Introduction to
Geophysical Exploration
Methods-Gravity
DR. RAJIB KUMAR SINHARAY
PhD, MScTech (Applied Geophysics)
Associate Professor
Department of Petroleum Engineering
Maharashtra Institute of Technology (MIT)-World Peace University (MIT-WPU), Pune
2.
o Associate Professor,MIT-World Peace University (WPU), Pune (2018-till date)
o Senior Geophysicist, Reliance Industries Limited, Mumbai (2009-2018)
o EM Geophysicist, Regional Technology Centre (RTC), Schlumberger, Mumbai (2007-2009)
o Junior Data Processor and Interpretor (DPI), WesternGeco Electromagnetics, Mumbai (2007)
o Member of XXII Indian Scientific Expedition to Antarctica (ISEA), Antarctica, 2003
o Research Assistant, Central Water and Power Research Station, Pune (2001-2006)
o Junior and Senior Research Fellow, Indian School of Mines (IIT(ISM)), Dhanbad (1998-2001)
o Master in Science and Technology in Applied Geophysics, IIT, Dhanbad (1994-1997)
o Bachelor of Science in Physics, University of Calcutta, Kolkata (1990-1993)
DR. RAJIB K. SINHARAY
Mobile/WhatsApp: +91-9004071757
email: rajib.Sinharay@mitpune.edu.in.com/ rsrism@gmail.com
3.
Safety in FieldWork
The highest priority in any field work!
1. Be Alert!
2. Read instrument manual thoroughly
3. Follow dos and don’ts strictly
4. Must wear safety gears
5. Carry First-Aid Box
6. Know locations and area before hand
7. Save data always in different storages simultaniously
Latitude Corrections
gP =gE + 6467+ 3370 - 4800 mgal = gE +5037 mgal
These variation of g with latitude θ:
g (θ) = 9.78031846 (1+ 0.0053024 sin ² θ – 0.0000058 sin² 2θ)
This equation is called the Geodetic Reference System for 1967.
Geoid
The geoid isa surface of constant potential energy that coincides with mean sea level over
the oceans. This definition is not very rigorous. First, mean sea level is not quite a surface of
constant potential due to dynamic processes within the ocean. Second, the actual
equipotential surface under continents is warped by the gravitational attraction of the
overlying mass. But geodesists define the geoid asthough that mass were always
underneath the geoid instead of above it. The main function of the geoid in geodesy is to
serve as a reference surface for leveling. The elevation measured by leveling is relative to
the geoid.
26.
ESA's GOCE missionhas delivered the most accurate model of the 'geoid' ever produced.
Red corresponds to points with higher gravity, and blue to points with lower gravity.
Case Study
Gravity anomaliesof the active mud diapirs off southwest Taiwan
W. Doo, Shu-Kun Hsu, Shu-Kun Hsu, Yi-Ching Yeh, Yi-Ching Yeh…….
December 2015
Geophysical Journal International 203(3):2089-2098
DOI: 10.1093/gji/ggv430
Filtering Methods
■ Measuredgravity values are plotted at different measurement points
■ Spatial wavelengths are calculated
■ High Cut, Low Cut and Band Pass filters are used to separate different spatial
frequency responses
■ Depth are estimated depending on frequencies of the signals
68.
Applications for Hydrocarbon
Exploration
■Mapping of sedimentary basins
■ Study of salt domes
■ Mapping of basement of sedimentary basin
■ Mapping of intrusive bodies i.e. dyke, seals, vents
■ Mapping of basalts and carbonate formations
Units of Measurements
■The magnetic field strength, H, is defined as the force per unit pole strength.
■ MKS unit: Force is N and magnetic monopoles in Amp - m, the units associated with
magnetic field strength are N / (Amp - m).
■ N / (Amp - m)=T (Tesla). Earth’s magnetic field=0.5 T
■ Magnetic anomaly are measured in nano Tesla (nT) which is 10-9
T
■ 1 Gamma=1 nT= 10-9
T
Magnetometers
■ Measures themagnetic field intensity (in nT or Gamma) along with inclination and
declinations
■ Schmidt type magnetometer
■ Torsion magnetometer
■ Flux gate magnetometer
■ Nuclear or the proton magnetometer
■ Rubidium vapour magnetometer
Fluxgate Magnetometer
■ Thefluxgate magnetometer is based on the
magnetic saturation circuit.
■ Two parallel bars of a ferromagnetic material
are placed closely together.
■ Each bar is rapped with a primary coil in reverse
direction
■ Difference of magnetic field creates potential
difference which is measured by secondary coil
■ Accuracy: 0.5 to 1.0 nT
Proton Precession Magnetometer
■The most commonly used magnetometer and measures
the total amplitude
■ The sensor is a cylindrical container filled with a liquid
rich in hydrogen atoms (water/ oil/ alcohol etc.)
surrounded by a coil
■ Measures current produced by spinning hydrogen
nuclei, they begin to precess around the direction of the
Earth’s total field
■ Frequency of precession is proportional to the strength
of the total field
■ Accuracy: 0.1 nT
Survey Modes
■ Airborne- Both fluxgate and proton precession magnetometers can be
mounted within or towed behind aircraft, including helicopters. Most
difficult problems associated with aeromagnetic surveys is fixing the
position of measuring point. Realtime, differential GPS systems are used to
solve this problem.
■ Shipborne - Magnetic surveys can also be completed over water by towing a
magnetometer behind a ship.
■ Ground Based - Magnetic surveys are also commonly conducted on foot or
with a vehicle. Ground-based surveys may be necessary when the target of
interest requires more closely-spaced readings.
88.
Magnetic Anomaly
■ Geomagneticforces are
perpendicular to the surface only at
poles
■ Geomagnetic field is horizontal at
equator
■ Geomagnetic field inclination varies
between equator and pole from 0 to
90o
depending on latitude
■ Magnetization and polarity of rocks
depends on latitude of occurrences
95.
Rate of changeof declination at Greenwich (GRW), Abinger (ABN), Hartland (HAD), Eskdalemuir (ESK) and
Lerwick (LER) observatories
Source of GeomagneticField
■ 99% from the Earth
– 94% dipole field
– 5% non-dipole field
■ 1% current in ionosphere
– diurnal variations
– magnetic storms
Diurnal Correction
■ Referencemagnetometer at Base Station (BS)
■ Continuously record magnetic field variation
with time (diurnal) at BS
■ Compensate the variation depending on the
time of measurement
■ Range of variation may be up to 20-80 nT
BS
Regional-Residual Separation
■ Estimatesof the regional field :
– IGRF (large area)
– Graphical method (local investigations)
– polynomial curves generated using least squares
– inversion at a large scale to define a regional field.
BResidual= BObserved−BRegional
Magnetic Anomaly &Declination
Magnetic anomaly from a vertically orientation 2 m pole for differing inclinations of the Earth’s field: a) 90o
, b) 45o
and c) 0o
.
Reduced To Pole(RTP)
Preferred when measurements are at higher latitude
Removes the dependence of magnetic data on the magnetic inclination
Converting data to what they would have looked like at Pole where field is
vertical
Reduction to the pole removes anomaly asymmetry caused by inclination
Locates anomalies above the causative bodies
Assumes that the remanent magnetism is small compared to the induced
magnetism.
Difficult to do at low magnetic inclinations
Quantitative Interpretation ofRTP
■ Dipole: Object is a compact body
Z X
∼ 1/2
■ Monopole: Object is an extended
body
Z ½ * X
∼ 1/2
Half-width, X1/2, as the width of the anomaly at half its
maximum
119.
Reduced To Equator(RTE)
■ Preferred when measurements are at low latitude
■ Reduction-to-Equator is a mathematical transformation of the total magnetic
intensity field at its observed inclination (I) and declination (D) to that of the
magnetic equator. I=0o
.
■ Difficult to use if measurements are in higher latitude
Magnetic Gradient: Vertical
Thevertical magnetic gradient offers a better means of
detecting near surface magnetic sources than total
magnetic field measurements, making the gradient method
ideal for mineral prospecting.
Applications for Hydrocarbon
Exploration
■Mapping of sedimentary basins
■ Study of salt domes
■ Mapping of basement of sedimentary basin
■ Mapping of intrusive bodies i.e. dyke, seals, vents
■ Mapping of basalts and carbonate formations
Resistivity and ApparentResistivity
■ Electrical resistance of a material with unit cross-
sectional area and unit length is called the resistivity
(ῼ-m) or True Resistivity.
■ Resistance of a specific lithology can change depending
on physical dimension but resistivity remains constant.
■ The resistance of a formation comprising more than
one lithological units is called Apparent Resistivity. It
depends on the number of different lithology units,
true resistivity of each units and their thickness.
130.
Electrical Conductivity
■ Degreeof ease for flowing the electrical charges
■ Conductivity (σ) is a tensor, (S/m)
J is current density (A/m2
) and E is electric field (V/m). The
linearity hold for most of the materials
E
σ
J
E
x,y,x)
J
E
J
Current and PotentialElectrodes
■ Current Electrodes (A&B): Used to sent current
in the ground and connected to DC source.
Current (I) through the circuit is measured for
a certain separation AB. If AB increases
current decreases for a fixed voltage.
■ Potential Electrode (M&N): Connected to
voltmeter to measure voltage difference (∆V)
for a certain distance MN.
Depth of Penetrationand Plotting
Point
■ Plotting point is the mid point of MN
■ Increase of AB helps deeper penetration or
larger depth of penetration (DOP)
■ Higher ∆V indicates good signal to noise ratio
or more accuracy in measurements
Plotting Point
140.
Vertical Resistivity Sounding(VES)
■ Schlumberger Array is the common survey
method used for VES,
■ Resistivity of the formations along the
depth can be obtained at the plotting
points by increasing AB separations.
■ Apparent resistivity are plotted against
AB/2 on Log-Log graphs to obtained VES
curves.
Plotting Point
Ultrasonic? No Sonic(Seismic)
Method!
1. Uses Sound Wave with higher frequency (2.5-3.5 MHz) than audible sound (20Hz-2.0 MHz)
2. Create image of soft tissues
3. Object is few mm to few cm below the skin (surface)
157.
Seismic Method
■ Usesseismic waves of low frequencies (~ 12-120 Hz)
■ Image soft sedimentary rocks up to ~ 5 Km below surface
■ Seismic waves reflect back from sedimentary bed interfaces
Geophone
Seismic Signals
1. Lowfrequencies penetrates deeper
2. High frequencies have higher resolution
3. Longer off-sets have deeper penetration
4. Reflected energy is proportional to seismic impedance (density x velocity) contrast
5. Difficult to image below hard and compact rocks, i.e. Basalt
Difficult Questions!
1. Whatif there a hard rock above sedimentary
rock, i.e. basalt or carbonates ?
2. How to map petroleum system below a salt
dome?
3. Am I sure that this beautiful structure is not
volcanic?
4. Am I sure that there is Petroleum in my
prospect NOW ?
5. Is the Gas saturation is commercial?
Golden Pot
But
Is there
water now?
164.
Electromagnetic Methods
■ Magnetotelluric(MT)
– Natural Source
– Very Low Frequency (0.1-0.001 Hz)
– Deep penetrating up 100 Km
– May be both Land and Marine
■ Controlled Source Electromagnetic (CSEM)
– Artificial source
– Frequency 0,1 -10 Hz
– Depth of penetration
– Marine method
165.
Working Principle ofMT
Natural EM field from Ionosphere
Different Frequency
Senses Different
Depth
f
503
MMT Frequency
Range 1-0.0001 Hz
166.
Survey Layout ofMMT
Basalt (Resistive)
Sub-Basalt Sediment (Conductive)
Basement (Resistive)
Induced Current
Sediment (Conductive)
Reference
MT Station
167.
H
E
How E &H Behaves ?
“Time Series” Data for Marine Magnetotelluric (MMT). H(s) are Magnetic and E(s) are Electric
fields. On land we measure Hz also.
Ex
Ey
Hx
Hy
Time
Amplitude
168.
Concept of MT:Cagniard’s Relation
)
(
)
(
)
(
y
x H
Z
E
E (Secondary) H
(Primary)
Earth
Air
169.
Apparent Resistivity andPhase
Apparent
Resistivity
(Ohm-m)
Phase (Degree)
Period (S)
2
0.2
ij
ij
Z
a f
1
Im
tan
Re
ij
ij
ij
Z
Z
Apparent resistivity (ρ) and
Phase (φ) can be calculated
from Z at each frequency (f):
170.
Salt Bodies :Gulf of Mexico, WGEM
Sandburg
et
al.
(2008)
171.
■ Basement mapping
■Salt body mapping and subsalt basin studies
■ Volcanic basin studies
■ Crustal studies
Application of MT/MMT
Working Principles ofCSEM
Field components are recorded continuously
against time (Time-series data).
Field amplitude and phase are plotted
against Tx-Rx offset distances for a particular
frequency
Amplitude value increases due to presence of
sub-surface resistive bodies (i.e.,
hydrocarbon filled reservoirs)
Tx
Rx
Amplitude
(V/Am
)
2
Tx-Rx Offset (km)
Time
Hydrocarbon
saturated
reservoir
(Resistive)
Increased
amplitude
response
Seabed
CSEM Put Colourson Seismic
2.5 D CSEM Results Adding Value in
Conventional Seismic Section
178.
CSEM for HydrocarbonExploration
Capable to detect thing HC saturated resistive reservoir layer
Prospect Evaluation and de-risking
Ranking and Prioritization of prospects
Mapping the extension of reservoir
Reservoir Monitoring (Experimental)
#6 Using petroleum for civilization is a human idea. Integration of all different information is very important to discover hydrocarbon. Tools may be few or many but the main tool is human mind. Developing a expert mind of explorer is the most important thing. Students shuld passionately learn and analyse all information carefully to be an successful hydrocarbon explorer. Oil is in human mind to fuel human civilization to lead better life.
#7 One thing we need to understand that No single technique can guarantee the success in E&P. we need 5 fingers to hold a thing, we need five senses to understand one object or event. Similarly, to understand a unknown sub-surface prospect we need to use multiple techniques- geological, geophysical, well information, geochemistry etc.
#9 Geophysics is like Human senses. Different tools senses different physical property of reservoirs. Seismic maps different layers below the surface and measures the sound velocity at different depths. Gravity senses the density of sub-surface formations, magnetic measures the magnetic nature of the material, CSEM & MMT measures the electrical property of subsurface. Integration of all these and further analysis is done to decide a well location.
#167 Time varying natural Magnetic field (H) is the source field which induces secondary Electric field (E) inside the sub-surface. E is proportional to H and should be coherent. The receivers records the H and E field components in X and Y directions continuously for 48 hours or more. For Land MT, Hz is also measured.
#169 Time series data (E and Hs) are transformed into Frequency domain using Fast Fourier Transformation (FFT). Impedance “Z” is calculated for each frequency from measured E and H values. Apparent resistivity and Phase is calculated for each frequency (f) and plotted over a wide range of measured frequencies.