Welcome!
Please take a moment to reflect on the
following question
“Why do you work at The Women’s
Center?”
Write your answer on the piece on the
index card.
I do hope to share a few anonymously.

We will get started in a few minutes!
“No Bad WomeN
Just Bad LaWs”
harm reduction basics for abortion
providers working with women in
the sex industry
Presentation by: Lindsay Roth, Project SAFE
with support from Kahn Miller, Project SAFE and the Sex
Workers Outreach Projects of NYC and Philadelphia
THIS IS A SAFE SPACE
S o me g u i d e l i n e s

• Confidentiality: What’s shared here stays here,
what’s learned here leaves here.
• One Mic
• Make Room, Make Noise
• Ouch/Oops
• If you don’t know - ask!
• Speak from the “I”
• Avoid assumptions
• Please do not record this presentation. (The
slide show with bibliography and notes will be
made available)
A big thanks to SWOP- NYC/SWANK for sharing their guidelines with us!
Objectives
• Explain the mission of Project Safe
• Promote critical discussion sex work
• Answer questions about risks associated with
sex work
• For audience members to gain an
understanding of harm reduction theory and
how it can be applied to a variety of settings,
especially when working with “vulnerable
populations”
• Consider possible interventions at the
women’s center
Who We Are,
What We Do
• All volunteer, grassroots harm reduction group for
working women in north Philly
Kensington:
• One of the poorest neighborhoods in Philadelphia
with prominent open air markets for heroin,
powder and rock cocaine, street-based sex trade
• HIV/AIDS rate for zip codes 19125 and 19134
some of the highest in the city. City wide
Philadelphia has HIV/AIDS rate three times higher
than the national average.
This Includes…
• Late Night Street Outreach
• Bad Date Alerts
• Home Deliveries
• Case Management
• Health & Safety Tips
• Overdose Response Training
• Rape and Assault Referrals
• Women Identified-Only Drop-In
• Bilingual Services
The Women's Centers:
What do you do?
Why do you do it?
Why does it matter?
So what do the terms:

Mean to you?
Who Is A Sex Worker?
•
•
•
•
•

Webcam
Escort/Independent
Profession Dom
Profession Sub
Stripper/ Exotic
Dancer
• Outdoor Worker
• Pornographic
Performer
More Examples of Sex Work
• Prostitution
•
• Escorting
•
• Indoor and Outdoor •
work
•
• Webcam work
•
• Professional
•
domination
• Professional
submission
•
• Sugar daddy/mommy
situations
•
• Survival sex

Phone sex
Pornography
Erotic Modeling
Fetish work
Working at a club
Owning a
club/brothel/venue/w
ebsite
Stripping/Dancing/
Burlesque
What you say it is!
What is Sex Work?
sexual acts performed in exchange for money,
food, housing, substances, security, or anything of
necessity or value. People engaging in sex work
can be of any age, race, gender, nationality,
sexuality, or class, and enter the trade through
choice, coercion, or circumstance.
What is Work?
Work is the opposite of Leisure and
something we may prefer not to do, but get
paid for.
(Keith Grint, The Sociology of Work)
Sex Work: some terms
•
•
•
•

sex work
sex trade(s)
survival sex
"choice, circumstance or coercion”

(Also, honoring a sex worker's language,
when speaking about sex worker(s).)
Continuum of Risk
Not OK for Anyone, Ever (In the History of
Ever)
OK for Some (Over There, Far Away)
Fine , But not Preferred Practice
Good for Others, Not Good for Me
Good for Others and Good for Me

What is “risk?” What are our
own anxieties or discomforts?
How do these things in flux?
Street-Level Sex Work
• Cis-Women, Trans-Women, Cis-Men/ All Ethnicities/ All Ages
• Some have “pimps/madams” some have “boyfriends,” some
are on their own, others use a buddy system.

Some Benefits:
•
•
•
•

People work within a community
There is a network of help/social services
There is mobility
There is a flexible schedule, ideal for mothers, people with
disabilities, people with other jobs, etc.
• “Open Air Drug Market” promotes a community of safe users
who take the time to get clean works or clean their works.
Also, an OD is acknowledged and addressed.
Disadvantages
– Stigma/Shame apparent due to lack of privacy
– Supply/Demand – low wages, lack of solidarity
– The Screening Process:
• Women have about 2 seconds to get a date because
– The is always some one willing to do it for
cheaper/faster/whatever
– They don’t want to be seen
– They need money
– Cops will arrest them for Loitering

– Dates happen in: Cars, Rented rooms, Abandos,
Parking lots, Vacant lots, Clients homes
– There are no safety precautions, these men are
complete strangers. Occasionally there are
“regulars”
– Men go to street walkers because they know just
What is Harm Reduction?
• A public health theory addressing
behaviors that carry risk.
• We all do things we know are bad for us,
and only the individual can decide what
measures to take to mitigate harm
• Those who engage in these behaviors
should have a leading voice in any
organization or program they utilize
Stages of Change
Harm Reduction:
There is a rainbow of options
between chaos or abstinence
Screening
Clients

Safe Sex

Staying sober
during dates

Seeing only
Regulars

Oral Only
WHAT CAN WE DO HERE?
• Safety Planning in case of Arrest
– Plan for kids, pets, legal representation
– Check out Plan, Don’t Panic @
www.redlightchicago.org
• Budgeting
– Help women develop a finical plan or connect them
with someone who can
• Check out a PROS Network
– PROS [Providing Resources and Services to
Individuals Involved in the Sex Trade] is a network of
sex workers, direct service providers, legal, medical
and mental health professionals, advocates and
organizers.
A Note about Exploitation, Coercion
and Trafficking
•

•

•

You can screen for exploitation and coercion: it is a violation of worker’s
rights
Many women may not report abuses because of very valid and real fears:
– It is an intimate partner or family member
– They fear the police/fbi/immigration authorities
– They fear retribution
– They have been traumatized by both their oppressor and/or systems of
oppression
DO NOT violate their trust again. But let them know there are services to
help them:
– National Human Trafficking Hotline 1-888-373-7888
– Text BeFree (233733)
– The National Domestic Violence Hotline 1-800-799-7233
– Child Line or relevant statewide agency
Appearance

•
•
•

Wear shoes you can run in
Avoid scarves necklace and bags that can be used to hold or choke you
War clothing that can be left on during sex in case you have to run away

Negotiation

•
•
•
•
•

Stick to a price list and time limit
Pick your own parking spot our hotel
Have a supply of condoms and lube
Get money up front
Use the same stroll/ places you are familiar with

The Car

•
•
•
•
•
•

Approach from the driver’s side
Arrange services and locations while outside car
Circle the car looking for other passengers
Take down the license plate or pretend to do it
Do not fasten the seatbelt
Wave goodbye to someone and shout the time of your return – or pretend to

Oral Sex

•
•
•

Learn to put a condom on with your mouth
At ejaculation, keep pressure on condo with your lips to prevent leakage
Gargle with mouthwash or liquor afterwards, but do not bursh your teeth

Vaginal Sex

•
•
•
•
•
•

Keep area well lubricated with water-soluble lubricant
Use birth control
Do not douche or use vaginal-drying substances
Position yourself on top, facing customer
Keep hand on base of penis to keep it hard and avoid spillage
After ejaculation, remove penis from vagina immediately

Anal Sex

•
•
•

Try to avoid this act by charging so much customers cant afford it – it has greater risks
Use extra lubricant
Use female condoms

SelfDefense

•
•
•
•
•
•

Do NOT carry weapons
Use your voice and speed (eg scream, hit car horn)
Attack body areas that are easily injured (eg, throat, eyes, testicles, shins)
Run away against tract, towards lights and people
Work with friends
Tell work makes about bad costumers
Create a SAFE Space
• Area or forum where a marginalized
group is free of standard
stereotypes, discrimination, and
tactics of silencing
• Physically safe: free of law
enforcement/other institutions,
potential clients and assault
• There are guidelines: “trolling” should
what not to do
• Don’t offer advice
unless asked but DO
recognize behavior
change that comes from
within
• Don’t assume a singular
identity; don’t generalize
• Don’t try to do it all at
once; the small things
count
• Don’t exploit the space
or the participants
• Don’t undervalue the
lack of trust in social
services and police
Other Resources
• Persist Health Project NYC
• St. James Infirmary (San Francisco)
• SWOP-USA (especially SWOP-NYC, SWOP-Chicago’s
websites)
• www.stripperweb.com
• The Sex Workers Project NYC (good legal resource)
• VANDU, Nothing About Us Without Us
• Young Women’s Empowerment Project (Chicago),
Girls Do What They Have To Do To Survive:
Illuminating Methods used by Girls in the Sex Trade
and Street Economy to Fight Back and Heal
• Youth United for Change (Phila), Pushed Out: Youth
Voices on the Drop-Out Crisis in Philadelphia
Applications at the Women’s
Centers
• Get into groups
• Discuss how TWC can better serve women
in the sex industry
• Use the worksheet as a guideline
• Be ready to share!
Thank You!
Please stay in touch
Lindsay Roth
443-370-7626
215-701-9398
lindsay.a.roth@gmail.com

For Abortion Providers: How to work with individuals in the sex trade

  • 1.
    Welcome! Please take amoment to reflect on the following question “Why do you work at The Women’s Center?” Write your answer on the piece on the index card. I do hope to share a few anonymously. We will get started in a few minutes!
  • 2.
    “No Bad WomeN JustBad LaWs” harm reduction basics for abortion providers working with women in the sex industry Presentation by: Lindsay Roth, Project SAFE with support from Kahn Miller, Project SAFE and the Sex Workers Outreach Projects of NYC and Philadelphia
  • 3.
    THIS IS ASAFE SPACE S o me g u i d e l i n e s • Confidentiality: What’s shared here stays here, what’s learned here leaves here. • One Mic • Make Room, Make Noise • Ouch/Oops • If you don’t know - ask! • Speak from the “I” • Avoid assumptions • Please do not record this presentation. (The slide show with bibliography and notes will be made available) A big thanks to SWOP- NYC/SWANK for sharing their guidelines with us!
  • 4.
    Objectives • Explain themission of Project Safe • Promote critical discussion sex work • Answer questions about risks associated with sex work • For audience members to gain an understanding of harm reduction theory and how it can be applied to a variety of settings, especially when working with “vulnerable populations” • Consider possible interventions at the women’s center
  • 5.
    Who We Are, WhatWe Do • All volunteer, grassroots harm reduction group for working women in north Philly Kensington: • One of the poorest neighborhoods in Philadelphia with prominent open air markets for heroin, powder and rock cocaine, street-based sex trade • HIV/AIDS rate for zip codes 19125 and 19134 some of the highest in the city. City wide Philadelphia has HIV/AIDS rate three times higher than the national average.
  • 6.
    This Includes… • LateNight Street Outreach • Bad Date Alerts • Home Deliveries • Case Management • Health & Safety Tips • Overdose Response Training • Rape and Assault Referrals • Women Identified-Only Drop-In • Bilingual Services
  • 7.
    The Women's Centers: Whatdo you do? Why do you do it? Why does it matter?
  • 8.
    So what dothe terms: Mean to you?
  • 9.
    Who Is ASex Worker? • • • • • Webcam Escort/Independent Profession Dom Profession Sub Stripper/ Exotic Dancer • Outdoor Worker • Pornographic Performer
  • 10.
    More Examples ofSex Work • Prostitution • • Escorting • • Indoor and Outdoor • work • • Webcam work • • Professional • domination • Professional submission • • Sugar daddy/mommy situations • • Survival sex Phone sex Pornography Erotic Modeling Fetish work Working at a club Owning a club/brothel/venue/w ebsite Stripping/Dancing/ Burlesque What you say it is!
  • 11.
    What is SexWork? sexual acts performed in exchange for money, food, housing, substances, security, or anything of necessity or value. People engaging in sex work can be of any age, race, gender, nationality, sexuality, or class, and enter the trade through choice, coercion, or circumstance.
  • 12.
    What is Work? Workis the opposite of Leisure and something we may prefer not to do, but get paid for. (Keith Grint, The Sociology of Work)
  • 13.
    Sex Work: someterms • • • • sex work sex trade(s) survival sex "choice, circumstance or coercion” (Also, honoring a sex worker's language, when speaking about sex worker(s).)
  • 14.
    Continuum of Risk NotOK for Anyone, Ever (In the History of Ever) OK for Some (Over There, Far Away) Fine , But not Preferred Practice Good for Others, Not Good for Me Good for Others and Good for Me What is “risk?” What are our own anxieties or discomforts? How do these things in flux?
  • 15.
    Street-Level Sex Work •Cis-Women, Trans-Women, Cis-Men/ All Ethnicities/ All Ages • Some have “pimps/madams” some have “boyfriends,” some are on their own, others use a buddy system. Some Benefits: • • • • People work within a community There is a network of help/social services There is mobility There is a flexible schedule, ideal for mothers, people with disabilities, people with other jobs, etc. • “Open Air Drug Market” promotes a community of safe users who take the time to get clean works or clean their works. Also, an OD is acknowledged and addressed.
  • 16.
    Disadvantages – Stigma/Shame apparentdue to lack of privacy – Supply/Demand – low wages, lack of solidarity – The Screening Process: • Women have about 2 seconds to get a date because – The is always some one willing to do it for cheaper/faster/whatever – They don’t want to be seen – They need money – Cops will arrest them for Loitering – Dates happen in: Cars, Rented rooms, Abandos, Parking lots, Vacant lots, Clients homes – There are no safety precautions, these men are complete strangers. Occasionally there are “regulars” – Men go to street walkers because they know just
  • 17.
    What is HarmReduction? • A public health theory addressing behaviors that carry risk. • We all do things we know are bad for us, and only the individual can decide what measures to take to mitigate harm • Those who engage in these behaviors should have a leading voice in any organization or program they utilize
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Harm Reduction: There isa rainbow of options between chaos or abstinence Screening Clients Safe Sex Staying sober during dates Seeing only Regulars Oral Only
  • 20.
    WHAT CAN WEDO HERE? • Safety Planning in case of Arrest – Plan for kids, pets, legal representation – Check out Plan, Don’t Panic @ www.redlightchicago.org • Budgeting – Help women develop a finical plan or connect them with someone who can • Check out a PROS Network – PROS [Providing Resources and Services to Individuals Involved in the Sex Trade] is a network of sex workers, direct service providers, legal, medical and mental health professionals, advocates and organizers.
  • 21.
    A Note aboutExploitation, Coercion and Trafficking • • • You can screen for exploitation and coercion: it is a violation of worker’s rights Many women may not report abuses because of very valid and real fears: – It is an intimate partner or family member – They fear the police/fbi/immigration authorities – They fear retribution – They have been traumatized by both their oppressor and/or systems of oppression DO NOT violate their trust again. But let them know there are services to help them: – National Human Trafficking Hotline 1-888-373-7888 – Text BeFree (233733) – The National Domestic Violence Hotline 1-800-799-7233 – Child Line or relevant statewide agency
  • 22.
    Appearance • • • Wear shoes youcan run in Avoid scarves necklace and bags that can be used to hold or choke you War clothing that can be left on during sex in case you have to run away Negotiation • • • • • Stick to a price list and time limit Pick your own parking spot our hotel Have a supply of condoms and lube Get money up front Use the same stroll/ places you are familiar with The Car • • • • • • Approach from the driver’s side Arrange services and locations while outside car Circle the car looking for other passengers Take down the license plate or pretend to do it Do not fasten the seatbelt Wave goodbye to someone and shout the time of your return – or pretend to Oral Sex • • • Learn to put a condom on with your mouth At ejaculation, keep pressure on condo with your lips to prevent leakage Gargle with mouthwash or liquor afterwards, but do not bursh your teeth Vaginal Sex • • • • • • Keep area well lubricated with water-soluble lubricant Use birth control Do not douche or use vaginal-drying substances Position yourself on top, facing customer Keep hand on base of penis to keep it hard and avoid spillage After ejaculation, remove penis from vagina immediately Anal Sex • • • Try to avoid this act by charging so much customers cant afford it – it has greater risks Use extra lubricant Use female condoms SelfDefense • • • • • • Do NOT carry weapons Use your voice and speed (eg scream, hit car horn) Attack body areas that are easily injured (eg, throat, eyes, testicles, shins) Run away against tract, towards lights and people Work with friends Tell work makes about bad costumers
  • 23.
    Create a SAFESpace • Area or forum where a marginalized group is free of standard stereotypes, discrimination, and tactics of silencing • Physically safe: free of law enforcement/other institutions, potential clients and assault • There are guidelines: “trolling” should
  • 24.
    what not todo • Don’t offer advice unless asked but DO recognize behavior change that comes from within • Don’t assume a singular identity; don’t generalize • Don’t try to do it all at once; the small things count • Don’t exploit the space or the participants • Don’t undervalue the lack of trust in social services and police
  • 25.
    Other Resources • PersistHealth Project NYC • St. James Infirmary (San Francisco) • SWOP-USA (especially SWOP-NYC, SWOP-Chicago’s websites) • www.stripperweb.com • The Sex Workers Project NYC (good legal resource) • VANDU, Nothing About Us Without Us • Young Women’s Empowerment Project (Chicago), Girls Do What They Have To Do To Survive: Illuminating Methods used by Girls in the Sex Trade and Street Economy to Fight Back and Heal • Youth United for Change (Phila), Pushed Out: Youth Voices on the Drop-Out Crisis in Philadelphia
  • 26.
    Applications at theWomen’s Centers • Get into groups • Discuss how TWC can better serve women in the sex industry • Use the worksheet as a guideline • Be ready to share!
  • 27.
    Thank You! Please stayin touch Lindsay Roth 443-370-7626 215-701-9398 lindsay.a.roth@gmail.com

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Introduce myself, project safe
  • #8 Review missions
  • #11 Varied amongst class and community. Various levels of risk
  • #13 GO OVER WHY WE THINK OF IT IN THIS FRAME WORK
  • #15  have everyone come in and do a quick exericise. There will be things listed and you are to reflect on them.Eating MeatSmoking MarijuanaDriving above the speed limitInjection DrugsOral sex with out a condomHaving sex in exchange for a place to stayHaving sex for money
  • #17 It is triggering. It is hard to date smart while you are high!QUESTIONS
  • #20 A scale of chaotic dating to seeing only regulars
  • #22 Call with consent and let them know you are calling
  • #23 Adapted from “sex work and harm reduction by Michael L Rekart”