SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 26
Warsaw, Poland
SECURE. PRIVATE. UNTRACEABLE.
Welcome
Justin Ehrenhofer
Finance
Management Information Systems
/u/SamsungGalaxyPlayer or sgp_
CryptoUMN.com
Fungibility
=
YOU
Why Fungibility Matters
Adapted from Keybase.io
Why Fungibility Matters
Adapted from Keybase.io
YOU
Known extremist
Drug lord
Hemorrhoid
Cream Direct
Your best friend
Bitcoin Crash Course
SENDER TRANSACTION
BROADCAST
ADDED TO
BLOCKCHAIN
BY MINING
RECEIVER
The Monero Difference
SENDER RECEIVER
RING
SIGNATURES
STEALTH
ADDRESSES
AMOUNT TRANSACTION
BROADCAST
ɱ
KOVRI
(I2P ROUTER)
RING CONFIDENTIAL
TRANSACTIONS (RINGCT)
Ring Signatures & RingCT
8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8)
9 (Tx ID cb8vqfi8dfj65f)
1 (Tx ID e4hn4ifqyd5ed)
3 (Tx ID wb4f5hdfdicnd)
4 (Tx ID nh5nogsefwjw)
6 (Tx ID ybwnng8nengf)
2 (Tx ID eshgni5lsvnf74)
5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54)
7 (Tx ID e4bgn8flwwrj8)
10 (Tx ID fnidmfnu3dm8)
11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas)
13 (Tx ID 7nr8mrjffijdtm)
12 (Tx ID h5o8mfdngkd)
14 (Tx ID f8n8madkrjmd)
15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn)
16 (Tx ID 5 f8wnfdmmii)
17 (Tx ID h8fn5mdfi4w)
18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki)
20 (Tx ID t4vn8lf8djer4)
19 (Tx ID fnidmnfdsam)
21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4)
BLOCKCHAIN
8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8)
5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54)
11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas)
15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn)
18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki)
21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4)
Ring Signatures & RingCT
Ringsize=6
INPUTSMinimumSeptember2017*
MinimumToday
5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54)
8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8)
11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas)
15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn)
18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki)
21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4) key image
5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54)5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54)
8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8)
11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas)
15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn)
18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki)
21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4)
Ring Signatures & RingCT
Ringsize=6
INPUTSMinimumSeptember2017*
MinimumToday
8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8)
11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas)
15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn)
18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki)
21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4) key image
RingCT ring signature,
signs difference
between commitments
? XMR
Pedersen commitment
Commitment
public key
Ring Signatures & RingCT
5
8
11
15
18
21
INPUTS
NewerOlder
https://xmrchain.net/search?value=9bb608c70622ce67333c267103241f19b8aca21b7915f237813e451e1f03576e
Ring Signatures & RingCT
Near 100% use of
optional RingCT
Source: moneroblocks.info/stats
ORIGIN
NODE
12.154.85.166
LOGGING
NODE
Tx ID: 375wd4h
ORIGIN
NODE
3dsnf28.i2p
LOGGING
NODE
Tx ID: 375wd4h
Stealth Addresses
OUTPUTS
? XMR
Back to Sender
To Receiver
INPUTS
100 XMR
OR
hfk5yndjdmnfirwm5dnu
7yf8dji8fbwb4f5hdfdicnd
ey5f8ne58nh5nogsefwjw
58fmd8jhybwnng8nengf
5hfnq835hng6iwfumwf8
3348dqnqcb8vqfi8dfj65f
Commitment public key
Summary
5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54)
8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8)
11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas)
15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn)
18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki)
21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4)
? XMR
hfk5yndjdmnfirwm5dnu
7yf8dji8fbwb4f5hdfdicnd
ey5f8ne58nh5nogsefwjw
58fmd8jhybwnng8nengf
5hfnq835hng6iwfumwf8
3348dqnqcb8vqfi8dfj65f
Commitment public key
Mandatory Privacy
Source: MoneroBlocks.info 24 Feb 2016
Source: zcha.in 15 March 2017
A Brief History
Launched
April 2014
All Tx Private
April 2016
Attacked
September 2014
GUI Beta 1
December 2016
RingCT
January 2017
Regulatory Compliance and Transparency
A view key is used to
reveal all transactions for
a Monero account, or just
the key for a single
transaction
Transparency
View keys can be given to
selected parties, or can be
made public
Selected Parties
By publishing their view
key, charities can invite
easy public oversight
Charities
Auditors can be given
access to accounts
without being able to
spend those account
funds
Auditing
Children can be given
their own accounts, and
parents can monitor their
spending
Parents
(with the View Key)
Adapted from Fluffypony’s Slides
Monero Limitations
Monero Limitations
Bitcoin (0.3kB)
Monero ringsize 3 (3kB)
Monero with RingCT (12-13kB)
Current Blockchain
Size on Disk: 13.0GB
Addressing Transaction Size
1. RingCT is brand new; optimizations could reduce
transaction sizes by 20%
2. Prune non-essential parts of blockchain for 50%
size reduction. Sharding possible
3. Large hard drives are cheap, and prices continue
to fall (even if it can’t meet Moore’s Law)
4. Any real scaling needs to be done off-chain
anyway
Ongoing Development
Multisig
Improvements to
Dynamic Fees &
Dynamic Blocks
Sub-Addresses &
Disposable Addresses
Translations
Lightweight
Wallet
Website
Redesign
Hardfork Schedule
April 15th September 18th*
• Dynamic Block Improvements
• Dynamic Fee Improvements
• Mandatory RingCT
• Minimum ringsize ≥5
• Fluffy blocks
• Wallet sync optimizations
(prefetch and resource allocation)
January April September
Thank You!
monero.stackexchange.com
getmonero.org
/r/Monero
Adapted from Fluffypony’s Slides
People Started Adding Tools to Bitcoin

More Related Content

What's hot

Cryptography (Distributed computing)
Cryptography (Distributed computing)Cryptography (Distributed computing)
Cryptography (Distributed computing)
Sri Prasanna
 

What's hot (9)

Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Vienna, Austria 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Vienna, Austria 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Vienna, Austria 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Vienna, Austria 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Rome, Italy 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Rome, Italy 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Rome, Italy 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Rome, Italy 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Stockholm, Sweden 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Stockholm, Sweden 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Stockholm, Sweden 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Stockholm, Sweden 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Brussels, Belguim 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Brussels, Belguim 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Brussels, Belguim 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Brussels, Belguim 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Milwaukee, Wisconsin 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Milwaukee, Wisconsin 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Milwaukee, Wisconsin 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Milwaukee, Wisconsin 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Cologne, Germany 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Cologne, Germany 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Cologne, Germany 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Cologne, Germany 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Zagreb, Croatia 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Zagreb, Croatia 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Zagreb, Croatia 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Zagreb, Croatia 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - New York City, New York 2019
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - New York City, New York 2019Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - New York City, New York 2019
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - New York City, New York 2019
 
Cryptography (Distributed computing)
Cryptography (Distributed computing)Cryptography (Distributed computing)
Cryptography (Distributed computing)
 

Similar to Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Warsaw, Poland 2017

Similar to Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Warsaw, Poland 2017 (12)

Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Oslo, Norway 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Oslo, Norway 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Oslo, Norway 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Oslo, Norway 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Copenhagen, Denmark 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Copenhagen, Denmark 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Copenhagen, Denmark 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Copenhagen, Denmark 2017
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Madison, Wisconsin 1 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Madison, Wisconsin 1 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Madison, Wisconsin 1 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Madison, Wisconsin 1 2017
 
BCHGraz - Meetup #9 - Monero by Justin Ehrenhofer
BCHGraz - Meetup #9 - Monero by Justin EhrenhoferBCHGraz - Meetup #9 - Monero by Justin Ehrenhofer
BCHGraz - Meetup #9 - Monero by Justin Ehrenhofer
 
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Graz, Austria 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Graz, Austria 2017Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Graz, Austria 2017
Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Graz, Austria 2017
 
Evaluating Private Cryptocurrency Technologies and Implementations
Evaluating Private Cryptocurrency Technologies and ImplementationsEvaluating Private Cryptocurrency Technologies and Implementations
Evaluating Private Cryptocurrency Technologies and Implementations
 
Privacy Coins
Privacy CoinsPrivacy Coins
Privacy Coins
 
ChapterTwoCryptoTheStreamCipherFHSU.pptx
ChapterTwoCryptoTheStreamCipherFHSU.pptxChapterTwoCryptoTheStreamCipherFHSU.pptx
ChapterTwoCryptoTheStreamCipherFHSU.pptx
 
Defcon Monero Ring Signatures Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer 2018
Defcon Monero Ring Signatures Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer 2018Defcon Monero Ring Signatures Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer 2018
Defcon Monero Ring Signatures Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer 2018
 
Compilation process
Compilation processCompilation process
Compilation process
 
The Bitcoin Protocol for Humans
The Bitcoin Protocol for HumansThe Bitcoin Protocol for Humans
The Bitcoin Protocol for Humans
 
The Burden of Proof
The Burden of ProofThe Burden of Proof
The Burden of Proof
 

Recently uploaded

Architecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native ApplicationsArchitecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
WSO2
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Architecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native ApplicationsArchitecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
 
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
Corporate and higher education May webinar.pptx
Corporate and higher education May webinar.pptxCorporate and higher education May webinar.pptx
Corporate and higher education May webinar.pptx
 
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law DevelopmentsTrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
 
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
 
Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...
Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...
Apidays New York 2024 - The value of a flexible API Management solution for O...
 
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
 
Apidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, Adobe
Apidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, AdobeApidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, Adobe
Apidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, Adobe
 
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfBoost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
 
Repurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost Saving
Repurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost SavingRepurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost Saving
Repurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost Saving
 
A Beginners Guide to Building a RAG App Using Open Source Milvus
A Beginners Guide to Building a RAG App Using Open Source MilvusA Beginners Guide to Building a RAG App Using Open Source Milvus
A Beginners Guide to Building a RAG App Using Open Source Milvus
 
Manulife - Insurer Transformation Award 2024
Manulife - Insurer Transformation Award 2024Manulife - Insurer Transformation Award 2024
Manulife - Insurer Transformation Award 2024
 
ICT role in 21st century education and its challenges
ICT role in 21st century education and its challengesICT role in 21st century education and its challenges
ICT role in 21st century education and its challenges
 
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CVReal Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
 
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone ProcessorsExploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
 
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectorsMS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
 
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ..."I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
 
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
 
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemkeProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
 

Monero Presentation by Justin Ehrenhofer - Warsaw, Poland 2017

  • 2. Welcome Justin Ehrenhofer Finance Management Information Systems /u/SamsungGalaxyPlayer or sgp_ CryptoUMN.com
  • 5. Why Fungibility Matters Adapted from Keybase.io YOU Known extremist Drug lord Hemorrhoid Cream Direct Your best friend
  • 6. Bitcoin Crash Course SENDER TRANSACTION BROADCAST ADDED TO BLOCKCHAIN BY MINING RECEIVER
  • 7. The Monero Difference SENDER RECEIVER RING SIGNATURES STEALTH ADDRESSES AMOUNT TRANSACTION BROADCAST ɱ KOVRI (I2P ROUTER) RING CONFIDENTIAL TRANSACTIONS (RINGCT)
  • 8. Ring Signatures & RingCT 8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8) 9 (Tx ID cb8vqfi8dfj65f) 1 (Tx ID e4hn4ifqyd5ed) 3 (Tx ID wb4f5hdfdicnd) 4 (Tx ID nh5nogsefwjw) 6 (Tx ID ybwnng8nengf) 2 (Tx ID eshgni5lsvnf74) 5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54) 7 (Tx ID e4bgn8flwwrj8) 10 (Tx ID fnidmfnu3dm8) 11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas) 13 (Tx ID 7nr8mrjffijdtm) 12 (Tx ID h5o8mfdngkd) 14 (Tx ID f8n8madkrjmd) 15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn) 16 (Tx ID 5 f8wnfdmmii) 17 (Tx ID h8fn5mdfi4w) 18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki) 20 (Tx ID t4vn8lf8djer4) 19 (Tx ID fnidmnfdsam) 21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4) BLOCKCHAIN 8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8) 5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54) 11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas) 15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn) 18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki) 21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4)
  • 9. Ring Signatures & RingCT Ringsize=6 INPUTSMinimumSeptember2017* MinimumToday 5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54) 8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8) 11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas) 15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn) 18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki) 21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4) key image
  • 10. 5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54)5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54) 8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8) 11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas) 15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn) 18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki) 21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4) Ring Signatures & RingCT Ringsize=6 INPUTSMinimumSeptember2017* MinimumToday 8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8) 11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas) 15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn) 18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki) 21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4) key image RingCT ring signature, signs difference between commitments ? XMR Pedersen commitment Commitment public key
  • 11. Ring Signatures & RingCT 5 8 11 15 18 21 INPUTS NewerOlder https://xmrchain.net/search?value=9bb608c70622ce67333c267103241f19b8aca21b7915f237813e451e1f03576e
  • 12. Ring Signatures & RingCT Near 100% use of optional RingCT Source: moneroblocks.info/stats
  • 15. Stealth Addresses OUTPUTS ? XMR Back to Sender To Receiver INPUTS 100 XMR OR hfk5yndjdmnfirwm5dnu 7yf8dji8fbwb4f5hdfdicnd ey5f8ne58nh5nogsefwjw 58fmd8jhybwnng8nengf 5hfnq835hng6iwfumwf8 3348dqnqcb8vqfi8dfj65f Commitment public key
  • 16. Summary 5 (Tx ID fgwinw3fwtk54) 8 (Tx ID hng6iwfumwf8) 11 (Tx ID twv8mf8dnfas) 15 (Tx ID wn3f4diiijffwn) 18 (Tx ID n48gfwmfdki) 21 (Tx ID 4f5f8njdoam4) ? XMR hfk5yndjdmnfirwm5dnu 7yf8dji8fbwb4f5hdfdicnd ey5f8ne58nh5nogsefwjw 58fmd8jhybwnng8nengf 5hfnq835hng6iwfumwf8 3348dqnqcb8vqfi8dfj65f Commitment public key
  • 17. Mandatory Privacy Source: MoneroBlocks.info 24 Feb 2016 Source: zcha.in 15 March 2017
  • 18. A Brief History Launched April 2014 All Tx Private April 2016 Attacked September 2014 GUI Beta 1 December 2016 RingCT January 2017
  • 19. Regulatory Compliance and Transparency A view key is used to reveal all transactions for a Monero account, or just the key for a single transaction Transparency View keys can be given to selected parties, or can be made public Selected Parties By publishing their view key, charities can invite easy public oversight Charities Auditors can be given access to accounts without being able to spend those account funds Auditing Children can be given their own accounts, and parents can monitor their spending Parents (with the View Key) Adapted from Fluffypony’s Slides
  • 21. Monero Limitations Bitcoin (0.3kB) Monero ringsize 3 (3kB) Monero with RingCT (12-13kB) Current Blockchain Size on Disk: 13.0GB
  • 22. Addressing Transaction Size 1. RingCT is brand new; optimizations could reduce transaction sizes by 20% 2. Prune non-essential parts of blockchain for 50% size reduction. Sharding possible 3. Large hard drives are cheap, and prices continue to fall (even if it can’t meet Moore’s Law) 4. Any real scaling needs to be done off-chain anyway
  • 23. Ongoing Development Multisig Improvements to Dynamic Fees & Dynamic Blocks Sub-Addresses & Disposable Addresses Translations Lightweight Wallet Website Redesign
  • 24. Hardfork Schedule April 15th September 18th* • Dynamic Block Improvements • Dynamic Fee Improvements • Mandatory RingCT • Minimum ringsize ≥5 • Fluffy blocks • Wallet sync optimizations (prefetch and resource allocation) January April September
  • 26. People Started Adding Tools to Bitcoin

Editor's Notes

  1. CoinJoin requires other participants to mix with. DASH, which built its PrivateSend functionality on CoinJoin, requires at least 3 participants. The service performing the functionality, whether it is a centralized server for Bitcoin or a randomly-selected masternode for DASH, can log what money goes where.