HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER
WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
Bertrand Levant
Conseil supérieur de l’audiovisuel (CSA),
Belgium
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
SURVEYS:SURVEYS:
• Lead by CSA: Broadcasting regulatory authority of the
French speaking community of Belgium (FSCB)
• On FSCB medias own productions: 26p
channels
• People appearing on TVp pp g
• Five main criteria of investigation : gender,
age origin profession disabilityage, origin, profession, disability
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
SURVEYS:SURVEYS:
• 3 « global » on Diversity and equality in the• 3 « global » on Diversity and equality in the
FSCB audiovisual media : 2011, 2012, 2013
1 ifi l t ti• 1 « specific » on young people representations
in the FSCB media : 2013
• 2013 global survey:
– More than 64.000 people indexed
– More than 400 hours of programs
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
MAIN RESULTS:MAIN RESULTS:
• Women only 36,88% of appearances (50,92%
in Belgian society)
• > 65 years old only 3,74% of appearances
(17,65% in Belgian society)
• Both sex/age criteria : double discrimination forBoth sex/age criteria : double discrimination for
women appearing on TV
• Quasi equality of M/W appearances in the• Quasi equality of M/W appearances in the
specific survey on young people representation
on TVon TV
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
DOUBLE DISCRIMINATIONDOUBLE DISCRIMINATION
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
QUASI EQUALITYQUASI EQUALITY
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
EXPLAINING FACTORS
• Two indicators used : identifiable
occupations and rolesoccupations and roles
• Predominant place of prestigious jobs
h d TVshowed on TV
• Prestigious job = prestigious rolePrestigious job prestigious role
More strongly for women (88,42%
VS 81 12%)VS 81,12%)
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
ARGUMENT
The nature of appearance contexts gives
a partial explanation:a partial explanation:
– Strong social differentiation M/W
inequalityinequality
– Weak social differentiation M/W equality
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
ARGUMENT
Generation Individual socialVS
membership status
VS
ELDER
YOUTH
ELDER
PEOPLE
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
STRUCTURING AND STRUCTURAL
FACTORS:
• Media Practices
• Societal realities: (un)employement
• Generational dynamics: (high) level of education• Generational dynamics: (high) level of education
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
2 KINDS OF CONCLUSION:
• The picture is pessimistic
• In real time, we can be optismistic only if:In real time, we can be optismistic only if:
– We have quantitative surveys for the coming years
– We better understand media practices and theWe better understand media practices and the
realities (or difficulties) that restrain them to
represent better gender equality
Agenda setting, sensibilisation, good
practicespractices
HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONS MATTER WITH
GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
Thank you for your attention
bertrand.levant@csa.be
http://www.csa.be/diversite

Les représentations femmes-hommes sont-elles influencées par les générations?

  • 1.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? Bertrand Levant Conseil supérieur de l’audiovisuel (CSA), Belgium
  • 2.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? SURVEYS:SURVEYS: • Lead by CSA: Broadcasting regulatory authority of the French speaking community of Belgium (FSCB) • On FSCB medias own productions: 26p channels • People appearing on TVp pp g • Five main criteria of investigation : gender, age origin profession disabilityage, origin, profession, disability
  • 3.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? SURVEYS:SURVEYS: • 3 « global » on Diversity and equality in the• 3 « global » on Diversity and equality in the FSCB audiovisual media : 2011, 2012, 2013 1 ifi l t ti• 1 « specific » on young people representations in the FSCB media : 2013 • 2013 global survey: – More than 64.000 people indexed – More than 400 hours of programs
  • 4.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? MAIN RESULTS:MAIN RESULTS: • Women only 36,88% of appearances (50,92% in Belgian society) • > 65 years old only 3,74% of appearances (17,65% in Belgian society) • Both sex/age criteria : double discrimination forBoth sex/age criteria : double discrimination for women appearing on TV • Quasi equality of M/W appearances in the• Quasi equality of M/W appearances in the specific survey on young people representation on TVon TV
  • 5.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? DOUBLE DISCRIMINATIONDOUBLE DISCRIMINATION
  • 6.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? QUASI EQUALITYQUASI EQUALITY
  • 7.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? EXPLAINING FACTORS • Two indicators used : identifiable occupations and rolesoccupations and roles • Predominant place of prestigious jobs h d TVshowed on TV • Prestigious job = prestigious rolePrestigious job prestigious role More strongly for women (88,42% VS 81 12%)VS 81,12%)
  • 8.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION?
  • 9.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? ARGUMENT The nature of appearance contexts gives a partial explanation:a partial explanation: – Strong social differentiation M/W inequalityinequality – Weak social differentiation M/W equality
  • 10.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? ARGUMENT Generation Individual socialVS membership status VS ELDER YOUTH ELDER PEOPLE
  • 11.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? STRUCTURING AND STRUCTURAL FACTORS: • Media Practices • Societal realities: (un)employement • Generational dynamics: (high) level of education• Generational dynamics: (high) level of education
  • 12.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? 2 KINDS OF CONCLUSION: • The picture is pessimistic • In real time, we can be optismistic only if:In real time, we can be optismistic only if: – We have quantitative surveys for the coming years – We better understand media practices and theWe better understand media practices and the realities (or difficulties) that restrain them to represent better gender equality Agenda setting, sensibilisation, good practicespractices
  • 13.
    HOW GENDER REPRESENTATIONSMATTER WITH GENERATION IN TELEVISION? Thank you for your attention bertrand.levant@csa.be http://www.csa.be/diversite