Watch the presentation of this webinar here: https://bit.ly/2VRylbi
How can you keep an adventitious virus from contaminating your gene therapy that is delivered by an adeno virus vector? As viral vector bioprocessing advances, regulatory requirements for viral safety will as well. Learn how to define your viral clearance strategy for AAV delivered gene therapies.
How do you define a strategy for viral clearance for a process that inherently aims at purifying a virus?
Gene delivery using AAV has received a boost from two major approvals and the nearly 300 programs in the clinic. Novel gene therapies using viral vectors enable companies to transform the lives of people living with certain rare and ultra-rare diseases where treatments are often not available currently. Amongst a multitude of challenges in viral vector bioprocessing, uncertainty in regulatory expectations is a major challenge to gene therapy developers. Regulatory requirements are evolving as the science and manufacturing matures with more stringent measures for viral safety assurance expected for future approvals.
Learn how to implement techniques for adventitious virus removal in your viral vector process; we will focus on strategies for viral clearance along your journey towards commercial readiness of AAV-based processes.
In this webinar, you will learn:
• AAV process flows and focus areas for viral safety
• Strategies for implementing viral clearance measures in bioprocessing
• Case studies and data driven approaches on log reduction values (LRV) in a viral vector process
• Best practices and evaluation roadmaps on conducting viral clearance studies
Presented by: Ratish Krishnan, Senior Strategy Consultant, Novel Modalities Bioprocessing
#9711199012# African Student Escorts in Delhi 😘 Call Girls Delhi
Keeping the (Adventitious) Virus Out of the (Adeno-Associated) Virus
1. Ratish Krishnan
Sr Strategy Consultant
Novel Modalities BioProcessing – Americas
12 Aug 2021
Keeping the (Adventitious) Virus out of
(Adeno-associated) Virus!
Approaches for
Viral safety in
AAV Processes
2. 2
The Life Science business of
Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany
operates as MilliporeSigma
in the U.S. and Canada.
3. The life science business of Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany operates as MilliporeSigma in the U.S. and Canada.
1. Background
2. Risk Mitigation Strategy
Prevent
Remove
Detect
3. Looking Ahead – Best Practices
OUTLINE
5. High unmet need and potential cures
5
< 5%
approved
therapy
Definition Data Population
~7000
Product Name Company
Type of
Therapy
Imlygic® Amgen
Oncolytic
virus
Yescarta® Kite (Gilead) CAR-T
Kymriah® Novartis CAR-T
Strimvelis® GSK
Gene
Therapy
Luxturna® Spark
Gene
Therapy
Zolgensma®
AveXis
(Novartis)
Gene
Therapy
Tecartus® Kite (Gilead) CAR-T
Breyanzi® BMS CAR-T
Abecma™ BMS CAR-T
Fastest growing sector in biotech; 1100+ active trials; $20B raised in 2020
Recent Approvals!
Rare diseases: Significant number among population
Source: FDA; ARM reports
• Affects < 200,000
people in US
• Primarily genetic
in origin
• No prior treatment
regimen available
1
in
10
• Children impacted most
• Survival rates are very low
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
6. Rushed PD is the New Normal
Compressed Timelines for Process Decisions
Years in pipeline 1 3 4 5 6 7 8
2
Phase III
Process Characterization PPQ
Control
Strategy
Submission Prep
Facility & Equipment
Readiness
Phase I Phase II
Process Development
Phase IIa/III
Process
Characterization
Control
Strategy
Submission
Prep
Facility & Equipment
Readiness
Process Development
PPQ
Years in pipeline
1 3 4 5 6 7 8
2
Phase I
6
Gene therapy manufacturers anticipate making post
approval changes in the manufacturing process. FDA
appears to be open* to such approach!
* Bridging studies, repeat PPQ and comparability demonstration minimally required
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
7. Regulatory Guidelines for Gene Therapies
Multiple Reference Documents
US FDA Guidance for Industry: Chemistry,
manufacturing and control (CMC) for
human gene therapy Investigational New
Drug Applications (INDs). (2020)
US FDA Guidance for Industry: Testing of
retroviral vector-based human gene
therapy products for replication competent
retrovirus during product manufacture and
patient follow-up. (2020)
WHO Recommendations for the evaluation of
animal cell cultures as substrates for the
manufacture of biological medicinal products
and for the characterization of cell banks. TRS
978, Annex 3 (2013)
ICH Q5A: Viral safety evaluation of
biotechnology products derived from cell
lines of human or animal origin. (1997)
ICH Q5D: Derivation and Characterization
of Cell Substrates used for Production of
Biotechnological /Biological Products
(1997)
1 3
2
4
CONSTANTLY
EVOLVING
Continuous Risk Assessment
Introduce viral clearance measures
Ongoing dialogue with agency
Draft guideline on quality, non-clinical and
clinical requirements for investigational
advanced therapy medicinal products in
clinical trials, EMA/CAT January 2019
EMA Guideline on the quality, non-clinical
and clinical aspects of gene therapy
medicinal products. EMA/CAT/80183/2014
March 2018
European Commission Guideline on Good
Manufacturing Practice specific to
Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products
(2017)
FDA
EMA
ICH
WHO
8. FDA Guidance Document
CMC Information for Human Gene Therapy INDs
8 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
10. Overview
Generic Process for Viral Vector Production
Raw
materials
Filtration
Clarification
Nuclease
Treatment
Concentration
and diafiltration
(UFDF)
Purification by
Chromatography
(multiple steps)
Concentration
and diafiltration
(UFDF)
Final filtration
Storage
Virus
production
Virus filtration
10 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
11. Does size matter?
Commonly used viruses
Item Adenovirus
Herpex
Simplex Virus
(HSV)
Adeno-
associated
Virus (AAV)
Lentivirus
(Retrovirus)
Genome ds DNA ds DNA ss DNA ss RNA
Coat Naked Enveloped Naked Enveloped
Genome Size 38-39 kb 150 kb 5 kb 9 kb
Transgene
Expression
Transient Transient
Potentially long-
lasting
Long-lasting
Packaging
Capability
7.5 kb >40 kb 4.5 kb 6 kb
Immune
Response
High Low Very low Low
Relative Viral
Titer
10^11 in bulk 10^9 in bulk 10^7 in bulk 10^7 in bulk
Relative
Transduction
Efficiency
100% 70% 70% 70%
Adenovirus
AAV
HSV
Lentivirus
11 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
12. Size does matter!
12
100nm 200nm 300nm
Vaccinia virus
200nm x 300nm
Adeno-
associate
Virus (AAV)
20nm
Adenovirus
60-90nm
Lentivirus or
Retrovirus
80-120nm
Sendai virus
260nm
Herpes simplex
virus (HSV)
~225nm
0.22 μm sterilizing
grade filter
Size increase
by aggregation
Biosafety
HSV
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
13. Basics of Virus Inactivation and Removal
Principles
DNA
Herpes
120 – 200nm
Pseuodorabies
(PRV)
Retro
80 – 110 nm
MuLV
Reo
60 – 80 nm
Reo 3
Parvo
~ 20 nm
AAV
Envelope
Protein
Lipid
Layer
Capsid
Protein
DNA
RNA
RNA
Removal
• Charge: IEX Chromatography
• Size: Virus Filtration
Inactivation
• Low/High pH, Detergent, Heat
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
13
14. Biosafety Strategy
Current Virus Reduction Technologies
Virus Filtration:
Size exclusion
viral clearance
Single Use Systems:
• Gamma irradiated
• Closed systems
• Aseptic sampling
Low pH/Solvent/Detergent:
Viral inactivation
Contract Labs:
Validation, detection and
characterization
HTST or UV:
Virus inactivation
Virus Resistant Cell Lines:
Prevent amplification in the
bioreactor
14 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
15. Biosafety
Millipore®
Preparation, Separation
Filtration & Monitoring Products
BioReliance®
Pharma & Biopharma
Manufacturing & Testing Services
SAFC®
Pharma & Biopharma
Raw Material Solutions
Biosafety Strategy
Tripod Approach for Complete Biosafety Assurance
15 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
16. Enveloped viral vectors; cell therapies
Non-enveloped viral vectors
Biosafety Strategy
Modified Approach for Enveloped Viruses
AAV
Lentivirus
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
16
19. Prevent
Raw Material Risk Mitigation Approach
“Point-of-origin”
• Low risk vendors
• Pretreated products (HTST pre-treated
glucose or gamma irradiated serum)
• Material origin (serum sourcing for BSE
mitigation)
“Point-of-use”
• Point of origin prevention will not mitigate
all components
• Virus barrier technologies
• Mitigate contamination from shipping
19
Eliminating or Reducing the Load with a Layered Approach
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
20. Identification of a new virus in Sf cell lines in 2014
by CBER*
Sf-Rhabdovirus Negative (RVN) cell line was
developed following work from the Jarvis group and
Glycobac technology
The absence of any rhabdovirus sequence was
proven Geisler, 2018**
Sf-RVN exhibit the same characteristics as non RVN
cell lines
In 2018 Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany obtained
the exclusive distribution license for the Sf9-RVN
cell line
Prevent
Sf-Rhabdovirus Negative Cell Line
*Ma et al, JVI, 201Identification of a Novel Rhabodovirus in Spodopteral frugiperda Cell line
**C. Gieser: A new approach for detecting adventitious viruses shows Sf-rhabdovirus-negative Sf-RVN cells are suitable for safe biologicals production, BMC
Biotechnology, 2018
Electron microscopy view of Sf-Rhabdovirus*
20 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
21. Prevent
Emprove® Quality and Regulatory Support
Emprove® Program
Addresses existing and anticipated quality
and regulatory requirements
Emprove® Dossiers
Supporting Qualification,
Risk Assessment and Process
Optimization
Emprove® Suite
24/7 access
Emprove® Portfolio
Chemicals addressing
different
risk levels
For Biologics: >400 different compendial raw materials in downstream/formulation
21
Value
Vs
Risk
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
23. Remove
Strategy for the Entire Process
Raw
material
Clarification Benzonase®
Endonuclease
Remove residual
DNA
Concentration
and diafiltration
(TFF)
Purification by
Chromatography
(multiple steps)
Concentration
and diafiltration
(TFF)
Millipak ® filter
Final filtration
Storage
Virus
production
NFR (For AAV process)
Remove
helper/adventitious
viruses
Viresolve ® Barrier
Remove virus, Bacteria,
mycoplasma
23
Remove
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
24. Remove
Viresolve® Barrier Filters
Robust protection from adventitious
agents
• ≥ 3.0 log removal of parvovirus
• ≥ 6.0 log removal of mycoplasma
• Sterilizing-grade protection from
bacteria
• Filters 100% integrity tested in
manufacturing
Efficient filtration for cell culture media
• No impact on media performance
• Fast, high-flux virus filtration
• Easy to implement, install and integrity
test
Chemically defined media only, Serum and hydrolysate are
difficult to filter; Eg., OptiCHO™ CD Media
24
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
0 100 200
Time (min)
300 400
Throughput
(L/m
2
)
Viresolve® Pro filter
Viresolve® NFP filter
Downstream Filter 1
Downstream Filter 2
Downstream Filter 3
Downstream
Filter 4
Viresolve® Barrier
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
25. Remove
Viresolve® Barrier Filters
Days
No changes in pH, osmolarity, glucose, glutamate, lactate, or NH3 levels were seen (as measured by BioProfile® FLEX).
No impact of virus filtration was observed on any cell culture attributes
Cellvento® CHO 200 Media with Molecule A EX-CELL® Advanced™ Media with Molecule B
0
2 4 6 8 1
0
1
2
1
4
Viable
Cell
Density
(cells
x
10
6
/mL)
Days
5
5
10
10
1
5
2
0
0
Virus Filtered
0.2 µm Filtered
0
15
20
- 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Viable
Cell
Density
(cells
x
10
6
mL)
Virus Filtered
0.2 µm Filtered
25 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
26. FDA – Cellular & Gene Therapy Guidance – Guidance for Industry: Guidance for
Human Somatic Cell Therapy and Gene Therapy:
[…] Gene therapy is a medical intervention based on modification of the genetic material
of living cells. Cells may be modified ex vivo for subsequent administration to humans, or
may be altered in vivo by gene therapy given directly to the subject. […]
Recombinant DNA materials used to transfer genetic material for such therapy are
considered components of gene therapy and as such are subject to regulatory
oversight.
[…]
1.Tests of drug substance (bulk product not necessarily in final formulation):
a. Purity (21 CFR 610.13)
[…] iii. Test for contamination with RNA or with host DNA, e.g. gel electrophoresis,
including test with bacterial host-specific probe. […]
• FDA requires DNA/RNA digestion (reduce the risk for the patients)
• Higher virus yields
• Drug Master File type II available (Benzonase® Endonuclease treatment is FDA approved
process, DMF could be cited by our customer in their drug filing)
• Full EMPROVE® dossiers
Literature on the use of Benzonase® Endonuclease
in Cell Therapy and Gene Therapy:
Templated Process using Benzonase®
Endonuclease:
Bioprocess Int. 2012 February ; 10(2): 32–43.
Production of CGMP-Grade Lentiviral Vectors
Lara J. Ausubel et al.
Benzonase® Endonuclease used in 7 of 11 described
trials:
Methods & Clinical Development (2016) 3, 16002;
doi:10.1038/mtm.2016.2
Manufacturing of recombinant adeno-associated viral
vectors for clinical trials
Nathalie Clément and Joshua C Grieger
26
Remove
DNA Removal in Gene Therapy
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
27. 27
DNA Digestion
Processing Challenges Caused by Nucleic Acids
BENEFITS
Frees virus from DNA Protects against DNA fouling Reduces viscosity
Yield loss due to virus-nucleic
acid complexes
Changes in virus / protein
characteristics
Unpredictable purification (shift in
pI, retention times etc.)
Low recovery and purity
Fouling of downstream
equipment
Shortened lifetime of
chromatography columns
Reduced capacity of filters
Viscosity increase
Impedes liquid handling
Reduced efficiency of
separation methods
Easy Removal Animal-Origin Free
(Benzonase® Endonuclease Safety Plus)
PATIENT SAFETY
…minimize the biological activity of any residual DNA
associated with your vector… limit the amount of
residual DNA for continuous non-tumorigenic cells to
less than 10 ng/dose and the DNA size to below
approximately 200 base pairs.
Source: Chemistry, Manufacturing, and Control (CMC) Information for Human Gene Therapy Investigational New
Drug Applications (INDs) Draft Guidance for Industry – FDA
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
28. Benzonase® endonuclease Safety Plus EMPROVE® Expert
Specifications
Standard Benzonase®
Endonuclease
Benzonase®
Endonuclease Safety
Plus EMPROVE®
Expert
Lot release testing for
Mycoplasma
No Yes
Lot release in-vitro test for
absence of adventitious viruses
(3 cell lines) by BioReliance®
Services
No Yes
Chemically defined fermentation
media to claim non-animal origin
No
Yes
(animal origin-free)
Microbial testing < 10 CFU/100,000 U < 10 CFU/100,000 U
Endotoxins (LAL) < 0.25 EU/1,000 U < 0.25 EU/1,000 U
FDA Drug master file (DMF) Yes Yes
Shipment with temperature strips
No Yes
Tailgate Samples No
Yes
(with 5M unit size)
Product Availability
Both Benzonase® Endonuclease products will
stay in portfolio
28
ASGCT Poster May 2020 – Ratish Krishnan
Remove
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
29. Virus Safety Strategy
Helper/Adventitious Virus Removal
29
Viresolve® Normal Flow
Retrovirus (NFR) filter
Pleated Retropore® membrane
≥ 6 log removal of retroviruses
> 98% recovery of protein (up to 700 kD)
100% integrity tested in manufacturing
Air-water diffusion integrity testable
SIP/autoclave compatible
Viresolve® NFR filter
Helper / Adventitious
virus retained
AAV passes
through
Data presented at ACS 2019, Orlando FL
Study Summary
• Capacity > 2e16 vp
• Throughput 115 L/m2
• Recovery > 90%
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
30. Remove
Maximizing Yield with Millipak® Filter
• Unique stacked design allows minimal hold-up volume and particle
shedding
• Constructed with Durapore® PVDF membranes for high flow rates
and throughputs
• Various stack sizes for optimum flexibility
Filter EFA
Total
Volume
(mL)
Downstream
Volume (mL)
Hold up
Volume
(mL)
Millipak® 200
Filter
1,000 cm² 130 40 9
Opticap® XL 2
Capsule
900 cm² 225 30 15
Benefits
• Minimum hold up volume and
protein binding
• Maximum product recovery
and cost savings
• Fully supported with different
formats and documentation
Millipak® 200 Filter VS Opticap® XL 2 Capsule
30 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
31. Perform normal 0.22μm
sterilizing filtration at final
filling step
Optimize process parameters,
in-process buffer and final
filling solution to control
aggregation
Perform normal 0.22μm
sterilizing filtration at final
filling step
Use sterilized raw materials to
prevent potential contamination
Implement closed processing
Adapt appropriate in-process
bioburden control method (e.g.,
2 x 0.45μm filters)
Remove
Sterilization Strategies for Viral Vectors
Small to Medium Virus Medium Aggregating Virus Large Virus (> 0.22μm)
Adeno-associate virus (AAV)
Adenovirus (AdV)
Retrovirus (RV)
Lentivirus (LV)
Herpes simplex virus (HSV)
Sendai virus
Vaccinia virus
31 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
34. Detect
Cell Banks Biosafety Testing
MCB WCB CAL*
Sterility: Bacteria, fungi &
mycoplasma
Adventitious viruses: In
vitro, in vivo & PCR
Retroviruses: EM, RT &
infectivity
Species specific viruses:
(PCR), ex: CMV, HIV, EBV,
HCV
Sterility: Bacteria, fungi &
mycoplasma
Adventitious viruses: In vitro
Sterility: Bacteria, fungi
& mycoplasma
Tumorigenicity: Nude
mice in vivo tumor
formation
Adventitious viruses: In
vitro, in vivo
Retroviruses: EM, RT &
retrovirus infectivity
Species specific viruses:
(PCR)
*Maximum use cells / Cells at Limit of in vitro cell age
34 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
35. Detect
Recommended Testing Options
35
AAV Lenti/Retrovirus Adenovirus
Identity
• PCR for Genomic Region of Interest
• AAV Serotype
• Vector Sequence (NGS)
Titer
• TCID50 Assay
• Genomic Titer by Droplet Digital PCR
Potency
• r-AAV Expressed Protein
Purity
• Sterility (also rapid method)
• Mycoplasma/Spiroplasma (also rapid method)
• Endotoxin
• In Vitro Adventitious Viruses
• In Vivo Adventitious Viruses
• Replication Competent AAV
Process/Product Residuals
• PCR for helper viruses or transfected plasmids
• Host Cell DNA
• Host Cell Protein
• DNA Size Distribution
• Empty/Full Capsid by AUC
• Residual AAV Ligand
• Residual Benzonase® Endonuclease
• Residual BSA
Final Product Characterization
• Vector Aggregates by DLS
• Osmolality
• pH
• Appearance
• Particulates
Identity
• PCR for Genomic Region of Interest
• Vector Sequence (NGS)
Titer
• TCID50 Assay
• Genomic Titer by Droplet Digital PCR
Potency
• r-LV/RV Expressed Protein
Purity
• Sterility (also rapid method)
• Mycoplasma/Spiroplasma (also rapid method)
• Endotoxin
• In Vitro Adventitious Viruses
• In Vivo Adventitious Viruses
• Replication Competent LV
Process/Product Residuals
• PCR for transfected plasmids
• Host Cell DNA
• Host Cell Protein
• DNA Size Distribution
• Residual Benzonase® Endonuclease
• Residual BSA
Final Product Characterization
• Vector Aggregates by DLS
• Quantitation of LV Particles Using Virus Particle Counter
• Osmolality
• pH
• Appearance
• Particulates
Identity
• PCR for Genomic Region of Interest
• Vector Sequence (NGS)
• Restriction Endonuclease Analysis for ID of Purified
Adenovirus Vector
Titer
• FFU Assay
• Genomic Titer by Droplet Digital PCR
Potency
• r-Adeno Expressed Protein
Purity
• Sterility (also rapid method)
• Mycoplasma/Spiroplasma (also rapid method)
• Endotoxin
• In Vitro Adventitious Viruses
• In Vivo Adventitious Viruses
• Replication Competent Adenovirus
Process/Product Residuals
• PCR for transfected plasmids
• qPCR Detection of AAV
• Host Cell DNA
• Host Cell Protein
• DNA Size Distribution
• Residual Benzonase® Endonuclease
• Residual BSA
Final Product Characterization
• Vector Aggregates by DLS
• Osmolality
• pH
• Appearance
• Particulates
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
36. Human 293
producer cells
Virus stock Vector bulk
harvest
Vector
purified
MCB WCB
Absence of microbial contamination
Sterility assay
Mycoplasma assay
Absence of adventitious viruses
In-vitro assay (3 detector cell lines, 28 days)
In-vivo (embryonated eggs suckling & adult mice
Transmission electron microscopy
PCR/RT-PCR assays for human viruses
PERT assay
Bovine virus assay
Porcine virus assay
Porcine circovirus
Absence of replication competent vectors
Other tests (biosafety related)
Host cell DNA
Residual plasmids
Endotoxin
Detect
Testing Regimen Recap
36 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
37. Detect
Next Generation Sequencing: An Additional Tool
“Is the biologic system
what is believed to be”?
“ Is the system
contaminated or impure? “
Genetic properties of the
MVSS
(identity/purity/stability)
Adventitious agent testing Raw material qualification
In process testing Lot release testing
• EP is recommending reducing in vivo virus detection assays and supplementing classical
virus detection and identity assays with new technologies such as NGS analysis
37
1. Sample
Processing
Nucleic Acid
Extraction &
Library
Construction
2. Sequencing
3. Data Analytics /
Bioinformatics
• Personalized Medicine and
Clinical Applications
• Biosafety Testing
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
MVSS – master virus seed stock
39. Viral Clearance Template
Evaluation Roadmap
39
Detergent Treatment
Low pH Hold
Nanofiltration
Nuclease Digestion
Chromatography
(multiple)
Leverage
•Past templates
•Other modalities
Analyze
•Current Process
•Midstream and
Downstream
Unit Operations
Experiment
•Non-GLP study
•Preliminary
results
Confirm
•GLP study
•Representative
Material
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
40. 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Log
Reduction
Value
Time (min)
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Titer
(logTCID
50
/mL)
Time (min)
0.5% TX-100
0.5% TDAO
Indicates no
detectable virus
Indicates no
detectable virus
TDAO detergent meets ASTM E3042-16 assurance of ≥4 log10 of infectious
rodent retrovirus (xMuLV) inactivation obtained with Triton™ X-100 treatment
within E3042-16 hold time of 60 min. No virus was detected in samples treated
with TDAO detergent within 5 min.
40
Virus Titer LRV
[Detergent]: 0.5% v/v
pH 8
Hold temp: 21-24°C
xMuLV in Clarified Harvest
Virus inactivation: Deviron™ C16 detergent vs. Triton™ X-100
0.5% Triton ™
X-100
0.5% TDAO
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
41. 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Titer
(logTCID
50
/mL)
Time (min)
1.0% TX-100
1.0% TDAO
0.5% TX-100
0.5% TDAO
TDAO detergent is as effective as Triton™ X-100 in the inactivation of other
enveloped viruses such as Pseudorabies Virus (PRV). No active virus was
detected after 5 min incubation at RT.
Indicates no
detectable virus
Indicates no
detectable virus
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Log
Reduction
Value
Time (min)
41
[Detergent]: 1.0% v/v
0.5% v/v
pH 8.0
Hold temp: 21-24°C
Virus Titer LRV
Virus inactivation: Deviron™ C16 detergent vs. Triton™ X-100
PRV in Clarified Harvest
0.5% Triton ™
X-100
0.5% TDAO
1% Triton ™ X-
100
1% TDAO
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
42. LRV data
Evidence of viral load reduction
42
Log10 Virus
Reduction of
BACV
Process Step
Log10 Virus
Reduction of
VSV
3.48 Low pH Inactivation 1.16
≥5.15 Detergent Inactivation ≥4.41
≥6.70 Chromatography 1 ≥6.08
2.67 Chromatography 2 3.93
1.82 Chromatography 3 3.84
≥4.41 Nanofiltration ≥4.83
ANALYSIS
• Low pH can achieve
inactivation of enveloped
viruses; reduction is
dependent on the pH and
the susceptibility of
individual viruses to low
pH.
• Detergent can achieve
effective inactivation of
enveloped viruses.
• Reduction by
chromatography is
dependent on the resin,
the conditions under
which the chromatography
step is run and the virus
itself.
• Nanofiltration provides
another useful assurance
to viral vector processes.
Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21
24.23 24.25
19.42
19.82
43. Take Away Messages
Conclusion
Strategy: Develop a multi-faceted contamination risk mitigation strategy when developing
a viral gene therapy
Prevent: Ensure safety of raw materials
Detect: Implement rigorous testing procedures for raw materials, cell banks, virus seed stocks,
bulk harvests and drug substances
Remove: Wherever possible implement virus, DNA & bacterial contaminant clearance
technologies
Solution: Partner with experts to develop your biosafety assurance strategy
43 Approaches for Viral Safety in AAV processes | 12 Aug 21