SlideShare a Scribd company logo
WHO EDUCATES 5 MILLION
                                                                                                                                     TEXAS STUDENTS?



   Texas public schools educate 5 million students.
                                                                                                                                                                   91%
   While full-time virtual school providers educate only a small                                                                                 PUBLIC
   fraction of them, their enrollment has grown rapidly despite poor                                                                             SCHOOLS
   academic results and little transparency.                                                                                                          Private Schools 6%
                                                                                                                                                        Public Charters 3%
   Rapid Expansion, Poor Performance
   Enrollment in full-time virtual schools has more than                                                                             PUBLIC SCHOOLS     PRIVATE SCHOOLS      PUBLIC CHARTERS
   quadrupled in the last four years alone – but full-time virtual                                                                   4,823,842          313,360              154,278
   schools have provided consistently poor results under the
   state accountability system.
   • Only one full-time virtual school has maintained even                      Full-Time Virtual School Accountability Ratings by School Year
     an Academically Acceptable rating for two consecutive
     years (and it was later rated Academically Unacceptable).                                   Texas               Texas Virtual        IQ Academy               Texarkana
                                                                                                 Connections         Academy                                       Virtual Academy
   • No full-time virtual school has ever achieved a rating
     of Exemplary or Recognized.                                                2006 - 07        Not Rated*          Acceptable           N/A**                    N/A
   No Taxpayer Accountability or Transparency                                   2007 - 08        Not Rated           Acceptable           N/A                      N/A
   Full-time virtual schools have been touted as producing                      2008 - 09        Not Rated           Unacceptable         N/A                      N/A
   cost savings for the state, yet there is little or no public                 2009 - 10        Not Rated           Acceptable           N/A                      N/A
   data available to substantiate this claim despite the use
   of taxpayer dollars.                                                         2010 - 11        Unacceptable        Unacceptable         Acceptable               N/A
                                                                                2011 - 12        TBD                 Closed               TBD                      TBD
     For more information, see our policy paper, “Virtual Schools
     in Texas: Good for Kids or Merely Good for Profit?” at:                  * “Not Rated” indicates that the school was in existence at this time, but was not rated by the
                                                                                 Texas Accountability System (reason unknown).
     http://www.raiseyourhandtexas.org/images/virtual-schools.pdf
                                                                              ** ”N/A” indicates the school was not in existence at this time.



   TAKE ACTION                                             Here’s what the Texas legislature can do to keep public schools strong:


       • Close the loophole that allows poor                   - Maintain the same accountability and                    - Require TEA to provide timely
         performing virtual schools to evade                     reporting requirements as public schools.                 information on TxVSN Online Schools,
         consequences by switching host districts.             - Maintain the requirement that virtual                     including cost and performance outcomes.
       • Do not allow virtual schools to act                     schools not serve students below 3rd grade,             - Require financial audits to determine
         as stealth vouchers.                                    where assessments are not administered.                   actual costs and whether per-pupil
                                                               - Maintain the existing requirement that a                  payments using taxpayer funds are
         - Maintain current eligibility requirements                                                                       reasonable.
           that a student must have attended a Texas             provider receives full payment on successful
           public school in the prior school year.               completion of online courses.                        • Limit expansion of virtual schools to high
         - Do not permit public funds to be paid            • Require a trusted third-party to administer               performing virtual school providers, as is
           directly to private virtual school providers.      state assessments for virtual school                      currently done with charters.
       • Maintain accountability for virtual schools.         students.                                               • Limit further expansion of full-time virtual
                                                            • Increase transparency for virtual schools.                schools pending independent third party
         - Maintain operational and fiscal                                                                              evaluation of academic performance and
           oversight by TEA under the Texas Virtual           - Require that contracts between virtual
                                                                                                                        cost-effectiveness.
           Schools Network (TxVSN).                             school providers and host district/charter
                                                                be public information and posted online.



VIRTUAL                  LEGISLATIVE ADVERTISING PAID FOR BY: David Anthony, CEO, Raise Your Hand Texas
                         3200 Southwest Freeway, Suite 2070 | Houston, TX 77027
SCHOOLS                  P 713.993.7667 | F 713.993.7691 | www.RaiseYourHandTexas.org

More Related Content

Similar to 5 Million Reasons Virtual Schools Don't Work

20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska
20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska
20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska
Vicki Alger
 
5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done
5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done
5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools
5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools
5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability
5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability
5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...
Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...
Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...
BDO
 
Letter to governor cooper re sb 392 final
Letter to governor cooper re sb 392 finalLetter to governor cooper re sb 392 final
Letter to governor cooper re sb 392 final
EducationNC
 
Turnaround Management Association seminar
Turnaround Management Association seminarTurnaround Management Association seminar
Turnaround Management Association seminar
Blake Morgan
 
Mind Trust Executive Summary
Mind Trust Executive SummaryMind Trust Executive Summary
Mind Trust Executive Summary
Abdul-Hakim Shabazz
 
Legions
LegionsLegions
Greg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of Recommendations
Greg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of RecommendationsGreg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of Recommendations
Greg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of Recommendations
Tam Nguyen
 
K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)
K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)
K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)
Michigan Virtual Learning Research Institute
 
Part 4 Foundation of Education
Part 4 Foundation of EducationPart 4 Foundation of Education
Part 4 Foundation of Education
Devi Hermasari
 
Key themes for the next five years - schools and academies
Key themes for the next five years - schools and academiesKey themes for the next five years - schools and academies
Key themes for the next five years - schools and academies
Browne Jacobson LLP
 
Patrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online Learning
Patrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online LearningPatrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online Learning
Patrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online Learning
VISCED
 
State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014
State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014
State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014
chume1
 
The Rise of K-12 Blended Learning
The Rise of K-12 Blended LearningThe Rise of K-12 Blended Learning
The Rise of K-12 Blended Learning
drchrisdavis
 
School dazed? Creating new partnerships with schools
School dazed? Creating new partnerships with schoolsSchool dazed? Creating new partnerships with schools
School dazed? Creating new partnerships with schools
Renaisi
 
RI Educator Autonomy Research Compilation
RI Educator Autonomy Research CompilationRI Educator Autonomy Research Compilation
RI Educator Autonomy Research Compilation
ppageegd
 
Online Learning - 10/20/10
Online Learning - 10/20/10Online Learning - 10/20/10
Online Learning - 10/20/10
Jeffrey Hunt
 
Price Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 Education
Price Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 EducationPrice Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 Education
Price Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 Education
StraighterLine
 

Similar to 5 Million Reasons Virtual Schools Don't Work (20)

20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska
20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska
20110623 The Vital Need for Virtual Schools in Nebraska
 
5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done
5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done
5 Million Reasons Vouchers Won't Get the Job Done
 
5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools
5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools
5 Million Reasons We Need Strong Public Schools
 
5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability
5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability
5 Million Reasons for Less Testing and Smarter Accountability
 
Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...
Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...
Beyond The Election: the three main political parties' plans for local govern...
 
Letter to governor cooper re sb 392 final
Letter to governor cooper re sb 392 finalLetter to governor cooper re sb 392 final
Letter to governor cooper re sb 392 final
 
Turnaround Management Association seminar
Turnaround Management Association seminarTurnaround Management Association seminar
Turnaround Management Association seminar
 
Mind Trust Executive Summary
Mind Trust Executive SummaryMind Trust Executive Summary
Mind Trust Executive Summary
 
Legions
LegionsLegions
Legions
 
Greg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of Recommendations
Greg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of RecommendationsGreg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of Recommendations
Greg Abbott Educating Texans Plan Governance List of Recommendations
 
K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)
K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)
K-12 Virtual Schools and Their Research Needs (Part 4 of 4)
 
Part 4 Foundation of Education
Part 4 Foundation of EducationPart 4 Foundation of Education
Part 4 Foundation of Education
 
Key themes for the next five years - schools and academies
Key themes for the next five years - schools and academiesKey themes for the next five years - schools and academies
Key themes for the next five years - schools and academies
 
Patrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online Learning
Patrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online LearningPatrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online Learning
Patrick, Teeter - iNacol - North America & K-12 Online Learning
 
State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014
State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014
State update-webinar-series-2014-updated-august-8-2014
 
The Rise of K-12 Blended Learning
The Rise of K-12 Blended LearningThe Rise of K-12 Blended Learning
The Rise of K-12 Blended Learning
 
School dazed? Creating new partnerships with schools
School dazed? Creating new partnerships with schoolsSchool dazed? Creating new partnerships with schools
School dazed? Creating new partnerships with schools
 
RI Educator Autonomy Research Compilation
RI Educator Autonomy Research CompilationRI Educator Autonomy Research Compilation
RI Educator Autonomy Research Compilation
 
Online Learning - 10/20/10
Online Learning - 10/20/10Online Learning - 10/20/10
Online Learning - 10/20/10
 
Price Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 Education
Price Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 EducationPrice Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 Education
Price Competition and Course-Level Choice in K-12 Education
 

More from Raise Your Hand Texas

Scaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learning
Scaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learningScaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learning
Scaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learning
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Lubbock chamber pre k ppt
Lubbock chamber pre k pptLubbock chamber pre k ppt
Lubbock chamber pre k ppt
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Central Texas Education Trends
Central Texas Education TrendsCentral Texas Education Trends
Central Texas Education Trends
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...
Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...
Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
School Vouchers: The Myth And The Reality
School Vouchers: The Myth And The RealitySchool Vouchers: The Myth And The Reality
School Vouchers: The Myth And The Reality
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech
5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech
5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Voucher Presentation for Round Rock ISD
Voucher Presentation for Round Rock ISDVoucher Presentation for Round Rock ISD
Voucher Presentation for Round Rock ISD
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Becoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And Success
Becoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And SuccessBecoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And Success
Becoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And Success
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
RYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big Changes
RYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big ChangesRYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big Changes
RYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big Changes
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
The Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School Innovation
The Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School InnovationThe Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School Innovation
The Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School Innovation
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
The Importance of Funding Early Childhood Education
The Importance of Funding Early Childhood EducationThe Importance of Funding Early Childhood Education
The Importance of Funding Early Childhood Education
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!
Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!
Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Pathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology Education
Pathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology EducationPathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology Education
Pathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology Education
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Bridging the Gap Between Business and Education
Bridging the Gap Between Business and EducationBridging the Gap Between Business and Education
Bridging the Gap Between Business and Education
Raise Your Hand Texas
 
Raise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion Conference
Raise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion ConferenceRaise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion Conference
Raise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion Conference
Raise Your Hand Texas
 

More from Raise Your Hand Texas (15)

Scaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learning
Scaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learningScaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learning
Scaling Student-Centered Instruction: The power of blended learning
 
Lubbock chamber pre k ppt
Lubbock chamber pre k pptLubbock chamber pre k ppt
Lubbock chamber pre k ppt
 
Central Texas Education Trends
Central Texas Education TrendsCentral Texas Education Trends
Central Texas Education Trends
 
Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...
Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...
Raise Your Hand Texas Praises Senate Passage Of Balanced Charter School Quali...
 
School Vouchers: The Myth And The Reality
School Vouchers: The Myth And The RealitySchool Vouchers: The Myth And The Reality
School Vouchers: The Myth And The Reality
 
5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech
5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech
5 Million Reasons to Expand Options for Career/Tech
 
Voucher Presentation for Round Rock ISD
Voucher Presentation for Round Rock ISDVoucher Presentation for Round Rock ISD
Voucher Presentation for Round Rock ISD
 
Becoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And Success
Becoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And SuccessBecoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And Success
Becoming "Data Wise" To Drive High Achievement And Success
 
RYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big Changes
RYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big ChangesRYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big Changes
RYHT Leadership Program Alum Brings Big Changes
 
The Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School Innovation
The Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School InnovationThe Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School Innovation
The Business of School Leadership: New Perspectives on Public School Innovation
 
The Importance of Funding Early Childhood Education
The Importance of Funding Early Childhood EducationThe Importance of Funding Early Childhood Education
The Importance of Funding Early Childhood Education
 
Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!
Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!
Cast Your Ballot for Texas Public Education Now!
 
Pathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology Education
Pathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology EducationPathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology Education
Pathways to High School Graduation - Career and Technology Education
 
Bridging the Gap Between Business and Education
Bridging the Gap Between Business and EducationBridging the Gap Between Business and Education
Bridging the Gap Between Business and Education
 
Raise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion Conference
Raise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion ConferenceRaise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion Conference
Raise Your Hand Texas Leadership Reunion Conference
 

5 Million Reasons Virtual Schools Don't Work

  • 1. WHO EDUCATES 5 MILLION TEXAS STUDENTS? Texas public schools educate 5 million students. 91% While full-time virtual school providers educate only a small PUBLIC fraction of them, their enrollment has grown rapidly despite poor SCHOOLS academic results and little transparency. Private Schools 6% Public Charters 3% Rapid Expansion, Poor Performance Enrollment in full-time virtual schools has more than PUBLIC SCHOOLS PRIVATE SCHOOLS PUBLIC CHARTERS quadrupled in the last four years alone – but full-time virtual 4,823,842 313,360 154,278 schools have provided consistently poor results under the state accountability system. • Only one full-time virtual school has maintained even Full-Time Virtual School Accountability Ratings by School Year an Academically Acceptable rating for two consecutive years (and it was later rated Academically Unacceptable). Texas Texas Virtual IQ Academy Texarkana Connections Academy Virtual Academy • No full-time virtual school has ever achieved a rating of Exemplary or Recognized. 2006 - 07 Not Rated* Acceptable N/A** N/A No Taxpayer Accountability or Transparency 2007 - 08 Not Rated Acceptable N/A N/A Full-time virtual schools have been touted as producing 2008 - 09 Not Rated Unacceptable N/A N/A cost savings for the state, yet there is little or no public 2009 - 10 Not Rated Acceptable N/A N/A data available to substantiate this claim despite the use of taxpayer dollars. 2010 - 11 Unacceptable Unacceptable Acceptable N/A 2011 - 12 TBD Closed TBD TBD For more information, see our policy paper, “Virtual Schools in Texas: Good for Kids or Merely Good for Profit?” at: * “Not Rated” indicates that the school was in existence at this time, but was not rated by the Texas Accountability System (reason unknown). http://www.raiseyourhandtexas.org/images/virtual-schools.pdf ** ”N/A” indicates the school was not in existence at this time. TAKE ACTION Here’s what the Texas legislature can do to keep public schools strong: • Close the loophole that allows poor - Maintain the same accountability and - Require TEA to provide timely performing virtual schools to evade reporting requirements as public schools. information on TxVSN Online Schools, consequences by switching host districts. - Maintain the requirement that virtual including cost and performance outcomes. • Do not allow virtual schools to act schools not serve students below 3rd grade, - Require financial audits to determine as stealth vouchers. where assessments are not administered. actual costs and whether per-pupil - Maintain the existing requirement that a payments using taxpayer funds are - Maintain current eligibility requirements reasonable. that a student must have attended a Texas provider receives full payment on successful public school in the prior school year. completion of online courses. • Limit expansion of virtual schools to high - Do not permit public funds to be paid • Require a trusted third-party to administer performing virtual school providers, as is directly to private virtual school providers. state assessments for virtual school currently done with charters. • Maintain accountability for virtual schools. students. • Limit further expansion of full-time virtual • Increase transparency for virtual schools. schools pending independent third party - Maintain operational and fiscal evaluation of academic performance and oversight by TEA under the Texas Virtual - Require that contracts between virtual cost-effectiveness. Schools Network (TxVSN). school providers and host district/charter be public information and posted online. VIRTUAL LEGISLATIVE ADVERTISING PAID FOR BY: David Anthony, CEO, Raise Your Hand Texas 3200 Southwest Freeway, Suite 2070 | Houston, TX 77027 SCHOOLS P 713.993.7667 | F 713.993.7691 | www.RaiseYourHandTexas.org