SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Aishona Jackson
Response Paper 3
Response to Daniel McCarthy's Essay
Daniel McCarthy's essay spoke to the ideologies of the United States party system, and
how the various wars affected those parties. In the essay he makes the point that our country says
that we are governed through a two party system, but in all actuality only one party runs at a
time. This means that yes two parties exists, but not both parties govern. I agree with Mr.
McCarthy's statement to an extent because due to the different beliefs the parties try to dominate
not only the vote but also on another. He ultimately states that the GOP no longer dominates and
the Democratic party is currently leading even though it was once deemed incompetent.
Although the GOP may not be the dominate party at the time, the Democratic party is not
necessairly dominating either. There is much division and friction within both parties, and
honestly the Democratic party needs to establish some sort of substance and control of it's own.
McCarthy states that the Vietnam war for the Democrats in 1969 is parallel to the Iraq
war to the GOP. This is a notion that I would not say I agree with, but I don't necessarily
disagree either. Yes both wars had a great impact on the culture war and the war on drugs, but
the Vietnam war received much more exposure and coverage than the Iraq war. The part on
which I agree is the reputation of both parties were at stake because of wars and the public has
very little understanding of foreign policy. Of course as long as we live the Republican Party will
forever be remembered for the Iraq war because of their continuous efforts to explain it and
make sense of the mistake.
In closing, I believe that Daniel McCarthy's essay is well beyond it's time and it is a great
read. His comparisons provided a greater understanding to the system of the American
government and the influence wars has on which party has dominated. Though his analogy
provides such perspective I think it is a little farfetched to say that the wars had the greatest
impact. I would say the media and coverage of the wars is what it all comes down to. Mr.
McCarthy made some great points when stating that the Republicans having lost the trust of
America due to these wars, but I would say the government as a whole is losing the trust of
citizens.

More Related Content

Similar to Document35 (1)

final draft
final draftfinal draft
final draft
Graham Scott
 
How fair is war in a society
How fair is war in a societyHow fair is war in a society
How fair is war in a society
Academic Research Paper Writing Services
 
Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?
Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?
Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?
Bruce LaCour
 
Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01
Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01
Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01
kinaahh
 
Taylor Block’s Discussion Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docx
Taylor Block’s Discussion        Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docxTaylor Block’s Discussion        Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docx
Taylor Block’s Discussion Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docx
rhetttrevannion
 
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdfDemocracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Wajid Khan MP
 
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdfDemocracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
WajidKhanMP
 
It Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docx
It Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docxIt Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docx
It Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docx
priestmanmable
 
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docxChapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
tiffanyd4
 
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docxChapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
mccormicknadine86
 

Similar to Document35 (1) (10)

final draft
final draftfinal draft
final draft
 
How fair is war in a society
How fair is war in a societyHow fair is war in a society
How fair is war in a society
 
Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?
Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?
Will The U.S. Split Into One or More Countries?
 
Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01
Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01
Pols2powerpoint5 130102145213-phpapp01
 
Taylor Block’s Discussion Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docx
Taylor Block’s Discussion        Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docxTaylor Block’s Discussion        Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docx
Taylor Block’s Discussion Aiko Herzig-Yoshinaga’s rec.docx
 
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdfDemocracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
 
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdfDemocracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
Democracy Become a Dictatorship.pdf
 
It Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docx
It Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docxIt Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docx
It Was Vital Not to Lose Vietnam by Force to Communism” .docx
 
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docxChapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
 
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docxChapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
Chapter 9International RelationsChapter Objectives1. Explain.docx
 

Document35 (1)

  • 1. Aishona Jackson Response Paper 3 Response to Daniel McCarthy's Essay Daniel McCarthy's essay spoke to the ideologies of the United States party system, and how the various wars affected those parties. In the essay he makes the point that our country says that we are governed through a two party system, but in all actuality only one party runs at a time. This means that yes two parties exists, but not both parties govern. I agree with Mr. McCarthy's statement to an extent because due to the different beliefs the parties try to dominate not only the vote but also on another. He ultimately states that the GOP no longer dominates and the Democratic party is currently leading even though it was once deemed incompetent. Although the GOP may not be the dominate party at the time, the Democratic party is not necessairly dominating either. There is much division and friction within both parties, and honestly the Democratic party needs to establish some sort of substance and control of it's own. McCarthy states that the Vietnam war for the Democrats in 1969 is parallel to the Iraq war to the GOP. This is a notion that I would not say I agree with, but I don't necessarily disagree either. Yes both wars had a great impact on the culture war and the war on drugs, but the Vietnam war received much more exposure and coverage than the Iraq war. The part on which I agree is the reputation of both parties were at stake because of wars and the public has very little understanding of foreign policy. Of course as long as we live the Republican Party will forever be remembered for the Iraq war because of their continuous efforts to explain it and make sense of the mistake.
  • 2. In closing, I believe that Daniel McCarthy's essay is well beyond it's time and it is a great read. His comparisons provided a greater understanding to the system of the American government and the influence wars has on which party has dominated. Though his analogy provides such perspective I think it is a little farfetched to say that the wars had the greatest impact. I would say the media and coverage of the wars is what it all comes down to. Mr. McCarthy made some great points when stating that the Republicans having lost the trust of America due to these wars, but I would say the government as a whole is losing the trust of citizens.