The document discusses the ethical challenges of electronic discovery (ediscovery) in litigation. It outlines attorneys' duties related to competence, confidentiality, candor and fairness under the Model Rules of Professional Conduct as they apply to ediscovery. Case law examples show courts sanctioning attorneys for failing to locate relevant electronically stored information, protect privileged communications, make false statements about evidence, and engage in obstructionist discovery tactics. Emerging technologies like social media and cloud computing are also raising new ethical issues regarding client information security and accessibility. Overall, the document emphasizes that attorneys must understand ediscovery to competently represent clients while avoiding ethical violations.
Whitepaper: The Enlightened Legal Hold 2014Zapproved
Three years after the Pension Committee opinion, Judge Shira Scheindlin's message is still loud and clear: The courts do not want to waste time and squander resources on motion practice, depositions and reams of submissions growing out of inexcusable failures to properly preserve relevant ESI.
Now is the time for enlightened legal holds, an age when counsel have the judgment to distinguish what must be preserved, the knowledge to negotiate and lucidly communicate the scope, and the skills and tools to select and instruct on reasonable and effective methods of preservation.
Download the white paper to discover:
How to avoid the 5 Deadly Sins of Legal Holds
Why a legal hold is an organic, bespoke process
How to know if you are 'over-preserving'
9 key elements of a sound legal hold
When to expect higher standards, raised stakes, and new vulnerabilities
The Enlightened Legal Hold serves as a guide for organizations of any size in tackling the task of preservation that at times can seem overwhelming. The 2014 version includes updated citations and other improvements to guide you on your path to Preservation Nirvana.
I presented comprehensive e-discovery webinar with Eric Mandel, national e-discovery counsel and leader of the information law practice group at Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP.
Here are a selection of the slides that I created for the presentation
Whitepaper: The Enlightened Legal Hold 2014Zapproved
Three years after the Pension Committee opinion, Judge Shira Scheindlin's message is still loud and clear: The courts do not want to waste time and squander resources on motion practice, depositions and reams of submissions growing out of inexcusable failures to properly preserve relevant ESI.
Now is the time for enlightened legal holds, an age when counsel have the judgment to distinguish what must be preserved, the knowledge to negotiate and lucidly communicate the scope, and the skills and tools to select and instruct on reasonable and effective methods of preservation.
Download the white paper to discover:
How to avoid the 5 Deadly Sins of Legal Holds
Why a legal hold is an organic, bespoke process
How to know if you are 'over-preserving'
9 key elements of a sound legal hold
When to expect higher standards, raised stakes, and new vulnerabilities
The Enlightened Legal Hold serves as a guide for organizations of any size in tackling the task of preservation that at times can seem overwhelming. The 2014 version includes updated citations and other improvements to guide you on your path to Preservation Nirvana.
I presented comprehensive e-discovery webinar with Eric Mandel, national e-discovery counsel and leader of the information law practice group at Zelle Hofmann Voelbel & Mason LLP.
Here are a selection of the slides that I created for the presentation
The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (Series: Newbie Litigator School)Financial Poise
This webinar provides an overview of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, with emphasis on recent changes and developments. By the end of the hour, the attendee will have a clear understanding of how a case is initiated, how defendants and issues are brought into the case, and the required pre-trial steps. We also touch on settlement procedure and trial practice. Join us to hear one of the cornerstone law school classes condensed into a brisk and engaging hour long discussion.
To view the accompanying webinar, go to: https://www.financialpoise.com/financial-poise-webinars/the-federal-rules-of-civil-procedure-2020/
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to KnowEd Sothcott
E-Discovery is becoming an increasing important part of the legal process. The effect of social media, e-mail and other electronic correspondence in lawsuits including civil and criminal matters and even divorce has become dramatic. What do lawyers need to do to preserve this evidence? What can happen if you don't?
“Who’s Afraid of E-Discovery” was presented by George E. Pallas and Jason Copley from the Law Firm of Cohen Seglias Pallas Greenhall & Fuman PC for the members of the Mid-Atlantic Steel Fabricators Association.
Attorney Ethics and Automated TechnologyPaul Freeman
Advances in technology allow more and more legal work to be automated. While automated systems can drastically improve efficiency in a law practice, it’s important for lawyers to understand their obligations under the disciplinary rules of professional conduct when it comes to automating legal tasks.
NEWBIE LITIGATOR SCHOOL - Part I 2022 - The Federal Rules of Civil ProcedureFinancial Poise
Has it been 10 years since you took Civil Procedure in law school? Are you a business owner that’s been sued for the first time? How does litigation really move through the Federal Courts? This webinar provides an overview of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, with emphasis on recent changes and developments. By the end of the hour, the listener will have a clear understanding of how a case is initiated, how defendants and issues are brought into the case, and the required pre-trial steps. We also touch on settlement procedure and trial practice. Join us to hear one of the cornerstone law school classes condensed into a brisk and engaging hour-long discussion.
Part of the webinar series: NEWBIE LITIGATOR SCHOOL- PART 1 2022
See more at https://www.financialpoise.com/webinars/
E-Discovery 10 Years after Qualcomm v. Broadcom - Where We Are and Where We A...Kirby Drake
This presentation provides an electronic discovery overview, identifies the lessons to be learned from Qualcomm v. Broadcom, and discusses cases that have come after Qualcomm v. Broadcom related to e-discovery.
PASSCO - Examining the Ebb and Flow of Electronic Discovery: Tips, Tools, and...Kirby Drake
This presentation discusses various court decisions relevant to electronic discovery and concludes with a discussion of the intersection between e-discovery and social media.
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...Finlaw Consultancy Pvt Ltd
Introduction-
The process of register multi-state cooperative society in India is governed by the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002. This process requires the office bearers to undertake several crucial responsibilities to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory frameworks. The key office bearers typically include the President, Secretary, and Treasurer, along with other elected members of the managing committee. Their responsibilities encompass administrative, legal, and financial duties essential for the successful registration and operation of the society.
More Related Content
Similar to A Trial Lawyer's Approach to Ethical Problems in E-Discovery
The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (Series: Newbie Litigator School)Financial Poise
This webinar provides an overview of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, with emphasis on recent changes and developments. By the end of the hour, the attendee will have a clear understanding of how a case is initiated, how defendants and issues are brought into the case, and the required pre-trial steps. We also touch on settlement procedure and trial practice. Join us to hear one of the cornerstone law school classes condensed into a brisk and engaging hour long discussion.
To view the accompanying webinar, go to: https://www.financialpoise.com/financial-poise-webinars/the-federal-rules-of-civil-procedure-2020/
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to KnowEd Sothcott
E-Discovery is becoming an increasing important part of the legal process. The effect of social media, e-mail and other electronic correspondence in lawsuits including civil and criminal matters and even divorce has become dramatic. What do lawyers need to do to preserve this evidence? What can happen if you don't?
“Who’s Afraid of E-Discovery” was presented by George E. Pallas and Jason Copley from the Law Firm of Cohen Seglias Pallas Greenhall & Fuman PC for the members of the Mid-Atlantic Steel Fabricators Association.
Attorney Ethics and Automated TechnologyPaul Freeman
Advances in technology allow more and more legal work to be automated. While automated systems can drastically improve efficiency in a law practice, it’s important for lawyers to understand their obligations under the disciplinary rules of professional conduct when it comes to automating legal tasks.
NEWBIE LITIGATOR SCHOOL - Part I 2022 - The Federal Rules of Civil ProcedureFinancial Poise
Has it been 10 years since you took Civil Procedure in law school? Are you a business owner that’s been sued for the first time? How does litigation really move through the Federal Courts? This webinar provides an overview of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, with emphasis on recent changes and developments. By the end of the hour, the listener will have a clear understanding of how a case is initiated, how defendants and issues are brought into the case, and the required pre-trial steps. We also touch on settlement procedure and trial practice. Join us to hear one of the cornerstone law school classes condensed into a brisk and engaging hour-long discussion.
Part of the webinar series: NEWBIE LITIGATOR SCHOOL- PART 1 2022
See more at https://www.financialpoise.com/webinars/
E-Discovery 10 Years after Qualcomm v. Broadcom - Where We Are and Where We A...Kirby Drake
This presentation provides an electronic discovery overview, identifies the lessons to be learned from Qualcomm v. Broadcom, and discusses cases that have come after Qualcomm v. Broadcom related to e-discovery.
PASSCO - Examining the Ebb and Flow of Electronic Discovery: Tips, Tools, and...Kirby Drake
This presentation discusses various court decisions relevant to electronic discovery and concludes with a discussion of the intersection between e-discovery and social media.
Similar to A Trial Lawyer's Approach to Ethical Problems in E-Discovery (20)
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...Finlaw Consultancy Pvt Ltd
Introduction-
The process of register multi-state cooperative society in India is governed by the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002. This process requires the office bearers to undertake several crucial responsibilities to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory frameworks. The key office bearers typically include the President, Secretary, and Treasurer, along with other elected members of the managing committee. Their responsibilities encompass administrative, legal, and financial duties essential for the successful registration and operation of the society.
NATURE, ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW.pptxanvithaav
These slides helps the student of international law to understand what is the nature of international law? and how international law was originated and developed?.
The slides was well structured along with the highlighted points for better understanding .
In 2020, the Ministry of Home Affairs established a committee led by Prof. (Dr.) Ranbir Singh, former Vice Chancellor of National Law University (NLU), Delhi. This committee was tasked with reviewing the three codes of criminal law. The primary objective of the committee was to propose comprehensive reforms to the country’s criminal laws in a manner that is both principled and effective.
The committee’s focus was on ensuring the safety and security of individuals, communities, and the nation as a whole. Throughout its deliberations, the committee aimed to uphold constitutional values such as justice, dignity, and the intrinsic value of each individual. Their goal was to recommend amendments to the criminal laws that align with these values and priorities.
Subsequently, in February, the committee successfully submitted its recommendations regarding amendments to the criminal law. These recommendations are intended to serve as a foundation for enhancing the current legal framework, promoting safety and security, and upholding the constitutional principles of justice, dignity, and the inherent worth of every individual.
A "File Trademark" is a legal term referring to the registration of a unique symbol, logo, or name used to identify and distinguish products or services. This process provides legal protection, granting exclusive rights to the trademark owner, and helps prevent unauthorized use by competitors.
Visit Now: https://www.tumblr.com/trademark-quick/751620857551634432/ensure-legal-protection-file-your-trademark-with?source=share
7. Ethics & Electronic Evidence
Ethical obligations do exist when it comes to ediscovery
Courts are more clearly articulating counsel’s affirmative
duty to act competently and diligently
Counsel should expect to be held to a higher standard
than ever before
7
8. The Model Rules of Professional Conduct
8
1.1 1.6 3.3
Competence Confidentiality Candor
3.4 4.4 8.4
5.6
Non-Lawyer
Assistance
Fairness Third Persons Integrity
9. Amended Ethics Rules
9
In August 2012, The ABA House of Delegates
approved recommendations sponsored by the ABA
Commission on Ethics 20/20
» Of special interest to ediscovery practitioners is Recommendation
105A, which amends existing rules as follows:
Rule 1.0 – “Writing” now includes an “electronic communication”
Rule 1.1 – Comment [8] adds an attorney’s duty to stay informed about
changes in practice and relevant litigation technology
Rule 1.6 – Adds section (c), identifying duty to prevent inadvertent
disclosure of confidential client information
Rule 4.4 – Adds “electronically stored information” to provision about
sending prompt notice when lawyer receives third party information
10. The Model Rules | Competence
1.1
“
„
10
“A lawyer shall provide competent
representation to a client.
Competent representation requires
the legal knowledge, skill,
thoroughness and preparation
reasonably necessary for the
representation.”
11. The Model Rules | Competence
“
„
1.1
11
“To maintain the requisite
knowledge and skill, a lawyer
should keep abreast of changes in
the law and its practice, including
the benefits and risks
associated with relevant
(Cmt. 8) technology…”
14. The Model Rules | Competence
Competence in locating, reviewing and producing ESI in
litigation and regulatory work is among the greatest
challenges for lawyers today
Counsel’s ability to examine and produce ESI is central to
managing discovery in the modern age
14
15. The Model Rules | Competence
Seek outside counsel or hire
a consultant when:
» Training and experience of your staff or
your client’s staff would make you
uncomfortable if you had to call them as
witnesses
» Conflicts of interest might really hurt your
case
» The current workload of your staff would
prevent them from focusing on your case
» Your staff lacks the tools and equipment to
handle the job
15
16.
17.
18. Case Law | Competence
In re A & M Florida Props. II
2010 WL 1418861 (Bkrtcpy. S.D.N.Y. Apr. 2010)
HELD: WHY:
18
Court found plaintiffs’ counsel “did
not understand the technical depths
to which electronic discovery can
sometimes go”
Counsel has an obligation to search
for sources of information to
understand where data is stored
Court issued
monetary sanctions
due to counsel’s
failure to speak with
key figures at the
company
19. The Model Rules | Confidentiality
“
1.6 A lawyer shall make reasonable
„
19
efforts to prevent the inadvertent
disclosure of, or unauthorized
access to, information relating to
the representation of a client.
Subd. (c)
…what efforts are reasonable to prevent disclosure?
20. Evidentiary Rules | Confidentiality
Amidst growing data volumes, protecting
privilege in the era of electronic discovery is
growing increasingly difficult
» FRE 502 limits waivers of attorney-client privilege and
work product doctrine
» Preventing waiver under FRE 502(b):
20
“Reasonable
attempts [made] to
prevent disclosure”
(502(b)(2))
Take “prompt,
reasonable
steps to rectify
error (502(b)(3))
No Waiver
Disclosure is
Unintentional
21. Case Law | Confidentiality
Alamar Ranch, LLC v. County of Boise
HELD: WHY:
21
Attorney should have been aware
client’s employer would be
monitoring and accessing e-mail
sent to that address since it is now
a common practice
Court found
privilege was
waived regarding e-mails
sent via
company e-mail
addresses using
company
computers
2009 WL 3669741 (D. Idaho. Nov. 2, 2009)
24. The Model Rules | Candor
“
3.3 A lawyer shall not knowingly:
Subd. (a)
„
24
(1) Make a false statement of fact or
law…
(3) Offer evidence lawyer knows to be
false
25. Case Law | Candor
Baez-Eliza v. Instituto Psicoterapeutico de Puerto Rico
HELD: WHY:
25
Defendant’s repeated claims of
privilege over 10 emails (because the
emails disclosed attorney-client
consultation) showed “an ill-advised
stubbornness” and “a poor
understanding of the privilege’s
reach.”
Turned discovery “into an all-out war”
Court ordered
defendants to pay
$1,000 in sanctions
for discovery
misconduct
2011 WL 2413051 (D.P.R. June 16, 2011)
26. The Model Rules | Fairness
“
„
3.4
26
A lawyer shall not
unlawfully obstruct another party’s
access to evidence or unlawfully alter,
destroy or conceal a document or
other material having potential
evidentiary value. A lawyer shall not
counsel or assist another person to
Subd. (a) do any such act….
29. The Model Rules | Fairness
Scott Adams, Inc./Dict. by UFS, Inc.
29
30. Case Law | Fairness
Sec. Nat’l Bank of Sioux City v. Abbott Labs.
HELD: WHY:
30
The judge began that “something is rotten . . .
in discovery in modern federal civil litigation”
and that “unless judges impose serious
adverse consequences,” obstructionist
behavior will persist
The lawyer on the case “proliferated hundreds
of unnecessary objections and interruptions
during the examiner’s questioning.”
Judge orders
sanctions for
counsel’s bad
deposition conduct
2014 WL 3704277 (N.D. Iowa July 28, 2014)
31.
32.
33. The Model Rules | Fairness
“
„
3.4
33
A lawyer shall not, in pretrial
procedure, make a frivolous
discovery request or fail to make
reasonably diligent efforts to comply
with a legally proper discovery
request by an opposing party….” Subd. (d)
34.
35. Case Law | Fairness
HELD: WHY:
35
The attorneys filed over 14 discovery-related
motions and engaged in
incessant “accusation-laced, uncivil
correspondence”
The attorneys consciously made the
litigation as “time-consuming, difficult,
unpleasant, and expensive as
possible”
Two defense
attorneys were held
personally liable in
the amount of
$3,750 each, to be
paid without
reimbursement from
the law firms or
clients.
Alford v. Rents
2010 WL 4222922 (S.D. Ill. Oct. 20, 2010)
36. Case Law | Fairness
B & B Hardware, Inc. v. Fastenal Co.
HELD: WHY:
36
Plaintiff failed to abide by local rule
requiring attorneys to meet and confer
in good faith before filing motion to
compel
Parties were acting “like armed
combatants,” not “highly skilled
professionals”
Court declined to
compel discovery or
grant a hearing
2011 WL 2115546 (E.D. Ark. May 25, 2011)
37. The Model Rules | Rights of Third Persons
“
„
4.4
37
A lawyer who receives a document or
electronically stored information
relating to the representation of the
lawyer’s client and knows or
reasonably should know that the
document or electronically stored
information was inadvertently sent
Subd. (b) shall promptly notify the sender.
38. Case Law | Rights of Third Persons
Stengart v. Loving Care Agency, Inc.
HELD: WHY:
38
Relying on company policy,
defendant’s accessed the plaintiffs’
personal Yahoo! emails sent to her
attorney on her work-issued laptop
Attorneys did not set aside the
arguably privileged messages and
failed to notify the plaintiff or seek
court permission for use
Court determined
attorneys’ retention
of a computer
forensic expert to
retrieve the
privileged e-mails
and the subsequent
use of those e-mails
violated Rule 4.4(b)
2010 WL 1189458 (N.J. Mar. 30, 2010)
39. The Model Rules | Non-lawyer Assistance
“
„
5.3
39
With respect to [employed/associated
non-lawyers], a partner… in a law firm
shall make reasonable efforts to
ensure that the firm has in effect
measures giving reasonable
assurance that the person's conduct
is compatible with the professional
Subd. (a) obligations of the lawyer
40. The Model Rules | Non-lawyer Assistance
“
„
5.3
40
Where the client directs the selection
of a particular non-lawyer service
provider outside the firm, the lawyer
ordinarily should agree with the client
concerning the allocation of
responsibility for monitoring as
(Cmt. 4) between the client and the lawyer
41. The Model Rules | Integrity of the Profession
“
„
8.4
41
It is professional misconduct for a
lawyer to:
(a) violate the Rules of Professional
Conduct
(c) engage in conduct involving
dishonesty, fraud, deceit or
misrepresentation
(g) knowingly fail to comply with a final
court order
42. Case Law | Integrity of the Profession
Aliki Foods, LLC v. Otter Valley Foods, Inc.
HELD: WHY:
42
Plaintiff’s “flagrant defiance” of
numerous court orders and warnings,
intentional destruction of computers
and hard drives, and blatant
disregard of discovery obligations
resulted in a “tremendous waste of
resources”
Dismissal was the
only viable sanction
2010 WL 2982989 (D. Conn. July 7, 2010)
43. Case Law | Integrity of the Profession
Victor Stanley, Inc. v. Creative Pipe, Inc.
Case 8:06-cv-02662-MJG (D. Md. June 15, 2011)
HELD: WHY:
43
“Defendants’ first spoliation efforts
corresponded with the beginning of
litigation” and “Defendants’
misconduct affected the entire
discovery process since the
commencement of this case.”
Court awarded
$1,049,850.04 in
attorney’s fees and
costs as a sanction
for discovery abuse
45. Social Networking & Blogs
“ „
45
[I]t should now be a matter of
professional competence for
attorneys to take the time to
investigate social networking sites
-Griffin v. State, 192 Md. App. 518, 535 (2010)
46. Social Networking & Blogs
Use of social networking sites
and blogs creates potential for
ethical violations or
disciplinary action for
misconduct
» Raises confidentiality, integrity and
propriety issues
» Attorneys cannot “friend under false
pretenses” to gain access to profiles
and information otherwise kept private
46
47. Case Law | Social Networking & Blogs
Case No. CL.08-1S0
47
Lester
v.
Allied Concrete
Gatto
v.
United Air Lines, Inc.
In a wrongful death case, lawyer and litigant
sanctioned for lawyer’s instruction to paralegal to
“clean up” litigant’s Facebook page. Attorney directly
sanctioned for $522,000; client for $180,000.
In a wrongful death case, the plaintiff deactivated his
Facebook during litigation. Because the information
was potentially relevant to damages, the court
2013 WL 1285285 granted an adverse inference instruction.
48. Cloud Computing
Cloud computing raises legal ethics issues, particularly
around competence and confidentiality of information as
information stored in the cloud is outside the lawyer’s
control, and is often in numerous locations, including
different countries
Lawyers must ensure steps are taken to safeguard
security and confidentiality of client information
48
50. Parting Thoughts
The connection between ediscovery and current ethics
rules is arguably growing stronger with each case
issued
To ensure you are upholding the oath integral to the
legal profession, develop a stronger understanding of
ediscovery and its interplay with ethical obligations
50
51. PLEASE DON’T HESITATE TO
CONTACT ME
Brendan M. Kenny
Blackwell Burke P.A.
(612) 343-3211
bkenny@blackwellburke.com
www.linkedin.com/in/brendanmkenny
Twitter: @KennyBrendan