SlideShare a Scribd company logo
www.organathonfoundation.org
ORGAN DONATION – OPTIONS
1.“opt in” or “ explicit consent”
2.“opt out” or “presumed consent”
3.“mandated choice”
References:
• Making it easier to register as an organ donor - The New York Times sep, 26 2009
• Give Life.org.nz
• Bulletin of the WHO – organ donation, presumed consent and allocation priority
• Driving licence applicants asked to join organ donor register | Society | The Guardian, 2011
• Impact of an opt out system for organ donation in the UK
(http://www.nhsbt.nhs.uk/to2020/resources/Thepotentialimpactofanoptoutsystemfororgandonationinthe
UK.pdf)
www.organathonfoundation.org
“opt in” or “ explicit consent”
Steven P. Jobs, Apple’s chief executive, received a liver transplant from the
victim of a car crash and suggested “opt in” option in iPhone, Social
Networking e.g., Facebook, Linkedin etc.
Disadvantages of “opt in” option
 Low percentage of acceptability ~ 10% to 15%
 No Incentivization vis-à-vis with “opt out” option
 Fear of richer get preference ?
 Only few countries opt for this option
www.organathonfoundation.org
“opt out” or “presumed consent
Advantages
 Most countries across the world adopt this option
 Acceptability rate is more than 90% and varies from country to country
 This option is either hard or soft- Despite being consented by the person relatives were also involved
and this form the basis of hard/soft option:-
 Incentivization of donor in case they need a organ during there lifetime OR some kind of rebate in the
Insurance sector of the pledged donor.
Note:
1. The allocation of the harvested organs is regulated by the central Government
2. 43 States of the US have a law that families cannot over – rule a donors’ wishes
Disadvantages
 Fear of the fact that health – care professional would let registered donor die to harvest there
organs – a myth
 Many refuses on the ground of there religions – a myth
 Fear of reincarnation – a myth
TO CLEAR ALL MYTHS AND FACTS PLEASE VISIT – www.organthonfoundation.org –myths/FAQs
section on the home page
Soft opt out Hard opt out
The views of relatives are saught and they can
refused the consent (Spain, NZ)
The views of relatives are not taken into the
account and they can’t refused consent (Austria,
Belzium, Sweden)
www.organathonfoundation.org
“mandated choice”
Advantages
Note:
1. The allocation of the harvested organs is regulated by the central Government
2. 43 States of the US have a law that families cannot over – rule a donors’ wishes
 A wining combination and may achieve a higher rate of donation
than presumed consent
 In the Driver License – Do you wish to be a organ donor ?
 High rate of donor sign up rate according to donate life Illinois
 In this taking permission from relatives of the donor is optional
 In nut shell Signing up to be an organ donor should be at least as easy
downloading any song to your Phone
Disadvantages
 India being a multi - linguistic with many religions – a real task to
convince all – please see our website for details related to all the aspects
irrespective of cast, creed or religion
www.organathonfoundation.org
ORGAN DONATION – OPTIONS
www.organathonfoundation.org
ORGAN DONATION – OPTIONS
Different consent
systems and
donation rates
www.organathonfoundation.org
Participants’ stance on opt out before and after the public
deliberative events
ORGAN DONATION – OPTIONS
www.organathonfoundation.org
“We need to bring it into the national
curriculum, perhaps as part of
personal and social education issues. I
think if we get children thinking
about it when they are young, then at
least they will have an opinion on it.”
(recipient family)
OPT OUT OPTION IN
THE DRIVING LICENSE Thanking You…

More Related Content

What's hot

Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools
Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools
Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools
Beckie Francis
 
Charter Schools
Charter SchoolsCharter Schools
Charter Schools
athomp27
 
Vhse required-docs
Vhse required-docsVhse required-docs
Vhse required-docs
Virtualhse
 
Charter Schools CI405
Charter Schools CI405Charter Schools CI405
Charter Schools CI405
athomp27
 
Refusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common Core
Refusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common CoreRefusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common Core
Refusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common Core
Lauren Lee Fischer
 
Psa Family Awareness
Psa Family AwarenessPsa Family Awareness
Psa Family Awareness
Reina Connolly
 
SaveUpNotSpendDown100611
SaveUpNotSpendDown100611SaveUpNotSpendDown100611
SaveUpNotSpendDown100611
Elizabeth Paulhus
 
Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013
Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013
Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013
Patrick Groves
 
Eld2 ppt ch02.revised
Eld2 ppt ch02.revisedEld2 ppt ch02.revised
Eld2 ppt ch02.revised
JFTantia
 
Charter Schoolsslide
Charter SchoolsslideCharter Schoolsslide
Charter Schoolsslide
athomp27
 
International grants for non government organizations
International grants for non government organizationsInternational grants for non government organizations
International grants for non government organizations
mortgagecalculator01
 
Summary of voluntary health case
Summary of voluntary health caseSummary of voluntary health case
Summary of voluntary health case
Sonia Taran Ahuja
 
3 14 12
3 14 123 14 12
3 14 12
wpwebsite
 
Undue Influence Infographic
Undue Influence Infographic Undue Influence Infographic
Undue Influence Infographic
Mark Hackard
 
Ethics
EthicsEthics
Ethics
Mirah Riben
 
Attorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5K
Attorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5KAttorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5K
Attorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5K
Jeff Weissman | Attorney
 
2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators
2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators
2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators
Lisa Dickson
 
American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...
American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...
American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...
Floyd Arthur
 
Better health for a better society
Better health for a better societyBetter health for a better society
Better health for a better society
tohyaoru
 

What's hot (19)

Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools
Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools
Erin’s Law Addresses Issues of Child Abuse in Schools
 
Charter Schools
Charter SchoolsCharter Schools
Charter Schools
 
Vhse required-docs
Vhse required-docsVhse required-docs
Vhse required-docs
 
Charter Schools CI405
Charter Schools CI405Charter Schools CI405
Charter Schools CI405
 
Refusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common Core
Refusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common CoreRefusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common Core
Refusing to Conform_ Arizona becomes the 10th State to Reject Common Core
 
Psa Family Awareness
Psa Family AwarenessPsa Family Awareness
Psa Family Awareness
 
SaveUpNotSpendDown100611
SaveUpNotSpendDown100611SaveUpNotSpendDown100611
SaveUpNotSpendDown100611
 
Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013
Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013
Students seek more state tuition help - Spokesman.com - Feb. 19, 2013
 
Eld2 ppt ch02.revised
Eld2 ppt ch02.revisedEld2 ppt ch02.revised
Eld2 ppt ch02.revised
 
Charter Schoolsslide
Charter SchoolsslideCharter Schoolsslide
Charter Schoolsslide
 
International grants for non government organizations
International grants for non government organizationsInternational grants for non government organizations
International grants for non government organizations
 
Summary of voluntary health case
Summary of voluntary health caseSummary of voluntary health case
Summary of voluntary health case
 
3 14 12
3 14 123 14 12
3 14 12
 
Undue Influence Infographic
Undue Influence Infographic Undue Influence Infographic
Undue Influence Infographic
 
Ethics
EthicsEthics
Ethics
 
Attorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5K
Attorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5KAttorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5K
Attorney Jeff Weissman Leads Firm in 2015 SAFEWALK-RUN 5K
 
2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators
2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators
2021 Training of Ohio Financial Aid Administrators
 
American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...
American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...
American academy of pediatrics issues statement on controversial HB2 by Floyd...
 
Better health for a better society
Better health for a better societyBetter health for a better society
Better health for a better society
 

Viewers also liked

Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society
Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society
Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society
Dr Hirman Ismail
 
Resonancia Presentacion
Resonancia PresentacionResonancia Presentacion
Resonancia Presentacion
guestd317606
 
Backdropsource
BackdropsourceBackdropsource
Backdropsource
Ansel Adams
 
Hawaii activity free listing
Hawaii activity free listingHawaii activity free listing
Hawaii activity free listing
mauivacationsaver232
 
Tugas wahyu
Tugas wahyuTugas wahyu
Tugas wahyu
SriRomadhani
 
Articulo de las elecciones presidenciales
Articulo de las elecciones presidencialesArticulo de las elecciones presidenciales
Articulo de las elecciones presidenciales
StevenDuk
 
Act 4 Circuitos Serie Y Paralelo
Act 4 Circuitos Serie Y ParaleloAct 4 Circuitos Serie Y Paralelo
Act 4 Circuitos Serie Y Paralelo
guestce655bf
 
Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK)
Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK) Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK)
Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK)
lipendik
 
Protocolo
ProtocoloProtocolo
Protocolo
sedruol
 
Diseño de Clase
Diseño de ClaseDiseño de Clase
Diseño de Clase
DIANA IDALIT ORTIZ PINEDA
 
피터 슈라이어
피터 슈라이어피터 슈라이어
피터 슈라이어
jeehwan
 
Boles nadal2013
Boles nadal2013Boles nadal2013
Boles nadal2013
jordi
 
Sección de contenido
Sección de contenidoSección de contenido
лекции
лекциилекции
лекции
idiyatulin
 
Boletin laboriosidad
Boletin   laboriosidadBoletin   laboriosidad
Boletin laboriosidad
lizethiturriago
 
Capitulo iii
Capitulo iiiCapitulo iii
Capitulo iii
sedruol
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society
Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society
Optingin vs opting out - Malaysian Thoracic Society
 
Resonancia Presentacion
Resonancia PresentacionResonancia Presentacion
Resonancia Presentacion
 
Backdropsource
BackdropsourceBackdropsource
Backdropsource
 
Hawaii activity free listing
Hawaii activity free listingHawaii activity free listing
Hawaii activity free listing
 
Tugas wahyu
Tugas wahyuTugas wahyu
Tugas wahyu
 
Articulo de las elecciones presidenciales
Articulo de las elecciones presidencialesArticulo de las elecciones presidenciales
Articulo de las elecciones presidenciales
 
Act 4 Circuitos Serie Y Paralelo
Act 4 Circuitos Serie Y ParaleloAct 4 Circuitos Serie Y Paralelo
Act 4 Circuitos Serie Y Paralelo
 
Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK)
Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK) Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK)
Materi Diklat Jurnalistik Lingkar Pena dan Jurnalistik (LIPENDIK)
 
Protocolo
ProtocoloProtocolo
Protocolo
 
Diseño de Clase
Diseño de ClaseDiseño de Clase
Diseño de Clase
 
피터 슈라이어
피터 슈라이어피터 슈라이어
피터 슈라이어
 
Boles nadal2013
Boles nadal2013Boles nadal2013
Boles nadal2013
 
Sección de contenido
Sección de contenidoSección de contenido
Sección de contenido
 
лекции
лекциилекции
лекции
 
Boletin laboriosidad
Boletin   laboriosidadBoletin   laboriosidad
Boletin laboriosidad
 
Capitulo iii
Capitulo iiiCapitulo iii
Capitulo iii
 

Similar to Opt-out-DL (4)

Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
Jessica Mahon
 
Shashwat organ-donation
Shashwat organ-donationShashwat organ-donation
Shashwat organ-donation
Shashwat-India
 
Transplant nov 13
Transplant nov 13Transplant nov 13
Transplant nov 13
Fusionspark Media, Inc.
 
Organ donation promotion activity
Organ donation promotion activityOrgan donation promotion activity
Organ donation promotion activity
Jeevan Jyoti Blood Bank
 
Organ Donation
Organ DonationOrgan Donation
Organ Donation
nagpurrotary
 
Why becoming an organ donor
Why becoming an organ donorWhy becoming an organ donor
Why becoming an organ donor
jenny10940
 
Organ TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docx
Organ TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docxOrgan TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docx
Organ TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docx
gerardkortney
 
How to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity Organizations
How to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity OrganizationsHow to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity Organizations
How to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity Organizations
Hearing Aid Associates
 
Consumer Behavior Towards Organ Donation
Consumer Behavior Towards Organ DonationConsumer Behavior Towards Organ Donation
Consumer Behavior Towards Organ Donation
Skalla Marketing
 
Show Us Your Heart Introduction
Show Us Your Heart IntroductionShow Us Your Heart Introduction
Show Us Your Heart Introduction
jtislerics
 
Incentives to-increase-kidney-donation
Incentives to-increase-kidney-donationIncentives to-increase-kidney-donation
Incentives to-increase-kidney-donation
Jake Solomon
 
Free online health resources 11 30-12
Free online health resources 11 30-12Free online health resources 11 30-12
Free online health resources 11 30-12
evardell
 
Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...
Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...
Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...AryanJawaharPrasadMa
 
Organ donation laws
Organ donation lawsOrgan donation laws
Organ donation laws
KhyatiTongia
 
Free Online Health Resources
Free Online Health ResourcesFree Online Health Resources
Free Online Health Resources
evardell
 
Organ Donation
Organ DonationOrgan Donation
Organ Donation
brendahuls
 
Gift of Life Michigan
Gift of Life MichiganGift of Life Michigan
Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)
Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)
Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)
Mary Howrey
 
1intro
1intro1intro
1intro
Eugene Hugho
 
Essay On My Study Room
Essay On My Study RoomEssay On My Study Room
Essay On My Study Room
Ana Hall
 

Similar to Opt-out-DL (4) (20)

Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
Shashwat organ-donation
Shashwat organ-donationShashwat organ-donation
Shashwat organ-donation
 
Transplant nov 13
Transplant nov 13Transplant nov 13
Transplant nov 13
 
Organ donation promotion activity
Organ donation promotion activityOrgan donation promotion activity
Organ donation promotion activity
 
Organ Donation
Organ DonationOrgan Donation
Organ Donation
 
Why becoming an organ donor
Why becoming an organ donorWhy becoming an organ donor
Why becoming an organ donor
 
Organ TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docx
Organ TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docxOrgan TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docx
Organ TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docx
 
How to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity Organizations
How to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity OrganizationsHow to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity Organizations
How to Become a Part of the Biggest Hearing Health Charity Organizations
 
Consumer Behavior Towards Organ Donation
Consumer Behavior Towards Organ DonationConsumer Behavior Towards Organ Donation
Consumer Behavior Towards Organ Donation
 
Show Us Your Heart Introduction
Show Us Your Heart IntroductionShow Us Your Heart Introduction
Show Us Your Heart Introduction
 
Incentives to-increase-kidney-donation
Incentives to-increase-kidney-donationIncentives to-increase-kidney-donation
Incentives to-increase-kidney-donation
 
Free online health resources 11 30-12
Free online health resources 11 30-12Free online health resources 11 30-12
Free online health resources 11 30-12
 
Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...
Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...
Trafficking of human beings for the purpose of organ removal problems and cha...
 
Organ donation laws
Organ donation lawsOrgan donation laws
Organ donation laws
 
Free Online Health Resources
Free Online Health ResourcesFree Online Health Resources
Free Online Health Resources
 
Organ Donation
Organ DonationOrgan Donation
Organ Donation
 
Gift of Life Michigan
Gift of Life MichiganGift of Life Michigan
Gift of Life Michigan
 
Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)
Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)
Building a Circle of Care 11_12_2016 (Final)
 
1intro
1intro1intro
1intro
 
Essay On My Study Room
Essay On My Study RoomEssay On My Study Room
Essay On My Study Room
 

Opt-out-DL (4)

  • 1. www.organathonfoundation.org ORGAN DONATION – OPTIONS 1.“opt in” or “ explicit consent” 2.“opt out” or “presumed consent” 3.“mandated choice” References: • Making it easier to register as an organ donor - The New York Times sep, 26 2009 • Give Life.org.nz • Bulletin of the WHO – organ donation, presumed consent and allocation priority • Driving licence applicants asked to join organ donor register | Society | The Guardian, 2011 • Impact of an opt out system for organ donation in the UK (http://www.nhsbt.nhs.uk/to2020/resources/Thepotentialimpactofanoptoutsystemfororgandonationinthe UK.pdf)
  • 2. www.organathonfoundation.org “opt in” or “ explicit consent” Steven P. Jobs, Apple’s chief executive, received a liver transplant from the victim of a car crash and suggested “opt in” option in iPhone, Social Networking e.g., Facebook, Linkedin etc. Disadvantages of “opt in” option  Low percentage of acceptability ~ 10% to 15%  No Incentivization vis-à-vis with “opt out” option  Fear of richer get preference ?  Only few countries opt for this option
  • 3. www.organathonfoundation.org “opt out” or “presumed consent Advantages  Most countries across the world adopt this option  Acceptability rate is more than 90% and varies from country to country  This option is either hard or soft- Despite being consented by the person relatives were also involved and this form the basis of hard/soft option:-  Incentivization of donor in case they need a organ during there lifetime OR some kind of rebate in the Insurance sector of the pledged donor. Note: 1. The allocation of the harvested organs is regulated by the central Government 2. 43 States of the US have a law that families cannot over – rule a donors’ wishes Disadvantages  Fear of the fact that health – care professional would let registered donor die to harvest there organs – a myth  Many refuses on the ground of there religions – a myth  Fear of reincarnation – a myth TO CLEAR ALL MYTHS AND FACTS PLEASE VISIT – www.organthonfoundation.org –myths/FAQs section on the home page Soft opt out Hard opt out The views of relatives are saught and they can refused the consent (Spain, NZ) The views of relatives are not taken into the account and they can’t refused consent (Austria, Belzium, Sweden)
  • 4. www.organathonfoundation.org “mandated choice” Advantages Note: 1. The allocation of the harvested organs is regulated by the central Government 2. 43 States of the US have a law that families cannot over – rule a donors’ wishes  A wining combination and may achieve a higher rate of donation than presumed consent  In the Driver License – Do you wish to be a organ donor ?  High rate of donor sign up rate according to donate life Illinois  In this taking permission from relatives of the donor is optional  In nut shell Signing up to be an organ donor should be at least as easy downloading any song to your Phone Disadvantages  India being a multi - linguistic with many religions – a real task to convince all – please see our website for details related to all the aspects irrespective of cast, creed or religion
  • 6. www.organathonfoundation.org ORGAN DONATION – OPTIONS Different consent systems and donation rates
  • 7. www.organathonfoundation.org Participants’ stance on opt out before and after the public deliberative events ORGAN DONATION – OPTIONS
  • 8. www.organathonfoundation.org “We need to bring it into the national curriculum, perhaps as part of personal and social education issues. I think if we get children thinking about it when they are young, then at least they will have an opinion on it.” (recipient family) OPT OUT OPTION IN THE DRIVING LICENSE Thanking You…