1) The document discusses strategies for harnessing female talent in organizations. It notes that traditional talent management systems are not advancing women into leadership positions.
2) It recommends that companies recognize women as a strategic resource and address unconscious biases that impact women's career trajectories. Senior leaders must become champions for advancing women.
3) Companies that overhaul their approaches to gender diversity and inclusion through clear leadership vision, modeling inclusive behaviors, and holding leaders accountable can realize increased profits by better utilizing their entire workforce.
The goal of the CEO & Gender Media Audit was to understand the media coverage of CEOs in various situations and determine if there are differences in the way male and female CEOs are covered.
Authored by David F. Larcker and Brian Tayan, April 1, 2020, Stanford Closer Look Series
We examine the size, structure, and demographic makeup of the C-suite (the CEO and the direct reports to the CEO) in each of the Fortune 100 companies as of February 2020. We find that women (and, to a lesser extent, racially diverse executives) are underrepresented in C-suite positions that directly feed into future CEO and board roles. What accounts for this distribution?
A ManpowerGroup whitepaper on female leadership. Making the case for more women leaders in businesses today. Find out how to get them and keep them in your organisation.
The goal of the CEO & Gender Media Audit was to understand the media coverage of CEOs in various situations and determine if there are differences in the way male and female CEOs are covered.
Authored by David F. Larcker and Brian Tayan, April 1, 2020, Stanford Closer Look Series
We examine the size, structure, and demographic makeup of the C-suite (the CEO and the direct reports to the CEO) in each of the Fortune 100 companies as of February 2020. We find that women (and, to a lesser extent, racially diverse executives) are underrepresented in C-suite positions that directly feed into future CEO and board roles. What accounts for this distribution?
A ManpowerGroup whitepaper on female leadership. Making the case for more women leaders in businesses today. Find out how to get them and keep them in your organisation.
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
By David F. Larcker, Stephen A. Miles, and Brian Tayan
Stanford Closer Look Series
Overview:
Shareholders pay considerable attention to the choice of executive selected as the new CEO whenever a change in leadership takes place. However, without an inside look at the leading candidates to assume the CEO role, it is difficult for shareholders to tell whether the board has made the correct choice. In this Closer Look, we examine CEO succession events among the largest 100 companies over a ten-year period to determine what happens to the executives who were not selected (i.e., the “succession losers”) and how they perform relative to those who were selected (the “succession winners”).
We ask:
• Are the executives selected for the CEO role really better than those passed over?
• What are the implications for understanding the labor market for executive talent?
• Are differences in performance due to operating conditions or quality of available talent?
• Are boards better at identifying CEO talent than other research generally suggests?
Prawie połowa osób zasiadających w Polsce na kierowniczych stanowiskach to kobiety – wynika z badania „Women in Business 2017” prowadzonego przez Grant Thornton. Polska jest pod tym względem w światowej czołówce
Happy International Women's Day. Cracking the Case. Why you need women leader...Mika Wilén
Maat, jotka ovat onnistuneet sukupuolten välisen tasa-arvon toteuttamisessa, ovat muita kilpailukykyisempiä. Silti naiset ovat yksi suurimmista alihyödynnetyistä osaajaresursseista maailmassa – ja erityisesti yritysten johtotehtävissä. Miksi? Johtuuko tämä siitä, että yritysten henkilöstökäytännöt eivät ole tältä vuosisadalta? Mihin asioihin ylimmän johdon tulisi kiinnittää huomiota, jotta muutos olisi mahdollinen? Lue lisää: Cracking the Case .
This Report answers questions on the makings of a modern day Tech CFO - the career paths, their personalities and the insights they use.
CFOs are the first line of defense from potential financial adversity.
They can also be the asset that allows companies to really expand their horizons rapidly.
Today, the CFO is a connector – the bridge between business, data & goals.
Yet, so little is spoken about these enablers.
So, we decided to shift the spotlight onto them.
What this report focuses on could address questions like:
who are they?
what is their education arc?
how has their career graph been?
what insights do we have about their personality style?
what makes them tick & what ticks them off?
when faced with rapid momentum, do they fight/ take flight?
Hope you get some answers to questions you have had in a while. If you want to ask me something or explore assistance as a CFO, please feel free to hit us up at connect@prequate.in.
Women in ICT Leadership - Are We Nearly There?Deanna Kosaraju
Voices 2014 presented by Global Tech Women
Women in ICT Leadership - Are We Nearly There?
Chandana Unnithan, Deakin University, Australia; Renu Rajani, Capgemini, India and Arathi G, RIPL, India
The CS Gender 3000: Women in Senior ManagementCredit Suisse
Greater gender diversity in companies' management improves their financial performance. A new Credit Suisse Research Institute study presents the financial evidence, looks at which regions and sectors show higher diversity levels and analyzes the obstacles to female participation in the workplace.
To download a copy of 'CS Gender 3000: Women in Senior Management', click here: http://bit.ly/1cWMUIM
Promoting multidimensional teams has a positive impact on business outcomes. Female presence in company's executive bodies is essential to build business projects that are successful and long-term oriented.
During the meeting held by Woman's Week foundation and the Association of Directors of Communication in Spain (Dircom), Chief Communication Officer and companies, committed to equal opportunities and diversity, professionals discussed about CSR regarding gender diversity.
We are indeed living a shift of paradigm where companies are more sensitive to the economic importance of their role as social actors and the strategic and integrated management of key intangible assets such as reputation, brand, communication or public issues. We are immersed in the so-called "reputation economy".
The main advantages of promoting diversity within the corporation are the greater capacity of attracting and retaining talent, improvement of leadership and innovation strategies and a closer approach to key stakeholders for the company. In fact, the main idea of the concept of diversity is to optimize human resources presented by heterogeneous groups, this is to say, diverse regarding the gender, age, race or nationality of their members.
We are making progress in integrating diverse teams in the organization, but we are still below the goal of 40 % female board managers in companies set out by the European Parliament and the European Commission.
This insight addresses the current situation and future leadership, where diversity will play a major role for sure.
As so many fields have in recent years, entry-level hiring must also make the transition from relying on untested intuition to leveraging the power of data and evidence. Employers now have access to talent analytics tools that can enable them to develop a deep understanding of what attributes drive good performance for their current employees, apply tools to objectively assess these attributes, and access broader talent pools to find individuals with the most-valued attributes. The talent analytics tools that enable this vision for data-driven hiring already exist. The key obstacle to their implementation is institutional will.
The Gender Gap At The Top: What's Keeping Women From Leading Corporate America?Subha Barry
This Working Mother research project takes a comprehensive look at the experiences of women - and men - at all levels of corporations to ascertain what perceptions and realities are keeping them out of the highest ranks and to offer real solutions to close the gap.
Hays ondersteunt de promotie van vrouwen op de werkvloer. Veel bedrijven hebben een tekort aan vaardigheden in huis en het vergroten van het aantal vrouwelijke professionals kan helpen om dit probleem aan te pakken. Het verbeteren van toegang tot talent, stelt organisaties beter in staat om prestaties te vergroten, te groeien en toekomstig succes veilig te stellen.
Hays Global Gender Diversity Report 2016Hays Portugal
De acordo com um inquérito realizado pela Hays junto de mais de 11.500 inquiridos em 24 países, por ocasião do Dia Internacional da Mulher, homens e mulheres têm percepções muito diferentes quanto à desigualdade entre géneros a nível profissional.
O relatório analisa as respostas dos inquiridos em factores como ambição, auto-promoção, igualdade salarial, oportunidades de carreira e políticas de diversidade de género nas empresas.
Why Gender Diversity Matters at Work | ChronusChronus
Making up 47% of the current workforce and growing, women are prime candidates for filling the leadership pipeline that will soon be left lighter by a departing generation of workers. And yet, the higher you look in companies, the fewer women you see, with C-level positions comprised of only 19% women.
Learn how greater gender diversity can improve your organization, and why mentoring is an ideal solution to enable women in the workplace.
Download the full Ebook: http://ow.ly/fGyK30fCsaB
Phaidon International continues the 2017 Inclusive Talent Series in March discussing the challenges faced by women group within STEM industries; Attraction, Retention and Advancement.
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
By David F. Larcker, Stephen A. Miles, and Brian Tayan
Stanford Closer Look Series
Overview:
Shareholders pay considerable attention to the choice of executive selected as the new CEO whenever a change in leadership takes place. However, without an inside look at the leading candidates to assume the CEO role, it is difficult for shareholders to tell whether the board has made the correct choice. In this Closer Look, we examine CEO succession events among the largest 100 companies over a ten-year period to determine what happens to the executives who were not selected (i.e., the “succession losers”) and how they perform relative to those who were selected (the “succession winners”).
We ask:
• Are the executives selected for the CEO role really better than those passed over?
• What are the implications for understanding the labor market for executive talent?
• Are differences in performance due to operating conditions or quality of available talent?
• Are boards better at identifying CEO talent than other research generally suggests?
Prawie połowa osób zasiadających w Polsce na kierowniczych stanowiskach to kobiety – wynika z badania „Women in Business 2017” prowadzonego przez Grant Thornton. Polska jest pod tym względem w światowej czołówce
Happy International Women's Day. Cracking the Case. Why you need women leader...Mika Wilén
Maat, jotka ovat onnistuneet sukupuolten välisen tasa-arvon toteuttamisessa, ovat muita kilpailukykyisempiä. Silti naiset ovat yksi suurimmista alihyödynnetyistä osaajaresursseista maailmassa – ja erityisesti yritysten johtotehtävissä. Miksi? Johtuuko tämä siitä, että yritysten henkilöstökäytännöt eivät ole tältä vuosisadalta? Mihin asioihin ylimmän johdon tulisi kiinnittää huomiota, jotta muutos olisi mahdollinen? Lue lisää: Cracking the Case .
This Report answers questions on the makings of a modern day Tech CFO - the career paths, their personalities and the insights they use.
CFOs are the first line of defense from potential financial adversity.
They can also be the asset that allows companies to really expand their horizons rapidly.
Today, the CFO is a connector – the bridge between business, data & goals.
Yet, so little is spoken about these enablers.
So, we decided to shift the spotlight onto them.
What this report focuses on could address questions like:
who are they?
what is their education arc?
how has their career graph been?
what insights do we have about their personality style?
what makes them tick & what ticks them off?
when faced with rapid momentum, do they fight/ take flight?
Hope you get some answers to questions you have had in a while. If you want to ask me something or explore assistance as a CFO, please feel free to hit us up at connect@prequate.in.
Women in ICT Leadership - Are We Nearly There?Deanna Kosaraju
Voices 2014 presented by Global Tech Women
Women in ICT Leadership - Are We Nearly There?
Chandana Unnithan, Deakin University, Australia; Renu Rajani, Capgemini, India and Arathi G, RIPL, India
The CS Gender 3000: Women in Senior ManagementCredit Suisse
Greater gender diversity in companies' management improves their financial performance. A new Credit Suisse Research Institute study presents the financial evidence, looks at which regions and sectors show higher diversity levels and analyzes the obstacles to female participation in the workplace.
To download a copy of 'CS Gender 3000: Women in Senior Management', click here: http://bit.ly/1cWMUIM
Promoting multidimensional teams has a positive impact on business outcomes. Female presence in company's executive bodies is essential to build business projects that are successful and long-term oriented.
During the meeting held by Woman's Week foundation and the Association of Directors of Communication in Spain (Dircom), Chief Communication Officer and companies, committed to equal opportunities and diversity, professionals discussed about CSR regarding gender diversity.
We are indeed living a shift of paradigm where companies are more sensitive to the economic importance of their role as social actors and the strategic and integrated management of key intangible assets such as reputation, brand, communication or public issues. We are immersed in the so-called "reputation economy".
The main advantages of promoting diversity within the corporation are the greater capacity of attracting and retaining talent, improvement of leadership and innovation strategies and a closer approach to key stakeholders for the company. In fact, the main idea of the concept of diversity is to optimize human resources presented by heterogeneous groups, this is to say, diverse regarding the gender, age, race or nationality of their members.
We are making progress in integrating diverse teams in the organization, but we are still below the goal of 40 % female board managers in companies set out by the European Parliament and the European Commission.
This insight addresses the current situation and future leadership, where diversity will play a major role for sure.
As so many fields have in recent years, entry-level hiring must also make the transition from relying on untested intuition to leveraging the power of data and evidence. Employers now have access to talent analytics tools that can enable them to develop a deep understanding of what attributes drive good performance for their current employees, apply tools to objectively assess these attributes, and access broader talent pools to find individuals with the most-valued attributes. The talent analytics tools that enable this vision for data-driven hiring already exist. The key obstacle to their implementation is institutional will.
The Gender Gap At The Top: What's Keeping Women From Leading Corporate America?Subha Barry
This Working Mother research project takes a comprehensive look at the experiences of women - and men - at all levels of corporations to ascertain what perceptions and realities are keeping them out of the highest ranks and to offer real solutions to close the gap.
Hays ondersteunt de promotie van vrouwen op de werkvloer. Veel bedrijven hebben een tekort aan vaardigheden in huis en het vergroten van het aantal vrouwelijke professionals kan helpen om dit probleem aan te pakken. Het verbeteren van toegang tot talent, stelt organisaties beter in staat om prestaties te vergroten, te groeien en toekomstig succes veilig te stellen.
Hays Global Gender Diversity Report 2016Hays Portugal
De acordo com um inquérito realizado pela Hays junto de mais de 11.500 inquiridos em 24 países, por ocasião do Dia Internacional da Mulher, homens e mulheres têm percepções muito diferentes quanto à desigualdade entre géneros a nível profissional.
O relatório analisa as respostas dos inquiridos em factores como ambição, auto-promoção, igualdade salarial, oportunidades de carreira e políticas de diversidade de género nas empresas.
Why Gender Diversity Matters at Work | ChronusChronus
Making up 47% of the current workforce and growing, women are prime candidates for filling the leadership pipeline that will soon be left lighter by a departing generation of workers. And yet, the higher you look in companies, the fewer women you see, with C-level positions comprised of only 19% women.
Learn how greater gender diversity can improve your organization, and why mentoring is an ideal solution to enable women in the workplace.
Download the full Ebook: http://ow.ly/fGyK30fCsaB
Phaidon International continues the 2017 Inclusive Talent Series in March discussing the challenges faced by women group within STEM industries; Attraction, Retention and Advancement.
Die neue Studie “The Female CEO Reputation Premium? Differences & Similarities“ von Weber Shandwick und KRC Research untersucht, wie Führungskräfte weibliche und männliche CEOs wahrnehmen. Obwohl die Unternehmensreputation unabhängig vom Geschlecht des CEOs ist, finden sich dennoch Unterschiede in der Führungskompetenz männlicher und weiblicher CEOs. Weibliche Führungskräfte bleiben daher eher in Unternehmen mit weiblichen CEOs als mit männlichen…
Women are less likely to receive the first critical promotion to manager—so far fewer end up on the path to leadership—and are less likely to be hired into more senior positions. Women also get less access to the people, input, and opportunities that accelerate careers. As a result, the higher you look in companies, the fewer women you see.
This disparity is especially pronounced for women of color, who face the most barriers to advancement and experience the steepest drop-offs with seniority.
Our annual report finds significant numbers of startups continue to have no women in leadership, yet a growing percentage have programs in place to change that.
The Kelly Global Workforce Index (KGWI) is an annual global survey that is the largest study of its kind. In 2015, Kelly collected feedback from 164,000 workers across 28 countries across the Americas, EMEA, and APAC regions and a multitude of industries and occupations.
This study is taking a high level look at:
- Work-Life Design as it pertains to the global worker today.
- Women in STEM Talent Gap - a study that at the gap of women talent in STEM – Science, Technology, Engineering and Math – fields.
- Career Management – specifically the emerging trend of do-it-yourself (“DIY”) career development – as it pertains to the global worker seeking to be as resilient as possible in today’s uncertain environment
- Collaborative Work Environment as it pertains to the global worker today.
Here is our second global report on the topic Women in STEM.
Millennial Women and Workplace Transformation: A PreparedU Infographic StorybookBentley University
Bentley University's PreparedU Project examines the unique challenges and opportunities facing millennial women in the 21st Century workforce. How can they be prepared for success? What roles do parents, companies, mentors, higher education institutions, and millennial women themselves need to play? Drawing on the results of the PreparedU survey, this infographic storybook moves past the problems to highlight solutions grounded in data and in the personal stories of women leaders at all stages of their careers. Learn more at www.bentley.edu/prepared and follow the conversation on Twitter with #PrepUWIB.
Strategies on how to attract and retain female talent - LVI Associates.pdfonline Marketing
Covering the state of diversity in the transportation market, LVI Associates Principal Consultant Sarah Davis discusses the challenges hiring managers and job seekers face within engineering, as well as how firms can attract female talent in a competitive market, and the importance of retention. please visit: https://www.lviassociates.com/disciplines/transportation
How to Attract and Retain Female Talent - LVI Associates.pdfonline Marketing
Covering the state of diversity in the transportation market, LVI Associates Principal Consultant Sarah Davis discusses the challenges hiring managers and job seekers face within engineering, as well as how firms can attract female talent in a competitive market, and the importance of retention. Please visit: https://www.lviassociates.com/blog/2022/09/attract-retain-female-talent-in-engineering
3. In today’s fiercely competitive environment, organizations
cannot afford to underutilize nearly half of their workforce.
Women influence 83 percent of all dollars spent on consumer
purchases. Both men and women agree that women have special
insights into female consumers. Yet little progress is being made
in the development, advancement and leveraging of female
talent at many consumer products and retail companies.
Traditional talent management systems are not advancing
women. Radical shifts in the workforce, pressures in the
marketplace and women employees who are less willing
to tolerate wage and opportunity gaps have made intrinsic,
foundational organization change a business imperative.
By recognizing the strategic importance of women to business
transformation and growth and acknowledging the profound
impact unconscious bias has on women’s career trajectory,
progressive companies can begin to overhaul their approach
to gender diversity and inclusion and realize increased profits.
These are the costs
of overlooking the talent
of women leaders.
Trudy Bourgeois, president and
CEO of The Center for Workforce
Excellence, is a workforce
performance strategist
specializing in developing 21st
century leaders. More on Trudy
on page 15.
The authors
Leslie Traub, chief consulting
officer for Cook Ross Inc., creates
sustainable systems of change
that yield greater performance,
profit and possibility. More on
Leslie on page 15.
4. Turn it on: Companies with the
best record for promoting women
outperformed industry revenue
averages by 46 percent.
5. N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E | 5
A changing talent pool
More than a decade ago, McKinsey & Company published a
groundbreaking study that said talent would be the most critical corporate
resource for the next 20 years. Since then, other research has supported that
conclusion, directly tying a company’s competitive advantage to a highly
engaged talent pool that mirrors the face of the consumer.
Companies that don’t leverage the potential of women hinder their chances
of finding the best leaders and limit their company’s outputs significantly,
according to a 2008 Deloitte study. That finding is supported by a 2009 study
by Pepperdine professor Roy Adler, who found companies with the best record
for promoting women outperformed industry revenue averages by 46 percent.
Seventy percent of all new incoming employees in 2010 were women,
people of color and immigrants, according to The
Economist article “Women and work: We did it!”
These demographic changes will be hastened as
huge numbers of Baby Boomers head for retirement
in the coming few years.
Another shift: More women than men are
graduating from college. In 2011, there were
2.6 million more women than men studying at
U.S. colleges and universities, according to an
estimate published inWomenomics by Katty Kay
and Claire Shipman.
America is not alone. Women comprise a
growing share of the workforce worldwide,
particularly in rapidly expanding economies
in countries like Brazil, India and China.
Today’s workforce needs leaders who can achieve breakthrough results. The
strengths of women leaders—to create collaborative relationships, inform
strategy with empathy, respond to nontraditional needs and be effective
mentors and sponsors—are key.
Leaders who can leverage both the masculine and the feminine characteristics
of leadership are crucial to the cpg/retail industry’s success, because today’s
workforce doesn’t just care about results, but how results are achieved.
Women earning more degrees than men
Women will earn nearly two-thirds of the associate degrees and
more than half of the doctorates in the United States this year.
n Men n Women
Source: National Center for Education Statistics.
Associate
Bachelor
Master
Doctorate
37.7% 62.3%
43.4% 56.6%
41.2% 58.8%
48.4% 51.6%
B E S T P R A C T I C E S S E R I E S C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
6. Despite these changes in the workforce and the business case for advancing
women in cpg/retail, 70 percent of U.S.‑based corporations have no clearly
defined strategy for developing women for leadership roles, according to a
2010 study by Mercer.
A review of companies in the Standard & Poor’s 100 reveals a diversity
deficit in the corporate c-suite: The number of women and minority board
members and executives at S&P 100 Index companies has remained flat
over the past several years, according to a 2010
Calvert Investments report, which evaluates S&P100
companies’ commitment to diversity and inclusion.
Well over half of these companies (56 percent) have
no women or minorities in their five highest-paid
executive positions. Of the100 CEOs represented,
92 are white males.
The scarcity of women in the c-suite is directly
related to the failure of traditional talent management
thinking, according to a study by Deloitte. Women’s
talent development has typically focused on “fixing”
women without addressing the environment in which
they work.
Optimizing the contributions of female leaders
requires clearly identifying and addressing their barriers
to success; actively identifying women as a strategic resource for growing the
business; and holding senior leaders, starting with the CEO, accountable for
talent management.
A number of barriers to success must be overcome. Bias, both conscious
and unconscious, is still alive and well in organizations, including assumptions
about what women want and don’t want in the workplace. Also, leadership
competencies are based on masculine style and leadership history.
Senior leaders must recognize these barriers and become public champions
for advancing women. “When companies fail to acknowledge and address
the impact of gender stereotypic bias, they lose out on top female talent,” said
Ilene H. Lang, president of Catalyst, a non-profit organization that works to
expand opportunities for women and businesses. “Ultimately, it’s not women’s
leadership styles that need to change. Only when organizations take action to
It’s not women who need to change
6 | N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
56%30%
14%
No women
or minorities in
the five highest
paid positions
One woman
or minority
in five highest
paid positions
Two or more women
and/or minorities
in five highest paid
positions
Source: “Examining the Cracks in the Ceiling: A Survey of Corporate Diversity Practices
of the S&P 100.” Calvert, October 2010.
Diversity lags at S&P 100 companies
Few women and minorities hold the top-paying executive
positions at S&P100 companies.
B E S T P R A C T I C E S S E R I E S C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
7. address the impact of gender stereotyping will they
be able to capitalize on the ‘full deck’ of talent.”
It’s a self-fulfilling prophecy: The lack of female
role models translates into less confidence, less
support and less willingness to pursue leadership
roles. When women do reach for the brass ring,
unrealistic work requirements often force them
to choose between personal and professional
aspirations.
To truly focus on meeting the shifting demands
of the consumer, the development and advancement
of women must become a business imperative. The
CEO must set the expectation that leaders who do
not actively engage in executing this strategy will
face the same kind of consequences they would
Why women don’t advance
A lack of opportunities to gain important job experience, dearth of executive sponsors and mentors, and
work/life balance issues are chief factors hindering the career advancement of women, according to a
survey of HR and diversity leaders.
face if they missed a key financial benchmark. The
consequences must go beyond withholding a small
slice of the year-end bonus. It must be linked to the
executive’s future advancement. Senior leaders must
believe the viability of the company depends on
the cultivation of women in leadership roles (guess
what—it does).
Three keys to shifting organizational culture are
clear, unequivocal leadership vision; modeling; and
accountability.
Although the intention of an organization’s
leaders may be aligned with their talent management
and inclusion goals, the unexamined aspects of an
organization—its mental models—may derail the
company’s objectives.
N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E | 7
Insufficientdepthofexperience
Insufficientbreadthofexperience
Lackofglobalexperience
Lackofexecutiveleadershippotential
Lackofexecutivesponsor
Lackofmentor
Limitedsocialnetwork/connections
Willingnesstorelocate
Work/lifebalance
Ambition
Confidence
Resilience
Decision-makingability
40%
30%
20%
10%
0
Source: “U.S. Women’s Leadership Development Survey” of 1,800 human resource, talent management and diversity leaders at 540 organizations worldwide.
Mercer with Talent Management and Diversity Management magazines, 2010.
8. To affect change, leaders need a strong vision for inclusion and a strategic
link between women in leadership ranks and achieving organizational goals.
They must also model inclusive behavior in their organization.
High-level sponsorship of gender inclusion is critical, regardless of the
leader’s gender. Leaders must embody the company’s diversity and inclusion
values and ensure they are fully translated into policies, behaviors, culture and
messaging. A leader who is authentic about his or her
commitment to gender equity will be forgiven more
quickly for an occasional misstep than a leader who
gives all the right answers but lacks commitment to
the cause.
When a high-ranking man—working alone or in
partnership with a female leader—assumes the key
leadership role in support of gender inclusion, it can
help shift long-held paradigms. Too often, this leadership role is held by a
woman. This often leads employees to think of gender diversity and inclusion
as a “woman’s issue,” not an organizational issue.
In their efforts to create change, many companies charge one leader with
embodying diversity and inclusion values, preventing them from becoming
a core competency of the entire leadership team. Often, the commitment
to gender equity and inclusion withers with the departure of the designated
“inclusion advocate.”
To ensure leaders are strategically focused and authentic, companies should:
n Feature the champions. Canvas the organization’s leadership to find the
person who most authentically can speak to the strategic reasons for full
gender inclusion, including multicultural women.
n Fully explore—in a small group setting—the company’s inclusion strategy
and its implications. Focus resources, messaging, expectations and
accountability for all of the company’s leaders.
n Gather key influencers in talent management and explore the effectiveness
of messaging.
n Listen for key influencers’ messaging and provide regular reinforcement and
coaching so that they may find their own words to convey the right message
for the organization.
What leaders can do
When a high-ranking man—working
alone or in partnership with a female
leader—assumes the key leadership
role in support of gender inclusion,
it can help shift long-held paradigms.
8 | N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
B E S T P R A C T I C E S S E R I E S C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
9. You can’t get
ahead if you work
part time. You must have an
MBA to lead a business unit. You
must have tenure
to get promoted.
Only an Ivy League grad can be a good
leader here. You have to
do an international
rotation to move to
the vice president
level.
Challenging old ideas
To further gender equity, existing thought models
and bias regarding talent management in the organiza-
tion must be identified and challenged. People responsi-
ble for talent management are the linchpin for expand-
ing the talent pool. All managers—regardless of gender,
race or nationality—have individual and collective
sociocultural programming that provides preferences,
standards, interpretations and filters of other people. No
one is bias-free. In fact, we need certain types of bias to
survive and manage in this complex world. But bias that
unconsciously extends to groups of people is detrimen-
tal to all concerned.
Unconscious bias intervention is needed to spot
and stop these often subtle behaviors. It begins with
talent managers who are aware of the potential for and
the existence of unconscious bias within the system.
One mistake many make as they focus on building an
inclusive culture is becoming stuck in the awareness
phase of unconscious bias intervention without develop-
ing behaviors that advance change.
Companies that want to strengthen their DI initia-
tives can use exercises and other tools to shed light
on the biases that may be imbedded throughout the
organization. One way to do this: Gather employees re-
sponsible for talent management and collectively identify
and challenge all of the assumptions the organization
makes about talent. Most often, these thought models
are never examined. They simply become part of the tal-
ent requirements because “that’s the way we’ve always
done it.” Some of these mental models could be: “You
must have an MBA to lead a business unit.” “You can’t
get ahead if you work part time.” “Only an Ivy League
grad can be a good leader here.” “You have to do an
international rotation before you can move to the vice
president level.” “You must have a certain amount of
tenure before you can get promoted.”
After the review, create a more objective list of
talent criteria and identify the appropriate channels for
communication. A credible outside voice may bring a
broader perspective.
N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E | 9
That’s the way we’ve
always done it
10. To seize the opportunities associated with advancing women, gender talent
management must become a shared responsibility for all line managers.
Accountability for inclusive talent management must be built into existing
performance management systems.
Depending on the industry and organization’s culture, the performance
management system can be the most highly leveraged opportunity for ensuring
a gender-equal pipeline of talent. Unfortunately, most performance management
tends to positively reinforce employees who model the leadership style and
characteristics of the organization’s existing leaders, often filtering out people
who are different and disregarding the results these individuals have produced.
Women do not receive corrective feedback, performance coaching or career
sponsoring as frequently as men. This impacts how women are perceived and
their ability to advance. Corrective feedback is
critical for growth. If an employee doesn’t grow,
she stagnates and is not seen as a leader.
Despite all the research, best practices and
structures built into performance management
systems, performance reviews are conducted by human beings, and that
makes them vulnerable to bias. Training on unconscious bias and its effect on
performance reviews is an important start to mitigating its negative impact.
Performance management systems should include:
n Tools to help managers think about each review before delivering it and
challenge assumptions about the employees. Such tools can help us break
down why one person is always the “go-to person” for any task and another
is never considered.
n An ombudsman who can talk to employees about their rating, objectively
evaluate the rating through independent documentation and observation,
and facilitate a new rating if warranted.
n Monitors who are present at all performance review sessions to question
language and ungrounded assertions about individuals. At Ernst Young,
monitors listen for stereotypical language in describing one gender over
another, for instance references to a woman’s “style” and a man’s “potential.”
n A post-review audit process. Each performance review should be scrutinized
to ensure the outcomes are as bias-free as possible. If the performance review
resulted in an employee being chosen for a higher position or bonus that
process also should be audited to ensure that a diverse slate was considered.
1 0 | N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
A shared responsibility
Women do not receive corrective
feedback, performance coaching or
career sponsoring as frequently as men.
B E S T P R A C T I C E S S E R I E S C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
11. Targets are not quotas
The history of quotas in U.S. corporations has given leaders
pause about setting representation targets. In the past, quotas
often meant putting people into positions they weren’t ready for.
Targets, however, identify where organizations think they should
be demographically, by level, and measure the process points
to achieve those levels of diversity. Diversity targets can help
expand representation at key leadership levels and in devel-
opmental activities, such job mobility, rotations, leadership
development programs and high-visibility assignments. They
require organizations to look at metrics, which causes leaders to
consider whether existing metrics support the company’s busi-
ness strategies. Targets that measure women in general, and
women of color as a subset, can be tracked and presented in a
diversity scorecard.
The data on a diversity scorecard should be considered key
business data, subject to the same rigors and attention as a
profit and loss statement, a company’s EBITA or other financial
and business data.
Key targets should include:
n Promotion rates by gender at all senior levels.
n The ratio of males to females in succession planning systems
and in line for senior positions.
n Gender representation at senior levels.
n Gender turnover at all levels.
n Gender distribution of protégés in mentoring programs.
n Gender distribution of mobility, participation in leadership
development and key assignments.
n Employee engagement measures by gender.
n Manager cultural competency by gender, including measures
of a manager’s ability to create an inclusive environment.
n Use of flexible work arrangements/programs by gender.
For every metric on gender there should be a sub-metric for
women of color, or women of color will continue to be overlooked
in organizational gender strategies.
N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E | 1 1
Ceo/senior
executive
Women
Men
nFirst job (post MBA) nCurrent job
2%
12%
6%
24%
Career trajectories of men vs. women
Men rise higher and faster than women. Men are more likely to start their first post-MBA job in higher posi-
tions than women and are twice as likely as women to currently hold CEO or senior-executive level positions.
Source: “The Promise of Future Leadership: A Research Program on Highly Talented Employees in the Pipeline,” based on a survey of 4,143 women and men
who graduated from full-time elite MBA programs between 1996 and 2007 and worked full-time at the time of the survey in 2007-2008. Catalyst, 2010.
Mid-manager
(Or equivalent
on professional/
technical track)
Women
Men
8%
13%
36%
38%
Entry level
(Or individual
contributor)
Women
Men
60%
46%
20%
12%
First-level
manager
(Or equivalent
on professional/
technical track)
Women
Men
30%
34%
32%
25%
12. To succeed, gender diversity and inclusion initiatives must have the full
participation of men. Culture-change messages about gender are more
powerful to men when they come from other men, according to a 2010
New York Times editorial by contributor Katrin Bennhold. The next wave
of equality support, she said, will come from men who exhibit work/life
balance, take advantage of flex work programs and discuss with their peers the
importance of women to the company’s business strategy.
For too long, a focus on retaining and developing women for
leadership positions has been the purview of women. But men’s
ownership, sponsorship, accountability and involvement can
catapult the dialogue to a new level—the only way both women
and men will benefit from a change in corporate culture.
For now, “high-potential women are over-mentored and
under-sponsored relative to their male peers—and those women
are not advancing in their organizations,” according to “Why
Men Still Get More Promotions than Women,” a 2010 article in the Harvard
Business Review. To create change, companies such as Sodexo, Deutsche
Bank and IBM Europe have created sponsoring programs aimed at inviting
senior-level men to be sponsors and advocates of high-potential women in
their organizations. As a result, sponsored high-potential women from Sodexo,
for example, have been promoted at higher rates than non-sponsored high-
potential women, “in part because the senior male sponsors serve as career
sponsors and learn to manage their unconscious biases,” the authors noted.
To engage men in culture change, companies need:
n Committed male champions (including the CEO, CFO and CIO) who
support and contribute to the strategy of women in leadership.
n Men who are willing to engage with other men and women about gender
stereotypes and the personal and organizational cost of not being full
partners with women at work.
n Men who take leadership roles in women’s employee resource groups by
sponsoring programs or women’s networks.
These champions are typically influential men who are motivated by their
own sense of inclusiveness, the good of their organizations and devotion to
their employees. For every active champion there are many more who are
willing but not yet engaged.
1 2 | N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
“ High-potential women are
over-mentored and under-
sponsored relative to their
male peers—and those
women are not advancing
in their organizations.”
Engaging men in gender DI
B E S T P R A C T I C E S S E R I E S C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
13. Work/life solutions for all
To encourage and support gender diversity at all
levels, a company should have a highly visible and
accessible work/life program that is targeted and
marketed to the entire workforce, not just women.
Many of today’s work/life programs are compre-
hensive, targeted to women—and underutilized. An
inclusive organizational culture builds work/life prac-
tices that appeal to all employees, not just women,
and ensures their use is not “career suicide” or “just
for young mothers.”
Too often a company’s human resources, talent
management or diversity practitioners create work/
life programs with leadership support, but neglect
to establish managerial accountability and practices
that will ensure their use.
A 2008 report from the Corporate Executive
Board’s Corporate Leadership Council that identified
the work/life preferences of 50,000 respondents
revealed employees most prefer flexible work sched-
ules, appropriate workloads, predictable working
hours, remote work sites and the ability to switch
between part-time and full-time employment. While
many organizations are recognized and awarded for
offering these programs, few are judged on the per-
centage of employees who actually use them. Those
who take advantage of work/life programs are often
the subject of unconscious and conscious biases and
perceived as lacking commitment to their organiza-
tion, career and team.
Forty-seven percent of the Corporate Executive
Board’s Corporate Leadership Council survey respon-
dents said seeing peers use programs, regardless
of gender, drives more use. Other drivers include
allowing employees to control the program and
practices, providing clear implementation guidelines
and encouraging managers to promote work/life
integration among their staff.
N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E | 1 3
Best practices for talent management
When evaluating work/life benefits, employees favor offerings
that enable better workload management: a flexible work schedule,
appropriate workload and predictable working hours.
Share of employees who ranked practice in top 5
Worktime practices
Flexible work schedule
Appropriate workload
Predictable work hours
Forced vacation time
Personal time interruptions
Job sharing
Switching part and full time
Work location practices
Telecommuting technology
Remote work sites
Business travel nights away
Time spent telecommuting
Family practices
Emergency leave of absence
Paid parental leave
Childcare subsidies
On-site childcare
Development practices
Education reimbursement
Employee counseling
Sabbatical/educational leave
Employee support groups
Services
Personal insurance
On-site parking
Fitness services
Cafeteria
Commuting subsidies
Health practices
Paid sick leave
Preventive health care program
On-site nurse or doctor
Source: “Improve Returns on Work-Life Balance Investments,” based on a survey of more
than 50,000 respondents from 35 organizations in more than 25 countries. Corporate
Executive Board, 2008.
63%
62%
33%
16%
12%
9%
7%
24%
14%
11%
9%
15%
9%
7%
6%
24%
12%
11%
8%
31%
17%
13%
11%
10%
25%
20%
6%
14. Concepts of gender inclusion should be fully integrated into existing
leadership and management development programs so that DI is a part of
the “business of the business.”
Organizational values, norms and behaviors may be taught through a range
of training initiatives. Surprisingly, most organizations do not include diversity
and inclusion scenarios, information or messaging in on-boarding, supervisory
training and leadership training programs.
A few steps will help ensure all of a company’s values are reflected in the
company’s portfolio of training programs:
n Invite a diverse group of employees to audit the organization’s soft skills
training portfolio. Each person is likely to perceive the programs differently.
n Ask auditors to note all references to diversity and inclusion. Are there case
studies that challenge participants to work out equitable solutions? Is there
diverse representation in all of the case studies and scenarios? Are inclusive
leadership behaviors presented as important to your organization?
n Share audit results and recommendations, including new or revised case
studies, with leaders responsible for managing the training portfolio.
n Ensure senior leaders direct and support the broadening of training
curriculums.
n Audit technical training as well. Ensure that cases, examples, scenarios,
videos and materials reflect the diversity that the company values. Modeling
DI unequivocally is more important and powerful than discussing it.
1 4 | N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
Training to change
B E S T P R A C T I C E S S E R I E S C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E
15. Resources
n Harvard University’s Implicit Association Test website explores the existence of
bias. Go to www.implicit.harvard.edu.
n The Intercultural Development Inventory (IDI) is an online assessment that
helps people expand the awareness of their biases and cultural competencies
based on a worldview. It supports the adoption of new behaviors and provides
insight on ways to hold one’s self and others accountable. Visit www.
workforceexcellence.com.
n Catalyst has done extensive research on the impact of unconscious bias on
talent management. “Cascading Gender Biases, Compounding Effects: An
Assessment of Talent Management Systems” identifies the way in which
required leadership traits and characteristics stem from the masculine approach
and model of leadership and rarely include leadership traits most commonly
associated with women’s leadership. This free report is available at www.
catalyst.org.
Catalyst also offers the Talent Management Evaluation Toolkit: Assessing
Systems for Gender Biases. Go to www.catalyst.org/publication/293/talent-
management-evaluation-toolkit-assessing-systems-for-gender-biases.
n “Proven Strategies for Addressing Unconscious Bias in the Workplace” is
offered by Cook Ross Inc. at www.cookross.com/docs/UnconsciousBias.
pdf. The firm also offers other tools for managing unconscious bias in talent
management.
About the authors
n Trudy Bourgeois, president and CEO of The Center for Workforce
Excellence, is a workforce performance strategist specializing in developing
21st century leaders who will elicit the greatest contribution from all employees.
Bourgeois provides unique insights on building authentic relationships to support
collaboration, innovation and best practices that result in breakthrough business
results and increased bottom lines. She is the author of Her Corner Office: A
Guide to Help Women Find a Place and Voice in Corporate America and The
Hybrid Leader: Blending the Best of the Male and Female Leadership Styles.
She is a former senior sales/marketing executive with 27 years of cross-
functional business experience. Bourgeois broke the glass ceiling in the tobacco
industry to become one of the consumer goods industry’s first African American
female vice presidents.
n Leslie Traub, chief consulting officer for Cook Ross Inc., has more than
25 years of experience leading gender equity, diversity, inclusion, cultural
competence and change management initiatives. She creates sustainable
systems of change that yield greater performance, profit and possibility. Traub
is a fellow in change management from Johns Hopkins University and holds
a master’s degree in biostatistics and epidemiology from Tulane University,
a bachelor’s degree in economics and history from Wheaton College and a
certificate in training and development from the University of Maryland. She is a
contributor to human resources and diversity publications and frequent speaker
at conferences and symposia around the world. Traub serves as guest faculty for
graduate programs at Georgetown University, George Washington University and
Johns Hopkins University.
References
Adler, Roy D. “Women in the executive suite correlate to high profits.” European
Project on Equal Pay. 2009.
“Women and work: We did it!” The Economist. December 30, 2009.
Augustine, Amy et al. “Examining the cracks in the ceiling: A survey of corporate
diversity practices of the SP 100.” Calvert Investments. October 2010.
Benko, Cathy and Weisberg, Anne C. Mass career customization: Aligning the
workplace with today’s nontraditional workforce. 1st Edition. Boston, Harvard
Business School Press. 2007.
Bennhold, Katrin. “Feminism of the future relies on men.” www.NewYorkTimes.
com. June 22, 2010.
Bourgeois, Trudy. The Hybrid Leader: Blending the best of the male and female
leadership styles. Winchester, VA, Oakhill Press. 2006.
Carli, Linda L. and Eagly, Alice H. “Women and the Labyrinth of Leadership.”
Harvard Business Review. September 2007.
Catalyst. “The Double Bind Dilemma for Women in Leadership: Damned if you do,
doomed if you don’t.” 2007.
Catalyst. “What keeps women from reaching the top?” WomensMedia.com. April
2, 2009.
Chambers, Elizabeth G. et al. “The War for Talent.” McKinsey Quarterly. August
1998.
Corporate Executive Board’s Corporate Leadership Council. “Improve Returns on
Work-Life Balance Investments: Workload management tactics matter much more
than traditional work-life benefits for driving candidate attraction and employee
commitment.” 2008.
Dychtwald, Maddy. Influence: How Women’s Soaring Economic Power Will
Transform Our World for the Better.1st Edition. Dallas, Voice Publishing. 2010.
Ibarra, Herminia et al. “Why Men Still Get More Promotions than Women.” Harvard
Business Review. September 2010.
Kay, Katty and Shipman, Claire. Womenomics. 1st Edition. New York,
HarperBusiness. 2009.
Mercer. “Most Employers Lacking a Strategy to Develop Women Leaders.” www.
mercer.com. October 25, 2010.
Pink, Daniel. “A Whole New Mind: Why right-brainers will rule the future.” New
York: Riverhead Trade. 2006.
Rosener, Judy. “Ways Women Lead.” Harvard Business Review. November/
December 1990.
Ross, Howard. “Proven Strategies for Addressing Unconscious Bias in the
Workplace.” Diversity Best Practices. 2008.
Smith, W. Stanton. “Decoding Generational: Fact, fiction or should we just get back
to work?” Deloitte Development LLC. 2008.
Warren, Anika K. “Cascading Gender Biases, Compounding Effects: An assessment
of talent management systems.” Catalyst. February 2009.
Warren, Anika K. “Talent Management Evaluation Toolkit: Assessing systems for
gender biases.” Catalyst. February 2009.
N E T W O R K O F E X E C U T I V E W O M E N — C H A N G I N G T H E G A M E | 1 5
16. A final word
A good CEO who learned of a major missed opportunity would immediately
assemble a team of the organization’s brightest individuals to build a strategy
to get back in the game. Every member of the team would commit to the
strategy and help mobilize the organization behind the plan.
Leveraging female talent is one such opportunity. To succeed, it must receive
focus, financial support, measurement and follow up. But developing and
advancing female leaders is bigger than any one organization’s success. It
is about sustainability and innovation for the entire consumer products and
retail industry.
For more information on the Network of Executive Women and our diversity
and inclusion events, programs and research, visit www.newonline.org.
Network of Executive Women
c/o Accenture for mail service
161 North Clark Street, 39th floor
Chicago, IL 60601
Tel. 312.957.7257
Email info@newonline.orgnewonline.org
facebook.com/newnational
newonline.org/linkedin
twitter.com/newnational
newonline.org/youtube
newonline.org/connectNEW
CONNECT