SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
Comment on Balancing embodied & operating carbon – wall
assembly by CreativeDestruction
Most twin cities area apartments are now framed with 2x8 to meet current energy code. I would
honestly steer you more toward that than your 2 options simply because it's familiar to all trades,
commercial subs will get it more airtight than SIPs, it's probably similar in overall U factor to the
Tstud assembly, and you'll get better pricing that can be invested elsewhere on the project.Of
course, I'm shooting from the hip and haven't done the exact math. Take with a grain of salt. 2x8 @
24" O.C. dense packed is not too shabby if continuous exterior insulation isn't in the cards.Best,jEdit:
definitely use plywood and/or paperless gypsum sheathing on the exterior if you go this route.

More Related Content

More from cmpspraysystems

Fine-Particle Air Pollution on the Decline
Fine-Particle Air Pollution on the DeclineFine-Particle Air Pollution on the Decline
Fine-Particle Air Pollution on the Declinecmpspraysystems
 
Smart High-Performance Homes Start With Good Design
Smart High-Performance Homes Start With Good DesignSmart High-Performance Homes Start With Good Design
Smart High-Performance Homes Start With Good Designcmpspraysystems
 
Hemp’s Promising Future in Construction
Hemp’s Promising Future in ConstructionHemp’s Promising Future in Construction
Hemp’s Promising Future in Constructioncmpspraysystems
 
Understanding Air Change Rates
Understanding Air Change RatesUnderstanding Air Change Rates
Understanding Air Change Ratescmpspraysystems
 
Trade Contractors: Trust but Verify
Trade Contractors: Trust but VerifyTrade Contractors: Trust but Verify
Trade Contractors: Trust but Verifycmpspraysystems
 
The BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVs
The BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVsThe BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVs
The BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVscmpspraysystems
 
The BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame House
The BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame HouseThe BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame House
The BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame Housecmpspraysystems
 
Book Club: The New Carbon Architecture
Book Club: The New Carbon ArchitectureBook Club: The New Carbon Architecture
Book Club: The New Carbon Architecturecmpspraysystems
 
Customer Retention Strategies that Really Work
Customer Retention Strategies that Really WorkCustomer Retention Strategies that Really Work
Customer Retention Strategies that Really Workcmpspraysystems
 
PURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLES
PURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLESPURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLES
PURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLEScmpspraysystems
 
Comment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impala
Comment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impalaComment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impala
Comment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impalacmpspraysystems
 
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_RComment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_Rcmpspraysystems
 
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_RComment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_Rcmpspraysystems
 
The BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd Benson
The BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd BensonThe BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd Benson
The BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd Bensoncmpspraysystems
 
Comment on Condensation by 1at
Comment on Condensation by 1atComment on Condensation by 1at
Comment on Condensation by 1atcmpspraysystems
 
Ban On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town Fizzles
Ban On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town FizzlesBan On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town Fizzles
Ban On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town Fizzlescmpspraysystems
 
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypezComment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypezcmpspraysystems
 
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypezComment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypezcmpspraysystems
 
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJFComment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJFcmpspraysystems
 
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJFComment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJFcmpspraysystems
 

More from cmpspraysystems (20)

Fine-Particle Air Pollution on the Decline
Fine-Particle Air Pollution on the DeclineFine-Particle Air Pollution on the Decline
Fine-Particle Air Pollution on the Decline
 
Smart High-Performance Homes Start With Good Design
Smart High-Performance Homes Start With Good DesignSmart High-Performance Homes Start With Good Design
Smart High-Performance Homes Start With Good Design
 
Hemp’s Promising Future in Construction
Hemp’s Promising Future in ConstructionHemp’s Promising Future in Construction
Hemp’s Promising Future in Construction
 
Understanding Air Change Rates
Understanding Air Change RatesUnderstanding Air Change Rates
Understanding Air Change Rates
 
Trade Contractors: Trust but Verify
Trade Contractors: Trust but VerifyTrade Contractors: Trust but Verify
Trade Contractors: Trust but Verify
 
The BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVs
The BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVsThe BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVs
The BS* + Beer Show: HRVs and ERVs
 
The BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame House
The BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame HouseThe BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame House
The BS* + Beer Show: Deep-Energy Retrofit of an Old Timber-Frame House
 
Book Club: The New Carbon Architecture
Book Club: The New Carbon ArchitectureBook Club: The New Carbon Architecture
Book Club: The New Carbon Architecture
 
Customer Retention Strategies that Really Work
Customer Retention Strategies that Really WorkCustomer Retention Strategies that Really Work
Customer Retention Strategies that Really Work
 
PURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLES
PURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLESPURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLES
PURE SAFETY GROUP LEADERS TAKE ON ROLES
 
Comment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impala
Comment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impalaComment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impala
Comment on Partial removal of chimney, will I be able to do it? by the74impala
 
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_RComment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
 
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_RComment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
Comment on Heating alternative for a PH by Jon_R
 
The BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd Benson
The BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd BensonThe BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd Benson
The BS* + Beer Show: Open Building Systems with Tedd Benson
 
Comment on Condensation by 1at
Comment on Condensation by 1atComment on Condensation by 1at
Comment on Condensation by 1at
 
Ban On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town Fizzles
Ban On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town FizzlesBan On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town Fizzles
Ban On New Gas Connections in Massachusetts Town Fizzles
 
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypezComment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
 
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypezComment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
Comment on How far from the furnace can I put an ERV unit? by quicktypez
 
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJFComment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
 
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJFComment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
Comment on Manual J slop? by MattJF
 

Comment on Balancing embodied & operating carbon – wall assembly by CreativeDestruction

  • 1. Comment on Balancing embodied & operating carbon – wall assembly by CreativeDestruction Most twin cities area apartments are now framed with 2x8 to meet current energy code. I would honestly steer you more toward that than your 2 options simply because it's familiar to all trades, commercial subs will get it more airtight than SIPs, it's probably similar in overall U factor to the Tstud assembly, and you'll get better pricing that can be invested elsewhere on the project.Of course, I'm shooting from the hip and haven't done the exact math. Take with a grain of salt. 2x8 @ 24" O.C. dense packed is not too shabby if continuous exterior insulation isn't in the cards.Best,jEdit: definitely use plywood and/or paperless gypsum sheathing on the exterior if you go this route.