SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 56
Download to read offline
Polsinelli PC. In California, Polsinelli LLP
Distressed Asset Sales in Both
Bankruptcy and Its Out-of-Court
Alternatives
James E. Bird
Christopher A. Ward
Randye B. Soref
Jerry L. Switzer, Jr.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Distressed Asset Sales in Both Bankruptcy
and Its Out-of-Court Alternatives
Agenda
1. Discussion of considerations for selling distressed assets in bankruptcy and out-of-court
arrangements and minimizing the risk to the purchaser
2. Available Distressed Asset Sale Mechanisms, Pros & Cons of Each Alternative
A. Bankruptcy
B. UCC - Article 9 ”Friendly Foreclosure” Sale
C. Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors
D. Receivership (Federal vs. State)
E. Comparison of Each Alternative
3. Why explore non-bankruptcy alternatives
A. Cost
B. Control
C. Timing
4. What is on the horizon for 2015?
A. More non-bankruptcy asset sales
B. Focus on Distressed Health Care and Energy Sector Transactions
C. Increased use of receiverships
real challenges. real answers. sm
Panelists
Jim Bird – Kansas City (Practice Group Co-Chair)
Chris Ward – Delaware (Practice Group Co-Chair)
Randye Soref – Los Angeles
Jerry Switzer - Chicago
Complete biographies of our panelists can be found at the end of the
presentation or at www.polsinelli.com.
real challenges. real answers. sm
PURCHASE OF A DISTRESSED
BUSINESS OUTSIDE OF BANKRUPTCY
In most distressed business situations, it is
advisable for a buyer to directly purchase the
assets of such business rather than purchase
the equity of the entity that owns the business.
With some exceptions, in most states it is well
established that a buyer can “cherry pick” the
assets and liabilities it wants to purchase or
assume, leaving undesired assets and liabilities
with the owner. However, the seller or its lender
may resist a partial sale of assets.
real challenges. real answers. sm
In evaluating any opportunity to purchase a
distressed business, a fundamental decision is
whether to purchase assets through a
bankruptcy proceeding or one of several out-
of-court alternatives.
There are several factors that purchasers
should consider in this analysis:
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
1. Secured Debt. If the acquisition target has secured
debt, the only way to obtain the assets free and
clear of liens is to get consensual lien releases from
all lienholders or pay the senior secured creditors in
full or an agreed upon amount.
2. State and Local Taxes. Several states impose
successor liability on an asset purchaser with
respect to unpaid taxes of the seller, unless the
purchaser either (i) withholds the taxes from the
purchase price or (ii) obtains a tax clearance
certificate. If a business is distressed, this is more
than likely an issue.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
3. Bulk Sales Act. A few states still have “Bulk Sales
Laws” requiring certain notices and procedures to
creditors when the buyer is purchasing substantially
the entire inventory of a business but is not
assuming its liabilities. Failure to comply generally
results in liability for the purchaser to creditors of the
seller.
4. Collective Bargaining Agreements. A purchaser of
distressed assets may be required to recognize and
bargain with a union that represented the seller’s
employees.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
5. Underfunded Pensions. If seller participates in an
underfunded multi-employer union pension plan, a
sale of assets can result in immediate withdrawal
liability by the seller. Some courts have held a
buyer liable for a seller’s delinquent contributions
and withdrawal liability under such pension plans.
6. Environment Liabilities. Potential risk of liability to
federal and state environmental authorities.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
7. WARN Act Liability. Buyer may have liability
related to unpaid wages for the seller’s failure to
provide adequate notice to employees that the
business is closing, assuming that the seller has
enough employees to be covered by the WARN
Act or similar state labor laws.
8. Product Liabilities. Buyer may inherit certain
seller product liabilities pursuant to existing case
law.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
9. Successor Liability. Pursuant to common law, in certain
circumstances a seller and buyer may be considered to have
undergone a “de facto” merger or the buyer may be considered
a “mere continuation” of the seller, with the result that the buyer
is liable to creditors of the seller. The successor liability
analysis is similar to piercing the corporate veil discussed
immediately below.
10. Piercing the Corporate Veil. If there appears to be too many
corporate similarities between the seller and purchaser, a
creditor may seek to pierce the corporate veil of the purchaser
in order to hold it liable for the debts of the seller. There are
strong legal doctrines that protect the sanctity of a corporation,
but the parties need to be aware of the risk in structuring a
distressed asset transaction.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
11. Fraudulent Transfers. One of the biggest risks of purchasing a distressed business
is that, after closing, one or more creditors of the seller (or a bankruptcy trustee)
may attempt to set aside the sale on “fraudulent transfer grounds” (based on actual
or constructive fraud of creditors). Actual fraud involves an attempt by the debtor to
hinder, delay, or defraud its creditors. Most often creditors make a claim for
constructive fraud, which involves a transfer of assets for less than fair
consideration when the seller was insolvent or became insolvent as a result of the
sale. These actions can be brought under state law or federal bankruptcy law (with
2-6 year statute of limitations).
12. Seller’s Creditor Body. If the seller has aggressive or disgruntled creditors holding
large claims, there may be a greater risk of a successor liability or fraudulent
transfer claim. The same may be true if the nature of the seller’s business is such
that future (but currently unknown) and large general liability or similar claims might
arise. The holders of such future claims may be motivated to pursue the buyer. In
contrast, if the seller’s creditors are passive, disorganized or hold relatively small
claims, and if there is low risk of future claims, the risk of successor liability or
fraudulent transfer claims may be small.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
Considerations to Mitigate Risk
1. Perform proper due diligence – especially so with a
distressed business. Perform searches of state and
local records for financing statements and consensual
liens, tax and judgment liens, and lawsuit filings.
2. Buyer should consider setting up a new and separate
entity to affect the purchase in order to isolate the
purchased assets from possible unknown liabilities.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
Considerations to Mitigate Risk
3. To create a defense against post-closing fraudulent
transfer claims, the buyer should consider obtaining
an opinion of the value of the assets to be purchased
from a reputable appraiser.
4. Make certain that the sales proceeds are allocated
and distributed by the seller properly in order to
demonstrate to existing creditors that the sale was
conducted in good faith.
5. Purchaser should obtain seller indemnification from
attacks on the sale, including fraudulent transfer
claims, piercing the veil, or successor liability claims
from creditors.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
Considerations to Mitigate Risk
6. Negotiate a holdback or third party escrow for
a substantial amount of the purchase price to
cover post-closing issues and indemnification
agreements.
real challenges. real answers. sm
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
If sufficient value is involved, and if the
distressed business can survive the
bankruptcy process, the parties often will
benefit from a section 363 sale in a
bankruptcy proceeding. This provision allows
the Bankruptcy Court to approve a sale of
assets free and clear of liens, encumbrances,
and adverse claims and interests.
real challenges. real answers. sm
A. Pros Section 363 Sale
1. Simplicity and speed.
2. Avoidance of corporate law requirements to
obtain majority shareholder approval.
3. The right to sell property free and clear of
all liens, claims and other interests. The
power of the Bankruptcy Court to free the
debtor’s assets of claims and interests
makes it more attractive to a potential
buyer.
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
4. The right to assume and assign executory contracts
and unexpired leases of non-residential real property
pursuant to section 365 of the Bankruptcy Code that
are otherwise not assignable outside of bankruptcy.
(However, as a general rule, patent licenses,
government contracts, and personal service contracts
are not assignable even in bankruptcy.)
5. The right to sell property despite contractual anti-
bankruptcy provisions and similar sale restrictions.
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
6. The right to sell property co-owned by the debtor and other
person(s) under certain circumstances.
7. The right to a good faith purchaser finding pursuant to section
363(m) of the Bankruptcy Code.
8. Protection against the reversal or modification on appeal of a
consummated bankruptcy sale. The Bankruptcy Code provides
that an order approving a sale cannot be reversed or modified
on appeal unless either the party bringing the appeal obtains a
court stay of the sale while the appeal is pending (i.e., usually by
posting a significant bond) or the purchaser buys the assets in
bad faith. In addition, the Third Circuit, amongst others, has a
very strong equitable mootness doctrine on appeal.
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
9. Approval of the sale and appropriate findings by the
bankruptcy court should prevent subsequent
fraudulent conveyance, successor liability, or piercing
the corporate veil claims by creditors or other
disgruntled parties.
10. Some courts find that successor liability is an
“interest” subject to sale free and clear. Cases often
turn on whether a particular claim is known and could
have been brought into the bankruptcy and whether a
particular claimant receives adequate notice of a sale
and bankruptcy proceeding. Providing notice to
known or potential claimants may defeat later
successor liability arguments.
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
B. Cons Section 363 Sale
1. The section 363 sale process can be
somewhat time consuming and costly.
2. Potential for negative bankruptcy publicity,
damaging the reputation of the business,
and customer willingness to purchase
goods and services. Most, however, find
this concept to be incredibly overstated.
3. Distressed business may not be able to
survive even a quick bankruptcy process
without losing significant value.
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
4. Some Bankruptcy Courts will not allow a section 363 sale in
circumstances in which only the secured lender benefits (i.e.,
where no funds are going to unsecured creditors). A seller
must be prepared to deal with (i.e., provide a “tip”) to
disenfranchised creditors.
5. Some courts disagree that successor liability is an “interest”
subject to the sale free and clear.
6. Section 363 sales must be subject to an auction that will
entertain higher and better bids (i.e., a “stalking horse” bidder
could lose the bid to a competing party, yet the stalking horse
bidder may be entitled to a “Break Up Fee”).
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
7. Creditors may try to obtain leverage by
objecting to the process and attempt to
extract “holdup” concessions.
8. Secured creditors have rights to “credit bid”
their secured debt amount pursuant to
section 363(k) of the Bankruptcy Code
against their collateral being sold. As a
result, buyers will normally negotiate with
secured creditors during the sale process.
11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
A UCC - Article 9 “friendly foreclosure” is a situation in
which a troubled borrower cooperates with its lender
(generally an undersecured lender) to facilitate a
foreclosure sale. A friendly foreclosure will deliver title
from the borrower to the lender or a third-party buyer.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
Under the Uniform Commercial Code (“UCC”), in
particular UCC 9-610, a lender may sell collateral after
the borrower’s default “at any time and place and on any
terms,” so long as every aspect of the transaction is
“commercially reasonable.” The UCC allows a
foreclosing lender to choose between a public and a
private sale. The UCC requires a lender to send
“reasonable” notice of an intended sale to the borrower,
any secondary obligors, such as sureties or guarantors,
and unless the collateral is consumer goods, any other
party with a secured claim on the collateral that either
has perfected its claim by filing or has notified the
secured lender of that claim.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
In the usual friendly foreclosure, the lender, borrower,
and buyer enter into a three-way foreclosure agreement
similar to an asset purchase agreement. The agreement
is intended to affect a quick transfer of the borrower’s
assets to the buyer in an Article 9 foreclosure by private
sale. The borrower will normally confirm the value of the
assets are less than the secured debt and affirm the
lender’s right to foreclose in the manner specified in the
agreement. A borrower also may make certain
representations to the buyer about its business that the
lender may not be in a position to provide.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
A lender may warrant to the buyer that it is entitled to convey
title to the collateral in good faith, but it usually disclaims most
warranties and representations that customarily accompany a
non-distressed sale. The buyer agrees to take the collateral in
its current condition. In some sales the lender may not make
any warranty of good title, thus imposing all the risk on the
buyer. The buyer also may assume some of the borrower’s
specified liabilities, but usually excludes most of the borrower’s
obligations, including taxes, employee benefits, trade debts,
contracts, and tort liabilities. The buyer’s recourse to the
lender, if any, almost always is contractually limited to the
amount of consideration paid by the buyer. The lender may
choose to finance a portion of the purchase price by specifying
in the agreement that the buyer is taking title subject to a
portion of the existing debt held by the lender.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
Assuming the lender who brings the friendly
foreclosure is the most senior secured
lender, the sale of the borrower’s assets
under an Article 9 foreclosure will wipe out
the interests of all other junior creditors (who
received notice of the sale).
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
Pros To “Friendly Foreclosure”
1. Often faster and less costly than a section
363 bankruptcy sale.
2. Creditors have less opportunity to extract
“holdup” concessions from a lender during
a sale process.
3. Parties are not subject to Bankruptcy Court
review and procedures.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
4. Article 9 requires notice to a smaller group
of entities than does bankruptcy. (Vendors
and customers usually need not be notified,
which may make it easier to maintain
operating a borrower’s business than in a
bankruptcy.)
5. Article 6 “Bulk Transfer” laws are exempted
from transactions that settle liens, including
friendly foreclosures. See UCC 6-103.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
Cons To “Friendly Foreclosure”
1. If lender is not undersecured, there is a likelihood
that the foreclosure may be challenged by other
creditors (as a fraudulent transfer, successor
liability, or veil piercing).
2. Lender and borrower will usually disclaim
warranties. Typically occurs as an “As Is, Where
Is” Transaction.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
3. Failure of lender to send a commercially “reasonable”
notice of intended sale to the borrower, secondary
obligors and other lienholders may taint the sale and
cause such parties to seek to challenge the sale. The
sale price, the efforts to find alternative buyers, and the
lender’s good faith in maximizing the value of the
collateral are all considered by courts when
determining “commercial reasonableness.” In actions
involving a deficiency or surplus after the sale, the
lender may have the burden to prove the sale was
commercially reasonable. Unsecured creditors may
seek to prove the sale was not commercially
reasonable in aid of a successor liability or fraudulent
transfer claim.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
4. Article 9 sale will not wipe out any security interests
that are senior to the foreclosing lenders.
5. There is no established “safe harbor” (via a court
review) for Article 9 foreclosures like there is in a
bankruptcy section 363 sale.
6. There is no bankruptcy stay against third parties.
Thus, there is a threat of creditor adverse action (i.e.,
notice of UCC sale could prompt creditors to file an
involuntary petition against the debtor or create the
potential that the UCC sale could be challenged and
avoided as a fraudulent transfer).
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
7. A UCC Article 9 foreclosure does not apply to real
estate sales, and thus is not a great vehicle for
sale of an entire business if the business has
significant owned real estate. The real estate must
be transferred via other means, including a short
sale, deed-in-lieu related transaction or structured
foreclosure sale.
8. Inability to assign leases and other contracts
containing non-assignment clauses unlike a
section 363 bankruptcy sale.
real challenges. real answers. sm
UCC - ARTICLE 9 –
“FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE”
9. Creditors of the seller could challenge the transaction
on “successor liability” grounds.
real challenges. real answers. sm
Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors
A general assignment provides a means of liquidating the assets of a
debtor in an orderly, controlled manner. A general assignment is a
vehicle used for the sale or liquidation of a business. It is not used to
financially rehabilitate or “turn the business around”.
Assignments are either common law or statutory, and the law varies
from state to state as to which form of assignment is utilized. Generally,
states will follow one of two approaches to the assignment process.
One approach requires court supervision of the assignment and the
assignee (e.g., Delaware, California, New Jersey to name a few); the
other permits the assignments to proceed without court supervision, but
require that the assignee follow state laws applicable to and governing
the liquidation of a business and its assets.
35
real challenges. real answers. sm
Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors
It is easy to think of a common law assignment as similar
to Chapter 7
All assets of the Assignor is transferred to the Assignee
The Assignee liquidates the property
An Assignee may have the power to pursue preferences
and fraudulent conveyances depending on state law in
which the Assignment takes place
Distributions are made to creditors according to statutory
priority and based on claims
36
real challenges. real answers. sm
Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors
The Assignee is generally someone who is not related to or directly
involved in the management or the day-to-day operations of the debtor
(i.e. a disinterested third party).
Assignee is usually an individual experienced in the process of
liquidating businesses; however, an the Assignee may also be a
corporate entity with such experience.
An Assignment is consummated when the Assignee accepts the
Assignment Trust "contract,” or Deed of Trust from the Assignor.
Upon acceptance of the assignment “contract,” all of the Assignor’s
right, title and interest in its assets is “transferred” to the Assignee for
the purposes of liquidation.
The Assignee then becomes a fiduciary on behalf of any and all
creditors of the Assignor, as well as for the Assignor and, ultimately, its
owners/shareholders.
37
real challenges. real answers. sm
Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors
The Assignee must preserve the assets for the benefit of
creditors.
The Assignee must liquidate and administer assets fairly.
The transfer of assets is subject to any and all existing
liens, and the assignee is bound to honor all valid,
perfected and enforceable liens.
General assignments do not typically give a debtor a
discharge, as discharge of debts can only be achieved
through a bankruptcy case.
38
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership
Equitable proceeding in which a court
appoints a disinterested person, the
receiver, to receive, preserve and
protect designated assets or property
39
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: Federal vs. State
Advantages of Federal Receiverships over State
Receiverships
– National jurisdiction; solves diversity of jurisdiction
problem over supervision and control of assets
– “Free and clear” sales
– Incorporation of bankruptcy concepts
Advantages of State Receiverships over Federal
Receiverships
– Statutory authority for appointment of a receiver in a
variety of contexts; see e.g., California code of Civil
Procedure Section 564
40
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: Common Purposes
Facilitating injunctive relief
Taking custody of and managing property
Preserving assets and business books and records
Obtaining an accounting of assets, income and use of
proceeds
Locating hidden assets
Uncovering fraud and misappropriations
Exposing criminal enterprises
Involuntarily dissolution
Enforcing a judgment
41
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: Factors for Appointment
Probability that fraudulent conduct has occurred
or will occur to frustrate opponent
Imminent danger that property will be concealed,
lost or diminished in value
Inadequacy of other legal remedies
Lack of less drastic equitable remedy
Likelihood that appointment of receiver will do
more good than harm
Contractual consent to appointment upon default
42
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: Common Types
Custodial Receiver
Liquidating Receiver
Interim Operating Manager, status quo
Provisional Director
Fiscal Agent
Post-Judgment Receiver
43
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: For the Benefit Of:
Secured Lender
Judgment Creditor
Deadlocked corporate directors, LLC members or partners
Oppressed minority shareholder, member or partner
Creditors or equity holders seeking to take custody or:
– Bring and defend lawsuits; seek injunctive relief; issue subpoenas to obtain
documents
– Compel testimony and the production of documents and things
Notify customers and tenants of any change in name of payee or mailing address
for payments
Change locks and security codes
Intercept and redirect mail
Evict tenants
Obtain permits as needed, such as for managing real estate projects
Pay, where permitted, “pre-receivership” expenses
44
real challenges. real answers. sm
How the Receiver is Selected:
By secured lender
By court
By creditor’s or debtor’s counsel
In all events, court approval is required
The Receiver’s Relationship With Other Parties:
Officer of the court
Qualified fiduciary role with respect to debtor/company
Allegiance to secured lender by virtue of authority and purpose
Duty to subordinate creditors and equity interests
45
Receivership
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: The Receiver’s Duties
Locate and preserve assets
Provide accounting to the court
Fulfill purpose as stated in court order
establishing the receivership
46
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: Types of
Powers of a Receiver
Take possession of and mange assets, as specified in court order,
including cash in bank accounts, goods, rights and credits
Take possession, custody and control of licenses, documents,
books and records, emails in possession of accountants, attorneys
and other third parties
Administer business operations as though the receiver were the
owner or president
Borrow money similar to bankruptcy’s DIP loans, granting a super-
priority lien; i.e. “receiver certificates” similar to DIP financing
Manage bank accounts, change signature cards, open new
accounts
The Receivership Order can, and should, be tailored to fit whatever
powers and duties the Receiver may need in their appointment.
47
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: Types of
Powers of a Receiver
Utilize receivership entity’s tax identification number for
all transactions
Hire professionals such as attorneys, accountants,
appraisers, and auctioneers
Expend funds for the preservation of assets, such as
repair, maintenance, insurance, licenses, taxes, utilities
and other operating expenses
Buy and sell assets
Enter into contracts obligating receivership assets
Market and sell receivership property; sale usually
requires court approval
48
real challenges. real answers. sm
Receivership: Powers of the Receiver
Bring and defend lawsuits; seek injunctive relief; issue subpoenas to
obtain documents
Compel testimony and the production of documents and things
Notify customers and tenants of any change in name of payee or
mailing address for payments
Change locks and security codes
Intercept and redirect mail
Evict tenants
Obtain permits as needed, such as for managing real estate projects
Pay, where permitted, “pre-receivership” expenses
49
real challenges. real answers. sm
COMPARISON OF CERTAIN AVAILABLE DISTRESSED SALE ALTERNATIVES
50
Topic Chapter 11 Chapter 7 Receiver Assignment
Procedures Detailed Code, rules and US Trustee
involvement
No formal court rules Streamlined; with or
without court (State
specific)
Company Involvement May still operate
as DIP and
attend 341
hearing
Must attend 341
hearing
None or TBD Debtor consensual
conveyance of the
property; ongoing
role limited/TBD
Publicity Public forum with all pleadings and
financial results available to the media
and public
Fewer reporting
requirements but
pleadings available
Publicity minimized;
public filings are
limited (subject to
specific State laws)
Court Federal Federal Federal or State State (if applicable)
Oversight US Trustee
Judge,
Committees
US Trustee
Judge
Judge Depends on State,
Judge or creditors
real challenges. real answers. sm
COMPARISON OF CERTAIN AVAILABLE DISTRESSED SALE ALTERNATIVES
51
Topic Chapter 11 Chapter 7 Receiver Assignment
Financing the Process DIP Lending
provisions attract
capital, process to
use cash
collateral
Asset Sale
Proceeds
Potentially financed
by Senior Creditor;
no process to secure
use of cash
Asset Sale
Proceeds, use of
secured creditor’s
collateral
Process Costs Expensive; cost
benefit analysis
should be
undertaken
Could be less
expensive; but
asset values
could = liquidation
value or less
Less Expensive Potentially least
Expensive
Cost Drivers Committee
Counsel and FA
US Trustee
Rigorous Court
Process
No Committee
No US Trustee
No Committee
No US Trustee
Fewer reporting
requirements
No Committee
No US Trustee
Potentially no
supervision. Speed
of ability to liquidate
assets
Time Detailed Code, rules and US Trustee
involvement=slow with statutory delays
Federal or State; no
formal court
rules=fast
State; streamlined
with no court
process=fast
real challenges. real answers. sm
COMPARISON OF CERTAIN AVAILABLE DISTRESSED SALE ALTERNATIVES
52
Topic Chapter 11 Chapter 7 Receiver Assignment
Flexibility of the
Process
Specific Law;
Federal
Jurisdiction
Vague and Open;
State laws vary,
could be Federal
Vague and Open;
dependent on State
law
Sales are “as-is,
where-is” so up to
buyer to be clear as
to liens on
purchased assets
Assignment or
Rejection of
Contracts/Leases
Yes - landlord claim limited pursuant to
502(b)(6)
No (opportunity with
Receiver Order and
Court approval)
No
Ability to Position
Operating Asset for
Best Value
Use Code to
restructure
operations
NA Operating Receiver;
limited ability
Limited
Creditor Composition/
Impact on Forum
Best Option for
complex capital
structure/multi
state
NA Best Option for
creditor
concentration;
single State
TBD; the less other
interested parties
the better
Other Considerations Ability to pursue claims and causes of
actions or other Code based creditor
recovery strategies
No Federal; State
Law may have
basis
State law specific
real challenges. real answers. sm
What is on the horizon for 2015?
A. More non-bankruptcy asset sales
B. Focus on Distressed Health Care
and Energy Sector Transactions
C. Increased use of receiverships
real challenges. real answers. sm
Contact Information
Polsinelli PC
www.polsinelli.com
Jim Bird – Kansas City (Practice Group Co-Chair)
jbird@polsinelli.com
Chris Ward – Delaware (Practice Group Co-Chair)
cward@polsinelli.com
Randye Soref – Los Angeles
rsoref@polsinelli.com
Jerry Switzer – Chicago
jswitzer@polsinelli.com
real challenges. real answers. sm
Polsinelli, a national law firm ranked among the Am Law 100 with over 740
attorneys located in 19 offices, deliberately seeks constant improvement in all
that we do. At its inception more than forty years ago, the firm established a
culture of openness and entrepreneurship that still pervades today. As the
fastest growing U.S. law firm for the past six years as ranked by The American
Lawyer*, the firm’s growth has been fueled by the recruitment of like-minded
attorneys from top law firms across the country.
Polsinelli attorneys successfully build enduring client relationships by providing
practical legal counsel infused with business insight, and with a passion for
assisting General Counsel and CEOs in achieving their objectives. The firm
focuses on healthcare, financial services, real estate, life sciences and
technology, and energy and business litigation, and has depth of experience in
100 service areas and 70 industries.
*The American Lawyer 2013 and 2014 reports
About Polsinelli
real challenges. real answers. smreal challenges. real answers. sm
Polsinelli provides this material for informational purposes only. The material
provided herein is general and is not intended to be legal advice. Nothing
herein should be relied upon or used without consulting a lawyer to consider
your specific circumstances, possible changes to applicable laws, rules and
regulations and other legal issues. Receipt of this material does not establish
an attorney-client relationship.
Polsinelli is very proud of the results we obtain for our clients, but you should
know that past results do not guarantee future results; that every case is
different and must be judged on its own merits; and that the choice of a lawyer
is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements.
© 2015 Polsinelli PC. In California, Polsinelli LLP.
Polsinelli is a registered mark of Polsinelli PC

More Related Content

What's hot

Contract remedies for sales
Contract remedies for salesContract remedies for sales
Contract remedies for salesBabasab Patil
 
Damages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in Canada
Damages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in CanadaDamages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in Canada
Damages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in CanadaDuff & Phelps
 
What You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy ClaimWhat You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claimppphilbin
 
Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors , Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...
Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors, Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors, Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...
Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors , Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...David S. Kupetz
 
Webinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 Final
Webinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 FinalWebinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 Final
Webinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 Finalgalligan
 
What Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy ClaimWhat Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy ClaimCredit Management Association
 
Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017
Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017
Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017Rebecca Hegarty
 
Buying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful Information
Buying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful InformationBuying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful Information
Buying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful InformationMadonna Hartley
 
Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014Eliot Norman
 
The Real Estate Marketplace Glossary: How to Talk the Talk
The Real Estate Marketplace Glossary:  How to Talk the TalkThe Real Estate Marketplace Glossary:  How to Talk the Talk
The Real Estate Marketplace Glossary: How to Talk the Talknetworkcapital
 
Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?
Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?
Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?Graeme Cross
 
Supply Contract Trumps Preference
Supply Contract Trumps PreferenceSupply Contract Trumps Preference
Supply Contract Trumps PreferenceDavidConaway
 
Connecticut short sale sellers
Connecticut short sale sellersConnecticut short sale sellers
Connecticut short sale sellersBridget Morrissey
 
Legal Updates Contract Basics
Legal Updates Contract BasicsLegal Updates Contract Basics
Legal Updates Contract Basicslegal3
 

What's hot (20)

Contract remedies for sales
Contract remedies for salesContract remedies for sales
Contract remedies for sales
 
Loan transfer
Loan transferLoan transfer
Loan transfer
 
Securitization 2
Securitization 2Securitization 2
Securitization 2
 
Damages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in Canada
Damages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in CanadaDamages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in Canada
Damages Calculations in Intellectual Property Cases in Canada
 
What You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy ClaimWhat You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What You Need To Know Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
 
Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors , Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...
Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors, Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors, Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...
Assignments for the Benefit of Creditors , Alternative to Formal Federal Bank...
 
Webinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 Final
Webinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 FinalWebinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 Final
Webinar Presentation Galligan And Emanuel Aug11 Final
 
What Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy ClaimWhat Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
What Should You Consider Before Selling Your Bankruptcy Claim
 
Introduction to CDS
Introduction to CDSIntroduction to CDS
Introduction to CDS
 
Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017
Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017
Coleman Greig Credit Management Workshop presentation - 25 July 2017
 
February 2011
February 2011February 2011
February 2011
 
Buying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful Information
Buying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful InformationBuying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful Information
Buying Your Home Selttlement Costs and Helpful Information
 
Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014
 
The Real Estate Marketplace Glossary: How to Talk the Talk
The Real Estate Marketplace Glossary:  How to Talk the TalkThe Real Estate Marketplace Glossary:  How to Talk the Talk
The Real Estate Marketplace Glossary: How to Talk the Talk
 
Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?
Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?
Why Use Transaction Liability Insurance in 2016?
 
Supply Contract Trumps Preference
Supply Contract Trumps PreferenceSupply Contract Trumps Preference
Supply Contract Trumps Preference
 
Connecticut short sale sellers
Connecticut short sale sellersConnecticut short sale sellers
Connecticut short sale sellers
 
Buy Sell Agreements
Buy Sell AgreementsBuy Sell Agreements
Buy Sell Agreements
 
Legal Updates Contract Basics
Legal Updates Contract BasicsLegal Updates Contract Basics
Legal Updates Contract Basics
 
BUS 300 Chapter 19
BUS 300 Chapter 19BUS 300 Chapter 19
BUS 300 Chapter 19
 

Similar to Distressed asset sales both in bankruptcy and out-of-court alter Feb 2015

Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...Financial Poise
 
Chapter 16
Chapter 16Chapter 16
Chapter 16gbrand
 
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...Financial Poise
 
Bankruptcy Claims Trading
Bankruptcy Claims TradingBankruptcy Claims Trading
Bankruptcy Claims TradingFinancial Poise
 
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers IiBankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Iiguestd2a8f81
 
Assignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docx
Assignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docxAssignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docx
Assignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docxjane3dyson92312
 
Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]
Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]
Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]Steven Silton
 
Help, My Business is In Trouble!
Help, My Business is In Trouble!Help, My Business is In Trouble!
Help, My Business is In Trouble!Financial Poise
 
Elizabethan England in the 2010 Global Recession
Elizabethan England in the 2010 Global RecessionElizabethan England in the 2010 Global Recession
Elizabethan England in the 2010 Global RecessionDavidConaway
 
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...Financial Poise
 
Useful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CT
Useful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CTUseful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CT
Useful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CTDavid Ford Avon Ct
 
THE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay Motion
THE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay MotionTHE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay Motion
THE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay MotionFinancial Poise
 
Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...
Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...
Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...Financial Poise
 
Short sale deficiencies SB 458
Short sale deficiencies SB 458Short sale deficiencies SB 458
Short sale deficiencies SB 458Ronny Budiutama
 
Warenty & product liability
Warenty & product liabilityWarenty & product liability
Warenty & product liabilityBabasab Patil
 
Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...
Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...
Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...Financial Poise
 
Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...
Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...
Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...Financial Poise
 

Similar to Distressed asset sales both in bankruptcy and out-of-court alter Feb 2015 (20)

Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions: Advice for the Ad...
 
Chapter 16
Chapter 16Chapter 16
Chapter 16
 
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...
Bankruptcy Claims Trading (Series: Bankruptcy Transactions 301: Advice for th...
 
Bankruptcy Claims Trading
Bankruptcy Claims TradingBankruptcy Claims Trading
Bankruptcy Claims Trading
 
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers IiBankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
Bankruptcy For Business Lawyers Ii
 
Assignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docx
Assignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docxAssignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docx
Assignment #3 Grading RubricNameHighly CompetentComp.docx
 
How to Approach a Chapter 11 Sold
How to Approach a Chapter 11 SoldHow to Approach a Chapter 11 Sold
How to Approach a Chapter 11 Sold
 
Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]
Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]
Surviving the death_of_the_old_e[1]
 
Article on Latent Defect.pdf
Article on Latent Defect.pdfArticle on Latent Defect.pdf
Article on Latent Defect.pdf
 
Help, My Business is In Trouble!
Help, My Business is In Trouble!Help, My Business is In Trouble!
Help, My Business is In Trouble!
 
Elizabethan England in the 2010 Global Recession
Elizabethan England in the 2010 Global RecessionElizabethan England in the 2010 Global Recession
Elizabethan England in the 2010 Global Recession
 
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
 
Useful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CT
Useful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CTUseful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CT
Useful Bankruptcy Law for Paralegals - David Ford Avon CT
 
Negotiating an M&A Deal
Negotiating an M&A DealNegotiating an M&A Deal
Negotiating an M&A Deal
 
THE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay Motion
THE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay MotionTHE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay Motion
THE NUTS & BOLTS OF BANKRUPTCY LAW 2022: The Nuts & Bolts of a Lift Stay Motion
 
Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...
Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...
Single Asset Real Estate Cases (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based ...
 
Short sale deficiencies SB 458
Short sale deficiencies SB 458Short sale deficiencies SB 458
Short sale deficiencies SB 458
 
Warenty & product liability
Warenty & product liabilityWarenty & product liability
Warenty & product liability
 
Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...
Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...
Defending Against Bankruptcy Avoidance Actions (Series: Complex Financial Lit...
 
Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...
Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...
Insider Lease Agreements (Series: Fairness Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankru...
 

More from Polsinelli PC

Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies
Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies
Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies Polsinelli PC
 
Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...
Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...
Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...Polsinelli PC
 
Life After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act Litigation
Life After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act LitigationLife After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act Litigation
Life After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act LitigationPolsinelli PC
 
The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...
The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...
The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...Polsinelli PC
 
Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019
Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019
Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019Polsinelli PC
 
Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions
Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions
Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions Polsinelli PC
 
340B Drug Pricing Under the Microscope
340B Drug Pricing Under the Microscope340B Drug Pricing Under the Microscope
340B Drug Pricing Under the MicroscopePolsinelli PC
 
The Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & Security
The Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & SecurityThe Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & Security
The Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & SecurityPolsinelli PC
 
The Emerald Series: It's (not) in the Handbook
The Emerald Series: It's (not) in the HandbookThe Emerald Series: It's (not) in the Handbook
The Emerald Series: It's (not) in the HandbookPolsinelli PC
 
Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...
Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...
Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...Polsinelli PC
 
The Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the Future
The Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the FutureThe Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the Future
The Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the FuturePolsinelli PC
 
Fraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in Review
Fraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in ReviewFraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in Review
Fraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in ReviewPolsinelli PC
 
Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018
Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018
Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018Polsinelli PC
 
Lessons learned from litigating real estate development projects
Lessons learned from litigating real estate development projectsLessons learned from litigating real estate development projects
Lessons learned from litigating real estate development projectsPolsinelli PC
 
Blockchain in Health Care
Blockchain in Health CareBlockchain in Health Care
Blockchain in Health CarePolsinelli PC
 
Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients
Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients
Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients Polsinelli PC
 
The Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have Changed
The Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have ChangedThe Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have Changed
The Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have ChangedPolsinelli PC
 
Diamond Datascram Decimated
Diamond Datascram DecimatedDiamond Datascram Decimated
Diamond Datascram DecimatedPolsinelli PC
 
Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Artificial Intelligence and Machine LearningArtificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Artificial Intelligence and Machine LearningPolsinelli PC
 
Class Actions Close-Up
Class Actions Close-UpClass Actions Close-Up
Class Actions Close-UpPolsinelli PC
 

More from Polsinelli PC (20)

Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies
Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies
Tax Cuts & Job Act Implications for Small Business Investments Companies
 
Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...
Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...
Preventing Compliance Quagmires in Senior Living Communities: Part 1 - Can So...
 
Life After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act Litigation
Life After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act LitigationLife After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act Litigation
Life After Escobar – Recent Developments In False Claims Act Litigation
 
The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...
The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...
The Emerald Series: Emily's Road to the Ideal Workplace Get to Work (Off the ...
 
Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019
Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019
Big Decisions: ACO Participation Reforming and Unwinding in 2019
 
Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions
Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions
Tax Cuts & Jobs Act Implications for Banking Institutions
 
340B Drug Pricing Under the Microscope
340B Drug Pricing Under the Microscope340B Drug Pricing Under the Microscope
340B Drug Pricing Under the Microscope
 
The Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & Security
The Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & SecurityThe Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & Security
The Intersection of OCR Enforcement and Health Care Data Privacy & Security
 
The Emerald Series: It's (not) in the Handbook
The Emerald Series: It's (not) in the HandbookThe Emerald Series: It's (not) in the Handbook
The Emerald Series: It's (not) in the Handbook
 
Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...
Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...
Health Care "Prime" - The Future of the Ownership, Organization, Payment, and...
 
The Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the Future
The Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the FutureThe Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the Future
The Trump Labor Board Goes Back to the Future
 
Fraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in Review
Fraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in ReviewFraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in Review
Fraud and Abuse - 2017 Year in Review
 
Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018
Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018
Health Care Policy Forecast: What to Expect in 2018
 
Lessons learned from litigating real estate development projects
Lessons learned from litigating real estate development projectsLessons learned from litigating real estate development projects
Lessons learned from litigating real estate development projects
 
Blockchain in Health Care
Blockchain in Health CareBlockchain in Health Care
Blockchain in Health Care
 
Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients
Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients
Mitigating Risk When Managing High Dose, Chronic Pain Patients
 
The Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have Changed
The Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have ChangedThe Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have Changed
The Feds Are Coming! Session One: The Rules Have Changed
 
Diamond Datascram Decimated
Diamond Datascram DecimatedDiamond Datascram Decimated
Diamond Datascram Decimated
 
Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Artificial Intelligence and Machine LearningArtificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
 
Class Actions Close-Up
Class Actions Close-UpClass Actions Close-Up
Class Actions Close-Up
 

Recently uploaded

FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptFINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptjudeplata
 
Introduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusion
Introduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusionIntroduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusion
Introduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusionAnuragMishra811030
 
Essentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmm
Essentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmmEssentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmm
Essentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmm2020000445musaib
 
如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书SD DS
 
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptxA Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptxPKrishna18
 
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptFINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptjudeplata
 
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书Sir Lt
 
如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书
如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书
如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书Fir L
 
如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书Fs Las
 
一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书E LSS
 
How You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad Visa
How You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad VisaHow You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad Visa
How You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad VisaBridgeWest.eu
 
国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》
国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》
国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》o8wvnojp
 
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptxPOLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptxAbhishekchatterjee248859
 
如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书SD DS
 
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKINGOffences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKINGPRAKHARGUPTA419620
 
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书FS LS
 
如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书
如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书
如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书Fir L
 
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书SS A
 

Recently uploaded (20)

FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptFINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
 
young Call Girls in Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Service
young Call Girls in  Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Serviceyoung Call Girls in  Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Service
young Call Girls in Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Service
 
Sensual Moments: +91 9999965857 Independent Call Girls Vasundhara Delhi {{ Mo...
Sensual Moments: +91 9999965857 Independent Call Girls Vasundhara Delhi {{ Mo...Sensual Moments: +91 9999965857 Independent Call Girls Vasundhara Delhi {{ Mo...
Sensual Moments: +91 9999965857 Independent Call Girls Vasundhara Delhi {{ Mo...
 
Introduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusion
Introduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusionIntroduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusion
Introduction to Corruption, definition, types, impact and conclusion
 
Essentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmm
Essentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmmEssentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmm
Essentials of a Valid Transfer.pptxmmmmmm
 
如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(Curtin毕业证书)科廷科技大学毕业证学位证书
 
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptxA Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
 
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptFINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
 
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
 
如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书
如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书
如何办理澳洲南澳大学(UniSA)毕业证学位证书
 
如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(USF文凭证书)美国旧金山大学毕业证学位证书
 
一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版牛津布鲁克斯大学毕业证学位证书
 
How You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad Visa
How You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad VisaHow You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad Visa
How You Can Get a Turkish Digital Nomad Visa
 
国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》
国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》
国外大学毕业证《奥克兰大学毕业证办理成绩单GPA修改》
 
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptxPOLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
 
如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(uOttawa毕业证书)渥太华大学毕业证学位证书
 
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKINGOffences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
 
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
 
如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书
如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书
如何办理新加坡南洋理工大学毕业证(本硕)NTU学位证书
 
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
 

Distressed asset sales both in bankruptcy and out-of-court alter Feb 2015

  • 1. Polsinelli PC. In California, Polsinelli LLP Distressed Asset Sales in Both Bankruptcy and Its Out-of-Court Alternatives James E. Bird Christopher A. Ward Randye B. Soref Jerry L. Switzer, Jr.
  • 2. real challenges. real answers. sm Distressed Asset Sales in Both Bankruptcy and Its Out-of-Court Alternatives Agenda 1. Discussion of considerations for selling distressed assets in bankruptcy and out-of-court arrangements and minimizing the risk to the purchaser 2. Available Distressed Asset Sale Mechanisms, Pros & Cons of Each Alternative A. Bankruptcy B. UCC - Article 9 ”Friendly Foreclosure” Sale C. Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors D. Receivership (Federal vs. State) E. Comparison of Each Alternative 3. Why explore non-bankruptcy alternatives A. Cost B. Control C. Timing 4. What is on the horizon for 2015? A. More non-bankruptcy asset sales B. Focus on Distressed Health Care and Energy Sector Transactions C. Increased use of receiverships
  • 3. real challenges. real answers. sm Panelists Jim Bird – Kansas City (Practice Group Co-Chair) Chris Ward – Delaware (Practice Group Co-Chair) Randye Soref – Los Angeles Jerry Switzer - Chicago Complete biographies of our panelists can be found at the end of the presentation or at www.polsinelli.com.
  • 4. real challenges. real answers. sm PURCHASE OF A DISTRESSED BUSINESS OUTSIDE OF BANKRUPTCY In most distressed business situations, it is advisable for a buyer to directly purchase the assets of such business rather than purchase the equity of the entity that owns the business. With some exceptions, in most states it is well established that a buyer can “cherry pick” the assets and liabilities it wants to purchase or assume, leaving undesired assets and liabilities with the owner. However, the seller or its lender may resist a partial sale of assets.
  • 5. real challenges. real answers. sm In evaluating any opportunity to purchase a distressed business, a fundamental decision is whether to purchase assets through a bankruptcy proceeding or one of several out- of-court alternatives. There are several factors that purchasers should consider in this analysis: Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales
  • 6. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales 1. Secured Debt. If the acquisition target has secured debt, the only way to obtain the assets free and clear of liens is to get consensual lien releases from all lienholders or pay the senior secured creditors in full or an agreed upon amount. 2. State and Local Taxes. Several states impose successor liability on an asset purchaser with respect to unpaid taxes of the seller, unless the purchaser either (i) withholds the taxes from the purchase price or (ii) obtains a tax clearance certificate. If a business is distressed, this is more than likely an issue.
  • 7. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales 3. Bulk Sales Act. A few states still have “Bulk Sales Laws” requiring certain notices and procedures to creditors when the buyer is purchasing substantially the entire inventory of a business but is not assuming its liabilities. Failure to comply generally results in liability for the purchaser to creditors of the seller. 4. Collective Bargaining Agreements. A purchaser of distressed assets may be required to recognize and bargain with a union that represented the seller’s employees.
  • 8. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales 5. Underfunded Pensions. If seller participates in an underfunded multi-employer union pension plan, a sale of assets can result in immediate withdrawal liability by the seller. Some courts have held a buyer liable for a seller’s delinquent contributions and withdrawal liability under such pension plans. 6. Environment Liabilities. Potential risk of liability to federal and state environmental authorities.
  • 9. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales 7. WARN Act Liability. Buyer may have liability related to unpaid wages for the seller’s failure to provide adequate notice to employees that the business is closing, assuming that the seller has enough employees to be covered by the WARN Act or similar state labor laws. 8. Product Liabilities. Buyer may inherit certain seller product liabilities pursuant to existing case law.
  • 10. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales 9. Successor Liability. Pursuant to common law, in certain circumstances a seller and buyer may be considered to have undergone a “de facto” merger or the buyer may be considered a “mere continuation” of the seller, with the result that the buyer is liable to creditors of the seller. The successor liability analysis is similar to piercing the corporate veil discussed immediately below. 10. Piercing the Corporate Veil. If there appears to be too many corporate similarities between the seller and purchaser, a creditor may seek to pierce the corporate veil of the purchaser in order to hold it liable for the debts of the seller. There are strong legal doctrines that protect the sanctity of a corporation, but the parties need to be aware of the risk in structuring a distressed asset transaction.
  • 11. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales 11. Fraudulent Transfers. One of the biggest risks of purchasing a distressed business is that, after closing, one or more creditors of the seller (or a bankruptcy trustee) may attempt to set aside the sale on “fraudulent transfer grounds” (based on actual or constructive fraud of creditors). Actual fraud involves an attempt by the debtor to hinder, delay, or defraud its creditors. Most often creditors make a claim for constructive fraud, which involves a transfer of assets for less than fair consideration when the seller was insolvent or became insolvent as a result of the sale. These actions can be brought under state law or federal bankruptcy law (with 2-6 year statute of limitations). 12. Seller’s Creditor Body. If the seller has aggressive or disgruntled creditors holding large claims, there may be a greater risk of a successor liability or fraudulent transfer claim. The same may be true if the nature of the seller’s business is such that future (but currently unknown) and large general liability or similar claims might arise. The holders of such future claims may be motivated to pursue the buyer. In contrast, if the seller’s creditors are passive, disorganized or hold relatively small claims, and if there is low risk of future claims, the risk of successor liability or fraudulent transfer claims may be small.
  • 12. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales Considerations to Mitigate Risk 1. Perform proper due diligence – especially so with a distressed business. Perform searches of state and local records for financing statements and consensual liens, tax and judgment liens, and lawsuit filings. 2. Buyer should consider setting up a new and separate entity to affect the purchase in order to isolate the purchased assets from possible unknown liabilities.
  • 13. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales Considerations to Mitigate Risk 3. To create a defense against post-closing fraudulent transfer claims, the buyer should consider obtaining an opinion of the value of the assets to be purchased from a reputable appraiser. 4. Make certain that the sales proceeds are allocated and distributed by the seller properly in order to demonstrate to existing creditors that the sale was conducted in good faith. 5. Purchaser should obtain seller indemnification from attacks on the sale, including fraudulent transfer claims, piercing the veil, or successor liability claims from creditors.
  • 14. real challenges. real answers. sm Considerations for Distressed Asset Sales Considerations to Mitigate Risk 6. Negotiate a holdback or third party escrow for a substantial amount of the purchase price to cover post-closing issues and indemnification agreements.
  • 15. real challenges. real answers. sm 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales If sufficient value is involved, and if the distressed business can survive the bankruptcy process, the parties often will benefit from a section 363 sale in a bankruptcy proceeding. This provision allows the Bankruptcy Court to approve a sale of assets free and clear of liens, encumbrances, and adverse claims and interests.
  • 16. real challenges. real answers. sm A. Pros Section 363 Sale 1. Simplicity and speed. 2. Avoidance of corporate law requirements to obtain majority shareholder approval. 3. The right to sell property free and clear of all liens, claims and other interests. The power of the Bankruptcy Court to free the debtor’s assets of claims and interests makes it more attractive to a potential buyer. 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
  • 17. real challenges. real answers. sm 4. The right to assume and assign executory contracts and unexpired leases of non-residential real property pursuant to section 365 of the Bankruptcy Code that are otherwise not assignable outside of bankruptcy. (However, as a general rule, patent licenses, government contracts, and personal service contracts are not assignable even in bankruptcy.) 5. The right to sell property despite contractual anti- bankruptcy provisions and similar sale restrictions. 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
  • 18. real challenges. real answers. sm 6. The right to sell property co-owned by the debtor and other person(s) under certain circumstances. 7. The right to a good faith purchaser finding pursuant to section 363(m) of the Bankruptcy Code. 8. Protection against the reversal or modification on appeal of a consummated bankruptcy sale. The Bankruptcy Code provides that an order approving a sale cannot be reversed or modified on appeal unless either the party bringing the appeal obtains a court stay of the sale while the appeal is pending (i.e., usually by posting a significant bond) or the purchaser buys the assets in bad faith. In addition, the Third Circuit, amongst others, has a very strong equitable mootness doctrine on appeal. 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
  • 19. real challenges. real answers. sm 9. Approval of the sale and appropriate findings by the bankruptcy court should prevent subsequent fraudulent conveyance, successor liability, or piercing the corporate veil claims by creditors or other disgruntled parties. 10. Some courts find that successor liability is an “interest” subject to sale free and clear. Cases often turn on whether a particular claim is known and could have been brought into the bankruptcy and whether a particular claimant receives adequate notice of a sale and bankruptcy proceeding. Providing notice to known or potential claimants may defeat later successor liability arguments. 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
  • 20. real challenges. real answers. sm B. Cons Section 363 Sale 1. The section 363 sale process can be somewhat time consuming and costly. 2. Potential for negative bankruptcy publicity, damaging the reputation of the business, and customer willingness to purchase goods and services. Most, however, find this concept to be incredibly overstated. 3. Distressed business may not be able to survive even a quick bankruptcy process without losing significant value. 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
  • 21. real challenges. real answers. sm 4. Some Bankruptcy Courts will not allow a section 363 sale in circumstances in which only the secured lender benefits (i.e., where no funds are going to unsecured creditors). A seller must be prepared to deal with (i.e., provide a “tip”) to disenfranchised creditors. 5. Some courts disagree that successor liability is an “interest” subject to the sale free and clear. 6. Section 363 sales must be subject to an auction that will entertain higher and better bids (i.e., a “stalking horse” bidder could lose the bid to a competing party, yet the stalking horse bidder may be entitled to a “Break Up Fee”). 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
  • 22. real challenges. real answers. sm 7. Creditors may try to obtain leverage by objecting to the process and attempt to extract “holdup” concessions. 8. Secured creditors have rights to “credit bid” their secured debt amount pursuant to section 363(k) of the Bankruptcy Code against their collateral being sold. As a result, buyers will normally negotiate with secured creditors during the sale process. 11 USC Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales
  • 23. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” A UCC - Article 9 “friendly foreclosure” is a situation in which a troubled borrower cooperates with its lender (generally an undersecured lender) to facilitate a foreclosure sale. A friendly foreclosure will deliver title from the borrower to the lender or a third-party buyer.
  • 24. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” Under the Uniform Commercial Code (“UCC”), in particular UCC 9-610, a lender may sell collateral after the borrower’s default “at any time and place and on any terms,” so long as every aspect of the transaction is “commercially reasonable.” The UCC allows a foreclosing lender to choose between a public and a private sale. The UCC requires a lender to send “reasonable” notice of an intended sale to the borrower, any secondary obligors, such as sureties or guarantors, and unless the collateral is consumer goods, any other party with a secured claim on the collateral that either has perfected its claim by filing or has notified the secured lender of that claim.
  • 25. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” In the usual friendly foreclosure, the lender, borrower, and buyer enter into a three-way foreclosure agreement similar to an asset purchase agreement. The agreement is intended to affect a quick transfer of the borrower’s assets to the buyer in an Article 9 foreclosure by private sale. The borrower will normally confirm the value of the assets are less than the secured debt and affirm the lender’s right to foreclose in the manner specified in the agreement. A borrower also may make certain representations to the buyer about its business that the lender may not be in a position to provide.
  • 26. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” A lender may warrant to the buyer that it is entitled to convey title to the collateral in good faith, but it usually disclaims most warranties and representations that customarily accompany a non-distressed sale. The buyer agrees to take the collateral in its current condition. In some sales the lender may not make any warranty of good title, thus imposing all the risk on the buyer. The buyer also may assume some of the borrower’s specified liabilities, but usually excludes most of the borrower’s obligations, including taxes, employee benefits, trade debts, contracts, and tort liabilities. The buyer’s recourse to the lender, if any, almost always is contractually limited to the amount of consideration paid by the buyer. The lender may choose to finance a portion of the purchase price by specifying in the agreement that the buyer is taking title subject to a portion of the existing debt held by the lender.
  • 27. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” Assuming the lender who brings the friendly foreclosure is the most senior secured lender, the sale of the borrower’s assets under an Article 9 foreclosure will wipe out the interests of all other junior creditors (who received notice of the sale).
  • 28. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” Pros To “Friendly Foreclosure” 1. Often faster and less costly than a section 363 bankruptcy sale. 2. Creditors have less opportunity to extract “holdup” concessions from a lender during a sale process. 3. Parties are not subject to Bankruptcy Court review and procedures.
  • 29. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” 4. Article 9 requires notice to a smaller group of entities than does bankruptcy. (Vendors and customers usually need not be notified, which may make it easier to maintain operating a borrower’s business than in a bankruptcy.) 5. Article 6 “Bulk Transfer” laws are exempted from transactions that settle liens, including friendly foreclosures. See UCC 6-103.
  • 30. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” Cons To “Friendly Foreclosure” 1. If lender is not undersecured, there is a likelihood that the foreclosure may be challenged by other creditors (as a fraudulent transfer, successor liability, or veil piercing). 2. Lender and borrower will usually disclaim warranties. Typically occurs as an “As Is, Where Is” Transaction.
  • 31. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” 3. Failure of lender to send a commercially “reasonable” notice of intended sale to the borrower, secondary obligors and other lienholders may taint the sale and cause such parties to seek to challenge the sale. The sale price, the efforts to find alternative buyers, and the lender’s good faith in maximizing the value of the collateral are all considered by courts when determining “commercial reasonableness.” In actions involving a deficiency or surplus after the sale, the lender may have the burden to prove the sale was commercially reasonable. Unsecured creditors may seek to prove the sale was not commercially reasonable in aid of a successor liability or fraudulent transfer claim.
  • 32. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” 4. Article 9 sale will not wipe out any security interests that are senior to the foreclosing lenders. 5. There is no established “safe harbor” (via a court review) for Article 9 foreclosures like there is in a bankruptcy section 363 sale. 6. There is no bankruptcy stay against third parties. Thus, there is a threat of creditor adverse action (i.e., notice of UCC sale could prompt creditors to file an involuntary petition against the debtor or create the potential that the UCC sale could be challenged and avoided as a fraudulent transfer).
  • 33. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” 7. A UCC Article 9 foreclosure does not apply to real estate sales, and thus is not a great vehicle for sale of an entire business if the business has significant owned real estate. The real estate must be transferred via other means, including a short sale, deed-in-lieu related transaction or structured foreclosure sale. 8. Inability to assign leases and other contracts containing non-assignment clauses unlike a section 363 bankruptcy sale.
  • 34. real challenges. real answers. sm UCC - ARTICLE 9 – “FRIENDLY FORECLOSURE” 9. Creditors of the seller could challenge the transaction on “successor liability” grounds.
  • 35. real challenges. real answers. sm Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors A general assignment provides a means of liquidating the assets of a debtor in an orderly, controlled manner. A general assignment is a vehicle used for the sale or liquidation of a business. It is not used to financially rehabilitate or “turn the business around”. Assignments are either common law or statutory, and the law varies from state to state as to which form of assignment is utilized. Generally, states will follow one of two approaches to the assignment process. One approach requires court supervision of the assignment and the assignee (e.g., Delaware, California, New Jersey to name a few); the other permits the assignments to proceed without court supervision, but require that the assignee follow state laws applicable to and governing the liquidation of a business and its assets. 35
  • 36. real challenges. real answers. sm Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors It is easy to think of a common law assignment as similar to Chapter 7 All assets of the Assignor is transferred to the Assignee The Assignee liquidates the property An Assignee may have the power to pursue preferences and fraudulent conveyances depending on state law in which the Assignment takes place Distributions are made to creditors according to statutory priority and based on claims 36
  • 37. real challenges. real answers. sm Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors The Assignee is generally someone who is not related to or directly involved in the management or the day-to-day operations of the debtor (i.e. a disinterested third party). Assignee is usually an individual experienced in the process of liquidating businesses; however, an the Assignee may also be a corporate entity with such experience. An Assignment is consummated when the Assignee accepts the Assignment Trust "contract,” or Deed of Trust from the Assignor. Upon acceptance of the assignment “contract,” all of the Assignor’s right, title and interest in its assets is “transferred” to the Assignee for the purposes of liquidation. The Assignee then becomes a fiduciary on behalf of any and all creditors of the Assignor, as well as for the Assignor and, ultimately, its owners/shareholders. 37
  • 38. real challenges. real answers. sm Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors The Assignee must preserve the assets for the benefit of creditors. The Assignee must liquidate and administer assets fairly. The transfer of assets is subject to any and all existing liens, and the assignee is bound to honor all valid, perfected and enforceable liens. General assignments do not typically give a debtor a discharge, as discharge of debts can only be achieved through a bankruptcy case. 38
  • 39. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership Equitable proceeding in which a court appoints a disinterested person, the receiver, to receive, preserve and protect designated assets or property 39
  • 40. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: Federal vs. State Advantages of Federal Receiverships over State Receiverships – National jurisdiction; solves diversity of jurisdiction problem over supervision and control of assets – “Free and clear” sales – Incorporation of bankruptcy concepts Advantages of State Receiverships over Federal Receiverships – Statutory authority for appointment of a receiver in a variety of contexts; see e.g., California code of Civil Procedure Section 564 40
  • 41. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: Common Purposes Facilitating injunctive relief Taking custody of and managing property Preserving assets and business books and records Obtaining an accounting of assets, income and use of proceeds Locating hidden assets Uncovering fraud and misappropriations Exposing criminal enterprises Involuntarily dissolution Enforcing a judgment 41
  • 42. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: Factors for Appointment Probability that fraudulent conduct has occurred or will occur to frustrate opponent Imminent danger that property will be concealed, lost or diminished in value Inadequacy of other legal remedies Lack of less drastic equitable remedy Likelihood that appointment of receiver will do more good than harm Contractual consent to appointment upon default 42
  • 43. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: Common Types Custodial Receiver Liquidating Receiver Interim Operating Manager, status quo Provisional Director Fiscal Agent Post-Judgment Receiver 43
  • 44. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: For the Benefit Of: Secured Lender Judgment Creditor Deadlocked corporate directors, LLC members or partners Oppressed minority shareholder, member or partner Creditors or equity holders seeking to take custody or: – Bring and defend lawsuits; seek injunctive relief; issue subpoenas to obtain documents – Compel testimony and the production of documents and things Notify customers and tenants of any change in name of payee or mailing address for payments Change locks and security codes Intercept and redirect mail Evict tenants Obtain permits as needed, such as for managing real estate projects Pay, where permitted, “pre-receivership” expenses 44
  • 45. real challenges. real answers. sm How the Receiver is Selected: By secured lender By court By creditor’s or debtor’s counsel In all events, court approval is required The Receiver’s Relationship With Other Parties: Officer of the court Qualified fiduciary role with respect to debtor/company Allegiance to secured lender by virtue of authority and purpose Duty to subordinate creditors and equity interests 45 Receivership
  • 46. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: The Receiver’s Duties Locate and preserve assets Provide accounting to the court Fulfill purpose as stated in court order establishing the receivership 46
  • 47. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: Types of Powers of a Receiver Take possession of and mange assets, as specified in court order, including cash in bank accounts, goods, rights and credits Take possession, custody and control of licenses, documents, books and records, emails in possession of accountants, attorneys and other third parties Administer business operations as though the receiver were the owner or president Borrow money similar to bankruptcy’s DIP loans, granting a super- priority lien; i.e. “receiver certificates” similar to DIP financing Manage bank accounts, change signature cards, open new accounts The Receivership Order can, and should, be tailored to fit whatever powers and duties the Receiver may need in their appointment. 47
  • 48. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: Types of Powers of a Receiver Utilize receivership entity’s tax identification number for all transactions Hire professionals such as attorneys, accountants, appraisers, and auctioneers Expend funds for the preservation of assets, such as repair, maintenance, insurance, licenses, taxes, utilities and other operating expenses Buy and sell assets Enter into contracts obligating receivership assets Market and sell receivership property; sale usually requires court approval 48
  • 49. real challenges. real answers. sm Receivership: Powers of the Receiver Bring and defend lawsuits; seek injunctive relief; issue subpoenas to obtain documents Compel testimony and the production of documents and things Notify customers and tenants of any change in name of payee or mailing address for payments Change locks and security codes Intercept and redirect mail Evict tenants Obtain permits as needed, such as for managing real estate projects Pay, where permitted, “pre-receivership” expenses 49
  • 50. real challenges. real answers. sm COMPARISON OF CERTAIN AVAILABLE DISTRESSED SALE ALTERNATIVES 50 Topic Chapter 11 Chapter 7 Receiver Assignment Procedures Detailed Code, rules and US Trustee involvement No formal court rules Streamlined; with or without court (State specific) Company Involvement May still operate as DIP and attend 341 hearing Must attend 341 hearing None or TBD Debtor consensual conveyance of the property; ongoing role limited/TBD Publicity Public forum with all pleadings and financial results available to the media and public Fewer reporting requirements but pleadings available Publicity minimized; public filings are limited (subject to specific State laws) Court Federal Federal Federal or State State (if applicable) Oversight US Trustee Judge, Committees US Trustee Judge Judge Depends on State, Judge or creditors
  • 51. real challenges. real answers. sm COMPARISON OF CERTAIN AVAILABLE DISTRESSED SALE ALTERNATIVES 51 Topic Chapter 11 Chapter 7 Receiver Assignment Financing the Process DIP Lending provisions attract capital, process to use cash collateral Asset Sale Proceeds Potentially financed by Senior Creditor; no process to secure use of cash Asset Sale Proceeds, use of secured creditor’s collateral Process Costs Expensive; cost benefit analysis should be undertaken Could be less expensive; but asset values could = liquidation value or less Less Expensive Potentially least Expensive Cost Drivers Committee Counsel and FA US Trustee Rigorous Court Process No Committee No US Trustee No Committee No US Trustee Fewer reporting requirements No Committee No US Trustee Potentially no supervision. Speed of ability to liquidate assets Time Detailed Code, rules and US Trustee involvement=slow with statutory delays Federal or State; no formal court rules=fast State; streamlined with no court process=fast
  • 52. real challenges. real answers. sm COMPARISON OF CERTAIN AVAILABLE DISTRESSED SALE ALTERNATIVES 52 Topic Chapter 11 Chapter 7 Receiver Assignment Flexibility of the Process Specific Law; Federal Jurisdiction Vague and Open; State laws vary, could be Federal Vague and Open; dependent on State law Sales are “as-is, where-is” so up to buyer to be clear as to liens on purchased assets Assignment or Rejection of Contracts/Leases Yes - landlord claim limited pursuant to 502(b)(6) No (opportunity with Receiver Order and Court approval) No Ability to Position Operating Asset for Best Value Use Code to restructure operations NA Operating Receiver; limited ability Limited Creditor Composition/ Impact on Forum Best Option for complex capital structure/multi state NA Best Option for creditor concentration; single State TBD; the less other interested parties the better Other Considerations Ability to pursue claims and causes of actions or other Code based creditor recovery strategies No Federal; State Law may have basis State law specific
  • 53. real challenges. real answers. sm What is on the horizon for 2015? A. More non-bankruptcy asset sales B. Focus on Distressed Health Care and Energy Sector Transactions C. Increased use of receiverships
  • 54. real challenges. real answers. sm Contact Information Polsinelli PC www.polsinelli.com Jim Bird – Kansas City (Practice Group Co-Chair) jbird@polsinelli.com Chris Ward – Delaware (Practice Group Co-Chair) cward@polsinelli.com Randye Soref – Los Angeles rsoref@polsinelli.com Jerry Switzer – Chicago jswitzer@polsinelli.com
  • 55. real challenges. real answers. sm Polsinelli, a national law firm ranked among the Am Law 100 with over 740 attorneys located in 19 offices, deliberately seeks constant improvement in all that we do. At its inception more than forty years ago, the firm established a culture of openness and entrepreneurship that still pervades today. As the fastest growing U.S. law firm for the past six years as ranked by The American Lawyer*, the firm’s growth has been fueled by the recruitment of like-minded attorneys from top law firms across the country. Polsinelli attorneys successfully build enduring client relationships by providing practical legal counsel infused with business insight, and with a passion for assisting General Counsel and CEOs in achieving their objectives. The firm focuses on healthcare, financial services, real estate, life sciences and technology, and energy and business litigation, and has depth of experience in 100 service areas and 70 industries. *The American Lawyer 2013 and 2014 reports About Polsinelli
  • 56. real challenges. real answers. smreal challenges. real answers. sm Polsinelli provides this material for informational purposes only. The material provided herein is general and is not intended to be legal advice. Nothing herein should be relied upon or used without consulting a lawyer to consider your specific circumstances, possible changes to applicable laws, rules and regulations and other legal issues. Receipt of this material does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Polsinelli is very proud of the results we obtain for our clients, but you should know that past results do not guarantee future results; that every case is different and must be judged on its own merits; and that the choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements. © 2015 Polsinelli PC. In California, Polsinelli LLP. Polsinelli is a registered mark of Polsinelli PC