Amparo Habeas corpus compared

•Download as PPT, PDF•

0 likes•581 views

D

A contrast and comparison analysis of the American and Mexican habeas corpus Law.

Comparative Analysis of the Amparo Mexican Law and the U.S. Judicial System by Olga M. Lazin, UCLA

The Amparo and American Law ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Major Differences ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Amparo and Habeas Corpus (U.S.) ,[object Object],[object Object]

Comparison HC vs Amparo ,[object Object]

Judge vs trial by a jury of your peers ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Duane Dog’s case ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Dog Jumped Bail in Mexico ,[object Object],[object Object]

How Unintegrated the 2 Systems Are ,[object Object]

Napoleonic code in Spanish colonies and French dominions ,[object Object],[object Object]

[object Object]

MILITARY ACT, 2005 ,[object Object]

http://foros.fox.presidencia.gob.mx/read.php?3,93807 ,[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

LochnervNy

What Else Marcos did on September 21, 1972

What Else Marcos did on September 21, 1972

What Else Marcos did on September 21, 1972

RubenCarranza12

Who makes the rules?

Who makes the rules?

Who makes the rules?

8th Grade - South Carolina History

Declarations and Rights

Declarations and Rights

Declarations and Rights

Jonathan Dresner

6-1(part 1) ush

6-1(part 1) ush

6-1(part 1) ush

Jeffrey Lambert

Colonial government

Colonial government

Colonial government

Comm law class 2 slides

Comm law class 2 slides

Comm law class 2 slides

06.10.08 POLI 383

06.10.08 POLI 383

06.10.08 POLI 383

christineshearer

USNA PUBLIC NOTICE

USNA PUBLIC NOTICE

USNA PUBLIC NOTICE

Roots of American Democracy

Roots of American Democracy

Roots of American Democracy

Lewis County High School

East west alliance_limited_vs_ukraine_ECHR Desicion

East west alliance_limited_vs_ukraine_ECHR Desicion

East west alliance_limited_vs_ukraine_ECHR Desicion

Chernikhovskiy Nazar

British extraterritorial jurisdiction in siam british extraterritorial jurisd...

British extraterritorial jurisdiction in siam british extraterritorial jurisd...

British extraterritorial jurisdiction in siam british extraterritorial jurisd...

Kanaphon Chanhom

Medieval English Government

Medieval English Government

Medieval English Government

Presumed “parapolitician” named ambassador in Holland. Paramilitary diplomacy

Presumed “parapolitician” named ambassador in Holland. Paramilitary diplomacy

Presumed “parapolitician” named ambassador in Holland. Paramilitary diplomacy

Comisión Colombiana de Juristas

Our political beginnings

Our political beginnings

Our political beginnings

Forgione Bill Of Rights

Forgione Bill Of Rights

Forgione Bill Of Rights

What's hot (16)

LochnervNy

What Else Marcos did on September 21, 1972

What Else Marcos did on September 21, 1972

What Else Marcos did on September 21, 1972

Who makes the rules?

Who makes the rules?

Who makes the rules?

Declarations and Rights

Declarations and Rights

Declarations and Rights

6-1(part 1) ush

6-1(part 1) ush

6-1(part 1) ush

Colonial government

Colonial government

Colonial government

Comm law class 2 slides

Comm law class 2 slides

Comm law class 2 slides

06.10.08 POLI 383

06.10.08 POLI 383

06.10.08 POLI 383

USNA PUBLIC NOTICE

USNA PUBLIC NOTICE

USNA PUBLIC NOTICE

Roots of American Democracy

Roots of American Democracy

Roots of American Democracy

East west alliance_limited_vs_ukraine_ECHR Desicion

East west alliance_limited_vs_ukraine_ECHR Desicion

East west alliance_limited_vs_ukraine_ECHR Desicion

British extraterritorial jurisdiction in siam british extraterritorial jurisd...

British extraterritorial jurisdiction in siam british extraterritorial jurisd...

British extraterritorial jurisdiction in siam british extraterritorial jurisd...

Medieval English Government

Medieval English Government

Medieval English Government

Presumed “parapolitician” named ambassador in Holland. Paramilitary diplomacy

Presumed “parapolitician” named ambassador in Holland. Paramilitary diplomacy

Presumed “parapolitician” named ambassador in Holland. Paramilitary diplomacy

Our political beginnings

Our political beginnings

Our political beginnings

Forgione Bill Of Rights

Forgione Bill Of Rights

Forgione Bill Of Rights

Similar to Amparo Habeas corpus compared

Amparo Habeascorpus Compared

Amparo Habeascorpus Compared

Amparo Habeascorpus Compared

Dr Lazin On The Amparo & habeas corpus compared, 12-10a-06

Dr Lazin On The Amparo & habeas corpus compared, 12-10a-06

Dr Lazin On The Amparo & habeas corpus compared, 12-10a-06

AleksandraKowalik (9)

AleksandraKowalik (9)

AleksandraKowalik (9)

Aleksandra Kowalik

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Yavuz Sefik 1/29/15 Week 21 Analysis The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen embodies enlightenment principles articulated by Locke, Rousseau and Voltaire as those principles were understood by bourgeois leaders and members of the French National Assembly, and this is apparent in the document itself. The “preamble” of the document begins by saying that the French people’s representatives, not the monarchy, are the ones who are setting the rights of man straight. “The representatives of the French people, organized as a National Assembly, believing that the ignorance, neglect, or contempt of the rights of man are the sole cause of public calamities and of the corruption of governments, have determined to set forth in a solemn declaration the natural, unalienable, and sacred rights of man.” The National Assembly then lists the rights of man and the citizen. The influence of prominent Enlightenment thinkers is obvious in the document. For example, the first right states that, “Men are born and remain free and equal in rights.” This is an idea that Rousseau would emphasize. The bourgeois leaders then continue by stating each human’s natural rights, which are, “liberty, property, security, and resistance to oppression.” Both Locke and Rousseau have contributed ideas to French society that the assembly picked up on. The document then continues stating rights, and allows the people the freedom to do any action that does not harm someone else. “Law can only prohibit such actions as are hurtful to society. Nothing may be prevented which is not forbidden by law, and no one may be forced to do anything not provided for by law.” This is an idea that Voltaire would have likely supported. Another right in the document that likely originated from Voltaire is the right to religious freedom. “No one shall be disquieted on account of his opinions, including his religious views, provided their manifestation does not disturb the public order established by law.” Yavuz Sefik 1/28/15 Week 21 Homework The French National Assembly came to be in a turmoil of chaos and oppression of French commoners; they had a goal of revolutionizing the French governmental system by giving more power to the people and less to the monarchy, and they were partially successful in doing this by passing the Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Constitution of 1791. In the 1780s, France was in a crisis. After paying for a costly war to ensure the independence of the Americans, the country was in deep debt. Since all taxes came from the poorest people of France, there was little that could be done in the current situation to alleviate the debt. As a result, the government called the Estates-General into session, which did not happen since 1614. Three estates, or social classes, made up this legislative body: the clergy, the nobility, and the commoners. Normally, each estate had one vote. However, the third estate, the commoners, did not like this, since any proposa.

Yavuz Sefik12915Week 21 AnalysisThe Declaration of the Ri.docx

Yavuz Sefik12915Week 21 AnalysisThe Declaration of the Ri.docx

Yavuz Sefik12915Week 21 AnalysisThe Declaration of the Ri.docx

Criminal justice power point eng1105

Criminal justice power point eng1105

Criminal justice power point eng1105

Court insider exposes judicial treachery november 16

Court insider exposes judicial treachery november 16

Court insider exposes judicial treachery november 16

CHAPTER 1 Legal Heritage and the Digital Age Statue of Liberty, New York Harbor The Statue of Liberty stands majestically in New York Harbor. During the American Revolution, France gave the colonial patriots substantial support in the form of money for equipment and supplies, officers and soldiers who fought in the war, and ships and sailors who fought on the seas. Without the assistance of France, it is unlikely that the American colonists would have won their independence from Britain. In 1886, the people of France gave the Statue of Liberty to the people of the United States in recognition of friendship that was established during the American Revolution. Since then, the Statue of Liberty has become a symbol of liberty and democracy throughout the world. Learning Objectives After studying this chapter, you should be able to: 1. Define law. 2. Describe the functions of law. 3. Explain the development of the U.S. legal system. 4. List and describe the sources of law in the United States. 5. Discuss the importance of the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Brown v. Board of Education. Chapter Outline 1. Introduction to Legal Heritage and the Digital Age 2. What Is Law? 1. Landmark U.S. Supreme Court Case • Brown v. Board of Education 3. Schools of Jurisprudential Thought 1. CASE 1.1 • U.S. Supreme Court Case • POM Wonderful LLC v. Coca-Cola Company 2. Global Law • Command School of Jurisprudence of Cuba 4. History of American Law 1. Landmark Law • Adoption of English Common Law in the United States 2. Global Law • Civil Law System of France and Germany 5. Sources of Law in the United States 1. Contemporary Environment • How a Bill Becomes Law 2. Digital Law • Law of the Digital Age 6. Critical Legal Thinking 1. CASE 1.2 • U.S. Supreme Court Case • Shelby County, Texas v. Holder “ Where there is no law, there is no freedom.” —John Locke Second Treatise of Government, Sec. 57 Introduction to Legal Heritage and the Digital Age In the words of Judge Learned Hand, “Without law we cannot live; only with it can we insure the future which by right is ours. The best of men’s hopes are enmeshed in its success.”1 Every society makes and enforces laws that govern the conduct of the individuals, businesses, and other organizations that function within it. Although the law of the United States is based primarily on English common law, other legal systems, such as Spanish and French civil law, also influence it. The sources of law in this country are the U.S. Constitution, state constitutions, federal and state statutes, ordinances, administrative agency rules and regulations, executive orders, and judicial decisions by federal and state courts. Human beings do not ever make laws; it is the accidents and catastrophes of all kinds happening in every conceivable way that make law for us. Plato Laws IV, 709 Businesses that are organized in the United States are subject to its laws. They are also subject to the laws of other countries in which they operate. Busin.

CHAPTER 1 Legal Heritage and the Digital AgeStatue of Liberty,.docx

CHAPTER 1 Legal Heritage and the Digital AgeStatue of Liberty,.docx

CHAPTER 1 Legal Heritage and the Digital AgeStatue of Liberty,.docx

“With this volume we celebrate 30 years of publishing critical and diverse perspectives on public policy and its impact on our communities. Given the significance of the upcoming elections, our Editorial Board worked tirelessly to include timely and innovative works that spark conversation and debate about ways to improve the social, economic, and political condition of Latinas and Latinos in the U.S.”

Earning Civil Rights

Earning Civil Rights

Earning Civil Rights

Lawrence Cisneros

The Law Of The Land The Land Act Of 1913 Essay Public Law And Private Law Essay The Supreme Law Of The Land Land Law 19th Century Easements Land Law Landlord Tenant Laws And Tenants Essay Land Law Procedures in Kenya Alien Land Law Dbq Analysis What Law Means To Me Essay Land Law Land Act Mauritius Electronic Conveyancing ( E Conveyancing ) Land Law Reform An Objective Behind The Land Law The Logic Of English Land Law Why Study Law Essay Land Law and Tenant

Land Law Essay

Best Paper Writing Service Reviews

Classification of cause of action / characterisation

Classification of cause of action / characterisation

Classification of cause of action / characterisation

carolineelias239

Understanding Legal Pluralism

Understanding Legal Pluralism

Understanding Legal Pluralism

surrenderyourthrone

1. Case Summary: In a narrative format, brief the Dred Scott case: detail the facts, issues and court holdings. 2. Case Analysis: What effect did the passage of 14th Amendment have on the precedential value of the decision in the Dred Scott case? 3. Case Analysis: Compare and contrast the three rights conferred on national citizens by the 14th Amendment. 4. Executive Decisions: If you were a Supreme Court Justice during the 1800's, would you interpret that Congress intended to incorporate the Bill of Rights into privileges of national citizenship? Give the rationale for your decision. C H A P T E R 1 The Meaning of Criminal Procedure The Constitution of the United States was ordained, it is true, by descendants of Englishmen, who inherited the traditions of English law and history; but it was made for an undefined and expanding future, and for a people gathered and to be gathered from many nations and of many tongues. —JUSTICE STANLEY MATTHEWS, Hurtado v. California, 110 U.S. 516, 530–31 (1884) CHAPTER OUTLINE ORDER AND LIBERTY Criminal Procedure and the Constitution Order, Liberty, and the Two Models of Criminal Justice The Dangers of Injustice Criminal Justice and Alternate Justice Systems LEGAL FOUNDATIONS Law The Court System Federalism The Special Role of the Supreme Court THE CONTEXT OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE INCORPORATING THE BILL OF RIGHTS Before the Civil War The Growth of Federal Judicial Power Dred Scott and the Fourteenth Amendment The Anti-incorporation Cases, 1884–1908 Adopting the Due Process Approach Incorporating First Amendment Civil Liberties Resistance to Incorporation and Growing Support, 1937–1960 The Due Process Revolution, 1961–1969 The Counterrevolution LAW IN SOCIETY: TERRORISM, JUSTICE, AND LIBERTY Justice and Liberty in Times of National Crisis The Global War on Terror and the Threat to Liberty Detainees: The Court’s Finest Hour Blowback SUMMARY APPENDIX TO CHAPTER 1: HOW TO READ AND BRIEF CASES Notes on Legal Precedent The Components of an Opinion Briefing a Case JUSTICES OF THE SUPREME COURT: THE PRECURSOR JUSTICES John M. Harlan I Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. Louis Dembitz Brandeis Benjamin Nathan Cardozo 1 M01_ZALM7613_06_SE_CH01.QXD 1/11/10 5:01 PM Page 1 G A R R E T T , M E G A N 1 3 2 4 T S 2 Chapter 1 KEY TERMS adequate and independent state grounds affirm brief Burger Court case law certiorari, writ of checks and balances common law constitutionalism court of general jurisdiction court of limited jurisdiction Crime Control Model dictum due process approach Due Process Model ex post facto law federalism fundamental rights test habeas corpus, writ of hierarchy of constitutional rights holding human rights incorporation doctrine incorporation plus judicial craftsmanship judicial restraint judicial review jurisdiction law legal reasoning liberty opinion order overrule police state precedent private law procedural law public law Rehnquist Court remand remedial law rever ...

1. Case Summary In a narrative format, brief the Dred Scott case.docx

1. Case Summary In a narrative format, brief the Dred Scott case.docx

1. Case Summary In a narrative format, brief the Dred Scott case.docx

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW.pdf

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW.pdf

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW.pdf

Christinavarghese10

Tocqueville on the American Judiciary

Tocqueville on the American Judiciary

Tocqueville on the American Judiciary

Shiva Kumar Srinivasan

The US Department of Defense finally rears its head: debt as an excuse

The US Department of Defense finally rears its head: debt as an excuse

The US Department of Defense finally rears its head: debt as an excuse

Maria de los Angeles TRIGO

Loumiet OCC complaint

Loumiet OCC complaint

Loumiet OCC complaint

Extradition leaves the victims a long way from truth, justice, and reparation

Extradition leaves the victims a long way from truth, justice, and reparation

Extradition leaves the victims a long way from truth, justice, and reparation

Comisión Colombiana de Juristas

Wolf vs. c olorado

Wolf vs. c olorado

Wolf vs. c olorado

Similar to Amparo Habeas corpus compared (20)

Amparo Habeascorpus Compared

Amparo Habeascorpus Compared

Amparo Habeascorpus Compared

Dr Lazin On The Amparo & habeas corpus compared, 12-10a-06

Dr Lazin On The Amparo & habeas corpus compared, 12-10a-06

Dr Lazin On The Amparo & habeas corpus compared, 12-10a-06

AleksandraKowalik (9)

AleksandraKowalik (9)

AleksandraKowalik (9)

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Lazin Amparo&Habeas Compared,May08

Yavuz Sefik12915Week 21 AnalysisThe Declaration of the Ri.docx

Yavuz Sefik12915Week 21 AnalysisThe Declaration of the Ri.docx

Yavuz Sefik12915Week 21 AnalysisThe Declaration of the Ri.docx

Criminal justice power point eng1105

Criminal justice power point eng1105

Criminal justice power point eng1105

Court insider exposes judicial treachery november 16

Court insider exposes judicial treachery november 16

Court insider exposes judicial treachery november 16

CHAPTER 1 Legal Heritage and the Digital AgeStatue of Liberty,.docx

CHAPTER 1 Legal Heritage and the Digital AgeStatue of Liberty,.docx

CHAPTER 1 Legal Heritage and the Digital AgeStatue of Liberty,.docx

Earning Civil Rights

Earning Civil Rights

Earning Civil Rights

Land Law Essay

Classification of cause of action / characterisation

Classification of cause of action / characterisation

Classification of cause of action / characterisation

Understanding Legal Pluralism

Understanding Legal Pluralism

Understanding Legal Pluralism

1. Case Summary In a narrative format, brief the Dred Scott case.docx

1. Case Summary In a narrative format, brief the Dred Scott case.docx

1. Case Summary In a narrative format, brief the Dred Scott case.docx

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW.pdf

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW.pdf

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW.pdf

Tocqueville on the American Judiciary

Tocqueville on the American Judiciary

Tocqueville on the American Judiciary

The US Department of Defense finally rears its head: debt as an excuse

The US Department of Defense finally rears its head: debt as an excuse

The US Department of Defense finally rears its head: debt as an excuse

Loumiet OCC complaint

Loumiet OCC complaint

Loumiet OCC complaint

Extradition leaves the victims a long way from truth, justice, and reparation

Extradition leaves the victims a long way from truth, justice, and reparation

Extradition leaves the victims a long way from truth, justice, and reparation

Wolf vs. c olorado

Wolf vs. c olorado

Wolf vs. c olorado

Amparo Habeas corpus compared

1. Comparative Analysis of the Amparo Mexican Law and the U.S. Judicial System by Olga M. Lazin, UCLA

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

11.

12.

13.

14.

Editor's Notes

Analysis of two Cases enclosed.
American vs Mexican legislation. Major differences. Map of the state of California, where most Mexican gang members are doing time in U.S. prisons (Read “Black Hand”) and the districting. More prisons are being built, instead of eradicating the problem.
See the now notorious case of Dog, Duane Chapman.
･ Dog the Bounty Hunter DVD- Duane Chapman
Bounty hunting is illegal in Mexico. Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog_the_Bounty_Hunter
http://www.cnn.com/2006/LAW/09/14/dog.bounty /Mexican police said that the three men subdued Luster outside a nightclub, put him in an SUV and drove off June 18, 2003. Police stopped the vehicles soon afterward and took the men into custody.Chapman and his crew were not authorized to track Luster and take him into custody in Mexico, Mexican officials said at the time, adding that bounty hunting is illegal in Mexico.
Full story on Andrew Luster’s criminal history: http://www.cnn.com/2003/LAW/06/19/max.factor.heir/index.html
secuetros exprés are, since June 15, 2005, now secuestros Juan Arvizu Arrioja El Universal online Ciudad de México Jueves 16 de junio de 2005.