This document appears to be an email chain discussing a complaint made against an Immigration Judge for making an anti-Muslim remark on September 15, 2010. Larry Dean provides updates on counseling the judge, including plans to conduct an oral counseling during a trip to El Paso. On July 1, 2011, Dean confirms he closed out the counseling.

1. Mouttnh(), Deborah (EOIR) Page 23. 12-20- l4 Release.
From: Keler, MaryBeth(EOIR)
Sent: Monday, Joly 11, 2011 10:35 Aft,.
To: Moutinho, Deborah (EOIR)
Subject; FW: Complaintre IJ WilliamLee Abbott (El Paso) - September 15, 2010 Anti-Muslim
remark.
3demeritsfor LallY Dean...©
From:Dean,LarryR. (EOIR)
sent: Thursday, July 07, 2011 12:57 PM
To: Keller,MaryBeth (EOJR)
Subject: RE:Complaintre u WIiiiamLee Abbott (El Paso)- september 15, 2010Anti-Muslimremark.
July 1, 2011. Sony.
Still have to write the complainant, too.
LRD
From: Keller,MarySett, (EOIR)
Sent: Thursday, July 07, 2011 10:07 AM
To: Dean, Lany R. (EOIR)
Cc: Moutinho,Oeboral'I(EOIR)
SUbjeet: RE:Complaintre D WilliamLeeAbbott (El Paso)- September15, 2010Anti-Muslimremar1<.
Larry,
Don't forget to give us the date on this oral c:ounseling...thanks!
mtk
From:Keller,MaryBeth (EOIR)
sent: Wednesday, June 29, 201112:02 PM
To: Dean, LarryR. (EOIR)
Cc: Moutinho,Deborah(EOIR)
Subject: RE:Complaintre U WilliamLeeAbbott (B Paso)- September15, 2010Anti·Muslimremark.
Thankyou -
mtk
From:Dean,LarryR.(EOIR)
Sent: Wednesd~y, June29, 201111:58 AM
To: Keller,MaryBeth (EOIR)
Cc: Moutinho, Deborah{EOIR)
subject: RE:Complaint re IJ William Lee Abbott (8 Paso)- September 15, 2010Anti-Muslimremark.
That'sthe plan. I am in El Pasotomorrow. I will closethe counselingoutthen andwill sendan e-mail
confirming.
LRD
From:Keller, MaryBeth(EOIR)
sent: Wednesday,June29,201110:56AM
To:Dean,LarryR.(EOIR)
Cc: Moutinho, Deborah (EOIR)
Subject: RE:Complaintre lJ WilliamLeeAbbott (ElPaso)• September15, 2010Anti-Muslim remali(.
7/11/2011
~ -

2. pg. 22)
22 (same as 4857 499 Email 6/24/1 1 Burr Moutinho 9
pg. 21)
23 4864 503 Email 7/11/1 1 Keller Moutinho Joke about the work ACIJ needed to do
close complaint
24 4940 520 Email 8/10/11 Bmr Keller 9 ACIJsdiscussingtheirvacations/plans
forvacation
25(same as 4967 524 Email 8/22/11 Kelly Moutinho 9
35 in 1/13)
26 4983 563 Email 11/8/11 Smith Keller 1
27 (sameas 5034 591 Email 1/9/12 Maggard Keller n/a ACIJinformingotherACIJabouthis
pg. 133in scheduleso that theycouldplanto talk
2/5)

3. complaint complaint complaint
IJ Code Number Open Date Closed Date
HFX 495 05/16/ 11 05/26/11
EXB 496 05/13/ 11 05/17/11
XUM 497 05/17/ 11 06/20/11
PSI 498 05/17/ 11 06/24/11
PSI 499 05/16/ 11 06/24/11
XLN 500 05/23/ 11 05/31/11
OPU 501 09/07/ 11 09/16/11
TXY 502 06/09/ 11 06/22/11
DWL ~03l 06/16/ 11 01/11/07
QJC 504 05/18/ 11 06/01/11
LLN 505 06/20/ 11 06/21/11
I-IPV F;nR nR1?n1 1 1 nR/?7/11

4. - Detail
Complaint Number: S03
Curreni ACIJ
Dean, Lany R.
PastAa.JS:
b)(6)
Immigration Judge: (b)(6)
ComplaiatNat•'N(s)
In-coonconduct
Status
CLOSED
RespondentAtty
Cooaplainf Received Date: 06/16/ 11
Final Actiun
Oralcounseling
Compbiat Sourct(s)
FinalActionDate
07/01/11
·-----------1
(b) (6)
Ct>mplaiotNan-atlve: lj hadan inappropriateprc-con~ivednotionaboutMuslims.madedi$paragingordismissivecommentsaboutMuslimreligion.and
judgedRasa Muslimw/oknowingwhetherRwasa Muslim.
06/16/ 11
06/16/11
06/16/1I
06/17/11
07/01/11
06/04/12
Sep 11,2013
/CU Listened toDAR
Complaintreferredto ACIJ
Copyof 589sentto ACIJper his request.
Databas(:entrycreated
Oralcounseling
ACIJrespondedto attorney'sfollow-upletter
---.,·---- ··--·ComplaintHim,ry
----~- ·----'
1 of 1