This document provides information on investing for the best returns in 2015. It outlines the benefits of asset-backed investments and asset diversification for long-term returns. It also discusses the risk-return relationship and differentiates between underperformance and abnormal performance of multiple assets. Additionally, it reinforces the benefits of passive investment management over active management due to lower fees.
2. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 2/17
Outline the benefits of asset-backed investments for long-term returns.
Differentiate between under and abnormal performance of multiple assets.
Fully justify the need for asset diversification.
Present the risk-return relationship, as well as its numerous comfort zones.
Reinforce why Swallow upholds passive management rather than active.
3. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 3/17
… Throughout these notes we have tried wherever possible to use 20 years of data.
May 1994
Inflation = 2.55%
Bank Base Rate = 5.13%
FTSE 100 = 2,970
bbbbb
Inflation=0.9% | Bank Base Rate=0.5% | FTSE100=6,773
Generate £10,000 of income.
Aim:
Security:
10 Year GILT.
Cost:
£492,610 (ignoring costs)
Inflation=3.51% | Bank Base Rate=6.63% | FTSE100=3137
Aim:
Cost:
£115,473 (ignoring costs)
Security:
10 Year GILT.
Generate £10,000 of income.
This is equivalent to an Annualised Growth Rate of 7.52%. Had the FTSE 100 grown by
the same sum it would now be at 13,375. (Bank of England and FTSE statistics).
4. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 4/17
Over the long-term, assets tend to perform better than cash or inflation:
-100%
0%
100%
200%
300%
400%
500%
600%
700%
800%
900%
TotalGrowth
Year
Asset Growth March 1995 to March 2015
FTSE 100
International Equities
Emerging Markets
Property
Global Bonds
Cash
RPI
5. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 5/17
For example, UK Small has an average return of approximately 10.91%, but in any one year this can
vary between -15.53% and + 37.34%. Cash averages at 3.8%, but this can also vary between 1.32%
and 6.27%.
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35%
AnnualisedReturn
Annualised Standard Deviation
Standard Deviation Chart March 1995 to March 2015
FTSE 100
UK Small
International Equities
Emerging Markets
Property
Global Bonds
Cash
6. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 6/17
Empirical evidence has shown that if you combine asset classes the end result is greater than that of the
composite parts. By choosing uncorrelated assets you can achieve reasonable returns in most markets
as when some assets are going down, others normally rise.
Correlation of 1.0 indicates a perfect association | Correlation of 0 indicates no relation | Correlation of -1.0 indicates perfect disassociation
03/1995 to 05/2015
7. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 7/17
We propose 7 different risk categories for our clients. These are based on your FinaMetrica score (1 to
100). If you would like to know how we reach a ranking, please refer to our Risk Profile notes.
So the most cautious investor (i.e. with a FinaMetrica score of less than 20) is the wary one. On the
other hand, the high risk investor (with a score of 90 +) is “Gung Ho”, holding the most volatile assets.
Investment
Option
Investor
Type
FIXED/CASH PROPERTY EQUITIES TOTAL
UK Intl UK Intl UK International
Core Value Small Main
Markets
Emerging
Markets
1 Wary 90.00% 10.00% - 100.00%
2 Cautious 60.00% 15.00% 10.00% 5.00% 10.00% - 100.00%
3 Prudent 30.00% 20.00% 15.00% 5.00% 15.00% 5.00% 10.00% 100.00%
4 Balanced 15.00% 10.00% 15.00% 10.00% 15.00% 5.00% 5.00% 20.00% 5.00% 100.00%
5 Adventurous 5.00% 5.00% 15.00% 5.00% 20.00% 10.00% 5.00% 27.50% 7.50% 100.00%
6 Speculative - - 10.00% 5.00% 23.00% 10.00% 10.00% 27.00% 15.00% 100.00%
7 High Risk - 10.00% 20.00% 20.00% 30.00% 20.00% 100.00%
8. -100%
0%
100%
200%
300%
400%
500%
600%
700%
800%
TotalGrowth
Year
High Risk Portfolio v Asset Class March 1995 to March 1995
High Risk FTSE 100 UK Value UK Small International Equities Emerging Markets
6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 8/17
The High Risk portfolio contains the other asset classes and has beaten all but UK Small whilst
generating far less volatile returns (Total growth over 20 years: 455%)
10. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 10/17
Risk is the uncertainty of an investment performing better or worse than expected. This is also called the
standard deviation from the norm. If we look at the returns for the above asset classes over 20 years
we have a table as follows:
As you can see, the use of a mixture of assets overall generates better returns at lower risk than does
an equivalent asset class.
In About 70% of Time Periods
Data Series Annualised Return Standard Deviation Minimum Return Maximum Return
Global Bonds 6.74% 3.82% 2.92% 10.56%
Cautious 6.17% 5.10% 1.08% 11.27%
Balanced 8.95% 14.89% ( 5.94%) 23.84%
International
Equities
7.39% 18.94% ( 11.55%) 26.34%
FTSE 100 7.50% 19.93% ( 12.43%) 27.43%
High Risk 8.95% 22.40% ( 13.45%) 31.35%
Property 9.06% 25.82% ( 16.76%) 34.88%
UK Small 10.91% 26.44% ( 15.53%) 37.34%
Emerging Markets 7.31% 30.12% ( 22.81%) 37.43%
11. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 11/17
Wary has an average return of 4.19%, a best return of 8.21% and a worst return of 0.08%. Opposing
this however is Speculative, which has an average return of 11.07% and a best return of 60.29%. But
most importantly, its poorest recorded performance was at -30.91%. Subsequently, if you are adverse
to such risk, choose a lower long term return.
( 40.00%)
( 35.00%)
( 30.00%)
( 25.00%)
( 20.00%)
( 15.00%)
( 10.00%)
( 5.00%)
-
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
25.00%
30.00%
35.00%
40.00%
45.00%
50.00%
Wary
Cautious
Prudent
Balanced
Adventurous
Speculative
HighRisk
Return
Portfolio
Highest And Lowest Returns, Swallow Portfolios March 1995 To March 2015
Highest
Lowest
Average
`
12. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 12/17
If you look at the best and worst returns from a selection of our recommended portfolios, you will observe
the following:
Best/Worst Returns Between March 1995 to March 2015
If you do not require your money for 10+ years , then you can afford a greater amount of risk knowing that
the return is more likely to be as expected.
13. £10,000
£15,000
£20,000
£25,000
£30,000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Value
Years
No charges
Passive
Active
6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 13/17
We believe investment returns in the future will (on average) reflect the inflation rate. Subsequently, if
Inflation is low then an average Passive Fund with charges of 1% is bound to out perform an average
Managed Fund with charges of 2.5%. See “Our Approach to Investment Management” notes for more.
£10,000 at a gross annual return of 5% over 20 years will grow to £26,500 with no charges, £21,911 in
a Passive Fund or £16,386 in an Active Fund. Consequently, an Active Fund has to grow by 30%
more than the index just to keep pace with it.
Active Versus Passive Investment: The Effect of Charges
14. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 14/17
If that is not enough to convince the sceptics, the 2013 ratio of US mutual fund new
investments was 62% Passive 38% Active.
Here are some facts to stir the pot:
Global Equity
UK Equity
European Equity
US Equity
Emerging Markets Equity
Global Bonds
GBP Diversified Bonds
Euro Diversified Bonds
US Divsified bonds
83%
65%
78%
80%
75%
82%
79%
99%
99%
% of Fund Managers Underperforming from 1999 to 2013
(Including Funds Wound Up)
(Vanguard approx, calculations made using Morningstar Data)
15. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 15/17
The Graham and Campbell study of 237 market timing newsletters showed that less than 25% of the
“experts” predicted the right outcome once, let alone consistently. If we cannot get the asset timing
right, we believe clients should remain invested in their optimum asset classes.
FTSE 100 UK Value UK Small International Equities Emerging Markets Property Global Bonds Cash
March
2006
March
2007
March
2008
March
2009
March
2010
March
2011
March
2012
March
2013
March
2014
March
2015
60.96% 19.16% 20.65% 5.84% 80.84% 18.17% 6.52% 29.74% 22.60% 28.91%
49.96% 17.00% 6.29% 3.74% 72.81% 12.44% 4.83% 23.69% 8.72% 20.38%
33.17% 16.92% 5.73% ( 19.65%) 71.66% 12.36% 3.05% 17.96% 8.10% 13.28%
29.58% 9.32% ( 3.76%) ( 26.56%) 66.37% 9.10% 1.24% 15.45% 6.66% 6.34%
28.81% 6.84% ( 6.26%) ( 28.17%) 50.42% 7.44% 0.80% 13.36% 0.61% 4.10%
25.99% 5.24% ( 17.77%) ( 37.27%) 43.36% 7.30% 0.45% 7.70% 0.38% 1.43%
4.70% 4.95% ( 17.95%) ( 38.72%) 6.68% 4.28% ( 4.81%) 4.30% ( 8.16%) 0.41%
3.70% 0.98% ( 24.01%) ( 49.47%) 0.42% 0.49% ( 8.26%) 0.36% ( 9.84%) ( .27%)
16. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 16/18
The benefits of
Diversification.
What is your risk
position?
The long-term
returns of different
sectors and their
antagonistic
relationships.
Passive Investment
strategies.
20 Year financial
Landscape
Fixed Interest Rate
Investment yields’
should go up!
Fundamental interest
is currently
approximately 0%.
The capital value of
fixed interest
securities bonds will
fall.
Property: Capital value
of commercial property
could fall alongside
rising interest rates.
Property: But rising new
build costs invites
inflation proofing over
the long term
Macro: Future equity
values are uncertain due
to competition
turbulence.
Throughout this report, we have proposed a wide array of considerations. Yet at all times, we have made
an explicit effort to retain a perspective centred around the Client’s best interests. The foundation to our
evaluation has subsequently been based on the following:
Investment Forecast Sectors
17. 6/26/2015 Investment Presentation 17/17
Disclosure and Fund Information
The graphs and schedules within this presentation would not have been possible without access to the Dimensional Fund Advisors Ltd back tested
database of funds. The funds we have used were somewhat restricted due to the desire to show 20 years performance (many indices are only 5 to 10
years old). The specific indices we have used are:
Citigroup World Government Bond Index 1-30+ Years (hedged)
Dimensional Global Short-Dated Bond Index (gross of fees, hedged in )
Dimensional Small Cap Index
Dimensional Value Index
FTSE 100 Index
FTSE All-Share Index
MSCI Emerging Markets Index (gross div.)
MSCI World ex UK Index (gross div.)
S&P Global Property Index (gross div.)
S&P Global REIT Index (gross div.)
One-Month Treasury Bills
Retail Price Index
In addition we have used Bank of England data concerning interest rates and related issues. Wherever possible we have included dividend income in
the returns so as to compare all investments on a like for like basis.
•We have taken no account of charges (except in our comments re active fund managers) although clearly charges have a major effect on long term
performance.
•We have taken no account of taxation within our figures. At present in the UK capital gains tax is at a maximum of 28% and income tax is at a
maximum of 45%. This makes a colossal difference to the end return on your investments.
•Performance data shown represents past performance. Past performance is no guarantee of future results and current performance may be higher or
lower than the performance shown.
And finally, whilst we have tried our best to ensure that we have presented you with an accurate and well reasoned presentation any advice we give to
clients must be client specific and not of a generalised nature. E.&.O.E.