SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Land Allocations by
Modi Government
1
The TRUE STORY!
Mindless Attacks V/S Actual Facts
V/S
While the Supreme Court & High Court have lauded the process of Land
Allocation in Gujarat during Modi regime, Congress Party & it's leaders in
order to take attention off their large scale corruption are repeatedly
attacking Gujarat on Land Allocation. So it is very important to examine the
truth.
2
Clearly Congress’ Strategy is to divert public attention
from its own large scale corrupt records.
The Truth
3
The Truth
4
BUT…
They ALL happened during preceding
Congress Government Regime
The True Story
of
Land Allocation Processes, Prices,
Policies and Impact during Narendra
Modi led Government!
5
Land Allocation : Congress Numbers
How many times and at what price did the
Congress government allocate land to industrial
houses between 1985-95?
6
28 Land Allocations done at a Rate of Rs. 2 or less
Some as less as 10 paisa
Who practiced the Toffee Model?
• If anyone has ever practiced the Toffee Model as
alleged by Rahul Gandhi, it has been Congress &
Allied Governments.
• Chimanbhai Patel of Congress gave land to Adani
at 10 paise per sq metre & Shankersinh
Vaghela government (who is now Leader of
Opposition in Gujarat) allotted around 30 lakh
square metres of land to Adani at Re. 1 per
square metre.
7
Rs 1.08 per
sq. mt
Rs. 20 - 22.20
per sq. mt
Upto 320 %
Higher Rate
Land Allocation Prices: Congress V/S BJP
8
Adani
Essar
At Hazira
L&T
200 Acre in Hazira
Reliance
In Lalpur taluka
10 paise
per Sq. Mt
Upto 300%
Higher
Rate!
0.74 paise
per sq. mt
Upto 700%
Higher Rate
Upto 120%
Higher Rate
More examples of Toffee Model !
9
If at all anyone practiced the ‘Toffee’ Model,
it has been the Congress
Land Allocation Process : Congress V/S BJP
10
Opaque
Arbitrary Pricing
No Defined Process
Scientific Method and
Technical Assessement
3-Stage Valuation Process
Further 2 stage Re-check for
valuations above Rs.50 Lakhs
Consent of the Gramsabha /
Grampanchayat
30% premium for sale of
grazing land
Modi Government (2001 onwards)Congress Government (till 1995)
• The policy for allocation of
land to industrial houses is in effect since 1956
and most of the raised issues are of allocation of
govt land.
• In the case of necessity to procure farming land ,
the state govt has solved the issue without
any pressure through
mutual understanding between the farmers &
industrial houses.
• Thus, the land agreement cannot be
reached till the farmers get adequate prices for
his land & the question of meting out
an injustice to the farmer does not arise at all.
11
Social Impact of Land Allocation Policies and Processes
Farm land
procurement for
industrial
development
Social Impact of Land Allocation Policies and Process
Gauchar Land
12
Important for raising livestock.
Without the land, farmers will become dependent for their cattle
Percentage allocation of
Gauchar land against
total land allocation
Social Impact of Land Allocation Policies and Process
13
Recovery through 30% premium charged for
the allocation of Gauchar land during 2001-
2012.
The same was used for developmental works
through district panchayats.
No such premium charged for social
development to balance land allocation
14
Rs.43.26
Crore
Rs.0
Commercial Benefit of Land Allocation Policies
Observation by the Supreme Court
•Commenting on the trend of forcible land acquisitions in the country,
the Supreme Court in 2011 noted that process of Land Acquisitions &
Allocations in Gujarat are sound & fair.
•The Hon’ble Supreme Court noted that “But there is one state from
where we do not receive any such complaints. Look at Ahmedabad
which is developing but there are no complaints from that place. They
have the same officers of the same cadre as in the rest of the country,"
the court said, adding officers from other states can train under their
Gujarat counterparts.”
15
Land Allocation to Nano
Rahul Gandhi attacked the land allocation process in relation to
the Tata Nano plant.
However..
16
Gujarat High Court’s VERDICT!
The processes followed in allocating land &
incentives to Tata Nano are totally fair & there is no
illegality or discrepancy involved
The True Story
of
Corporate Links and Land Allocation
17
The Adani Link
• What is Gujarat’s share
among Adani’s Business
Investments in other states
of India?
• Adani group started,
flourished & got land in
Mundra much before
Narendra Modi even came
to power
18
ONLY
35%
The Corporate Link – Adani V/s Vadra
Adani Investments
19
Himachal Pradesh Haryana,
Rajasthan Uttar Pradesh
Madhya Pradesh
Maharashtra Goa Chhattisgarh
Odisha West Bengal
Andhra Pradesh Karnataka Assam
Gujarat
Vadra Investments
Haryana
Rajasthan
Only CongressState Governments belonging to different
Parties including opposition parties
Did Gujarat Govt Favour Adani : Case Study
2005
Adani applied for three tracts of land.
State Pricing Committee determined following prices.
20
1500 acres in
Mundra village
Rs. 4.25
per sq. mt.
228 acres in
Zarpara village
Rs. 6 per
sq. mt.
34 acres in
Dhrab village
Rs. 25
per sq. mt.
FINAL SALE PRICE
Highest amount of
Rs. 25 per sq. mt. for
all the three tracts
was decided by State
Govt headed by Mr
Modi
Beyond Truth Lies Vision!
Go Beyond…
The Mindless Propaganda Rahul
Gandhi & Congress.
Realise the Dream…
Of ridding the nation from
Congress Party, that sold land at
throw away prices and favoured
Corporates in Land deals
21
22
Thank You!

More Related Content

Similar to Myths Regarding Land Final (7)

Gujarat persecuting people through greedy governance
Gujarat persecuting people through greedy governanceGujarat persecuting people through greedy governance
Gujarat persecuting people through greedy governance
 
Issue brief, gujarat
Issue brief, gujarat Issue brief, gujarat
Issue brief, gujarat
 
Analysis of compulsory voting in gujarat
Analysis of compulsory voting in gujaratAnalysis of compulsory voting in gujarat
Analysis of compulsory voting in gujarat
 
Analysis of compulsory voting in gujarat
Analysis of compulsory voting in gujaratAnalysis of compulsory voting in gujarat
Analysis of compulsory voting in gujarat
 
An idea to bank on
An idea to bank onAn idea to bank on
An idea to bank on
 
Answer To Public
Answer To PublicAnswer To Public
Answer To Public
 
3 farm laws - 27Feb21.pptx
3 farm laws - 27Feb21.pptx3 farm laws - 27Feb21.pptx
3 farm laws - 27Feb21.pptx
 

More from ManushiIndia

Ganga proposasl for national river
Ganga   proposasl for national riverGanga   proposasl for national river
Ganga proposasl for national river
ManushiIndia
 
Part 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street Vendors
Part 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street VendorsPart 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street Vendors
Part 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street Vendors
ManushiIndia
 
Government’s Warfare against Cycle Rickshaws
Government’s Warfare against Cycle RickshawsGovernment’s Warfare against Cycle Rickshaws
Government’s Warfare against Cycle Rickshaws
ManushiIndia
 
Part 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class Cities
Part 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class CitiesPart 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class Cities
Part 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class Cities
ManushiIndia
 
Part 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot Project
Part 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot ProjectPart 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot Project
Part 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot Project
ManushiIndia
 
Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...
Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...
Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...
ManushiIndia
 
Zealous Reformers, Deadly Laws
Zealous Reformers, Deadly LawsZealous Reformers, Deadly Laws
Zealous Reformers, Deadly Laws
ManushiIndia
 
The Broom Wielding Goddess of Good Governance
The Broom Wielding Goddess of Good GovernanceThe Broom Wielding Goddess of Good Governance
The Broom Wielding Goddess of Good Governance
ManushiIndia
 
Enhancing Women’s Representation In Legislatures
Enhancing Women’s Representation In LegislaturesEnhancing Women’s Representation In Legislatures
Enhancing Women’s Representation In Legislatures
ManushiIndia
 

More from ManushiIndia (12)

Isi 13 sep
Isi 13 sepIsi 13 sep
Isi 13 sep
 
Ganga proposasl for national river
Ganga   proposasl for national riverGanga   proposasl for national river
Ganga proposasl for national river
 
Ganga For Moef Presentation By Sunita Narayan
Ganga For Moef   Presentation By Sunita NarayanGanga For Moef   Presentation By Sunita Narayan
Ganga For Moef Presentation By Sunita Narayan
 
Save Ganga Presentation By Mallika Bhanot
Save Ganga Presentation By Mallika BhanotSave Ganga Presentation By Mallika Bhanot
Save Ganga Presentation By Mallika Bhanot
 
Part 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street Vendors
Part 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street VendorsPart 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street Vendors
Part 5 : The History of Nehru Place Street Vendors
 
Government’s Warfare against Cycle Rickshaws
Government’s Warfare against Cycle RickshawsGovernment’s Warfare against Cycle Rickshaws
Government’s Warfare against Cycle Rickshaws
 
Part 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class Cities
Part 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class CitiesPart 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class Cities
Part 3 : Agenda for Action : Towards People Friendly World Class Cities
 
Part 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot Project
Part 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot ProjectPart 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot Project
Part 2 : History of Sewa Nagar Pilot Project
 
Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...
Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...
Part 1: Laws Liberty & Livelihood : A Call for A Bottom-up Agenda of Economi...
 
Zealous Reformers, Deadly Laws
Zealous Reformers, Deadly LawsZealous Reformers, Deadly Laws
Zealous Reformers, Deadly Laws
 
The Broom Wielding Goddess of Good Governance
The Broom Wielding Goddess of Good GovernanceThe Broom Wielding Goddess of Good Governance
The Broom Wielding Goddess of Good Governance
 
Enhancing Women’s Representation In Legislatures
Enhancing Women’s Representation In LegislaturesEnhancing Women’s Representation In Legislatures
Enhancing Women’s Representation In Legislatures
 

Recently uploaded

PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...
PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...
PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...
Faga1939
 

Recently uploaded (16)

Nika Muhl Visa Approval Shirt, Nika Muhl Visa Approval T-Shirt
Nika Muhl Visa Approval Shirt, Nika Muhl Visa Approval T-ShirtNika Muhl Visa Approval Shirt, Nika Muhl Visa Approval T-Shirt
Nika Muhl Visa Approval Shirt, Nika Muhl Visa Approval T-Shirt
 
Mizzima Weekly Analysis & Insight Issue 1
Mizzima Weekly Analysis & Insight Issue 1Mizzima Weekly Analysis & Insight Issue 1
Mizzima Weekly Analysis & Insight Issue 1
 
Textile Waste In India | Textile Waste Management
Textile Waste In India | Textile Waste ManagementTextile Waste In India | Textile Waste Management
Textile Waste In India | Textile Waste Management
 
role of women and girls in various terror groups
role of women and girls in various terror groupsrole of women and girls in various terror groups
role of women and girls in various terror groups
 
27052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
27052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf27052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
27052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
26052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
26052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf26052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
26052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
23052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
23052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf23052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
23052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
25052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
25052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf25052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
25052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
Meta_AI_ads_investigation.pdfldoljjwejolejolol
Meta_AI_ads_investigation.pdfldoljjwejolejololMeta_AI_ads_investigation.pdfldoljjwejolejolol
Meta_AI_ads_investigation.pdfldoljjwejolejolol
 
May 2024 - Crypto Market Report_FINAL.pdf
May 2024 - Crypto Market Report_FINAL.pdfMay 2024 - Crypto Market Report_FINAL.pdf
May 2024 - Crypto Market Report_FINAL.pdf
 
Draft-1-Resolutions-Key-Interventions-.pdf
Draft-1-Resolutions-Key-Interventions-.pdfDraft-1-Resolutions-Key-Interventions-.pdf
Draft-1-Resolutions-Key-Interventions-.pdf
 
Chapter-8th-Recent Developments in Indian Politics-PPT.pptx
Chapter-8th-Recent Developments in Indian Politics-PPT.pptxChapter-8th-Recent Developments in Indian Politics-PPT.pptx
Chapter-8th-Recent Developments in Indian Politics-PPT.pptx
 
24052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
24052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf24052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
24052024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
HISTORY- XII-Theme 3 - Kinship, Caste and Class.pptx
HISTORY- XII-Theme 3 - Kinship, Caste and Class.pptxHISTORY- XII-Theme 3 - Kinship, Caste and Class.pptx
HISTORY- XII-Theme 3 - Kinship, Caste and Class.pptx
 
ys jagan mohan reddy political career, Biography.pdf
ys jagan mohan reddy political career, Biography.pdfys jagan mohan reddy political career, Biography.pdf
ys jagan mohan reddy political career, Biography.pdf
 
PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...
PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...
PEACE BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINE REQUIRES EXTREMISTS OUT OF POWER AND RESTR...
 

Myths Regarding Land Final

  • 1. Land Allocations by Modi Government 1 The TRUE STORY!
  • 2. Mindless Attacks V/S Actual Facts V/S While the Supreme Court & High Court have lauded the process of Land Allocation in Gujarat during Modi regime, Congress Party & it's leaders in order to take attention off their large scale corruption are repeatedly attacking Gujarat on Land Allocation. So it is very important to examine the truth. 2 Clearly Congress’ Strategy is to divert public attention from its own large scale corrupt records.
  • 4. The Truth 4 BUT… They ALL happened during preceding Congress Government Regime
  • 5. The True Story of Land Allocation Processes, Prices, Policies and Impact during Narendra Modi led Government! 5
  • 6. Land Allocation : Congress Numbers How many times and at what price did the Congress government allocate land to industrial houses between 1985-95? 6 28 Land Allocations done at a Rate of Rs. 2 or less Some as less as 10 paisa
  • 7. Who practiced the Toffee Model? • If anyone has ever practiced the Toffee Model as alleged by Rahul Gandhi, it has been Congress & Allied Governments. • Chimanbhai Patel of Congress gave land to Adani at 10 paise per sq metre & Shankersinh Vaghela government (who is now Leader of Opposition in Gujarat) allotted around 30 lakh square metres of land to Adani at Re. 1 per square metre. 7
  • 8. Rs 1.08 per sq. mt Rs. 20 - 22.20 per sq. mt Upto 320 % Higher Rate Land Allocation Prices: Congress V/S BJP 8 Adani Essar At Hazira L&T 200 Acre in Hazira Reliance In Lalpur taluka 10 paise per Sq. Mt Upto 300% Higher Rate! 0.74 paise per sq. mt Upto 700% Higher Rate Upto 120% Higher Rate
  • 9. More examples of Toffee Model ! 9 If at all anyone practiced the ‘Toffee’ Model, it has been the Congress
  • 10. Land Allocation Process : Congress V/S BJP 10 Opaque Arbitrary Pricing No Defined Process Scientific Method and Technical Assessement 3-Stage Valuation Process Further 2 stage Re-check for valuations above Rs.50 Lakhs Consent of the Gramsabha / Grampanchayat 30% premium for sale of grazing land Modi Government (2001 onwards)Congress Government (till 1995)
  • 11. • The policy for allocation of land to industrial houses is in effect since 1956 and most of the raised issues are of allocation of govt land. • In the case of necessity to procure farming land , the state govt has solved the issue without any pressure through mutual understanding between the farmers & industrial houses. • Thus, the land agreement cannot be reached till the farmers get adequate prices for his land & the question of meting out an injustice to the farmer does not arise at all. 11 Social Impact of Land Allocation Policies and Processes Farm land procurement for industrial development
  • 12. Social Impact of Land Allocation Policies and Process Gauchar Land 12 Important for raising livestock. Without the land, farmers will become dependent for their cattle Percentage allocation of Gauchar land against total land allocation
  • 13. Social Impact of Land Allocation Policies and Process 13
  • 14. Recovery through 30% premium charged for the allocation of Gauchar land during 2001- 2012. The same was used for developmental works through district panchayats. No such premium charged for social development to balance land allocation 14 Rs.43.26 Crore Rs.0 Commercial Benefit of Land Allocation Policies
  • 15. Observation by the Supreme Court •Commenting on the trend of forcible land acquisitions in the country, the Supreme Court in 2011 noted that process of Land Acquisitions & Allocations in Gujarat are sound & fair. •The Hon’ble Supreme Court noted that “But there is one state from where we do not receive any such complaints. Look at Ahmedabad which is developing but there are no complaints from that place. They have the same officers of the same cadre as in the rest of the country," the court said, adding officers from other states can train under their Gujarat counterparts.” 15
  • 16. Land Allocation to Nano Rahul Gandhi attacked the land allocation process in relation to the Tata Nano plant. However.. 16 Gujarat High Court’s VERDICT! The processes followed in allocating land & incentives to Tata Nano are totally fair & there is no illegality or discrepancy involved
  • 17. The True Story of Corporate Links and Land Allocation 17
  • 18. The Adani Link • What is Gujarat’s share among Adani’s Business Investments in other states of India? • Adani group started, flourished & got land in Mundra much before Narendra Modi even came to power 18 ONLY 35%
  • 19. The Corporate Link – Adani V/s Vadra Adani Investments 19 Himachal Pradesh Haryana, Rajasthan Uttar Pradesh Madhya Pradesh Maharashtra Goa Chhattisgarh Odisha West Bengal Andhra Pradesh Karnataka Assam Gujarat Vadra Investments Haryana Rajasthan Only CongressState Governments belonging to different Parties including opposition parties
  • 20. Did Gujarat Govt Favour Adani : Case Study 2005 Adani applied for three tracts of land. State Pricing Committee determined following prices. 20 1500 acres in Mundra village Rs. 4.25 per sq. mt. 228 acres in Zarpara village Rs. 6 per sq. mt. 34 acres in Dhrab village Rs. 25 per sq. mt. FINAL SALE PRICE Highest amount of Rs. 25 per sq. mt. for all the three tracts was decided by State Govt headed by Mr Modi
  • 21. Beyond Truth Lies Vision! Go Beyond… The Mindless Propaganda Rahul Gandhi & Congress. Realise the Dream… Of ridding the nation from Congress Party, that sold land at throw away prices and favoured Corporates in Land deals 21