState v. kimball
State v. kimball
Harold Sowards
 
State v. chaney
State v. chaneyState v. chaney
State v. chaney
Harold Sowards
 
State v. akers
State v. akersState v. akers
State v. akers
Harold Sowards
 
State in the interest of m.t.s.
State in the interest of m.t.s.State in the interest of m.t.s.
State in the interest of m.t.s.
Harold Sowards
 
Remsburg v. docusearch inc
Remsburg v. docusearch incRemsburg v. docusearch inc
Remsburg v. docusearch inc
Harold Sowards
 

More from Harold Sowards (19)

Dive heart project
Dive heart projectDive heart project
Dive heart project
 
Pseudo family violence
Pseudo family violencePseudo family violence
Pseudo family violence
 
Pseudofamilyviolence sowards
Pseudofamilyviolence sowardsPseudofamilyviolence sowards
Pseudofamilyviolence sowards
 
Sowards 440exam
Sowards 440examSowards 440exam
Sowards 440exam
 
Rape review
Rape reviewRape review
Rape review
 
Movie review
Movie reviewMovie review
Movie review
 
Line of duty review
Line of duty reviewLine of duty review
Line of duty review
 
Us v. garcia
Us v. garciaUs v. garcia
Us v. garcia
 
Us v. ancheta
Us v. anchetaUs v. ancheta
Us v. ancheta
 
State v. tomaino
State v. tomainoState v. tomaino
State v. tomaino
 
State v. sexton
State v. sextonState v. sexton
State v. sexton
 
State v. schleifer
State v. schleiferState v. schleifer
State v. schleifer
 
State v. metzger
State v. metzgerState v. metzger
State v. metzger
 
State v. mays
State v. maysState v. mays
State v. mays
 
State v. kimball
State v. kimballState v. kimball
State v. kimball
 
State v. chaney
State v. chaneyState v. chaney
State v. chaney
 
State v. akers
State v. akersState v. akers
State v. akers
 
State in the interest of m.t.s.
State in the interest of m.t.s.State in the interest of m.t.s.
State in the interest of m.t.s.
 
Remsburg v. docusearch inc
Remsburg v. docusearch incRemsburg v. docusearch inc
Remsburg v. docusearch inc
 

Recently uploaded

How to Obtain Permanent Residency in the Netherlands
How to Obtain Permanent Residency in the NetherlandsHow to Obtain Permanent Residency in the Netherlands
How to Obtain Permanent Residency in the Netherlands
BridgeWest.eu
 
ASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptx
ASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptxASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptx
ASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptx
shweeta209
 
定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
9ib5wiwt
 
Notes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.doc
Notes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.docNotes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.doc
Notes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.doc
BRELGOSIMAT
 
1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样
1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样
1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样
9ib5wiwt
 
RIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptx
RIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptxRIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptx
RIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptx
OmGod1
 
The Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot Citizenship
The Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot CitizenshipThe Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot Citizenship
The Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot Citizenship
BridgeWest.eu
 
ALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdf
ALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdfALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdf
ALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdf
46adnanshahzad
 
EMPLOYMENT LAW AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptx
EMPLOYMENT LAW  AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptxEMPLOYMENT LAW  AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptx
EMPLOYMENT LAW AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptx
MwaiMapemba
 
Donald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdf
Donald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdfDonald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdf
Donald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdf
ssuser5750e1
 
Military Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense Counsel
Military Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense CounselMilitary Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense Counsel
Military Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense Counsel
Thomas (Tom) Jasper
 
VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...
VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...
VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...
Dr. Oliver Massmann
 
Introducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdf
Introducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdfIntroducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdf
Introducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdf
AHRP Law Firm
 
NATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptx
NATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptxNATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptx
NATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptx
anvithaav
 
Abdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal Court
Abdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal CourtAbdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal Court
Abdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal Court
Gabe Whitley
 
PRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptx
PRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptxPRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptx
PRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptx
OmGod1
 
DNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptx
DNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptxDNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptx
DNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptx
patrons legal
 
Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.
Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.
Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.
Purushottam Jha
 
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...
Finlaw Consultancy Pvt Ltd
 
Agrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quiz
Agrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quizAgrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quiz
Agrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quiz
gaelcabigunda
 

Recently uploaded (20)

How to Obtain Permanent Residency in the Netherlands
How to Obtain Permanent Residency in the NetherlandsHow to Obtain Permanent Residency in the Netherlands
How to Obtain Permanent Residency in the Netherlands
 
ASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptx
ASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptxASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptx
ASHWINI KUMAR UPADHYAY v/s Union of India.pptx
 
定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
定制(nus毕业证书)新加坡国立大学毕业证学位证书实拍图原版一模一样
 
Notes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.doc
Notes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.docNotes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.doc
Notes-on-Prescription-Obligations-and-Contracts.doc
 
1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样
1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样
1比1制作(swansea毕业证书)英国斯旺西大学毕业证学位证书托业成绩单原版一模一样
 
RIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptx
RIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptxRIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptx
RIGHTS OF VICTIM EDITED PRESENTATION(SAIF JAVED).pptx
 
The Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot Citizenship
The Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot CitizenshipThe Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot Citizenship
The Main Procedures for Obtaining Cypriot Citizenship
 
ALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdf
ALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdfALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdf
ALL EYES ON RAFAH BUT WHY Explain more.pdf
 
EMPLOYMENT LAW AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptx
EMPLOYMENT LAW  AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptxEMPLOYMENT LAW  AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptx
EMPLOYMENT LAW AN OVERVIEW in Malawi.pptx
 
Donald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdf
Donald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdfDonald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdf
Donald_J_Trump_katigoritirio_stormi_daniels.pdf
 
Military Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense Counsel
Military Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense CounselMilitary Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense Counsel
Military Commissions details LtCol Thomas Jasper as Detailed Defense Counsel
 
VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...
VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...
VIETNAM - DIRECT POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS (DPPA) - Latest development - What...
 
Introducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdf
Introducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdfIntroducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdf
Introducing New Government Regulation on Toll Road.pdf
 
NATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptx
NATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptxNATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptx
NATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptx
 
Abdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal Court
Abdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal CourtAbdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal Court
Abdul Hakim Shabazz Deposition Hearing in Federal Court
 
PRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptx
PRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptxPRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptx
PRECEDENT AS A SOURCE OF LAW (SAIF JAVED).pptx
 
DNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptx
DNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptxDNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptx
DNA Testing in Civil and Criminal Matters.pptx
 
Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.
Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.
Law Commission Report. Commercial Court Act.
 
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...
 
Agrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quiz
Agrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quizAgrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quiz
Agrarian Reform Policies in the Philippines: a quiz
 

State v. loge

  • 1. HaroldSowards CJ 322, Tu/Th 9:30 9/17/15 State v. Loge 608 N.W. 2d 152 (Minn. 2000) 1. Facts  StevenMark Loge borrowshisdad’spickupon Sept.2,1997  Is stoppedby2 AlbertLeaCityPO @ 8:15 PMfor speeding  Duringthe stop,one of the POs seesabeer bottle stickingoutof a brownpaperbag underthe passengerseat,itwasretrieved,whichresultsinafull searchof the truck. Thisresultsinthe findingof 1 full unopenedcanand1 emptycan  Loge passesall standardfieldsobrietytestsstill givena citationforviolatingMinn.Stat. 169.122, Subd.3 (1998)  Trial court says that undersubd.3, he had “absolute liability”andissentencedto5 days injail,executionstayed,placedonprobationfor1 yr, fined$150 and$32.50  Stevenappeals  The Court of Appealsaffirmsthe trial courtsstatingthatknowledge of the bottle inthe truck isn’trequiredtosustainaconviction  Grantedpetitionforfurtherreview,the AttorneyGeneral isgivenresponsibilityandhe arguesthat there isno knowledgerequirementundersubd.3  Decisionisaffirmed 2. Issue Is the meaningof Statute 169.122 clearand free fromall ambiguity? Is knowledgeanecessaryelementof the opencontaineroffense? 3. Holdings No No 4. Reasoning Theystate that Minn. Stat.169.122 subd.3 establishesliabilityforthe driverwhenthatdriver “keepsorallowstobe kept”anyopenbottle containingintoxicatingliquorwithinthe area normallyoccupiedbythe driverandpassengers.Sincethese twoconceptsare separatedbythe disjunctive“or”,theyusedtheirpreviousholdingsthatsince there isanabsence of some ambiguitysurroundingthe legislature’suse of the word“or”, theyread that the disjunctive requiredonlyone of the possiblefactual situationsbe presentinorderforthat statute tobe satisfied.Theylimitedtheiropinionstothe word“to keep”.If knowledge wasrequiredthan there wouldbe difficultyindeterminingproof,sotheythoughtthe legislature decidedthata proof of knowledgeundersubd.3wasn’tnecessaryinordertoprotectsociety. Since Steven
  • 2. tookcontrol of the truck, theydecidedthathe tookcontrol overall the contentsof the truck whichincludedthe openbottles.